Manitoba Hansard — 1 June 2026 (Sitting 64, 43rd Legislature, 3rd Session)

43-3-64

Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)

Third Session – Forty-Third Legislature of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES and PROCEEDINGS Official Report (Hansard) Published under the authority of The Honourable Tom Lindsey Speaker Vol. LXXX No. 64 – 1:30 p.m., Monday, June 1, 2026 ISSN 0542-5492

MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Forty-Third Legislature Member Constituency Political Affiliation ASAGWARA, Uzoma, Hon. Union Station NDP BALCAEN, Wayne Brandon West PC BEREZA, Jeff Portage la Prairie PC BLASHKO, Tyler Lagimodière NDP BRAR, Diljeet Burrows NDP BUSHIE, Ian, Hon. Keewatinook NDP BYRAM, Jodie Agassiz PC CABLE, Renée, Hon. Southdale NDP CHEN, Jennifer Fort Richmond NDP COMPTON, Carla Tuxedo NDP COOK, Kathleen Roblin PC CORBETT, Shannon Transcona NDP CROSS, Billie Seine River NDP DELA CRUZ, Jelynn Radisson NDP DEVGAN, JD McPhillips NDP EWASKO, Wayne Lac du Bonnet PC FONTAINE, Nahanni, Hon. St.

Johns NDP GOERTZEN, Kelvin Steinbach PC GUENTER, Josh Borderland PC HIEBERT, Carrie Morden-Winkler PC JOHNSON, Derek Interlake-Gimli PC KENNEDY, Nellie, Hon. Assiniboia NDP KHAN, Obby Fort Whyte PC KINEW, Wab, Hon. Fort Rouge NDP KING, Trevor Lakeside PC KOSTYSHYN, Ron, Hon. Dauphin NDP LAGASSÉ, Bob Dawson Trail Ind. LAMOUREUX, Cindy Tyndall Park Lib. LINDSEY, Tom, Hon. Flin Flon NDP LOISELLE, Robert St. Boniface NDP MALOWAY, Jim Elmwood NDP MARCELINO, Malaya, Hon. Notre Dame NDP MOROZ, Mike, Hon. River Heights NDP MOSES, Jamie, Hon. St. Vital NDP MOYES, Mike, Hon.

Riel NDP NARTH, Konrad La Vérendrye PC NAYLOR, Lisa, Hon. Wolseley NDP NESBITT, Greg Riding Mountain PC OXENHAM, Logan Kirkfield Park NDP PANKRATZ, David Waverley NDP PERCHOTTE, Richard Selkirk PC PIWNIUK, Doyle Turtle Mountain PC REDHEAD, Eric Thompson NDP ROBBINS, Colleen Spruce Woods PC SALA, Adrien, Hon. St. James NDP SANDHU, Mintu, Hon. The Maples NDP SCHMIDT, Tracy, Hon. Rossmere NDP SCHOTT, Rachelle Kildonan-River East NDP SCHULER, Ron Springfield-Ritchot PC SIMARD, Glen, Hon. Brandon East NDP SMITH, Bernadette, Hon. Point Douglas NDP STONE, Lauren Midland PC WASYLIW, Mark Fort Garry Ind.

WHARTON, Jeff Red River North PC WIEBE, Matt, Hon. Concordia NDP WOWCHUK, Rick Swan River PC Vacant The Pas-Kameesak

2659 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA Monday, June 1, 2026 The House met at 1:30 p.m. The Speaker: O Eternal and Almighty God, from Whom all power and wisdom come, we are assembled here before Thee to frame such laws as may tend to the welfare and prosperity of our province. Grant, O merciful God, we pray Thee, that we may desire only that which is in accordance with Thy will, that we may seek it with wisdom, know it with certainty and accomplish it perfectly for the glory and honour of Thy name and for the welfare of all our people. Amen.

We acknowledge we are gathered on Treaty 1 territory and that Manitoba is located on the treaty territories and ancestral lands of the Anishinaabeg, Anishininewuk, Dakota Oyate, Denesuline and Nehethowuk nations. We acknowledge Manitoba is located on the Homeland of the Red River Métis. We acknowledge northern Manitoba includes lands that were and are the ancestral lands of the Inuit. We respect the spirit and intent of treaties and treaty making and remain committed to working in partner- ship with First Nations, Inuit and Métis people in the spirit of truth, reconciliation and collaboration. Please be seated.

MLA Robert Loiselle (St. Boniface): L'Honorable Président [Honourable Speaker] , on a matter of privilege. MATTER OF PRIVILEGE The Speaker: The member for St. Boniface, on a matter of privilege. MLA Robert Loiselle (St. Boniface): L'Honorable Président [Honourable Speaker], last Thursday during question period, the member for La Vérendrye (Mr. Narth) took it upon himself to question my ability, the Premier's (Mr. Kinew) ability and, in fact, every member in this Chamber's ability to express themselves in either of Canada's two official languages.

Honourable Speaker, I bring this serious matter to your attention at my earliest occasion, having needed time to review the broadcast and Hansard on Thursday, May 28. L'Honorable Président [Hon ourable Speaker] , last Thursday, during question period, in an exchange between the member for La Vérendrye and the Premier, who exercised his constitutional right to answer in French, the member for La Vérendrye was heard by myself and many members heckling: Respect, respect, respect, I asked my question in English; to which I interjected with: The Premier speaks French, just put your earpiece on for the translation.

The member for La Vérendrye did not do so and went on to say: I didn't ask my question in French, I asked my question in English. Honourable Speaker, this shows another lack of respect by the member for La Vérendrye, not only for the Canadian Constitution of 1867, but also for The Manitoba Act of 1870 and, more specifically,

section 23 of The Manitoba Act, which I would like to table at this point.

French spoken Et l'Honorable Président, j'aimerais partager exactement et précisément ce que l'article 23 de l'Acte du Manitoba dit : « L'usage de la langue française ou de la langue anglaise sera facultatif dans les débats des Chambres de la législature; mais dans la rédaction des archives, procès-verbaux et journaux respectifs de ces chambres, l'usage de ces deux langues sera obligatoire; et dans toute plaidoirie ou pièce de procédure par devant les tribunaux ou émanant des tribunaux du Canada, qui sont établis sous l 'autorité de la Loi constitutionnelle de 1867, et par devant tous les tribunaux ou émanant des tribunaux de la province, il pourra être également faire usage, à faculté, de l'une ou de l'autre de ces langues ».

De plus, les actions du député de La Vérendrye (M. Narth) témoignent d'une haute incompréhension alarmante du caractère bilingue du Canada et du Manitoba, ainsi que des règles qui régissent le fonctionnement de cette Chambre, et cela de la part d'un déput é qui représente justement des milliers de francophones dans la circonscription de La Vérendrye, notamment dans les villages de La Broquerie, Saint-Malo et Saint-Pierre, où se trouve d'ailleurs un Centre de services bilingues de la Province du Manitoba.

En tant que député de Saint-Boniface, en tant que métis de la rivière Rouge et en tant que francophone, je ne laisserai personne remettre en cause l'un des principes fondamentaux de notre pays ou de cette province, ainsi que de mon droit constitutionnel de

2660 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 m'exprimer dans la langue officielle de mon choix au sein de cette Assemblée. Translation And, Honourable Speaker, I would like to quote exactly and precisely what

section 23 of The Manitoba Act states: "Either the English or the French language may be used by any person in the debates of the Houses of the Legislature, and both those languages shall be used in the respective Records and Journals of those Houses; and either of those languages may be used by any person, or in any Pleading or Process, in or issuing from any Court of Canada established under the Constitution Act, 1867, or in or from all or any of the Courts of the Province." Furthermore, the actions of the member for La Vérendrye demonstrate an alarming and profound lack of understanding of the bilingual nature of Canada and Manitoba, as well as of the rules governing the operation of this House–and this from a member who represents thousands of francophones in the riding of La Vérendrye, particularly in the villages of La Broquerie, St.

Malo, and St. Pierre, where, incidentally, there is a Bilingual Service Centre of the Province of Manitoba. As the member elected to represent St. Boniface, as a Red River Métis, and as a francophone, I will not allow anyone to call into question one of the fundamental principles of our country or this province, nor my constitutional right to express myself in the official language of my choice within this Assembly.

English Therefore, Honourable Speaker, I move a motion in the House that the audio recordings be retrieved and distributed publicly, recording last week's exchange during question period so that we can get to the truth of what was said by the member for La Vére ndrye; and that the member for La Vérendrye apologize on the record to every member of this Chamber, to every francophone in Manitoba and every Manitoban for violating

section 23 of The Manitoba Act and disrespecting the privilege given to all members of this House. Miigwech, Thank you. Merci. The Speaker: Before recognizing any other member to speak, I would remind all members that–keep your comments directly related to the matter of privilege. Mr. Konrad Narth (La Vérendrye): Honourable Speaker, in response to the matter of privilege from the member for St. Boniface (MLA Loiselle), I don't believe that the member has a matter of privilege, but I will start by simply apologizing if my comments were taken by the francophone com munity or the Premier (Mr.

Kinew) or anyone on the govern ment benches, if they were taken in that way. Honourable Speaker, my constituents throughout my constituency have been–have always been proud– before I even ran for the role of repre senting La Vérendrye–proud that that constituency represents the most amount of bilingual municipalities and com- munities across all of our province out of any other constituency. And I've been a strong ally in protecting and promoting French language in our province.

And I feel strongly the importance that in plays not only in the history of our province, but who we have become and the direction that we go.

Honourable Speaker, my comments had nothing to do with French language, promoting bilingualism and supporting bilingualism in the province; it was in the manner that the Premier had used his ability to answer in French. * (13:40) As much as I promote and protect and endorse French language use, the francophone community of our province, Honourable Speaker, I have never claimed to be bilingual or have the ability to interpret French language, especially in a 45-second segment.

So, Honourable Speaker, the direction that the Premier chose to unfortunately use French language in question period with me had very little to do with promoting French language. I encourage the Premier in debate, when the opportunity arises, to debate in– and put his words on the record in French. But in a conversation format, I would think that– any francophone Manitoban that I've ever had a con- versation with throughout the communities that I represent, and in fact across all of Manitoba, have never engaged in conversation in that way. And that, we know, is the intent of question period.

So, Honourable Speaker, I'll –I started that way and I'll finish that way. I do apologize if it –my comment, which was not on the record, was taken in that way, but it was to showcase the political motive of the structuring of the response by the Premier instead of, unfortunately, representing French language. And I think the French community of Manitoba,

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2661 I think those that protect French language, would appreciate the respect to not use it as a political pawn. So, thank you, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: The honourable Opposition House Leader, on the same point of –or same matter of privilege? Mr. Derek Johnson (Official Opposition House Leader): On the same matter of privilege, Honour - able Speaker. The Speaker: The hon ourable Op position House Leader, on the same matter of privilege. Mr. Johnson: Yes, I just want to point out this isn't the earliest op portunity for the member to bring this forward.

I also want to point out that no rights or privileges were impugned at all by the member, as the member was able to choose their language of choice when they answered the question, which they did, and it was in French. Thank you, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: I believe I will take this matter under advisement to consult whatever authorities I need to and come back to the House with an answer. Routine proceedings. An Honourable Member: Point of order. Point of Order The Speaker: The hon ourable First Minister, on a point of order. Hon.

Wab Kinew (Premier): Just in the previous response to our colleague from Saint-Boniface– French spoken – le député de Saint -Boniface (DAL Loiselle), qui a fait son commentaire. Dans la réponse, le membre – le député de La Vérendrye (M. Narth) – a dit qu'on est supposé de parler en anglais, quelque chose à cet effet. Ce n'est pas vrai. Les règles de cette Chambre nous donnent l'opportunité de parler soit en anglais, soit en français à n'importe quel quand.

Alors, il a violé une des règles en présenter ses commentaires de cette façon, et puis je pense que tous les Conservateurs ont fait une grande erreur en 'applaud' – en leur applaudissement de cet mauvais commentaire du député. Translation –the member for St. Boniface (MLA Loiselle), who made his comment. In response, the member –the member for La Vérendrye (Mr. Narth) –said that we are supposed to speak in English, or something to that effect. That is not true. The rules of this House give us the opportunity to speak in either English or French at any time.

So, he violated one of the rules by making his remarks in that manner, and I think all the Conservatives made a big mistake by applauding the member's inappro- priate comment. The Speaker: I thank the honourable First Minister for his comments, and I think I will take it under advisement, and I'll come back to the House with a combined response to both the matter of privilege and the point of order. Mr. Derek Johnson (Official Opposition House Leader): Yes, you didn't openly offer the floor to have people respond to the point of order.

The Speaker: The honourable Opposition House Leader, on the same point of order. Mr. Johnson: On the same point of order. Obviously, no rules were violated, and the mem- ber got up and was able to speak in French as we encourage all Manitobans to exercise their bilingual abilities, and it showed here today. So there was no point of order. Thank you. The Speaker: I–as I previously stated –will take this under advisement and come back to the House with a ruling that hopefully will address both the matter of privilege and the point of order. ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS The Speaker: Introduction of bills?

Introduction of bills? Tabling of reports? Committee reports–sorry. TABLING OF REPORTS Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): I'm pleased to table the 2024 annual report for the Manita [phonetic] human–Manitoba Human Rights Commission and Manitoba Human Rights Adjudication Panel. Hon. Mike Moyes (Minister of Environment and Climate Change): I am tabling responses to written questions. Hon. Lisa Naylor (Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure): I'm tabling responses to written questions. The Speaker: No further tabling of reports?

2662 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS Pride Month Hon. Lisa Naylor (Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure): I am so proud to rise today to recog- nize June 2026 as Pride Month in Manitoba, the first time Pride Month has been officially recognized in this Chamber since legislation received royal assent last fall. I know all members will want to congratulate and thank my colleague, the MLA for Lagimodière, whose legislation made this possible. Pride Month celebrates the history, culture, dignity and visibility of 2SLGBTQIA+ people.

It is also a time to remember the protests and acts of resistance that challenged injustice and advanced human rights and to recognize that the fight for equality continues today. Honourable Speaker, our government is proud to stand with queer, trans and two- spirit Manitobans. Since forming government, we have taken meaningful action to advance inclusion, dignity and human rights. We passed legislation officially recognizing June a s Pride Month in Manitoba and we established March 31 as Two -Spirit and Transgender Day of Visibility.

We removed discriminatory barriers for trans, non-binary and gender -diverse Manitobans legally changing their name or gender markers on official documents. We also strengthened the Manitoba Human Rights Code by adding protections for gender expression. Our government is also proud to have expanded access to gender-affirming care and to have introduced free PEP, PrEP and HIV treatment for uninsured Manitobans. These changes are not just policy; they are about people, about lives, about safety and belonging.

Beyond legislation, our government hosted the first annual Pride celebration inside the Manitoba Legislature, and we invite all members to the event this Friday, June 5, when we will be celebrating again. Every year, our members attend and support Pride events across the province. Through our Minister of Families, Women and Gender Equity (MLA Fontaine), our government has also engaged with 2SLGBTQIA+ community members and service providers and is now developing an action plan to improve access to government services and address barriers community members face.

Through Women and Gender Equity Manitoba, we're also proud to provide ongoing financial support to organi- zations, including Pride Winnipeg and 2Spirit Manitoba, whose work strengthens community, provides vital services and creates spaces for belonging. Historically, Pride marches were a protest, and we must always continue to confront the harms caused by homophobia and transphobia, past and present. But today, Pride is also a celebration of resilience, of queer joy, community and progress.

We celebrat e not only 2SLGBTQIA+ inclusion in society but also that 2SLGBTQIA+ people make society better through our diverse relationships, diverse sexualities, diverse genders, through our leadership, through our resist - ance and through our love. * (13:50) Honourable Speaker, this month, Manitobans have the opportunity to learn, celebrate and stand together in support of our vision that everyone can live openly, safely and with pride. We are one Manitoba. I wish a happy Pride Month to every member of this House. Thank you, Honourable Speaker.

MLA Jeff Bereza (Portage la Prairie): As we con- clude Pride week and step into the month of June, it is my honour to celebrate Pride Month here in Manitoba. Not only does this month allow for an opportunity to celebrate the contributions and the resilience of the 2SLGBTQIA+ Manitobans, it offers a chance to reflect on the values of equality and dignity for all people. It's also an opportunity to recognize the progress made and the brighter future that lies ahead of us. This year, Portage la Prairie will be marking its 11th annual Pride festival.

This fact speaks to the root of not only our city but of Manitoba as a whole, that we are diverse and growing province that is stronger when all Manitobans feel a sense of belonging. For that reason, I'd like to thank the member of Lagimodière for introducing The Pride Month Act. I had the honour of attending various Pride events in Portage and Long Plain First Nation and the Portage Collegiate last year, and I look forward to joining in once again this month. Progressive Conservatives believe that all people deserve to live freely, safely and with dignity.

We believe that ensuring the full participation of Manitobans in our society is essential to a thriving province. This is proven through the everyday contributions of the 2SLGBTQIA+ community members, from business, to arts, to health care, to public service.

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2663 I invite all members of the Chamber to work together to ensure that Manitoba remains a province where everyone can prosper. Thank you. Environment Officer Recognition Day Hon. Mike Moyes (Minister of Environment and Climate Change): Today I rise not just for a formal recognition, but to celebrate the quiet, essential work of environment officers across Manitoba.

I am proud to declare June 1, 2026, as environment officer recog- nition day in our province, coinciding with World Environment Day, a fitting moment to honour those who protect our air, water, land and communities. Manitoba's environment officers are the people who make environmental protection real on the ground. They issue licences and permits, conduct inspections, monitor compliance and enforce environmental and drinking water safety legislation. They are scientists, investigators, educators and peace officers and, often, all at once.

Their work reaches every corner of this province, from our northern lakes and boreal forests to the Red River Valley, from small towns to Winnipeg's neigh- bourhoods. When things go wrong, environment officers are the ones who step forward. They respond to spills and contamination incidents, quickly assessing risks to people, wildlife and water supplies. They take samples, co -ordinate with munici- palities and Indigenous partners and work with first responders to contain hazards.

They advise on imme- diate protective actions, from issuing drinking water advisories to arranging emergency treatment, and they oversee the cleanup and remediation that follows. That work can mean long hours in difficult conditions, complex technical decisions and careful co-ordination with multiple agencies to protect public health and restore the environment. They also play a critical role in preventing prob- lems from becoming crises. Through inspections and compliance monitoring, they identify risks early: faulty storage tanks, improper waste handling or failing water systems.

And they work with owners and operators to fix them. When enforcement is required, they gather evidence, document incidents and support regulatory and legal processes that hold polluters accountable. Their diligence helps prevent long-term damage to our lakes, rivers, wetlands and drinking water sources. Beyond emergencies and enforcement, environ - ment officers are educators and partners. They pro- vide guidance to municipalities, industry, farmers and homeowners on best practices for waste management, petroleum storage, contaminated site management and source water protection.

They build relationships with Indigenous com - munities, municipal leaders and local organizations so that responses are timely, culturally informed and effective. Those partnerships are how we turn rules into real, lasting improvements. This is often unsung work. It means late -night calls, winter road travel, careful sampling in the field and the steady application of science and judgment under pressure. It means showing up when a river is at risk, when illegal dumping is discovered or when a community faces a drinking water concern.

To every environment officer in Manitoba: thank you for your courage, your expertise and your unwavering commitment to public health and the environment. Protecting our environment is a Manitoba effort. The officers we honour today are a vital part of that team. As Minister of Environment and Climate Change, I want to reaffirm our commitment to support your work, to strengthen the partnerships you rely on and to ensure you have the tools and training needed to meet the challenges ahead.

I ask all members to rise and recognize the environment officers from the divisions of Water Stewardship and Environmental Stewardship who are able to be with us today and ask for their names to be added to Hansard. Thank you, merci, miigwech, Honourable Speaker. Andrew Benger, Mary Odere, Wajed Shah, Samantha St. Germain-Silva, Sheffy Tom. Introduction of Guests The Speaker: Prior to the response, there are some guests in the gallery that I hope are still in the gallery.

We have seated in the public gallery from River East Collegiate 25 grade 9 to 12 students under the direction of Duyen Chau and they are located in the constituency of the honourable member for Rossmere (MLA Schmidt). And we welcome you here today. * * *

2664 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 Mr. Wayne Balcaen (Brandon West): Today I rise to recognize environment officer recognition day, observed each year on June the 1st. This day was formally recognized by legislation passed by our previous Progressive Conservative government in 2021 to honour the important and often underap- preciated work of those dedicated professionals. Environment officers are the quiet guardians of our province's health and natural beauty. They are responsible for the delivery of provincial, environ- mental and public health protection programs across Manitoba.

Their work touches many parts of our daily lives, from inspecting water systems and public facilities to ensuring that industries comply with environmental regulations. They diligently monitor and address potential hazards to protect both the environment and public health. Their commitment and attention to detail help prevent harm and promote safety in every community across Manitoba. Their role is vital to maintaining the high quality of life we enjoy here in Manitoba.

Because of their hard work, Manitoba remains a place where families can live, work and raise their children surrounded by clean air, safe water and beautiful landscapes . The work environmental officers do often goes unseen, but the impact is felt every day by all Manitobans. On behalf of our PC caucus, I want to extend my heartfelt thanks to all environmental officers across the province. We acknowledge and appreciate your commitment and dedication to protecting Manitoba's environment and human health.

I've had the chance to understand the vital work they go through conserving our province and making sure that it is kept safe through the work of my older brother, Darin, who is actually retiring after 40 years working in various roles throughout the de partment here in Manitoba. A shout-out to my brother: he started as a conser- vation officer 40 years ago in 1986, becoming a natural resource officer, and in February 2019, becoming an environmental officer specialist. He's retiring on August 4 after giving tactical and operational advice for over–for 30 field officers.

He liaises with manage- ment, writes policy and commits to training all of these officers. * (14:00) And I know that his plans are to thoroughly enjoy retirement and practice his golf game, which I know he really has to work on because I'm his golf partner. Congratulations, Darin, enjoy your retirement, and thank you to all environment officers. Introduction of Guests The Speaker: Prior to member statements, there's some guests I'd like to introduce.

I'd draw the attention of all honourable members to the public gallery where we have with us today law enforcement students from the University College of the North who are visiting southern Manitoba as part of their career exploration trip. They're here visiting various police agencies and correctional centres in Winnipeg, Portage la Prairie and Brandon as well as a visit to the Manitoba Legislature to attend question period and for a visit to the Canadian Museum of human rights. They are Isacc Chartrand, Anthony Commodore-Schommer, Montgomery Primrose, Chastin Young; Darby Brown is their instructor.

The late member for The Pas -Kameesak (Ms. Amanda Lathlin) looked forward to hosting UCN students on their annual basis. And on behalf of all honourable members, we welcome you here today. And I would draw the attention of all honourable members to the Speaker's gallery, where we have with us today our six legislative interns. The interns have each written farewell statements, which I am pleased to share with the House. Ahdieh Bimrew came into the internship without a single clue or expectation of what it would look like.

He applied in part due to his fascination with the building's architecture, and in part because his good friend Silvia's suggestion, who was an intern the previous year. The first time he entered the building was for his interview, and every day since, has loved walking into the building and finding new details of the beauty within its walls. Ahdieh has been grateful for many parts of the internship, first and foremost to his fellow interns – Hayden, Sidney, Ngozi, Fred and Emma, who have helped him foster feelings of joy, camaraderie that he will cherish going forward.

He would also like to give thanks to all the caucus and legislative staff who have supported him throughout his novice understanding of the world of governance and politics. Most of all, he would like to thank Habesha maintenance and

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2665 cleaning staff who have treated him like their own and provided him with a greater understanding of the oppor- tunity that his own parents have provided for him. Going forward, Ahdieh looks forward to the pos- sibility of continuing with the government to enhance his perspectives on provincial affairs before moving on to grad school at either the University of Winnipeg or University of Manitoba. Next, we have Sidney Burzynski. Sidney entered the internship eager to gain a better understanding of the political world and inner workings of the people's building.

Much to her parents' surprise and perhaps slight relief, she was also able to discover that through the program, she could actually put her degree in political science to good use after all. Sidney would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all NDP members and caucus staff for their patience, kindness and constant willingness to answer thousands of questions. She's equally grateful to Andrea, Rick, Brandon for welcoming her so warmly to the Legislative Building. What struck Sidney most during her internship was seeing all the places former interns ended up throughout the building and beyond.

It quickly became clear to her and her peers that this program continues to leave lasting impact long after the internship comes to an end. Sidney feels incredibly lucky to have spent the last 10 months alongside her fellow interns: Ahdieh, Hayden, Emma, Fred and Ngozi–whether it was participating in her increasingly goofy video ideas for the intern Instagram account, or accepting a challenge to race up the Grand Staircase, their friendship made this experience unforgettable. As the interns prepare for their next adventure, Sidney leaves with immense gratitude for everyone who made this program so meaningful.

Although she will soon be moving away to com- plete her master's degree, Sidney knows Manitoba will always remain close to her heart because no matter where life takes her, there really is no place like home. Hayden Gilmour: Over the past 10 months, Hayden has had the privilege of working within the govern- ment caucus, gaining an inside perspective on the leadership of the province he was raised in and deeply loves.

He had the opportunity to be involved in every part of the legislative process and is eternally grateful for the opportunity to be the first mem ber of Brokenhead to be a part of the internship program and further infiltrate the system with more environmental, Indigenous and youth representation within politics. Hayden would like to thank the Clerk's office for their tireless effort to make this program the best it can be, being amazing leaders and examples to learn from.

He would also like to thank the rest of the Assembly staff and all of the NDP staff that welcomed him into this crazy political world with open arms and made the office feel like home. He looks forward to what's next. He will forever be grateful for this year's being a foundation

chapter in the never-ending story that is life. He is grateful for the amazing people he has met and friends he has made. Miigwech, merci, thank you. Fredrich McCracken: Fredrich–this internship pro- gram has far exceeded his expectations. The program broadened his horizons and deepened his interest in a multitude of fields. He found that every single day in the Manitoba Legislature is an opportunity to learn something new and unexpected. This internship offers the opportunity to experi - ence our political system first-hand, and it more than delivers.

Fredrich learned directly about the processes, procedures and traditions of our democracy. He and his colleagues also had the pleasure of speaking with leaders from many important sectors across Manitoba and acquiring invaluable insight into the process. What Fredrich has gained from the program will stay with him forever –not just knowledge and skills, but relationships that will last a lifetime. From his experience, he can safely say that politics touches each and every aspect of our lives, and that is why it's so important to always stay interested and engaged.

It is with a tender heart that Fredrich bids farewell to his colleagues, fellow interns and all MLAs he had the honour and pleasure to work with. His final message for everyone is this: Knowing Manitoba, our paths will surely cross again. Next, we have Ngozi Okose: When my internship began, it coincided with the 40th anniversary celeb- ration of the internship program. It was an honour to meet and hear the stories and experience of those who had come before us. Their journey affirmed my own, and it reminded me that this opportunity represents more than personal achievement.

I hope my presence here encouraged other Black, immigrant girls to pursue opportunities they may not initially see as accessible to them.

2666 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 Stepping into this role was both eye-opening and rewarding. I gained hands-on experience with adminis- trative and legislative processes. From co -ordinating tasks and managing records to supporting the daily operations of the caucus, these responsibilities reveal the extensive work behind governance and deepened my appreciation for collaboration, professionalism and attention to detail. This internship showed me the role is more than a title. It is growth, learning, reflection and service.

I develop professional skills while deepening my understanding of humility, active listening and serving others, for which I am grateful. Moving forward, I will carry the relationships and lessons gained.

Thank you to Amy Karlinsky, Hanna Farris for your warmth; to Mark Moi for your support and listening to professor Brandon Task for academic guidance; and to Rick, the Clerk's office, MLAs, ministers and assembly staff for your mentorship and kindness throughout this ex perience, which will stay with me long term. * (14:10) Emma Winram: Emma–for Emma, this program was the one that will stick with her for a long time. She would never have been able to fully understand the realities, the nuances, the politics and the personalities that are here in the people's building without this program.

There are many im portant lessons she learned that have helped shape her into a more well-rounded individual than before. She is now ready and eager to enter Manitoba's workforce with the program's knowledge under her belt. She thanks all Legis lative staff, caucus staff and MLAs for the experience and she says a special thank you to Rick, Andrea, Brandon and Amanda for the endless support throughout the program. Their guidance was so invaluable that she struggles to find words to express her gratitude. Suffice to say the program is in good hands.

Additionally, she cannot leave here without thank- ing her fellow interns. This cohort was filled with some fierce leaders that she was proud to work with alongside throughout the year. She cannot wait to see where they go next. Joining the interns today in the internship pro- gram is the internship program academic director, professor Brandon Trask from the Uni versity of Manitoba law school. Also joining the interns is Andrea Norlock from the Clerk's office, administrative assistant assigned to the internship program.

The internship program operates under the direction of our Clerk, Rick Yarish, and the caucus repre sentatives from the pr ogram are the member for Seine River (MLA Cross) and the member for La Vérendrye (Mr. Narth). On behalf of all hon ourable members, I'd like to thank the interns for their hard work and dedi cation this year. I hope each of you will carry many fond memories with you from your exper ience at the Manitoba Legislature. Congratulations, and we look forward to your future. It's beginning to look like it will be all Speaker today.

So we have some more legis lative pages that it's their last day today. Kathryn Sacher: Kathryn will be graduating from Collège Jeanne-Sauvé this June. Her hard work and dedication towards her academics have paid off as she was offered spots in her top two universities, and she has made the decision to attend Canadian Mennonite University in the fall, focusing on the social sciences. As she prepares for this new

chapter in her life, she is also grateful for the experience she has gained for the past two years as a page at the Legislature. During her time here, she developed not only a greater understanding of how provincial governments operate but also a stronger appreciation for public ser- vice, leadership and the importance of civic engage - ment in shaping our communities and society. More than anything, Kathryn is grateful for the people she met throughout her time at the Legislature.

She would also like to extend her heartfelt gratitude to everyone who encouraged, supported and believed in her over the past two years. To those who took the time to mentor her, answer her questions, share their wisdom and help her grow, thank you. Your kindness, patience and guidance made her experience truly unforgettable, and the lessons and memories she gained will stay with her for years to come. Karson Craven: Karson is set to graduate from Collége Churchill High School in the coming weeks.

He's looking forward to continuing his academics at the University of Winnipeg, where he hopes to earn his bachelor of arts and education in the coming years. As he moves on to the next stage of his life, he can't help but look back on this past year and his time

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2667 working at the Legislature. He's learned so much about the inner workings of our provincial govern- ment and its impact on our communities. He would like to thank everyone who helped through patience while he was learning and continues to learn, especially when mixing up the C names calling votes, and providing him with encouragement. Karson would also like to give a special thanks to his parents and teachers for supporting him and helping him in making all of this possible.

He will forever cherish the memories he has made during his time as a page and for the kindness he has been shown along the way. He is confident that his experiences working at the Legislature will help him to better the world around him and hopes that the future will bring him back here at some point. Until then, he wishes every- one the very best. Milena Zaiats: Milena will be graduating this June, marking the completion of an important

chapter in her life. Throughout her high school journey, she has demonstrated a strong commitment to academic excellence, leadership and community involvement while adapting to a new life in Canada. She successfully balanced studying in both a Ukrainian and a Canadian school, graduating with honours. Alongside her academics, she has been actively involved in her community, volunteering at an immi- gration service to support newcomers, as well as at her church, where she teaches catechism to younger students. She has also taken

part in various leadership initiatives and projects, consistently striving not only for personal growth, but to use her skil ls as experi - ences to create a more meaningful impact on those around her. Most notably, she founded her own initiative aimed at supporting teenagers in developing leader - ship skills, personal growth and creating positive change in the world. Through these experiences, she has developed a strong sense of purpose and a com - mitment to contributing to her community.

Having moved to Canada from Ukraine just three years ago due to the war, she has shown resilience, deter - mination and a deep appreciation for the opportunities she has been given. Looking ahead, she plans to pursue a bachelor's degree in political science as a pathway toward her ultimate goal of studying law. Her passion for law is rooted in a desire to fight for justice, protect human rights and contribute to building a more equitable society.

She believes that understanding political systems is essential in order to create meaningful and lasting change, and she is committed to using her education to advocate for others. Working in the Manitoba government alongside such inspiring individuals, learning from their example and drawing energy from their dedication, she's received offers to study political science at the University of Alberta, the University of Ottawa and even at Minerva University, recognized as one of the most innovative universities in the world.

She ultimately chose to continue her journey at the University of Manitoba, where she can remain close to her community and the people she loves. This summer, she will also be participating in an academic program formerly known as the Harvard venture and technology summer program, focusing on business and law. As she prepares for this next chapter, she's deeply grateful for her experience as a page at the Legislature. Being present in the Chamber has given her a deeper understanding of how government systems function and how they serve the people.

More importantly, it has shown her that change is possible –that through belief in oneself and in others, meaningful progress can be achieved. As a girl from Ukraine who could not have imagined standing here just a few years ago, this experience has been incredibly meaningful and has brought her closer to her dream of defending people and fighting for their rights. She would like to express her heartfelt gratitude to her family in Ukraine, whose strength and love and unwavering belief in her continue to inspire her every day, especially during such a difficult time.

She is deeply thankful for her parents for support ing her through every step of her journey. She would also like to thank Dave and Rob for their guidance, patience and for always taking the time to answer her questions. Finally, she extends her sincere appreciation to all the MLAs, whose kindness and encouragement made her experience in the Chamber truly special. She will carry the lessons and memories from this experience with her as she continues to pursue her goals. She hopes that in the future, she'll be able to

2668 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 make meaningful contributions to society and have a positive impact on the lives of others. And we thank each and every one of you for your service. And we have some students in the gallery that have to leave before too much longer, so we have, seated in the public gallery, from Strathcona School, 35 grade 4 to 6 students under the direction of April Spence. This group is located in the constituency of the honour able member for Point Douglas (Ms. Smith). * (14:20) And we welcome you all here today.

MEMBERS' STATEMENTS Manitoba Association of Filipino Teachers MLA Jelynn Dela Cruz (Radisson): Maligayang Buwan ng Pamanang Pilipino. [Happy Filipino Heritage Month.] Happy Filipino Heritage Month, Honourable Speaker. On behalf of all of us in the Manitoba Legislature: Tagalog spoken Mabuhay mga Pilipino dito sa Manitoba. Mabuhay ang ating mahuhusay 'nang' mag- aaral at guro, ipinagmamalaki nating lahat. Translation Long live Filipinos here in Manitoba. Long live our excellent students and teachers who make all of us proud.

English Honourable Speaker, I invite you to turn your attention to the gallery where we are joined by out - standing students and teachers from Radisson cele - brating Filipino Heritage Month with pride, alongside the Manitoba Association of Filipino Teachers. Founded in 1977, the Manitoba Association of Filipino Teachers Inc, otherwise known as MAFTI, has spent decades lifting students, families and educators up in Manitoba.

Through the leadership of educators, educational assistants, child -care workers and community mentors, MAFTI has helped preserve and promote Tagalog heritage and culture while strengthening ties to the school communities. I know how powerful it can be for young people to see educators who understand their stories, their families and the sacrifices that brought them here. Represen tation changes the way that students see themselves, what they believe is possible and how they choose to show up. Brought to us by Ms.

Shane Matabalan, we are honoured to recognize the students who've shown up for us here today: Janna Kaamino, Margaret Gonzales, Marjedd Alcantara, Vanessa Perejan, who join us from the grade 10 class at Transcona Collegiate. And, Honourable Speaker, last but not least, have you ever met a 13- year-old volleyball and basketball coach? Today we all have. From John W. Gunn Middle School, we recognize Jhyanna Cadag as well: a multi- sport athlete, student leader, Folklorama volunteer and John W. Gunn's outstanding athlete of May 2026.

When I was Jhyanna's age, I was sitting in the front row on my first day of school next to my newest best friend, Jhyanna's teacher, Ms. Xyza Singcay. So this is your heads-up: time flies, so I implore each of you to keep soaring with it. Honourable Speaker, today I invite the Chamber to rise to recognize these students, their teachers and the pride they bring sa aming kababayan [to our compatriots]. Cost of Living, Taxes and the Economy Mr. Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): Manitoban families deserve better: Manitobans deserve better than a junk food tax.

They deserve better than what this Kinew govern ment who takes more and more taxes from you and it only gives you pennies back. I've spoken with many Manitobans over the years, and especially over the past three months during this session. Families, seniors, small businesses, students and more all share a similar story. They're working hard, harder than they've ever worked, doing every- thing they can, but they still can't get ahead. They can't even pay their bills. They want better. They deserve better. This will change when our PC Party returns to government.

We believe families should keep more of what they earn. We believe economic growth matters. We believe the government should create opportunity, not roadblocks, not division, not more red ta pe, not more excuses, not more blame, not picking winners and losers just like this Kinew government does time and time again. That's why we, on this side of the House, are fighting to increase your basic personal exemption to $30,000, so you can keep up to $3,000 of your hard- earned money. Real savings, real affordability, real results.

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2669 We believe in Manitobans. We believe we can grow our economy, we can create better jobs, make our communities safer and make life more affordable. If we face an election between now and the next sitting session, we know we will offer Manitobans a real choice: a choice between junk food savings or real savings; a choice between economic decline or oppor- tunity and prosperity; a choice between self -satisfied government or a govern ment that will work for the people.

We believe Manitoba can do better, we know Manitoba deserves better and we, the PC Party of Manitoba, will deliver better. C.A.M.P. Rossmere Hon. Tracy Schmidt (Minister of Education and Early Childhood Learning): With the arrival of June comes the end of the school year, a time to celebrate the year's accomplishments and look towards the summer break. For many lucky Manitobans, summer break means summer camp, a place where young people can build skills, make lasting memories and learn what it means to be a part of something bigger than themselves. The same principles inspired C.A.M.P.

Rossmere, a new initiative in our constituency office this summer. And as today marks the first day of camp, I welcome our 2026 campers to the people's building, their building. Now, C.A.M.P. Rossmere is not your average summer camp, Honourable Speaker. C.A.M.P. stands for Constituency Assistance Mentorship Program, and it's designed to give young folks in Rossmere a hands- on experience in public service, community leader - ship and civic engagement. It is our hope that this is just the first of many camps to come in Rossmere and across Manitoba.

Honourable Speaker, democracy may live in this Chamber, but it is born on the doorstep. Ideas, policies and progress do not arrive here on their own. The work that we do is carried here by Manitobans. Neighbours listening to their neighbours, advocates speaking up for change and people across our prov- ince working hard to build stronger communities. To our 2026 cohort: Mac, Addison, Ethan, Luke and Elliot, thank you for choosing to spend your summer in service to our community. Each of you brings your own strengths, your own perspective and your own gifts to this work, and we are stronger because of you.

I hope that over the course of this summer you come to fully trust what our team already knows: that your voices matter, that your ideas matter and that your place in this building matters. Honourable Speaker, I would like to acknowledge the work of our lead camp counsellor, Bethany, for all of her hard work in setting up C.A.M.P. Rossmere as a way of engaging young folks into our work of serving the good people of Rossmere. I invite all members of this House to join me in welcoming the students of C.A.M.P.

Rossmere here to the Manitoba Legislature and also in wishing all of the many students and educators across our beautiful province a warm, beautiful Manitoba summer. Dr. Chandy Jacob Mrs. Carrie Hiebert (Morden-Winkler): I rise today to recognize and honour Dr. Chandy Jacob, whose dedication and vision have profoundly shaped the health care and touched countless lives in Winkler and across the southern Manitoba. As the first medical specialist to establish a rural surgical program in southern Manitoba, Dr. Jacob brought advanced care closer to home for patients.

Over an extraordinary 60- year career, he embodied the highest value of the medical profession: integrity, excellence and an unwavering commitment to patient care. Through his skills, kindness and self –selfless service, he earned the trust and gratitude of genera - tions of Manitobans. Dr. Jacob has advocated for rural health care, inspired colleagues and improved the lives of so many. He is also a visionary. Beginning in 1974, he championed the concept of regional health- care centres, helping lay the foundation for what would become the Boundary Trails health centre.

His contributions have been wildly recognized. He was named physician of the year by Doctors Manitoba in 1993, received honorary membership to the Canadian Medical Association and recognized as a physician emeritus by Southern Health. Beyond this –beyond his medical practice, he's also helped established WC Wiebe community founda- tion and is an avid outdoorsman enjoying hunting, fishing and golfing with his friends and family. Dr. Jacob could have chosen to practise anywhere in Canada, but he chose to stay in Winkler because of the relationships he built and the community he loves.

On behalf of all of us at the Legislature and con- stituents of Morden -Winkler and all Manitobans, thank you. Mere words cannot express our sincere

2670 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 gratitude to you, Dr. Jacob, for your lifetime of service to us. As you celebrate your 90th birthday today, we extend our deepest wish– warm wishes. Your legacy lives on in many lives you have touched through your service, your generosity and leadership and unwavering commitment to others. Your story will be forever recorded in history in the Manitoba Legislature. I ask my colleagues to please rise and join me in honouring Dr. Jacob today. Dr. Ganesan Abbu, Donald Elias, Lloyd Elias, Archie Heinrichs, Dr. Chandy Jacob, Indira Jacob, Dr. Mary V.

Jacob, Betty Klassen, Dr. Donald H. Klassen, Dr. Eric Lane, Tena Lane, Ed Martens, Dr. Adashnee Pather, Alfred Peters, Gerald Suderman, Julia Suderman, Alisha Thiessen, Connor Thiessen, Ernie Wiebe, Jack Wiebe. * (14:30) Filipino Heritage Month Mr. Diljeet Brar (Burrows): Mabuhay [Live], Honourable Speaker. Today, I rise to recognize and celebrate Filipino Heritage Month throughout our beautiful province. During this special month of June, we come together as Manitobans to honour the outstanding achieve - ments, vibrant cultural traditions and sacrifices of our incredible Filipino community.

Filipino Manitobans are widely known for their helpful, warm and inviting nature. This spirit of genuine hospitality defines their community and forms the foundation for how they welcome everyone around them. Many support newcomers to settle and thrive in Manitoba, while many others are active members in their communities, often through local neighbourhood networks or organized volunteer groups. Their vital, everyday contributions are also felt across every single sector of our province.

From the front lines of health care and classrooms of education to essential roles in service and industry, their unwavering dedication keeps our economy moving forward, our neighbourhoods vibrant and our families safe. Furthermore, numerous Filipino community organizations across Manitoba are proudly marking milestone anniversaries and decades of dedicated service this year. These volunteer leaders have invested decades into educa tion–into educating and empowering Filipino youth, effectively preserving cultural heritage while guiding the next generation to dream big and work hard.

This special month gives us a wonderful oppor - tunity to express our deep provincial gratitude to how they continually enrich our shared land and strengthen our collective future. Happy Filipino Heritage Month, everyone. Please join me in celebrating these remarkable contributions and honouring this wonderful community today. Salamat po. [Thank you.] Mrs. Carrie Hiebert (Morden-Winkler): I ask for leave that my 20 guests' names are entered into Hansard directly behind my statement today. The Speaker: Is there leave as requested? [Agreed] Thank you.

Introduction of Guests The Speaker: There are other guests in the gallery that I'd like to introduce. We have from France Chanta Le Gal, mother of Fabienne Boulanger, who works with the MLA for St. Boniface. And we welcome you here today. We have guests seated in the public gallery.

With us from Strathcona School: April Spence, teacher; Samantha Gilkes, teacher; Margaret Konteh, edu ca- tional assistant; and students Xavier Bantog, Liam Beardy, Matt Francisco, Carter Johnson, Jaxson Kosc, April Pacifico, Yazmin [phonetic] Rumbaoa, Donovan Beardy, Gabriel Marer o, Johnny Coates, James Lozada, Louies Andres, Shema Jean, Liam Vila, Mbo Huzaifa, Jazer Bocobo, Deijah Chartrande, Sofia Filoteo, Hailyn-Jade Mitchell, who are guests of the honourable Minister of Housing, Addictions and Homelessness (Ms. Smith). And we welcome you all here today.

We also have from Transcona Collegiate Shane Matabanlan, Gia Manimbembo [phonetic], Hannah Fernandez, Sharlette Mendoza, Charlette Cun anan, Janna Kaamio [phonetic], Margaret Gonzales, Marjedd Alcantara, Vanessa Perejan; from M -F-T-I, Genalyn Tan, Victoria Cabrera, Maryjane Napolino [phonetic], Gloria Agravante. From John W. Gunn: Jhyanna Cadag, Xyza Singcay, who are teachers from Transcona Collegiate, and they're guests of the honourable member for Radisson (MLA Dela Cruz). And we're pleased to welcome all of you here today.

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2671 ORAL QUESTIONS Buy Canadian Act Timeline for Proclamation Mr. Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): While the Premier is busy focused on building his national profile for his federal run, many Manitobans are focused on something far more immediate: paying their bills, putting food on their table and making ends meet during an affordability crisis. Today is buy Manitoban, buy Canadian day, a day that should be supporting local workers, businesses, farmers and manufacturers.

Yet despite the gov - ernment's announcements and photo opportunities, Manitobans still have no clear buy Canadian strategy to review or follow, and that's one year after this NDP government promised they would have it. The Premier was quick to embrace the slogan and generate headlines, but where is the long- term plan to strengthen local supply chains and support Manitobans? If this part -time patriot Premier wants to be taken seriously, why, after a full year, has he failed to proclaim the act and provide a strategy to support Manitoba? Hon.

Wab Kinew (Premier): Honourable Speaker, I wanted to take this opportunity on the last sitting day of the House to congratulate the members of our internship program, who did a lot of amazing work on both sides of the House over the past–of this past few sittings, I guess I'll say. And also to thank the legislative pages for the amazing work that they do each and every day. I hope in both cases, these great young Manitobans learned a lot and I hope that they only take the positive things forward from this people's building. When it comes to what the member opposite is selling, Manitobans aren't buying it.

That's why we're going to keep working together to build up the most Canadian province of all: Manitoba. The Speaker: The honourable Leader of the Official Opposition, on a supplementary question. Procurement Contracts Awarded to US Companies Impact on Manitoba Businesses and Economy Mr. Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): If that wasn't the fakest answer out there, I don't know what is. The NDP government is full of contradictions and hypocrisy. They offer a headline catching statistics or announcement, but they refuse to validate or back it up.

Freedom of information requests are going unanswered, and Manitobans have questions. What Manitobans can clearly see is a Premier quick to say anything to catch the headlines, but nothing of substance behind the scenes. He says buy Canadian, yet this Kinew government just awarded a three-year, $36- million contract to an American - based com pany. The Premier increased government contracts to SpaceX and Starlink by five times and uses US-owned firms for polling and survey work. Why is the Premier refusing to engage with local businesses and industry to help Manitoba's economy? Hon.

Wab Kinew (Premier): Each and every day, Manitobans get up and work hard. That's what inspires us to serve you as the deliverers of health care, as the people who bring the economy to life. It makes us so proud that we decided to hang a giant Canadian flag on the front of the Manitoba Legislature. Such is the nature of our patriotism. While you're doing hard work, the opposition is light work. These folks on the other side thanked Donald Trump literally. The member for Fort Whyte, the leader of the PCs, went on a podcast the week after Trump levied the tariffs and he goes: I would thank–I would say thank you.

That's a verbatim quote of how he –then, it's bad enough–Borderlands, Spruce Woods, how many other of them are in love with Donald Trump? On this side of the House, we're getting sued by Elon Musk because we love Canada so much. I'll put that lawsuit down in front of them any day. * (14:40) We'll keep working for you to build up– The Speaker: Member's time has expired. The honourable Leader of the Official Opposition, on a new question. Sole-Sourced Procurement Contracts Transparency in Procurement Processes Mr. Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): Boy, oh boy, oh boy.

Hanging a Canadian flag outside the Legislature does not make up for sending $36 million to the United States. You know who's thanking this Premier is Donald Trump. This Premier has sent tens of millions of dollars to the United States, betraying Manitobans. He has done nothing to grow our economy or support local , other than a catchy slogan, Honourable Speaker.

2672 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 Manitobans want contracts to be awarded through open and fair transparent competition. Yet, time and time again, this government is sole -sourcing con- tracts. Whether it's lucrative contracts to political appointments, highly paid positions, this government continues to make decisions behind closed doors. Manitobans are left wondering why this government is so reluctant to embrace transparency.

If the 'tremier' truly believes in accountability and fairness, will he commit today to reducing sole-source contracting, increasing transparency and ensuring Manitobans– The Speaker: Member's time has expired. Hon. Wab Kinew (Premier): You know, there was a business during COVID. I can't remember if it was GoodLocal or bad local. Something about that. I don't recall a procurement process, a tender. I don't recall a call for proposals going out. And yet there he was, the member for Fort Whyte, jumping in to collect his $500,000 cheque.

Don't come in here, Honourable Speaker, and try to lecture us about procurement, whether it's the mem- ber for Red River North (Mr. Wharton) breaking the law, the member for Springfield-Ritchot (Mr. Schuler) building roads without contracts, or the Leader of the PCs himself, they've got their grubby hands lined up at the trough, and we are setting it free. A better example for kids and a stronger economy for you. The Speaker: The honourable Leader of the Official Opposition, on a supplementary question. Manitoba's Washington Trade Representative Compensation and Measurable Outcomes Mr.

Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): There you have it, the true colours of the Premier: personal attacks on myself and my team when we we're standing up, talking about– Some Honourable Members: Oh, oh. The Speaker: Order. Mr. Khan: –Manitoba's affordability crisis. You know what's most alarming is the fact that this Premier has hand -chosen his own friend and former colleague from CBC to make over $700,000. Here are the details: between October and April, Richard Madan was paid $380,000. If you extrapolate that over the year, that's $700,000 being paid to this Premier's close personal friend.

At a time when families can't pay the bills, this Premier has awarded Richard Madan, the trade commissioner for Washington, DC and Manitoba, $700,000, and he's brought zero dollars into Manitoba. How can the Premier stand up and justify paying his friend $700,000 when he has done nothing to grow Manitoba's economy? Hon. Wab Kinew (Premier): Honourable Speaker, Donald Trump has launched a trade war against our country. Now, what would the PCs have us do? They closed our presence in Washington, DC, and their leader bows down before Donald Trump and says thank you in the face of tariffs. There' s no spine in that.

There's no pride in that. There's no patriotism in that. Yes, we have retained a trade embassy, a trade ambassador for Washington, DC. He is not my friend. He is an employee, and he is working on behalf of you, the people of Manitoba, to ensure that Donald Trump's tariff war will stop at the border and we can get back to a good relationship. The members opposite, however, continue to be a mess. The Speaker: The honourable Leader of the Official Opposition, on a final supplementary question. Mr.

Khan: Donald Trump is thanking this Premier for sending him tens of millions of dollars to the United States, out of Manitoba's economy, into the American economy. Now, the Premier, you can clearly see, did not deny paying his friend $700,000 for a job that was done behind closed doors, Honourable Speaker. Manitobans have a right to know how this Premier can justify that. Also, Manitobans have a right to know, this Premier paying him $700,000, what has he delivered for Manitoba? Nothing. No results, no contracts, nothing for Manitobans to hang their hat on.

Why will the Premier –or, will the Premier stand up and apologize to Manitobans for betraying their trust, and will he do the right thing and fire Richard Madan today and start growing Manitoba's economy? Mr. Kinew: You know that meme with the guy and all the red yarn behind him? It's a bit like watching the member opposite in question period. On the one hand, he wants us to strengthen the economy, which would mean fighting Donald Trump and his tariffs. Then he goes and runs off and he's on a podcast where he's thanking Donald Trump. And then

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2673 he comes in here and says that somehow my pushing back, taking American booze off the shelves, is in some way leading Donald Trump to thank me. Nobody knows what the PCs are up to. Nobody knows what is going on in their heads. When it comes to us, one thing is clear: We build health care, we build buildings, we build the economy and we work hard for you each and every day. We'll continue to do that every single day and, of course, have some fun owning the Conservatives. Introduction of Guests The Speaker: Order, please. If we could get the clock stopped.

There's some more guests in the gallery. I would like to draw the attention of all honour - able members to the public gallery where we have with us 30 people who are watching proceedings as part of the normal Monday public tour. And we welcome you all here today. Affordability for Manitobans Proposed Policy Measures Mr. Konrad Narth (La Vérendrye): Honourable Speaker, this session should have been about making life more affordable, growing our economy and keeping jobs here in Manitoba.

Instead, this govern ment rejected real tax relief, ignored warning signs from busi nesses and passed a budget that does nothing to improve affordability or Manitoba's long-term competitiveness. We offered solutions, raising the basic personal exemption, eliminating land transfer tax for first-time homebuyers and imple menting a single -desk permitting system. This out-of-touch Premier rejected all of them. As members return to their con stituencies this summer, will the Premier finally start listening to Manitobans or does he still believe he knows better than the people that have elected him?

And I welcome his answer– The Speaker: Member's time has expired. French spoken Hon. Wab Kinew (Premier): Cet membre, ce député a fait une faute très grave, très, très grave. Et puis son chef aussi, qui a applaudi ce qu'il a dit. Mais leur commentaire dans les médias a dit que j'étais en train de mentir, alors pourquoi est -ce qu'il a à s'excuser si j't'ai menti? Translation That member–that MLA–made a very serious mistake– a very, very serious one. And so did his leader, who applauded what he said. But their comments in the media claimed that I was lying, so why does he have to apologize if I lied?

Economy, Taxes and Inflation Government's Record on Affordability Mrs. Lauren Stone (Midland): Let's look at this NDP's record since they've been elected: worst econ- omic growth in Canada, six straight quarters of busi - ness excess, 50 per cent of Manitobans within $200 of insolvency, the highest property taxes in Canada and among the highest provincial income taxes in Canada. And the NDP has now made Manitoba the infl ation capital of Canada. That's their record since they've been elected, despite the fact that Canada has now entered a technical recession and Manitobans deeply need more affordability relief.

So why is this Premier and this Kinew gov ern- ment ignoring the very real struggles that Manitoba families are facing? Hon. Adrien Sala (Minister of Finance): Let's take a look at our record, Honour able Speaker. We just passed a bill that's going to take the PST off all food in grocery stores in Manitoba. And let's dig deeper into our record. We came in– what do we do? We got rid of the gas tax for an entire year. Then we brought in a permanent 10 per cent gas tax cut. Then we brought in a hydro rate freeze.

Then we continued to do the work of making owning a home more affordable with increasing homeowner education property tax credits, the biggest cheques that have ever gone out before, supporting Manitobans with their costs of education property taxes. And, of course, renters. We're helping renters more than ever before. After the PCs raised taxes on renters we're doing the work of restoring that credit with that last BITSA bill that we just passed. We are going to continue– The Speaker: Member's time has expired. Children with Autism Support for Families in Southern Manitoba Mr.

Josh Guenter (Borderland): I've heard from parents of children with dis abilities about the gap in support services in southern Manitoba. These parents tell me that there are no government programs in their

2674 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 area to provide support to families who have children with autism. To fill this need, a local businessman, John Loewen and his family, along with the support of the commu- nity, have spearheaded an effort to set up a non-profit called Clover Creek Learning Centre to help families and children with ASD. This organi zation does great work, and will soon be opening a second location in Gretna. * (14:50) Can the minister commit to fixing the gap in the resources and the support that families in southern Manitoba are looking for? Hon.

Nahanni Fontaine (Minister of Families): Our government understands and is committed to sup- porting children and their families that are struggling with autism and ensuring that they get the supports that they need. That's why our government also raised the Children's disABILITY Services program by $900,000 in Budget 2025, but we also announced a n additional $5 million in increased spending in autism. And we are also, right now, looking and working with partners to create a centre of excellence in respect of autism.

Our government is committed to working with families and committed to continuing that important support for children with autism. Nurse Practitioners Working in Manitoba Request for Alternative Public Funding Model Mrs. Kathleen Cook (Roblin): Nurse practitioners are autonomous, highly trained clinicians who provide comprehensive patient care in every part of Manitoba. British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Ontario and PEI have all implemented new funding models that enable nurse practitioners to work independently, serve patients better and ensure those provinces are in compliance with the Canada Health Act.

When will the Minister of Health get on board with the rest of Canada and commit to implementing an alternative public funding model for nurse practitioners in Manitoba so that they no longer have to bill patients directly for services? Hon.

Uzoma Asagwara (Minister of Health, Seniors and Long -Term Care): Honourable Speaker, our government respects and appreciates the work –the invaluable work–that nurse practitioners do across our province each and every day, which is why we've met on many occasions with the nurse practitioners, and that's why we'll continue to meet with them, work with them and our partners to make sure that Manitobans have more access to the essential care they provide, not less. We have worked also with post -secondary to make sure that nurse practitioners can actually specialize now, moving forward in our province.

So there's a lot of work we're doing with our part- ners, including nurse practitioners, to move the profession in the direction they've asked; didn't happen for seven and a half years under the PCs. Alzheimer Society of Manitoba Funding Increase Announcement MLA Carla Compton (Tuxedo): Honourable Speaker, families affected by dementia deserve support they can count on. After years of uncertainty under the PCs, we're ensuring Manitobans living with dementia and their loved ones have access to the services they need.

This weekend, the minister joined hundreds of Manitobans at the Alzheimer Society of Manitoba walk. Can the Minister of Health, Seniors and Long- Term Care please tell Manitobans about the exciting announcement that they gave at the walk? Hon. Uzoma Asagwara (Minister of Health, Seniors and Long-Term Care): Honourable Speaker, great question from my friend from Tuxedo. Unlike the previous government, we're providing stable and long- term support for Manitobans living with dementia and the families who care for them.

This past Saturday, I was so proud to stand with my colleague and friend, the MLA for Kildonan-River East, to announce that our government is permanently increasing the annual funding for the Alzheimer Society of Manitoba to $525,000. And, on top of that, we are providing an additional $50,000 to support the caregivers of those with dementia across Manitoba. We know there's much more work to do, but we also know that we get good things done by working together, so let's keep doing that across Manitoba. Highway 110 and Richmond Avenue East Safety Concerns at Brandon Intersection Mr.

Wayne Balcaen (Brandon West): This Minister of Infrastructure is truly uninformed on her file. Last week, a 49 -year-old woman died in a crash at the known-to-be-unsafe intersection of Highway 110 and Richmond Avenue East. This minister says the intersection is safe and appropriate. She said that after

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2675 a woman died, and she said that after multiple Brandonites have raised concerns with this intersection. This is the second fatality at this intersection in five years, the fourth collision this year and the 11th in the last year and a half. This was a preventable tragedy. No intersections in Winnipeg are brought down by a single part on backorder, so why is the safety of my community an afterthought? Hon.

Lisa Naylor (Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure): There is a number of erroneous remarks in that question, but I'm going to first start with my first public opportunity to give my condol - ences to the family that was affected by this terrible tragedy.

And I want to say here what I've also been trying to say in the media and at every conversation with federal ministers–three federal ministers over the last two and a half years –the crux of this collision, the fault for this collision rests on the driver, an inexperienced driver operating with a company that have their licence, their operating ability taken away in Manitoba. But we have a problem across the country where operators are allowed to then get a fitness –a safety certificate in another province and be allowed to keep operating. That needs to stop. The Speaker: Member's time has expired.

Proposed Silica Sand Mine Project Uranium and Radon Exposure Concerns MLA Bob Lagassé (Dawson Trail): Residents living near the proposed silica sand mining project have raised concerns that drilling and groundwater disturbances could mobilize naturally occurring uranium and increase radon levels in nearby homes. Can the minister explain what assessment has been conducted on the potential for uranium mobiliza- tion and elevated radon 'exposion' –exposure for neighbouring homes and what mitigation and com - pensation program will be put in place if radon levels exceed Health Canada guidelines? Hon.

Mike Moyes (Minister of Environment and Climate Change): Quite frankly, we care about water and we care about the environment and Manitobans know who they can trust when it comes to this and everything else. The same can't be said for all of the members opposite in the PC caucus. They tried to ram through a controversial project that had a lot of questions that remained on the aquifer in southeast Manitoba. This attempted backroom deal was an absolute affront to our democracy. We're always going to protect our water. We're always going to protect our environment. And we stand for democracy.

The Speaker: The honourable member for Dawson Trail, on a supplementary question. Environmental Review Process MLA Lagassé: Manitobans were previously told that the proposed Sio Silica project required a higher level of environmental review under a class 3 designation. Now concerns have been raised that the project is being advanced under a class 2 process, which less scrutiny and fewer opportunities for public input.

Can the minister explain why this project is no longer being subjected to the more rigorous review process that was previously deemed necessary, and what assurances can he provide that the environment protection has not been compromised? MLA Moyes: Honourable Speaker, we know that we can build up our economy as well as protect the environment. This project is going through the normal process just like any other project that gets applied for. We're going to always ensure that the highest levels of environmental standards are applied to any project as well as the evaluation process.

Now when it comes to the record of the PCs, they tried to ram through a controversial mining project and this is why three members were fined by the Ethics Commissioner. We're not going to do that. We're going to ensure that all projects go through a rigorous process and I recommend the members of the PCs get on board. The Speaker: The honourable member for Dawson Trail, on a final supplementary question. Drinking Water Contamination Concerns MLA Lagassé: The Sio Silica proposal involves drilling into aquifer systems that supply drinking water to thousands of Manitobans.

Residents continue to express concerns about the potential risk to ground water quality and long-term water security. If there is a failure, contamination event or other environmental disaster affecting the aquifer, who will be responsible for the cleanup costs and what contingency plans has the government put in place to

2676 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 protect Manitoba families, communities and my constituents of Dawson Trail? MLA Moyes: To be perfectly clear, there's been no project that have been approved. In fact, the previous project that was applied for was denied by this government. We will always protect the environment; we will always protect the water. And we will always listen to Manitobans. Now it's clear that the PCs only work for them- selves and their high- rolling friends.

Their corrupt behaviour is why the Ethics Commissioner fined three members of their party, including the member for Red River North (Mr. Wharton). We'll never do that. We're always going to protect our environment and the water. * (15:00) Health-Care Workforce Number of Workers Added MLA Robert Loiselle (St. Boniface): L'Honorable Président [Honourable Speaker], after eight years of cuts, closures and chaos under the failed PC govern - ment, Manitobans were left with staffing shortages across the entire health -care system.

But instead of firing nurses, our government has been focused on rebuilding the front lines and strengthening patient care across the province. Can the Minister of Health, Seniors and Long-Term Care please tell Manitobans how many net -new health-care workers have been hired since our govern- ment took office? Hon. Uzoma Asagwara (Minister of Health, Seniors and Long -Term Care): I thank my friend from St. Boniface for that fantastic question. When the PCs were busy at working hard to fire nurses, we made a commitment to rebuild the front lines, and that's exactly what we're doing.

And today, our government is proud to say that we 've added over 4,000 net -new health-care workers to the front lines of Manitoba's health-care system. We've added over 350 doctors, bringing our total to a historic, a record-breaking 3,700 doctors practising here in Manitoba, helping families every single day; over 500 allied healthcare professionals, over 1,400 nurses–almost 1,500 nurses as of now–and over 1,700 health-care aides. Honourable Speaker, we are just getting started. We're going to keep fixing– The Speaker: Member's time has expired.

Association for Community Living Program and Operational Funding Mr. Wayne Ewasko (Lac du Bonnet): Association for Community Living organizations who support our community members living with disabilities are now being forced by this minister to sell their group homes, shut down supportive employment options and to stop taking new community members bec ause of her cuts to services by this Kinew government. I will table the Minister of Accessibility's own document that proves that her so-called increase is only inflationary.

Will she stand up and apologize to all those com- munity members all across this great province of ours, Honourable Speaker? Hon. Nahanni Fontaine (Minister responsible for Accessibility): The member for Lac du Bonnet con- tinues to get up in this Chamber and put up erroneous facts to try and peddle some narrative of his and the PCs. We know that we have investments in dis abil- ities, more than has ever been in the history of Manitoba. We are committed to folks that are on the front lines working with Manitobans with disabilities and supporting their families.

It is a sacred respon- sibility that our government takes incredibly seriously. And I would ask the member for Lac du Bonnet to stop peddling whatever he's trying to peddle and actually just get out of the way and allow us to continue the good work that we're doing, fixing the damage that they did for seven and a half years. Crime in Rural Manitoba Request for Measures to Address Ms. Jodie Byram (Agassiz): Summer has arrived and residents of Agassiz and right across rural Manitoba continue to experience an alarming rise in crime, including break- ins, thefts and trespassing on farm properties.

Many Manitoba residents feel vulnerable and the NDP camera rebates doesn't stop the crime. What measures is the Minister of Justice imple - menting to address rural crime ensuring the safety and security of our communities? What concrete steps is the minister administering to prevent such incidents? Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): Honourable Speaker, the concrete steps were in our budget document, the budget that mem - bers opposite voted against; an $8-million increase to the RCMP in communities all across this province.

And because we've invested in the RCMP, because we've partnered with community, we've been able to bring the vacancy rate, left at 30 per cent under

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2677 members opposite, down below 10 per cent in this province. That's real officers on the street, in commu- nities from the north to the south to the east to the west, Honourable Speaker. Boundary Trails Health Centre Request for Road Repairs Mrs. Carrie Hiebert (Morden-Winkler): Honour- able Speaker, Boundary Trails health centre sits on a high-traffic corridor and serves thousands of Manitobans daily.

Despite this, the road leading to the hospital is riddled with large potholes, forcing oncoming traffic to avoid damage –going into– 'torming'–sorry–forcing drivers into oncoming traffic to avoid damage. Will the minister commit to repairing this danger- ous stretch of highway imme diately–not just a patch job, but actually repairing all of the intersections in my constituency of Morden-Winkler? Hon.

Lisa Naylor (Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure): Certainly, whenever I get a question on highways in this Legislature, the theme that emerges is how frustrated all the new PC MLAs are with the previous govern ment and the fact that they underspent their budget year after year after year: they left these roads in disarray. And, you know, I have been very committed to raising the budget for our department, spending the full budget for our department.

And I'm very excited that Budget 2026 has an additional $10 million so that we can continue to repair the damage done to the infrastructure by the PC government before us. Thank you. Provincial Parks Specialty Licence Plates Mr. Greg Nesbitt (Riding Mountain): Bill 211, allowing for Manitoba Parks specialty licence plates, received royal assent in June of 2024. Two years later and Manitobans still can't show their love of our prov- incial park system or help sustain projects in these amazing parks. Clearly, this Minister of Environment and Climate Change seems more interested in credit than doing the work.

We FIPPA'd the delays, and it turns out they all lead back to this minister's office. Is this minister so ashamed that the PC caucus beat him to such a good idea that he would needlessly delay the availability of Parks plates for all Manitobans? Hon. Mike Moyes (Minister of Environment and Climate Change): Honourable Speaker, I appreciate that the member opposite finally got up on his feet and asked a question. I know that the Parks plate is the most pressing issue in our environment.

I –actually, no, I've never heard that from any environmental group, anywhere, or any Manitoban; although we do love our parks and so, you know, sure, we'll bring the plate forward. But I do want to talk about our record. What have we done in two and a half years? Started up an EV rebate, started the first wind–[interjection] The Speaker: Order. MLA Moyes: –farms, restored funding to environ- mental groups that they cut, supporting families with heat pumps, saved the Lemay Forest, started the –or, created the Path to Net Zero, had free park entry for over a year, created an efficiency power plant.

We did so much, and yet what does he focus on? The Speaker: Member's time has expired. Agricultural Equipment Copper Theft Prevention MLA Jeff Bereza (Portage la Prairie): Portage la Prairie farmers are fed up with the theft that they're – that now they're offering rewards of $10,000 to catch criminals stealing copper from equipment. That stolen copper can be turned into drug money. While this NDP government pours resources into drug-enabling policies, hard-working Manitobans are left paying the price through more theft, more disorder and less safety. Farmers shouldn't have to police their own communities.

Honourable Speaker, when will this government properly protect rural Manitobans? Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): Well, Honourable Speaker, we're mere moments away from the House rising and all of us returning back to our constituencies. I would encourage the member opposite to spend some time in Portage. Spend some time with the people there. Talk to them about the incredible initiatives that community has brought forward that they've partnered with us on, including the community safety officer program, coupled with the First Nation Safety Officer Program from Long Plain.

These are two shining examples for everyone in the province to see how municipalities can work with the Province. Funding those programs, funding the

2678 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 people on the street, making sure that crime's going down, that's what our government committed to, and that's what we're accomplishing. Rural Manitoba Roads Condition of Provincial Roads Mr. Rick Wowchuk (Swan River): Now, the only thing with more holes in it than the roads in rural Manitoba is this Infrastructure Minister's failed plan. I table some photos sent from my constituents. Provincial roads such as PTH 486, PR 363, PR 275 are riddled with massive potholes, some measuring up to 7 inches deep, 4 feet wide and 10 feet long.

And Provincial Road 487 washboards are shaking your dentures out. Enough is enough. If the minister isn't willing to do her job and main- tain these roads, can my constituents at least expense their next alignments to her office? * (15:10) Hon. Lisa Naylor (Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure): I thank the member opposite for that question, and I'm sincerely sorry about the state of his dentures.

What I would like to say is that it's clear that it's not just the new members of the government, but also previous members of the government who sat next to Transportation ministers year after year and allowed them to underinvest in the Transportation Department. Year after year, $300 -million, $400-million budgets that went underspent. So we're continuing to invest. We're investing in highways and infrastructure across the province. And I'll ask folks that are struggling with spring potholes– The Speaker: Member's time has expired. Condition of Highway 34 Timeline for Repairs Mrs.

Colleen Robbins (Spruce Woods): Honourable Speaker, Highway 34 has been named Manitoba's worst road for the second consecutive year in CAA's annual campaign to find the worst roadways in Manitoba. Highway 34 is an important corridor in my con- stituency of Spruce Woods and central Manitoba that connects the US border and Trans -Canada and the Yellowhead Highway. Unfortunately, potholes, deteriorating pavement and inadequate maintenance are putting motorists, truck drivers and families at risk every day.

When will the Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure finally commit the necessary funding and begin repairs on Highway 34 to ensure the safety of the Manitobans who rely on it? Hon. Wab Kinew (Premier): Honourable Speaker, as it turns out, it's hard to fix all the roads that the PCs left to decay under their watch for us under one term. I guess we'll need a second, if Manitobans will have one. Cost-of-Living Crisis Budget 2026 Measures Mrs. Lauren Stone (Midland): Things for Manitoba families here in Manitoba are getting worse under this NDP government.

The NDP has made Manitoba the inflation capital of Canada. And what's even worse is Manitoba is also the food inflation capital of Canada. Over 50 per cent of Manit obans are within $200 of insolvency. And yet this NDP government offered them nothing in their budget to help with this very real cost-of-living crisis. So how can this Premier and the Kinew govern- ment justify denying Manitobans $3,000 a year, which is money that Manitobans desperately need right now? Hon. Adrien Sala (Minister of Finance): Honour- able Speaker, what about no PST on food? What about free transit for youth?

And what about free child care for the lowest income families in Manitoba? We're going to go–we're going to keep going to work every single day. Phoenix School Renovation and Expansion Project Mrs. Kathleen Cook (Roblin): Phoenix School in Headingley is overcrowded and in desperate need of expansion. It is, in fact, the No. 1 capital priority of the St. James-Assiniboia School Division. The previous government approved the expansion and renovation project that students, teachers and families in Headingley have been asking for for years, but when the NDP took power, they cancelled the project.

When is this NDP government finally going to prioritize the teachers, students and families in Headingley and move forward with the Phoenix School expansion and renovation project?

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2679 Hon. Tracy Schmidt (Minister of Education and Early Childhood Learning): Honourable Speaker, the member speaks of priority, but the PCs waited 'til, like, question 25 today to ask a question about educa- tion. So I'm happy to speak about education. If the member opposite would have –we're going to work with the members in Charleswood. We're going to work with constituents all across the province.

In our beautiful budget, which we just passed last week, we announced four schools: Devonshire Park, we have a school in Brandon, we have a school in Waverley, we have a school in McPhillips. But that wasn't enough, Honourable Speaker. We had to build a school with– French spoken – la DSFM in Saint-Boniface. Pourquoi, Honour- able Speaker? Pour qui ? C'est pour les étudiants et les étudiantes, pour les éducateurs et les éducatrices. Ça – Translation –the DSFM in St. Boniface. Why, Honourable Speaker? For whom? It's for the students, for the educators.

That– English –that's who we work for in this province, Honour- able Speaker. The member opposite needs to get on board. [interjection] The Speaker: Order. Violence in Public Schools Frequency and Severity of Incidents Mr. Obby Khan (Leader of the Official Opposition): The Minister of Education, the Minister of Families (MLA Fontaine) and the Minister of Justice (Mr. Wiebe) love to yell from their seats but don't have any interest in actually doing their job. Maybe they're simply too busy watching The Matrix when they're supposed to be working.

The Minister of Education, according to Manitoba Teachers' Society, quote: Violence in Manitoba public schools has reached overwhelming levels, with educators reporting increases in both the frequency and severity of incidences. End quote. The Minister of Education swears she has all the data, but when we filed the freedom of infor mation request, what came back? No data found. Violence in schools is spiking. It's impacting the teachers' ability to teach. It's impacting students' ability to learn. And it undermines the entire education system under this failing Kinew government.

Will the minister admit she does not have the data, admit her failures and listen to Manitoba Teachers' Society, or will she tell Manitoba teachers how to do their job just like the Premier does? Hon. Wab Kinew (Premier): Honourable Speaker, we know that the issue of violence in schools is a major concern. We know that teachers and educational assistants and, really, everybody involved– parents, students–identify this as a top priority. And that's why our government is working together with them as partners.

And so we'll continue to do that over the course of the summer break so–ensure that when students and teachers go back in the fall, that everybody will be able to learn safely. When it comes to the PCs, though, they never seem to learn. Started question period today by trying to ask about dropping the writ. There's no election coming. He just wants to get out of here because he doesn't know how many more of his MLAs are going to drop out this summer. The Speaker: Order, please. The time for oral questions has expired. Speaker's Statement The Speaker: And I have a statement for the House.

As the House is expected to adjourn later today for our summer break, I'm encouraging all members to remove the contents of their desks today. I would encourage everyone to please recycle as much of the material as possible. Any material you would like to recycle may be placed in the larger recycling con - tainers in both message rooms located just outside of the Chamber. The big blue bins inside the Chamber are designed for–or, designated for recycling copies of Hansard only as these can be reused by Hansar d and the Legislative Library. Thank you. Petitions? Grievances?

2680 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 ORDERS OF THE DAY GOVERNMENT BUSINESS Hon. Nahanni Fontaine (Government House Leader): Could you please canvass the House for leave to consider a government reso lution regarding the hiring of the Chief Electoral Officer, despite the fact the resolution is not on the Order Paper? The Speaker: Is there leave, as requested by–is there leave to consider a gov ernment resolution regarding the hiring of the Chief Electoral Officer, despite the fact that the resolution is not on the Order Paper?

Is there leave? [Agreed] GOVERNMENT RESOLUTION Appointment of the Chief Electoral Officer Hon. Nahanni Fontaine (Government House Leader): I move, seconded by the Minister for Justice,

WHEREAS a Sub-Committee of the Standing Committee on Legislative Affairs was struck to manage the hiring process of the Chief Electoral Officer; and– Let me begin again, Honourable Speaker.

WHEREAS a Sub -Committee of the Standing Committee on Legislative Affairs was struck to manage the hiring process for the Chief Electoral Officer; and

WHEREAS the Sub-Committee, following an open competition and consid eration of applicants, recom - mended to the Standing Com mittee on Legis lative Affairs that Josh Watt be appointed Chief Electoral Officer; and

WHEREAS the Standing Com mittee on Legis - lative Affairs recommends the same to the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba. THEREFORE

BE IT RESOLVED that, pursuant to

section 23(1) of The Elections Act, Josh Watt will be appointed as the Chief Electoral Officer effective July 15, 2026. * (15:20) The Speaker: So it's been moved by the honourable Minister of Families (MLA Fontaine), seconded by the honourable Minister of Justice (Mr. Wiebe), that THEREFORE

be it resolved that pursuant to

section 23(1)– Some Honourable Members: Dispense. The Speaker: Dispense. Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt–[interjection] The honourable Government House Leader. MLA Fontaine: On behalf of our NDP caucus and our NDP government, we want to welcome you to your new position as the Chief Electoral Officer. We have all confidence that you will do your duties with amazing resolve. And welcome to your new role.

The Speaker: Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt the motion? [Agreed] The motion is accordingly passed. * * * MLA Fontaine: Honourable Speaker, please call the government motion in respect to Bill 300, followed by the government motion with respect to Bill 301. I now would also like to table the specified government bills –apologies–for the third session of the 43rd Legislature; and then, Honourable Speaker, can you please call concurrence and third reading of Bills 3, 4, 8, 9, 31, 34, 40, 42, 44, 5, 6, 36, 11, 15, 16, 18, 37, 19, 26, 27, 28, 32, 50, 29, 35, 45, 33, 38, 41 and 43.

The Speaker: So it has been announced that we will now proceed to government motion in respect to Bill 300; followed by the government motion with respect to Bill 301; followed by the specified govern- ment bills, Bill 3, 4, 8, 9, 31, 34, 40, 42, 44, 5, 6, 36, 11, 15, 16, 18, 37, 19, 26, 27, 28, 32, 50, 29, 35, 45, 33, 38, 41 and 43. GOVERNMENT MOTIONS The Speaker: So now we will consider the govern- ment motion that fees paid with respect to Bill 300, The Winnipeg Foundation Amendment Act, be refunded, less the cost–okay. Hon.

Nahanni Fontaine (Government House Leader): I move, seconded by the Minister for Education, THAT the fees paid with respect to Bill 300, The Winnipeg Foundation Amendment Act, be refunded, less the cost of printing. Motion agreed to. MLA Fontaine: I move, seconded by the Minister for Natural Resources and Indigenous Futures, THAT the fees paid with respect to Bill 301, The Westminster United Church Foundation Incorporation Amendment Act, be refunded, less the cost of printing. Motion agreed to.

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2681 CONCURRENCE AND THIRD READINGS The Speaker: So now we'll move on to concurrence and third reading of the bills as laid out earlier, starting with Bill 3. Bill 3–The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister responsible for the Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation): I move, seconded by the Minister of Housing, Addictions and Homelessness (Ms. Smith), that Bill 3, The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act, reported from the Standing Committee on Justice, be concurred in and be now read for a third time a nd passed.

Motion presented. Mr. Wiebe: I'm pleased to rise in the House today for third reading of Bill 3, The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act. This bill is about keep- ing insurance rates affordable for Manitobans by preserving MPI's current registered owner insurance model. Manitobans already benefit from some of the lowest auto insurance rates in Canada, and this bill keeps it that way. Our system uses a simple and fair driver safety rating where drivers with a good driving record play–pay less and drivers with a poor drivi ng record pay more.

Manitobans are overwhelmingly supportive of the current registered driver model. In fact, at public committee, several Manitobans came in to voice their support for this legislation. If members opposite really do care about afford - ability for Manitobans, I expect that they might actually support this bill here in the Legislature this evening. I urge all members to pass Bill 3, The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act, to ensure that Manitobans can continue to enjoy some of the most affordable auto insurance rates in the country. Thank you, Honourable Speaker. Mr.

Trevor King (Lakeside): I rise today to speak to third reading of Bill 3. And let me begin with some - thing and make it very clear that every member in this House can agree on affordability and how much it matters: Manitoba families are dealing with rising costs everywhere they turn. They expect us to protect affordability wherever we can, and they expect us to ensure that public insurance remains stable, fair and financially responsible for the long term. That is exactly why we on this side cannot support Bill 3.

Because despite all of the government's talking points, despite all of the slogans about protecting affordability, there is one central problem with this legislation: there is no evidence proving this bill will actually make insurance more affordable for Manitobans. It's not my opinion, Honourable Speaker; it is a reality established through the Public Utilities Board process itself.

The Public Utilities Board, the independent regulator created to protect ratepayers, ordered MPI to study and evaluate a primary- driver module because evidence presented during hearings suggested the current registered owner model may distort risk and force safer drivers to subsidize higher risk drivers. The PUB did not make that direction casually. It came after years of hearings, actuar ial review, evidence, expert testimony and public participation. * (15:30) When MPI challenged the PUB authority in court, the Manitoba Court of Appeal rejected that appeal.

Justice Freda Steel was very clear, the court confirmed that the PUB has jurisdiction over the methodology underlying the driver safety rating system. In ot her words, the regulator responsible for protecting Manitoba's ratepayers has the legal authority to examine whether MPI risk model is fair, accurate and actuarily sound.

After losing in court to MPI, it publicly stated it would work collaboratively with the PUB toward a model that provides the greatest value for Manitobans, but instead of allowing that evidence-based process to continue, this government has introduced Bil l 3 to legislate the current registered -owner model directly into statute. Honourable Speaker, that is a problem before us today. The government is not bringing forward com - pleted evidence, the government is not bringing forward a finished pricing study, the government is not bring- ing forward actuarial proof.

Instead, it is legislating first and asking questions later. And even MPI's own CEO acknowledged during the PUB proceedings that MPI does not yet have the data necessary to determine which model is actually more affordable. And that point matters because if MPI itself canno t say which system costs less, how can this government claim Bill 3 is an affordability measure? How can the minister repeatedly say this bill pro- tects affordability when the underlying analysis has

2682 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 not even been completed? The answer is, Honourable Speaker, that they cannot. Insurance pricing is not supposed to be based on politics. It is supposed to be based on actuarial science. It is supposed to reflect measurable risk. That is how you protect fairness, that is how you maintain stability and that is how you avoid sudden rate shocks in the future. When governments out–override evidence-based regulatory processes, there are no consequences.

Blocking a single desk–single risk model permanently into legislation removes flexibility from MPI systems; driving behaviour changes, technology changes, claims pattern change, risk profiles change. And when the governments tie the hands of regulators and actuaries, corrections eventually become unavoidable. That means bigger adjustments later. That means larger premium increases in the future. That is not long- term afford- ability, that is short-term politics. Consumer advocates have also raised serious concerns about this legislation.

The Consumers' Association of Canada (Manitoba) and the Manitoba Seniors Equity Action Coalition have both warned against proceeding without evidence. Importantly, they have not endorsed either model outright. Instead, they have said the same thing we are saying right here today: collect the data, complete the analysis, allow the independent regulator to do its job.

Those organizations warn that this current system can create distortions where safer drivers–excuse me– safer drivers pay more than their fair share because the actual primary driver of the vehicle may be someone entirely different from the registered owne r, and MPI's own data appears to support concerns about that distortion. We know that a significant number of collisions involve someone other than the registered owner driving the vehicle. We know that many claims occur when the registered owner is not the primary operator.

Those are exactly the kinds of issues the PUB wanted studied through an evidence-based review. Instead of completing that work, this government is shutting the door before the evidence is even gathered. What makes this situation even more striking is the inconsistency from members opposite regarding independent oversight.

For years, the NDP members passionately defended the authority of the Public Utilities Board when discussing Manitoba Hydro, they warn ed repeatedly about governments setting rates at the Cabinet table, they accused previous governments of circumventing the PUB, they said removing independent oversight would weaken trans- parency and accountability. Those were not isolated comments. Those argu - ments were repeated over and over again by members opposite, including senior ministers and even the Premier (Mr. Kinew) himself. Independent oversight either matters or it doesn't.

You cannot defend the PUB when it is politically convenient and dismiss it when its findings become uncomfortable. Our position is straightforward: if the government has a credible actuarial evidence providing that the registered-owner model clearly more affordable and more sustainable, then let Manitobans see it. Table the study, release the data, allow the PUB to review it publicly. That is how independent regulation is sup- posed to work. But that–but today, that evidence doesn't exist, and because of it doesn't exist, this House is being asked to pass legislation based on assumptions instead of facts.

That is not responsible govern ance, it is not evidence-based policy making and it is c ertainly not how we should manage a public insurance system relied upon by hundreds of thousands of Manitobans. At report stage, we 'reprosed' –proposed reason- able amendments. Not radical amendments, not ideo - logical amendments–reasonable amendments. We've proposed requiring MPI to complete a comprehensive actuarial comparison between the registered -owner model and a primary- driver model. We proposed requiring analysis of impacts on young drivers, seniors, rural Manitobans and multi -driver house - holds.

We proposed independent review of the driver safety rating system itself to ensure fairness and actuarial soundness. And we proposed that those reports be tabled publicly in this Legislature so Manitobans could see the evidence for themselves. Those are common sense proposals. If the government is truly confident this model is superior, then why oppose independent analysis? Why oppose transparency? Why oppose evidence? Affordability cannot simply be declared; it must be demonstrated. And the role of the Public Utilities Board is to ensure that rates remain fair, transparent and actuarially sound for everyone.

Bill 3 weakens that process. It limits the regulator's ability to examine methodology, it overrides years of PUB direction and it bypasses the very evidence the government claims supports its position. We believe Manitobans deserve better than that. They deserve transparency, they deserve evidence,

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2683 they deserve independent oversight, and they deserve insurance policy built on actuarial reality, not political messaging. For those reasons, Honourable Speaker, we cannot support Bill 3. Thank you. The Speaker: Is the House ready for the question? Some Honourable Members: Question. The Speaker: The question before the House is concurrence and third reading of Bill 3, The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Amendment Act. Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt the motion? Some Honourable Members: Agreed. Some Honourable Members: No. The Speaker: I hear a no.

Voice Vote The Speaker: All those in favour, please say aye. Some Honourable Members: Aye. The Speaker: All those opposed, please say nay. Some Honourable Members: Nay. The Speaker: In my opinion, the Ayes have it. Mr. King: On division, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: The motion is accordingly passed, on division. Bill 4–The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act The Speaker: As previously announced, we will now move on to Bill 4, The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act. Hon.

Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): I move, seconded by the Minister of Education, that Bill 4, The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act, reported from the Standing Committee on Justice, be concurred in and now be – and be now read a third time and passed. Motion presented. Mr. Wiebe: I'm pleased to rise to third reading on Bill 4. At its core, this bill is about holding govern- ments accountable to protect the rights of citizens. Bill 4 requires that whenever the notwithstanding clause is used, the government must automatically refer that decision to the Court of Appeal for review.

If a Manitoba government does invoke the notwith- standing clause, we just want to make sure that Manitobans have the information that they need when they then go to vote. We've seen how certain right -wing governments in other jurisdictions have used the notwithstanding clause to attack the rights of minorities and vulnerable people in communities.

And we want to make it clear here in Manitoba that these hateful human right s violations have no place in this province. * (15:40) While members opposite campaigned against the rights of LGBTQIA+ Manitobans, on this side of the House, we're committed to protecting the rights of vulnerable Manitobans. We are building one Manitoba, a Manitoba where everyone feels valued and pro- tected, and Manitobans deserve a government that they can trust to do this. They deserve a government that's accountable, and that they deserve a government that stands against hate and discrimination.

I'm proud that Bill 4 has the support of many community groups, including the National Council of Canadian Muslims, the Rainbow Resource Centre, the Criminal Defence Lawyers Association of Manitoba, the Public Service Alliance of Canada, Manitoba Federation of Labour, the Manitoba Federation of Union Retirees, who have all advocated for this bill at public committee. I urge all members of this House to support the government's accountability–to support a government accountability, pardon me, by passing Bill 4, The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act, today. Thank you, Honourable Speaker. Mr.

Wayne Balcaen (Brandon West): Bill 4 adds yet another procedural layer, but no new legal safe - guards. That is very typical of what we've seen by this NDP government, is increasing red tape. It does not strengthen Charter protection since judicial and political checks already exist throughout

section 1, litigation and public accountability at election time.

Section 33 already balances the legislative suprem- acy and judicial oversight. This bill's mandatory reference process adds costs and delays without alter- ing rights protection. The rights most fundamental to democracy, equality and Indigenous peoples remain untouchable under

section 33 of our Charter. True accountability rises from open legislative debate and public consent, not repetitive legal procedures, which this NDP government is trying to rely upon. Bill 4 does not confer any new protection of the Charter of Rights in the Constitution. The Constitution

2684 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA June 1, 2026 was created by democratically elected representatives from the provinces and federal government. They came to a compromise that balanced the powers of the federal government, provincial government and the judiciary. The Charter, through sections 1 and 33, gives the final say to the electorate, not the judiciary, thus entrench- ing the supremacy of democracy. Manitoba has never invoked

section 33. The NDP government has stated it never intends to do so, nor does the PC Party.

Section 33 already contains strong democratic safeguards: express declaration is required, five -year sunset and public renewal. All Manitobans continue to enjoy absolute protection of democratic mobility, equality, language and Indigenous rights, regardless of

section 33 of the Charter. The proposal may be seen as more political theatre than constitutional reform. Something that this Justice Minister and the NDP are famous for is that political theatre. To say that this bill protects demo - cratic rights is inaccurate;

section 33 cannot override democratic rights. Bill 4 formalizes this principle. Any future invocation must be automatically referred to the Manitoba charter –or Court of Appeal for an advisory opinion. This would make Manitoba the first province in Canada with a mandatory judicial review mechanism tied to

section 33. This, again, ties up the courts and is costly for Manitobans, not required and is not a protection of Manitobans. Under the national content, the federal govern- ment, the Parliament of Canada, has never invoked

section 33. Successive Justice ministers have rejected its use as inconsistent with federal leadership on Charter of Rights. Presently, there is a case before the Supreme Court, Hak v. Quebec, in which Mani toba and many other provinces have intervener status. It would have been wise for this government and for this Minister of Justice to await the ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada on this very topic before entering legislation that will become either inept or, at worst, hitting the garbage can. Premier Kinew and – sorry, the Premier (Mr. Kinew)– The Speaker: Order, please.

I'd remind members that we're not allowed to use members' names. You have constituency or their ministerial title. Mr. Balcaen: My apologies, Honourable Speaker. The Kinew government and the Minister of Justice has presented Bill 4 as a transparency measure, arguing it would guarantee Manitobans' visibility into the future attempts to override Charter rights. There is no particular urgency to this bill, as there is no pressing matter of public concern that would make the passage of this bill important.

Any bill that may alter the application of the Constitution, especially when it impacts Charter rights, requires thorough consultation. Again, that has not happened. Given the relevant–given that relevant matters are currently before the Supreme Court, this bill seems premature and may be rendered moot by the ruling. I brought forward a report stage amendment that actually said: but the court may decline to consider the matter if the court has already decided the issue set out in subsection 2 at the end of the proposed subsection 1.1.

Bill 4 should not force the Court of Appeal to re -hear issues that have already been decided by a court. Our amendment was a practical safeguard to pre- vent duplication, unnecessary delay and the misuse of judicial resources. Unfortunately, those were all turned down by this NDP government. We simply cannot support political theatre when it comes to our democracy and our Charter. Thank you, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: Is the House ready for the question? The question before the House is concurrence and third reading of Bill 4, The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act.

Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt the motion? Some Honourable Members: Agreed. The Speaker: Agreed and so ordered– Some Honourable Members: No. The Speaker: Oh, there was a no. Voice Vote The Speaker: So, all those in House in favour, please say aye. Some Honourable Members: Aye. The Speaker: All those opposed, please say nay. Some Honourable Members: Nay. The Speaker: The Ayes have it, in my opinion. Mr. Balcaen: On division, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: The motion is accordingly passed, on division.

June 1, 2026 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA 2685 Bill 8–The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Amendment Act The Speaker: And we will now move on to Bill 8, The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Amendment Act. Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): I move, seconded by the Minister of Agri- culture (Mr. Kostyshyn), that Bill 8, The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Amendment Act, reported from the Standing Committee on Justice, be concurred in and be now read for a third time and passed. Motion presented. Mr.

Wiebe: I'm pleased to rise in the House today for the third reading of Bill 8, The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Amendment Act. This bill is about keeping Manitobans safe by keeping dangerous long- bladed weapons out of the hands of youth and criminals. * (15:50) In 2024, we introduced The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Act, which banned the sale of machetes and long-bladed weapons to minors. As a direct result of this legislation, Winnipeg saw a 24.1 per cent decrease in youth weapon offences in 2025.

This brings us to a total of 41 per cent decrease in youth violent crime with a weapon as compared to the previous government. Our government has greatly reduced the number of dangerous weapons in the hands of youth over the last year. But we know that online sellers and resale platforms are still selling these weapons without proper age checks. Bill 8 puts an end to that by banning online and secondary sellers from selling long-bladed weapons to minors.

While the members opposite fired 55 Winnipeg police officers and cut front-line safety resources, our government is choosing targeted and evidence -based action to make our communities safer and reduce the rate of violent crime. This bill has strong support from law en forcement, municipalities, Indigenous leader - ship, the retail sector and Manitobans who have voiced their support for this legislation at public com- mittee. Manitobans, they want safer streets, and that's what this bill delivers.

Honourable Speaker, I urge all members to support Bill 8 to keep long-bladed weapons out of the hands of young people and criminals. Thank you, Honourable Speaker. The Speaker: No further speakers? Is the House ready for the question then? Some Honourable Members: Question. The Speaker: Question before the House is concur - rence and third reading of Bill 8, The Long- Bladed Weapon Control Amendment Act. Is it the pleasure of the House to adopt the motion? [Agreed] The motion is accordingly passed. Bill 9–The Street Weapons Control Act The Speaker: We will now move on to Bill 9, The Street Weapons Control Act.

Hon. Matt Wiebe (Minister of Justice and Attorney General): I move that Bill 9, The Street Weapons Control Act, reported from the Standing Com mittee on Justice, be concurred in and now be read for a third time and passed. The Speaker: The honourable Minister of Justice. Mr. Wiebe: I move, seconded by the Minister of Municipal and Northern Relations (Mr. Simard), that Bill 9, The Street Weapons Control Act, reported from the Standing Committee on Justice, be concurred in and be now read for a third time and passed. Motion presented. Mr.

Wiebe: I'm pleased to rise in the House today for third reading of Bill 9, The Street Weapons Control Act. Unlike members opposite who front –who cut front-line safety resources and fired 55 Winnipeg police officers, our government is c

Document details

Collection	Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)
Citation	43-3-64
Type	hansard
Volume / chapter	43rd 3rd hansardpdf 64.pdf
Language	en
Format	pdf
Source	PROVINCIAL
Identifier	993929cb5c346d52e94f78e090f0f389440bb8d1

Source file is stored in the law ingest library (pdf).