Manitoba Hansard — 34th 2nd hansardpdf 34th 2nd index

34th 2nd hansardpdf 34th 2nd index

Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)

INDEX of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES and PROCEEDINGS 38-39 Elizabeth II Second Session - Thirty-Fourth Legislature which opened the 18th of May, 1989 and dissolved by proclamation the 7th of August, 1990 Volume XXXVIII Printed by the Office of the Quee ns Printer. Pro•ince of Manitoba

TABLE OF CONTENTS Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES AND PROCEEDINGS Second Session - Thirty-Fourth Legislature Table of Contents ............................... ....................................................... .............. . List of Members ................. .................................................................................... . Legislative Assembly ........................ ......... ................................... .......................... . Introduction ............................................................................................................. .

Member /Subject Index ........................... .................................................... ........... . Appendices Appendix A: Oral Questions ................................................. ..................... ........ . Appendix B: Members of Executive Council ........................................ .......... .. Appendix C: Standing and Special Committees ............... ............... ................ . II Ill IV 244 290 292

ALCOCK, Reg ANGUS, John ASHTON, Steve BURRELL, Parker CARR, Jim CARSTAIRS, Sharon CHARLES, Gwen CHEEMA, Guizar CHORNOPYSKI, Wi lliam CONNERY, Edward COWAN, Jay CUMMINGS, Glen DERKACH, Leonard DOER, Gary DOWNEY, James E. DRIEDGER, Albert DRIEDGER, Herold DUCHARME, Gerald EDWARDS, Paul ENNS, Harry ERNST, Jim EVANS, Laurie E. EVANS, Leonard S. FILMON, Gary FINDLAY, Glen M. GAUDRY, Neil GILLESHAMMER, Harold GRAY, Avis HAMMOND, Gerrie HARAPIAK, Harry M. HARPER, Elijah HELWER, Edward HEMPHILL, Maureen KOZAK, Richard LAMOUREUX, Kevin MALOWAY, Jim MANDRAKE, Ed MANNESS, Clayton McCRAE, James C.

MINENKO, Mark MITCHELSON, Bonnie NEUFELD, Harold OLESON, Charlotte ORCHARD, Donald PANKRATZ, Helmut PATTER SON, Allan PENNER, Jack PLOHMAN, John S. PRAZNIK, Darren ROCAN, Denis ROCH, Gilles ROSE, Bob STORIE, Jerry T. TAYLOR, Harold URUSKI, Bill WASYLYCIA-LEIS, Judy YEO, Iva MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY THIRTY-FO URTH LEGISLATURE Members, Constituencies and Political Affiliation Osborne St. Norbert Th ompson Swan River Fort Rouge River Heights Selkirk Kildonan Burrows Portage Ia Prairie Churchill Ste. Rose Roblin-Russell Concordia Arthur Emerson Niakwa Riel St.

James Lakeside Charleswood Fort Garry Brandon East Tuxedo Virden St. Boniface Minnedosa Ellice Kirkfield Park Th e Pas Rupertsland Gimli Logan Transcona Inkster Elmwood Assiniboia Morris Brandon West Seven Oaks River East Rossmere Gladstone Pembina La Verendrye Radisson Rhineland Dauphin Lac du Bonnet Turtle Mountain Springfield St. Vital Flin Flon Wolseley Interlake St.

Johns Sturgeon Creek II Liberal Liberal NDP PC Liberal Liberal Liberal Liberal Liberal PC NDP PC PC NDP PC PC Liberal PC Liberal PC PC Liberal NDP PC PC Liberal PC Liberal PC NDP NDP PC NDP Liberal Liberal NDP Liberal PC PC Liberal PC PC PC PC PC Liberal PC NDP PC PC Liberal Liberal NDP Liberal NDP NDP Liberal

�4 ...JI.)l 'f, � LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Lieutenant-Go vernor of Man itoba ......................................... Hon. Dr. George Johnson Speaker of the Legislative Assembly ..................................... Hon. Denis C. Roean, M.L .A. Deputy Speaker and Chairman of Committee of the Whole .................................................... Mr. William Chornopyski, M.L .A. Deputy Chairman of Committee of the Whole .................................................... Mr. Harold Gilleshammer, M.L.A. Government House Leader ..................................................... Hon. James McCrae, M.L .A.

Opposition House Leader ....................................................... Mr. Reg Alcock, M.L .A. Second Opposition House Leader .......................................... Mr. Steve Ashton, M .L.A. Government Whip ................................................................... Mr. Edward Helwer, M. L.A. Opposition Whip ...................................................................... Mr. Kevin Lamoureux, M. L.A. Second Opposition Whip ........................................................ Mr. Steve Ashton, M.L .A. Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ......................................... Mr. W.

H. Remnant Deputy Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ........................... Ms. Beverley Rosiak Ms. Patricia Chaychuk-Fitz patrick Clerk of Committees ............................................................... Ms. Bonnie Greschuk Legislative Counsei. .................................... ............................. Shirley Strutt Sergeant-at-Arms ........... ......................................................... Mr. Clifford S. Morrissey Deputy Sergeant-at-Arms ....................................................... Mr.

Roy MacGillivray Hansard Editor ....................................................... ................. Suzanne L. Dion Hansard Indexer ...................................................................... Ms. Brenda L. Walker III

INTRODUCTION Ma nitoba Hansard Index is designed to provide easy access to topics discussed in the Legislative Assembly. For this reason it corresponds strictly to the text of Manitoba Hansard. FORMAT The index is in two sections: (

I) combined Member /Subject index, and (2) appendices. Member /Subject index: Main entry in this

section is a subject or personal name heading which may be subdivided. Following the main entry are secondary headings, "see" and "see also" references, and a listing of individuals who spoke on that subject. Appendices: Included in this

section is a complete listing of Oral Questions by department, Bills, Members of the Executive Council, and Chairmen of Standing and Special Committees. FILING ARRANGEMENT The basic filing principle is alphabetical, letter by letter. The sequence is as follows:

a) numbers file at the beginning of the alphabet, if they are the first word in the filing element;

b) initials separated by punctuation, abbreviations, acronyms without interior punctuation are filed at the beginning of their alphabetic group. ABBREVIATIONS 1 r .......................................... First Reading (M) ................................ .................. Motion 2r ...................................... Second Reading 0/C ................................ Order -in-Council 3r ......... ....... ........................ Third Reading P /0 .............. ........................ point of order Arndt ...................................... Amendment R/R .......... ..................

Read and Received CjW .................. Committee of the Whole R/ A ...................................... Royal Assent R/S ........................... Report Stage IV

4-H Clubs 4-H Week Findlay 2535; Gray 2535; Storie 2535; Uruski 2535 Highway cleanup A. Driedger 311 9-20 55- Plus Games Yeo 822 ACRE Business participation Cummings 2515; L.E. Evans 2515 Staffing L.E.

Evans 2515; Cummings 251 5-6 See also Manitoba Hazardous Waste Corp. - Pesticide disposal AIDS Education Misconceptions Doer 934; Orchard 934 Needle exchange program Funding Cheema 1840, 2212; Orchard 1840, 2212 Outreach workers Cheema 18 40; Orchard 1840 Reporting Confidentiality breach Cheema 1010; Doer 933-4; Orchard 933-4, 974, 1010 Guidelines Cheema 1010; Orchard 10 10 Treatment Terminal care facilities Cheema 2212; Orchard 2212 See also Health (Supply) - Communicable Disease Control ARM Industries F-u nding Oleson 11 20; Wasylycia-Leis 11 20 Abitibi-Price Expansion Praznik 169 Aboriginal people Adoptions Repatriation Harper 5980; Oleson 5980 Child care centres Government initiatives Harper 5980; Oleson 5980 Government relationship Harper 4976-80 · Leaders, government support Downey 1973; Harper 19 73 See also Private Members' Business - Resolutions Aboriginal rights Premier's position Filmon 5976; Harper 5976 Supreme Court of Canada Hansard Index 1 Aboriginal rights-Cont.

Harper 5978, 6015; McCrae 5978, 6015 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Recommendations Harper 5979; McCrae 5979 Actors' Showcase Hemphill 19 19; Mitchelson 1918-9 Address for Papers No. 5- September 21, 1989 accepted (Alc ock) 1165 No. 6 - September 21, 1989 accepted (L .S. Evans) 1165 No. 7 - September 27, 1989 accepted (Wasylycia-Leis) 1349 No. 8 - October 20, 1989 accepted (Cheema) 2058 No. 9 - November 28, 19 89 accepted (Roch) 3334 Administration of Oaths of Office,

An Act respecting the (Bill 1) lr Filmon 7 Affirmative action Implementation plan Gray 2057; Hammond 2057 Northern programs Derkach 11 93; Rose 1193 See also Civil Service Commission Agassiz Youth Services Power plant downgrading A. Driedger 1865-6; Edwards 1865-6 Agricultural Advisory Committee Background data Findlay 2614 ; Uruski 2614 Crow rate review L.E. Evans 277, 4395; Findlay 277, 4395-6 Agriculture (Supply) Opening Remarks Findlay 627-30 Response L.E. Evans 630-5; Uruski 635-8 Administration and Finance Communications Branch Salaries L.E.

Evans 768; Findlay 768-9; Uruski 768-9 Computer Services Salaries Findlay 842; Uruski 842 Executive Support Policy Studies L.E. Evans 639-40, 755-8, 763-5; Findlay 639-42, 755-8, 759-62, 766-8; Orchard 762-3; Uruski 640-2, 759-62, 765-8 Salaries L.E. Evans 638-9, 758-9; Findlay 639, 759; Uruski 759 Financial and Administrative Services

Agriculture (Supply}--Cont. Other Expenditures L.E. Evans 842; Findlay 842 Salaries L.E. Evans 840-2; Findlay 840-2 Minister's Salary L.E. Evans 17 14-5; Findlay 171 4-20; Uruski 1715 -20 Personnel Services Salaries L.E. Evans 842-5; Findlay 843-7; Gray 845-7; Kozak 846 Program Analysis Salaries L.E. Evans 847 ; Findlay 847 Summerfallow Compensation Program Administration L.E. Evans 847-8; Findlay 847-8; Uruski 848 Agricultural Development and Marketing Administration Other Expenditures L.E. Evans I 320; Findlay I 320-2; Uruski 13 22 Animal Industry Branch Other Expenditures L.E.

Evans 13 23-4; Findlay I 322-4; Uruski I 322 Marketing Branch Other Expenditures L.E. Evans I 332; Findlay I 332-4; Minenko I 333-4; Uruski I 332-4 Soils and Crops Branch Other Expenditures L.E. Evans 13 25-30; Findlay 13 26-3 1; Uruski I 326-8, I 330 Special Assistance for Commercial Beekeepers L.E. Evans I 33 I; Findlay I 33 I -2; Uruski I 33 I -2 Veterinary Services Branch Other Expenditures L.E. Evans I 322-3; Findlay I 322-5; Uruski I 322, I 324-5 Drugs and Semen Purchases L.E. Evans 16 47-8; Findlay 16 47-8 Education Tax Reduction Program for Farmers L.E.

Evans 16 48; Findlay 16 48-9; Uruski 16 48-9 Emergency Interest Rate Relief Program L.E. Evans 16 40; Findlay 16 40 Federal/Provincial Agreements Agri- Food Agreement L.E. Evans 16 40-1; Findlay 16 40- 1, 16 45-7; Uruski I 645-7 Soil Conservation Agreement Angus 16 44-5; L.E. Evans 16 42-4; Findlay 16 42-5 Income Insurance Fund Hansard Index 2 Agriculture (Supply }--Cont. Administration Findlay 15 I 5-20; Uruski I 5 I 5-20 Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation L.E. Evans 12 87-8; Findlay I 286-9 1; U ruski I 288-9 I Ma nitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Administration L.E.

Evans 849-55, 11 69, 12 41- 6, I 280-3; Findlay 848-55, 11 68-70, I 24 I -54, I 280-6; Uruski 853-5, 12 46-55, I 279-80, I 283-6 Policy and Economics Division L.E. Evans 141 I; Findlay 141 1- 4; Minenko 141 1- 4 Agriculture Research University of Manitoba - Grant Derkach I 555-6; L.E. Evans I 554-6; Findlay I 554-6 Certification Agency Findlay 15 I 3-5; Patterson I 5 I 4; Uruski I 5 I 3-4 Economics Branch Other Expenditures L.E. Evans 14 72-6; Findlay 14 72-83; Uruski 14 76-82 Family Farm Protection Act L.E.

Evans 15 56-8; Findlay I 556-64, I 638-40; Uruski 15 58-64, I 638-40 Manitoba Farms Lands Ownership Board L.E. Evans 15 51- 3; Findlay 15 51- 4; Uruski I 553 Manitoba Natural Products Marketing Council L.E. Evans 14 83-6; Findlay I 483-6, 15 I 0-3; Patterson I 5 I I; Uruski 1510 -3 Milk Prices Review Commission L.E. Evans I 548-50; Findlay 15 48-5 1; Uruski I 550- I Regional Agricultural Services Division L.E. Evans I 334; Findlay 13 34-7; Gray 13 35; Minenko 13 36; Uruski 13 34-5 Agricultural Crown Lands Branch Enns I 408-9; L.E.

Evans 14 04-5; Findlay I 404- I I; Uruski 14 05- 11 Agri-Food, Advisory Council on Impacts of Change Doer 2527; L.E. Evans 2527; Findlay 2527 Agri-Food Agreement See Agriculture (Supply) Agri-Food Policy Conference Drought assistance L.E. Evans 3635; Findlay 3635 GATT negotiations L.E. Evans 3634-5; Findlay 3635 Safety net programs L.E. Evans 3635; Findlay 3635 Supply management programs

Agri-Food Policy Conference-Cont. LE . Evans 2878; Findlay 2878 Agri-Food programs Funding Downey 5482; LE . Evans 5482 Ahluwalia, Karter Cheema 11 27; Doer 11 27; Mitchelson 11 27 Aidun, Dr.

Jamshid McCrae 13 86 Air ambulances See Privilege, Matters of Airport protection All -party agreement Ducharme 2007; Taylor 2007 Airports - Northern See Highways and Transportation (Supply) Aiyawin Housing Corporation Racism documentary Carstairs 271 Alberta Beef Store False advertising Maloway 856 ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne) Address for Papers No. 5 - September 21, 19 89 accepted 11 65 No. 8 - October 20, 19 89 accepted 2058 Budget Debate 584-9 Child and Family Services Amendment Act (B ill 30) 2r 882-3, 939-40 Documents Tabled Developing an Indian and Metis Urban Strategy for Man itoba 2509 Population statistics December 18 , 19 89 3874 Workshop for the Development of an Indian and Metis Urban Strategy for Manitoba 2509 Economic Development, Standing Committee 1s t Report Helwer 15 71 Contempt, Matter of (al leged) 15 71; taken under advisement 15 74-5; Referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections 41 93-6; 4255-7 Education Administration Amendment Act (Bill 60) lr 205 1 Environment (Supply) Administration and Finance Executive Support Hansard Index 3 ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne)---- Cont.

Salaries 3353-6 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act (Bill 27) 2r 2488-9 1; C ;w 3660-4, 3669- 72; R/S 3783 Grievance, Matter of Rules of the House Review 4980-2 Hansard Corrections Reprint request 3246 Health (Supply) Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 3340-3 House Business Adjournment Motion 10 30, 4068, 5956 Estimates order change 2536 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 29) 3r 1017 -9 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (2) (Bill 90) 2r 3955-7 Loan Act, 19 89 (Bill 34) 2r 3401- 6; c;w 3570 -1, 3647 Manitoba Data Services Disposition and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 98) 2r 5603-5 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 96 1 Ministerial Statements Curtis, Charles Vanier Medal recipient Response 969-70 Public Accounts Availability Response 4706 Non-Political Statements Mcilwain, Kelsey International Computer Problem-Solving Contest winner 3857 Prairie Theatre Exchange New facilities- Portage Place 18 44-5 Oral Questions Bank of Canada rate Impact Man itoba 3848 Bill C-2 1 Manitoba position 729 Bankruptcies Job loss statistics 4647, 4707 Budget Deficit reduction 346 Fiscal Stabilization Fund 380, 525 Accountability 525 Aud itor's opinion 380 Health care funding 344 Multiyear forecast 346 Surplus 343-4 Tax reduction 343 CFB Portage Ia Prairie Compensation 3980- 1

ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne}-Cont.

ERD A Agreements Expenditures 5359 Negotiations 782 Premier intervention 782 Economic growth Budget request 5094-5, 5444 Deficit forecast 3849 Full-time employment decline 3635 Government initiatives 28 18 Manitoba rate 28 18 Personal bankru ptcies 2818 Retail sales tax revenues 38 17 Farming industry Financial assistance 3652 Federal Equalization payments Budget predictions 365 2 Manitoba statistics 3636, 3652 Reduction 28 19 Federal funding Manitoba representation 5340 Manitoba statistics 534 1 Premier's position 5300- 1 Spending agenda 5340 Federal programs Cutbacks 3652 First Ministers' Conference Federal equalization payments 2530 Forest fires Compensation, federal 3874 Free Trade Agreement Adjustment assistance 3849 Cancellation clause 5339 Impact Labour 4646 Manitoba 5358 Labour adjustment strategy 4646-7 ' 4 706-7 Goods and services tax Blenkarn report 3651 Cascading 3944 Consumption tax 1917 Corporate contribution 2529 Cost to Manitobans 2529 Federal support funding I 036 Finance Minister's position 365 1- 2 House of Commons Finance Committee Submission tabling request 1917 Impact Cultural industries I 037 Families 10 37 Labour 398 1 Low-income families 3943 Manitoba 454, 1917 Tourism 454 Implementation 3943-4 Income security programs 16 89 Indexing 3944 Opposition support 3980 Revenue neutral 454 Sales tax credits 16 89 Interest rates Increase 5339 Hansard Index 4 ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne}-Cont.

Klinic Community Health Centre New facilities 344 Labour adjustment strategy Government initiatives 4647 Labour force Jnformetrica forecast 5358 Man itoba Agriculture Credit Corp.

Interest rates 5340 Mining tax Impact Thompson 4708 Revenue estimate 4708 Northern Development Agreement Government initiatives 530 1 Out-migration Federal support 3873 Government strategy 4646 Port of Churchill Continued use 5358 Premier's Council Economy 4708 Progressive Conservative Party Agenda 5443 Red River Community College President reporting 2531 Student affairs 2530 Selkirk, Town of Dry dock facilities 5358 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Announcement 5301 Throne Speech Tourism priorities 78 1 Tourism agreement Replacement 5301 Unemployed Help Centres Funding 3850 Unemployment rate Job training initiatives 728 Manitoba statistics 3636 Women 28 19 Unemployment Insurance Commission Benefit reforms 728 Manitoba statistics 3849 Replacement support 3849 Western Diversification Fund Spending agenda 5300 Orders for Return No. 9, dated September 21, 19 89 Ma nness 11 66 No. 10 , dated October 20, 19 89 McCrae 2058-9 Points of Order P/0 by Alcock respecting words "fear mongers" (Cummings) 1616 ; withdrawn voluntarily (Cummings) 1616 P/0 by Alc ock respecting word "irresponsible" (Orchard) 3727; withdrawal requested 3727; withdrawn (Orchard) 3727 P jO by Alc ock respecting unparliamentary language

ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne)-- Cont. (Doer) 3808; taken under advisement 3808; ruled out of order 592 1 P jO by Alc ock respecting imputation of motives (M anness) 4201- 2; Man ness 4202; taken under advisement (Gaudry) 4202; ruled out of order 5920 P/0 by Doer respecting words "poor, poor girl" used by Orchard referencing Gray 224; Alcock 224; withdrawn (Orchard) 224 P/0 by Ma nness respecting alleged criticism of Provincial Auditor (Gray) 2241; Alcock 2241; Gray 2241; ruled out of order 2241 P /0 by McCrae respecting brevity of supplementary questions 13 82; Alcock 13 82; ruled in order 13 82 P /0 by McCrae respecting imputation of motives (Carstairs) 1448; Alcock 1448; taken under advisement 14 48; ruled out of order 1918 P /0 by McCrae respecting discussion of House Business (Roch) 4024; Alc ock 4024; Ashton 4024; ruled in order 4024 P /0 by McCrae respecting political nature of non-political statement (M inenko) 5655; Alcock 5655; Member cautioned 5655 Private Members' Business Address for Papers Goods and services tax 2672-4 Resolutions CSIS Agreement, renegotiation of 3292-3 Privilege, Matter of Air Ambulance Service Access Policy Alc ock 864; Ashton 863-4; McCrae 864; (Orchard) 863; Storie 864; taken under advisement 864; ruled out of order 979 Economic Development, Standing Committee Events occurring on May I, 19 89 referred to Standing committee on Privileges and Elections (An gus) 18 -9; Ashton 19 -20; McCrae 20-2; taken under advisement 22; ruled out of order 31 1- 2; comment on Chair (Supply) Alcock 621- 2 Labour, Minister of Misleading information respecting gas inspections Hansard Index 5 ALCOCK, Reg (Lib, Osborne)--Cont.

Alc ock 4509; Ashton 4509; (H arapiak) 4508; McCrae 4508-9; taken under advisement 4509; ruled out of order 5920- 1 Ombudsman, Office of Impartiality questioned Alc ock 81 2-3; Ashton 81 3; (Connery) 812 ; McCrae 813 ; taken under advisement 813 ; ruled out of order 978-9 Public Gallery attendance Rules of the House Alcock 5961; Ashton 5961; Har per 5961; McCrae 5961; taken under advisement 596 1- 2; Speaker's ruling 5973 Workers Compensation Minister Apology requested by Alcock respecting comments made 14 22; withdrawn (Connery) 14 22 Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 59) lr 2051 Statute Law Amendment (T axation) Act, 19 89 (Bill 86) 2r 3225-7; c;w 3643-4 Supply, Committee of Motion Committee rise Highways and Transportation 11 67-8; Motion carried 11 70 Throne Speech Debate 263-8 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Budget - Federal Effects on Manitoba 23-4, 5448, 5455-7 Child care crisis Effects on Man itobans 10 88-9, 11 01- 2 Goods and services tax Effects on Manitoba 785-6, 787, 10 39 LynnGold Resources Inc.

Intervention to prevent closure 2247-8 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba Amalgamation, Health Carstairs 14 28; Orchard 14 28 Budget reductions Carstairs 14 28; Orchard 420, 14 28; Wasylycia-Leis 420 Funding Cheema 947 See also Health (Supply) Allard, Candace Surgery costs Hemphill 2532; Orchard 2532 Alumax Hydro rates Ernst 426 Ambulance service, air Access policy Derkach 817 ; Storie 817

Ambulance service, air-Cont. See also Privilege, Matters of Amtrak Shuttle Service Impact VIA workers Carstairs 2207; Filmon 2207 Western Canada Carstairs 2207; A. Driedger 2207; Filmon 2207 Justification Doer 2209; Filmon 2209 Minister's involvement Carstairs 2206; A. Driedger 2206 ANGUS, John (Lib, St.

Norbert) Agriculture (Supply) Federal/ Provincial Agreements Soil Conservation Agreement 16 44-5 Beverage Container Act (Bill 10 ) 2r 2960 Budget Debate 428-33 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 32) 3r 2521- 2 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs (Supply) Corporate Affairs Public Utilities Board Salaries 2942-4 Crown Corporations Public Review and Accountability Amendment Act (Bill 55) I r 16 84; 2r 4943-4 Documents Tabled MacLaren Plansearch Letter to Environment Control Division dated May 12 , 19 89 Re: environmental study (M anfor) 12 6 Economic Development, Standing Committee First Report Helwer 15 71 Contempt, Matter of (al leged) 15 71; taken under advisement 15 74-5; referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections 41 93-6; 4207- 10 Energy and Mines (Supply) Opening Remarks (N eufeld) 318 8-9 1, 319 4-5 Response 3191 Administration and Finance Administrative Services Other Expenditures 3351 Salaries 3 3 50 Executive Support Salaries 31 95-7, 319 9 Minister's Salary 41 58-9 Energy Energy Policy Salaries 3351 -3, 3694 Hansard Index 6 ANGUS, John (Lib, St.

Norbert)--Cont.

Man itoba Energy Council 3699 Ma nitoba Energy Authority 415 7 Mineral Resources Mineral Resource Administration Salaries 3699-3702 Mines Salaries 41 43-8, 415 6 Energy Rate Stabilization Amendment Act (Bill 53) 2r 2902 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act (B ill 27) 2r 11 76-8 Highways and Transportation (Supply) Administration and Finance Executive Support Other Expenditures 623 Planning and Design and Land Surveys Planning and Design Salaries and Wages 839, 12 66-7 Industry, Trade and Tourism (Supply) Administration and Finance Strategic Planning Salaries 4448 Liquor Control Amendment Act (Bill 14 ) lr 14 24 Manitoba Data Services Disposition and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 98) 2r 5422-6; 3r 5944-5 Manitoba Energy Foundation Repeal Act (Bill 92) 2r 4401 Man itoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 183 2-4 Ministerial Statements Ma nitoba Hydro Seasonal Diversity Agreements Response 3069-70 Ma nitoba HydroBonds Response 447 Natural Resources (Supply) Engineering and Construction Technical Services Less: Recoverable 4909 Non-Political Statements Manitoba Marathon 68 1 Oral Questions Aut opac Cyclical renewals 4 7 31 Merit discounts 4732 Quarterly payments 4732 Budget Gasoline tax increase 381 Conawapa Project Environmental impact study 13 44 Ontario Hydro agreement 13 45 Preferential employment policy 4433-4 Public Utilities Board study 13 45 Crown Corporation Public Review Act Amendments 15 79, 1612

ANGUS, John (Lib, St. Norbert�Cont. Environmental impact hearings Advertising 12 7 Process review 12 7 Freedom of Information Act Obstruction, Finance Minister 11 58-9 Gas utilities Annual rate increase 5647 Goods and services tax Impact Autopac rates 5648 Energy resources 11 26 Hydro rates 5648 LynnGold Resources Inc.

Negotiations 2380 Premier's intervention 2380- 1 Man itoba Data Services Divestiture Employee notification 59 16 Freedom of Information Act I 086-7 Systemhouse proposal 59 16 Manitoba Hydro Capital projects review 1613 Preferential policy 5414 Project information release 15 79 Rate increase Justification 5278 Water rental charges 5278 Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Advertising policy 4952 Standing Committee referral 4952 Man itoba Public Insurance Corporation General Insurance Division Privatization 5648 Research and Training Centre 56 11 Public Utilities Board Capital pro jects Crown corporations 1612 Gas rate review 4084 Jur isdiction Manitoba Hydro 15 79, 1612 -3 Resources 4085 Repap Manitoba Inc.

Asset recovery 282 1 Construction

schedule 2734 Contractual obligations 3443 Cutting areas 2734 Phase 2 approval 4340 Environmental impact hearings 12 6-7, 2734 Environmental impact study - U.S. 2473 Environmental licensing 4436, 4900 Monitoring 4864 Environmental lobbying 4864, 4900 Road upgrading agreement 38 1 Sale agreement security 2472 Swan River plant delay 282 1, 4340, 4436 Guarantee 3443-4 Standing and Special Committees Scheduling 4953 Ozone Depleting Substances Act (Bill 83) 2r 3840- 1 Hansard Index 7 ANGUS, John (Lib, St. Norbert�Cont.

Petitions Waverley and Pembina Highway Request for safety measures 3239; ruled in order 3327 Points of Order P jO by Angus respecting imputation of motives (Ashton) 3828; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 3828; ruled out of order 5889 P/0 by Angus respecting threat of invisible axe (M anness) 4208; taken under advisement (Gaudry) 4208; withdrawn (M anness) 4208 P jO by Ashton requesting tabling of documents (Orchard) 15 3; McCrae 15 3; Orchard 15 3; ruled out of order 15 4 P /0 by Cowan respecting reflections on past proceedings of the House (Lam oureux) 5636; Angus 5636; ruled in order 5636; Member cautioned 5636 P /0 by Rocan respecting words "hypocritical" and "arrogant" (Angus) referencing Man ness 4675; withdrawal requested 4675-6; withdrawn (Angus) 4676 Private Members' Business Address for Papers Goods and services tax 4675-6 Resolutions Boards, Commissions and Agencies, Appointment to 11 55 Manfor, environmental impact studies 4676-8 Small businesses, support for 5641- 2 Winnipeg Rivers Ma nagement 38 10 -2 Privilege, Ma tter of Economic Development, Standing Committee Events occurring on May 1, 19 89 referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections (Angus) 18 -9; Ashton 19 -20; McCrae 20-2; taken under advisement 22; ruled out of order 31 1- 2 LynnGold Resources Inc.

False information alleged Angus 230 1; (Cowan) 2299-30 1; McCrae 230 1- 2; Storie 2302; taken under advisement 2302; ruled out of order 4398 Public Health Amendment Act (Bill 91) 2r 514 9-50 Rural Development (Supply) Municipal Board Salaries 18 27 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Child care crisis

ANGUS, John (Lib, St. Norbert )--Cont. Day care worker walkout 18 68-9. 18 98- 1 900 Effects on Man itobans I I I 0- 1 Goods and services tax Effects on Manitoba I 069-70 LynnGold Resources Inc.

Intervention to prevent closure 2267-8 Announcements Conflict of Interest Bill 75 - Insurance Amendment Act Ducharme 3860 Bill 98 - Manitoba Data Services Disposition and Consequential Amendments Act Edwards 537 1 Edwards, Paul and wife Anne Birth of son, Evan Lawrence Murdoch Rocan 884 Applied Linguistics Centre Funding Derkach 4999; Yeo 4999 Appointments Chaychuk-Fitzpatrick, Patricia Clerk of Committees appointment Rocan 14 9 Chornopyski, William Committees Chairmanship Whole House appointment Filmon 8 Deputy Speaker appointment Filmon 8 Contradictions Edwards 34-5; McCrae 35 Page appointments Rocan 8 Appointments, political Education, Department of Derkach 973; Yeo 973 Apprenticeship in Manitoba 45th ann iversary Ashton 14 44; Edwards 14 43-4; Hammond 1443 Appropriation Act, 1989 (Bill 99) lr Man ness 5634; 2r Charles 5732-7; Cheema 5705-9; Downey 5867-72; A.

Driedger 5849-53; H. Driedger 5737-42; L.E. Evans 5669-75; Gray 581 2-4, 5923; Kozak 57 10 -4; Lamoureux 5634-7, 566 1 -4; McCrae 5848-9; Minenko 5742-7; Mitchelson 5854-7; Oleson 5857-6 1, 5866-7; Patterson 57 1 9-23, 5923; Roch 57 14 -9; Rose 5675-7, 569 1 -2, 5704-5; Yeo 5664-8; CfW 5923; R/S Man ness 5943; 3r 5946; R/ A 5958 Hansard Index 8 Arthritic Self-Help Association See Health care - Rheuma tologist shortage Arts Policy Review Committee Agenda Charles 5534; Mit chelson 5534 Appointments Charles 13 82-3; Mitchelson 13 83 Hearings Participation criteria Charles 2075; Mitchelson 2075

Schedule Charles 2075; Mitchelson 2075, 215 6 Impartiality Mitchelson 5534-5; Wasylycia-Leis 5534 Man itoba Arts Council Charles 5533; Mitchelson 5533 Mismanagement Charles 5533; Mitchelson 5533 Report author Mitchelson 5534; Wasylycia-Leis 5534 Rural representation Charles 5534; Mitchelson 5534 See also Culture, Heritage and Recreation (Supply) - Cultural Resources ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson) Business Practices Act (B ill 64) 2r 4427 Civil Service (Supply) Opening Remarks (H ammond) 4603-5 Response 4605-6 (Gray) 4605 Civil Service Commission Executive Office Salaries 4607- 11 Constitution Amendment, 19 87 6054-8 Documents Tabled Health Letter from V.Chernecki (M ONA) respecting bed closures 307 5 Industry, Trade and Tourism Advertisement promoting good labour-management relations 5239 Labour Management Review Committee Letter to Campbell from Connery dated March 2, 19 89 re: transportation provision 11 95 Man itoba Medical Association Minister of Health's speaking notes 4599 Motion Picture Projectionists Union Letter from G.M ironuk to Hammond respecting licensing 45 15 Thompson General Hospital

ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)---Cont.

Memo respecting nursing staff shortage 4269 Ecological Reserves Amendment Act (Bill 33) 2r 3904-6 Economic Development, Standing Committee 1s t Report Helwer 1571 Contempt, Matter of (al leged) 1571; 15 73; taken under advisement 15 74-5; referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections 41 93-6; 4203-7 Education and Training (Supply) Universities Grants Commission Salaries 5034-5 Employment Standards Amendment Act (Bill 17 ) lr 91; 2r 17 39-40, 18 34-5 Energy Rate Stabilization Amendment Act (Bill 53) 2r 3485-6, 3555 -9 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act (Bill 27) 2r 2882-8 Grievance, Matter of Rules of the House review 4982-5 Health (Supply) Opening Remarks (Orchard) 17 91- 3, 18 03-6, 19 33 Response 17 98- 1 803, 19 28-33 Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 19 3 5-7 Health Advisory Network 2084-90, 2093-2 1 00, 21 20-2, 21 24-32 Human Resource Ma nagement Salaries 2348-52 Minister's Salary 333 5-40, 3344-6 Research and Planning Other Expenditures 21 62-4, 21 70-4, 21 76-8 Salaries 2326-8, 2344-5 Alcoholism Foundation of Ma nitoba 3080-9 Community Health Services (Operations) Northern Health 3794-8 Regional Services Salaries 2836-7, 2839-40 Community Health Services (Programs) Communicable Disease Control Salaries 2391 -9, 253 6-40 Continuing Care Home Care Assistance 2746-53 Dental Health Salaries 2784 Environmental Health Salaries 2785 Hansard Index 9 ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)---Cont.

Gerontology Salaries 2702 Health Promotion Salaries 2589-93 Hearing Conservation Salaries 2699-270 1 Maternal and Child Health Salaries 2579-86 Manitoba Health Services Commission 31 68-76, 325 1- 60 Mental Health Mental Health Administration Salaries 2845-6 Mental Health Clinical Salaries 3010 Mental Health Promotions Salaries 3001- 3 Mental Health Services Other Expenditures 3046-9 Health of Non-Sm okers,

An Act to Protect the Health (Bill 16 ) 2r 5335-7 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (Bill 3) 2r 71 7-20 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (2) (Bill 4) 2r 17 36 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (5) (Bill 54) 3r 19 82-5 House Business Adjournment Motion 10 30, 4068-9, 5956 Estimates order change 2536 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 29) 2r 920-7; c;w 10 28-9 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (2) (Bill 90) 2r 3962-8; c;w 4038, 4044- 5, 4047-50, 4055 International Sale of Goods Act (Bill 7) 2r 3895 Labour (Supply) Opening Remarks (Hammond) 4343-5 Response 4348-50 (Edwards) 4345-8 Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 4752-3 Research and Planning Salaries 4352-4 Labour Apprenticeship and Training Salaries 4569-7 1 Employment Standards Salaries 4564-7 Fire Prevention Salaries 4362 Grants 4575-6

ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)-Conr.

Manitoba Labour Board Salaries 4568 Mechanical and Engineering Salaries 4356-9 Pension Commission Sala ries 4574 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 31) 2r 4402-8 Landlord and Tenant Amendment Act (Bill 2) 2r 11 85-8 Law Society Amendment Act (2) (Bill 71) 2r 3952-4 Legislative Assembly Management Commission Amendment Act (Bill 12 ) 2r 3948-50 Loan Act, 19 89 (Bill 34) 2r 2482-8 Manitoba Data Services Disposition and Consequential Amendments Act (B ill 98) 2r 5597- 603 Manitoba Energy Foundation Repeal Act (Bill 92) 2r 5573 -4 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 959 Ministerial Statements Ap prenticeship in Manitoba 45th Ann iversary Response 1444 Manitoba HydroBonds Response 447-8 Mun icipal Assessment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 79) 2r 3836-8; 3r 428 1 Non-Political Statements Canadian Flag 25th Ann iversary 5309- 10 Consumer Week 19 22 Festival du Voyageur 516 0 Mcilwain, Kelsey International Computer Problem-Solving Contest winner 3857 Oral Questions Bill No. 31 Withdrawal 5238-9 Budget Gallery admittance 331 Invitation list 330- 1 Job creation 450 Cardiac care Waiting period 3875-6 Dauphin General Hospital Quick-r esponse team 5519 Deer Lodge Hospital Extended care beds 31 27-8 Family Services, Department of Underspending 5345 Hansard Index 10 ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)-Conr.

Final Offer Selection Information release 17 46-7 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Job creation 450 Hazardous materials storage Emergency regulations 413 8 Health care Community-based clinics 17 83 Extended care bed report 4733 MONA report 38 1 7-8 Northern staff shortages 818 Quick response team 4599 Surgery waiting list 4341- 2 Two-tiered system 4733 Underspending 5344 Health care facilities Bed closure policy 3075-6 Extended care beds 316 3 Health care profession Binding arbitration 3492 Negotiations 4732 Pay equity 3333, 38 18 Health, Minister of Apology requested 3492 Campaign promises 4087 Speech tabling request 3493 Health Sciences Centre Emergency department Shutdowns 316 4 Upgrading 316 3 Klinic Community Health Centre Funding, Capital 17 83 Labour Man agement Review Committee Transportation provision 11 94-5 Manitoba Medical Association Health Minister's speech 4599 Negotiations 4088, 4904 Northern Development Agreement Negotiations 215 8 Northern education Government support 18 67 Northern health care Quick-response team 5520 Northern Tax Allo wance Extensions 4026 First Ministers' Conference 3244 Prime Minister discussions 3245 Removal impact 3245 Thompson exclusion 11 25-6 Plant closures Layoff protection 307-8 Legislation implementation 3656 Thompson Crisis Centre Closure 2822 Minister's intervention 2822 Service reduction 2822 Thompson General Hospital Anesthetist shortage 818 -9 Funding 4269 Funding, maintenance 819 Immigrant physician licensing 2078 Pay equity 4269

ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)-- Cont. Quick- response team 55 19 Staff recruitment 2078, 4269 Thompson, Man itoba Clinic setup 2078 Solvit Resources Inc.

Fire Commissioner's report 413 7 Public inquiry 413 8 Unemployed Help Centres Funding 308 Unemployment Insurance Commission Benefit reforms 308 Unemployment rate Man itoba statistics 3655-6 Villa Royale Project Minister's meeting 4970- 1 Welcome Home Program 497 1 Workers Compensation Board King Task Force recommendations 450- 1 Workplace Safety and Health Inspector reinstatement 45 14 -5 Projectionist regulations 45 15 Ozone Depleting Substances Act (Bill 83) 2r 4422-4 Petitions Workers Compensation Request for legislative changes I 006; ruled in order I 079 Points of Order P /0 by Angus respecting imputation of motives (Ashton) 3828; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 3828; ruled out of order 5889 P /0 by Ashton requesting tabling of documents (Orchard) 15 3; McCrae 15 3; Orchard 15 3; ruled out of order 15 4 P /0 by Ashton requesting clarification Committee of Supply adjournment 11 70; clarification 11 70 P /0 by Ashton respecting Minister's statement during consideration of Estimates 12 24; Downey 11 67; Manness 11 67-8; taken under advisement (Gilleshammer) 11 68; ruled out of order (Gilleshammer) 12 24 P jO by Ashton respecting Ministers answering question not specifically taken as notice 12 99; taken under advisement 12 99; ruled in order 15 75 P /0 by Ashton respecting unparliamentary language (Orchard) 17 84; Members cautioned 17 84 P /0 by Ashton respecting words "the Member of Hypocrisy" (T aylor) referencing Wasylycia-Leis 18 42; Taylor 18 42; taken under advisement 18 42; Hansard Index 11 ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)-- Cont. ruled out of order 215 8 P jO by Ashton respecting political nature of non-political statements 19 20; Cowan 19 20; McCrae 19 20; taken under advisement 19 20- 1; Members cautioned 21 58-9 P jO by Ashton respecting use of points of order 2659; Members cautioned (Chornopyski) 2659 P /0 by Ashton respecting reference to absence of Member (Filmon) 31 28; ruled in order 312 8; withdrawn (Filmon) 312 8 P /0 by Ashton respecting reference to absence of Me mber (Connery) 31 39-40; Cowan 314 0; taken under advisement (K ozak) 314 0; ruled in order 3447; apology offered (Connery) 3447 P /0 by Ashton respecting alleged reflection upon the Chair (Connery) 314 0; McCrae 3141; previously taken under advisement (K ozak) 3141 P jO by Ashton respecting words "deliberately putting false information on the record" (Filmon) referencing Taylor 3586; taken under advisement 3586; ruled in order 5922; withdrawal requested 5922; withdrawn (F ilmon) 5922 P /0 by Ashton respecting leave denied to have Bill 31 remain standing (H arper) 5097; McCrae 5097; ruled out of order 5097-8; challenged (Ashton) 5098; sustained 5098 P /0 by Ashton respecting relevancy of debate (Connery) 5264; McCrae 5264; Members cautioned (Chornopyski) 5264 P /0 by Cheema respecting comments by Connery, apology requested 13 85; Ashton 13 85; taken under advisement 13 85; withdrawn (Connery) 14 22 PjO by Downey respecting relevancy of debate (Ashton) 2503; Members cautioned 2503 P/0 by Harper respecting resolutions appearing on Order Paper 5967-9; Ashton 5969; McCrae 5969- 70; ruled in order 5970 P/0 by Lamoureux respecting relevancy of debate (Ashton) 5640; ruled in order 5640; Member cautioned 5640 P /0 by McCrae respecting words "The people of Flin Flon want the whole truth" (Storie) 730; Ashton 730; withdrawal requested 730; Storie 730; unequivocal withdrawal requested 730;

ASHIDN, Steve (NDP, Thompson)--- Cont. withdrawn (Storie) 730 P /0 by McCrae respecting words "We have all noted with interest that there have been changes to the Public Utilities Board, I presume so it is easier for ICG to get their rate applications through" (Storie) 870; withdrawal requested (Mc Crae) 870; Ashton 870; Filmon 870; taken under advisement 870; ruled in order 979; withdrawal requested 979; withdrawn (Storie) 979 P JO by McCrae respecting brevity of supplementary question I 086; Ashton 10 86; ruled in order I 086 P JO by McCrae respecting discussion of House Business (Roch) 4024; Alc ock 4024; Ashton 4024; ruled in order 4024 P /0 by McCrae respecting relevancy of debate (Cowan) 51 65-6; Ashton 516 6; ruled in order (Chornopyski) 516 6 P JO by Plohman respecting reference to inattentiveness of NDP opposition critic (Connery) 2215 ; Ashton 2215 ; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 2215 ; ruled in order 3447; apology offered (Connery) 3447 P JO by Rocan respecting word "guts" (Ashton) 45 1; withdrawal requested 45 1; withdrawn (Ashton) 45 1 P JO by Rocan respecting exhibit (peanuts) 12 94; ruled out of order 12 94; Subsequent P/0 by Ashton respecting past practice in regard to exhibits 12 94; McCrae 12 94; Speaker's ruling 12 94 Private Members' Business Address for Papers Goods and services tax 2675-7 Resolutions CFB shutdowns 4775-8 Health Ombudsman 4114 -6 Northern Tax Allowance 2336-8 Northern University, establishment of 2570-3 Obstetrical centres, establishment of 5393-5 Pharmacard system, implementation 12 61- 3 Senate reform 31 59-60 Small business, support of 5638-4 1 Privilege, Matter of Air Ambulance Service Access policy Alcock 864; Ashton 863-4; McCrae 864; (Orchard) 863; Hansard Index 12 ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)--- Cont.

Storie 864; taken under advisement 864; ruled out of order 979 Economic Development, Standing Committee Events occurring on May I, 19 89 referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections (Angus) 18 -9; Ashton 19 -20; McCrae 20-2; taken under advisement 22; ruled out of order 31 1- 2 Harapiak, Harry False information respecting Minister of Labour Ashton 4594-5; Carstairs 4595; (H ammond) 4594; McCrae 4595; taken under advisement 4595; ruled out of order 5920 Labour, Minister of Misleading information respecting gas inspections Alcock 4509; Ashton 4509; (H arapiak) 4508; McCrae 4508-9; taken under advisement 4509; ruled out of order 5920- 1 Ombudsman, Office of Impartiality questioned Alcock 812 -3; Ashton 813 ; (Connery) 812 ; McCrae 813 ; taken under advisement 813 ; ruled out of order 978-9 Public Gallery attendance Rules of the House Alcock 5961; Ashton 5961; Harper 5961; McCrae 5961; taken under advisement 596 1- 2; Speaker's ruling 5973 Residential Tenancies Act (Bill 42) 2r 4079 Roman Catholic Archiepiscopal Corporation of Winnipeg and the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Winnipeg,

An Act to amend

an Act respecting the (Bill 96) 2r 551 1 Rural Development (Supply) Municipal Assessments Other Expenditures 18 07-11 Social Allowances Amendment Act (Bill 67) 2r 3825-30 Statute Law Amendment Act (B ill 10 2) c;w 5923-4 Statute Re-enactment and By-law Validation (Winnipeg) Act (Bill 38) 2r 3950 Throne Speech Debate 210 -7 Unfair Business Practices Act (Bill 21) 2r 2502-4

ASHTON, Steve (NDP, Thompson)---Cont.

Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Budget - Federal Effects on Manitoba 24 Child care crisis Day care worker walkout 18 70, 18 86-8 Effects on Man itobans II 16 -7 Goods and services tax Effects on Manitoba 786-7, 1041, 10 53-5 Housing conditions in Manitoba 5830 Native education Post-secondary funding 321- 2 VIA Rail cutbacks Impact on Man itoba 432 1- 2 Waste Reduction and Prevention and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 84) 2r 3883-9 Wildlife Amendment Act (Bill 35) 2r 5405-7 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (Bill 46) 2r 15 85-9 1 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) 2r 5505-8, 5582-5 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (3) (Bill 97) 2r 5274 Assinihoine Community College Discrimination Derkach 2968, 312 8; Wasylycia-Leis 2968 Autopac See Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation B-A Construction Closure L.S.

Evans 3222; Man ness 3222-3 Bank of Canada rate Impact Man itoba Alc ock 3848; L.S. Evans 5181; Manness 3848-9, 5181 Small business Man ness 5754; Minenko 5754 Bankruptcy rate Job loss statistics Alcock 4647, 4707; Cummings 4647; Manne ss 4707-8 Beaconia Beach Preservation Taylor 257 Bedson, Derek Death of, former Clerk of Executive Council Carr 9; Doer 1 0; Filmon 9 Benham, Donald Carstairs 10 14 ; Doer 1014 ; McCrae 1014 Hansard Index 13 Beverage Container Act (Bill 10) I r Roch 14 9; 2r Angus 2960; Doer 2962-3, 3208-9; A. Driedger 311 9-20; H.

Driedger 2637-8; Gaudry 4383-4; Gray 2201 -3; Lamoureux 4639-4 1; Mandrake 4638-9; Man ness 3374-5; McCrae 2960-2; Orchard 514 4-6; Patterson 2959-60; Roch 16 52-3; Biathlon, Falcon Lake H.

Driedger 5846-7; Rose 5827 Bill C-21 Manitoba position Alcock 729; Filmon 729 Bill C-22 Challenge Manitoba Society of Seniors Carr 274, 866, 886-7; Downey 274, 887; McCrae 866, 886 Constitutionality Carr 866; McCrae 866 Impact Pharmaceutical prices Cowan 12 56; Carr 12 58 Seniors Carr 274; Connery 274 Provincial jurisdiction Carr 886; McCrae 887 See also Petitions Bill No. 16 Education Minister's support McCrae 5648; Storie 5648 Bill No. 31 Withdrawal Ashton 5238-9; Filmon 5239; Hammond 5239 Bill No. 37 Minister's support Penner 18 41; Roch 18 40- 1 Bill No. 42 Alternative Cowan 5782; Ducharme 5782-3 Consultations Cowan 5752-3; Ducharme 5752-3; Filmon 5689, 5753; Lamoureux 5689 Government support Filmon 5688-9; Lamoureux 5688-90 Hotel inclusion Ducharme 16 60; Hemphill 16 60 Lobby groups Cowan 4734, 54 17 ; Doer 582 1 -2; Ducharme 4734, 5417 ; Filmon 582 1- 2 Minister's position Carstairs 5749; Cowan 5783; Ducharme 5749-50, 5783 Passage Ducharme 5752; Lamoureux 5752 Residential Tenancies Commission

Bill No. 42-Cont. Cowan 5783; Ducharme 5783 Standing committee referral Cowan 4734, 541 6-7, 5701 -2; Doer 5750- 1; Ducharme 54 17 , 5518 , 5702, 5750; Filmon 5701, 5750- 1; McCrae 4734; Wasylycia-Leis 551 7-8 Winnipeg Real Estate Board Doer 5821; Filmon 5821 Withdrawal Ducharme 5752; Lamoureux 5752 Bill No. 79 Aboriginal exemptions Harper 5978-9; McCrae 5979 Tax collection statistics Penner 25 13 ; Roch 25 13 Bills (See titles of particular Bills) No. I - Administration of Oaths of Office,

An Act respecting the No. 2 - Landlord and Tenant Amendment Act No. 3 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act No. 4- Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(2) No. 5 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(3) No. 6 - Law Reform Commission Act No. 7 - International Sale of Goods Act No. 8 - Endangered Species Act No. 9 · Forest Amendment Act No. I 0 - Beverage Container Act No. I I - Electoral Divisions Amendment Act No. 12 - Legislative Assembly Man agement Commission Amendment Act No. 13 - Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act No. 14 - Liquor Control Amendment Act No. 15 - Motor Vehicle Standards Act No. 16 - Health of Non-Sm okers,

An Act to Protect the No. 17 - Employment Standards Amendment Act No. 18 - Ozone Layer Protection Act No. 19 - Ground Water and Water Well Amendment Act No. 20 - Municipal Assessment Amendment Act No. 21 - Unfair Business Practices Act No. 22 - Consumer Protection Amendment Act No. 23 - Consumer Protection Amendment Act

(2) No. 24 - Business Names Registration Amendment Act No. 25 - Corporations Amendment Act No. 26 - Real Property Amendment Act No. 27 - Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act No. 28 - Public Inquiry into the Hansard Index 14 Bills-Cont. Administration of Justice and Aboriginal People,

An Act to establish and validate the No. 29 - Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 No. 30 - Child and Family Services Amendment Act No. 31 - Labour Relations Amendment Act No. 32 - City of Winnipeg Amendment Act No. 33 - Ecological Reserves Amendment Act No. 34 - Loan Act, 19 89 No. 35 - Wildlife Amendment Act No. 36 - Real Estate Brokers Amendment Act No. 37 - Municipal Assessment Amendment Act No. 38 - Statute Re-enactment and By-law Validation (Winnipeg) Act No. 39 - Human Tissue Amendment Act No. 40 - Land Surveyors Amendment Act No. 41 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(4) No. 42 - Residential Tenancies Act No. 44 - Travel Industry Act No. 45 - Confidentiality of Personal and Corporate Records Compiled and Stored by Government Departments and Agencies,

An Act to Protect No. 46 - Workers Compensation Amendment Act No. 47 - Dependants Relief Act No. 48 - Intestate Succession and Consequential Amendments Act No. 49 - Dower Amendment Act No. 50 - Wills Amendment Act No. 51 - Marital Property Amendment Act No. 52 - Family Maintenance Amendment Act No. 53 - Energy Rate Stabilization Amendment Act No. 54 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(5) No. 55 - Crown Corporations Public Review and Accou ntability Amendment Act No. 56 - Workers Compensation Amendment Act

(2) No. 57 - Pension Benefits Amendment Act No. 58 - Pension Benefits Amendment Act

(2) No. 59 - Public Schools Amendment Act No. 60 - Education Administration Amendment Act No. 61 - City of Winnipeg Amendment Act

(2) No. 62 - City of Winnipeg Amendment Act

(3) No. 63 - Consumer Protection Amendment Act No. 64 - Business Practices Act No. 65 - Fatality Inquiries Act

Hansard Index Bills-Con t. No. 66 -

Summary Convictions Amendment Act No. 67 - Social Allowances Amendment Act No. 68 - Court of Appeal Amendment Act No. 69 - Law Society Amendment Act No. 70 - Provincial Court Amendment Act No. 71 - Law Society Amendment Act

(2) No. 72 - Securities Amendment Act No. 73 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(6) No. 74 - Highway Traffic Amendment Act

(7) No. 75 - Insurance Amendment Act No. 76 - Real Estate Brokers Amendment Act

(2) No. 77 - Cemeteries Amendment Act No. 78 - Prearranged Funeral Services Amendment Act No. 79 - Municipal Assessment and Consequential Amendments Act No. 80 - Civil Service Superannuation Amendment Act No. 81 - Environment Amendment Act No. 82 - Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Amendment Act No. 83 - Ozone Depleting Substances Act No. 84 - Waste Reduction and Prevention and Consequential Amendments Act No. 85 - Elections Amendment Act No. 86 - Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 19 89 No. 87 - Employment Standards Amendment Act

(2) No. 88 - Physically Disabled Persons Parking Act No. 89 - United Health Services Commission,

An Act to amend

an Act to Incorporate No. 90 - Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89

(2) No. 91 - Public Health Amendment Act No. 92 - Ma nitoba Energy Foundation Repeal Act No. 93 - Franchises Act No. 94 - Consumer Protection Amendment Act

(4) No. 95 - Certified General Accountants Act No. 96 - Roman Catholic Archiepiscopal Corporation of Winnipeg and the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Winnipeg,

An Act to amend

an Act respecting the No. 97 - Workers Compensation Amendment Act

(3) No. 98 - Man itoba Data Services Disposition and Consequential Amendments Act No. 99 - Appropriation Act, 19 89 No. 10 0 - Supplementary Appropriation Act, 19 89 No. 101 -S tatute Re-enactment and 15 Bills-Cont.

By-Law Validation (M unicipal) Act No. 10 2 - Statute Law Amendment Act, 19 90 No. 10 3 - Statute Law Amendment (R e-enacted Statutes) Act, 19 90 No. 104 - Professional Home Economists Act No. 10 5 - Legislative Assembly Amendment Act No. 10 6 - Victoria Beach By-law Validation Act, Rural Municipality of Biomedical waste Disposal Cummings 5538; Lamoureux 5538 Safety standards Cummings 5538; Lamoureux 5538 Block Parents Program Funding Kozak 2766-7; Mitchelson 2767 Boards, Commissions and Agencies Appointments See Private Members' Business - Resolutions Boating Safety - Winnipeg Rivers Speed limits Ducharme 819 ; Taylor 819 See also Private Members' Business - Resolutions Boeing Canada Technology Limited Expansion - Japan Ernst 4056; Minenko 4056 Bond, Dr.

S.L. Untendered contract Carstairs 933; Ernst 933 Borger, Alan PC Party donation Lamoureux 13 2 Brandon Avenue Snow dump site Alcock 266 Brandon, City of Air control tower L.S. Evans 5687-8; McCrae 5688 Cabinet Office Provincial crisis line Charles 17 44-5; Penner 17 44-5 Services - rural community Penner 17 44; Roch 17 44 Redevelopment funding L.S. Evans 5537; Penner 5537 See also Private Members' Business - Resolutions Brandon Community Options Program Funding formula Gray 31 28-9; Oleson 31 28-9

Hansard Index Brandon General Hospital Anesthetist shortage Cheema 3727; Orchard 3727; Funding LS. Evans 13 50- 1 Hemodialysis patients LS. Evans 16 64; Orchard 16 64 Nur sing reclassification LS. Evans 16 65; Orchard 16 65 Peer Review Committee LS. Evans 13 85, 4039-44; Orchard 13 85, 4039-44 Pharmaceutical consulting service L.S.

Evans 16 64; Orchard 16 64-5 Brandon Mental Health Centre Staffing levels Cheema 2297; Orchard 2297 Bratun, Rostyslav Enns 5446; Minenko 5446; Uruski 5446 Breast cancer screening See Private Membe rs' Business - Resolutions Brick Warehouse Business name registration Connery 30 1 8-9; Maloway 2660, 3020- 1 Charges Connery 15 26; Maloway 15 26 Consumer bulletin Connery 15 27; Maloway 15 27 Fines levied Maloway 15 27; McCrae 15 27 Buchan, Bob See LynnGold Resources Inc. Budget CRISP allocations Oleson 383; Rose 383 Deficit reduction Alc ock 346; Man ness 346 Economic development Doer 305; L.S.

Evans 347-8; Filmon 305-6; Ma nness 348 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Alc ock 380, 525; Doer 345; L.S. Evans 347; Manness 345, 347, 380, 525 Accou ntability Alc ock 525; Man ness 525 Aud itor's opinion Alc ock 380; Man ness 380- 1 Gal lery admittance Ashton 33 1; Filmon 331 Gasoline tax increase Angus 38 1; Manness 38 1 Health care Al cock 344; Cheema 565; Doer 378-80; Filmon 379-80; Ma nness 344, 379, 565 lnfill housing commitment Ducharme 306; Lamoureux 306 Invitation list Ashton 330-1; Filmon 330- 1 1 6 Budget-C oni.

Job creation Ashton 450; Carstairs 448-9; Doer 345; Filmon 448-9; Man ness 345, 450 Manufacturing equipment tax Doer 328; Filmon 328 Mult iyear forecast Alcock 346; Manness 346 Payroll tax reduction L.S.

Evans 347; Manness 347 Rural development Filmon 381 -2; Uruski 38 1 Secrecy Doer 328; Filmon 328 Support Carstairs 378; Ma nness 378 Surplus Alcock 343-4; Manness 344 Tax reduction Alcock 343; Carstairs 377-8; Manness 343, 377-8 Budget Address Ma nness 334-41 Budget Debate Alcock 584-9; Angus 428-33; Carr 568-73; Carstairs 350-8; Charles 295-8; Cheema 51 5-9; Cowan 489-94; Cummings 573-6; Doer 385-9 1; Downey 519 -2 1, 530-4; A. Driedger 548-5 1; H. Driedger 484-9; Enns 404-8; Ernst 423-8; L.E. Evans 465-7, 476-80; L.S.

Evans 576-82; Filmon 551 -9; Gaudry 443-6; Gray 534-9; Hammond 480-4; Harapiak 433-8; Kozak 368-7 1; Lamoureux 582-4; Maloway 539-44; Man drake 544-8; Manness 589-93; McCrae 494-500; Minenko 500-5; Neufeld 39 1- 5; Oleson 438-43; Orchard 358-63; Pankratz 506- 1 0; Penner 457-60; Plohman 51 0-5; Praznik 371 -6; Roch 408- 13 ; Storie 398-404; Uruski 363-8; Wasylycia-Leis 460-5 Budget - Federal Farm income assistance Findlay 5413 ; Uruski 5413 Impact Child care Gray 5517 ; Hemphill 36-7; Oleson 37, 55 17 Education Carstairs 5478; L.S.

Evans 5445; Filmon 5478-9; Manness 5445 Environmental programs Cummings 5578; Taylor 5578 Health care Carstairs 5439, 5440- 1; Cheema 5445; Doer 541 8-9, 5441; Filmon 541 8-9, 5440- 1, 5441, 5445;

Hansard Index Budget - Federal-Cont. Manness 5439 Labour force Doer 5442; L.S. Evans 5444; Filmon 5442; Ma nness 5444 Manitoba Carstairs 12 9; Filmon 12 9-30 Northern/Native people Downey 5482-3, 55 17 , 5538; Gray 5517 ; Harper 5482, 5538 Out-mi gration Carstairs 5479; Filmon 5479 Seniors' programs Downey 5517 ; Gray 5517 Native Communication Network Doer 5479; Filmon 5479-80 Port of Churchill A.

Driedger 5364-5; Plohman 5364 Premier's correspondence Carstairs 12 ; Filmon 12 Transfer payments Doer 53 59-60; Filmon 5359-60 Western Diversification Fund Carr 15 5; Filmon 15 5 See also Urgent Public Importance, Mat ters of Burns Foods I OOth anniversary Filmon 553 Government discussions Edwards 548 1; Filmon 548 1 BURRELL, Parker (PC, Swan Rifer) Industrial Relations, Standing Committee on 3rd Report 5926-30 Law Amendments, Standing Committee on 2nd Report 3980 3rd Report 4059 Private Members' Business Resolutions Aboriginal Treaty Rights 29 11 Throne Speech Debate 41- 2 Business Names Registration Amendment Act (Bill 24) I r Maloway 342; 2r H.

Driedger 3541 -2, 4387; Ma loway 19 59-6 1; Minenko 3540- 1; Patterson 508 I See also Petitions Business Practices Act (Bill 64) I r Connery 19 67; 2r Ashton 4427; Connery 31 39-45; Maloway 314 6-5 1; Minenko 390 1 -4; Patterson 4411 -2 Business, small See Private Members' Business - Resolutions Business Start Program Funding Ernst 421; Minenko 421 Start-up 17 Business Start Program-C ont. Ernst 5754; Minenko 5754 CCOSH See Canadian Centre for Occupation Safety and Health CFB Portage Ia Prairie Alternative use Carstairs 13 ; Filmon 13 Closure Carstairs 13 , 28, 97 1; Connery 26-7, 19 8-9; Doer 2732; L.E.

Evans 78; Filmon 13 , 97 1, 2732 Compensation Alcock 3980- 1; Carstairs 10 07, 439 1 -2, 4682, 5275; Cummings I 007, 4682; Filmon 398 1, 439 1- 2, 5275 Federal/Provincial meetings Carstairs 10 07; Cummings 1007 Government position Carstairs 4683; Manness 4683 Government strategy Carstairs 4682; Cummings 4682-3 Premier's meeting agenda Carstairs 439 1; Filmon 4392 Western Premiers' Conference Carstairs 970; Cummings 970- 1 See also Private Members' Business - Resolutions; Urgent Public Importance, Matters of - (Budget - Federal) CFB Summerside Aeronautical centre Carstairs 4392; Filmon 4392 CN Rail layoffs Ma ndrake 61 7-8; Plohman 620, 948-9 Aversion Driedger 4228; Plohman 4228; Equipment maintenance A.

Driedger 13 43; Plohman 13 43 Labour adjustment strategy Carstairs 54; A. Driedger 14 52; Filmon 54-5; Hammond 14 52; Plohman 14 52 Minister's intervention Carstairs 53-4; A. Driedger 53-4 Rail line abandonment Carstairs 19 70- 1; A. Driedger 1971 -2; Filmon 19 70- I Relocation Carstairs 53; A. Driedger 161 1; Penner 53; Plohman 161 1 Rural impact Cowan 332; A. Driedger 58, 332; Filmon 59; Penner 58; Plohman 58-9 Safety record Carstairs 53; Cowan 332; A. Driedger 54, 332 CPIC See Crop Protection Institute of Canada

Hansard Index CSIS See Canadian Security and Intelligence Service Cadham Protincial Laboratory Infectious material storage Doer 3982; Orchard 3982, 3985; Campbell, Melissa Miller See Social assistance - Citizenship Canada Assistance Plan Compliance Oleson 2733, 312 6; Rose 2733, 312 6 Canada Day Derkach 5540 Canada-Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) 5059 Canada-Manitoba Tourism Agreement Deadline extension Carr 48 19 , 4860, 4897-8; Ernst 4819 , 4860, 4897-8 Forks Renewal Corporation Carr 5884; Filmon 5884 Canada Pension Plan Claw backs Doer 1212 ; Filmon 1212 -3 Reforms Cowan 937-8; Downey 938 Canada Post Northern subsidy reduction Carstairs 31 23-4; Downey 312 4; Filmon 312 4 Canada- U.S.S.R. trade Ma nitoba representation Ernst 2878-9; Minenko 2878 Port of Churchill usage Doer 2988; Filmon 2988, 4822; Harapiak 4822 Canadian Airlines International Ma nitoba service Carstairs 2151- 2; A.

Driedger 2151- 2 Maintenance hangar A.

Driedger 616 Canadian Centre for Occupational Safety and Health Free information Hammond 4901; Harapiak 4901 Funding Hammond 4901; Ha rapiak 4901 Grant Edwards 4576, 4689; Ha mmond 4576, 4689-90 Privatization Hammond 4901; Harapiak 4901 Canadian Diseases Weekly See AID S Reporting - Confidentiality breach Canadian energy supplies See Private Members' Business - Resolutions 18 Canadian flag Ashton 5309- 1 0; Carr 5309; Enns 5310 Canadian Security and Intelligence Senice Confidentiality information Edwards 2055; McCrae 2055 Records security Carstairs 92; McCrae 92 Renegotiation Carstairs 92; McCrae 92 Suspension Edwards 2055; McCrae 2055 See also Private Members' Business - Resolutions Canadian Wbeat Board See Private Members' Business - Resolutions Canadian Wildlife Federation Rafferty- Alameda Dam Project Charles 2279; Cummings 15 79; Enns 2279; Taylor 15 78-9 Canola oil industry Seed crushing plants L.E.

Evans 45 14 ; Findlay 45 14 Tariff reduction L.E. Evans 45 14 ; Findlay 45 14 U.S. production L.E. Evans 45 14 ; Findlay 45 14 Carbon monoxide poisoning Chimney inspection policy Edwards 4085-6; Hammond 4085-6 Detection Edwards 45 1 0; Hammond 45 10 Inspector reinstatement Hammond 4085; Harapiak 4085 Out- of-province treatment Cheema 4268; Orchard 4268; Cardiac care Waiting period Ashton 3875-6 Cheema 15 3, 602; Doer 151- 2; Orchard 151- 2, 15 3, 602, 3876 CareerStart '90 Statistics L.S. Evans 5241; Oleson 5241 Cargill Foods Limited Interprovincial trade L.E.

Evans 2238; Findlay 2238 CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge) Budget Debate 568-73 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 32) 2r 17 56-9; 3r 25 19 -21 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 61) 2r 441 2-5 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 62) 2r 3438-9, 3860- 1

CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge)--- Cont.

Constitution Amendment, 19 87 6058-61 Culture, Heritage and Recreation (Supply) Communication and Information Resources Provincial Archives Salaries 277 1 Culture, Heritage and Recreation (Programs) Cultural Resources Salaries 2722 Grants to Cultural Organizations 27 1 8-20 Documents Tabled Village at Portage Place Affidavit of Gary John Julius 5046 Electoral Divisions Amendment Act (Bill II ) 2r 791 Environment (Supply) Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 361 5-7 Health (Supply) Administration and Finance Health Advisory Network 2028 Minister's Salary 3343-4 Community Health Services (Programs) Gerontology Salaries 2707-8 Landlord and Tenant Amendment Act (Bill 2) 2r 858-60 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 18 30-2 Ministerial Statements Bedson, Derek Death of former Clerk of Executive Council of Man itoba Response 9 Municipal Assessment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 79) 2r 383 1- 3 Non-P olitical Statements Canadian Flag 25th Ann iversary 5309 Manitoba Government Employees' Assoc.

All Charities Campaign 11 64 Rosh Hashana 14 31 Royal Winnipeg Ballet 50th Anniversary 15 82 Seniors' Day 872-3 Seniors' Month 279 McBryde, Ron Death of former MLA (The Pas) 821 United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, 41s t Ann iversary 3659 Oral Questions Bill C-22 Challenge Man itoba Society of Seniors Hansard Index 1 9 CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge)---Con t. 274, 866, 886-7 Constitutionality 866 Impact seniors 27 4 Provincial jurisdiction 886 Budget - Federal Western Diversification Fund 15 5 Canada- Manitoba Tourism Agreement Deadline extension 48 19 , 4860, 4897-8 Forks Renewal Corporation Funding 5884 Canadian Constitution Notwithstanding clause 15 27 Centre for Aging Status report 15 4 Child care workers Salaries I 083 Core Area Initiative Public hearings 817 Renewal 816 -7 Crime prevention programs Seniors 2437 Crown corporations Accountability 47 10 Executive salary review 419 Crystal Casino Lease agreement 29 14 Start -up costs 2914 Upgrade costs 2915 Decentralization Announcement 316 3 Tabling request 3161- 2 Transfer notice 316 1- 2 Elderly abuse Discussion paper Cost 473 Delay 865 Release 16 , 472 Documentation project 2688 Hearings Participants 2688 Private meetings 2688 Initiatives 472 Legislation 536 1- 2 Family Services, Department of Spending decisions 11 91 Federal/Provincial relations Political climate 2913 Forks Renewal Corporation Accountability 4395, 47 10 -1, 5885 Boat basin Construction 5575-6, 5650- 1 Contract 5783-4 Delay costs 5784, 5786 Funding 5650, 5702, 5786 Development moratorium 38 19 , 3852, 4082, 5684, 5884 Documentation 15 25 Government priorities 38 1 8-9 Historical artifacts protection 5684 Hotel conversion 4081- 2, 4395 Parking 51 18 Leasing arrangements 15 24-5

CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge}--- Cont.

Planning 41 8-9 Recreation centre 3852 Standing committee referral 5118 Visitor Centre Funding 48 18 , 4860, 4898 Status 5575 Free Trade Agreement Labour adjustment strategy 11 96 Gold mine - Shoal Lake Environmental impact study 562 Water protection plan 562 Laboratory Centre for Disease Control Construction delay 5514 Funding 16 60 Government support 333 1 Lobby efforts 2612 , 3332 Provincial involvement 2052-3 Site selection 12 1 1- 2, 1915 -6, 16 60-1, 19 73-4, 2052, 2612 Labour adjustment strategy Federal consultations 11 96 Literacy programs Seniors 1012 -3 Ma nitoba Intercultural Council Russell, Grant - appointment 56 1- 2 Meech Lake Accord Parallel agreement 551 3-4 Premier's position 3332-3, 3656-7 Quebec consultations 55 14 Senate reform committee 3657, 5513 Mentally handicapped Service reduction 11 91 Minority language rights - Quebec Premier's position 5683 Throne speech 560 Municipal Conflict of Interest Act Amendments 12 95-6 Public perception 12 1 1, 12 96 Mu nicipal Works Yard Provincial capital funding 3332 North Portage Development Corporation Accou ntability 4395, 47 10-1, 4861 Board of Directors 4288, 4488 Cost to Manitoba 4229 Crown corporations, accountability 4339 Documentation request 419 0, 4229, 4288 Legal intervention 419 0 Parking garage contract 4287 Place Promenade Construction costs 4267, 4688-9 Developer's costs 4267 Documentation request 5047 Financial discrepancies 5089 Monthly shortfall 497 1- 2, 5046 Non-profit management 4689 Profit forecast 4972 Property appraisal 497 1, 5046 Tabling request 5046 Takeover 497 1 Vacancy rate 41 90, 5047, 5089-90, 51 19 Provincial auditor 4897, 495 1, 5090 Hansard Index 20 CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge}---Co nt.

Public Accounts, Standing Committee on 47 10 -1, 4897, 495 1- 2 Southside Portage Avenue 5484 Village at Portage Place Cost to Manitoba 413 7 Financial instability 4487 Government intervention 413 7 Leasing arrangements 4488 Monthly shortfall 4394 Mortgage documentation request 4081 Mortgage 4339, 4487 Public auction 4081 Vacancy rate 41 37, 4488 Orders- in-Council Release I 083 Pharmacard system Implementation 16 , 5362 Pharmacare Budget increase 866 Premier's staff Salary cap 10 83 Provincial/M unicipal projects City Works Yard relocation 215 4 Cost sharing 205 1 Criteria 2052 Scrap yard relocation 215 3 Riverbank development Environmental impact study 5702 Housing Government support 308 Historical study 308 Noise level 308 Senate reform committee Announcement 291 9-20 Formation 5303-4 Make-up 2920 Seniors Directorate Accomplishments 865 Initiatives 865, 2437 Minister's responsibilities 2437 Role 536 1 Seniors' programs Initiatives 15 -6 Skills Unlimited Funding 11 91- 2 Order- in-Council 11 91 Winnipeg Arena proposal Federal/ Provincial discussions 2913 Provincial involvement 2913 Site preference 3852 Winnipeg, City of Capital grants 1915 Winnipeg downtown revitalization Initiatives 817 Program co-ord ination 418 Petitions Bill C-22 challenge Manitoba Society of Seniors 303; ruled in order 342 Roman Catholic Archiepiscopal Corporation of Winnipeg and the Roman Catholic Archidiocese of Winnipeg,

CARR, James (LIB, Fort Rouge}-Co nl.

An Act to amend

an Act respecting 4430; ruled in order 4487 Private Members' Business Resolutions CFB shutdowns 4773-5 Pharmacard system, implementation 12 57-9 Senate reform 31 54-6 Urban Commercial Districts 5730- 1 Roman Catholic Archiepiscopal Corporation of Winnipeg and the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Winnipeg,

An Act to amend

an Act respecting the (Bill 96) lr 4508; 2r 5510 -1; R/S 5942; R/A 5958 Seniors Directorate (Supply) 2365-6, 2370-2, 2407- 10 , 2416 , 241 9-22, 2553-5 Throne Speech Debate 289-94 Urban Affairs (Supply) Opening Remarks (Ducharme) 21 34-5 Response 21 35-6 Administration and Finance Executive Support Other Expenditures 21 38-44 Minister's Salary 2359-60 Expenditures Rela ted to Capital Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg 2333-4 Financial Assistance - City of Winnipeg Current Programs Grant 214 4-6, 214 8, 21 78-9, 2181- 2, 218 5 Urban Policy Co-ordination Canada-Manit oba Winnipeg Core Area Renewed Agreement 233 1- 2 North Portage Redevelopment 2329-31 Other Expenditures 218 8, 21 90-4, 219 6 Riverbank Development 2332-3, 2335 Salaries 2328 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Child care crisis Day care worker walkout 18 93-5 Effects on Manitobans II 06-7 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights) Budget Debate 350-8 Constitution Amendment, 19 87 5989-94 Documents Tabled Bill C-2 1 Letter from P.Savoie (Senate of Canada) respecting attendance before Committee 515 3 Health Advisory Network Interim report on extended care beds 4728 Personal Care Homes Minnedosa Tribune

article quoting Carstairs, November 22, 19 89 Hansard Index 21 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights}-Cont. 4728 Economic Development, Standing Committee 1s t Report Helwer 15 71 Contempt, Matter of (alle ged) 15 71; taken under advisement 15 74-5; Referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections 419 3-6; 4241- 3 Electoral Divisions Amendment Act (Bill II) 2r 789-90 House Business Adjournment Motion 5946-8 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 647-9 Ministerial Statements Ecole Polytechnique (Mo ntreal) Student shooting Response 3582-3 Man itoba Export Awards Response 2468 Manitoba Hydro Ontario Hydro Agreement Response 358 1 Manitoba Telephone System 1 urisdictional control Response 19 65 Meech Lake Accord Man itoba Task Force Report Response 2073 Provincial Court backlog reduction Response 11 90 Non-Political Statements Benham, Donald Winnipeg Sun Reporter 1014 Chilean elections 3857 China - Military violence 333 Handicap Awareness Employment Day 384 Hanen, Dr.

Marsha P. President University of Winnipeg 60 Hnatyshyn, Ray Governor General appointment 16 65-6 Mandela, Nelson Prison release 518 4 McKenzie, Debbie and Lars Sharp Marriage congratulations 978 Royal Winnipeg Ballet David Peregrine, death of 658 Season's Greetings 4067 Smerchanski, Mark Death of former MLA (Burrows) 11 63 Oral Questions Alcoholism Foundation of Ma nitoba Amalgamation, Health 14 28 Budget reduction 14 28 Amtrak shuttle service Impact VIA Rail workers 2207 Western Canada 2207

Hansard Index CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights}-- Cont. Minister's involvement 2206 Anti-racism programs Funding 271 Initiatives 27 1 Bill C-3 1 - Senate Committee Manitoba representation 515 3 Bill No. 42 Housing Minister's position 5749 Bond, Dr. S.L.

Untendered contract 933 Budget Job creation 448 Support 378 Tax reduction 377-8 Budget - Federal Impact Education 5478 Health care 5439, 5440- 1 Manitoba 12 9 Out-migration 5479 Premier's correspondence 12 Transfer payments 515 2 CFB Portage Ia Prairie Aeronautical centre 4392 Alternative use 13 Closure 13 , 970 Compensation 1007, 439 1 -2, 4682, 5275 Federal/provincial meeting 1007, 439 1 Government strategy 4682-3 Western Premiers' Conference 970 CN Rail layoffs Labour adjustment strategy 54 Minister's Awareness 54 Intervention 53-4 Rail line abandonment 19 70- 1 Relocation 53 Safety record 53 CSIS Agreement Records security 92 Renegotiation 92 Canada Post Northern subsidy reduction 31 23-4 Canadian Airlines International Manitoba service 2151 Charter of Rights and Freedoms Equality of Rights 4949 Chief Medical Examiner Communicable diseases 468 Child and Family Services Budget commitment 2964-5 Deficits Analysis 5412 Responsibility 2965 Firearms reporting 523 Government communication 54 13 Loan costs 2965 Referrals - schools 523 Service reduction 54 12 Staffing levels 5412 Child care Federal strategy 111 8 22 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights}--Cont.

Long-range planning 1912 Space assurances 111 8 Standards reduction I 033 Task force Recommendations 1912 Workers Cost of living increase 16 58 Incentives 16 58 Salary negotiations 191 1 China - Military violence Man itoba's position 325 Special telephone service 325 Civil servants Accountability 1447 Performance evaluation 97 1 Civil Service Act Compliance 14 45-6, 14 47-8 Government policy 14 47 Civil Service Commission Policy grievance 14 46 Term positions 14 46 Conawapa Project Environmental impact study 3544, 3583 Environmental interveners Funding 3544 Licensing stages 3583 Native training programs 3584-5 Preferential employment policy 3584 Public Utilities Board review 2644-5 Concordia Hospital Laboratory worker safety 17 78 Consultants Ou t-of-province bids 933 Provincial bids 933 Consumer protection legislation Negative option disallowance 726 Cross-border trade Impact retail business 2876 Man itoba tourism strategy 2876 Crown corporations Accou ntability 45 1 2-3 Day surgery Program expansion 417 Decentralization Hiring policy 5838, 5840, 5882 Impact families 5840 MGEA consultations 5839 -40 Management notification 5882 Office locations 5839 Teacher Certification Branch 5882 Wrongful dismissal analysis 5883 Deer Lodge Hospital Extended care beds 32 17 , 4060, 4225, 4728 Douglas Scott and Company Responsibilities 884-5 Untendered contract 884-5, 932 Drought assistance Federal/Provincial program 5275 ERDA agreements Negotiations II Announcement 5275-6

Hansard Index CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights)--- Cont.

Signing date 51 52-3 Tourism expenditures 779 Economic growth Federal-pro vincial discussions 4683 Government initiatives 3327-8, 4682 Job creation 2875 Education, Assistant Deputy Minister of Termination 97 1 Educational facilities Child care spaces 387 1 Elderly abuse Discussion paper Author 885, 932 Costs 932 Environmental protection Policy I 006-7 Provincial jurisdiction I 007 Family Services, Department of Staffing I 033 Family Services, Minister of Premier's support 11 56 Resignation request 10 33, 111 9 Family violence Charges 522-3 Counselling availability 523 Firearms seizure 523 Federal Equalization Payments Documentation request 11 57 Reductions 11 57, 4264 Federal funding Manitoba statistics 5276 Zero growth 5!7 7 -8 Federal Immigration Office Relocation 15 22-3 Federal operations Man itoba jobs 19 71 Winnipeg facilities 15 23 Finance, Minister of Federal/Provincial meeting 814 -5 Revenue neutral 813 Tax neutral 778 Tourism impact 779 Financial Report, Quarterly Health Care underspending 38 13 First Ministers' Conference Education task force 2876 Issues discussed 312 4 VIA Rail service 2208 Forest fires Compensation, federal 5822 Total costs 5822 Forks Renewal Corporation Man date 45 13 Free Trade Agreement Impact social programs 3070 Labour adjustment funding 307 1- 2 Motor vehicle regulations 16 85 Subsidy negotiations 2986-7, 3070- 1, 312 3 Programs analysis 312 3 Social programs list 307 1 Freedom of Information Act Gag orders 2003 23 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights)--- Cont.

Ombudsman Report 2002 Goods and services tax Application 778 Concessions 363 1 Conference Board of Canada 2729-30 Consumption tax 2529 Departmental impact studies I 080 Finance Minister, position 16 59, 2729, 363 1 Food exclusion 16 59 Government position 2528, 2608, 2644, 3240 Housing Application 2875 Exemption 3240 Impact Man itobans 2528, 2729 Small business 3240 Increases Job losses 449 Indexing 10 80, 2528, 394 1 Liberal minority report 3239 Ministerial support 394 1 Position paper I 080 Premier's Intervention 10 32 Position 3940 Rebates 10 80 Indexing 16 59, 2608, 2609, 3240 Revenue neutral 10 79 Seven percent tax alternative 394 1 Tax credits 10 79, 3632 Government documents Security 325 Review 326 Government management Secrecy 10 3 3 Government vehicles Misuse 3776 Minister's awareness 3776 Policy review 3776 Grace Hospital Asbestos 2469 Handling 24 70 Health and Safety conditions 2470 Investigation 2469 Removal policy 2470 Grain silo project Cancellation 12 9 Hazardous materials Designated materials list 65 1- 2 Storage Mandatory reporting 65 1 Health Advisory Network Extended care report 4225 MONA membership 38 14 Report release 32 16 Health care Acute care beds 4225 Administrative decisions 3 216 -7 Anesthetist Recruitment 416

Hansard Index CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, Rifer Heights)-Cont.

Shortage 416 Elective surgery backlog 3654 Extended care bed report 4728-9 Overcrowding 517 7 Premier's intervention 413 3 Rural services 4729 Surgery delays 51 7 6-7 Health care facilities Elevator Inspections 413 6 Regulations 413 4 Employee safety 38 14 Police response 17 77 Security systems 17 77 Health care profession Pay equity 38 14-5 Health, Department of Administrative decisions 4224 Health, Minister of Binding arbitration position 3489-90 Misinformation provided 3441 Health Sciences Centre Anesthetist shortage 417 , 3654 Elevator Inspection 413 4, 418 8 Upgrading 418 7 Emergency facility upgrading 41 33-4 , 4224 Patient death inquest 418 8 Housing market Declining demand 304 Human rights education Curriculum Compulsory 272 Development 4970 Pilot program amendments 4970 Industry Potato processing 4392-3 Job Training for Tomorrow Funding 449 Labour adjustment strategy Government initiatives 3632 Labour Skills Training Funding 3329 Initiatives 449, 3328, 3632 Ladco land development deal Cash distribution 303 Finalization date 242 Nelson River Construction 242 Proposals 241- 2 Tabling request 242, 304 Start-up date 304 Lemay House Federal rehabilitation funds 4019 Man itoba Child Care Association Meeting request 191 1 Man itoba Data Services Confidentiality guidelines 92-3 Divestiture 32, 92 Records security 32 Manitoba Hydro Preferential rates 15 0 24 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, Rifer Heights)-Cont.

Manitoba Intercultural Council Advisory role 469 Board member selection 469 Government interference 468-9 Russel l, Grant Appointment 598-600 Endorsement 599 Resignation request 600 Manitoba Medical Association Binding arbitration 344 1' 3654, 5698, 5748 Negotiations 3440, 3488, 5696-7 Ma nitoba Telephone System Competition 203-4 Facsimile machine sales 203 Sales tax elimination 779 Medical profession Binding arbitration 3489 Recruitment 5234, 5749 Meech Lake Accord Canada clause 261 1 Man itoba position reaction 2611 Public discussions 2611 Mental health care Facility upgrading 15 22 Staff protection 15 22 Survey recommendations 15 21 Military personnel Transfers 12 93 Minority language rights Premier, position 1215 Prime Minister, position 1215 Mu nicipal Hospitals New facilities 4060 Upgrading funds 4728 Native education All-party resolution 310 Funding, post-secondary 309- 10 Native women Abuse Education programs 4492 Statistics 4492 Networks of Centres of Excellence Agricultural projects 2378 Manitoba Business applicants Funding share 2377 Primary centres 2377 Recipients 2377 University of Manitoba grant 2378 North Portage Development Corporation Accountability 4596 Cash flow 204 Place Promenade Auction delay 45 12 Public Accounts, Standing Committee 5048-9 Viability 4596 Village at Portage Place Mortgage Auction 4595 Default 204

Hansard Index CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights)---Co nt.

Value 4595 Northern Telecom contract Job security 2003 Nur sing profession Abusive treatment 17 77 Immunization costs 38 14 PCB storage sites Regulation amendments 12 92 Site security 12 92 Theft 12 92 Parent-Child Centres Funding 2965 Personal care homes Communicable diseases 468 Complaint process 2303 Inspection Policy 2302-3 Report access 2303 Menus provided 2305 Parainfluenza deaths 468 Sanitation standards 2305-6 Standards enforcement 2302-3, 2306 Pharmacard system Implementation 4059 Port of Churchill Grain shipments 12 Prairie Militia headquarters Building occupants 12 92 Relocation 12 92 Premier Gary Filmon Federal/Provincial relations 10 08 Premier's Council formation Industry and technology 3329 Progressive Conservative Party Agenda 5440, 5477 Progressive Conservative Party - Federal Premier's disassociation 5822 Public Utilities Board Funding 3543 Man itoba Hydro, Capital projects 3543 Racism All-party task force 4969 Racist lapel pins Legal Intervention 4948-9 Opinion request 4948-9 Private prosecution 4948 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Environmental Hearing process 272 Impact study 272, 1007 Legal intervention 34 18 Repap Manitoba Inc.

Swan River Project guarantee 341 8-9 Ridd, Karen Arrest - El Salvador 2986 Robert H. Smith School Child care spaces 387 1- 2 Rural Development, Department of Deputy Minister reporting 17 41 Minister's concerns 17 42 Rural services 25 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, River Heights)---Co nt. Decentralization 17 41- 2 Inventory 17 42 St.

Boniface Hospital Elevator Inspection 418 8 Upgrading 418 8 Obstetrical capacity 32 Intensive care nursery 4060 Patient turnaways 33 Sales tax, provincial Cascading 814 Reduction 778, 813 , 814 Schools, private Child abuse investigation 4341 Corporal punishment 434 1 Seniors Directorate Communications 884 Silica-Sand Plant Environmental impact study 151 Negotiations 15 0 Revenue source !5 0 Provincial investment 14 9-50 Skills Development Program Funding reduction 449 Skills Unlimited Evaluation 111 9 Funding 11 19 , 11 56, 11 91 Stubble and peat burning Accident statistics 18 60 Regulations 18 60- 1 Substance abuse Availability 465 1 Compulsory education programs 4020- 1, 4061, 4650, 4652 Counselling programs 4650 Crack cocaine education programs 13 79-80 Education programs 3775 Federal rehabilitation funds 13 80, 14 28, 2509, 3775, 401 9-20 Out-o f-province treatment 4020 Youth education program 2509- 10 , 3775, 4060 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Announcement 5274 Taxicab drivers Protective shields 16 84 Loan program 16 84 Safety and Health Training program 16 85 Teaching profession Binding arbitration 3489 Thompson General Hospital Bed closures 4263-4 Staff recruitment 4264 Transfer payments Man itoba statistics 5275 Transportation industry Ma nitoba services 215 2 Meeting request 215 2, 2207 Unemployment rate

Hansard Index CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, Rifer Heights}-- Cont.

Manitoba statistics 3632, 4264-5 University Act Amendments 18 61- 2 University of Manitoba Board of Governors Student representation 18 61 Faculty of Medicine Accreditation downgrading 5234 Funding 5235 Program enhancement 5234-5 Residency program 5235 Surgical training 5235 Urban Native Strategy Native women abuse 4493 VIA Rail Correspondence request 13 41 Cutbacks Cost to Manitoba 4084 Documentation 13 42 Government position 15 75 Impact study 13 41- 2, 13 79, 15 76-7 Labour adjustment 4084 Legal intervention 4227, 4286 Maintenance centre 15 77 Manitoba statistics 4083, 4286 Prevention campaign 15 76 Transfers 4287 Federal/Provincial discussions 13 78 Northern route protection 13 42 Provincial strategy 13 79 Videon Cable TV Negative option sales 726-7 Western Diversification Fund Funding allocations II Manitoba statistics 515 3 Winnipeg downtown revitalization Program co-ord ination 205 Workplace Safety and Health Regulation amendments 673, 413 6 Advisory council recommendations 673 Prevention plans 652 Reversal 674 Points of Order P JO by Carstairs respecting comments by Connery, apology requested 26; McCrae 26; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 26; ruled out of order (Rocan) 210 Private Members' Business Resolutions Boards, Commissions and Agencies Appointments to 11 47-9 Immigration and Human Rights 3468 Privilege, Matter of Curtis, Charles, Public Servant Apology requested from Carstairs respecting comments made (Ma nness) 414 ; L.S.

Evans 414 -5; apology volunteered 414 Harapiak, Harry False information respecting 26 CARSTAIRS, Sharon (LIB, Rifer Heights}-- Cont.

Minister of Labour Ashton 4594-5; Carstairs 4595; (H ammond) 4594; McCrae 4595; taken under advisement 4595 ruled out of order 5920 Throne Speech Debate 43-50 Motion Amendment 50 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Budget - Federal Effects on Ma nitoba 27-8, 545 1- 2 Child care crisis Effects on Man itobans 11 04-5 Goods and services tax Effects on Ma nitoba 1043-4 Native education Post-secondary funding 313 -4, 316 -7 VIA Rail cutbacks Impact on Man itoba 4294-5 Written Questions No. 5 - February 12 , 19 90 51 85 No. 6 - February 19 , 19 90 5366 Cataract surgery Waiting list Ashton 434 1; Orchard 434 1 Cattle feed industry Government support Downey 5820; L.E.

Evans 5820 Cemeteries Amendment Act (Bill 77) I r Connery 2151; Connery 4399; Lamoureux 4964; Maloway 4960-4; Patterson 4960 Centre for Aging Status report Carr 15 4; Downey 15 4-5 Certified General Accountants Act (Bill 95) I r Praznik 4430; 2r H. Driedger 5086-7; Kozak 51 50; Praznik 5085-6; R/S Praznik 5942; 3r 5944; R/ A 5958 Chalmers, Angela McCrae 4270 CHARLES, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk) Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 99) 2r 5732-7 Budget Debate 395-8 Culture, Heritage and Recreation (Supply) Opening Remarks (M itchelson) 2557-60 Response

CHARLES, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk}-Cont. 2560- 1 Administration and Finance Communications Salaries 2567-8 Executive Support Salaries 256 1- 3, 2566-7 Finance and Management Services Salaries 259 5-7 Manitoba Film Classification Board Salaries 2597-8 Minister's Salary 2772 Communication and Information Resources Executive Administration Salaries 2767 Ma nagement and Purchasing Salaries 2768 Provincial Archives Salaries 277 1 Queen's Printer Other Expenditures 2770 Translation Services Salaries 2770 Culture, Heritage and Recreation (Programs) Community Places Program 2765-6 Cultural Resources Salar ies 2720-4 Grants to Cultural Organizations 2603-4, 2606-7, 27 10-2, 27 14 -7 Historic Resources 2726-7 Man itoba Intercultural Council 2756-60 Public Library Services 2724-5 Recreation 2727 Regional Services Salaries 2756 Documents Tabled Rape examinations Letter from Dr.

Dittberner to W. Grieger respecting Selkirk and District General Hospital policy 4191 Economic Development, Standing Committee 1s t Report Helwer 15 71 Contempt, Matter of (all eged) 15 71; taken under advisement 15 74-5; referred to Standing Committee on Privileges and Elections 4 J 93-6; 421 3-5 Electoral Divisions Amendment Act (Bill II ) 2r 792-3 Endangered Species Act (B ill 8) 2r 11 44-5 Family Services (Supply) Child and Family Services Family Dispute Services External Agencies 4549-5 1 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act (Bill 27) 2r 11 71- 3 Hansard Index 27 CHARLES, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk}-Cont.

Forest Amendment Act (Bill 9) 2r 14 35-6 Ground Water and Water Well Amendment Act (Bill 19 ) 2r 14 36-8 Health (Supply) Mental Health Mental Health Clinical Salaries 30 I 0-1 Mental Health Promotions Salaries 3000- 1 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 29) 2r 980-4 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (2) (Bill 90) 2r 4001- 3 Ma nitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) lr 12 6; 2r 643-5, 3768-70 Ministerial Statements Forestry Month Response 30- 1 Municipal Assessment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 79) 3r 4279-80 Natural Resources (Supply) Opening Remarks (Enns) 4822-3 Response 4823 (Har apiak) 4823-4 Administration and Finance Computer Services Salaries 4824 Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. 4824-5 Engineering and Construction Regional Engineering Services Salaries 4909 Fisheries Administration Salaries 501 6-9 Forestry Administration Salaries 4990-4 Land Administration Salaries 492 1- 2 Parks Administration Salaries 49 17-9 Regional Services Administration Salaries 4828-9 Northern Development Agreement Provincial Fire Program Development and Evaluation Salaries 4833-7 Resource Support Services Garrison Diversion Opposition 5027 Sustainable Development 5027

CHARLES, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk)-- Cont. Water Resources Administration Salaries 4909- 13 Wildlife Administration Salaries 5023-5 Non-Political Statements China - Military violence 82 1 Drug Awareness Week (Selkirk) 2736 Lange, Cindy Teen consumer-b ased TV program 2736 Mental Il lness Awareness Week 15 83 Order of the Buffalo Hunt recipients Martin Bergen, Ernst Hansch, Ernst Keller, Rubin Spletzer 18 45-6 Royal Winnipeg Ballet 50th Anniversary 60 Speaker's Forum on the Status of Disabled Persons 279 Oral Questions Arts Policy Review Committee Agenda 5534 Appointments 13 82-3 Hearings

schedule 2075 Participation criteria 2075 Ma nitoba Arts Council 5533 Mismanagement 5533 Rural presentations 5534 Brandon Cabinet Office Provincial crisis line 17 44-5 Canadian Wildlife Federation Rafferty-Alameda court challenge 2279 Civil Service Commission Affirmative action 4866 Community Investment Fund Funding delays 16 88 Independent board 15 81 Legislation 16 87-8 Morris Conservative Association 15 81 Volunteer Board announcement 15 81 Conawapa Project Environmental impact study 2646-7 Fish ladders 264 7 Lake Winnipeg levels 2647 Wildlife protection 2646 Cross-cultural education Government initiatives 4866, 5653 Crown lands Nat ive land claims 2686 Sale of 2686 Cultural organizations Funding 13 83 Culture, Minister of Apology request 654 Resignation request 654 Environment Act City of Winnipeg compliance 14 51- 2 Sewage disposal charges 331 Ferreira, Antonio Deportation 2988 Family Services involvement 2988 Hansard Index 28 CHARLES, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk)--Co nt.

Government intervention 2988 Fishing industry Impact low water levels 55 19 Forest fires Public inquiry invitations 51 57-8 Forest management Clear cutting 14 25 Goods and services tax Impact cultural industries 16 65 Goose farming Impact environment 5784 Human Rights Program Curriculum development 4866 Irrigation report Tabling request 2074 Manitoba Intercultural Council Advisory role 57, 676 Board appointment criteria 653-4 Funding responsibilities 676 Granting capacity 36, 57-8 Russell, Grant Resignation request 675 Meech Lake Accord Racist editorial cartoon 2278 Morden Reservoir Low water levels 5519 Mult icultural Grants Advisory Council Board appointments 36, 13 82 Disbursement of funds 35 Racist material Cha rges 5653 Rafferty- Alameda Dam Project Compensation agreement 2279 Environmental impact study 2278-9 Rape assessments Rural Man itoba 4191, 4289 Red River City of Winnipeg 14 26, 2213 Health concerns 14 25 Management plan 14 25 Rural services Crisis line funding 45 15 Sewage disposal Cleanup 332 Municipal guidelines 331 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Site announcement 14 24 Victims' Assistance Fund Rape counselling 4289 Water pollution Low water level warning 55 18 Water resources Arden Ridge 2074 Plumas district 207 4 Workers Compensation Board Appeals 733 Claims 733 Private Members' Business Address for Papers Goods and services tax 40 14-6

CHARLFS, Gwen (LIB, Selkirk)---Cont. Resolutions Electoral Boundaries Commission Composition of 3685-6 Environmentally Acceptable Packaging 4560-1 Farm Income Stabilization Program 708-9 Pharmacard system, implementation 12 57-9 Public Health Facility in Dauphin 16 03-4 Selkirk Landing Project 5009- 11 Rural Development (Supply) Man itoba Water Services Board Other Expenditures 210 6 Mu nicipal Advisory /Financial Services General Support Grants 19 54-5 Throne Speech Debate 11 0-5 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Child care crisis Effects on Manitobans 11 14 -5 LynnGold Resources Inc.

Intervention to prevent closure 2257-9 VIA Rail cutbacks Impact on Manitoba 43 10 -1 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (Bill 46) 2r 15 93-6 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) 2r 5585-7 Charleswood Corridor Environmental impact study Cummings 2080, 3267-7 1; Yeo 2080, 3267-7 1 Charter of Rights and Freedoms Equality Rights Carstairs 4949; Filmon 4949 CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan) Appropriation Act, 19 89 (B ill 99) 2r 5705-9 Budget Debate 515 -9 Constitution Amendment, 19 87 5998- 6000 Documents Tabled Anesthetists Manitoba statistics 3728 Speech pathology Letter from E.Romancik respecting services for preschool children 25 13 Education and Training (Supply) Financial Support - Schools School Grants and Other Assistance 4760-2 Universities Grants Commission Salaries 5044-5 Environment (Supply) Hansard Index 29 CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan)--- Conl.

Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 3370-2 Health (Supply) Opening Remarks (Orchard) 17 91- 3, 18 03-6, 19 33 Response 17 93-7 ' 19 26-8 Administration and Finance Administration and Financial Services Other Expenditures 2347 Salaries 234 7 Communications Salaries 2345-7 Executive Support Salaries 19 26-8, 201 4-6, 2022-3 Health Advisory Network 2023-8, 2082-4, 2091- 2, 210 0- 1, 21 19 -20, 21 22-4, 213 1- 2 Human Resource Ma nagement Salaries 2348, 235 1 Internal Audit Salaries 2352-4 Minister's Salary 3334-5, 3346-7 Research and Planning Other Expenditures 21 60-2, 21 64-9, 21 74-6 Salaries 21 32-4, 232 1- 5 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba 3078-80, 3089-92 Community Health Services (Operations) Regional Services Salaries 2839 Community Health Services (Programs) Communicable Disease Control Other Expenditures 2543-4 Salaries 2357, 2387-9 1, 2399-2405, 2540-2 Continuing Care External Agencies 2754-5 Home Care Assistance 2739-44, 2753-4 Salaries 2738-9 Gerontology External Agencies 2737-8 Salaries 2737 Health Promotion Salaries 2593 Maternal and Child Health Salaries 2544-8, 2586-9 Program and Operation Support Other Expenditures 2357 Salaries 2355-7 Manitoba Health Services Commission Administration 3093-5, 316 9, 31 78-87, 3263-6, 3295 Air Ambulance Program 3303 Ambulance Program 3301- 3 Hospital Program 3303-7 Medical Program 3308- 12 Personal Care Home Program 3308 Pharmacare Program 3295-9 Mental Health

CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan)-C ont.

Brandon Mental Health Centre Salaries 305 1- 3 Chief Provincial Psychiatrist Salaries 2934-4 1, 2993-6 Child and Adolescent Mental Health Salaries 3050- 1 Mental Health Administration Salaries 2840-5, 2928-32 Mental Health Clinical Salaries 3009, 301 1 Mental Health Programs Salaries 2996-8 Mental Health Promotions Salaries 2998-9, 3003-6 Mental Health Rehabilitation Salaries 3007-9 Mental Health Services Other Expenditures 3041- 6 Sala ries 304 1 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 29) 2r 894-6, 944-7 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (2) (Bill 90) 2r 3960-2 Loan Act, 19 89 (Bill 34) 2r 18 57-9 Ma nitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 13 ) 2r 770- 1 Ministerial Statements St.

Boniface General Hospital World Health Organization Collaborating Centre Response 3487 Non-Political Statements Ahluwalia, Karter Run for the Children Marathon 11 27 Festival du Voyageur 516 0 Guru Nanek Celebration of Sikh religion 2735-6 National No n-Smoking Week 45 17 Sakharov, Andrei Death of human rights activist 3858 Oral Questions AID S Confidentiality I 010 Ne edle exchange program 18 40, 2212 Outreach workers 18 40 Treatment Terminal care facilities 2212 Air ambulan ces Transportation costs 515 5 Brandon General Hospital Anesthetist shortage 3 727 Brandon Mental Health Centre Staffing levels 2967 Budget - Federal Impact health care 5445 Carbon monoxide poisoning Out-of-province treatment 4268 Hansard Index 30 CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan)-Cont.

Cardiac care Waiting period !5 2, 602, 4494 Children's Hospital Staff shortages 94, 15 4, 327 Communicable diseases Reporting 2308 Concordia Hospital Extended care beds 3074 Funding, capital 3220 Deer Lodge Hospital Acute care beds I 15 9 Extended care beds 48 15 , 5113 Report 4863 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Health care 565 Goods and services tax Impact health care 3494 Head injuries Community-b ased programs 729, 935 Extended care beds 48 15 Report release 394 7 Services 729, 934, 3947, 4601- 2 Head Injuries Association Report 935 Health Advisory Ne twork Acute care report 4435, 45 16 Health care Acute care beds 2005, 4435, 4601 Anesthetist Recruitment 2613 Shortage 3727 Community-b ased clinics 4494 Education 95 Emergency services 2005, 3493, 5279 Review 3384 Extended care beds Report 48 14 , 4863, 511 4 Funding mismanagement 51 1 4 Municipal Hospitals 48 14 Obstetrical services 4494 Out-patient services 5114 Physician recruitment 327 Policy consultants 47 13 Respiratory technologist shortage 4267 Rheumatologist shortage 887, 4602 Seniors' services 4816 Service duplication 505 1- 2 Surgery delays 328, 2613 U nderspending 12 99 User fees 5445-6 Ventilator shortage 4267 Walk-in clinics 5052 Health care facilities Overcrowding 51 13 Health care profession Laboratory misuse 505 1 Physician shortages Immigrant physician licensing 2281 Health, Minister of Apology requested 602 Health Sciences Centre Funding, capital 316 4

CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan}--- Conl.

Emergency department upgrading 316 4, 3220 Home care program Expansion 3384, 48 16 Klinic Community Health Centre New facilities 13 47 McPhillips Children's Centre (Co-op) Funding 2733 Licensing 2733 Meeting request 2733 Mental health care Forensic assessments 13 84 Mental health care facilities Patient safety 2967 Mental Health Review Board Replacements 13 84-5 Mu nicipal Hospitals New facilities 13 47 Ophthal mology program Implementation 5886-7 Personal care homes Parainfluenza Deaths 419 , 868-9 Reporting 869, 2308 Pharmacard system Implementation 5886 Pharmacare Deductible increase 5886 Pharmaceuticals Experimental drug testing 3876-7 Psychogeriatric care Initiatives 2438 Training programs 2056 Psychogeriatric Planning Committee Report recommendations 2056, 2439 Public health Information release 4I 9-20 Public Health Act Amendments 2308 Rheumatic disease services Rehabilitation 888 Waiting period 887-8 Rivers, Manitoba Extended care beds 4863 St.

Boniface Hospital Ambu latory care 3073 Maternity ward expansion 13 48, 3073 Selkirk Mental Health Centre Staffing levels 2967 Seven Oaks Hospital Emergency services 3384, 3493 Speech therapy Children services 565, 603 Educational incentives 3984 Funding 3984 Preschool services 25 12 Rural services 25 13 Waiting period 565, 3984 Taxicab drivers Protective shields 14 50- 1 Safety and health 14 50 Hansard Index 31 CHEEMA, Guizar (LIB, Kildonan}---Co nl.

Thompson General Hospital Intensive care services 515 5 Thompson, Manitoba Physician shortage 2280- 1 University of Manitoba Faculty of Medicine Accreditation downgrading 5279 Emergency care program 5279 Varta Batteries Closure 5577 Labour adjustment strategy 5577 Point of Order P/0 by Cheema respecting comments by Connery, apology requested 13 85; Ashton 13 85; taken under advisement 13 85; withdrawn (Connery) 14 22 P /0 by Lamoureux respecting words "Sit down, boy" (Orchard) referencing Cheema 896; Doer 896; Orchard 896; Members cautioned (M inenko) 896; apology submitted (Orchard) 901; apology accepted (Cheema) 903 P /0 by McCrae respecting words "children of Manitoba, who have not, particularly, voted at this time, that is why they are not looking after them" (Cheema) referencing Orchard 603; taken under advisement 603; voluntary withdrawal 729 P /0 by Rocan respecting word "misleading" (Cheema) 419 ; withdrawal requested 419 ; withdrawn (Cheema) 419 Private Members' Business Resolutions Breast Cancer Screening 5208-9 Throne Speech Debate 19 2-6 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Budget - Federal Effects on Ma nitoba 5460- 1 Goods and services tax Effects on Ma nitoba 10 67-8 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) 2r 5587-8 Chief Medical Examiner 19 88 Annual Report Edwards 3548; McCrae 3548 Communicable diseases Carstairs 468; Filmon 468 Child abuse treatment Service expansion Gray 597-8; Oleson 597; Wasylycia-Leis 597 Child and Family Services 90th Ann iversary

Child and Family Senices-Con t. L.S.

Evans 2972; Gray 2972; McCrae 2972 Administration Gray 4491; Manness 449 1 Agency deficits Gray 4490; Oleson 4490- 1 Budget Commitment Carstairs 2964-5; Filmon 2964-5 Request Gray 21 55; Oleson 215 5 Counselling services Gray 12 16 ; Oleson 1216 Deficits Filmon 53 61; Gray 536 1 Analysis Carstairs 54 12 ; Gray 215 5; Oleson 215 5, 541 2-3 Reduction Gray 5787; Oleson 5787-8 Responsibility Carstairs 2965; Filmon 2965 Firearms control Edwards 4430; Oleson 4430- 1 Funding Filmon 5363; Gray 5788; Oleson 5788; Wasylycia-Leis 5363 Government communication Carstairs 5413 ; Filmon 5360- 1; Gray 5360; Oleson 54 13 Marriage counselling Gray 1217 , 17 83; Oleson 12 17 , 17 83 Report recommendations Gray 5787; Oleson 5787 Service reduction Carstairs 541 2; L.S.

Evans 215 5; Oleson 215 5, 54 12 Staffing levels Carstairs 54 12 ; Oleson 541 2 Child and Family Senices Amendment Act (Bill 30) Ir Oleson 673; 2r Alcock 882-3, 939-40; Gray 881 -2; Oleson 880-1, 942-3; Wasylycia-Leis 940-2; Cj W 943; 3r 943-4, 1015 ; A.

Driedger 1017 ; Edwards 1016 -7; McCrae 1016 ; Plohman 1017 ; Uruski 1015 ; R/A 1031 Child care Americanization Oleson 2007; Wasylycia-Leis 2006-7 Budget planning Oleson 18 43; Wasylycia-Leis 18 43 Corporate status Edwards 2879; Ole son 2879 Environmental concerns Cummings 11 24; Taylor 11 23 Lead exposure Cummings 10 85; Taylor 10 84-5 Federal strategy Carstairs 11 18 ; Doer 2732; Hansard Index 32 Child care--Cont. Filmon 2732; Oleson 111 8 Fee

schedule Filmon 191 3-4; Wasylycia- Leis 1913 -4 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Cummings 10 82; Gray 10 82 Funding Filmon 4597, 56 12 ; Oleson 2007; Uruski 56 12 ; Wasylycia-Leis 2007, 4597 Parental fee

schedule Oleson 2476; Wasylycia-Leis 2475-6 Premier's statement retraction Filmon 16 62-3; Wasylycia-Leis 16 62-3 Funding, federal Doer 2076; Filmon 2076 Grants Legal opinion request Filmon 5579; Wasylycia-Leis 5579 Humphrey, Mary - Removal Alcock 11 02; Doer 11 22; Gray 1093; Hemphill I I 14 ; Oleson 11 22; Wasylycia-Leis I 09 1 Long-range planning Carstairs 1912 ; Doer 18 40; Filmon 18 40, 18 43, 1912 -3; Gray 18 63; Oleson 18 63, 1912 ; Wasylycia-Leis 18 42-3 Maintenance grants Doer 11 21- 2; Oleson 11 22 Parent co-operative funding Oleson 14 31; Wasylycia-Leis 14 31 Pay equity Hammond 10 84; Wasylycia-Leis 10 84 Policy study Oleson 2006; Wasylycia-Leis 2006 Profit-based centres Hemphill 37; Oleson 37 Revenue decrease Filmon 18 38; Gray 18 38 Rur al Space commitment Filmon 56 12 ; Uruski 56 12 Space commitment Filmon 561 2; Oleson 5786; Uruski 561 1 Standard reduction Carst�irs, 10 33, 11 18 ; Filmon 10 33; Oleson I I 18 -9 Training programs Derkach 277-8, 346-7; Wasylycia-Leis 277-8; Yeo 246 Underspending Filmon 4596-7; Wasylycia-Leis 4596 Workers Budget guarantees Filmon 18 38; Gray 18 38 Funding formula Filmon !8 38; Gray 18 38; Oleson 4435; Wasylycia-Leis 4434-5 Cost of living increase Carstairs 16 58; Filmon 16 58-9; Oleson 16 58

Hansard Index Child care-Con t.

In centives Carstairs 16 58; Oleson 16 58 Legislative requirements Derkach 307; Gray 307; Oleson 347; Yeo 347 Report tabling request Oleson 4435; Wasylycia-Leis 4435 Salaries Carr 10 82; Cummings 10 82-3; Filmon 12 94-5, 5578-9; Gray 10 82; Ha mmond 10 84; Oleson 12 94-5; Wasylycia-Leis 10 84, 12 94-5, 5578-9 Salary enhancement grants Hemphill 37; Oleson 37, 1012 ; Wasylycia-Leis 1012 Salary negotiations Carstairs 191 1; Filmon 10 38, 18 37, 191 1- 2; Gray 18 37; Wasylycia-Leis 10 38 Standards Gray 307; Filmon 316 6; Oleson 307 Wasylycia-Leis 316 6 Walkout Conciliation Doer 18 39-40; Filmon 17 82, 18 39-40; Wasylycia-Leis 17 82 Government initiati ve Doer 18 62; Oleson 18 62-3 Premier's intervention Filmon 18 37; Gray 18 37 Workplace centres Oleson 1012 ; Wasylycia-Leis 1012 See also Petitions; Private Members' Busi ness - Resolutions; Specific child care centres; Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Child Care Task Force Recommendations Carstairs 1912 ; Cummings 18 62; Doer 18 39, 18 62; Filmon 18 39; Gray 18 63; Oleson 18 62-3, 1912 Child Care Working Group Representation Filmon 4597; Wasylycia-Leis 4597 Children's Homes of Winnipeg Support programs Oleson 597 Children's Hospital Staff shortages Cheema 94, 15 4, 327; Orchard 94-5, 15 4, 327 Chilean elections Carstairs 3857; Orchard 3857; Wasylycia-Leis 3857 China - Military violence Carstairs 333; Charles 821; Doer 821 -2; Filmon 332-3; Hemphill 333; Mitchelson 821 Development agreement suspension 33 China - Military violence-Cont.

Filmon 326; Hemphill 326 Manitoba's position Carstairs 325; Cummings 325 Visa extensions - students Filmon 326; Hemphill 326 Chocolate Lake Sludge dumping Cummings 679; Harapiak 678-9 CHORNOPYSKI, William (LIB, Burrows) City of Winnip eg Amendment Act (Bill 32) 2r 2291- 2 Electoral Divisions Amendment Act (Bill II ) 2r 796 In troduction of Guests Garden City Collegiate, Grade 11 (K ildonan) 3239 James Nisbet Community School, Grade 5 (K ildonan) 3327 Mini sterial Statements Remembrance Day Response 2682 Non-Political Statements D-Day Anniversary 350 Festival du Voyageur 5161 Petitions Waverley and Pembina Highway Request for safety measur es 3239; ruled in order 3327 Points of Order P /0 by Angus respecting imputation of motives (Ashton) 3828; taken under advisement (C hornopyski) 3828; ruled out of order 5889 P/0 by Ashton respecting use of points of order 2659; Members cautioned (Chornopyski) 2659 P /0 by Ashton respecting relevancy of debate (Connery) 5264; McCrae 5264; Members cautioned (Chornopyski) 5264 P /0 by Carstairs respecting comments by Connery; apology requested 26; McCrae 26; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 26; ruled out of order (Rocan) 210 P /0 by Chornopyski respecting request for legal opinion 3330; Cowan 3330; taken under advisement 3330; Speaker's ruling 5919 P/0 by Downey respecting comments allegedly reflecting on persons unable to defend themselves in the Chamber (Piohman) 735; taken under advisement ( Chornopyski) 7 3 5; ruled out of order 978 P jO by Manness respecting relevancy of debate (M andrake) 5756;

Hansard Index CHORNOPYSKI, William (LIB, Burrows)-Cont. ruled in order (Chornopyski) 5756; Member cauti oned 5756 P/0 by McCrae respecting relevancy of debate (Cowan) 51 65-6; Ashton 516 6; ruled in order (Chornopyski) 516 6 P/0 by Plohman respecting imputation of motives (Downey) 532; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 532; ruled in order 892; withdrawal requested 892; withdrawn (Downey) 892 P /0 by Plohman respecting reference to absence of Member (Lamoureux) 13 89; ruled in order (Chornopyski) 13 89; withdrawal requested 13 89; withdrawn (Lamoureux) 13 89 P /0 by Plohman respecting reference to inattentiv eness of ND P opposition critic (Connery) 22 15 ; Ashton 221 5; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 221 5; ruled in order 3447; apology offered (Connery) 3447 P/0 by Taylor respecting imputation of motives (Cu mmings) 37 13 ; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 37 13 ; Supplementary Appropriation Act, 19 89 (Bill 100) 2r 5762-4 Churchill, Manitoba Rental units Ducharme 253 1; Lamoureux 253 1 Churchill Place, Leaf Rapids Closure Cowan 3681; Ducharme 368 1 Churchill River Dam Envir onmental impact study Cummin gs 15 23-4, 15 80-1, 4687; H.

Driedger 15 24; Storie 15 23, 15 80-1; Taylor 4687 Legal intervention Cumm ings 15 23-4; Storie 15 23-4 Licensing Cummin gs 15 23-4, 4687; H.

Driedger 15 24; Storie 15 23; Taylor 4687 Meeting cancellation Cumm in gs 4687; Taylor 4687 PCB spill Cummings 15 80; Storie 15 80 Churchill Rocket Range Funding Ernst 2242; Harper 2242 Marketing plans Ernst 2242; Harper 2242 See also Private Members' Busi ness - Address for Papers 34 Citation Award Gray 2246; Harapiak 2245-6; Oleson 2246 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 32) I r Ducharme 812 ; 2r Carr 17 56-9; Chornopyski 2291- 2; Doer 2286-90; Ducharme 11 31- 5; Rose 18 46-50; R/S Ducharme 25 17-9; Plohman 25 18 ; 3r Angus 2521 -2; Carr 25 19 -21; Ducharme 2522-3; Maloway 2521; Rose 252 1; R/A 2524 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 61) I r Ducharme 19 67; 2r Carr 44 12 -5; Ducharme 2443-5; R/S Ducharme 5940; 3r 5944; R/ A 5957 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 62) I r Ducharme 2002; 2r Carr 3438, 3860- 1; Ducharme 2445-6; R/S Ducharme 5940; 3r 5944; R/ A 5957 Civil servants Accountability Carstairs 1447; Filmon 1447 Performance evaluation Carstairs 97 1; Cummings 97 1 Transfer notices Penner 2970; Plohman 2970 Civil Service Act Compliance Carstairs 1445-6, 1447-8; Filmon 1446, 1448; Gray 1449; Hammo nd 14 50 Government policy Carstairs 1447; Filmon 1447 Civil Service Commission Affirmative action Charles 4866; Mitchelson 4866 Hir ing practices Criteria Gray 1450; Hammond 14 50 In vestigation Gray 15 26; Hammond 15 26 Policy grievance Carstairs 1446; Filmon 1446-7 Term positions Carstairs 1446; Filmon 1446 See also Civil Service (Supply) Civil Service (Supply) Opening Remarks Hammond 4603-5 Response Ashton 4605-6 Gray 4605 Civil Service Commission Executive Office Salaries Ashton 4607-1 1; Gray 4606-7,

Civil Service (Supply}-Con t. 46 11 -4; Hamm ond 4606- 14 Human Resource Management Services Salaries Gray 46 14-8; Hammond 46 1 4-8; Wasylycia-Leis 46 !8 Civil Service Superannuation Amendment Act (Bill 80) lr Hamm ond 2299; 2r Ha mmond 266 1- 2; Patterson 3437-8; R/S Ha mmond 5941; 3r 5944; R/ A 5957 Committees, Standing and Special Man itoba Liquor Control Commission Angus 4952; McCrae 4952-3 Scheduling Angus 4953; McCrae 4953 Communicable diseases Reporting Cheema 2308; Orchard 2308 Community Centres Week Wasylycia-Leis 2921 Community Colleges Administrative appointments Derkach 2684; Yeo 2684 Advisory Committee recommendations Derkach 2684; Yeo 2684 See also names of specific colleges Community Investment Fund Funding Charles 16 88; Mitchelson 16 88 Independent board Charles 15 81; Filmon 15 81 Legislation Charles 16 87-8; Mitchelson 16 88 Morris Conservative Association Charles !5 8!; Filmon 15 81 Volunteer board announcement Charles 15 81; Filmon 15 81 See also Lottery revenues - Profit decline Community Places Program Worship centre exclusion Filmon 131- 2; Wasylycia-Leis 131 See also St.

Vladimir Cathedral Community Therapy Program Han dicapped parking decals A. Driedger 15 30; Plohman 15 30 Community Tourism Action Plan Endorsement Ernst 976; Gray 976 Gender-neutral language Ernst 976, 101 1; Gray 976 Conawapa Dam Project Diesel fuel spill Cumm ings 3779; Taylor 3778-79 Employment opportunities Filmon 3491; Neufeld 2649-50; Storie 2649-50, 3491 Hansard Index 35 Conawapa Dam Project-Con t. Employment training program Derkach 2649; H.

Driedger 2649 Environmental hearings Cummin gs 3587; Taylor 3586-7 Environmental impact study Angus 13 45; Carstairs 3544, 3583; Charles 2646-7; Cummin gs 3583, 3877-8; Enns 2646-7, 2686-7; Filmon 3544, 3583- 4; Neufeld 13 45; Taylor 3877 Environmental working group Filmon 3491; Storie 349 1 Fish ladders Charles 2647, 501 8-9; Enns 2647, 5019 Lake Winnip eg levels Charles 2647; Enns 2647 Licensing stages Carstairs 3583; Cummin gs 3583 Native Benefits Filmon 3585-6; Har per 3585 Involvement Filmon 3585; Harper 3585 Training programs Carstairs 3584; Derkach 3585; Filmon 3584; Harper 3585 Ontario Hydro agreement Angus 13 45; Filmon 3490; Neufeld 13 45; Storie 3490 Preferential policy Angus 4433-4; Carstairs 3584; Ernst 4433-4; Filmon 3584; Neufeld 4434 Public Utilities Board study Angus 13 45; Carstairs 2644-5; Neufeld 13 45, 2644-5 River diversions Cummings 3587; Filmon 3587; Taylor 3587 Treaty land claims Filmon 3586; Har per 3586 Wildlife protection Char les 2646; Enns 2646-7 Concordia Hospital Capital funding Cheema 3220; Orchards 3220 Extended care beds Cheema 3074 ; Doer 3072, 48 17 ; Fi1mon 48 17 ; Orchard 3072, 307 4 Laboratory employee safety Carstairs 17 78; Ham mond 17 78 Conference on Urban Safety Man itoba representation Edwards 17 79-80; McCrae 17 79-80 Confidentiality of Personal and Corporate Records Compiled and Stored by Government Departments and Agencies (Bill 45) 1r L.S.

Evans 1445

Conflict of Interest See Announcements CONNERY, Hon.

Edward (PC, Portage Ia Prairie) (Minister of Cooperatite, Consumer and Corporate Affairs) (Minister responsible for The Workers Compensation Act (except as it relates to Worker Adtisers) ) Busi ness Practices Act (Bill 64) Jr 19 67; 2r 31 39-45 Cemeteries Amendment Act (Bill 77) lr 2151; 2r 4399 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (2) (Bill 63) lr 1967; 2r 2654-6; R/S 5847 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs (Supply) Opening Remarks 2846-8, 2849 Response (Patterson) 2848 (Uruski) 2848-9 Administration and Finance Communications Salaries 28 51 Executive Support Salaries 28 51 Mini ster's Salary 30 18 -21, 3026-7 Consu mers Bureau Grants 28 57-6 1 Salaries 285 1- 7 Co-operative/Credit Union Development and Regulation Co-operative/Credit Union Development Salaries 2944-5, 30 11 -5 Corporate Affairs Ins urance Branch Salar ies 2862-6 Public Utilities Board Salaries 294 1- 4 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (2) (Bill 4) 2r 5263-6 In surance Amendment Act (Bill 75) 2r 38 59-60; RjS 59 41; R/ A 5957 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 89 (2) (Bill 90) c;w 4038-9, 4046-55 Non-Political Statements Consumer Week 19 20 Manitoba Developmental Centre Two-year accred itation 5540 Strawberry Festival, Portage Ia Prairie 1014 -5 Uniroyal Goodrich World Junior Curling Championship 582 6-7 Oral Questions Bill C-22 Hansard Index 36 CONN ERY, Hon.

Edward�Cont.

Impact seniors 274 Brick Warehouse Charges 15 26 Consumer bulletin 15 27 Consumer protection legislation Amendments 2284 Cost analysis 31 65-6 Fraudulent car repairs 316 5 Memberships inclusion 2282 Negative option disal lowance 726 Regulations enforcement 316 5 Co-operative development Manitoba statistics 2282 Credit unions Government financial liability 4600 Loan Joss reserves 4600 European Health Spa Closure 228 1- 2 Grant, Nan cy External Affairs intervention 2685 Family Law Branch in tervention 2686 Heaman Family Consumer Minis ter's awareness 4821 JCG Utilities Shut-off regulations 870 LynnGold Resources Inc.

Worker co-operative analysis 2283 Non-custodial parents Legislation 2686 Public Utilities Board Gas rate review 4084-5 Resources 4085 Transportation industry Layoffs 976 Travel In dustry Act Support 15 81 Videon Cable TV Negative option sales 726 Western Sun Vacations Closure 15 81, 16 64 Workers Compensation Board Appeal delays 680, 733, 936 Busi ness plan 782 Claim Analysis 782 Delays 733, 782, 891 In quiries 935 King Task Force recommendations 450- 1' 6 79-80 Medical consultations 935 Pension indexing 679 Ozone Layer Protection Act (Bill 18 ) 2r 2643; 321 J- 3 Points of Order p jO by Ashton respecting reference to absence of Member (Connery) 31 39-40; Cowan 314 0; taken under advisement (K ozak) 314 0; ruled in order 3447; apology offered (Connery) 3447 p jO by Ashton respecting alleged

CONNERY, Hon.

Edward- Cont. reflection upon the Chair (Connery) 314 0; McCrae 314 1 ; previously taken under advisement (K ozak) 3141 P jO by Ashton respecting relevancy of debate (Connery) 5264; McCrae 5264; Members cautioned (Cho rnopyski) 5264 P jO by Carstairs respecting comments by Connery, apology requested 26; McCrae 26; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 26; ruled out of order 21 0 P jO by Cheema respecting comments by Connery, apology requested 13 85; Ashton 13 85; taken under advisement 13 85; withdrawn (Connery) 1422 P /0 by Plohman respecting reference to ina ttentiveness of ND P opposition critic (Connery) 221 5; Ashton 221 5; taken under advisement (Chornopyski) 221 5; ruled in order 3447; apology offered (Connery) 3447 P /0 by Rocan respecting words "H eaven forbid should I take the word of the Member opposite as being the facts (Connery) referencing Charles 733; withdrawal requested 733; withdrawn (Connery) 733 Prearranged Funeral Services Amendment Act (Bill 78) lr 2151; 2r 4399 -4400; R/S 5941; R/A 5957 Private Members' Business Resolutions CF B shutdowns 4778-80 Canadian Wheat Board, Retaining oats under the 13 76-7 Health Ombudsman 410 9-10 Privilege, Matter of Ombudsman, Office of Im partiality questioned Alcock 812 -3; Ashton 813 ; (Connery) 812 ; McCrae 813 ; taken under advisement 81 3; ruled out of order 978-9 Workers Compensation Min ister Apology requested from Alcock respecting comments made 14 22; withdrawn (Connery) 1422 Real Estate Brokers Amendment Act (2) (Bill 76) 2r 2446-7; R/ A 4079 Securities Amendment Act (Bill 72) 2r 3151; RjS 5940; R/A 5957 Sessional Papers Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs Hansard Index 37 CONNERY, Hon.

Edward- Cont.

Annual Report for year ended March 31, 19 89 2238 Co-operative Loans and Loans Guarantee Board Annual Report for year ended March 31, 19 88 2206 Co-operative Promotion Board Annual Report for year ended March 31, 19 88 19 67 Ins urance Act Annual Report for year ended May 31, 19 88 415 Messages - Lieutena nt-Governor Recommending Bill 46 15 21 Recommending Bill 56 18 60 Public Utilities Board Annual Report for year ended December 31, 19 88 24 1 Trade Practices Inquiry Act Annual Report for year ended May 26, 19 88 415 Workers Compensation Board of Man itoba Annual Report for year ended December 31, 19 88 415 Workers Compensation Board of Manitoba Quarterly Report for three month period January to March, 19 89 415 Throne Speech Debate 19 6-202 Unfair Busi ness Practices Act (Bill 21) 2r 1004-5 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Budget - Federal Effects on Manit oba 26-7 Goods and services tax Effects on Man itoba 1066-7 VIA Rail cutbacks Im pact on Manit oba 4333-4 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (Bill 46) lr 1444-5; 2r 15 94; R/A 16 00 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) lr 18 60; 2r 22 14-2 1, 559 1-2; R/S 5940; R/A 5957 Consolidated Professor Mines Ltd.

See Shoal Lake - Gold Mine; Winnipeg Water Protection Group Constitution Amendment, 1987 Resolution

Constitution Amendment, 1987-Cont. Ashton 6054-8; Carr 6058-6 1; Carstairs 5989-94; Cheema 5998-6 000· Cowan 6043-6; Doer 5995-8; ' H. Driedger 6023-6; Edwards 6053-4; L.S. Evans 6000-6; Filmon 598 1-9; Gaudry 6026-9; Gray 603 1- 3; Har per 60 16-9; Hemphill 6038-40; Lamoureux 6040-2; Maloway 6034-6; McCrae 60 19-23; Min enko 6036-8; Plohman 6029-3 1; Taylor 6046-53; Wasylycia-Leis 6006-9 Constitutional Affairs Aboriginal rights Canadian Constitution -

Section 35 Filmon 5978; Harper 5978 Participation Filmon 5977; Harper 5977 Aboriginal participation Filmon 6012 , 60 13 ; Harper 60 12, 60 13 Aboriginal people Distinct society Filmon 60 10-1; Harper 60 10 Retribution, federal Filmon 60 12-3; Harper 60 12 Aboriginal self -government Premier's position Filmon 5977; Harper 5977 Canadian Constitution Notwithstanding clause Carr 15 27; McCrae 15 27 Negotiation process Filmon 60 11- 2; Ha rper 60 11 Man itoba Assembly of Chiefs Personal attacks Filmon 60 10 ; Harper 6010 Negotiation process Filmon 5976-7; Harper 5976 Public hearings Filmon 6013 ; Harper 6013 Territorial governments Provincial status Filmon 5977-8, 60 II ; Harper 5977, 60 11 See also Constitution Amendment, 19 87; Meech Lake Accord Construction industry Decline analysis L.S.

Evans 3222; Manness 3222 Consultants Out-of-province bids Carstairs 933; Ernst 933 Provincial bids Carstairs 933; Ernst 933 Consumer Protection Act Enforcement Maloway 48 19 ; McCrae 48 19-20 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 22) I r Maloway 342; 2r H. Driedger 4642-4; Hansard Index 38 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 22}--Cont.

Kozak 41 85-6, 4386; Maloway 860- 1 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (2) (Bill 23) I r Maloway 342; 2r Maloway 86 1- 2, 16 51- 2 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (3) (Bill 63) I r Connery 19 67; 2r Connery 2654-6; Maloway 2656-6 1; Min enko 3895-8; Patterson 3435-7; Storie 3898-390 1; R/S Connery 5847 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) (Bill 94) I r Maloway 439 1; 2r Maloway 5778 Consumer protection legislation Amendments Connery 2284; Wasylycia-Leis 2284 Cost analy sis Connery 31 65-6; Edwards 316 5 Fraudulent car repairs Connery 316 5; Edwards 316 5 Memberships inclusion Connery 2282; Minenko 2282 Negative option disal lowance Carstairs 726; Connery 726 Regulations enforcement Connery 316 5; Edwards 316 5 Consumer Week Ashton 19 22; Connery 19 20; Maloway 19 21- 2; Patterson 19 22 Contempt, Matter of See Economic Development, Standing Committee on Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs (Supply) Opening Remarks Connery 2846-8, 2849 Response Patterson 2848 Uruski 2848-9 Administration and Finance Communic ations Salaries Connery 285 1; Uruski 285 1 Executive Support Salaries Connery 28 51; Patterson 2850- 1; Uruski 2851 Mi nister's Salary Connery 30 18 -21 , 3026-7; Doer 3024-6; Maloway 301 5-23, 3028-3 1; Mann ess 3023; Patterson 301 5 Consumers Bureau Grants Connery 2857-60; Harapiak 2857- 60; Patterson 2860- 1 Salaries

Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs (Supply)--- Cont.

Connery 28 51 -7; Uruski 28 51-6 Co-operative/Credit Union Development and Regulation Cooperative/Credit Union Development Salaries Connery 2944-55, 301 1- 5; Cowan 2946-56; Maloway 301 4-5; Minenko 301 1- 4; Uruski 2944-6 Corporate Affairs Insu rance Branch Salaries Connery 2862-6; Doer 2862-6 Public Utilities Board Salaries Angus 2942-4; Connery 294 1- 4; Uruski 2941- 2 Co-operative development Manit oba statistics Connery 2282; Cowan 2282 Co-o perative housing Funding Cowan 972; Ducharme 972 Loan approvals Ducharme 5823; Lamoureux 5823 Program cuts Ducharme 18 66-7; Filmon 18 44; Lamoureux 18 44, 18 66-7 Core Area Initiative Corydon Avenue project Doer 5277; Ducharme 5277 Negotiations Ducharme 4730; Wasylycia-Leis 4730 Public hearings Carr 817 ; Ducharme 817 Reallocation Doer 5276-7; Ducharme 5277-8 Renewal Carr 816 -7; Ducharme 817 See also Winnipeg downtown revitalization Corporations Amendment Act (Bill 25) I r Maloway 377 Court of Appeal Amendment Act (Bill 68) lr McCrae 2002; 2r Edwards 4408-9; McCrae 2524-6; R/S McCrae 5789; 3r 5790; R/ A 5836 COWAN, Jay (NDP,

Document details

Collection	Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)
Citation	34th 2nd hansardpdf 34th 2nd index
Type	hansard
Volume / chapter	34th 2nd hansardpdf 34th 2nd index.pdf
Language	en
Format	pdf
Source	PROVINCIAL
Identifier	5d2f1a55fa433cb2419808d93acc94ecf0b1d9d0

Source file is stored in the law ingest library (pdf).