Manitoba Hansard — 36th 2nd committees committee36th 2nd

36th 2nd committees committee36th 2nd

Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)

ISSN 0712-0990AA INDEX of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba STANDING and SPECIAL COMMITTEES 1995-6

INDEX of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba STANDING and SPECIAL COMMITTEES Second Session - Thirty-Sixth Legislature which opened the 5th of December, 1995 and adjourned the 28th of November, 1996

TABLE OF CONTENTS Legislative Assembly of Manitoba Standing and Special Committees Second Session - Thirty Sixth Legislature Table of Contents ................................................................................................................. I Members' List .....................................................................................................................

II Legislative Assembly Staff ................................................................................................III Introduction ...................................................................................................................

IV Subject Index ......................................................................................................................1 Appendices Appendix A: Chairpersons (Election dates) ....................................................................53 Appendix B: Public Presenters/Crown Corporation staff ...............................................54 Appendix C: Committee

Schedule ..................................................................................73 I

Name ASHTON, Steve BARRETT, Becky CERILLI, Marianne CHOMIAK, Dave CUMMINGS, Glen, Hon. DACQUA Y, Louise, Hon. DERKACH, Leonard, Hon. DEWAR, Gregory DOER, Gary DOWNEY, James, Hon. DRIEDGER, Albert, Hon. DYCK, Peter ENNS, Harry, Hon. ERNST, Jim, Hon. EVANS, Clif EVANS, Leonard S. FILMON, Gary, Hon. FINDLAY, Glen, Hon. FRIESEN, Jean GAUDRY, Neil GILLESHAMMER, Harold, Hon. HELWER, Edward HICKES, George JENNISSEN, Gerard KOWALSKI, Gary LAMOUREUX, Kevin LA THLIN, Oscar LAURENDEAU, Marcel MACKINTOSH, Gord MALOWA Y, Jim MARTINDALE, Doug McALPINE, Gerry McCRAE, James, Hon. McGIFFORD, Diane MciNTOSH, Linda, Hon.

MIHYCHUK, MaryAnn MITCHELSON, Bonnie, Hon. NEWMAN, David PALLISTER, Brian, Hon. PENNER, Jack PITURA, Frank PRAZNIK, Darren, Hon. RADCLIFFE, Mike REID, Daryl REIMER, Jack. Hon. RENDER, Shirley ROBINSON, Eric ROCAN, Denis SALE, Tim SANTOS, Conrad STEFANSON, Eric, Hon. STRUTHERS, Stan SVEINSON, Ben TOEWS, Vic, Hon. TWEED, Mervin VODREY, Rosemary, Hon. WOWCHUK, Rosann MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thirty-Sixth Legislature Members, Constituencies and Political Affiliation Constituency Thompson Wellington Radisson Kildonan Ste.

Rose Seine River Rob lin-Russell Selkirk Concordia Arthur-Virden Steinbach Pembina Lakeside Charleswood Interlake Brandon East Tuxedo Springfield Wolseley St. Boniface Minnedosa Gimli Point Douglas Flin Flon The Maples Inkster The Pas St. Norbert St. Johns Elmwood Burrows Sturgeon Creek Brandon West Osborne Assiniboia St. James River East Riel Portage Ia Prairie Emerson Morris Lac du Bonnet River Heights Transcona Niakwa St. Vital Rupertsland Gladstone Crescentwood Broadway Kirkfield Park Dauphin La Verendrye Ross mere Turtle Mountain Fort Garry Swan River II ! Party N.D.P. N.D.P. N.D.P. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. P.C.

N.D.P. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. Lib. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. N.D.P. Lib. Lib. N.D.P. P.C. N.D.P. N.D.P. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. P.C. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. N.D.P. P.C. N.D.P. N.D.P. P.C. N.D.P. P.C. P.C. P.C. P.C. N.D.P.

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Lieutenant-Governor of Manitoba ............................ Hon. Yvon Dumont Speaker of the Legislative Assembly ................ Hon. Louise M. Dacquay, ML A Deputy Speaker and Chairperson of Committees of the Whole House ..................... Mr. Marcel Laurendeau, ML A Deputy Chairperson of Committees of the Whole House ...... Mr. Ben Sveinson, ML A Government House Leader . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hon. Jim Ernst, MLA Opposition House Leader . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mr.

Steve Ashton, ML A Government Whip . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mr. Ed Helwer, ML A Opposition Whip . ... . .. . ... .. .. . .... .. ... . .... . ..... · Mr. George Hickes, ML A Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ............................ Mr. W.H. Remnant Deputy Clerk of the Legislative Assembly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ms. Beverley Bosiak Clerk Assistants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ms. Judy White ......... ..... ............. ............... ... ......... Ms.

Patricia Chaychuk Legislative Counsel ......................................... Ms. Shirley Strutt Sergeant-at-Arms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mr. Dennis Gray Hansard Manager .......................................... Mrs. Edith Mc Lure Hansard Indexer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ms. Brenda Walker III

INTRODUCTION The Index of the Standing and Special Committees is designed to provide easy access to topics discussed in the Legislative Assembly. For this reason it corresponds strictly to the text of the Committee Hansards. FORMAT The index is in two sections:

(1) Subject index, and

(2) Appendices Subject Index: Main entry in this

section is a subject heading which may be subdivided. Following the main entry are secondary headings, "see" and "see also" references, and a listing of individuals who spoke on that subject. Appendices: Included in this

section is a complete list of Chairpersons and dates elected, Public Presenters and Crown Corporation staff and Committee schedules. FILING ARRANGEMENT The basic filing principle is alphabetical, letter by letter. The sequence is as follows:

a) numbers are filed at the beginning of the alphabet, if they are the first character in the filing element;

b) initials separated by punctuation are filed at the beginning of their alphabetic group ABBREVIATIONS AG Agriculture, Standing Committee on ED Economic Development, Standing Committee on IR Industrial Relations, Standing Committee on LA Law Amendments, Standing Committee on MA Municipal Affairs, Standing Committee on PA Public Accounts, Standing Committee on PB Private Bills, Standing Committee on PE Privileges and Elections, Standing Committee on PUNR Public Utilities and Natural Resources, Standing Committee on RH Rules of the House, Standing Committee on SRO Statutory Regulations and Orders, Standing Committee on IV

Index of Standing and Special Committees Agricultural Credit Corporation Amendment Act (Bill 24)

Definitions Enns AG 35 Mortgages, sale of Enns AG 36 Fegol AG 1 Wowchuk AG 36 Ambulance Services Amendment Act (Bill 37) Advanced life support Forsman LA 161 Amendments Clause 2 McCrae LA 273; passed LA 273 Driver training program Forsman LA 161 First aid/CPR training Forsman LA 161 Nonambulance stretcher companies Forsman LA 160 Opening remarks Chomiak LA 271 Regulations Chomiak LA 162, LA 272 Forsman LA 162 McCrae LA 272 Title Forsman LA 160—1 Animal Care Act (Bill 70) Accepted activities Burns AG 54 Nazare AG 56 Pearson AG 58—9 Wall AG 54—5 Wowchuk AG 54, AG 58 Youngdahl AG 57, AG 58 Amendments Wall AG 55 Wowchuk AG 55 Animal care standards Burns AG 51 Enns AG 53 Youngman AG 51—3 Animal Care Act–Cont.

Animal protection officers Pearson AG 59, AG 60 Wowchuk AG 60 Fines Burns AG 51 Youngdahl AG 57 Licensing–kennels/breeders Burns AG 50—1 Langille AG 49 Prosecution Youngdahl AG 57 Barbers Repeal and Hairdressers Repeal Act (Bill 12) Apprenticeship Friesen LA 411, LA 413—4 McIntosh LA 411—2, LA 414 Education requirements Friesen LA 410 McIntosh LA 410—1 Inspections Friesen LA 414 McIntosh LA 414 National standards Friesen LA 412 McIntosh LA 412—3 Opening remarks Friesen LA 410 McIntosh LA 409—10 Professional development Friesen LA 412 McIntosh LA 412 Recertification Friesen LA 412 McIntosh LA 412 Boxing and Wrestling Commission Amendment Act (Bill 66) Amendments Clause 10 Cerilli LA 327; defeated LA 329 Consultations Cerilli LA 325—6 Ernst LA 325 1

Index of Standing and Special Committees Boxing and Wrestling Commission–Cont.

Deregulation Cerilli LA 305—6, LA 322—4 Ernst LA 322—4 Holliday LA 305—6 Enforcement Cerilli LA 326 Ernst LA 326 Health/safety concerns Cerilli LA 305, LA 307—8 Holliday LA 305, LA 307 Revenues Cerilli LA 326 Ernst LA 326 Charleswood Bridge Facilitation Act (Bill 16) Financing Moist PUNR 3—4 Stefanson PUNR 4 Child and Family Services Amendment Act (Bill 35) Amendments Clause 4 Mitchelson LA 7; passed LA 7 Child abuse committees Barrett LA 7 Martindale LA 6—7 Mitchelson LA 6—7 Child Abuse Registry –exclusions Mackintosh LA 5—6 Mitchelson LA 5—6 Child Abuse Registry –reporting Mackintosh LA 2—4, LA 7 Mitchelson LA 2—4, LA 7 Community notification Mackintosh LA 6 Mitchelson LA 6

Definitions –courts Mackintosh LA 1—2 Mitchelson LA 2

Definitions –pedophiles Mackintosh LA 2 Mitchelson LA 2 Opening remarks Martindale LA 1 Child and Family Services–Cont.

Mitchelson LA 1 Public awareness Mackintosh LA 8 Mitchelson LA 8 Children's Advocate, review of Opening remarks Martindale PE 5 Mitchelson PE 4—5 Chiropodists Amendment Act (Bill 8) Local anesthesia Colledge LA 18 City of Winnipeg Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 44) Executive Policy Committee –ad hoc committees Angus PUNR 11—2 Barrett PUNR 12 Reimer PUNR 11—2 Sound attenuation barriers Angus PUNR 11 Civil Service Superannuation Amendment, Public Servants Insurance Amendment and Teachers' Pensions Amendment Act (Bill 51) Amendments Clause 5 Toews AG 69; passed AG 70 Clause 9 Toews AG 70; passed AG 71 Clause 10 Toews AG 71 P AG 71 Clause 38 Toews AG 71; passed AG 72 Clause 42 Toews AG 72; passed AG 72 Teachers' Pension Act Barrett AG 48 Pearce AG 47—8 2

Index of Standing and Special Committees Civil Service Superannuation–Cont.

Toews AG 48 Commodity Futures and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) Amendments Clause 1 Ernst LA 941-2; passed LA 942 Clause 18 Ernst LA 942; passed LA 942 Clause 22 Ernst LA 942; passed LA 942 Clause 41 Ernst LA 942; passed LA 942 Clause 44 Ernst LA 942; passed LA 942 Clause 48 Ernst LA 942-3; passed LA 943 Clause 69 Ernst LA 943; passed LA 943 Clause 79 Ernst LA 943; passed LA 943 Title Ernst LA 943; passed LA 943 Communities Economic Development Fund Annual report –format Praznik ED 23—4 Sale ED 23—4 Wakeling ED 24 Directors' fees Maloway ED 29—30 Wakeling ED 29—30 Doubtful accounts Ashton ED 17 Wakeling ED 17 First Nations Communities Economic Development–Cont.

Ashton ED 19—21 Wakeling ED 19—20 Fisherman's Loan Program Ashton ED 21 Wakeling ED 21 Fishing industry–Lake Winnipegosis Wakeling ED 28 Wowchuk ED 28 Forestry industry Wakeling ED 29 Wowchuk ED 28—9 Gilbert International Praznik ED 23 Sale ED 22—3 Wakeling ED 22—3 Interest rates Sale ED 21—2 Wakeling ED 21—2, ED 27 Wowchuk ED 26 Loans, term of Wakeling ED 27—8 Wowchuk ED 27—8 Opening remarks Ashton ED 16—7 Praznik ED 15—6 Swan River office Praznik ED 29 Wowchuk ED 29 Vehicle leases Maloway ED 30 Wakeling ED 30 Construction Industry Wages Amendment Act (Bill 73) Amendments Clause 2 Reid IR 231; defeated IR 232 IR 232; defeated IR 233 IR 233; defeated IR 234 IR 234; defeated IR 235 Toews IR 229; passed IR 230 IR 230; passed IR 230 IR 231; passed IR 231 3

Index of Standing and Special Committees Construction Industry Wages–Cont. Clause 3 Reid IR 236; defeated IR 236 Clause 8 Reid IR 242; defeated IR 243 IR 243; defeated IR 244 IR 243; defeated IR 243 Clause 11 Reid IR 245; defeated IR 246 Toews IR 245; passed IR 245 Clause 12 Reid IR 246; defeated IR 247 Clause 14 Reid IR 248; defeated IR 249 IR 249; passed IR 250 IR 251; ruled out of order IR 252 Clause 16 Toews IR 251-2; passed IR 254 IR 254; passed IR 254 Consultations Bova IR 218—9 Reid IR 218 Crown corporations Hilliard IR 199—200

Definitions –Greater Winnipeg Bova IR 216 Dauphinais IR 221 Hilliard IR 198, IR 200 Martin, D. IR 195 Martin, P. IR 222 Reid IR 200 Toews IR 221

Definitions –heavy construction Lorenc IR 214—5

Definitions –journeyperson Dauphinais IR 220—1 Reid IR 220 Tesarski IR 190 Deregulation Construction Industry Wages–Cont. Tesarski IR 189 Elimination Evans, M. IR 202—3, IR 205 Norman IR 201 Reid IR 201, IR 204—5 Toews IR 203 Enforcement Dauphinais IR 221 Gallos IR 208 Laurendeau IR 207 Martin, P.

IR 222, IR 224—5 Reid IR 191, IR 207, IR 211—2, IR 221, IR 224 Tesarski IR 190, IR 191 Toews IR 207, IR 211, IR 221 Wightman IR 210—2 Wright IR 206—7 Hours of work Bova IR 216 Wright IR 206 House -building sector Cumming IR 192 Hilliard IR 199 Tesarski IR 188, IR 191 Toews IR 191 Labour Management Review Committee Martin, P. IR 222 Maintenance, repair and redecoration Cook IR 214 Cumming IR 192—3 Dauphinais IR 220 Gallos IR 208 Hilliard IR 199 Martin, D. IR 195—6 Martin, P.

IR 222 Reid IR 192 Tesarski IR 189, IR 192 Wright IR 206 Opening remarks Reid IR 228—9 Skilled versus unskilled ratios Bova IR 216 Snow removal Laurendeau IR 215 Lorenc IR 215—6 Third -party intervention 4

Index of Standing and Special Committees Construction Industry Wages–Cont. Bova IR 216—7 Cook IR 214 Wage advisory boards Cook IR 214 Cumming IR 193, IR 194 Dauphinais IR 220 Gallos IR 209 Reid IR 191, IR 194 Tesarski IR 191 Toews IR 194 Wightman IR 211 Wage levels Martin, D.

IR 196—7 Wage levels –public input Norman IR 202 Toews IR 201 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 45) Amendments Clause 2 Ernst LA 310; passed LA 311 LA 311; passed LA 312 LA 311; passed LA 311 Contaminated Sites Remediation and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 34) Amendments Clause 3 Cummings PUNR 17; passed PUNR 18 Clause 60 Cummings PUNR 18-9; passed PUNR 19 PUNR 19; passed PUNR 19 PUNR 19; passed PUNR 19 Clean Environment Commission Norman PUNR 10 Due diligence Cummings PUNR 18 Kowalski PUNR 18 Due diligence, standard of Stefaniuk PUNR 6 Leniency Norman PUNR 10 Contaminated Sites Remediation–Cont.

Liability Cummings PUNR 10 Norman PUNR 10 Stefaniuk PUNR 5—6 Lien rights Stefaniuk PUNR 7 Opening remarks Cummings PUNR 16—7 Redress, rights of Stefaniuk PUNR 7 Responsibility Ryall PUNR 8 Stefaniuk PUNR 6 Council on Post-Secondary Education Act (Bill 32) Academic freedom Arrell LA 469 Cerilli LA 487—8 Friesen LA 455, LA 469, LA 484, LA 487 Levine LA 451—3, LA 454—6 Sale LA 454 Silver LA 486—8 Stearns LA 484 Accountability Bruneau LA 336—7 Carlyle LA 502 Daniels LA 869—70 Donatelli LA 899—900 Friesen LA 379, LA 900 Giles LA 341 Koolage LA 890 Lines LA 377, LA 379 Markham LA 873 McIntosh LA 379, LA 502—3, LA 869—70 Pruitt LA 899—900 Struthers LA 889—90 Administration duties –consultations Kushneryk LA 397 Administrative duties Nembhard, J.

LA 543 Amendments Clause 11 Friesen LA 965; defeated LA 966 McIntosh 5

Index of Standing and Special Committees Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont. LA 964; passed LA 964 Clause 12 Friesen LA 966; defeated LA 967 LA 967; defeated LA 969 McIntosh LA 964-5; passed LA 965 Clause 13 Friesen LA 969; defeated LA 970 Clause 14 McIntosh LA 970; passed LA 972 Clause 21 McIntosh LA 973; passed LA 974 Clause 24 McIntosh LA 974; passed LA 974 Clause 27 McIntosh LA 974; ruled out of order LA 978

Preamble Friesen LA 980; defeated LA 981, passed LA 981 McIntosh LA 979; passed LA 980 Autonomy Arrell LA 466—9 Bailey LA 488—9 Blaikie LA 345, LA 346 Byard LA 470 Donatelli LA 905 Dooley LA 441 Enns LA 889 Ferguson LA 391—2 Friesen LA 468—9, LA 888, LA 892 Giles LA 341 Glendinning LA 892 Golden LA 443 Kelcey LA 538—40 McIntosh LA 346, LA 391, LA 479, LA 887 Murray LA 446 Noble LA 477—8 Pallister LA 540 Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont.

Phillips LA 505 Sale LA 478 Tudiver LA 851—2 Whiteley LA 886—8, LA 889 Brandon University, impact on Barlow LA 346 Blaikie LA 346 Cerilli LA 346 Budgetary operations Malabar LA 525 Cabinet committee Hanen LA 395 Centres of excellence Booth LA 877 McIntosh LA 877 Chairperson/vice -chairperson Amirault LA 531 Dooley LA 442 Colleges Act Bashforth LA 361 Friesen LA 361 Collegiate programs Bashforth LA 361 Consultations Amirault LA 532 Carlyle LA 501—2 Cerilli LA 509 Friesen LA 532 Giles LA 342 Heller LA 535 McIntosh LA 341—2, LA 408, LA 435, LA 535 Pallister LA 535 Slater LA 433, LA 435, LA 508—9 Sullivan LA 504 Tudiver LA 852 Wright LA 408 Credit transfers Herda LA 397

Definitions Hanen LA 395

Definitions –academic freedom Friesen LA 541 Kelcey LA 541—2

Definitions –student Kushneryk LA 397 6

Index of Standing and Special Committees Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont. Direction from minister Byard LA 470 Chernomas LA 521, LA 523 Clark LA 405—6 DeLong LA 462 Dooley LA 441 Ferguson LA 391 Gabbert LA 549 Glendinning LA 890 Hanen LA 394, LA 396 Markham LA 872—3 McIntosh LA 396, LA 404—6, LA 408—9, LA 458, LA 482, LA 522—4 Mills LA 430 Murray LA 446 Nembhard, K.

LA 459 Noble LA 477 Reitano LA 854 Seymour LA 491—2 Taylor LA 481, LA 482 Turner LA 427 Wright LA 407—9 Duties and powers Amirault LA 531 Byard LA 471 Clark LA 403 Dooley LA 442 Ferguson LA 391 Friesen LA 409, LA 428, LA 855 Herda LA 397 Janzen LA 528 Lipsett LA 383—4, LA 384 Malabar LA 524—5 Nembhard, J. LA 543 Noble LA 477 Reitano LA 854—5 Seymour LA 492—3 Shaw LA 882 Taylor LA 481 Turner LA 428 Wright LA 409 Education accessibility Cerilli LA 476, LA 544 Dooley LA 442 Friesen LA 442, LA 459—60, LA 502, LA 880 Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont.

Fulton LA 476 Giles LA 342 Holborn LA 880 Markham LA 874—5 McGifford LA 342, LA 874 McIntosh LA 544 Mihychuk LA 845 Nembhard, J. LA 544—5 Nembhard, K.

LA 460 Phillips LA 506 Shaw LA 881 Sullivan LA 501, LA 502 Szathmary LA 845—6 Education system –funding Forest LA 886 Struthers LA 886 Faith-based institutions Daniels LA 871 Eichhorst LA 349—52 Friesen LA 349—51, LA 871 McIntosh LA 350—1 Fiscal year-end Bashforth LA 361 Funding Bailey LA 490 Byard LA 471, LA 473 Friesen LA 473, LA 479—80 Leo LA 832—3 Lines LA 378 McGifford LA 832—3 McIntosh LA 490 Noble LA 480 Intent Daniels LA 866—8 Fulton LA 475 Golden LA 444 McIntosh LA 444 Interim transition committee Bashforth LA 362 Friesen LA 361—2, LA 395 Hanen LA 395 Turner LA 427 Legislative process Carlyle LA 500—1 Friesen LA 457 7

Index of Standing and Special Committees Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont. McIntosh LA 458 Nembhard, K.

LA 457—8 Newman LA 457—8 Sullivan LA 503 Liability, protection from Lipsett LA 384 Limitations Amirault LA 531 Ferguson LA 391 Glendinning LA 890 Kushneryk LA 398 Laznicka LA 536 Lipsett LA 383 McIntosh LA 845 Reitano LA 854 Seymour LA 491 Stearns LA 483 Szathmary LA 844—5 Limitations–institutional priorities Anderson LA 356 Mandate Anderson LA 356, LA 359 Arrell LA 467 Byard LA 470 Cerilli LA 358—9 Clark LA 404 DeLong LA 462—3 Dooley LA 441 Hanen LA 394 Lines LA 376—7 Lipsett LA 383 McIntosh LA 462—3 Reitano LA 854 Shaw LA 881 Stearns LA 483 Tudiver LA 850—1 Market -driven programs Bashforth LA 360, LA 363 Cerilli LA 362—3 Nembhard, K.

LA 457 Membership Amirault LA 531 Babcock LA 510, LA 511—2 Blaikie LA 345, LA 347 Byard LA 470—1 Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont. Cerilli LA 347 Chernomas LA 521 Dooley LA 441—2 Ferguson LA 391 Friesen LA 963 Giles LA 341 Golden LA 444 Johannson LA 815—6 Kowalski LA 902 Kushneryk LA 397—8, LA 400 Laurendeau LA 400 Layman LA 352, LA 353 Lines LA 377 Malabar LA 524, LA 526 Markham LA 873 Martin LA 545—6 McIntosh LA 353, LA 378, LA 511, LA 852—3, LA 963—4 McIntosh LA 511 Nembhard, K.

LA 456 Pallister LA 526 Ross LA 901, LA 902 Seymour LA 492 Struthers LA 816 Taylor LA 481 Tudiver LA 852 Ministerial authority Anderson LA 356 Blair LA 438—40 Daniels LA 871 Ferguson (for Gaudet) LA 864 Forest LA 885 Friesen LA 870—1 Glendinning LA 890—1 Holborn LA 878—9 Laurendeau LA 453 Levine LA 453—4 McIntosh LA 438—9, LA 879 Sale LA 439 Shaw LA 881—2 S truthers LA 885 National standards Bruneau LA 338 Friesen LA 338, LA 342 Giles LA 342 8

Index of Standing and Special Committees Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont. Performance indicators Giles LA 341 Personnel records –privacy Friesen LA 909 Orlandini LA 909 Power to regulate programs Byard LA 471 Chernomas LA 520—1, LA 522 Gabbert LA 549—51 Hanen LA 394 McIntosh LA 521—2, LA 550—1, LA 883 Noble LA 477 Reitano LA 854 Ross LA 901 Shaw LA 882—3 Struthers LA 845 Szathmary LA 845 Taylor LA 481—2

Preamble Amirault LA 531 Anderson LA 355—6 Chernomas LA 521 Ferguson (for Gaudet) LA 863—4 Halborn LA 878 Hanen LA 394 Janzen LA 528 Lipsett LA 383 Nembhard, J. LA 543 Shaw LA 881 Taylor LA 480—1 Privacy issues Friesen LA 888 Whiteley LA 888—9 Program accessibility Friesen LA 529 Janzen LA 530 Malabar LA 527 McGifford LA 527, LA 530 Program approval Anderson LA 356—7 Bashforth LA 360 Program development Leo LA 831—2 Program duplication Bashforth LA 360—1 Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont.

Cerilli LA 498 Ferguson (for Gaudet) LA 864 Friesen LA 541, LA 833, LA 846 Golden LA 444 Johannson LA 815 Kushneryk LA 398 Leo LA 833 Lines LA 378 McIntosh LA 398 Pallister LA 540, LA 541 Render LA 361 Stearns LA 483—4 Suss LA 498 Szathmary LA 846—7 Program funding Anderson LA 357 Relationship to government Friesen LA 962—3 McIntosh LA 962—3 Research Friesen LA 507 Phillips LA 507 Senates/boards of governors Bruneau LA 337—8 Forest LA 885—6 Render LA 337 Struthers LA 885 Standards Forest LA 884—5 Students, impact on Amirault LA 531 Teaching evaluations Clark LA 404, LA 406 Friesen LA 399, LA 406 Herda LA 399 Kushneryk LA 399 Terms of office McIntosh LA 497 Suss LA 497 Tuition fees Amirault LA 533 Cerilli LA 401 Friesen LA 379, LA 399, LA 816, LA 843 Herda LA 397, LA 399 Johannson LA 816—7 9

Index of Standing and Special Committees Council on Post-Secondary Education–Cont.

Kushneryk LA 401 Lines LA 379 McIntosh LA 379, LA 401, LA 842—3 Pallister LA 533 Stevens LA 840—1, LA 842—3 Universities Grants Commission Donatelli LA 906 Ferguson LA 393 Giles LA 341 Jansen LA 392—3 Janzen LA 530 McIntosh LA 341, LA 392—3, LA 530 Render LA 906 University funding DeLong LA 463 Sale LA 463 University Review Commission Bashforth LA 360 Court of Queen's Bench Amendment Act (Bill 74) Opening remarks Ernst LA 15—6 Court of Queen's Bench Surrogate Practice Amendment Act (Bill 43) Opening remarks Vodrey MA 59 Credit Unions and Caisses Populaires Amendment Act (Bill 22) Amendments Clause 9 Ernst LA 308; passed LA 308 Dairy Act (Bill 30) Opening remarks Enns 36 —7 Wowchuk 37 Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Amendment Act (Bill 19) Amendments Clause 2 Dewar Dangerous Goods Handling–Cont.

PUNR 15; withdrawn PUNR 16 Education Administration Amendment Act (Bill 33) Advisory committees Beresford LA 578 McIntosh LA 578 Alternative programs Cerilli LA 592 Friesen LA 590—1 Kowalski LA 592 McIntosh LA 590 Mihychuk LA 591 Stearns LA 590—2 Amendments Clause 3 Friesen LA 597; defeated LA 598 Annual school plans Beresford LA 573 Friesen LA 598—9 McIntosh LA 598—9 Assessment methods Beresford LA 572, LA 577 Cerilli LA 577 Auditor's supplementary report Beresford LA 573 Education programs, approval of Beresford LA 571 Information release–school boards Beresford LA 572—3 Instructional materials, approval of Beresford LA 571 Instructional time Beresford LA 571 Ministerial authority Beresford LA 571, LA 576—7 Friesen LA 576 Green LA 369—70 Hanuschak LA 579—80 Mihychuk LA 579 Opening remarks Friesen LA 597 Parent committees Hanuschak LA 580 Kowalski LA 580 10

Index of Standing and Special Committees Education Administration Amendment–Cont.

Privacy, guarantee of Friesen LA 595—6 McIntosh LA 595—6 Pupil achievement Mihychuk LA 558 Wiens LA 558—9 Pupil achievement –information release Beresford LA 571 Stearns LA 589 Schools, choice of Friesen LA 582—3 Gillies LA 582—3 Schools, independent Friesen LA 580 Hanuschak LA 580 Standards testing Cerilli LA 583 Friesen LA 584 Gillies LA 580—1, LA 583, LA 584 Hammond LA 560 McIntosh LA 590 Stearns LA 589, LA 590 Elk ranching See Livestock Industry Diversification and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 31) Farm Lands Ownership Amendment, Real Property Amendment and Registry Amendment Act (Bill 68) Amendments Clause 3 Enns AG 67; P AG 67 Clause 6 Enns AG 67; P AG 67 Clause 7 Enns AG 67; P AG 68 Clause 24 Enns AG 68; P AG 68 Clause 32 Farm Lands Ownership Amendment–Cont.

Enns AG 68; P AG 68 Clause 34 Enns AG 68; P AG 68 Clause 35 Enns AG 69; P AG 69 Clause 39 Enns AG 69; P AG 69 Opening remarks Enns AG 66—7 Wowchuk AG 66—7 Financial Administration and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 55) Amendments Clause 6 Stefanson LA 933; passed LA 932—3 Clause 44 Stefanson LA 933; passed LA 932—3 Clause 82 Stefanson LA 934; passed LA 934 Clause 93 Stefanson LA 934; passed LA 935 Clause 99 Stefanson LA 935; passed LA 935 Clause 108 Stefanson LA 935; passed LA 935 Clause 113 Stefanson LA 935; passed LA 936 Opening remarks Stefanson LA 932—3 Fisheries Amendment Act (Bill 41) Opening remarks Driedger IR 227—8 11

Index of Standing and Special Committees Fisheries Amendment Act–Cont.

Struthers IR 228 Gaming Control and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 76) Aboriginal gaming issues Brant LA 928 Amendments Clause 1 Stefanson LA 944; passed LA 944 Clause 6 Stefanson LA 944; passed LA 944 Clause 9 Stefanson LA 944; passed LA 944 Clause 10 Stefanson LA 944; passed LA 945 Clause 11 Stefanson LA 945; passed LA 945 Clause 14 Stefanson LA 945-6; passed LA 946 Clause 42 Stefanson LA 946; passed LA 946 Clause 45 Stefanson LA 946; passed LA 946 Clause 52 Stefanson LA 946; passed LA 948 LA 948; passed LA 948 Clause 53 Stefanson LA 948; passed LA 949 Clause 60 Stefanson LA 949; passed LA 949 Clause 66 Stefanson LA 949; passed LA 949 Clause 75 Gaming Control and Consequential–Cont.

Stefanson LA 949; passed LA 949 Appeal process Chernichan LA 926 Stefanson LA 926 Bingo operations –nonprofit Turbovsky LA 927—8 Commission, duties of Desjardins LA 931 Fines Chernichan LA 926 Inspections Chernichan LA 925—6 Licence suspension Chernichan LA 925 Opening remarks Stefanson LA 943 Plebiscite –VLTs Desjardins LA 930 Public inquiries Desjardins LA 931 Reporting process Desjardins LA 930—1 Government Essential Services Act (Bill 17) Amendments Clause 2 Reid IR 286; defeated IR 287 Clause 5 Reid IR 286; defeated IR 287 Clause 6 Reid IR 287; defeated IR 287 Clause 7 Reid IR 288; defeated IR 288 Clause 8 Reid IR 289; defeated IR 290 IR 290; defeated IR 290 IR 290; defeated IR 290 Clause 9 Reid IR 291; defeated IR 291 12

Index of Standing and Special Committees Government Essential Services–Cont.

Clause 12 Reid IR 291; defeated IR 292 Clause 16 Toews IR 292; passed IR 293 Clause 17 Reid IR 293; defeated IR 293 Toews IR 293; passed IR 293 Clause 20 Toews IR 294; passed IR 294 Appeal process Olfert IR 276—7 Binding arbitration Holmes IR 280 Jennissen IR 280 Conflict of interest Hilliard IR 272—3 Santos IR 272—3 Employee classifications Olfert IR 276, IR 278 Santos IR 278 Health care facilities Holmes IR 279 Health care sector Sinclair IR 274—5 Necessity Jennissen IR 269 Santos IR 275 Sinclair IR 275 Tesarski IR 269 Negotiated agreements Holmes IR 279 Olfert IR 277—8 Reid IR 281—2 Santos IR 277 Toews IR 277—8, IR 279, IR 281—2 Opening remarks Reid IR 281 Personal care homes Olfert IR 278 Toews IR 278 Government Essential Services–Cont.

Terms and conditions, temporary Olfert IR 276 Voluntary agreements Hilliard IR 271—2 Olfert IR 276 Reid IR 272 Santos IR 269 Sinclair IR 274 Tesarski IR 268—9 Toews IR 269 Grand Lodge of Manitoba of the Independent Order of Oddfellows Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 302) Opening remarks Martindale IR 295 Strutt IR 295 GRIP and Related Programs Termination and Crop Insurance Amendments Act (Bill 23) Enns AG 34 Wowchuk AG 34—5 Amendments Title Enns AG 35; P AG 35 Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (2) (Bill 38)

Definitions –resident Chomiak LA 25—7 McCrae LA 25—7 Ministerial responsibility Chomiak LA 27—8 McCrae LA 28 Opening remarks Chomiak LA 23 Personal care homes –per diems Chomiak LA 23—4 McCrae LA 23—4 Highway Traffic Amendment (Lighting on Agricultural Equipment) Act (Bill 13) Opening remarks Findlay LA 29 Jennissen LA 29 13

Index of Standing and Special Committees Highway Traffic Amendment (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act (Bill 20) Amendments Clause 18 Findlay LA 30; passed LA 30 Clause 19 Findlay LA 30; passed LA 30 LA 30; passed LA 31 Opening remarks Findlay LA 29 Jennissen LA 29 Stretcher bearer services Chomiak LA 29 Findlay LA 29 Jobs Fund Repeal Act (Bill 62) Opening remarks Sale LA 315 Judicial Compensation Committee report Ability to pay Kopstein PE 18—9 Kowalski PE 20 Sinclair PE 19, PE 20 Stefanson PE 18—9 Legal challenges Kopstein PE 15 Kowalski PE 14—5 Sinclair PE 14 —5 Legislative process Kopstein PE 15—6 Sinclair PE 15 —6 Toews PE 15—6 Morale Mackintosh PE 16—7 Sinclair PE 17 Opening remarks Kowalski PE 26—8 Mackintosh PE 25—6 Stefanson PE 11, PE 24, PE 28—9 Toews PE 2 Pension plan Kopstein PE 20 Stefanson PE 20 Judicial Compensation Committee report–Cont.

Public perception Kowalski PE 21 Sinclair PE 21 Jury Amendment Act (Bill 25) Amendments Clause 3 Mackintosh LA 318; defeated LA 320 LA 320; defeated LA 321 Opening remarks Mackintosh LA 318 Vodrey LA 316—8 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 26) Accountability Reid IR 28 Tesarski IR 28 Amendments Clause 3 Reid IR 296; defeated IR 296 IR 297; defeated IR 298 Clause 5 Reid IR 298; defeated IR 299 Clause 6 Reid IR 299; defeated IR 299 Clause 7 Reid IR 300; defeated IR 300 Clause 8 Reid IR 300; defeated IR 301 IR 301; defeated IR 301 Clause 9 Reid IR 301; defeated IR 302 IR 302; defeated IR 303 IR 303; defeated IR 304 Clause 10 Reid IR 304; defeated IR 305 14

Index of Standing and Special Committees Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont.

Clause 14 Reid IR 306; defeated IR 307 IR 307; defeated IR 308 IR 308; defeated IR 308 Toews IR 305; passed IR 305 IR 305; passed IR 306 IR 306; passed IR 306 IR 306; passed IR 306 Clause 15 Reid IR 309; defeated IR 309 IR 310; defeated IR 310 IR 310; defeated IR 311 Toews IR 309; passed IR 309 Clause 17 Reid IR 311; defeated IR 312 Clause 18 Reid IR 313; defeated IR 314 IR 314; defeated IR 315 Toews IR 312; passed IR 313 IR 315; passed IR 316 Clause 19 Reid IR 316; defeated IR 317 IR 317; defeated IR 318—9 IR 319; defeated IR 320 IR 321; defeated IR 325 Toews IR 319; passed IR 319 IR 320; passed IR 320 IR 321; passed IR 321 IR 321; passed IR 321 IR 325; passed IR 326 IR 326; passed IR 326 Clause 21 Toews IR 327; passed IR 327 Arbitration, expedited Barrett IR 58 Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont.

Burrell IR 151, IR 153—4 Christophe IR 32 Gardner IR 60, IR 61 Hancharyk IR 50 Hilliard IR 54 Hunt IR 104 Martin, R. IR 23 Olfert IR 110 Patterson IR 57, IR 58 Reid IR 153 Tesarski IR 27 Toews IR 61 Walton IR 89—90 Ziegler IR 130—1 Arbitration/mediation costs Bjornson IR 21 Henderson IR 101 Reid IR 21 Walton IR 89 Certification Borger IR 74, IR 75 Burrell IR 151 Christophe IR 30 Desjarlais IR 170 Gardner IR 59—60 Gonick IR 114—5 Hancharyk IR 50 Henderson IR 100 Hilliard IR 53 Huber IR 123—4 Hunt IR 103—4 Kelly IR 62 Martin, D. IR 33, IR 35 Martin, P.

IR 97 Norman IR 66 Olfert IR 109 Patterson IR 57 Reid IR 35 Ryan IR 134 Stevens IR 46 Tesarski IR 27 Toews IR 75 Vrsnik IR 139 Ziegler IR 131—2 Consultations 15

Index of Standing and Special Committees Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont. Chudy IR 142 Cumming IR 123 Desjarlais IR 171, IR 172 Gonick IR 116—7 Hancharyk IR 52 Henderson IR 102 Hilliard IR 55 Hunt IR 106 Javier IR 113 Martin, P. IR 99 Moist IR 41 Olfert IR 111 Reid IR 41, IR 52, IR 55, IR 99, IR 102, IR 111, IR 113, IR 116, IR 122, IR 129, IR 142, IR 172 Taylor IR 129 Toews IR 106 Employees –personal information Christophe IR 31 Employer's last offer Christophe IR 31 Gagne IR 167 Gonick IR 115 Hancharyk IR 50 Henderson IR 100 Hilliard IR 54 Hunt IR 104 Kelly IR 63 Nickel, K.

IR 142—3 Olfert IR 109, IR 111 Reid IR 110—1 Stevens IR 47 Tesarski IR 27 Timlick IR 36 Toews IR 143 Walton IR 89 Final offer selection Ashton IR 15 Christophe IR 30 Mackling IR 14, IR 15—6 Financial statements Ashton IR 19, IR 25—6 Bjornson IR 20—1 Borger IR 74—5, IR 76 Burrell IR 151 Christophe IR 32 Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont. Gagne IR 167 Garofalo IR 144—6 Grant IR 159 Hancharyk IR 51 Henderson IR 101 Hicks IR 17, IR 19—20 Hilliard IR 53 Hillis IR 25—6 Joyce IR 77—8 Kelly IR 62 Maldonado IR 163 Martin, D. IR 34—5, IR 36 Martin, P. IR 97 Martin, R. IR 23 Nickel, K.

IR 144 Olfert IR 110 Patterson IR 57 Penner IR 149—50 Reid IR 19, IR 26, IR 28—9, IR 35—6, IR 48, IR 76, IR 129, IR 132, IR 144, IR 146, IR 163 Sahan IR 136 Samyn IR 148, IR 150 Stevens IR 48 Taylor IR 129 Tesarski IR 27, IR 28—9 Thomas IR 36 Timlick IR 36 Trottier IR 157 Ziegler IR 131, IR 132 Health and welfare plans Martin, D. IR 35 Thomas IR 35 Toews IR 35 Impact Emberley IR 119 Maldonado IR 164 Reid IR 119, IR 164 Stecher IR 126 Struthers IR 126 Information release Gagne IR 169 Grant IR 161 Reid IR 160—1, IR 169 Labour Management Review Committee Anderson IR 156 16

Index of Standing and Special Committees Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont.

Gardner IR 61 Henderson IR 99 Hunt IR 106 Mackling IR 15 Reid IR 15, IR 61, IR 105—6, IR 156, IR 158 Trottier IR 158 Legal challenges Gonick IR 116 Reid IR 116 Manitoba Labour Board Hunt IR 105 Reid IR 105, IR 132 Ziegler IR 132 Minimum wage Jennissen IR 120 Rankin IR 120 Misconduct Barrett IR 58 Borger IR 74 Christophe IR 30 Chudy IR 142 Desjarlais IR 171 Gardner IR 61 Henderson IR 100, IR 103 Hilliard IR 54—5 Olfert IR 109 Patterson IR 56—7, IR 58 Reid IR 90—1, IR 103, IR 137—8, IR 142 Sahan IR 136—8 Tesarski IR 27 Toews IR 61, IR 91 Walton IR 89, IR 90—1 Opening remarks Reid IR 296 Rand Formula Anderson IR 155 Cumming IR 122 Garofalo IR 145, IR 147 Green IR 45—6 Hilliard IR 54 Joyce IR 79 Kelly IR 64 Martin, P.

IR 98—9 Reid IR 45, IR 78—9, IR 98, IR 122, IR 147 Toews IR 44—5, IR 64 Labour Relations Amendment Act–Cont. Vrsnik IR 139, IR 140 UN International Labour Organization Hicks IR 19 Hiebert IR 94 Reid IR 19, IR 94 Union dues –political purposes Ashton IR 24 Christophe IR 31—2 Desjarlais IR 170—1, IR 172, IR 175 Downey IR 126 Gagne IR 167 Gonick IR 115 Grant IR 159 Hancharyk IR 50—1 Henderson IR 102—3 Hicks IR 17 Hilliard IR 52—3 Huber IR 124 Jennissen IR 126—7 Joyce IR 78 Kelly IR 63 Martin, P.

IR 98 Martin, R IR 23, IR 24 Olfert IR 109—10 Patterson IR 57 Penner IR 172 Reid IR 91, IR 102 Samyn IR 149 Stecher IR 126—7 Stevens IR 46—7 Sveinson IR 78 Tesarski IR 27 Vrsnik IR 139 Walton IR 90, IR 91 Voting constituency Christophe IR 31 Walton IR 89 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 60) Amendments Clause 9 Vodrey LA 314; passed LA 314 Benchers, reduction of Mackintosh LA 304, LA 313—4 17

Index of Standing and Special Committees Law Society Amendment Act–Cont.

Neufeld LA 301—2, LA 304—5 Vodrey LA 313—4 Contingency fee contracts Mackintosh LA 304 Neufeld LA 302—3, LA 304 Oath of allegiance Mackintosh LA 303, LA 313 Neufeld LA 302, LA 303 Vodrey LA 313 Opening remarks Vodrey LA 312 Livestock Industry Diversification and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 31) Aboriginal involvement Enns AG 38—9 Wowchuk AG 38 Amendments Clause 37 Enns AG 42; P AG 43 Bear ranching Stott AG 8 Struthers AG 8 Elk ranching Alternatives Hughes AG 23 Struthers AG 23 Animal welfare Abra AG 15 Enns AG 14, AG 17 Mentz AG 13, AG 14, AG 16—7 Pearson AG 27 Santos AG 16—7 Antlers, harvesting of Burns AG 18, AG 21 Enns AG 41—2 Mentz AG 13—4, AG 15 Pearson AG 25 Struthers AG 15, AG 21 Wowchuk AG 41 Breeding Stott AG 8 Wowchuk AG 8 Capture contracts Livestock Industry Diversification–Cont.

Mentz AG 16 Struthers AG 16 Whitford AG 11 Wowchuk AG 11 Capture/transportation Pearson AG 25 Consultations Pearson AG 28 Wowchuk AG 27 Disease control Burns AG 19—20, AG 21—2 Enns AG 21 Mentz AG 16 Pearson AG 25—6, AG 28 Rutley AG 32—3 Stott AG 8—9 Struthers AG 8—9, AG 16, AG 28, AG 32 Economic benefits Pearson AG 26 Ruthley AG 29, AG 31—2 Wowchuk AG 31—2 Elk, distribution of Enns AG 39—40 Wowchuk AG 39 Insurance Burns AG 20 Enns AG 20—1 Santos AG 20—1 Licensing Mentz AG 14 On -farm hunts Enns AG 40 Stott AG 9 Struthers AG 9 Wowchuk AG 40 Overpopulation Pearson AG 24 Poaching Burns AG 20 Hughes AG 22 Pearson AG 26—7 Species, protection of Pearson AG 24—5 Trade barriers Stott AG 7—8 18

Index of Standing and Special Committees Livestock Industry Diversification–Cont.

Wowchuk AG 7 Opening remarks Enns AG 37—8 Wowchuk AG 38 Manitoba Film and Sound Recording Development Corporation Act (Bill 71) Opening remarks Gilleshammer ED 38 Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board Affirmative action Brennan PUNR 91 Kowalski PUNR 91 Board members Mihychuk PUNR 96 Praznik PUNR 96—7 Divisional managers Brennan PUNR 91 Kowalski PUNR 91 Hiring policy Brennan PUNR 97—9 Mihychuk PUNR 97—9 Praznik PUNR 97—8 Mandate Brennan PUNR 95—6 Mihychuk PUNR 93—4 Praznik PUNR 93—5 Opening remarks Brennan PUNR 84—90 McCallum PUNR 83—4 Mihychuk PUNR 91—3 Praznik PUNR 81—3 Manitoba Investment Pool Authority Act (Bill 56) Mauws PUNR 13—4 Zimberg PUNR 12—3 Amendments Clause 22 Stefanson PUNR 21; passed PUNR 21 Opening remarks Stefanson PUNR 20 Manitoba Mineral Resources Ltd.

Motion Mihychuk ED 12—3 Opening remarks Mihychuk ED 2—6 Praznik ED 1—2 Privatization Clarke ED 8—9 Mihychuk ED 8—12 Praznik ED 8—12 Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Appeal Commission Cummings PUNR 31 Evans, L. PUNR 31—2 Zacharias PUNR 31—2 Auto theft Cummints PUNR 42 Kowalski PUNR 41—2 Laurendeau PUNR 30 Zacharias PUNR 30—1, PUNR 41 Commissions –brokers Toews PUNR 39—40 Zacharias PUNR 40 Hailstorm, cost of Evans, L. PUNR 39 Zacharias PUNR 39 No -fault insurance Cummings PUNR 29, PUNR 31 Evans, L. PUNR 28—9, PUNR 31 Opening remarks Cummings PUNR 23—5 Evans, L.

PUNR 25 Privatization Cummings PUNR 26—8, PUNR 29—30 Evans, L. PUNR 26—8 Maloway PUNR 29—30 Rate reduction Cummings PUNR 34—9, PUNR 40—1 Evans, L. PUNR 37—9 Maloway PUNR 34—7, PUNR 40—1 Zacharias PUNR 34—5, PUNR 41 Tort claims Evans, L. PUNR 32—3 Maloway PUNR 33—4 Zacharias PUNR 33—4 19

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act (Bill 4) Antitheft devices Gagnon LA 923—4 Mackintosh LA 923 Auto theft Gagnon LA 922—3 Mackintosh LA 923 Manitoba Telephone System Benson, Julian–role of Ashton PUNR 70—1 Findlay PUNR 70—1 Censure motion Ashton PUNR 75—6 Findlay PUNR 75—6 Customer database Fraser PUNR 68—70 Sale PUNR 68—70 Opening remarks Ashton PUNR 49—52 Findlay PUNR 45—7 Fraser PUNR 48—9 Stefanson, T. PUNR 47—8 Privatization Ashton PUNR 55—9, PUNR 62—9 Findlay PUNR 53—5, PUNR 59—60, PUNR 66—7 Stefanson, T.

PUNR 60—5 Privatization –brokerage firms Ashton PUNR 74 Stefanson, T. PUNR 74 Valuation Ashton PUNR 71—3 Findlay PUNR 71 Fraser PUNR 71—2 Stefanson, T. PUNR 72—3 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 67) 911 service Fricke PUNR 612 Lathlin PUNR 612 Advertising campaign Ashton PUNR 682 Cherpako PUNR 153 Dewar PUNR 492—3 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Gretsinger PUNR 148 Hartle, R.

PUNR 682 Hudson PUNR 544 Malabar PUNR 683 Miller PUNR 317 Sale PUNR 153 Scarcella PUNR 302 Struthers PUNR 544 Webb PUNR 493 Affiliated bodies Findlay PUNR 785, PUNR 799 Sale PUNR 785, PUNR 799—800 Yaffe PUNR 800 Alternatives Ashton PUNR 378, PUNR 650 Blomquist PUNR 650 Graham PUNR 378 Hales PUNR 433 Olson PUNR 609 Seymour PUNR 248 Shuster PUNR 404—5 Silver PUNR 633 Tait, C.

PUNR 564 Amendments Clause 1 Findlay PUNR 779; passed PUNR 780 PUNR 780; passed PUNR 780 PUNR 780; passed PUNR 781 PUNR 781; passed PUNR 782 PUNR 782; passed PUNR 782 PUNR 782; withdrawn PUNR 783 PUNR 783; passed PUNR 783 PUNR 783-4; passed PUNR 784 PUNR 785; passed PUNR 785 Clause 5 Findlay PUNR 790; passed PUNR 791 PUNR 791; passed PUNR 791 PUNR 791-2; passed PUNR 813 PUNR 813; passed PUNR 813 PUNR 852; passed PUNR 852 Clause 6 Findlay PUNR 798; passed PUNR 798 20

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Clause 7 Findlay PUNR 796; passed PUNR 796 Clause 10 Findlay PUNR 798; passed PUNR 798 Clause 11 Findlay PUNR 799; passed PUNR 799 PUNR 800; passed PUNR 800 Clause 12 Findlay PUNR 800-1; passed PUNR 801 Clause 13 Findlay PUNR 815; passed PUNR 816 Clause 14 Findlay PUNR 820; PUNR 823; passed PUNR 824 PUNR 824; passed PUNR 824 PUNR 827; passed PUNR 827 Clause 15 Findlay PUNR 830; passed PUNR 830 PUNR 872; passed PUNR 873 PUNR 873; passed PUNR 873 PUNR 873-4; passed PUNR 874 PUNR 874; passed PUNR 874 PUNR 874; passed PUNR 874 PUNR 874-5; passed PUNR 875 Sale PUNR 881; defeated PUNR 885 PUNR 885; defeated PUNR 885 Clause 16 Findlay PUNR 836; passed PUNR 850 PUNR 837; passed PUNR 838 Clause 17 Findlay PUNR 838; passed PUNR 838 PUNR 838; passed PUNR 838 Clause 18 Findlay PUNR 838; passed PUNR 838 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

PUNR 838; passed PUNR 838 PUNR 839; passed PUNR 839 PUNR 839-40; passed PUNR 840 PUNR 840; passed PUNR 840 PUNR 840; passed PUNR 840 Clause 20 Findlay PUNR 841; passed PUNR 841 PUNR 841; passed PUNR 841 Clause 21 Findlay PUNR 841; passed PUNR 841 PUNR 841; passed PUNR 841 Clause 22 Findlay PUNR 842; passed PUNR 843 Clause 24 Findlay PUNR 843; passed PUNR 843 PUNR 843; passed PUNR 843 Clause 25 Findlay PUNR 843; passed PUNR 843 PUNR 843; passed PUNR 843 Clause 27 Findlay PUNR 844; passed PUNR 844 Clause 28 Findlay PUNR 844; passed PUNR 844 Clause 33 Findlay PUNR 848; passed PUNR 848 Clause 37 Ashton PUNR 876; defeated PUNR 880 Findlay PUNR 849; passed PUNR 849 Clause 38 Findlay PUNR 849; PUNR 875-6; passed PUNR 876 Clause 39 Sale PUNR 853; defeated PUNR 856 21

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

PUNR 856-8; defeated PUNR 868 Analysis Doer PUNR 642 Wasylycia -Leis PUNR 642—3 Board of directors Findlay PUNR 814—5 Sale PUNR 814—5, PUNR 816—7 Struthers PUNR 816 Yaffe PUNR 816 Brokerage firms Ashton PUNR 144, PUNR 212, PUNR 264, PUNR 344—5, PUNR 382, PUNR 581, PUNR 585—6, PUNR 650, PUNR 687 Barrett PUNR 479 Blomquist PUNR 650—1 Eigenkind PUNR 581 Harris PUNR 345 Hudson PUNR 544 Jacob PUNR 687 Keenan, Jany PUNR 381, PUNR 382 McWilliams PUNR 264 Olson PUNR 608 Orton PUNR 212 Owen PUNR 144 Sayeau PUNR 293 Scarcella PUNR 305 Stadfield PUNR 478, PUNR 479 Struthers PUNR 544 Tefft PUNR 409 Welfley PUNR 584, PUNR 586 Wowchuk PUNR 305 Business plan Ashton PUNR 691 Pilano PUNR 691—2 Cable assets Hales PUNR 435 Markham PUNR 554 Owen PUNR 142 Rebeck PUNR 306—7 Sale PUNR 293—4 Sayeau PUNR 292, PUNR 293—4 Shiaro PUNR 117 Welfley PUNR 585 Caveats Ashton PUNR 647—8 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Kowalski, A. PUNR 646—8 Laurendeau PUNR 648 Certificate of continuance Findlay PUNR 825—6 Sale PUNR 824—6 Yaffe PUNR 824—5 Competition Ashton PUNR 160, PUNR 353, PUNR 379, PUNR 407, PUNR 580—1 Block, S. PUNR 353 Derkach PUNR 202 Eigenkind PUNR 581 Farley PUNR 233 Graham PUNR 379—80 Gretsinger PUNR 147 Hartle, R. PUNR 680 Kelly PUNR 241 MacKay PUNR 407 —8 Maruntz PUNR 160 Morrow -Litke PUNR 202 Nestruck PUNR 501 —3 Norman PUNR 167 Penner PUNR 232—3 Praznik PUNR 502—3 Reid PUNR 428 Reske PUNR 603 Samyn PUNR 428 Santos PUNR 503 Sveinson PUNR 561—2 Tait, F.

PUNR 562 Constituents, survey of Ashton PUNR 153 Cherpako PUNR 153 Consultations Ashton PUNR 128, PUNR 137, PUNR 148—9, PUNR 218, PUNR 242, PUNR 326, PUNR 371, PUNR 405, PUNR 583, PUNR 595—6, PUNR 633, PUNR 675 Barrett PUNR 479, PUNR 490, PUNR 530 Beaudry (for Hickerson, W.) PUNR 375 Brick PUNR 675 Cardoso PUNR 644, PUNR 646 Cote PUNR 532 Dewar PUNR 479, PUNR 571 Dilay PUNR 529, PUNR 530 22

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Doer PUNR 643 Dudgeon PUNR 356 Eliason PUNR 540 Fritz PUNR 165 Geisel PUNR 394 Gretsinger PUNR 149 Hallick PUNR 215—6, PUNR 218 Hewitt -Smith PUNR 205 Johannson, C. PUNR 370, PUNR 371 Kelly PUNR 242 Laser PUNR 436—7 Lord PUNR 324—5, PUNR 326 MacKinnon PUNR 320 Mackling PUNR 127—8 Martin, R.

PUNR 136, PUNR 137—8 Martindale PUNR 489 Miller PUNR 318 Ndayumvire PUNR 511—2 Nembhard PUNR 422 Norman PUNR 167 Pauls PUNR 596 Rebeck PUNR 307, PUNR 308 Reddy PUNR 582, PUNR 583 Reid PUNR 475 Riley PUNR 676 Robins PUNR 552 Robson PUNR 600—1 Sale PUNR 422 Samyn PUNR 427 Scarcella PUNR 302, PUNR 305 Schellenberg PUNR 571 Seymour PUNR 246 Shuster PUNR 403, PUNR 405 Silver PUNR 632—3, PUNR 634 Sokoloff PUNR 475 Stadfield PUNR 478—9 Stieffenhofer PUNR 414 Struthers PUNR 308, PUNR 646 Sullivan PUNR 487—8, PUNR 489—90 Sveinson PUNR 205 Tait, C.

PUNR 564 Tefft PUNR 409 Venema PUNR 368 Wasylycia -Leis PUNR 643 Wilson PUNR 363 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Wowchuk PUNR 218, PUNR 304—5, PUNR 318, PUNR 321, PUNR 356, PUNR 363, PUNR 368 Consumer protection Ashton PUNR 170—1 Norman PUNR 167, PUNR 170—2 Cost benefit analysis Keenan, M. PUNR 419 Sale PUNR 419 Crown corporations, role of Dudgeon PUNR 354—5 Farley PUNR 231 Grabowski, W.

PUNR 480 Orlikow PUNR 254 Reid PUNR 480 Crown Corporations Act Sale PUNR 788, PUNR 847 Yaffe PUNR 788 Crown shares Nicol PUNR 130 Shiaro PUNR 117 Customer database Scarcella PUNR 303 Debt load Cummings PUNR 499 Findlay PUNR 499, PUNR 602 Hales PUNR 434 Holle PUNR 587 Laser PUNR 437 Odlum PUNR 425 Olson PUNR 610 Reske PUNR 603 Robson PUNR 602—3 Sale PUNR 425, PUNR 437, PUNR 602, PUNR 610, PUNR 817—8, PUNR 827—30 Smith PUNR 535 Stefanson PUNR 817—8, PUNR 827—9 Vorst PUNR 498, PUNR 499 Welfley PUNR 584 Declaration Sale PUNR 841—2 Yaffe PUNR 841—2

Definitions –associate Findlay PUNR 779 Sale PUNR 779—80 Yaffe PUNR 779—80 23

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Definitions –foreign government Findlay PUNR 780 Struthers PUNR 780

Definitions –land Findlay PUNR 793 Sale PUNR 792—3, PUNR 814, PUNR 852 Yaffe PUNR 792—3, PUNR 814, PUNR 852

Definitions –nonresident of Canada Findlay PUNR 783 Sale PUNR 783 Disabled community, impact on Ducharme PUNR 112—5 Economic development Kelly PUNR 241 Economic impact Ashton PUNR 365, PUNR 374, PUNR 674—5 Brick PUNR 674—5 Campbell PUNR 337—8 Graham PUNR 377 Hiebert, P. PUNR 558—9 Johannson, C. (for Duncan, G.) PUNR 366 Jones PUNR 568 McClelland PUNR 411—2 McGregor PUNR 364—5 Slater PUNR 374—5 Taylor (for Jones) PUNR 266 Election Ashton PUNR 118 Shiaro PUNR 118 Employment, impact on Ashton PUNR 156—7, PUNR 160—1, PUNR 163, PUNR 166, PUNR 209, PUNR 257, PUNR 268, PUNR 271, PUNR 679 Burrows PUNR 162—3 Clune, E.

PUNR 277—8 Cote PUNR 531 Curtis PUNR 255—6, PUNR 257 Dolenuk PUNR 207—10 Eigenkind PUNR 580 Fritz PUNR 165, PUNR 166 Grabowski, A. PUNR 548 Gretsinger PUNR 148 Hadfield PUNR 155, PUNR 156—8 Hartle, E. PUNR 679 Hartle, R. PUNR 681 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Henry PUNR 269—70, PUNR 271 Jacob PUNR 686 Johannson, C. PUNR 552 Martz PUNR 260, PUNR 262 Maruntz PUNR 161 Masse PUNR 290—1 McWilliams PUNR 264, PUNR 265 Milne PUNR 636 Norman PUNR 167 Penner PUNR 261, PUNR 290—1 Reid PUNR 432—3, PUNR 474 Riley PUNR 677 Sale PUNR 265 Samyn PUNR 426 Sayeau PUNR 293 Seymour PUNR 247 Simbandumwe, A.

PUNR 514 Sokoloff PUNR 474—5 Struthers PUNR 552 Taylor PUNR 268 Trottier PUNR 433 Employment, impact on Mallea PUNR 124 Essential service Ansell PUNR 651, PUNR 652 Ashton PUNR 652, PUNR 677, PUNR 689 Barr PUNR 516 Barrett PUNR 445 Blanco PUNR 120 —1 Brick PUNR 673—4 Cameron PUNR 538, PUNR 539 Cardoso PUNR 644 Cummings PUNR 521 Doer PUNR 520 Eigenkind PUNR 580 Frolick, D. PUNR 444, PUNR 445 Geisel PUNR 393 Hammond PUNR 527 Jones PUNR 567 Keenan, Jerry PUNR 519, PUNR 520—1 Lucas PUNR 486 Martin, B. PUNR 575—7 Martindale PUNR 651—2 McAlpine PUNR 539 Ndayumvire PUNR 512 24

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Pankiw PUNR 173 Plummer PUNR 504—5 Riley PUNR 676—7 Sale PUNR 173, PUNR 527, PUNR 538, PUNR 565 Saleski PUNR 688—9 Simbandumwe, M. PUNR 508—9 Tait, C. PUNR 565 Tefft PUNR 408 Webb PUNR 490 Welfley PUNR 585 Yeo PUNR 522—3 Evaluation period Goddard PUNR 385—6 Faneuil Hales PUNR 435 Martin, R.

PUNR 136 Owen PUNR 142—3 Shiaro PUNR 117 Government investment Kelly PUNR 241 Government mandate Anderson PUNR 626 Ashton PUNR 339, PUNR 410, PUNR 583, PUNR 586, PUNR 614—5, PUNR 616—7 Barker PUNR 615—7 Barr PUNR 516 Barrett PUNR 456, PUNR 458, PUNR 497, PUNR 532 Beaudry PUNR 346—7, PUNR 348 Blomquist PUNR 649 Brown PUNR 667 Bukoski PUNR 618 Burgess PUNR 606 Campbell PUNR 339 Cardoso PUNR 644 Carlyle PUNR 476 Clune, E. PUNR 277 Clune, K. PUNR 464, PUNR 466 Cote PUNR 531, PUNR 532 Dewar PUNR 570—1, PUNR 574 Doer PUNR 513, PUNR 514—5, PUNR 642 Dooley PUNR 234—5 Eigenkind PUNR 579 Frolick, A.

PUNR 605 Gooding PUNR 572—3 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Graham PUNR 376—7 Hartle, R. PUNR 681 Hawkins PUNR 457, PUNR 458 Hiebert, W.

PUNR 620 Hooper PUNR 614—5 Hrynyk PUNR 449 Jack PUNR 446—7 Jacob PUNR 685—6 Keenan, Jany PUNR 380 Laser PUNR 436 MacDonald PUNR 623 Mackintosh PUNR 604 Malabar PUNR 683 Marshall PUNR 331—2 McGregor PUNR 364 Miller PUNR 316—7 Milne PUNR 635 Ndayumvire PUNR 513 Nembhard PUNR 420 Odlum PUNR 424 Olson PUNR 608 Pilano PUNR 690 Rebeck PUNR 307 Reddy PUNR 582, PUNR 583 Reid PUNR 466 Reske PUNR 603, PUNR 604 Riley PUNR 676 Roman PUNR 496, PUNR 497 Romphf PUNR 455, PUNR 456 Sale PUNR 348 Samyn PUNR 426 Schellenberg PUNR 569—71 Seymour PUNR 246 Shuster PUNR 403 Simbandumwe, A.

PUNR 514—5 Slater PUNR 373 Smith PUNR 534—5 Stadfield PUNR 478 Steur PUNR 494 Stieffenhofer PUNR 414 Still PUNR 574 Tefft PUNR 408, PUNR 410 Trottier PUNR 430—1 Venema PUNR 368 Wasylycia -Leis PUNR 642 25

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Webb PUNR 491 Welfley PUNR 584, PUNR 586 Wilson PUNR 362 Guarantees Mallea PUNR 123 Head office Benson PUNR 803—5 Findlay PUNR 801—5 Jennissen PUNR 801—5 Highway Traffic Act Sale PUNR 847 Yaffe PUNR 847 Indebtedness to the Crown Findlay PUNR 781 Sale PUNR 781 Struthers PUNR 781 Information release Ashton PUNR 205 Doer PUNR 639 —40 Hewitt -Smith PUNR 205 Hudson PUNR 543 Regehr PUNR 639—40 Judicial commission Ashton PUNR 223 Schultz PUNR 222, PUNR 223 Justification Barrett PUNR 537 Findlay PUNR 495 Santos PUNR 495 Schultz PUNR 220—1 Smith PUNR 537 Steur PUNR 495 Land Acquisitions Act Sale PUNR 847 Yaffe PUNR 847 Land assessments Findlay PUNR 846—7 Penner PUNR 846—7 Sale PUNR 845—7 Yaffe PUNR 845—7 Land assets Sale PUNR 790—1 Legal challenge Schultz PUNR 222 Legislative process Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Altemeyer, J. PUNR 451 Ashton PUNR 141, PUNR 650 Barr PUNR 516 Barrett PUNR 449—50 Blomquist PUNR 650 Bukoski PUNR 619 Dilay PUNR 530—1 Eigenkind PUNR 578—9 Espey PUNR 482 Fainman PUNR 668 Forrest PUNR 671 Fricke PUNR 611 Hiebert, E. PUNR 141 Hiebert, W.

PUNR 619 Hrynyk PUNR 448—50 Jones PUNR 566—7 Malabar PUNR 683 McAlpine PUNR 416—7 Nembhard PUNR 420 Odlum PUNR 423 Pauls PUNR 594—5 Sale PUNR 530, PUNR 618—9 Sokal PUNR 417 Wiens PUNR 629 Mandate Blanco PUNR 120 NAFTA regulations Ashton PUNR 326—7 Lord PUNR 325, PUNR 326—7 Opening remarks Findlay PUNR 769—70 Sale PUNR 771—5 Order in Council Findlay PUNR 782 Sale PUNR 782 Ownership Arnason PUNR 468 Ashton PUNR 261, PUNR 345, PUNR 405, PUNR 686—7 Barrett PUNR 484, PUNR 541 Beaudry PUNR 347 Cerilli, A. PUNR 245—6 Dooley PUNR 235 Eliason PUNR 539, PUNR 541 Espey PUNR 484 26

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Findlay PUNR 499—500 Goddard PUNR 385 Hallick PUNR 217 Harris PUNR 345 Jacob PUNR 686—7 Keenan, Jerry PUNR 519 Keenan, M.

PUNR 418 Kelly PUNR 242 Martz PUNR 261 Miller PUNR 316—7 Morrow -Litke PUNR 203 Nembhard PUNR 421 Reid PUNR 468, PUNR 474 Reske PUNR 603 Sale PUNR 810—3 Shuster PUNR 405—6 Silver PUNR 632, PUNR 633 Sokoloff PUNR 474 Steur PUNR 494 Sullivan PUNR 488 Vorst PUNR 500 Wowchuk PUNR 203, PUNR 217, PUNR 245 Ownership, recovery of Goddard PUNR 386 Ownership, restrictions of Sale PUNR 786—7 Yaffe PUNR 786—7 Pension plan Arnason PUNR 469 Ashton PUNR 133, PUNR 134—5, PUNR 210, PUNR 259, PUNR 262—3, PUNR 265, PUNR 279, PUNR 808—10, PUNR 871—2 Barrett PUNR 537 Beatty PUNR 441—3 Benson PUNR 851 Cerilli, A.

PUNR 245 Chanas PUNR 175 Clune, E. PUNR 278, PUNR 279 Clune, K. PUNR 464—5, PUNR 466 Dolenuk PUNR 210 Findlay PUNR 263, PUNR 442—3, PUNR 808—9, PUNR 869—71 Hadfield PUNR 155 Hartle, E. PUNR 679 Leochko PUNR 259 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Martin, R.

PUNR 137 Martz PUNR 260 McWilliams PUNR 264, PUNR 265 Meronek PUNR 295 —9 Nyhof PUNR 262—3 Praznik PUNR 298—9 Reid PUNR 427—8, PUNR 466, PUNR 469 Rudiak PUNR 132—3 Sa le PUNR 135, PUNR 157, PUNR 175, PUNR 245, PUNR 263, PUNR 298—9, PUNR 442—3, PUNR 789, PUNR 881—3, PUNR 881—4 Samyn PUNR 426—8 Sharpe PUNR 134—5 Smith PUNR 535—6, PUNR 537 Stefanson PUNR 883 Taylor PUNR 267 Process Ashton PUNR 276 Minish, E.

PUNR 275—6 Proclamation Ashton PUNR 854—50, PUNR 860—2, PUNR 863—5 Doer PUNR 865 —8 Sale PUNR 853—4, PUNR 858—60 Prospectus Ashton PUNR 144 Benson PUNR 833—6 Findlay PUNR 835 Markham PUNR 556 Owen PUNR 144 Sale PUNR 556, PUNR 832—6 Yaffe PUNR 833—5 Public debt Aasland PUNR 401 Curtis PUNR 255, PUNR 256 Hallick PUNR 217 Kelly PUNR 240—1 Mackling PUNR 127 Martin, R. PUNR 136 McWilliams PUNR 263 Nicol PUNR 129, PUNR 131 Owen PUNR 142 Sale PUNR 131, PUNR 256 Public's interest Barrett PUNR 528 27

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Beaudry PUNR 347 Bukoski PUNR 617 Fainman PUNR 670 Fricke PUNR 611 Friesen PUNR 669—70 Geisel PUNR 394 Hammond PUNR 528 Johannson, C. (for Duncan, G.) PUNR 366—7 Johannson, E. PUNR 589—90 Keenan, M. PUNR 418 Plummer PUNR 505—6 Santos PUNR 505—6 Shuster PUNR 404 Tibelius PUNR 653 Venema PUNR 368 Vorst PUNR 498 Wasylycia -Leis PUNR 641 Rates, impact on Altemeyer, J.

PUNR 451 Anderson PUNR 628 Ansell PUNR 652 Ashton PUNR 125, PUNR 173, PUNR 206, PUNR 236, PUNR 248, PUNR 254, PUNR 279, PUNR 345, PUNR 373—4, PUNR 618, PUNR 630—1, PUNR 634, PUNR 649, PUNR 652, PUNR 675 Barker PUNR 615 Barr PUNR 517 Barrett PUNR 445, PUNR 492, PUNR 509—10 Blomquist PUNR 649—50 Brick PUNR 675 Brown PUNR 668 Bukoski PUNR 618, PUNR 619 Cardoso PUNR 644—6 Carlyle PUNR 475—6 Clune, E. PUNR 278—9 Clune, E. (for Chanas) PUNR 174 Clune, K.

PUNR 464 Cummings PUNR 619, PUNR 625 Curtis PUNR 255 Dilay PUNR 528 Doer PUNR 517, PUNR 524—5, PUNR 637 Dooley PUNR 235—6 Eigenkind PUNR 579 Forrest PUNR 671, PUNR 672—3 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Friesen PUNR 672 Frolick, D. PUNR 445 Geisel PUNR 393—4 Gretsinger PUNR 147—8 Hallick PUNR 216 Hammond PUNR 527, PUNR 528 Harris PUNR 345 Hartle, R. PUNR 681 Hewitt -Smith PUNR 204, PUNR 206 Hooper PUNR 614 Hrynyk PUNR 449 Hudson PUNR 542—3 Jacob PUNR 686 Johannson, C. PUNR 370 Keenan, Jany PUNR 380—1 Keenan, M.

PUNR 418 Lucas PUNR 487 MacDonald PUNR 625 MacKinnon PUNR 320 Mallea PUNR 123—4, PUNR 125 Markham PUNR 554—5 Martin, B. PUNR 578 Martindale PUNR 510 McAlpine PUNR 445 McGonigal PUNR 341—2 Milne PUNR 635—6, PUNR 637 Morrow -Litke PUNR 201 Nembhard PUNR 420—1 Odlum PUNR 425 Olson PUNR 610 Orlikow PUNR 254 Orton PUNR 211 Pankiw PUNR 172, PUNR 173 Pilano PUNR 690 Reid PUNR 487 Reske PUNR 604 Riley PUNR 676 Robins PUNR 552—3 S ale PUNR 415, PUNR 425, PUNR 528, PUNR 566, PUNR 604, PUNR 619, PUNR 625, PUNR 628, PUNR 668, PUNR 672 Sayeau PUNR 292 Seymour PUNR 247, PUNR 248 Shuster PUNR 403—4 Silver PUNR 634 28

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Simbandumwe, M. PUNR 510 Slater PUNR 372—4 Smith PUNR 536 Steur PUNR 494 Stieffenhofer PUNR 415 Struthers PUNR 645 Tait, C. PUNR 566 Tait, F. PUNR 560 Taylor (for Jones) PUNR 266 Trottier PUNR 431—2 Vorst PUNR 499 Wasylycia -Leis PUNR 641—2 Webb PUNR 492 Welfley PUNR 584 Wiens PUNR 631 Wowchuk PUNR 211, PUNR 578 Yeo PUNR 522, PUNR 523, PUNR 525 Rates, impact one Scarcella PUNR 303 Referendum Ashton PUNR 218, PUNR 339, PUNR 591, PUNR 675 Barr PUNR 517 Brick PUNR 675—6 Campbell PUNR 339 Doer PUNR 515, PUNR 634 Grabowski, A.

PUNR 548 Hallick PUNR 216, PUNR 218 Hewitt -Smith PUNR 205 Johannson, E. PUNR 591—2 Silver PUNR 634—5 Simbandumwe, A. PUNR 515 Reversal Campbell PUNR 338 Rural Manitoba, impact on Ashton PUNR 131, PUNR 163, PUNR 291, PUNR 630 Barrett PUNR 456 Burrows PUNR 163 Cerilli PUNR 246 Cummings PUNR 395, PUNR 602 Dooley PUNR 237 Dudgeon PUNR 356 Frolick, A. PUNR 605 Geisel PUNR 395—6 Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Grabowski, A. PUNR 549 Gretsinger PUNR 147 Hales PUNR 433 Hewitt -Smith PUNR 204 Hiebert, P. PUNR 558 Jennissen PUNR 203 Keenan, M.

PUNR 418 MacDonald PUNR 624 MacKay PUNR 406 Marshall PUNR 333 Masse PUNR 289, PUNR 291 McGonigal PUNR 342 Minish, K. PUNR 150—1 Morrow -Litke PUNR 203 Nicol PUNR 131 Penner PUNR 203 Robson PUNR 601, PUNR 602 Romphf PUNR 456 Sale PUNR 151, PUNR 395, PUNR 601, PUNR 788—9 Seymour PUNR 248—9 Struthers PUNR 549 Tait, C. PUNR 564 Trottier PUNR 431 Venema PUNR 369 Wiens PUNR 630 Wilson PUNR 362—3 Wowchuk PUNR 237, PUNR 246, PUNR 248—9, PUNR 291, PUNR 332—3, PUNR 342, PUNR 356, PUNR 362—3, PUNR 369 Rural stress line Martin, B.

PUNR 577 Riley PUNR 678 Wowchuk PUNR 577, PUNR 677—8 Save Our System campaign Blanco PUNR 121 —2 Dewar PUNR 121—2 Seniors, impact on Ashton PUNR 173 Block, J. PUNR 351—2 Pankiw PUNR 173—4 Wowchuk PUNR 352 Services, impact on Ashton PUNR 650, PUNR 682—3 Barrett PUNR 541, PUNR 549 29

Index of Standing and Special Committees Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont. Blomquist PUNR 650 Eliason PUNR 540, PUNR 541 Grabowski, A. PUNR 548, PUNR 549 Hartle, R. PUNR 681, PUNR 682—3 Lucas PUNR 487 Markham PUNR 555 Milne PUNR 636 Reid PUNR 487 Tibelius PUNR 653 Wowchuk PUNR 653 Share value Ashton PUNR 146, PUNR 166—7 Fritz PUNR 167 Minish, G. PUNR 145—6 Shares Ashton PUNR 876—9 Barrett PUNR 456, PUNR 555—6 Burgess PUNR 607 Curtis PUNR 256—7 Derkach PUNR 256—7 Eigenkind PUNR 580 Hiebert, W.

PUNR 620, PUNR 622 Jones PUNR 567 Mackintosh PUNR 607 Markham PUNR 556 Milne PUNR 636 Romphf PUNR 456 Sale PUNR 607, PUNR 614, PUNR 622 Sayeau PUNR 294 Scarcella PUNR 303 Stefanson PUNR 879—80 Steur PUNR 495 Wowchuk PUNR 294 Shares held as collateral Sale PUNR 787—8 Yaffe PUNR 787—8 Shares –employee incentives Beatty PUNR 441 Shares –nonvoting Sale PUNR 794—5 Yaffe PUNR 794 Shares –public offering Sale PUNR 796—8 Yaffe PUNR 796—8 Shares –purchase of Manitoba Telephone System Reorganization–Cont.

Orton PUNR 212 Wowchuk PUNR 212 Social impact Flynn PUNR 349—51 McGifford PUNR 342—3 McGonigal PUNR 340—1, PUNR 343 Novak PUNR 334—6 Sale PUNR 335—6, PUNR 350—1 Vieno PUNR 357 —60 Strategic partner Findlay PUNR 839 Sale PUNR 839 Students, impact on Ashton PUNR 684—5 Cummings PUNR 685 Malabar PUNR 684—5 Survey Ashton PUNR 243 Kelly PUNR 243 Taxpayer protection Norman PUNR 167 Technology Goddard PUNR 385 Mackling PUNR 127 Universal service Ashton PUNR 261 Martz PUNR 261 Manitoba Trading Corporation Amendment Act (Bill 14) Opening remarks Downey ED 40 Sale ED 39—40 Medical Amendment Act (Bill 7) LA 14—5 Municipal and Various Acts Amendment Act (Bill 54) Amalgamation/annexation Angus MA 110—1 Barrett MA 112, MA 117—8 Derkach MA 100—1, MA 111, MA 116—7 Fleming MA 116—8 Garlich MA 116 Laurendeau MA 101 30

Index of Standing and Special Committees Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

Murray MA 98—102 Ternette MA 113—4 Zimberg MA 78 Ambulance service Borotsik MA 74 Amendments Clause 1 Derkach MA 124; passed MA 125 MA 125; passed MA 125 MA 125; passed MA 125 MA 125; passed MA 125 Clause 4 Derkach MA 125-6; passed MA 126 Clause 9 Derkach MA 126; passed MA 126 MA 126-8; passed MA 129 Clause 22 Derkach MA 129; passed MA 129 Clause 38 Derkach MA 129; passed MA 129 Clause 50 Derkach MA 129; passed MA 129 Clause 51 Derkach MA 129-30; passed MA 130 Clause 52 Derkach MA 130; passed MA 130 Clause 67 Barrett MA 130-1; defeated MA 132 MA 132; defeated MA 133 Clause 71 Barrett MA 133; defeated MA 134—5 MA 135; defeated MA 135 Derkach MA 136; passed MA 136 Clause 72 Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

Barrett MA 136; defeated MA 138 Clause 79 Derkach MA 138; passed MA 138 MA 138-9; passed MA 139 Clause 80 Derkach MA 139; passed MA 139 Clause 81 Derkach MA 139; passed MA 140 Clause 85 Derkach MA 140; passed MA 140 Clause 87 Derkach MA 140; passed MA 140 MA 140; passed MA 140 MA 140-1; passed MA 141 MA 141; passed MA 141 Clause 89 Derkach MA 141; passed MA 141 MA 142; passed MA 142 Clause 107 Derkach MA 142; passed MA 142 MA 142; passed MA 142 Clause 108 Derkach MA 142-3; passed MA 143 Clause 117 Derkach MA 143; passed MA 143 Clause 147 Derkach MA 143; passed MA 143 Clause 148 Derkach MA 143; passed MA 144 MA 144; passed MA 144 Clause 154 Derkach MA 144; passed MA 144 31

Index of Standing and Special Committees Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

MA 144; passed MA 144 MA 144; passed MA 144 Clause 158 Derkach MA 145; passed MA 145 Clause 162 Derkach MA 145; passed MA 145 Clause 163 Derkach MA 145-6; passed MA 146 Clause 164 Derkach MA 146; passed MA 146 Clause 174 Derkach MA 146-7; passed MA 147 Clause 176 Derkach MA 147; passed MA 147 Clause 229 Derkach MA 147; passed MA 147 Clause 249 Derkach MA 147; passed MA 148 Clause 261 Derkach MA 148; passed MA 148 MA 148; passed MA 148 Clause 269 Derkach MA 149; passed MA 149 MA 149; passed MA 1498 Clause 270 Derkach MA 149; passed MA 149 Clause 290 Derkach MA 149; passed MA 149 Clause 296 Derkach MA 150; passed MA 150 Clause 316 Derkach Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

MA 150; passed MA 150 Clause 318 Derkach MA 151; passed MA 151 Clause 327 Derkach MA 152; passed MA 152 Clause 328 Derkach MA 152-3; passed MA 153 Clause 330 Derkach MA 153; passed MA 153 Clause 341 Derkach MA 153; passed MA 154 Clause 378 Derkach MA 154; passed MA 155 Clause 387 Derkach MA 155; passed MA 155 Clause 394 Derkach MA 155; passed MA 155 Clause 416 Derkach MA 155-6; passed MA 156 Clause 419 Derkach MA 156; passed MA 156 Clause 425 Derkach MA 156; passed MA 156 Clause 428 Derkach MA 156; passed MA 157 Clause 431 Derkach MA 157; passed MA 157 MA 158; passed MA 158 MA 158; passed MA 158 MA 158-9; passed MA 159 Clause 439 Derkach 32

Index of Standing and Special Committees Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

MA 159; passed MA 159 Clause 440 Derkach MA 159; passed MA 159 Clause 442 Derkach MA 160; passed MA 160 Clause 457 Derkach MA 160; passed MA 160 Clause 458 Derkach MA 160; passed MA 160 MA 160-1; passed MA 161 Clause 460 Derkach MA 161; passed MA 161 Building inspections Zimberg MA 79—80 Collective agreements Barrett MA 97 Derkach MA 97 Summerlus MA 96—7 Commercial development Nicol MA 82 Councillors, disqualification of Zimberg MA 78 Councils –practice and procedures Nicol MA 83 Downloading Struthers MA 71 Yakielashek MA 71 Elected office–municipal employees Borotsik MA 73 Elected office–residency requirement Borotsik MA 73 Nicol MA 83 Equality Zimberg MA 79 Financial plans Nicol MA 83 Fiscal responsibility Zimberg MA 79 Formation, fundamental change Nicol MA 82—3 Municipal and Various Acts–Cont.

Grants in lieu of taxes Borotsik MA 74 Derkach MA 76 Evans, C. MA 76—7 Nicol MA 83—4 Wasylowski MA 75—7 Zimberg MA 79 Incorporation Sutherland MA 103—4 Local goverment districts Nicol MA 82 Local improvements and special services Derkach MA 81 Evans, C. MA 80 Laurendeau MA 71—2 Yakielashek MA 70, MA 72 Zimberg MA 79, MA 80—1 Local urban districts Derkach MA 71 Frey MA 71 Yakielashek MA 70, MA 71 Zimberg MA 78 Opening remarks Derkach MA 69, MA 124 Evans, C.

MA 124 Pension plans Borotsik MA 74 Policing services Borotsik MA 74 Zimberg MA 79 Public meetings Borotsik MA 73 Regulations Borotsik MA 74 Zimberg MA 80 Tax refunds, interest rates Derkach MA 106 Sanders MA 104—6 Taxpayer protection Derkach MA 95, MA 108—9 Struthers MA 109 Ternette MA 113 Vrsnik MA 107—10 Wright MA 94—5 Transition funding 33

Index of Standing and Special Committees Municipal and Various Acts–Cont. Frey MA 70 Unincorporated village districts Derkach MA 92 Gluska MA 86—7, MA 88 Holme MA 93—4 Hrabarchuk MA 91—3 Jennissen MA 88 Laurendeau MA 94 Sutherland MA 102—3 Sveinson MA 91—3, MA 94 Urban sprawl Garlich MA 115 Voting –abstention from Borotsik MA 73 Braun MA 89 Zimberg MA 79 Voting –mayor/reeve Borotsik MA 75 Braun MA 90 Derkach MA 90 Evans, C.

MA 75 Zimberg MA 78—9 Municipal Assessment Amendment, City of Winnipeg Amendment and Assessment Validation Act (Bill 43) Amendments Clause 3 Derkach MA 61; passed MA 52—3 Clause 6 Derkach MA 62; passed MA 62 MA 62; passed MA 62 Clause 7 Derkach MA 62-3; passed MA 63 Clause 9 Derkach MA 63-4; passed MA 64 Clause 11 Derkach MA 64; passed MA 64 Clause 12 Derkach Municipal Assessment Amendment–Cont.

MA 64; passed MA 64 Appeal process Baldwin MA 52 Chappel MA 11—2 Derkach MA 12, MA 22, MA 50—1, MA 52 Diner MA 49, MA 51 Dupont MA 23 Frohlinger MA 45—6 Khan MA 26 Nelson MA 27—8 Nicol MA 7 Sanders MA 21—2 Smith MA 47 Steele MA 35 Weind MA 29 Wong MA 39—40 Appeals –commercial Khan MA 25 Appeals –third-party Khan MA 25 Mercury MA 31—2 Nelson MA 27 Smith MA 47—8 Assessment cycle Chappel MA 11, MA 12 Derkach MA 12, MA 38 Dupont MA 24 Frohlinger MA 45, MA 46—7 Kelly MA 37, MA 38—9 Khan MA 26—7 Laurendeau MA 33 Mercury MA 32, MA 33 Nelson MA 27 Nicol MA 6—7 Penner MA 46 Sanders MA 20—1 Steele MA 34 Weind MA 29—30 Assessment departments–privatization Kelly MA 37 Burden of proof Weind MA 29 Consultations Derkach MA 39 Kelly MA 39 34

Index of Standing and Special Committees Municipal Assessment Amendment–Cont.

Definitions –railway roadway Barrett MA 43 Derkach MA 6, MA 43—4 Olyniuk MA 4—6 Zacharopoulos MA 41—4

Definitions –value Steele MA 36 Information, provision of Dupont MA 23—4 Frohlinger MA 46 Khan MA 25—6 Nelson MA 28 Sanders MA 22 Steele MA 35—6 Weind MA 29 Market value Baldwin MA 52—3 Penner MA 52—3 Weind MA 29 Municipal Board Wong MA 40 Railway industry, impact on Derkach MA 18—9 Prentice MA 18—9 Reference year, definition of Steele MA 36 Transitional clauses Sanders MA 22 Municipal Assessment Amendment and Assessment Validation Act (Bill 2) Amendments Clause 6 Derkach MA 53-4; passed MA 54 MA 54 passed MA 54 Appeal, right of Derkach MA 15—6 Whitehill MA 13—6 Rules of practice Derkach MA 9 Eadie MA 9—10 Sanders MA 8 Steek MA 9 Validation Municipal Assessment Amendment. . .(Bill 2)–Cont.

Chappel MA 10—1 Derkach MA 10—1 Museum of Man and Nature Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 27) ED 37—8 Native Alcoholism Council of Manitoba Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 301) Opening remarks Martindale IR 294—5 Strutt IR 294 Natural Products Marketing Amendment Act (Bill 77) Interprovincial pooling Enns AG 62 Van Ryssel AG 61—2 Wowchuk AG 62 Nelson House First Nation Northern Flood Implementation Agreement Act (Bill 53) Amendments Clause 2 Praznik ED 97; ED 98 See also Northern flood agreements North Portage Development Corporation Financial outlook Keller ED 77 Sale ED 77—8 Smith ED 77 Steiman ED 77—8 Opening remarks Keller ED 59—60 Reimer ED 58—9 Smith ED 60—5 Property taxes Keller ED 65 Laurendeau ED 65 Smith ED 65 The Forks Future development 35

Index of Standing and Special Committees North Portage Development Corporation–Cont.

Barrett ED 72 Keller ED 72 Sale ED 71 Smith ED 71—2 Steiman ED 72 Heritage plan Friesen ED 76—7 Keller ED 76—7 Smith ED 76—7 Multiplex facility Barrett ED 65—6, ED 68 Keller ED 65—8 Reimer ED 69 Sale ED 67 Smith ED 67—8 Steiman ED 67—8 Parks Canada program Friesen ED 74—5 Keller ED 75 Promotion Friesen ED 73—4 Smith ED 74 Residential development Barrett ED 69—70 Keller ED 70 Sale ED 70—1 Smith ED 69 South Point development Barrett ED 73 Keller ED 73 York Avenue extension Keller ED 71 Sale ED 71 Northern Affairs Amendment Act (Bill 42) Amendments Clause 2 Praznik ED 35; P ED 35 Clause 14 Praznik ED 35; P ED 36 Opening remarks Robinson ED 35 Northern flood agreements Consultations Ashton ED 84—5 Primrose ED 85 Opening remarks Lemieux ED 90—2 Moody ED 83—4 Primrose ED 82—3 Saunders ED 86—90 See also Nelson House First Nation Northern Flood Implementation Agreement Act (Bill 53); York Factory First Nation Northern Flood Implementation Agreement Act (Bill 52) Oil and Gas Production Tax and Oil and Gas Amendment Act (Bill 21) Amendments Clause 5 Praznik ED 34 P ED 34 Clause 165 Praznik ED 34 P ED 34 Reduced tax rate Mihychuk ED 34 Praznik ED 34 Parental Responsibility Act (Bill 58) Alternatives Hart LA 1010 Mackintosh LA 1010 Mirochnick LA 1012 Amendments Clause 2 Mackintosh LA 1031; ruled out of order LA 1031 Clause 6 Mackintosh LA 1035; defeated LA 1035 Certificate as proof Mackintosh LA 1034 Vodrey LA 1034 Defence McCormick LA 1021—2

Definitions –parent Lehman LA 1018 36

Index of Standing and Special Committees Parental Responsibility Act–Cont.

Factors to be considered McCormick LA 1022 Juvenile Delinquents Act Mackintosh LA 1013 Mironchnick LA 1011, LA 1013 Method of payment McCormick LA 1022 Noncustodial parents Dyck LA 1024—7 Mackintosh LA 1026—7 Opening remarks Mackintosh LA 1028—9 Vodrey LA 1027—8 Parent, onus on Clark LA 1016 Hart LA 1009, LA 1010 Mackintosh LA 1010, LA 1016, LA 1035—8 McCormick LA 1022 Santos LA 1036 Vodrey LA 1036—8 Parent liability Hart LA 1009 Mackintosh LA 1033—4 McCormick LA 1021 Vodrey LA 1033—4 Parenting skills program Mackintosh LA 1038 Vodrey LA 1038 Personal injury Mackintosh LA 1030—1 Vodrey LA 1030—1 Property damage McCormick LA 1021 Purpose Kowalski LA 1031 Vodrey LA 1032 Restitution Kowalski LA 1032—3 Vodrey LA 1032—3 Small claims court Kowalski LA 1023 Lehman LA 1017—8 McCormick LA 1023 Young Offenders Act Mirochnick LA 1011—2 Parental Responsibility Act–Cont.

Vodrey LA 1012—3 Pari-Mutuel Levy and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 39) Levies, distribution of Downey ED 41 Sale ED 41 Manitoba Jockey Club Downey ED 41—4 Sale ED 41—3 Offences Downey ED 44 Kowalski ED 44 Opening remarks Downey ED 41 Sale ED 41 Payment of Wages Act (Bill 18) AG 63 Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 40) AG 43 Pharmaceutical Amendment Act (Bill 10) Ministerial responsibility Chernecki LA 19 Opening remarks Chomiak LA 21—2 McCrae LA 21—2 Powers of Attorney and Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 59) Amendments Clause 16 Mackintosh LA 938; passed LA 939 Clause 26 Mackintosh LA 939; passed LA 941 Opening remarks Mackintosh LA 937—8 Vodrey LA 936—7 Public Accounts A.E.

McKenzie Co. Ltd. Johnson PA 51 Sale PA 50—1 37

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Accounts–Cont.

Stefanson PA 50—1 APM Consultants Johnson PA 12—3 Maloway PA 12 —3 Sale PA 38—9 Stefanson PA 12—3, PA 38—9 Audits –contracting Johnson PA 18—21, PA 28 Maloway PA 19 Sale PA 18—21 Stefanson PA 18—21 Bellringer, Carol Lamoureux PA 3—4 Sale PA 2—4 Stefanson PA 3 Capital assets Johnson PA 9—10, PA 12 Sale PA 8—10 Stefanson PA 9—11, PA 12 Deficit, reconciliation of Johnson PA 6 Sale PA 7 Stefanson PA 5, PA 7 Faneuil Johnson PA 44—5 Lamoureux PA 43—4 Stefanson PA 43—4 Financial indicators Johnson PA 7—8 Sale PA 7 Glossaries Johnson PA 6 Sale PA 8, PA 29 Stefanson PA 5—6, PA 8, PA 29 Grow Bonds program Johnson PA 22—3, PA 32—3 Sale PA 22—3, PA 32—4 Stefanson PA 22—3, PA 32—4 Lottery revenues Johnson PA 40—1 Sale PA 39—43 Stefanson PA 39—43 Manitoba Trading Corporation Johnson PA 31 Sale PA 30—2 Public Accounts–Cont.

Stefanson PA 30—2 Opening remarks Johnson PA 4 Stefanson PA 2, PA 25—6 Public Accounts, release of Stefanson PA 5 Repurchasing –land Johnson PA 12 Sale PA 12 Stefanson PA 12 Schools, independent Johnson PA 45 Sale PA 45—6 Stefanson PA 45 Special operating agencies Johnson PA 35—8 Sale PA 34—8 Stefanson PA 35—8 Superannuation Fund Johnson PA 46 Sale PA 46 Stefanson PA 46 Tax expenditure account Johnson PA 15 Sale PA 14—8 Stefanson PA 15—8, PA 27—8 Trust funds Stefanson PA 26—7 Untendered contracts Sale PA 29—30 Stefanson PA 29—30 Vacation pay, accrual of Johnson PA 7 Sale PA 7 Stefanson PA 7 Valuation allowance Sale PA 14 Stefanson PA 14 Winnipeg Jets agreement Sale PA 46—50 Stefanson PA 46—50 Public Health Amendment Act (Bill 9) Penalties Chomiak LA 21 38

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Health Amendment–Cont. McCrae LA 21 Public Schools Amendment Act (2) (Bill 72) Ability to pay Barker LA 656, LA 657 Beresford (for MacNeil) LA 824—5 Boisvert LA 673—4 Cerilli, A. LA 786 Cherpako LA 752 Doer LA 774 Ducharme LA 755 Duhamel LA 648—9 Dyrkacz LA 663 Eliasson LA 686, LA 688 Friesen, H. LA 653 Friesen, J.

LA 679, LA 688 Fritske LA 667 Gelinas LA 765 Gendreau LA 733—4 Goodridge LA 729 Grabowski LA 703 Hilliard LA 710 Hinchliffe LA 777 Isaak LA 791 Jonasson LA 681 Kyle LA 706, LA 708 Land LA 809 Lawrie LA 699—700 MacLellan LA 788—9 McIntosh LA 657, LA 699—700, LA 702—3, LA 708, LA 756 Minaker LA 783 Munro LA 720—1 Pallister LA 691 Paterson LA 792 Pauls LA 797 Pearce LA 767—9, LA 772—3, LA 774—5 Peters LA 730 Render LA 775 Robertson LA 758—9 Schiman LA 689, LA 691 Stecheson LA 679 Struthers LA 762—3 Tavares LA 793—4 Teel LA 716 Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Thompson, M.

LA 780—1 Trush LA 683—4 Wedel LA 713 Wiebe LA 801 Zaidman, B. LA 761, LA 763 Zaidman, H. LA 805—6 Amendments Clause 4 McIntosh LA 912; passed LA 913 Clause 18 McIntosh LA 914; passed LA 916 Clause 32 McIntosh LA 916; passed LA 917 Arbitration, matters not referable Cherpako LA 752 Duhamel LA 649 Friesen, H. LA 653, LA 654 Gelinas LA 765 Gendreau LA 734 Land LA 810 McIntosh LA 653 Minaker LA 783—4 Minish, K. LA 748 Munro LA 720 Thompson, M. LA 780 Arbitration board, oath of Thompson, M.

LA 779—80 Arbitration process Grafton LA 724 Hilliard LA 710 Render LA 804 Smith LA 803—4 Teel LA 715—6 Wedel LA 713 Arbitrator, role of Boisvert LA 674 Friesen, J. LA 672 LaRiviere LA 672 Paterson LA 792 Zaidman LA 762 Arbitrator, selection of Friesen, H. LA 653 39

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Goodridge LA 731 Peters LA 730 Render LA 731 Binding arbitration Lawrie LA 697—8 Robertson LA 758 Robson LA 692 Collective agreements –expiry dates Friesen, H.

LA 653 Watts LA 650 Collective bargaining Barker LA 656 Beaumont LA 726—8 Dyrkacz LA 663 Fritske LA 666 Gelinas LA 764—5 Green LA 647—8 Hilliard LA 709 Jonasson LA 680 Land LA 809 LaRiviere LA 670 McKnight LA 694—5 Santos LA 804—5 Smith LA 804—5 Teel LA 715 Wedel LA 712 Zaidman LA 761—2 Collective bargaining, notice to begin Hilliard LA 709—10 Munro LA 720 Conciliation Gelinas LA 765 Minaker LA 784 Pearce LA 771 Teel LA 716 Conciliation officer, remuneration of Friesen, H. LA 652 Consultations Boisvert LA 674 Cerilli LA 674 Dispute resolution Beaumont LA 728—9 Friesen, J.

LA 728 Land LA 810 MacLellan LA 790 Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Minaker LA 783 Pearce LA 769—70 Render LA 728 Thompson, M. LA 779 Education system –funding Beresford (for MacNeil) LA 824 Cerilli LA 695, LA 725 Dyrkacz LA 664, LA 666 Friesen, J. LA 682, LA 696, LA 705, LA 763, LA 813 Fritske LA 668 Grafton LA 723—4, LA 725 Jonasson LA 682 McGifford LA 690, LA 693, LA 717 McIntosh LA 665—6, LA 682 McKnight LA 695, LA 696 Mihychuk LA 668, LA 717, LA 725 Robson LA 693 Schiman LA 690 Struthers LA 807 Teel LA 717—8 Trush LA 684—5 Veldink LA 703—4, LA 705 Wedel LA 712—3 Wiens LA 763 Wilgosh LA 813 Zaidman, H.

LA 807—8 Employer's last offer McIntosh LA 695 McKnight LA 695 Watts LA 650—1 Fairness Goodridge LA 729 Final offer selection Friesen, J. LA 913 McIntosh LA 913 Grievances Cerilli LA 687, LA 714 Duhamel LA 651 Eliasson LA 687 Evans, Caroline LA 662 LaRiviere LA 671 Martin LA 660 McIntosh LA 651, LA 660, LA 662, LA 686—7, LA 695, LA 704 McKnight LA 695 40

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Pearce LA 772 Veldink LA 705 Wedel LA 714—5 Income inequities Friesen, H. LA 654—5 Friesen, J. LA 654—5 Independent schools, funding Gilles LA 814 Wilgosh LA 814 Information release Pearce LA 770—1 Intent McIntosh LA 812 Wilgosh LA 812—3 Labour relations, impact on Barker LA 655 Evans, Caroline LA 661 Friesen, H.

LA 654 LaRiviere LA 671 McIntosh LA 677, LA 685—6 Mihychuk LA 654 Stecheson LA 676—8 Trush LA 685 Labour Relations Act Gelinas LA 766 Laurendau LA 766 McIntosh LA 773—4 Pearce LA 774 Legal opinion Boisvert LA 675 Kowalski LA 675 Mediation Minish, K. LA 749 Render LA 717, LA 749, LA 762 Teel LA 717 Zaidman LA 762 Negotiations –time limits Fritske LA 667 MacLellan LA 789 Pearce LA 769 Peters LA 729—30 Schiman LA 689 Notice provisions Watts LA 650 Oath of office Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Friesen, J. LA 913 McIntosh LA 913—4 Obligation to act fairly Duhamel LA 649—50 Munro LA 719—20 Opening remarks Friesen, J.

LA 911—2 McIntosh LA 911 Parent Advisory Committee Kyle LA 707 Pupil -teacher ratio Pauls LA 797—8 Struthers LA 797—8 Reconsideration Friesen, J. LA 712 Hilliard LA 710, LA 712 Right to strike Grafton LA 725 McIntosh LA 724, LA 731 Peters LA 731 Salaries, impact on Ducharme LA 755 Friesen, J. LA 702 Grabowski LA 701—2 Isaak LA 793 Kowalski LA 792—3 McIntosh LA 701—2, LA 732 Minish, K. LA 748 Moore LA 732 Pallister LA 702 School divisions, impact on Cerilli LA 714 Wedel LA 713, LA 714 Schools, choice of Kyle LA 707—8 Teacher classification Doer LA 751 Minish, G. LA 750, LA 751 Teacher classifications Thompson, M.

LA 781 Teacher morale Barrett LA 796 Cerilli, A. LA 787 Cherpako LA 753, LA 754 Doer LA 749, LA 753, LA 787 41

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Schools Amendment–Cont. Friesen, J. LA 710—1 Fritske LA 667—8 Hinchliffe LA 777—8 Kowalski LA 754 Lawrie LA 698 McIntosh LA 778 Minish, K. LA 749 Pauls LA 797 Reimer LA 795 Tavares LA 794 Waroway LA 795—6 Wiebe LA 799—800 Zaidman, H. LA 806 Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 47) Access to personnel records Lipsett LA 386 Access to pupil records Friesen, H. LA 374 Green LA 372, LA 373 Laurendeau LA 373 McGifford LA 372 Watts LA 367 Access to schools/programs Friesen, H. LA 374—5 Friesen, J.

LA 375 Lipsett LA 384—5 Mihychuk LA 374—5 Tweed LA 375 Watts LA 367 Advisory councils Friesen, H. LA 374, LA 376 Green LA 368—9 McIntosh LA 375—6 Amendments Clause 6 Friesen, J. LA 599; defeated LA 600 Clause 8 Friesen, J. LA 601; ruled out of order LA 602 McIntosh LA 600; passed LA 600 LA 602; passed LA 602 Clause 10 Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 47)–Cont. Friesen, J. LA 609; defeated LA 609—10 LA 610; defeated LA 610 LA 610; defeated LA 611 LA 611; defeated LA 612 McIntosh LA 602; passed LA 602 LA 602; passed LA 603 LA 611; passed LA 611 Clause 14 Friesen, J.

LA 612; ruled out of order LA 612 Clause 16 McIntosh LA 612; withdrawn LA 613 LA 614; withdrawn LA 615 Appeal process McIntosh LA 605—6 Mihychuk LA 605—6 Auditors Beresford LA 574 Budget process Beresford LA 574 Deficit reduction Penner LA 370—1 Watts LA 367, LA 371 Legislative process Gillies LA 582 Ministerial authority Hammond LA 561 Parent Advisory Councils Cerilli LA 608 McIntosh LA 608 Parents and children Beresford LA 575 Privacy, guarantee of Beresford LA 576 McIntosh LA 575—6 Program assessment Cerilli LA 561—2 Enns LA 562—3 Hammond LA 561—3 Mihychuk LA 562 Program information Watts LA 367 42

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 47)–Cont. Pupil files Beresford LA 574 Cerilli LA 389 Lipsett LA 384, LA 387—90 McIntosh LA 388—9 Mihychuk LA 387—8 Responsibility of parents Friesen, J. LA 603—5 McIntosh LA 603—5, LA 606—7 Mihychuk LA 606—7 Right to attend school Beresford LA 575 Rights and responsibilities of parents/pupils Cerilli LA 373 Davies LA 568—9 Friesen, J.

LA 388, LA 568 Green LA 368, LA 373 Lipsett LA 385—6, LA 387, LA 388 Mihychuk LA 387 Rights of parents Gillies LA 581 Rights of pupil Beresford LA 575 Gillies LA 581—2 Kowalski LA 559 Stearns LA 589 Wiens LA 559 School boards, duties of Beresford LA 573—4 Friesen, H. LA 373, LA 374 Friesen, J. LA 372 Green LA 364—6, LA 371, LA 372 Mihychuk LA 371, LA 374 Schools, choice of Beresford LA 575 Standardized curriculum Hammond LA 561 Standards testing Davies LA 565, LA 567—8, LA 570 Friesen, J.

LA 564 Hammond LA 564—6 Kowalski LA 568 McIntosh LA 565, LA 567, LA 569—70 Transfer fees Beresford LA 573 Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 47)–Cont. Dyck LA 375 Friesen, H.

LA 373, LA 375 Watts LA 366—7 Transfer of pupil Hammond LA 561 Public Sector Compensation Disclosure Act (Bill 57) Accountability Atkins LA 1004—5 Barrett LA 1001 Grafton LA 996 Kelcey LA 989 Kelly LA 991 North LA 1007 Peloquin LA 1001 Santos LA 996, LA 1005 Stefanson LA 996 Amendments Clause 1 Barrett LA 1039; defeated LA 1040 Clause 2 Mackintosh LA 1041; defeated LA 1042 Stefanson LA 1040; passed LA 1041 Clause 9 Barrett LA 1042; defeated LA 1043 Clause 13 Barrett LA 1043; defeated LA 1043

Definitions –compensation Voss LA 1002 Disclosure period Stefanson LA 1002—3 Voss LA 1002—3 Grants/subsidies Barrett LA 990, LA 992—3, LA 996 Grafton LA 996 Kelcey LA 989—90 Kelly LA 993 Opening remarks 43

Index of Standing and Special Committees Public Sector Compensation Disclosure–Cont.

Barrett LA 1039 Stefanson LA 1038—9 Privacy, protection of Atkins LA 1004 Loney LA 1003—4 MacIntyre LA 998, LA 999—1000 Mackintosh LA 999, LA 1004 North LA 1004 Peloquin LA 1000, LA 1001 Santos LA 999, LA 1001 Salary threshold Kelcey LA 990 Kelly LA 991 Santos LA 990 Salary/wage comparisons Kelly LA 991—2, LA 993, LA 994 Mackintosh LA 993 Santos LA 994 Teaching profession Barrett LA 985, LA 995 Grafton LA 994—5 MacIntyre LA 986—8, LA 996—8 Martindale LA 1001 Peloquin LA 1000, LA 1001 Veldink LA 985 Young LA 986—7 Real Estate Brokers Amendment Act (Bill 69) Board members DeLeeuw LA 13 Kowalski LA 13 Palmer LA 14 Habitat for Humanity Kowalski LA 12 Palmer LA 12 Opening remarks Ernst LA 15 Selection process DeLeeuw LA 13 Kowalski LA 13 Palmer LA 13 Target area DeLeeuw LA 13 Kowalski LA 12 Palmer LA 12 Regional Health Authorities and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 49) Access to services McCrae MA 292—3 Sale MA 292 Accessibility Doerksen MA 163 Accountability Goodyear Whitely MA 186 Singh MA 216 Advisory councils Creith MA 170 Robinson, M.

MA 180 Amendments Clause 1 Chomiak MA 281; defeated MA 281 MA 282; defeated MA 283 Clause 2 Chomiak MA 289; defeated MA 289 McCrae MA 284; passed MA 285 Clause 3 Chomiak MA 287; defeated MA 289 Clause 5 McCrae MA 183; passed MA 184 Clause 7 Chomiak MA 293; defeated MA 294 Clause 8 Chomiak MA 294; withdrawn MA 295 Clause 9 Chomiak MA 295; defeated MA 297 Clause 10 Chomiak MA 297; withdrawn MA 298 Clause 14 Chomiak MA 184-5; defeated MA 185 Clause 19 Chomiak 44

Index of Standing and Special Committees Regional Health Authorities and–Cont.

MA 185; defeated MA 185—6 Clause 23 Chomiak MA 186; defeated MA 186 Clause 24 Chomiak MA 187; defeated MA 187 MA 187-8; defeated MA 188 Clause 25 Chomiak MA 188; defeated MA 188 Clause 30 Chomiak MA 189; defeated MA 189 Clause 38 Chomiak MA 189; defeated MA 190 Clause 51 Chomiak MA 190; defeated MA 191 Clause 54 Chomiak MA 191; defeated MA 191 Clause 62 Chomiak MA 192; defeated MA 193 McCrae MA 192; passed MA 192 Clause 63 McCrae MA 193-4; passed MA 195 Clause 64 Chomiak MA 196; defeated MA 197 Clause 69 McCrae MA 197; passed MA 197 Clause 74 Chomiak MA 198; defeated MA 199 McCrae MA 199; passed MA 199 Clause 75 Chomiak MA 199-200; defeated MA 200 Regional Health Authorities and–Cont.

Clause 76 -77 McCrae MA 201; passed MA 201 Clause 78 McCrae MA 201; passed MA 202 MA 202; passed MA 202 Clause 79 Chomiak MA 202; defeated MA 203 Clause 84 McCrae MA 204; defeated MA 205 Appeal process Robinson, M.

MA 179—80 Board of directors Chernecki MA 191 Chomiak MA 164 Doerksen MA 164 Kruger MA 266, MA 265 Minaker MA 251 Olfert MA 253 Board of directors –appointments Chomiak MA 176 Nicol MA 165 Potovsky -Beachell MA 171, MA 172, MA 174 Wiens MA 175—6 Wowchuk MA 174 Board of directors –elected Goodyear Whitely MA 187 Maxwell MA 205, MA 207 Mintz MA 200 Singh MA 215—6 Wowchuk MA 207 Canada Health Act Chomiak MA 284 Conner MA 212—3 Goodyear Whitely MA 187 Hanuschak MA 259 Kruger MA 264—5, MA 266 Lord MA 243—4, MA 245—6 Maxwell MA 205—6 McCrae MA 284 Olfert MA 254 Peters MA 210 45

Index of Standing and Special Committees Regional Health Authorities and–Cont. Praznik MA 259 Sale MA 242 Shapiro MA 240, MA 242 Singh MA 215 Charitable foundations Wiens MA 176 Commissioner, role of Audette MA 177 Doerksen MA 163 Shapiro MA 241 Community health centres Chernecki MA 191, MA 193 Chomiak MA 193 Lord MA 245 Peters MA 211 Poyser MA 221 Robinson, M.

MA 179 Sale MA 245 Community health services Chomiak MA 283 McCrae MA 283 Poyser MA 222 Consultations Chernecki MA 193 Chomiak MA 238, MA 180, MA 193, MA 201 Hiebert MA 238—9 Kruger MA 265 Maxwell MA 205 Mintz MA 201 Muswaggon MA 232—3 Penner MA 239, MA 201 Potovsky -Beachell MA 173 Robinson, M. MA 180—1 Consultations –rural Manitoba Chomiak MA 163—4, MA 166 Doerksen MA 162, MA 163—4 Nicol MA 166 Contracting out Audette MA 177—8 Chernecki MA 191 Chomiak MA 177 Doerksen MA 163 Singh MA 216 Core services Chomiak MA 280 Regional Health Authorities and–Cont.

Conner MA 213 Kruger MA 266 Laurendeau MA 266 McCrae MA 280 Potovsky -Beachell MA 171, MA 172 Deficits Chomiak MA 166 Nicol MA 165, MA 166

Definitions Goodyear Whitely MA 186

Definitions –health care provider Chomiak MA 280—1 McCrae MA 281

Definitions –holistic Singh MA 215

Definitions –pre-existing boards Chomiak MA 275—6, MA 278—9 McCrae MA 275—9 Penner MA 278 Sale MA 276—8 Deinsurance Chomiak MA 173 Potovsky -Beachell MA 173—4 Equity, province -wide Shapiro MA 240 Faith-based facilities Chomiak MA 170 Creith MA 169, MA 170 Robinson, M. MA 178 First Nations health authorities Chomiak MA 234 Lathlin MA 235—6 Muswaggon MA 232, MA 233—6 Funding Chomiak MA 166 Javier MA 269 Kruger MA 265 Maxwell MA 206 Nicol MA 166 Penner MA 269, MA 174—5 Peters MA 210 Potovsky -Beachell MA 174—5, MA 173 Shapiro MA 241 Health care provider council Goodyear Whitely MA 187—8 46

Index of Standing and Special Committees Regional Health Authorities and–Cont. Home care, impact on Chomiak MA 221, MA 219 Gerbasi MA 217—21 Penner MA 220 Information release LeBlanc MA 223 Labour adjustment strategy Chernecki MA 193 Chomiak MA 193 Labour relations Abraham MA 259—60 Barnabe MA 260—1 Chernecki MA 192 Chomiak MA 185, MA 196, MA 250 Christophe MA 248—51 Goodyear Whitely MA 188 Hilliard MA 194—6 Javier MA 268 Kruger MA 265 LeBlanc MA 224 Lord MA 244—5 Macdonald MA 203 McMahon MA 226—7 Minaker MA 252 Mintz MA 200 Olfert MA 254, MA 255—6 Peters MA 211 Praznik MA 250—1, MA 256 Robinson, M.

MA 180 Sale MA 255, MA 260 Sigurdson MA 183—5 Legal challenge Olfert MA 255 Sale MA 255 Mental health services Chomiak MA 214 Conner MA 213—4 Ministerial authority Chernecki MA 191 Chomiak MA 279 Goodyear Whitely MA 187 Maxwell MA 206 McCrae MA 280 Muswaggon MA 232 Robinson, M. MA 179 Regional Health Authorities and–Cont. Wiens MA 175 Needs assessmentss Kruger MA 265 Opening remarks Chomiak MA 274 McCrae MA 273—4 Physician resources Nicol MA 165, MA 167—8 Penner MA 167 Wowchuk MA 166—7

Preamble Singh MA 215 Private charter hospitals Chomiak MA 258 Hanuschak MA 257—8 Public awareness Abraham MA 260 Chomiak MA 260 Public health Chomiak MA 204 Lord MA 244 Macdonald MA 202—3, MA 204 Public health services Chomiak MA 291 McCrae MA 291—2 Regional health plans Potovsky -Beachell MA 172 Regulations Chomiak MA 173 Conner MA 213 Creith MA 169 Goodyear Whitely MA 186—7 Kruger MA 266 Minaker MA 251 Peters MA 210—1 Potovsky -Beachell MA 172, MA 173 Robinson, M. MA 179 Shapiro MA 240 Singh MA 215 Social services Kruger MA 265—6 Macdonald MA 203 Standards Chernecki MA 191 Conner MA 213 47

Index of Standing and Special Committees Regional Health Authorities and–Cont. Davidson Dick MA 189—90 Goodyear Whitely MA 187, MA 188, MA 189 Lathlin MA 189 User fees Barnabe MA 261, MA 262 Doerksen MA 162—3 Goodyear Whitely MA 188 Lord MA 245 Macdonald MA 203 Nicol MA 167 Olfert MA 254 Penner MA 262 Potovsky -Beachell MA 173 Robinson, M.

MA 180 Sale MA 245 Shapiro MA 240—1 Sigurdson MA 182 Singh MA 216 Wowchuk MA 167 Volunteerism, impact on Penner MA 199 Sweatman MA 198—9 Winnipeg health authority Chomiak MA 212, MA 252, MA 280 Davidson Dick MA 188 McCrae MA 280 Minaker MA 252 Wiktorowicz MA 212 Women, impact on Maxwell MA 205 Peters MA 209—10, MA 211—2 Wowchuk MA 211—2 Remembrance Day Amendment Act and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 50) Amendments Clause 7 Toews IR 255; passed IR 257 Clause 8 Toews IR 260; passed IR 266 Clause 9 Toews IR 266; passed IR 266 Remembrance Day Amendment–Cont.

Consultations Anderson Checkley IR 188 Wowchuk ir 188 Employees' right to refuse work Anderson Checkley IR 188 Toews IR 188 Rules of the House Budget address Remnant RH 15 Budget motion, amendments to Ernst RH 32 Lamoureux RH 32 Mackintosh RH 32 Committees, Standing and Special Ernst RH 26 Martindale RH 25—6 Remnant RH 25 Daily routine Remnant RH 5—6 Emergency debate Ernst RH 33 Mackintosh RH 33 Extraordinary circumstances Ashton RH 4—5 Ernst RH 4 Remnant RH 4 Friday sittings Martindale RH 5 Remnant RH 5 Government bills Remnant RH 26 Government business Ernst RH 29 Martindale RH 30 Grievance, matters of Remnant RH 8—9 Members’ statements Ashton RH 7—8 Barrett RH 7 Dacquay RH 7 Ernst RH 6 Lamoureux RH 6—8, RH 30 Martindale RH 30 McIntosh RH 7 48

Index of Standing and Special Committees Rules of the House–Cont.

Remnant RH 6 Sveinson RH 8 Opposition Day Motions Ernst RH 31 Lamoureux RH 31 Martindale RH 31 Opposition days Ashton RH 9—10, RH 11—4 Barrett RH 10—1, RH 13 Ernst RH 9, RH 11, RH 12—3 Lamoureux RH 9, RH 11 Laurendeau RH 11, RH 14 Martindale RH 12 McIntosh RH 10 Remnant RH 9—10, RH 12, RH 13—4, RH 13—5 Order Paper Remnant RH 15—6 Orders not take up Remnant RH 32 Private Members' Business Ashton RH 19, RH 21, RH 36—40 Barrett RH 18, RH 20 Dacquay RH 17—8, RH 38 Ernst RH 18—20, RH 23—4, RH 35—6, RH 39, RH 42 Lamoureux RH 17, RH 21—4, RH 37 Mackintosh RH 34—6, RH 41—2 Martindale RH 17, RH 22—4 Remnant RH 5, RH 6, RH 16—24 Sitting hours Ashton RH 5 Ernst RH 5 Lamoureux RH 5 Remnant RH 5 Spring/fall sittings Ashton RH 3, RH 44 Dacquay RH 44 Ernst RH 2—3, RH 28—9, RH 43—5 Mackintosh RH 28—9 Martindale RH 2—3, RH 28 Remnant RH 2 Supply, Committee of Ernst RH 25 Martindale RH 25 Remnant RH 15, RH 24—5 Rules of the House–Cont.

Urgent Public Important, Matters of Remnant RH 15 Whole House, Committee of the Remnant RH 24 Salvation Army Catherine Booth Bible College Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 300) Opening remarks Laurendeau LA 31—2 Perry LA 31 Securities Amendment Act (Bill 46) Amendments Clause 5 Ernst LA 312; passed LA 312 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 36) Adequate income Flett, M. LA 107—8 Flett, P. LA 107 Frankel LA 45, LA 48 Johannson, J.

LA 40, LA 42, LA 43 Kruger LA 47 Lathlin LA 48 Martindale LA 42, LA 43 Advisory council on poverty Frankel LA 46 Johannson, J LA 40—1 Affirmative Action Bruce LA 94 Amalgamation –City of Winnipeg Churchill LA 123 King LA 66—8 Martindale LA 58, LA 67, LA 72, MA 177—82 Mitchelson MA 177—81 Moist LA 69—70, LA 72 Murray LA 58 Riley LA 61 Sale LA 67—8 Seymour LA 76 Amendments Clause 3 Martindale 49

Index of Standing and Special Committees Social Allowances Amendment–Cont. MA 169; defeated MA 169 Clause 5 Martindale MA 169-70; ruled out of order MA 171 Clause 9 Martindale MA 171; ruled out of order MA 172 Clause 16 Martindale MA 177; defeated MA 177 Clause 30 Mitchelson MA 182; defeated MA 182 Appeal process Cote LA 113 Frankel LA 46 Johannson, J LA 40 Lambier LA 74—5 Martindale LA 74, LA 113 Assets Johannson, J.

LA 41 Partanen LA 50 Benefit levels Forrest LA 52 Frankel LA 45—6 Johannson, J LA 41, LA 42 Martindale LA 42 Nicoles LA 127—8 Benefit reduction Lambier LA 72—3 Benefits –daily breakdown Ansell LA 44 Martindale LA 44 Canada Assistance Plan Norberg LA 81—2 Charter of Rights and Freedoms Martindale LA 79 Price LA 79 Child care initiatives Barr LA 94 Martindale LA 94 Children, impact on Martindale LA 63 Riley LA 63 Consultations Social Allowances Amendment–Cont.

Martindale LA 103—4 Simbandumwe LA 104 Crime rate, impact on Despatis LA 89—90 Kowalski LA 109 Lavoie LA 109 Sale LA 89 Discrimination Frankel LA 46 Education programs McGifford LA 104 Simbandumwe LA 105 Employment assistance Finlay LA 59 Kruger LA 47—8 Martindale LA 63 McGifford LA 63 Riley LA 61, LA 62, LA 63 Employment obligations Ansell LA 44—5 Bleich LA 64—6 Chorney LA 130—1 Churchill LA 122—3 Graham LA 110—1 Johannson, C.

LA 93 King LA 68—9 Lambier LA 72 Lavoie LA 106 Loewen LA 82—3, LA 84—5 Martindale LA 66, LA 79, LA 84, LA 91, MA 175—7 McGifford LA 45, LA 81, LA 130 Mitchelson MA 175—7 Moist LA 71 Naismith LA 120—1 Nicoles LA 128 Olson LA 91—2 Pankiw LA 117—8 Price LA 78—9, LA 81 Sale LA 44, LA 65, LA 68—9, LA 71 Sale, I. LA 121 Seymour LA 76 Sutherland LA 85—6 Faith organizations Dyck LA 109 Lavoie LA 109 50

Index of Standing and Special Committees Social Allowances Amendment–Cont. Food allowance Finlay LA 60—1 Partanen LA 50 Food banks Martindale LA 51, LA 122 Partanen LA 51—2 Sale, I.

LA 122 Fraud line Forrest LA 52, LA 54 Martindale LA 54 GST refunds Martindale LA 51 Partanen LA 51 Health, impact on Ellman LA 113—6 McGifford LA 115—6 Health services Blue LA 75 Chorney LA 129—30, LA 131 Finlay LA 59, LA 60 Martindale LA 75, LA 137 McGifford LA 131 Pankiw LA 117 Partanen LA 50 Riley LA 62 Vieno LA 135—8 Housing Lambier LA 73 Legal challenge Martindale LA 79 Price LA 79—80 Maintenance support McGifford LA 52 Minimum wage Flett, M. LA 109 Flett, P.

LA 109 Martindale LA 109 Moving expenses Chorney LA 131 McGifford LA 131 Opening remarks Martindale MA 163—8 Mitchelson MA 162—3, MA 168—9 Penalties Forrest LA 52 Social Allowances Amendment–Cont. Frankel LA 48—9 Martindale LA 48 Poverty rate, impact on Martindale LA 121—2 Naismith LA 122 Sale, I. LA 121 Seniors, impact on McGifford LA 119 Pankiw LA 118—9 Sale, I. LA 118 Service agreement Barrett MA 172—5 Martindale MA 173—5 Mitchelson MA 173—5 Shelter allowance Partanen LA 49—50 Special needs Johannson, J.

LA 41—2 Taking Charge! program Martindale LA 63, LA 64 Riley LA 63 Tax credit –volunteer work Martindale LA 86 Sutherland LA 86—7 Telephone allowance Sale LA 77 Seymour LA 77 Unemployment rate Forrest LA 52 Sale LA 77 Seymour LA 78 Work/training program Johannson, J LA 40, LA 42 Statute Law Amendment Act, 1996 (Bill 61) Opening remarks Vodrey LA 941 Tourism and Recreation Amendment Act (Bill 15) Administration Downey ED 41 Sale ED 40—1 Opening remarks Downey ED 40 51

Index of Standing and Special Committees University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 48) Board of governors Ferguson LA 827—8, LA 829—30 Jansen LA 829 Lines LA 857—8, LA 859—60 McGifford LA 829, LA 837, LA 839—40, LA 849 McIntosh LA 849—50, LA 858 Mihychuk LA 829, LA 836, LA 858, LA 859—60 Szathmary LA 835—6, LA 837 Toews LA 859 Tudiver LA 847—8, LA 849—50 Turner LA 838—40 Mandatory retirement Doer LA 818—9 Ferguson LA 828—9 Jansen LA 830 Lines LA 858—9 Lipsett LA 817—9 McIntosh LA 858—9 Mihychuk LA 830, LA 837, LA 838, LA 858 Render LA 840 Szathmary LA 836, LA 837 Tudiver LA 848 Turner LA 838, LA 840 Opening remarks McIntosh LA 910 Mihychuk LA 911 Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd.

Falcon Lake Golf Course Boyle ED 50—1 Driedger ED 49—50 Sale ED 48—52 Sparrow ED 51—2 Sveinson ED 54 Financial statement Driedger ED 47—8, ED 52 Sale ED 47—8, ED 52—4 Sparrow ED 47 Hecla Golf Course Sale ED 48 Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd.–Cont. Sparrow ED 48 Opening remarks Driedger ED 45—6 Sale ED 46 Property maintenance Driedger ED 54—6 Evans, C.

ED 54—6 Sparrow ED 55 Veterinary Science Scholarship Fund Amendment Act (Bill 6) Enns AG 34 Wowchuk AG 34 Winnipeg Commodity Exchange Act (Bill 29) Amendments Clause 1 Ernst LA 309; passed LA 309 Clause 5 Ernst LA 309; passed LA 309 Clause 7 Ernst LA 310; passed LA 310 Clause 9 Ernst LA 310; passed LA 310 Winnipeg Stock Exchange Act (Bill 28) Amendments Clause 11 Ernst LA 309; passed LA 309 York Factory First Nation Northern Flood Implementation Agreement Act (Bill 52) Amendments Clause 2 Praznik ED 96; ED 97 See also Northern flood agreements 52

Committee Agriculture Economic Development Industrial Relations Law Amendments Municipal Affairs Privileges and Elections Public Accounts Appendices APPENDIX A Election of Chairpersons Standing and Special Committees Chairperson Mr. Jack Penner Mr. Mike Radcliffe Mr. Peter Dyck Mr. Mike Radcliffe Mr. David Newman Mr. Mervin Tweed Mr. Gerry McAlpine Mr. Marcel Laurendeau Mr. Jack Penner Mr. Mike Radcliffe Mr. Conrad Santos Public Utilities and Natural Resources Mr. Frank Pitura Mr. Jack Penner Rules of the House Hon. Louise M.

Dacquay 53 Election Date October 1, 1 996 September 20, 1996 September 27, 1 996 October 24, 1 996 June 3, 1996 September 25, 1996 October 1 7, 1 996 October 22, 1996 June 4, 1996 November 5, 1996 April 19, 1996 September 25, 1996 November 2, 1996 February 22, 1 996

Appendices APPENDIX B Public Presenters/Crown Corporation Staff Agricultural Credit Corporation Amendment Act (Billl4) Fegol, Ken Private Citizen Ambulance Services Amendment Act (Bi1137) Forsman, Dwayne Animal Care Act (Bill 70) Boutet Nazare, Susan Bums, Vicki Langille, Dale Pearson, James Wall, Debbie Youngdahl, Donna Youngman, John Manitoba Prehospital Professions Association Private Citizen The Winnipeg Humane Society Private Citizen People Acting for Animal Liberation Manitoba Animal Alliance Manitoba Farm Animal Council The Winnipeg Humane Society Boxing and Wresting Commission Amendment Act (Bill 66) Holliday, Bob World Wrestling Federation Written submissions Boroditsky, Martin Krushel, Audrey Charleswood Bridge Facilitation Act (Billl6) Moist, Paul Chiropodists Amendment Act (BillS) Colledge, Martin Private Citizen � Group Against' Pornography Canadian Union of Public Emplo yees, Local 500 Manitoba Association of Chiropodists City of Winnipeg Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill44) Angus, John City of Winnipeg, St.

Norbert Ward Written submission The Provincial Council of Women of Manitoba and The Council of Women of Winnipeg Civil Service Superannuation Amendment, Public Servants Insurance Amendment and Teachers' Pensions Amendment Act (Bill 51) Pearce, Ken Manitoba Teachers' Society Communities Economic Development Fund Wakeling, Gordon Construction Industry Wages Amendment Act (Bill 73) General Manager and Chief Executive Officer Bova, Jo.e Private Citizen Cook, Ted Winnipeg Construction Association 54

Appendices Cumming, Jack· Dauphinais, Terry Emberley, Kenneth Evans, Mike Gallos, Ed Harrison, David Hilliard, Rob Lorenc, Chris Martin, Dave Martin, Patrick Norman, Lance Tesarski, Dave Wightman, Peter Wright, Fred Construction Association of Rural Manitoba, In c. International Union of Elevator Constructors, Local 102 Private Citizen Private Citizen Master Roofing Ltd.

Winnipeg Construction Association Manitoba Federation of Labour Manitoba Heavy Co nstruction Association Manitoba Building and Con struction Trades Council Carpenters Union Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Manitoba Council of the Canadian Federation of Labour Construction Labour Relations Association of Manitoba Private Citizen Contaminated Sites Remediation and Consequential Amendments Act (Bi1134) Norman, Lance Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Ryall, Bill Union of Manitoba Municipalities Stefaniuk, John Canadian Bankers' Association Council on Post-Secondary Education Act (Bill32) Amirault, Michael Anderson, C.

Dennis Arrell, Douglas Babcock, Tim Bailey, Donald Barlow, Noreen Bashforth, Gerard Blaikie, Erik Blair, Danny Booth, Tom Bruneau, William Byard, Ed Cameron, Alistair Carlyle, Elizabeth Chernomas, Robert Clark, Jim Daniels, Bruce De Long, Linwood Donatelli, Joseph Dooley, Chris Eichhorst, William 55 University of Manitoba Student Action Coalition President and Vice -Chancellor and Chair of Senate, Brandon University Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Brandon University Students Union Assiniboine Community College, Brandon Brandon University Students Union Private Citizen Private Citizen Canadian Association of University Teachers University Winnipeg Senate Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Organization of Faculty Associations Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Choices Chancellor, Church -R elated Colleges of Manitoba

Evans, Murray Ferguson, Earle Forest, Jim Fulton, Keith- Louise Gabbert, Mark Gaudet, Rolland Giles, Robin Glendinning, Robert Golden, Mark Hanen, Marsha Heller, Henry Herda, Cheryl Holborn, Stephen Jansen, Sylvia Janzen, Ed Johannson, Elizabeth Kaufman, W.

Reuben Kelcey, Brian Koolage, William Kushneryk, Susan Layman, Lewis Laznicka , Sarka Leo, Christopher Levin, Elliot Linek, Vaclav Lines, Trevor Lipsett, Edward Malabar, Sara Markham, David Martin, William Mills, Allen Murray, Colin Nembhard, Jennifer Nembhard, Kemlin Noble, Richard Orlandini, Richard Phillips, Paul Pruitt, William Reitano, Caterina Ross, Maggie Seymour, William Shaw, Michael Silver, Jim Appendices 56 Private Citizen University of Manitoba Faculty Association Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Physics Department, Brandon University, Vice- President of the Faculty Association Private Citizen Private Citizen Council ofPr esidents of Universities in Manitoba Private Citizen Red River Community College Students' Association Private Citizen University of Manitoba Faculty Association Private Citizen Private Citizen Association of Academic Staff, University of Alberta Manitoba Taxpayers Association Private Citizen University of Wjnnipeg Students' Association Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen University of Manitoba Students' Union Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Manitoba Young New Democrats Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Lesbian, Gay & Bisexual Collective Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen

Appendices Slater, Shannon Slater, Shannon Stearns, Brent Stevens, Wesley M.

Sullivan, Don Suss, Jennifer Szathmary, EmOke Taylor, Blake Tudiver, Neil Turner, Alden Whiteley, John Wiebe, Jason Wright, Claudia Written submissions Carlyle, Elizabeth Hanen, Marsha Lipsett, Edward Mallea, John Turner, Alden Canadian Federation of Students (Manitoba) Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen University of Manitoba Private Citizen Private Citizen University of Winnipeg Faculty Association Private Citizen University of Manitoba Students' Union Private Citizen Canadian Federation of Students (Manitoba) Council of Presidents of Universities in Manitoba Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Private Citizen University of Winnipeg Faculty Association Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Amendment Act (Bill19) Written submission Union of Manitoba Municipalities Education Administration Amendment Act (Bill33) Beresford, Diane Emberley, Kenneth Gillies, Dee Green, Betty Hammond, Barry Hanuschak, Ben Stearns, Candice Weins, John Zaidman, Ben Written submissions Lipsett, Edward Manitoba Teachers' Society Private Citizen Coalition Against Standard Testing Manitoba Association of School Trustees Choices Private Citizen Private Citizen Seven Oaks School Division Seven Oaks School Division Private Citizen Farm Lands Ownership Amendment, Real Property Amendment and Registry Act (Bill 68) Written Submis sion Heibert, Eduard Private Citizen Gaming Control and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 76) Brant, David Four Winds Founders Chernichan, Doug Manitoba Hotel Association Desjardins, Larry Private Citizen Tubovsky, Sheldon Winnipeg Bingo and Gaming Magazine 57

Government Essential Services Act (Billl7) Hilliard, Rob Holmes, Catherine Olfert, Peter Sinclair, John Tesarski, Dave Appendices Manitoba Federation of Labour Tache Family Association, Tache Nursing Centre Manitoba Government Employees' Union Manitoba Health Organizations Canadian Federation of Labour Judicial Compensation Committee, Report and Recommendations of Collerman, Howard Judge, Provincial Court Kopstein, Robert Manitoba Provincial Judges Association Sinclair, Murray Manitoba Provincial Judges Association Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 26) Anderson, George Beresford, Diane Bjornson, Randy Borger, Alan Jr.

Burreii,Buffy Christophe, Bernard Chudy, Claudette Cumming, Reg Desjarlais, Bob Ducharme, Theresa Emberley, Kenneth Gagne, Gill Gardner, William F. Jr.

Garofalo, Cindy Gonick, Cy Grant, Heather Green, Sidney Hancharyk, Maureen Harris, George Hickes, Chris Hiebert, Eduard Hilliard, Rob Hillis, Keith Huber, Heinrich Hunt, Brian Javier, Mario Joyce, Gerald Kelly, Dan Mackling, AI Maldonado, Jorge Martin, Dave 58 Public Service Alliance of Canada, Union of Taxation Employees, Local 50021 Manitoba Teachers' Society Lakeshore Teachers' Association Private Citizen Private Citizen United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 832 Private Citizen Canadian Auto Workers, Local 2224 United Steelworkers of America, Local 6166 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce Private Citizen Private Citizen Winnipeg Labour Council Private Citizen Manitoba Nurses' Union Private Citizen Souris Valley Teachers' Association Private Citizen Manitoba Federation of Labour Private Citizen Private Citizen United Steelworkers of America Private Citizen Private Citizen Canadian Federaton oflndependent Business Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Building and Construction Trades Council

Martin, Patrick Martin, Ross Moist, Paul Nickel, Ken Nonnan, Lance Olfert, Peter Patterson, Greg Rankin, Darrell Ryan, Carolyn Sahan, Mark Samyn, Jack Stecher, Caroline Stevens, Bob Taylor, Iris Tesarski, Dave Thomas, Frank Timlick, Brian Trottier, Philippe Vrsnik, Victor Walton, Bryan Ziegler, Robert Written submissions Campbell, Yvonne Finkel, Allan Lorenc, Chris Nordman, Grant Silver, Jim Triplett, John Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 60) Neufeld, John Appendices United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, Local 343 Brandon & District Labour Council Canadian Union of Public Employees, Manitoba Private Citizen Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Manitoba Government Employees' Union Private Citizen Communist Part of Canada-Manitoba Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Restaurant and Foodservices Associatio n Private Citizen Manitoba Council of the Canadian Federation of Labour Manitoba Building and Cons truction Trades Council Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Taxpayers Association Canadian Council of Grocery Distributors-Canada Safe way Private Citizen Public Service Alliance of Canada, Local 50021 Manitoba Fashion Institute Manitoba Heavy Construction Association Assiniboia Chamber of Commerce Choices Teachers for Excellence in Education Law Society of Manitoba Livestock Industry Divers ification and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 31) Abra, Douglas Manitoba Veterinary Medical Association Burns, Vicki The Winnipeg Humane Society Hughes, Tracy Private Citizen Mentz, Ronald Manitoba Veterinary Medical Association Pearson, James People Acting for Animal Liberation Rudley, John Private Citizen Stott, Gary Manitoba Elk Growers' Association Taylor, Kelly Private Citizen Whitford, Brion Keeseekoowenin First Nation 59

Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board Brennan, Robert Mc Callum, John Appendices Manitoba Investment Pool Authority Act (Bill 56) Mauws, Jerome Zimberg, Rochelle Manitoba Mineral Resources Ltd.

Clarke, James Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Zacharias, Jack President and Chief Executive Officer, Manitoba Hydro Chairman, Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board Union of Manitoba Municipalities Manitoba Association of Urban Municipalities Chairman of the Board Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Manitoba Public Insurance Corpora tion Amendment Act (Bill 4) Gagnon, Nap Private Citizen Manitoba Telephone System Fraser, Bill Stefanson, Tom President and Chief Executive Officer, Manitoba Telephone System Chairman of the Board, Manitoba Telephone System Manitoba Telephone System Reorganiza tion and Consequential Amendments Act (Bi1167) Aasland, Kemiel Private Citizen Altemeyer, Jean Private Citizen Altemeyer, Rob Private Citizen Anderson, Grant Private Citizen Ansell, Donna Private Citizen Amason, Arnie Private Citizen Barker, Tom Private Citizen Barr, Kristine Private Citizen Beatty, Ken Private Citizen Beaudry, Marc Private Citizen Benson, Julian Secretary to Treasury Board Blanco, Shelly Private Citizen Block, Jeanette Private Citizen Block, Sam Private Citizen Blomquist, James Private Citizen Brauer, Oskar Private Citizen Brick, Marilyn Private Citizen Brown, Bernard Private Citizen Bukoski, Lisa Private Citizen Burgess, Jim Private Citizen Burrows, Sel Private Citizen Byhre, Edith Private Citizen 60

Cain, Holly Cl:lmeron, Susan Campbell, Bruce Cardosa, John Carlyle, Elizabeth Cerilli, Albert Cherpako, Gail Clune, Emile Clune, Katherine Coles, Teresa Cote, Eric Curtis, Philip Dilay, Richard Dolenuk, Andrew Dooley , Chris Ducharme, Theresa Dudgeon, Roy Duncan, Glen and Noreen Eigenkind, Heidi Eliason, Magnus Emberley , Kenneth Espey, Sean Fainman, Fagie Farley, Sylvia Flynn, Peter Forrest, Michelle Fricke, Yutta Fritz, Rod Frolick, Anna Frolick, Diane Gaffray, Valerie Geisel, Lynne Goddard, William R. Golden , Mark Gooding, Robert N.

Grabows ki, AJJen Grabow ski, Winnie Graham, Paul Gretsinger, Connie Hadfield, Maggie Hales, Bill Hallick, Glen Hammond, Barry Harris, George Appendices 61 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Federation of Union Retirees Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Choices People in Equal Participation Inc. Private Citizen Private Citizens Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Federation of Labour St.

Matthew's Maryland Community Ministry Private Citizen Private Citizen International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Loca1 435 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Com munications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada, Local 55 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen

Hartle, Ellen Hartle, Roy Hawkins, Beverly Henry, Edie Hewitt-Smith, Mary Hickerson, William J. Hiebert, Eduard Hiebert, Peter Hiebert, Werner Holle, Peter Hooper, Jason Hrynyk, Suzanne Hudson, Peter Jacks, Eli Jacob, John Johannson, Catharine Johannson, Catharine Johannson, Elizabeth Johannson, Joan Jones, Esyllt Keenan, Jany Keenan, Jerry Keenan, Mike Kelly, Dan Kowalski, Anthony Laser, Sig Leochko, Dave Lord, Shirley Lowe, Jeffrey Lucas, Brian Mac Donald, T.

Mac Kay, Bruce Mac Kinnon, Shauna Mackling, AI Malabar, Sara Mallea, Paula Markham, David Marshall, George Martin, Bill Martin, Ross Martz, Carl Maruntz, Debbie Masse, Carol Mc Clelland, Audrey Mc Gonigal, Marilyn Appendices 62 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Prairie Centre Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Young New Democrats Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Canadian F �deration oflndependent Business Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Save Our Telephone System Private Citizen Private Citizen Canadian Mental Health Association Brandon & District Labour Council, CLC Private Citizen Comm unications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada, Local 55 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen

McGregor, Betty McLachlan, Jack McWilliams, Bob Meronek, Brian Miller, Kevin Milne, Kim Minish, Erin Minish, Garth Minish, Karen Morrow-Litke, Chris Murray, Colin Ndayumvire, Marceline Nembhard, Kemlin Nestruck, Shane Nicol, John Norman, Lance Novak, Thomas Nyhof, David Odium, Bruce Olson, Victor Orlikow, David Orton, Heather Owen, Martha Pankiw, Mary Pauls, Brenda Pilano, Lori Plummer, Dave Rebeck, Kevin Reddy, Nalini Regehr, William Reske, Henry Riley, Pauline Robins, Harle Robson, Ian Robson, John Roman, Roy Romphf, Rob Rudiak, Ron Saleski, Heinz Samyn, Jack Sayeau, Tim Scarcella, Brenda Schellenberg, Harry Schultz, Herb Seymour, William Appendices 63 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Retired Employees ofMTS, TEAM and IDEW Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Union of Manitoba Municipalities Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Manitoba Oblate Justice and Peace Committee International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local435 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Society of Seniors Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Canadian Union of Public Employees Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoa Action Committee on the Status of Women Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen

Sharpe, William Shiaro, Bud Shuster, Harold Silver, Jim Simbandumwe, Angeline Simbandumwe, Louise Slater, Shannon Smith, Murray Sokal, Alexis Sokoloff, Ben Stadfield, Carol Steur, Thomas Stieffenhofer, Katharina Still, Jim Strutt, Shirley Sullivan, Don Tait, Chris Tait, Fred Taylor, Iris Teffi, Bruce Tibelius, Klaus Trottier, Phillippe Venema, Grace Vieno, Marlene Vorst, Jesse Wasylycia -Leis, Judy Webb, Steve Welfley, Michael Wiens, John Wilson, Jean Yaffe, Richard Yeo, Marion Written submissions Chanas, Winnie M. Friesen, Rosemary Goddard, William R.

Hadfield, Maggie Henry, Kevin Hiebert, Eduard National Farmers Union, Region 5 Olson, Victor Pankiw, Mary Schultz, Herb Shiaro, Bud Mallea, Paula Appendices 64 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Legislative Counsel Private Citizen National Farmers Union Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citi�n� Manitoba Network for Mental Health Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Counsel to the Province Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Comm unications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada, Local 55 Private Citizen Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Society of Seniors Private Citizen Private Citizen Save Our Telephone System

Appendices Martin, Ross Nicol, John Owen, Martha Robinson, Jasper and family Rudiak, Ron Sharpe, William Medical Amendment Act (Bill 7) Abra, Doug Municipal and Various Acts Amendment Ad (Bill 54) Angus, John Borotsik, Rick Braun, Clarence Fleming, Elizabeth Frey, Ray Garlich, Carolyn Giesbrecht, Evelyn Gluska, Leonard Holme, Ken Hrabarchuk, Mary Johnson, Larry Murray, Glen Nicol, John Sanders, David Summerlus, Bill Sutherland, David Ternette, Nick Vrsnik, Victor Wasylowski, Garry Wright, Diane Y akielashek, Sylvester Zimberg, Rochelle Written submissions Manitoba Municipal Administrators Association Town of Selkirk Brandon & District Labour Council, CLC Union of Manitoba Municipalities Private Citizen Private Citizens Private Citizen Private Citizen College of Physicians and Surgeons of Manitoba City of Winnipeg Councillor (St.

Norbert Ward) City of Brandon Town ofNiverville Provincial Council of Women of Manitoba Council of the Local Government District of Park Council of Women of Winnipeg Unincorporated Village District of Landmark Local Government District of Consol Unincorporated Village District of Grunthal Unincorporated Village District of Landmark Unincorporated Village District of Cranberry Portage ! ?

City of Winnipeg Councillor (Fort Rouge Ward) Union of Manitoba Municipalities Colliers Pratt McGarry Canadian ·union of Public Employees, Manitoba Division Unincorporated Village District of Landmark Private Citizen Manitoba Taxpayers Association Local Government District of Armstrong Tache Ratepayers Association Council of the Local Government District of Park Manitoba Association of Urban Municipalities Municipal Assessment Amendment and Assessment Validation Act (Bill2) Chappell, Charles Private Citizen Eadie, Jae City of Winnipeg Norman, Lance Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Prentice, Barry University of Manitoba Transport Institute Sanders, David Colliers Pratt McGarry Steek, Garth City of Winnipeg 65

Appendices Whitehill, Guy Centra Gas Manitoba Inc. Municipal Assessment Amendment, City of Winnipeg, Amendment and Assessment Validation Act (Bill43) Baldwin, Warren Chappell, Charles Diner, Joe Dupont, Henri Eadie, Jae Frohlinger, Thomas Kelly, Dan Khan, M.S. Mercury, Michael Moist, Paul Nelson, Jack Nicol, John Norman, Lance Olyniuk, Rhine Prentice, Barry Sanders, David Smith, Don Steele, 0.

William Steek, Garth Weind, Richard Wong, Ken Zacharopoulos, Ike Written submissions City of Brandon Union of Manitoba Municipalities Natural Products Marketing Amendment Act (Bill 77) Private Citizen Private Citizen Aronovitch and Leipsic Ltd. Richard Realty Advisors Inc.

City of Winnipeg Private Citizen Canadian Federation oflndependent Business Westcan Property Tax Consultants Private Citizen Local 500, Canadian Union of Public Employees Professional Property Managers Association Union of Manitoba Municipalities Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Canadian National Railways Company University of Manitoba Transport Institute Colliers Pratt Mc Garry Private Citizen Private Citizen City of Winnipeg Canadian (Jnion of Public Employees The Hong Kong -Canada Business Association Canadian Pacific Railway Van Ryssel, Neil Manitoba Milk Producers Nelson House First Nation Northern Flood Implementation Agreement Act (Bill 53) Lemieux, Valerie Matthews Legal Counsel Moody , Marcel Director, Nelson House Trust Office Primrose, Jerry Chief North Portage Development Corporation, operating as The Forks North Portage Partnership Keller, Ernst Chairman of the Board Smith, Kent President and Chief Executive Officer Steiman, Gary Board Member Parental Responsibility Act (Bill 58) Clark, Jim 66 Private Citizen

Dyck, Rosella Hart, Glynis Hart Lehman, Victoria McConnick, Nonna Mirochnick, Marvin Written submission Wookey, Russ Pharmaceutical Amendment Act (BUilO) Chemecki, Vera Hancharyk, Maureen Public Accounts Johnson, Warren Ricard, Nonnan Public Schools Amendment Act (Bill 47) Barker, Tom Beresford, Diane Davies, Derwyn Emberley, Kenneth Friesen, Howard Gillies, Dee Green, Betty Hammond, Barry Lipsett, Edward Stearns, Candice Watts, Betty Ann Weins, John Zaidman, Ben Written submissions Klassen, Ed Lipsett, Edward Public Schools Amendment Act (2) (Bill 72) Barker, Cordell Beaumont, Jean Boisvert, Aurele Cerilli, Albert Cherpako, Gail Dixon, Bob Duchanne, Theresa Duhamel, Carolyn Dyrkacz, Linda Eliasson, Gail Evans, Caroline Appendices 67 Coalition of Custodial Parents of Manitoba Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Private Citizen Coalition of Custodial Parents of Manitoba Private Citizen Private Citizen Manitoba Nurses' Union Private Citizen Acting Provincial Auditor Director of Value for Audits Private Citizen Manitoba Teachers' Society Private Citizen Private Citizen Garden Valley School Division No. 26 Coalition Against Stapdard Testing Manitoba Association of School Trustees Choices Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Private Citizen Manitoba Association of School Trustees Seven Oaks School Division Seven Oaks School Division Manitoba Association of School Business officials Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Pine Creek Teachers' Association Manitoba Association of School Superintendents Francophone School Division Manitoba Federation of Union Retirees Private Citizen Private Citizen People in Equal Participation Inc.

Manitob

Document details

Collection	Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)
Citation	36th 2nd committees committee36th 2nd
Type	hansard
Volume / chapter	36th 2nd committees committee36th 2nd.pdf
Language	en
Format	pdf
Source	PROVINCIAL
Identifier	7cf263ec92272d32b62fe53f28de70b6cd8ec004

Source file is stored in the law ingest library (pdf).