Manitoba Hansard — 35th 1st hansardpdf 35th 1st index

35th 1st hansardpdf 35th 1st index

Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)

MG-8048 INDEX of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES and PROCEEDINGS 39-40 Elizabeth II First Session - Thirty-Fifth Legislature which opened the 11th of October, 1990 and prorogued the 6th of March, 1991 Volume XXXIX Printed by the Office of the OUHns Printer. Province of Manltobs

TABLE OF CONTENTS Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES AND PROCEEDINGS First Session - Thirty-Fifth Legislature Table of Contents .................................................................. I Ust of Members ... .................................................................. II Legislative Assembly ............................................................. Ill Introduction............................................................................

IV Member/Subject Index........................................................... 1 Appendices Appendix A: Oral Questions .............................. ................ 131 Appendix 8: Members of Executive Council...................... 151 Appendix C: Standing and Special Committees................ 153

MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thlrty·Fifth Legislature Members, Constituencies and Political Affiliation NAME ALCOCK, Reg ASHTON, Steve BARRETT, Becky CARR, James CARSTAIRS, Sharon CERILLI, Marianne CHEEMA, Guizar CHOMIAK, Dave CONNERY, Edward, Hon. CUMMINGS, Glen, Hon. DACOUAY, Louise DERKACH, Leonard, Hon. DEWAR, Gregory DOER, Gary DOWNEY, James, Hon. DRIEDGER, Albert, Hon. DUCHARME, Gerry, Hon. EDWARDS, Paul ENNS, Harry, Hon. ERNST, Jim, Hon. EVANS,Ciif EVANS, Leonard S. FILMON, Gary, Hon. FINDLAY, Glen, Hon. FRIESEN, Jean GAUDRY,Neil GILLESHAMMER, Harold, Hon. HARPER, Elijah HELWER, Edward R.

HICKES, George LAMOUREUX, Kevin LATHLIN, Oscar LAURENDEAU, Marcel MALOWAY, Jim MANNESS, Clayton, Hon. MARTINDALE, Doug McALPINE, Gerry McCRAE, James, Hon. MciNTOSH, linda MITCHELSON, Bonnie, Hon. NEUFELD, Harold, Hon. ORCHARD, Donald, Hon. PENNER, Jack, Hon. PLOHMAN, John PRAZNIK, Darren, Hon. REID, Daryl REIMER, Jack RENDER, Shirley ROCAN, Denis, Hon. ROSE, Bob SANTOS, Conrad STEFANSON, Eric STORIE, Jerry SVEINSON, Ben VODREY, Rosemary WASYL YCIA-LEIS, Judy WOWCHUK, Rosann CONSTITUENCY Osborne Thompson Wellington Crescentwood River Heights Radisson The Maples Kildonan Portage Ia Prairie Ste.

Rose Seine River Roblin-Russell Selkirk Concordia Arthur-Virden Steinbach Riel St. James Lakeside Charleswood Interlake Brandon East Tuxedo Springfield Wolseley St. Boniface Minnedosa Rupertsland Gimli Point Douglas Inkster The Pas St. Norbert Elmwood Morris Burrows Sturgeon Creek Brandon West Assiniboia River East Rossmere Pembina Emerson Dauphin lac du Bonnet Transcona Niakwa St. VItal Gladstone Turtle Mountain Broadway Kirkfield Park Ain Ron La Verendrye Fort Garry St. Johns Swan River II PARTY.

Liberal NDP NDP Liberal Liberal NDP liberal NDP PC PC PC PC NDP NDP PC PC PC liberal PC PC NDP NDP PC PC NDP liberal PC NDP PC NDP liberal NDP PC NDP PC NDP PC PC PC PC PC PC PC NDP PC NDP PC PC PC PC NDP PC NDP PC PC NDP NDP

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Lieutenant-Governor of Manitoba ..... .............. Hon. Dr. George Johnson Speaker of the Legislative Assembly .............. Hon. Denis C. Rocan, M.L.A. Deputy Speaker and Chairman of Committee of the Whole ............................ Mrs. Louise Dacquay, M.L.A. Deputy Chairman of Committee of the Whole ............................ Mr. Marcel Laurendeau, M.L.A. Government House Leader. ............................ Hon. Clayton Manness, M.L.A. Opposition House Leader ............................... Mr. Gary Doer, M.L.A. Second Opposition House Leader .................. Mr.

Reg Alcock, M.L.A. Government Whip ....... ................... .......... ....... Mr. Edward Helwer, M.L.A. Opposition Whip.............................................. Mr. George Hickes, M.L.A. Second Opposition Whip ................................ Mr. Kevin Lamoureux, M.L.A. Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ................... Mr. W. H. Remnant Deputy Clerk of the Legislative Assembly....... Ms. Beverley Bosiak Ms. Patricia Chaychuk-Fitzpatrick Clerk of Committees ...................... ................. Ms. Bonnie Greschuk Legislative Counsel.... ............ .........................

Shirley Strutt Sergeant-at-Arms....... ..................................... Mr. Clifford S. Morrissey Chief of Hansard Services ...... ... . .................. .. Suzanne L. Dion Hansard Indexer .......... ......... ................. ......... Ms. Brenda L. Walker Ill

INTRODUCTION Manitoba Hansard Index is designed to provide easy access to topics discussed in the Legislative Assembly. For this reason, it corresponds strictly to the text of Manitoba Hansard. FORMAT The index is in two sections: (1) combined Member/Subject index, and

(2) Appendices. Member/SubJect Index: Main entry in this

section is a subject or personal name heading which may be subdivided. Following the main entry are secondary headings, see and see also references, and a listing of individuals who spoke on that subject. Appendices: Included in this

section is a complete listing of Oral Questions by department, Members of the Executive Council, and matters referred to Standing and Special Committees. - -- FILING ARRANGEMENT The basic filing principle is alphabetical, letter by letter. The sequence is as follows:

a) numbers file at the beginning of the alphabet, if they are the first word in the filing element;

b) initials separated by punctuation, abbreviations, acronyms without interior punctuation are filed at the beginning of their alphabetic group. ABBREVIATIONS 1 r ...................................... First Reading 0/C .............................. Order-in-Council 2r ................................. Second Reading P/0 .................................. Point of Order 3r ..................................... Third Reading RIR ........................ Read and Received Arndt ................................... Amendment CIW ................. Committee of the Whole RIA ....................................

Royal Assent RIS .................................... Report Stage (M) .............................................. Motion S.P ............................... Sessional Paper T.P ................................... Tabled Paper IV

Hansard Index 4-H Week See Non-Political Statements A.E. McKenzie Seeds Announcement Downey 2490; Rose 2489-90 Auditor's Report, 1988 and 1989 (S.

P. 39) Downey318 Funding status Downey 704-5; Rose 704 News release (T.P. 119) Downey2483 ACCESS Program Continuation Doer 438-40; Filmon 439-40 Funding Cheema 1086; Doer 3120; Filmon 3120-1; Man ness 1087 Student recruitment Chomiak 97; Derkach 97-8 ACRE Group proposal Hazardous waste storage Doer 937; Filmon 937 AIDS Education Family life curriculum Carstairs 2296; Orchard 2296 Prevention programs Carstairs 2295-6; Orchard 2296 Government initiatives Cheema 3013-9; Orchard 3008-22; Wasylycia-Leis 3008-12, 3020-2 HIV studies Patient notification Cheema 984; Orchard 984 Patient participation Cheema 984; Orchard 984 Public awareness Cheema 984; Orchard 984 Aboriginal Concerns, Royal Commission on Establishment Filmon 820; Lathlin 819 Aboriginal Honour CelebraUon Banquet See Non-Political Statements 1 Aboriginal Issues Throne speech Downey 236; Harper 236 Aboriginal Justice Inquir y Report release Harper 1403; McCrae 1403 See also Justice, Department of (S upply) Aboriginal language program Funding Downey 190; Ducharme 369; Filmon 369; Hickes 190, 369 Government priority Filmon 370; Hickes 370 Aboriginal rights Hunting Downey 16-7; Enns 236-7; Harper 236; Lathlin 16-7 Aboriginal tribal councils Health services administration Derkach 1621 ; Lathlin 1621 Adjournment Motion Manness 3139 Agape House Funding Barrett 15; Gilleshammer 15-6 Agassiz Youth Centre Living conditions Edwards 98; McCrae 98-9 Renovations Alcock 362-3; Driedger 362-3; McCrae 363 Report tabling request Edwards 99; McCrae 99-100 Age and Opportunity Centre Funding Downey 2382, 2557; Orchard 2558; Santos 2381-2, 2557-8 Agricultural Producers' Organization Certification Agency Annua1Report,1989 ( S.P.33) Findlay 157

Hansard Index Agricultural assistance Debt restructuring Findlay 1324-5; Plohman 1324 Deficiency payments Film on 2490, 2610, 2661-2; Plohman 2490, 2661-2; Wowchuk 2610 Enhancement Findlay 679-86; Plohman 678-86 Federal responsibility Findlay 1325; Plohman 1325 Fuel tax rebate Findlay 19, 628-9; Plohman 19; Wowchuk 628 GRIP proposal C.

Evans 1012-3; Findlay 1012-3 Government action Filmon 2490; Findlay 1324; Plohman 1324, 2490-1 Land lease program Filmon 261 0; Wowchuk 261 0 Agricultural assistance-Federal Manitoba position Findlay 234-5; Plohman 234-5 Responsibility Findlay 2037-8; Plohman 2037 Agricultural economy All-party task force Filmon 983-4; Plohman 983 Agricultural productivity Federal statement, rejection of Findlay 982; Plohman 982 Agriculture, Department of Annua1Report,1989(S.P.2 7) Findlay257 Employment Security memorandum (T.

P. 97) Wowchuk 1326 Staffing Findlay 1326-7; Wowchuk 1326-7 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 67) Findlay 1322 Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Findlay 1921-4 Response Carstairs 1926-8; Plohman 1924-6 2 Agriculture (Supply) - Cont.

Administration and Finance Communications Branch Salaries Carstairs 1941-2; Findlay 1942 Excess Summerfallow Compensation Program Carstairs 1947-8; Findlay 1948 Executive Support Other Expenditures Carstairs 1936-9; Findlay 1928-41 ; Plohman 1928-36, 1939-41 Financial and Administrative Services Other Expenditures Findlay 1943; Plohman 1942-3 Minister's Salary Plohman 21 02 Personnel Services Other Expenditures Carstairs 1945-6; Findlay 1943-6; Plohman 1943-5 Program Analysis Other Expenditures Findlay 1946-7; Plohman 1946-7 Agricultural Development and Marketing Administration Salaries Carstairs 2021-30; Findlay 2012-30; Plohman 2012-21 Federal-Provincial Agreements Agri-Food Agreement Findlay 2099-21 00; Plohman 2099-2101 Soil Conservation Agreement Findlay 21 01 ; Plohman 21 01 Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Carstairs 2006-10; Findlay 2002-10; Plohman 2002-6, 201 0 Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Canada-Manitoba Waterfowl Compensation Agreement Findlay 2002; Plohman 2002 Premiums Carstairs 1953-7, 1998-2000; Findlay 1948-59, 1991-2002; Plohman 1948-53, 1957-9, 1991-8, 2000-2 Policy and Economics Division Carstairs 2075-81 ; Enns 2080-1 ; Findlay 2076-98; Plohman 2081-98 Manitoba Farm Lands Ownership Board Salaries Findlay 2099; Plohman 2099 Regional Agricultural Services Division Agricultural Crown Lands Branch Findlay 2074-5; Plohman 2074-5

Agriculture - Cont.

Interlake Region Carstairs 207-23; Findlay 2072-4; Plohman 2073-4 Northwest Region Findlay 2070-2; Plohman 2070-2 Agriculture Ind ustry Cost-of-production formula Findlay 821-2, 982-3; Plohman 821, 983 Debt restructuring Filmon 1199 -1200; Findlay 1623, 2095-7; Plohman 1199-1200, 1623,2095-7 Deficiency payments Findlay 1623; Plohman 1623 Diversification Findlay 2092-4; Plohman 2092-4 Economic conditions Findlay 470-1; Plohman 470-1 Fuel tax rebate Findlay 1622-3; Plohman 1622 Interest rate assistance program Carstairs 263, 2078-80; Enns 2080-1 ; Findlay 263, 2078-80, 2081-8; Plohman 2081-8 Irrigation strategy Findlay 2094; Plohman 2094 Safety net program Rndlay 2037, 2088-9; Plohman 2037, 2088-9 Subsidy totals Carstairs 2081 ; Rndlay 2081 Agri-Food Agreement Food processing research Ernst 1206-7; Storie 1206 Replacement Findlay 1946-7; Plohman 1946-7 Air ambulance program Funding Orchard 443; Wasylycia-Leis 443 Alcock, Reg (Liberal, Osborne) Budget Debate 577-80,590-4 Family Services, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Gilleshammer 1266-8 Response 1271-3 Administration and Finance Agency Relations Bureau Hansard Index 3 Alcock, Reg - Cont.

Salaries 1556, 1563-7 4 Executive Support Salaries 1345-52 Management Services Finance and Administrative Services Salaries 1575-6 Information Systems Salaries 1676-82 Program Budgeting and Reporting Salaries 1577 Social Services Advisory Committee Salaries 1687-90 Minister's Salary 2763-4 Planning and Research Salaries 1357-62, 1364-9, 1435-54 Child and Family Services Administration Salaries 1979-91, 2044-8 Child and Family Support Salaries 2060-70, 2160-75 Children's Special Services Salaries 2437-45, 2493-5 Family Dispute Services Salaries 2181-2, 2418-9, 2426-33 Seven Oaks Youth Centre Salaries 2177-9 Day Care, Youth and Employment Support Child Day Care Salaries 2616-31, 2700-5 Special Programs and Immigrant Services Branch Operations 2752-63 Youth Employment Services Branch Operations 2708-14 Regional Employment Services 2715-7 Income Security 2504-18 Registration and Licensing Services Residential Care Licensing Salaries 1699-1701 Vital Statistics Salaries 1695-6 Rehabilitation and Community Living Administration 1736-44 Manitoba Developmental Centre Salaries 1753-4 Operations Salaries 17 46-9 Programs Salaries 1759, 1961-8 Finance, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Manness 705-6

Hansard Index Alcock, Reg - Cont.

Response 709 Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 713, Financial and Administrative Services Other Expenditures 714 Salaries 714 Human Resource Management Salaries 716 Financial and Management Systems Salaries 731 Minister's Salary 1095-1106 Comptroller's Division Disbursements and Accounting Other Expenditures 770 Salaries 769-70 Information Systems Support Salaries 771-3 Systems Operations 77 4 Federal-Provincial Relations and Research Division Economic and Federal-Provincial Research Branch Salaries 836-8, 845-7, 849-50 Taxation Division Administration Salaries 775-9 Corporation Capital Tax/Health and Post-Secondary Education Tax Levy Branch 790-3,795 Retail Sales Tax Branch Other Expenditures 780-1 Treasury Division Salaries 723-5 Housing, Department of (Sup ply) Opening Remarks Ducharme 2889-90 Response 2893-5 General Administration Planning and Information Systems Salaries 2896-9 Support Services Salaries 2902 Landlord and Tenant Affairs Salaries 2902-7, 2911-3 Operations Administration Salaries 2914-5 Property Management Salaries 2919 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19 ) 4 Alcock, Reg - Cont.

C/W 358, 360-4, 686-91, 915-21 Manitoba Seniors Directorate (S upply) Other Expenditures 1 022-6 Ministerial Statements Wage settlements, public sector Response 3119 Non-Political Statements Foster Family Week 195 Manitoba School for the Deaf 25th anniversary 21 Salutations 3140 Oral Questions Child and Family Services Administration 1144, 1205 Agency structure 1145 Budget cuts 2155 Canada Assistance Plan payments 945 Caseload selection criteria 699 Funding 442, 1553-4 Redirection 1883 Northwest division Layoffs 260 Reference check charges 890-1 Service reduction 699, 945 Staffing, night shift 1619-20 Youth victim services 260 Child Protection Services Job creation 673 Workload review 673 Economic growth Government forecast 2154-5 Foster parenting Funding 234, 1884 Goods and services tax Communication billing 441 Retail trade predictions 441 Retail sales tax application 388-9 Income security program Federal Minister's comments 2800-1 Parent-Child Centres Funding 321-2 Reid family inquiry Firearms recommendations 673 Points of Order P/0 by Manness respecting words "attempting to mislead" (St orie) 260-1 ; Ashton 260-1 ; Alcock 261 ; taken under advisement 261 ; ruled in order 540-1 ; withdrawal requested 541 ; withdrawn 541 P/0 by Manness respecting brevity of

Hansard Index Alcock, Reg - Cont. questions and answers 1883; Alcock 1883-4; Members cautioned 18 84 P/0 by Vodrey respecting words "what the hell" (Alcock) 1365; taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1365; ruled out of order 1365; Members cautioned 13 65 Private Members' Business Resolutions Social assistance, one-tier system 1068-71 Statute Law Amendment (Taxati on) Act (Bi11 20) 2r 2676-8 Tabled Papers Canada Assistance Plan payments, 1988-89 (T.P. 48) 945 Family Services Grants to external agencies analysis (T. P. 84) 1554 Health Action Centre report (T.

P. 47) 945 Income Security Program Letter dated November 30, 1989 from Minister of Health & WeHare (T. P. 126) 2800 Interim Report, Staffing in Child and Family Services (T. P. 28) Alcock 673 Letter dated October 24, 1990 from Winnipeg Chief of Police regarding reference check charges (T.P. 43) 890 Petition and correspondence regarding funding (T.P. 12) 321 Throne Speech Debate 282-90 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba Annua1Report,1989( S.P.60) Orchard 461 Funding Cheema 675-6; Orchard 675-6 Youth Intervention: Final Report (T.

P. 125) Wasylycia-Leis 2792 Anesthetist shortage Government initiatives Carstairs 3032; Cheema 2801-3; Filmon 3032; Orchard 2801-4, 3032 5 Anesthetist shortage - Cont.

Surgery waiting lists Cheema 2556; Orchard 2556 See also Concordia Hospital; Grace Hospital; Medical Manpower Committee Appointments Chair of Committees/Deputy Speaker Filmon 10 Deputy Chair of Committees Filmon 10 Deputy Sergeant-at-Arms Rocan 9 Pages Rocan 9-10 Sergeant-at-Arms Rocan9 Speaker of the House Doer 2; Filmon 1-2; Rocan 2-3 Apprenticeship training Affirmative action Doer 532; Rlmon 532 Funding Derkach 532; Doer 531-2 Government initiatives Derkach 531 ; Doer 532 Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 27) 1 r Manness 3096; 2r Manness 3096; CIW 3112; RIS Manness 3113; RIA 3140 Archaeological assessments Justification Friesen 1148-9; Mitchelson 1148-9 Payment responsibility Cummings 1329; Friesen 1329 Arts Polley Review Committee Report, 1990 (T.

P. 74) Mitchelson 1406 Ashton, Steve (NDP, Thompson) Budget Debate 510-7 Civil Service, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Praznik 2934-6 Response 2936-7 Civil Service Commission Executive Office Salaries 2938-41

Hansard Index Ashton, Steve - Cont.

Employment Standards Amendment Act (Bill 3) 1 r 186 Employment Standards Amendment Act (2) (Bill23) 2r 2866-8 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 2r 2306-13; 3r 3198-200 Rnance, Department of (S upply) Taxation Division Corporation Capital Tax/Health and Post- Secondary Education Tax Levy Branch 787-8 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill19) C/W 364, 911-4 Labour, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Praznik 1502- 6 Response 1506-11 Administration and Rnance Management Services Salaries 1512-20, 1528-35 Minister's Salary 1846-7 Labour Apprenticeship and Training Other Expenditures 1591-3 Rre Prevention Salaries 1544 Mechnical and Engineering Salaries 1540-1 Pay Equity Salaries 1583-91 Pension Commission Other Expenditures 1582-3 Workplace and Worker Services Employment Standards Payment of Wages Fund 1845 Salaries 1843-4 Worker Advisor Off ice 1841-3 Workplace Safety and Health Salaries 1828-37 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12) 2r 2957-63; 3r 3134-5 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (B ill9) 2r 967-9 Non-Political Statements Harper, Elijah Newsmaker of the Year 3034-5 Oral Questions Labour laws Non-unionized replacement workers 2954 6 Asht on, Steve - Cont.

Bill No. 2 Firefighter amendments 327 CKY Television strike Government advertising withdrawal 2954 Government position 2954, 3033-4 Communities Economic Development Fund Economic forecast 436 Crystal Casino Negotiations 1 02-3 Premier's statement 1 03 Employment standards Night worker safety 2151 Employment Standards Act Amendments 1402-3 Labour negotiations Premier's statement withdrawal818 Labour relations Provincial status 818 Minimum wage Increase 2489, 2797 Two-tiered system 2151, 2489 Mystery Lake School Board Portable classroom construction 1013-4 Northern Affairs, Minister of Resignation request 436-7 Northern tax allowance Community concerns 2665-6 Federal announcement 2665 Rnance Minister's position 239-40 Reinstatement 1809 Plant closure legislation Builders Furniture Ltd. 147 Improvements 147 Worker protection 147 Unemployment Insurance changes Impact on Manitoba 1401-2 Workers compensation Rrefighter claims 2558-9 Funding 2558 Review 2559 Petitions Workers Compensation Act, amendments 696; ruled out of order 816 Points of Order P/0 by Ashton respecting unparliamentary language (Manness) 19; withdrawn 19 P/0 by Mb1Qn respecting brevity of questions and answers 99-1 00; McCrae 1 00; ruled in order 100 P/0 by� respecting two Ministers answering questions 258; Filmon 259; ruled out of order 259

Hansard Index Ashton, Steve - Cont.

P/0 by A� respecting abuse of Question Period (D owney) 432-3; Manness 432-3; ruled in order 433 P/0 by Ashton respecting brevity of answers 532-3; Manness 533; ruled in order 533 P/0 by� respecting unparliamentary language (Orchard ) 538; withdrawal requested 538; withdrawn 538 P/0 by &b1Qn respecting word "deliberately" (Filmon) 582; withdrawn 582 P/0 by Mb1Qn respecting unparliamentary language (F ilmon) 697; withdrawal requested 697; withdrawn 697 P/0 by� respecting answers to questions provoking debate (Filmon) 701 ; Member cautioned 701 P/0 by &b1Qn respecting imputation of motives (F ilmon) 702; Member cautioned 702 P/0 by &b1Qn respecting brevity of answers (Mitche lson) 825; Members cautioned 825 P/0 by &b1Qn respecting word "gutless" (F ilmon) 2484; Members cautioned 2484 P/0 by � respecting response to question not relating to matter raised (F ilmon) 2694; Manness 2694; Member cautioned 2694 P/0 by Carstairs respecting word "dishonest" (Orchard) 2385; Ashton 2385; taken under advisement 2385; ruled out of order 3127; Members cautioned 3127-8 P/0 by .Ei1.m.Qn respecting

preambles to supplementary questions (Ashton) 1402; ruled in order 1402 P/0 by Lamoureux respecting word "dishonest" (F ilmon) 2152; Manness 2152; Ashton 2152; withdrawal requested 2152; withdrawn 2152 P/0 by Manness respecting word "sabotage" (Wasylycia-Leis) 148; Ashton 148; ruled in order, withdrawal requested 148; withdrawn 148 7 Asht on, Steve - Cont.

P/0 by Manness respecting question seeking an opinion 150; Ashton 150; ruled in order, question rephrased 150 P/0 by Manness respecting content of replies to Ministerial Statements 183-4; Ashton 184; Lamoureux 184; taken under advisement 184; ruled out of order 541 P/0 by Manness respecting words "attempting to mislead" (S torie) 260-1 ; Ashton 260-1 ; Alcock 261 ; taken under advisement 261 ; ruled in order 540-1 ; withdrawal requested 541 ; withdrawn 541 P/0 by Manness respecting comments questioning the sincerity of an apology (S torie) 433-4; Ashton 433; withdrawal requested 434; withdrawn 434 P/0 by Manness respecting comments made during First Reading (Wasylycia-Leis) 461 ; Ashton 461 ; ruled in order 461 P/0 by Manness respecting words "potentially racist attitudes" (Cerilli) 464; Ashton 464; taken under advisement 464 ruled in order 632; withdrawal requested 632; withdrawn 632 P/0 by Manness respecting question seeking information beyond a Minister's responsibility (Lamoureux) 465; Lamoureux 465; Ashton 465; taken under advisement 465; ruled in order 632-3 P/0 by Manness respecting

preambles to supplementary questions 539; Ashton 539; ruled in order 539 P/0 by Manness respecting repetitive questions (Lamoureux) 826; Ashton 826; Members cautioned 826 P/0 by Manness respecting repetitive questions (Wowchuk) 1327; Ashton 1327; question rephrased 1327 P/0 by Manness respecting

preambles to supplementary questions (Reid ) 1550; Ashton 1550; Member cautioned 1550 P/0 by Manness respecting reference to answer previously given (D oer) 2150;

Hansard Index Ashton, Steve - Cont. Ashton 2150; ruled in order 2150 P/0 by Manness respecting

preambles to supplementary questions (Wasylycia-Leis) 2376; Ashton 2376; ruled in order 2376 P/0 by Manness respecting brevity of questions and answers 2556; Ashton 2557; Lamoureux 2556-7; Members cautioned 2557 Privilege, Matters of Apology/withdrawal, request for Member for Dauphin Ashton 2695; Lamoureux 2695; Manness 2694-5; withdrawn (Piohman) 2695-6 Censure, request for Minister of Consumer and Corporate Affairs Ashton 1320-1; Manness 1321; taken under advisement 1322 Re-enacted Statutes of Manitoba (Private Acts) Act, 1990 (Bill15) 2r 895-8 Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act (B ill20) 2r 2678-84; C/W 2876 Throne Speech Debate 75-81 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Acting Minister of Offensive public statements 947 Health care syste�ational 2388 Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Government handling 3152-3, 3164-6 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (Bill 2) 1r 318 Workers Compensation (S upply) Opening Remarks Connery 3036, 3038-9 Response 3036-7 Workers Compensation 3040-1 As sembly of Manitoba Chie fs Meeting request Filmon 366-7; Lathlin 366 As slnlbolne Community College See Education and Training, Department of (Sup ply)-Post-secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training 8 Attorney General, Department of Annua1Report,1989 (S.P. 54) McCrae 383 BUNTEP See University of Brandon Bankruptcy rates Government initiatives Carstairs 1667; Downey 1667-8 Barrett, Becky (NDP, Wellington) Budget Debate 499-502 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supp ly) Consumers' Bureau 1278-9 Corporate Affairs Corporations Branch Salaries 1281 Employment Standards Amendment Act (2) (Bill23) 2r 2868-9 Family Services, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Gilleshammer 1266-8 Response 1268-71 Administration and Rnance Agency Relations Bureau Salaries 1460-1 , 1556-63 Communications Salaries 1457-9 Executive Support Salaries 1346-9, 1352-4 Internal Audit Salaries 1459-60 Management Services Rnance and Administrative Services Salaries 1575 Human Resource Services Salaries 1577-81 Information Systems Salaries 1581-2, 1677 Program Budgeting and Reporting Salaries 1576-7 Social Services Advisory Committee Salaries 1682-7, 1690 Minister's Salary 2764-5 Planning and Research Salaries 1354- 7, 1362-4, 1366-7,1454-7 Child and Family Services

Hansard Index Barrett, Becky - Cont.

Administration Salaries 1968-78 Child and Family Support Salaries 2048-61 Children's Special Services Salaries 2434-7 Family Conciliation Salaries 2179-81 Family Dispute Services Other Expenditures 2182-7 Salaries 2419-26, 2433-4 Seven Oaks Youth Centre Salaries 21 75-7 Day Care, Youth and Employment Support Child Day Care Salaries 2519, 2614-6 Special Programs and Immigrant Services Branch Operations 2717-8, 27 48-52 Youth and Regional Services Branch Operations 2705-8 Regional Employment Services 2717 Income Security 2495-2504, 2518 Registration and Licensing Services Residential Care Licensing Salaries 1696-9 Vital Statistics Salaries 1691-5 Rehabilitation and Community Living Administration 1734-6, 17 44 Manitoba Developmental Centre Salaries 17 49-53 Operations Salaries 17 45-6 Programs Salaries 1754-9, 1968-78 Grievance, Matters of Health care system-National 2409-15 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill12) 2r 2565-72 Ministerial Statements Person's Day Response 183-4 Violence against women Response 2599-2600 Non-Political Statements Foster Family Week 195 Oral Questions Agape House Funding 15 Child and Family Services Administration 1143 9 Barrett, Becky - Cont.

Funding 144-5, 944 , 1143-4, 2153 Metis programs 1668-9 Outreach workers 2153 Premier apology request 1143 Resources 2153 Service reduction 944 Services provided 145 Staffing 2039 Children's rights United Nations Convention 2039 Eastman Crisis Centre Funding 188 Funding delay 325 Funding formula 325 Reopening date 188 Employment Standards Act Amendments 1618-9 Family violence Crimes against women Education programs 2605 Government strategy 2492 Protection-Universities 2605 Government strategy 188 Justice system review 1200 Sentence lengths 535 Firearms legislation Government support 2605-6 Krantz court case Destruction of evidence 890 Legislative Building Access policy 30 Libraries, publio-Winnipeg Inner city funding 2954-5 Manitoba Hydro Pay equity 468 Parent-Child Centres Funding 30, 585-6 Pay equity Extension 3126-7 Prairie Places Funding 1327-8 Unemployment Insurance changes Impact on Manitoba 1618-9 Women's crisis shelters Funding 16, 534, 1201 Funding-Rural534 Government initiatives 16 Recommendations 324-5 Status of Women (Supply) Advisory Council on the Status of Women 3044-6 Women's Directorate

Hansard Index Barrett, Becky - Cont. 3046 Supply, Committee of Concurrence Motion 3089-91 Tabled Papers Child and Family Services Letter from Manitoba Metis Foundation regarding Child and Family Support Program (T. P. 95) 1668 Children's rights United Nations Convention on the Rights of Children (T.P. 104) 2039 Parent-Child Centres Letter dated October 30, 1990 from Gilleshammer to Theresa Thiesen (T.P. 22) 585 Prairie Places Inc. Correspondence dated September, 1989 to October, 1990 (T.

P. 69) 1327 Unemployment Insurance Commission Analysis of changes (T.P. 90) 1618 Throne Speech Debate 69-71 Belanger-Campeau Commission Manitoba meeting Carstairs 1625; Filmon 1625 Bill C-21 Cost to Manitoba Gilleshammer 265; Martindale 265 Bill C-22 Impact on Manitoba Carr 1290; Connery 1290 Legal intervention Carr 1035; Downey 1035, 1405; Santos 1404 Bill of Rights, Environmental Introduction Cerilli 2794; Cummings 2794 Bills (See titles of particular Bills) Appropriation Act, 1990 (B ill 27) Business Practices Act (B ill 6) Employment Standards Amendment Act (B ill 3) 10 Bills - Cont.

Employment Standards Amendment Act (2) (B ill 23) Environment Amendment Act (B ill 24) Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (B ill 19) Labour Relations Amendment Act (B ill 12) Loan Act, 1990 (B ill 26) Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (B ill9) Oaths of Office,

An Act respecting the Administration of (B ill 1 ) Ombudsman Amendment Act (B ill 25) Pay Equity Amendment Act (B ill4) Private Acts Repeal Act (B ill 17) Re-enacted Statutes of Manitoba (Private Acts) Act, 1990 (B ill15) Re-enacted Statutes of Manitoba (P ublic General Acts) Act, 1990 (B ill16) Residential Rent Regulation Amendment Act (B i11 11) Residential Tenancies and Consequential Amendments Act (B ill 13) Retail Sales Tax Amendment Act (B ill5) Statute Law Amendment Act, 1990-91 (B ill22) Statute Law Amendment (Re-enacted Statutes) Act (B ill18) Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act (B ill 20) Workers Compensation Amendment Act (B ill 2) Bluestem Park Pollution cleanup Cummings 368; Edwards 368 Bond, Dr.

S.L. Proposal to Department of Industry, Trade and Tourism (T.P. 59) Ernst 1206 Provincial audit Ernst 1554-5 ; Storie 1554 Research proposal Ernst 1178-9; Filmon 1554; Storie 1554, 1178-9 Brandon Cabinet Off ice Director CKX TV and Radio employment L. Evans 891-2; Penner 892 Workload review L. Evans 892; Penner 892 See also Rural Development, Department of

Hansard Index Brandon General Hospital Funding L. Evans 699-700; Orchard 700 Regional role L. Evans 700; Orchard 700 Brandon, Manitoba Industrial development plan Ernst 669; L. Evans 669 Industry closures Ernst 668-9; L. Evans 668 Brandon Mental Health Centre Crisis intervention services Cheema 192; Orchard 192 Fire safety Cheema 191-2; Orchard 192 In-patient services Cheema 192; Orchard 192 Brandon University Annual Financial Report, 1990 (T.

P. 16) Derkach 366 Bridge constructi on projects See Private Members' Business Britcher Lumber Cutting rights Enns 1552; Plohman 1551 -2 Budget Agriculture marketing Carstairs 386; Findlay 386-7 Education Carstairs 386; Doer 384; Derkach 386; Filmon384 Home care program Doer 384-5; Orchard 384-5 Northern Manitoba Downey 389-90; Neufeld 390; Storie 389-90 Retail sales tax revenue Carstairs 385-6; Manness 286 Budget Address Man ness 37 4-80 Budget Debate Alcock 577-80, 590-4; Ashton 51 0-7; Barrett 499-502; Carr 653-7; Carstairs 401-13; Cerilli 637-40; Chomiak 616-23; Connery 634-5; 11 Budget Debate - Cont.

Cummings 609-16; Derkach 491-9; Doer 392-401 ; Downey 479-86; Driedger 553-9; Ducharme 542-9; Edwards 453-9; Ernst 419-26; C. Evans 651 -3; L. Evans 594-9; Filmon 642-51 ; Friesen 559-63; Gaudry 603-9; Harper 599-603; Hickes 657-60; Lamoureux 523-30; Maloway 413-9; Manness 660-5; Martindale 549-53; McCrae 502-9; Mitchelson 517-23; Neufeld 447-53; Orchard 563-70; Plohman 570-7; Reid 636-7; Santos 486-91; Storie 426-31 , 444-7; Wasylycia-Leis 459-60, 473-9; Wowchuk 640-2 Burns Meats Ltd.-Brandon Alternative usage Ernst 669; L. Evans 669 Feasibility study Ernst 1669; L.

Evans 1669 Industry incentive grants Ernst 1670; L. Evans 1669 Job placements Doer 667-8; Filmon 668 Plant closure Cheema 669-70; Doer 667; Filmon 667, 670; Praznik 670 Preferential employment policy Ernst 1669; L.

Evans 1669 Business Practices Act (Bill 6) 1 r Connery 581 ; 2r Connery 989-97, 1817; Gaudry 1638-40; Maloway 18 10- 6; referred to Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Committee Report 2149; RIS Manness 3091; RIA 3140 Business Start Program Status report Ernst 1218-9; Storie 1218-9 CBC cutbacks Alternative employment Carstairs 2606-7; Mitchelson 2607 Government action Filmon 2551 ; Friesen 2551 Government reaction Carstairs 2606; Film on 2606 Regional programming

Hansard Index CBC cutbacks - Cont. Friesen 2697-8; Mitchelson 2698 CEDF See Communities Economic Development Fund CIDO See Cultural Industry Development Office CKY Tele vision strike Government advertising withdrawal Ashton 2954; Filmon 2954 Government position Ashton 2954, 3033-4; Filmon 2954, 3034 CN Rail Layoffs Driedger 149-50; Reid 149-50 CP Rail Fisher Branch elevator C. Evans 891 ; Driedger 891 Highways maintenance costs C.

Evans 891 ; Driedger 891 Rail car inspections Driedger 1805 CSIS agreement Medical record confidentiality Edwards 536; McCrae 536 Minister's position Edwards 536; McCrae 536 Canada Assistance Plan Negotiations Alcock 1368-9, 1440; Gilleshammer 1368-9, 1440 Canada Health Act Amendments Orchard 1553; Wasylycia-Leis 1552-3 Canada-Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) Doer 3049-52; Manness 3049-52 Canada Post services Minister's position Downey 239; Santos 239 Carr, James (Liberal, Crescentwood) Budget Debate 653-7 12 Carr, James - Cont.

Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Connery 127 4-5 Response 1276-7 Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 1290 Corporate Affairs Public Utilities Board Salaries 1283-7 Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Department of (Supply) Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs Cultural Resources Salaries 1389-93 Information Resources Translation Services Salaries 1425-6 Lotteries Funded Programs Manitoba Arts Council 1423 Provincial Archives Grant Assistance 1422-3 Energy and Mines, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Neufeld 2270-2 Response 2273-4 Administration and Finance Administrative Services Other Expenditures 2279 Executive Support Other Expenditures 2277-8 Salaries 227 4-6 Minister's Salary 2291-2 Energy Energy Administration Salaries 2280-1 Energy Planning Salaries 2281-4 Petroleum Salaries 2285 Manitoba Energy Authority 2291 Mineral Resources Geological Services Salaries 2291 Mineral Development Salaries 2287-8 Executive Council (Supply) General Administration 750-3 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of (Supply)

Hansard Index Carr, James - Cont.

Opening Remarks Ernst 1 172-3 Response 117 4-5 Administration and Finance Finance and Administration Salaries 1180 Minister's Salary 1240 Canada-Manitoba Tourism Agreement-1985-90 Salaries 1235-8 Tourism Division Administration Salaries 1223-7 Corporate and Community Relations Salaries 1234-5 Development Salaries 1233 Marketing Salaries 1230-3 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bi11 19) C/W 345-8, 904-11 Justice, Department of (S upply) Administration and Finance Human Resource Services Other Expenditures 1869 Salaries 1868-9 Research and Development Salaries 1865 Loan Act, 1990 (Bill 26) C/W 3105-6 Manitoba Seniors Directorate (S upply) Other Expenditures 1035 Ministerial Statements Grand Rapids Generating Station Flooding settlement package Response 1396 Non-Political Statements Hanukkah, celebration of 2956 Harper, Elijah Newsmaker of the Year 3035 Ombudsman Amendment Act (Bill 25) 2r 2974-6 Oral Questions Conawapa Dam Project Access road tenders 2486 Clean Environment Commission 584 Delay penalities 584 Final approval1622 Hydro spending 981 , 1012, 1198, 2486 Withdrawal penalties 1199 Crown corporations Accountability 1 02 Crown Corporations Council 13 Carr, James - Cont.

Conawapa Dam Project 819 Manitoba Hydro review 101 1 Downtown development agreements Co-ordination 1 02 Downtown development corporations Amalgamation 326 Energy Alternate sources 189 Conservation policy 189, 1621-2 Forks Renewal Corporation Chief executive officer 326 Housing development 1 02 Home CHEC Program Reinstatement 189 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Spending, Tourism 1401 National Energy Board Minister's intervention 942 Trans pipeline ruling 942 North Portage Development Corporation South Portage initiatives 1331 · Ontario Hydro agreement Public Utilities Board Deadline469 Recommendations 468-9 Portage Avenue Commercial vacancy rate 1331 Tourism Manitoba statistics 1401 Winnipeg Arena proposal land lease 2300 Premier's discussion 2300 Premier's position 2299 Private Members' Business Resolutions Senate elections 2587-90 Tabled Papers Conawapa Dam Project Capital expenditure forecast (T.P. 54) 981 Throne Speech Debate 207-13 Urban Affairs, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Ducharme 1462-3 Response 1464-5 Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 1466-8 Minister's Salary 1501 Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area Renewal Agreement

Hansard Index Carr, James - Cont.

Payments to Other Implementing Jurisdictions 1495-6 Financial Assistance to City of Winnipeg Unconditional Current Programs Grant 1470-1 Urban Transit Operating Grant 1472-3, 1476 Riverbank Development 1498-9 Urban Policy and Agreement Management North Portage Redevelopment 1479-85, 1489-91 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Govemment handling 3166-8 Ways and Means, Committee of Capital Supply 2879-80 Carsta lrs, Sharon (Liberal, River Heights) Agriculture, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Findlay 1921-4 Response 1926-8 Administration and Finance Communications Branch Salaries 1941-2 Excess Summerfallow Compensation Program 1947-8 Executive Support Other Expenditures 1936-9 Financial and Administrative Services Other Expenditures 1943 Personnel Services Other Expenditures 1945-6 Agricultural Development and Marketing Administration Salaries 2021-30 Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation 2006-10 Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Premiums 1953-7, 1998- 2000 Policy and Economics Division 2075-81 Regional Agri-Services Division Interlake Region 2072-3 Budget Debate 401-13 Decentralization (S upply) 2920-1 ' 2928-32, 2934 Education and Training, Department of (S upply) Opening Remarks Derkach 851-9 Response 859-62 Administration and Finance Administration and Professional Certification 14 Carsta lrs, Sharon - Cont.

Salaries 1 056-9 Financial Services Salaries 1 050-3 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Salaries 963-5,967, 1046 Bureau de ('education francaise 1135-8 Expenditures Related to Capital Acquisition/Construction Red River Community College 1255-6 Financial Support-Schools School Grants and Other Assistance 1108-12,1116-8 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Assiniboine Community College Salaries 1188-90 Keewatin Community College Salaries 1192-3 Red River Community College Salaries 1186-8 Student Financial Assistance Salaries 1194 Workforce 2000/Job Training for Tomorrow Salaries 1241-2 Program Development Support Services Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area Renewal Agreement-Education Development Grants 1133 Curriculum Services Salaries 1119-24 Distance Education and Technology Salaries 1128-31 Inner-City Education Initiative Salaries 1134-5 Manitoba School for the Deaf Salaries 1125-6 Native Education Salaries 1125 Statutory Boards and Commissions 1060-1 Universities Grants Commission 1249-52 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 3r 3194-6 Executive Council (S upply) Opening Remarks Filmon 731 Response 734-5 General Administration 7 40, 796-801 , 810-4 Ministerial Statements Manitoba Constitutional Task Force

Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont.

Response 2603 Person's Day Response 185 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Response 936 Violence against women Response 2600 Non-Political Statements Hall, Gordon Death of former Manitoba Court of Appeal justice 444 National Students Day 152 Remebrance Day 988 Oral Questions AIDS education Family life curriculum 2296 Prevention programs 2295-6 Agricultural industry Interest relief program 263 Anesthetist shortage Government initiatives 3032 Bankruptcy rates Government initiatives 1667 Belanger-Campeau Commission Manitoba meeting 1625 Budget Agriculture marketing funding 386- 7 Education funding 38 6 Retail sales tax revenue 385-6 CBC cutbacks Alternative employment 2606-7 Government reaction 2606 Constitution, Citizens Forum on the Mandate 1625 Manitoba meeting 1625 Constitutional issues Public consultations Membership 627 Crown Corporations Council Clarification-Minister's statement 703 Mackness, William-appointment 702-3 Decentralization Equivalent employment 180 7 Statistics 1806 Economic growth Public consultations 627 Education, aboriginal Government commitment 3122 Energy and Mines, Minister of Community concerns 939-40 Government apology 940 Hansard Index 15 Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont.

Established Programs Financing Government position 1880 , 2035-6 Family violence Crimes against children 13 28 Firearms confiscation 30-1 Firearms reporting 31 Ottawa program evaluation 2158 Prosecution 2158 Service delays 2159 Federal government Premier's support 2692 Federal-provincial agreements Education programs 3122-3 Federal transfer payments Equalization 627 Finance Ministers' meeting Health care communique 2377 Health care resolution 2376-7 Goods and services tax Legal intervention 17 Government statistics Accuracy 324 Health care system Underspendlng controls 324 Health care system-National British Columbia's position 2377 Government position 2035 Standards 1881 Immigration policy Family reunification 437-8 Manitoba Association of School Trustees Cabinet meeting request 167 0-1 Manitoba Learning Centre Funding 1399 Meetingrequest13 99 Service cutbacks 1399 Manitoba Nurses' Union Contract length 3151 Negotiations 3031 Pay equity 314 7-8 Pension trusteeship 3151 Premier's involvement 3147 Mathematics examination Manitoba Association of School Trustees Position 167 0 Mystery Lake School Board Portable classroom construction 1 008-9 Orders-in-Council Salary publication 533-4 RCMP services Regional replacement 2691-2 School divisions

Cars talrs, Sharon - Cont.

Boundaries review 889 Enrollment reporting 888 Schools, public Breakfast programs 1551 Sexual assault Parole review 96-7 Plea bargaining 97 Sentence lengths 1328 Substance abuse Government initiatives 2794-5 Unemployed Help Centres Funding 1668 University of Brandon BUNTEP program funding 3124 Winnipeg Education Centre Funding 2663-4 Winnipeg School Division No. 1 Breakfast programs 1551 Points of Order P/0 by Carstairs respecting word "dishonest" {Orch ard) 2385; Ashton 2385; taken under advisement 2385; ruled out of order 3127; Members cautioned 3127-8 Private Members' Business Resolutions School Division Boundary Review 16 54-7 Rural Development, Department of {Supply) Opening Remarks Penner 218 7- 9 Response 21 91- 2 Administration and Finance Brandon Office Salaries 2197-8 Executive Support Salaries 2193-4 Financial and Administrative Services Salaries 2199 -2200 Human Resource Management Salaries 2198-9 Municipal Advisory and Financial Services Salaries 2203, 2206-7 Municipal Assessments Salaries 221 0-5 Municipal Board Salaries 2202-3 Provincial Planning Salaries 221 7-8 Status of Women {Supply) Opening Remarks Mitchelson 3044 Hansard Index 16 Cars talrs, Sharon - Cont.

Response 3044 Advisory Council on the Status of Women 3046-8 Women's Directorate 3048- 9 Tabled Papers Government statistics Statistics Canada documents (T.P. 11) 324 Family violence Ottawa Police Force Wife Assault Pamphlet (T.P. 113) 2158 Throne Speech Debate 48-54 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Health care system-National 2386 -7 Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Government handling 3152, 3154-5 Cerllll, Marianne {NDP, Radisson) Budget Debate 637-40 Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Mitchelson 1295-8 Response 1298-9 Multicultural Secretariat Salaries 1301-2, 1304-10, 1313-4, 1316-9 Environment Amendment Act {Bill 24) 2r 297 6-8; 3r 3184 -8 Environment, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Cummings 2446-8, 2453 Response 2448- 50 Administration and Finance Community Relations Salaries 2538 -41 Executive Support Salaries 2453-8, 2470-3 Planning and Innovation Salaries 2477-8 0, 2482 , 2527-37 Environmental Advisory Organization Clean Environment Commission Salaries 2784-7 Manitoba Environment Council Salaries 2787-9 Environmental Management Environmental Management Salaries 2631-46, 2718-31 , 2780-2 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Hansard Index Cerllll, Marianne - Cont. 2783 Fitness and Sport (Supply) Lotteries Funded Programs Sport Directorate 17 03, 17 04-8, 1711, 1713-4 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12) 2r 2581-6 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 9) 2r 880 -3 Oral Questions Bi11No. 24 Consultations 2298, 2382 -3, 2608 Federal-provincial discussions 2383 Federal responsibility 2608 Justification 2298 Wording 2608 Bill of Rights, Environmental Introduction 2794 Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Acting Minister of RemovaVapology request 938 Resignation request 2487 Ducks Unlimited Canada Environmental licensing 388, 1885 Withdrawal 2157 Expansion 2157 Minister's endorsement 21 58 Environment, Department of Staffing 265-6, 982 Environmental Innovations Fund Funding criteria 1 14 6-7 Environmental laws Enforcement 2793-4 Increased fines 981 Informant protection 2794 Reporting system 981-2 Environmental programs Funding 101 Recycling initiatives 11 46 Garrison Diversion Project Government action 3123 Manitoba interests 31 23-4 Green Plan Government position 2299 Hazardous waste Disposal site-North Dakota 3030 Landfill sites Government policy 162 0 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Funding388 Manitoba Intercultural Council 17 Cerllll, Marianne - Cont.

Anti-racism report 588, 939 Availability 1673 Distribution 1673 Implementation 1673 Cabinet committee meeting 939 Manitoba Hydro Affirmative action 588 Multicultural policy Contradictions 463-4, 532-3, 589 Government initiatives 2487 Oak Hammock Marsh Tourism potential1885 Traffic increase 1884 Recycling programs Government initiatives 14 03-4, 155 0, 1620 Resource Recovery Institute Blue Bag Program funding 100, 15 49 Correspondence request 1549 Funding commitment 1404 Meetingrequest162 0 Seine River Illegal dumping 372 Pollution cleanup 371 Points of Order P/0 by Manness respecting words "potentially racist attitudes" (Cerilli) 464; Ashton 464; taken under advisement 464 ruled in order 632; withdrawal requested 632; withdrawn 632 taken under advisement 464 Tabled Papers Letter dated July 26, 1990 to Cummings from Wayne Neily (T.P. 20) 388 Letter dated September 7, 1990 to Cummings from Enns (T.P. 19) 388 Letter dated September 14 , 1990 regarding mediation process (T.P. 18) 388 Throne Speech Debate 119-22 Channel Area Loggers Ltd.

Annua1Report, 1989 (S.P. 72) Downey 624 Cheema, Guizar (Liberal, The Maples) Civil Service, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks

Hansard Index Cheema, Guizar - Cont.

Praznik 2934-6 Response 2937 Civil Service Commission Executive Office Salaries 2941 -5 Finance, Department of (Supply) Federal- Provincial Relations and Research Division Economic and Federal-Provincial Research Branch Salaries 1 084-6 Fitness and Sport (Supply) lotteries Funded Programs Sport Directorate 1711-2 Grievance, Matters of Health care system-National 2394-2402 Health, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Orchard 2219-23 Response 2227-30 Administration and Anance Administrative and Anancial Services Salaries 3024-5 Executive Support Salaries 2241-8, 2256 Health Advisory Network 225�9. 232�32,233�0 Policy and Planning Secretariat Salaries 2340-7, 2801-9, 2819-23, 2995-3001' 3012-9 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba 3081 Community Health Services (Programs) Gerontology Salaries 30�9 Home Care Equipment and Supplies 3075 Women's Health Directorate Salaries 3064-5 Manitoba Health Services Commission Administration 3081-2 Hospital Program 3083 Mental Health Mental Health Administration 307� labour, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Praznik 1502-6 Response 1511-2 Administration and Anance Management Services Salaries 1521-4, 1536 labour 18 Cheema, Guizar - Cont.

Mechanical and Engineering Salaries 15 41-4 Pay Equity Salaries 1583 labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12 ) 2r 1337-40 Non-Political Statements Winnipeg Blue Bomber s Grey Cup 1810, 1887 Oral Questions AIDS-HIV studies Patient notification 984 Patient participation 984 Public awareness 984 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba Funding 675-6 Anesthetist shortage Surgery waiting lists 2556 Brandon Mental Health Centre Crisis intervention services 192 Fire safety 191-2 In-patient services 192 Bums Meats ltd.- Brandon Plant closure 669-70 Concordia Hospital Anesthetist shortage 2488 Grace Hospital Anesthetist shortage 2555-6 Children's Unit closure 146 Health Advisory Network Cardiac care report 2038 Reports completed 2038 Teaching hospital review 2038 Health care system Out-of-province treatment 266 Out-patient clinics 266 Surgery delays 266 Immigrant physicians Internship positions 2952 Immigration, Department of Medical examination policy 370 Staff shortages 370 Vistor visas 370 labour Adjustment Branch Funding 670 Medical Manpower Committee Anesthetists, recommendations 2488, 2557 Elective surgery 2488 Minimum wage Increase 114 7 Review process 11 47 St.

Boniface Hospital

Hansard Index Cheema, Guizar - Cont.

Obstetrical unit Closure 2611 Expansion 2612 Patient transfers 2612 Points of Order P/0 by Mcintosh respecting word "guy" (Cheema) 2397; ruled out of order (Stefanson) 2397 Private Members's Business Resolutions Pharmacare card 758-60 Throne Speech Debate 274-9 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Government handling 3161- 3 Child abuse See Family violence Child and Family Services Administration Alcock 686-9; Barrett 1 143; Filmon 1143; Gilleshammer 688- 9; Manness 686- 7 Study Alcock 11 44 , 1205; Filmon 1144 -5, 1205 Agency structure Alcock 1145; Filmon 1145 Apology request-Premier Barrett 1143; Film on 1143 Budget Alcock 689-90 , 2155; Gilleshammer 689- 90, 2155 Canada Assistance Plan payments Alcock 945; Gilleshammer 945 Canada Assistance Plan payments, 19 88-89 (T.P. 47) Alcock945 Caseload selection criteria Alcock 699; Gilleshammer 699 Children's special services (T.P. 120) Gilleshammer 2493 Deficits Alcock 915; Gilleshammer 915 Funding Alcock442, 1553-4 , 18 83 ; Barrett 144- 5, 944, 114 3-4, 21 53; Filmon 1144 ; Gilleshammer 145 , 442, 944, 1553-4,1 8 83 , 2153 Health Action Centre report (T.P. 48 ) Alcock945 19 Child and Family Services - Cont.

Letter dated October 24, 1990 from Winnipeg Chief of Police regarding reference check charges (T.P. 43) Alcock890 Letter from Manitoba Metis Foundation regarding Child and Family Support Program (T .P. 95) Barrett 1668 Metis programs Barrett 166 8-9; Gilleshammer 1668 -9 Night staffing policy Alcock 1619- 2; Gilleshammer 1619- 20 Northwest division Funding Doer 96; Gilleshammer 96 Layoffs Alcock 260; Doer 95; Gilleshammer 95-6, 260 Outreach workers Barrett 2153; Gilleshammer 2153 Permanancy planning Alcock 690, 915; Gilleshammer 690, 915 Reference check fees Alcock 890-1 ; Gilleshammer 890-1 Resources Barrett 2153; Gilleshammer 2153-4 Services provided Barrett 145; Gilleshammer 145 Service reduction Alcock 699, 945; Barrett 944 ; Gilleshammer 699, 944-5 Staffing Barrett 2039; Gilleshammer 2039 Youth victim services Alcock 260; Gllleshammer 260 See also Family Services, Department of (Supply) Child care Federal-provincial negotiations Alcock 144 3-4; Gilleshammer 144 3-4 School-based Alcock 916, 919, 1450; Derkach 919; Gilleshammer 915 , 14 50 Space allocation Alcock 363-4; Derkach 363-4 Child Protect ion Services Interim Report, Staffing in Child and Family Services (T.P. 28 ) Alcock673 Job creation Alcock 673; Gilleshammer 673

Hansard Index Child Protec tion Services - Cont.

Workload review Alcock 673; Gilleshammer 67 3 Children's Home of Winnipeg Service and funding agreement (T.P. 1 00) Gilleshammer 196 0 Children's rights United Nations Convention Barrett 2039; Gilleshammer 2039 United Nations Convention on the Rights of Children (T.P. 1 04) Barrett 2039 Chomlak, Dave (NDP, Klldonan) Budget Debate 61 6-23 Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Derkach 851- 9 Response 86 2-6 Administration and Finance Administration and Professional Certification Salaries 1 059-60 Communications Salaries 1055 Executive Support Salaries 866 -7 Financial Services Salaries 1047-50, 1053-5 Personnel Services Salaries 1047 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Salaries 868 -75, 963, 1043-7 Bureau de I' education francaise 1137 Expenditures Related to Capital Acquisition/Construction Red River Community College 1252-5 Financial Support-schools School Grants and Other Assistance 1062�.110�. 1112- 6, 1118 Post- Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Executive Administration Salaries 1184 Keewatin Community College Salaries 1190-2 Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Salaries 1184 20 Chomlak, Dave - Cont.

Red River Community College Salaries 1 18 5-6 Student Financial Assistance Salaries 1193 Workforce 2000/Job Training for Tomorrow Salaries 1240-1 Program Development Support Services Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area Renewed Agreement-Education Development Grants 1131-2 Child Care and Development Salaries 1127 Curriculum Services Salaries 1122- 3 Distance Education and Technology Salaries 1128 Division Administration Salaries 1119 Inner-C ity Education Initiative Salaries 1133 - 4 Instructional Resources Salaries 1127-8 Native Education Salaries 1 124-5 Statutory Boards and Commissions 1061-2 Universities Grants Commission 1242-9 Grievance, Matters of Health care system-National 2402-9 Justice, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks McCrae 1787 -8 Response 1788-9 Administration and Finance Communications Salaries 1872-3 Executive Support Salaries 1791 -5, 18 51-4, 1855 - 6 Human Resource Services Other Expenditures 1872 Salaries 18 66-7, 1869 Public Inquiry into the Administration of Justice and Aboriginal People 1875-6 , 2349-51 Research and Development Other Expenditures 1866 Salaries 1859- 65 Public Prosecutions Provincial Police 2370-1 Public Prosecutions Salaries 2352-61 , 2367

Chomlak, Dave - Cont.

Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12) 2r 1647-54 Non- Political Statements Crime Prevention Month 633 National Students Day 152 Orlikow, Lionel Distinguished Education Award 16 25-6 Oral Questions ACCESS program Student recruitment 97 Budget Education funding 391 Education and Training, Department of Five-year strategic plan 887-8 Education finance Consultation paper 2668 Education, post-secondary Funding, federal 1881 Tuition increases 1881 Family violence Case reviews 2154 Police protocol 2154 Prosecution 2154 Restraining orders 33, 588 Firearms control Legislation, federal 2693 Government initiatives 2692-3 Goods and services tax Educational texts 986 Impact education 262-3, 1398 Judicial system Cutbacks 320-1 Dismissal of charges 587 Inquiry 3028 Probation officer training 369 Probation breach 587 Probation services 321 , 368 Prosecution delays 2948-9 Public confidence 3027-8 Public protection 320, 369 Mathematics examination Consultations 2799 Implementation 1674 Withdrawal 2799 Radon gas levels Schools, public 826 Testing 827 St.

James-Assiniboia School Division Accountability system 888 Enrollment figures 2302 Independent assessment 986 Provincial Auditor's report 1330, 2799 Hansard Index 21 Chomlak, Dave - Cont.

Schools, public Deterioration 238 Rebuilding program 238 Sexual assault Police reporting guidelines 1330 STOPiifting Program Funding 2379 Victims Assistance Fund 2379 Strategies For Success report Government consultations 167 4 Sterilization, involuntary Government policy 16 66-7 University of Manitoba Dean-Faculty of Management Assessment report 67 4-5 Human Rights Commission referral 674 lnquiry 674 Winnipeg Adult Education Centre Funding98 Winnipeg Education Centre Funding 2668-9 Winnipeg School Division No. 1 Special education costs 1398 Women's crisis shelters Funding34 Services review 34 Private Acts Repeal Act (Bill 17) 2r 903-4 Private Members' Business Resolutions Crime Prevention Council, establishment 930-2 School Division Boundary Review 1659 -61 Re- enacted Statutes of Manitoba (Public General Acts) Act, 1990 (Bill 16) 2r 899-903 Statute Law Amendment Act, 1990-91 (Bill22) C/W2877 Tabled Papers Judicial system Probation supervision memo (T.P. 1 0) 320 St.

James-Assiniboia School Division Superintendent's report (T.P. 115) 2302 Throne Speech Debate 179-82 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Government handling 3169

Churchill, Manitoba Rail access Driedger 177 4-6; Reid 1774 -6 Civil Service Commission Affirmative action Ashton 2939-41 ; Cheema 2941 -5; Praznik 2939-40, 2942-5 Hiring freeze Ashton 2938 ; Praznik 2938 Job security Ashton 2938- 9; Praznik 2938 -9 MGEA negotiations Ashton 2939; Praznik 2939 Pay equity Ashton 2939; Praznik 2939 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 58 ) Praznik 1196 Civil Service Commission-Federal Manitoba job loss Filmon 233; Storie 232-3 Civil Service, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Praznik 2934-6 Response Ashton 2936-7; Cheema 2937 Civil Service Commission Executive Office Salaries Ashton 2938-4 1 ; Cheema 2941- 5; Praznik 2938 -45 Civil Service SuperannuaUon Fund Actuarial Report, 198 9 (S.P. 84) Praznik 2149 Clean Environment Commission Assessment referrals Cummings 2480-1 ; Edwards 248 0-1 Colleges, Community Competency Based Learning Review Chomiak 87 1 ; Derkach 87 1 See also specific colleges Colleges, Private Accreditation Chomiak 872; Derkach 87 2 Hansard Index 22 Commonwealth Parliamentary Association See Non-Political Statements Communities Economic Development Fund Annual Report, 1989 (S.P. 40) Downey318 Economic forecast Ashton 436; Filmon 436 See also Northam Affairs, Department of (Supply)-Administration and Finance Community Calling Program See Manitoba Telephone System Community Living, Working Group on Mandate Alcock 1737; Barr 1744; Gilleshammer 1736 -7 Community Services, Department of Annual Report, 198 9 (S.P . 1 0) Gilleshammer 95 Community Support Programs Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 46) Mitchelson 935 Community Support Programs (Supply) Lotteries Funded Programs Lotteries Distribution Systems Dewar 14 33-5 ; Lamoureux 1433-4; Mitchelson 1433- 5 Conawapa Dam ProJect Access road tenders Carr 2486, 2488 ; Cummings 2486 ; Neufeld 2488 Capital expenditure forecast (T.P. 54) Carr 981 Clean Environment Commission Carr 584 ; Cummings 584 Consulting services Carr 2277-8 ; Hickes 2277-8 ; Neufeld 2277-8 Crown Corporations Council Carr 2275; Neufeld 227 5 Delay penalties Carr 584; Cummings 58 7; Edwards 58 7; Manness 58 4; Neufeld 584

Hansard Index Conawapa Dam Project - Cont.

Ecosystem boundaries Cummings 11 97; Doer 1197 Employment preference policy Hickes 1010; Neufeld 1010 Employment training programs Derkach 356-8 ; Hickes 356-7 Energy saving proposal Doer 11 97; Neufeld 1197 Environmental impact study Cummings 1325 -6; Edwards 1325-6 Environmental licensing Cummings 11 97; Doer 1196 -7 Environmental review process Cummings 2462-7; Doer 1666; Downey 1666; Edwards 2462-6 Final approval Carr 16 22; Filmon 1622 Funding Carr 2879 ; Manness 28 80; Neufeld 2879-80 Hydro spending Carr 981, 1 012, 1 198, 2488 ; Neufeld 981, 1012, 1198, 2488 Natural Resources involvement Edwards 284 1 ; Enns 284 1 Public Utilities Board review Carr 2274; Neufeld 2274-5 Start-up date Hickes 1010; Filmon 1010 Withdrawal penalites Carr 1199 ; Neufeld 1199 Concordia Hospital Anesthetist shortage Cheema 2488 ; Orchard 2488 Conflict of Interest Administrative process Carr 12 90-1, 12 93; Connery 1290-4, 2129; Downey 1293-4; Maloway 1292, 21 29 ; McCrae 129 4-5; Praznik 1293-4 Ducks Unlimited Canada Edwards 2720 Connery, Hon.

Edward (PC, Portage Ia Prairie) (Minister of Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Aff airs) (Minister respo nsible for The Workers Compensati on Act (except as It relates to Worker Advisers)) Budget Debate 634-5 23 Connery, Hon. Edward - Cont.

Business Practices Act (Bill 6) 1r 581 ;2r 989- 97, 1817 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 40) 816 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 127 4-5 Response Carr 127 6-7; Maloway 1275-6 Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 1290-3 Consumers' Bureau 1277-81 Co-operative and Credit Union Development and Regulation Co-operative and Credit Union Development Salaries 1287- 90 Corporate Affairs Corporations Branch Salaries 1281 Manitoba Securities Commission Salaries 1281-2 Public Utilities Board Salaries 1282- 7 Insurance Act Annual Report, 1990 (S.

P. 67) 581 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19) C/W340-2 Messages Bill No. 6 Recommendation-L ieutenant-Governor (S.P. 69) 581 Oral Questions Bill No. 2 Firefighter amendments 327 Fuel price increases Government action 367 Justification 367-8 Franchise legislation Introduction 1808 Fuel price increases Correspondence request 1671 Federal taxation 1671 Government action 889 -900 Price monitoring 1329 Regulations 1329 Goods and services tax Consumer refunds 1809

Hansard Index Connery, Hon. Edward - Cont. New Homes Warranty Program Replacement program 1202-3 Ontario Hydro agreement Public Utilities Board Recommendations 468 Videon Cable TV Negative option sales 1328 Private Members' Business Resolutions Co-operative housing projects 27 42-5 Public Utilities Board Annua1 Report, 1989 (S.

P. 85) 2149 Capital Projects-Manitoba Hydro (T.P. 116) 2303 Tabled Papers Fuel pricing Graph: CON Refiners rack prices (T.P. 42) 890 Letter dated November 14 , 1990 from Connery regarding gas prices (T.P. 94) 1671 Throne Speech Debate 200-7 Trade Practices Act Annua1R eport, 1990 (S.P. 66)581 Workers Compensation Board of Manitoba Annua1Report, 1989 (S.P. 41) 318 Workers Compensation (Supply) Opening Remarks 3036, 3038- 9 Response Ashton 3036-7; Edwards 3037-8 Workers Compensation 3041-4 Conservation Districts of Manitoba Annua1Report, 1989 (S.P. 17 ) Penner 142 Consoli dated Professor ,.nes See Shoal Lake-Water quality Constitut ion, Citizens Forum on the Mandate Carstairs 16 25; Filmon 1625 Manitoba meeting Carstairs 16 25; Filmon 1625 Constitut ional Issues Aboriginal representation Doer 626; Filmon 367 , 626; Lathlin 367 Notwithstanding clause 24 Constitutional Issues - Cont.

Carr 345-8 ; McCrae 345-9 Public consultations Doer 625; Filmon 625-6 Membership Carstairs 627 ; Filmon 627 See also Citizens Forum on the Constitution Construction Industry Wages Act Enforcement Ashton 184 3-4; Praznik 184 3-4 Consumer legislation Lemon law Connery 2127; Maloway 2127 Consumers' Bureau See Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate, Affairs, Department of (Supply) Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affa irs, Department of Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 40) Connery816 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supply} Opening Remarks Connery 127 4-5 Response Carr 127 6-7; Maloway 127 5-6 Administration and Finance Minister's Salary Carr 12 90 ; Connery 1290-3; Downey 1293 -4; Maloway 12 92; McCrae 1294-5; Praznik 1291 , 1293-4 Consumers' Bureau Barrett 1278-9 ; Connery 12n -81 ; Maloway 12n -81 Co-operative and Credit Union Development and Regulation Co-operative and Credit Union Development Salaries Connery 128 7- 90; Maloway 1287-90 Corporate Affairs Corporations Branch Salaries Barrett 1281 ; Connery 1281 Manitoba Securities Commission Salaries

Hansard Index Co-operative, Consumer (Supply) - Cont.

Connery 1281-2 ; Maloway 1281 - 2 Public Utilities Board Salaries Carr 1283-7; Connery 12 82 -7; Maloway 1282- 3 Core Area Initiative Alternative Ducharme 21 05; Friesen 2104-5 Analysis Filmon 2295; Friesen 229 5 Contingency funding Ducharme 96; Friesen 96 Education funding Ducharme 190; Hickes 190 Education programs Chomiak 21 08; Derkach 21 08 Evaluation Ducharme 21 05; Friesen 21 05 Extension Filmon 2295; Friesen 229 5 Government position Carr 21 05; Ducharme 21 05 Phasing out Ducharme 21 04; Friesen 2104 Program evaluations Ducharme 2040; Martindale 2039-40 Public hearings Filmon 2295; Friesen 2295 Renewal Carr 2139; Doer 21 03-4; Ducharme 2139-40; Filmon 21 03-4 Replacement funding Ducharme 2040; Martindale 2040 See also Urban Affairs (Supply)-Urban Policy and Agreement Management Court of Appeal Expansion Edward 1799; McCrae 1799 French language services Edwards 1854; McCrae 1854 Transcription Edwards 1854- 5 ; McCrae 1855 Crime prevention Government initiatives Edwards 631 ; McCrae 631-2 Crime Preve ntion Council See Private Members Business 25 Crime Preve ntion Month See Non-Political Statements Crlmlnal lnjurles compensation Program implementation Edwards 2609; McCrae 2609 Crlmlnal lnjurles Compensa tion Board Annual Report, 1990 (S.P. 63) McCrae 531 Criminal prosecut ions Assistant Deputy Minister's comments Edwards 2666; McCrae 2666 Crisis Intervention Services Funding allocations, 19 90-91 (T.P. 108) Gilleshammer 2044 Shelter occupancy rates (T.P. 118) Gilleshammer 2419 Cross Lake Indian Band Timber cutting rights Doer 462; Filmon 462 Cross Lake, Manitoba Pipestone Crossing bridge Driedger 3031; Harper 3031 Water quality Cummings 3031 ; Harper 3030-1 Crow benefit Payment method Carstairs 1937-9; Findlay 1929- 35, 1937-9; Plohman 1929- 35, 1939 Crown corporations Accountability Carr 1 02; Manness 1 02 Crown Corporations Council Annua1Report, 1989 (S.P. 70) Manness 624 Appointments Mackness, William Carstairs 702-3; Filmon 702-3 Clarification Finance, Minister of-Statement Carstairs 703; Manness 704 Conawapa Dam Project Carr 819, 904-1 0; Manness 819, 904-11 Manitoba Hydro

Crown Corporations Council - Cont.

Review Carr 1 011 ; Manness 1 01 1-2 Crystal Casino Mediator appointment Dewar 264-5; Mitchelson 264-5 Negotiations Ashton 1 02-3; Almon 1 03 Premier's statement Ashton 103; Almon 103-4 Revenue forecasts Dewar 1433; Lamoureux 1433-4; Mitchelson 1433-4 Cultural awareness programs Implementation Doer 980-1; Almon 981 Cultural grants Cutbacks Friesen 2552; Mitchelson 2552 Cultural Industry Dev elopment Off ice Agreement renewal Friesen 2552; Mitchelson 2552 Culture, Heritage and Recrea tion, Acting Minister of Removal/apology request Cerilli 938; Doer 979; Almon 938, 978; Lamoureux 2491 ; Neufeld 2491 Resignation request Cerilli 2487; Almon 2487 See also Grievance, Matters of; Urgent Public Importa nce, Matters of Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Department of Annual Report, 1989 (S.P. 75) Mitchelson 1196 Impact assessments request Friesen 11 49; Mitchelson 1149 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 45) Mitchelson 935 Culture, Heritage and Recreati on, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Mitchelson 1295-8 Hansard Index 26 Culture, Heritage (Supply) - Cont.

Response Cerilli 1298-9; Friesen 1369-72; Lamoureux 1299-1301 Administration and Finance Communications Salaries Friesen 1374-5; Lamoureux 1375; Mitchelson 137 4-5 Executive Support Salaries Friesen 1372-3; Lamoureux 1372-3; Mitchelson 1372-4 Anance and Administrative Services Other Expenditures Friesen 1375- 6; Mitchelson 1375-6 Human Resource Services Salaries Enns 1376-7; Friesen 1376, 1378; Lamoureux 13n -8; Mitchelson 1376 Manitoba Aim Classification Board Salaries Friesen 1378-9; Lamoureux 1378-80; Mitchelson 1378-80 Minister's Salary Friesen 1428-9, 1431-2; Lamoureux 1429-31 ; Mitchelson 1428-31 Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs Cultural Resources Salaries Carr 1389-93; Friesen 1387-9; Mitchelson 1387-93 Executive Administration Salaries Friesen 1380-1, 1383; Lamoureux 1381-3; Mitchelson 1380-3 Grants to Cultural Organizations Friesen 1384-6; Lamoureux 1386-7; Mitchelson 1384-7 Historic Resources Salaries Friesen 1394, 1407-9, 1413-5; Lamoureux 1409-13, 1415; Mitchelson 1394, 1406-15 Library Services Salaries Friesen 1393; Mitchelson 1393-4 Recreation Salaries Friesen 1415-6; Lamoureux 1416; Mitchelson 1415-6 Regional Services Salaries

Hansard Index Culture, Heritage (Supply) - Cont.

Friesen 14 17; Lamoureux 1417-8 ; Mitchelson 1417-8 Information Resources Legislative Library Salaries Friesen 1427; Mitchelson 14 27 Management and Purchasing Other Expenditures Lamoureux 14 24; Mitchelson 1424 Salaries Friesen 142 3-4; Mitchelson 14 23-4 Provincial Archives Salaries Friesen 1426-7; Mitchelson 1426-7 Queen's Printer Salaries Friesen 1424; Mitchelson 1424 Translation Services Salaries Carr 1425-6; Friesen 1425; Mitchelson 1425-6 Lotteries Funded Programs Manitoba Arts Council Carr 14 23; Mitchelson 1423 Provincial Archives Grant Assistance Carr 1422- 3 ; Friesen 1418 ; Lamoureux 14 18, 1420-2 ; Mitchelson 14 18 -23 Multicultural Secretariat Salaries Cerilli 13 01-2, 13 04-10, 13 1 3-4, 13 16-9 ; Lamoureux 1302-4, 13 10-3, 13 15- 6 ; Mitchelson 13 01-19 Cummings, Hon.

Glen (PC, Ste. Rose) (Minis ter of Environment) (Minister charged with the administration of The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Act and The Jobs Fund Act) Budget Debate 609-16 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 2r 2979-80 ; RIS 3175-6; 3r 3203-5 Environment and Workplace Safety and Health Annu�Report, 1988 (S.P.95) 3026 Environment, Department of Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 32) 696 Environment, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 2446-8, 2453 27 Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont.

Response Cerilli 2448- 50; Edwards 2450-3 Administration and Finance Community Relations Salaries 2538-41 Executive Support Salaries 2453-77 Planning and Innovation Salaries 2477-82, 2519- 38 Environmental Advisory Organization Clean Environment Comm ittee Salaries 278 3-7 Manitoba Environment Council Salaries 2787-90 Environmental Management Environmental Management Salaries 2548-50 , 2631- 49, 2718-36, 2765-82 Environmental Operations Salaries 2541 -8 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp. 2783 Sustainable Development, International Institute for 2790 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Annu�Report, 1989 (S.

P. 12) 95 Oral Questions Archeological assessments Payment responsibility 13 29 Bi11No.24 Consultations 2382-3, 2554 Federal-provincial discussions 2383 Federal responsibility 2608 Provincial responsibility 2553 Wording 2608-9 Bill of Rights, Environmental Introduction 2794 Bluestem park Pollution cleanup 368 Conawapa Dam Project Access road tenders 2486 Clean Environment Commission 584 Delay penalites 587 Ecosystem boundaries 1197 Environmental impact study 13 25-6 Environmental licensing 1197 Cross Lake, Manitoba Water quality 3031 Ducks Unlimited Canada Environmental licensing 388, 1885 Environment, Department of

Hansard Index Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont.

Staffing 265-6, 982 Environmental assessments Government position 194 Federal authority 2553-4 Environmental Innovations Fund Funding criteria 1147 Grant limit 1202 Environmental laws Enforcement 2794, 3029-30 Increased fines 981 Informant protection 2794 Reporting system 982 Environmental programs Funding 1010, 1201 Recycling initiatives 114 6 Environmental project reviews Federal-provincial panels 58 6 Standards reduction 58 6-7 Hazardous waste Disposal regulations 258 Disposal site-North Dakota 3030 Manitoba Environmental Council Operating budget 1548 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Funding388 Manitoba Public Insurance Corp. No fault insurance 1 01-2 Oak Hammock Marsh Tourism potential18 84-5 Traffic Increase 1884 Palliser Furniture Ltd.

Emission levels 267, 2700 Environmental permit conditions 472 Environmental testing 535 Radon gas levels Schools, public 826- 7 Testing 827 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Government action 1323-4 Government initiatives 193-4 Government position 144 Legal intervention 33 Legal opinion request 144 Licence withdrawal 37, 1323 Manitoba interests 144 Recycling programs Government initiatives 14 04, 15 49-50 Remand Centre construction Contaminated soil 3029 Gasoline seepage 2949 Resource Recovery Institute Blue-Bag Program funding 1 00-1 , 15 49 28 Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont.

Correspondence request 1549 Funding application 1202 Funding commi ttment 1404 Government action 147 Review 15 48-9 Seine River Illegal dumping 372 Pollution cleanup 371 Shoal Lake- Water quality Compensation 2798 Consolidated Professor Mines 2697 Consultations 2697 Environmental impact hearings 2697 Winnipeg, City of Sewage system upgrade 2798 Dacquay, Louise (PC, Seine River) Introduction of Guests Hammon d, Gerrie Former MLA (Kirkfield Park) 116 Roch, Gilles Former MLA (Springfield) 116 Oral Questions Economic growth Forecast, Royal Bank 631 Points of Order P/0 by McCrae respecting words wmislead" and wdeceivedw (Lamoureux) 524-5 ; withdrawn 525 Throne Speech Debate 81- 4 Day care See Child care Decentralization Agriculture, Department of Carstairs 194 5-6; Findlay 194 3-6, 2072, 2074, 2078 ; Plohman 194 3-5, 2072,2074 Co-ordination Carstairs 2929-31 ; Downey 929-31 Costs Downey 2923-4; Wowchuk 2923-4 Criteria Downey 2925; Wowchuk 2924-5 Education, Department of Carstairs 1 056-9, 1129 ; Chomiak 1 059-60; Derkach 1 056- 60, 1129 Energy and Mines, Department of Hickes 2286 ; Neufeld 2286 Equivalent employment

Hansard Index Decentral ization - Cont. Carstairs 1807 ; Downey 1807 Expansion Downey 2933; Wowchuk 2933 Family Services, Department of Alcock 1695- 6 ; Barr 16 91- 5 ; Gilleshammer 1691- 6 Government Services, Department of Dewar 16 00; Driedger 1595-1601 ; Lamoureux 1595 -8; Plohman 1598-1601 Highways and Transportation, Department of Driedger 1720; Gaudry 1720 Labour, Department of Lamoureux 1839; Praznik 1839 Manitoba Agriculture Credit Corporation Downey 2927-8; Wowchuk 2927-8 Natural Resources, Department of Enns 2853 ; C.

Evans 2853 Northem tax allowance Downey 2932; Wowchuk 2932 Office space Carstairs 2931-2; Downey 2931- 2 Relocation statistics Carstairs 2928-9 ; Downey 2922-3, 2928 -9; Wowchuk 2922-3 Rural Development, Department of Carstairs 2198-2 200; Penner 2198-2200 Statistics Carstairs 180 6 ; Downey 180 6-7 Status report L.

Evans 338 ; Downey 338-9 Water Resource Manager Downey 2925-7; Enns 3055-6; Wowchuk 2925-7, 3055-6 Decentralization (Supply) Carstairs 2920-1, 2928-32 , 2934; Downey 2920-34; Wowchuk 2920, 2922 -8, 2932-3 Deer Lodge Hospital Extended care beds Cheema 2107; Orchard 148-9 , 2107-8 ; Wasylycia-Leis 148 Understaffing Orchard 14 9; Wasylycia-L eis 149 Derkach, Hon. Leonard (PC, Roblln-Russell) (Minister of Education and Training) Brandon University Annual Financial Report, 1990 (T.P. 16) 366 29 Derk ach, Hon, Leonard - Cont.

Budget Debate 491-9 Education and Training, Advisory Board for Annu�Report,1 989 (S.P.78 ) 1800 Education and Training, Department of Planning, Research and Policy Branch Project list (T.P. 4) 868 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 31) 696 Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 851-9 Response Carstairs 859 -62; Chomiak 862- 6 Administration and Finance Administration and Professional Certification Salaries 1 056-60 Communications Salaries 1055 Executive Support Salaries 866-7 Financial Services Salaries 1047-55 Personnel Services Salaries 104 7 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Salaries 868 -75, 963-7, 1043-7 Bureau de le'education francalse 1135- 9 Financial Support-8chools School Grants and Other Assistance 1062-5,1 106-19 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Assiniboine Community College Salaries 1188-90 Executive Administration Salaries 1184 Keewatin Community College Salaries 1 190-3 Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Salaries 1 184 -5 Red River Community College Salaries 1 185-8 Student Financial Assistance Salaries 1 193-4 Workforce 2000/Job Training for Tomorrow Salaries 1240-2 Program Development Support Services Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area

Hansard Index Derk ach, Hon. Leonard - Cont.

Renewed Agreement- Education Development Grants 1131-3 Child Care and Development Salaries 112 7 Curriculum Services Salaries 1119-24 Distance Education and Technology Salaries 1 128- 31 Division Administration Salaries 1119 Inner-City Education Initiative Salaries 1 133-5 Instructional Resources Salaries 112 7 -8 Manitoba School for the Deaf Salaries 1125- 7 Native Education Salaries 1124-5 Statutory Boards and Commissions 1060-2 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19) C/W 353-8 , 363-4, 919-21 Non-Political Statements National Students Day 152 Oral Questions ACCESS Program Student recruitment 97-8 Aboriginal tribal councils Health services administration 1621 Apprenticeship training Funding532 Government initiatives 531 Budget Education funding 386, 391 Education, aboriginal Government commitment 3122 Education and Training, Department of Five-year strategic plan 888 Education finance Consultation paper 2668 Family violence Crimes against women Education programs 2605 Protection-Universities 2605 Federal-provincial agreements Education programs 3123 Goods and services tax Impact education 1398 Keewatin Community College Hiring freeze 3125 Literacy programs Corporate sponsorship 1006-7 30 Derk ach, Hon.

Leonard - Cont. Manitoba Association of School Trustees Cabinet meeting request 1670-1 Manitoba Learning Centre Funding 2038 Mathematics examination Implementation 1674 Manitoba Association of School Trustees Position 1670 Mystery Lake School Board Portable classroom construction 1008- 9, 1013-4 Pay equity Extension 3127 St.

James-Assiniboia School Division Accou ntability system 888 Provincial Auditor's report 2796-7 School divisions Boundaries review 889 Enrollment reporting 888 -9 Schools, public Breakfast programs 1551 Deterioration 372 Rebuilding program 372, 374 Strategies For Success report Government consultations 167 4 University of Brandon BUNTEP program funding 3124 University of Manitoba Dean-Faculty of Management Assessment report 823 Human Rights Commission referral823 lnquiry 822 Winnipeg Adult Education Centre Funding 98 Winnipeg Education Centre Funding 2663-4, 2668-9, 3119 -20 Winnipeg School Division No. 1 Breakfast programs 1551 Special education costs 1398-9 Private Members' Business Resolutions School Division Boundary Review 1657- 9 Immig rants, equivalency of education and work experience of 971-4 Public Schools Finance Board Annua1Report, 1989 (S.P.49 )366 Tabled Papers Pupil transportation discussion paper (T.P. 62) 1254 Teachers' Retirement Allowances Fund Board

Hansard Index Derkach, Hon. Leonard • Cont. Annua1Report, 19 89 (S. P.50)366 Universities Grants Commission Annu�Report, 19 89 (S.

P. 48) 366 University of Manitoba Annual Financial Report, 19 90 (S.P. 47) 366 University of Winnipeg Financial Statements, 1990 (T.P. 15) 366 Dew ar, Gregory (NDP, Selkirk) Community Support Programs (Supply) Lotteries Funded Programs Lotteries Distribution Systems 1433-5 Government Services, Department of (Supply) Administration Human Resource Services Salaries 1600 Property Management Executive Administration Salaries 1603 Leased Properties Other Expenditures 1607-8 Security and Parking Salaries 1609 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bi1112) 2r 2885 -6 Oral Questions Crystal Casino strike Government action 264 Mediator appointment 264 Manitoba Telephone System Board member replacement 19 4 Community Calling Program 371, 537 Jessie Avenue property 538 Rural rate increase 675 Selkirk Mental Health Centre Employee morale 2301 Informational picket line 2300 Pay equity 2300 Sport Select Market survey 2699 Sale to minors 2699 Tabled Papers Thompson, City of Resolution regarding Toll Free Calling (T.P. 17) 371 Throne Speech Debate 225-7 Doer, Gary (NDP, Concordia) Appointments 31 Doer, Gary - Cont.

Speaker of the House 2 Budget Debate 392-401 Canada-Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) 3049-52 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 3r 3200-3 Executive Council (Supply) Opening Remarks Filmon731 Response 732-4 General Administration 737-49 754-8 , 802- 1 0, 813 General Salary Increases (Supply) 3053 Health, Department of (Supply) Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 2237-40 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19 ) CIW 358-60 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12) 2r 2963-8; 3r 3135-8 Legislation (Supply) Elections Manitoba 3052 Ministeri� Statements Manitoba Constitutional Task Force Response 2602-3 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Response 936 Wage settlements, public sector Response 3118-9 Non-Political Statements Hall, Gordon Death of former Manitoba Court of Appeal justice 444 Remembrance Day 988 Salutations 3141 Winnipeg Blue Bombers Grey Cup 1809 -10, 1886 -7 Oral Questions ACCESS program Continuation 438- 40 Funding 3120 ACRE Group Hazardous waste storage proposal 937 Apprenticeship training Affirmative action 532 Funding 531-2 Government initiatives 531 Budget

Doer, Gary - Cont.

Education funding 384 Burns Meats Ltd.-Brandon Job placements 667-8 Plant closure 667 Child and Family Services Funding 96 Layoffs 95 Conawapa Dam Project Ecosystem boundaries 1197 Energy saving proposal 1197 Environmental licensing 11 96-7 Environmental review process 1666 Constitutional issues Aboriginal representation 626 Public consultations 625 Cross Lake Indian Band Timber cutting rights 462 Cultural awareness programs Implementation 980-1 Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Acting Minister of RemovaVapology request 979 Economic growth Community involvement 383 Government strategy 31 9-20 Public consultations 626 Economic recession All-party committee 2662-3 Business/labour summit 2663 Established Programs Financing Government position 2375 Family violence Government strategy 28- 9 Federal-provincial relations Responsibility 2293-4 Finance Minister's meeting Economic discussions 2604 Health care system-National 2662 Free Trade Agreement-Mexico Government initiatives 231-2 Government position 2150 Negotiations 231 Fuel price increases Government initiatives 186 -8 GATT negotiations Contingency plan 114 2 Government position, federal1 141-2 Goods and services tax Amendments 3026 Exemptions 3026-7 Hazardous waste Disposal regulations 257-8 Hansard Index 32 Doer, Gary - Cont.

Health care system Drug rehabilitation programs 385 Home Care Program funding 384 -5 Health care system-National Decentralization 1877 - 8 Government action 2604 Government position 2032-4,2 374, 2604-5 Manitoba position 1878 Human Rights Commission Case backlog 980 Resources 980 Labour laws Notwithstanding clause 817 Literacy programs Corporate sponsorship 1006- 7 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Government proposal 938 Pesticide disposal 937 Manitoba Intercultural Council Anti-racism report recommendations 978-9 Manitoba Nurses' Union Government offer 3144-6 Government position 314 6-7 Premier's involvement 31 43-5 Minimum wage Increase 2149 Ministers of Finance meeting Goods and services discussion 180 1 Oak Hammock Marsh Environmental licence appea1582 RCMP services Manitoba representation 2948 Premier's position 2947-8 Regional replacement 2689 -90 Rafferty- Alameda Dam Project Court decision 887 Government action 1322- 3, 1666 Licence procedure 144 Licence withdrawal 37, 1323 Manitoba interests 1 04, 142-3 Manitoba representation 1802 Premier's position 143 Water quality 11- 2, 1801- 2 Recycling programs Funding 16 65-6 Repap Manitoba Inc.

Agreement renegotiation 581-2 Share value 463 Retail sales tax Revenue forecast1800 Senate appointments First Ministers' meeting 1547

Hansard Index Doer, Gary - Cont.

Legal decision-New Brunswick 1546-7 Legal intervention 12 Legal opinion request 12-3 Shoal Lake-water quality Mining permits 1397 Premier of Ontario meeting 886, 1396 Premier of Sakatchewan meeting 887 Telecommunications Competition 696-7 Transportation industry Open-s ky policy 16 17- 8, 2294-5 Winnipeg Education Centre Funding 3119 Points of Order P/0 by Manness respecting reference to answer previously given (Doer) 2150; Ashton 2150; ruled in order 2150 Private Members' Business Resolutions Senate elections 2595-8 Tabled Papers Federal- provincial funding Chart: Dollars paid to Ottawa by Provinces, 196 1 -85 (T.P. 103) 2033 Multiculturalism Interim Report: Combatting Racism (T.P. 53) 978 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Letter dated June 14, 1990 from Natural Resources to Rafferty-Alameda Panel (T.P. 68) 1323 Saskatchewan Water Corporation/Federal Government addendum (T.P. 3) 143 Throne Speech Debate 37-48 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Manitoba Nurses' Union strike Government handling 3159 -61 Domestic violence See Family violence Domtar Soil contamination Cerilli 2781- 2; Cummings 2781- 2 33 Downey, Hon.

James (PC, Arthur-VIrden} (Minister of Northern Aff airs) (Minister respo nsible for Native Aff airs, The Manitoba Natural Resources Development Act (with respect to Channel Area Loggers Ltd. and Moose Lake Loggers Ltd.}, A.E. McKenzie Co. Ltd. and The Manitoba 011 and Gas Corporation Act} (Minis ter resp onsible for and charged with the administrati on of the Communities Economic Development Fund Act) (Minister responsible for Seniors) A.E. McKenzie Co. Ltd. Auditor's Report, 1988 and 1989 (S. P. 39) 318 News release (T.P. 119) 2483 Budget Debate 479-86 Channel Area Loggers Ltd.

Annum Report, 1989 (S.P. 72)624 Communities Economic Development Fund Annum Report, 1989 (S.P.40) 318 Co-operative, Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supply) Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 12 93-4 Decentralization (Supply) 2920- 34 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19) CIW 338-9, 914-5 Manitoba Intercultural Council Amendment Act (Bill 9) 2r 883-5 Manitoba Seniors Directorate Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 199 0-91 Estimates (T.P. 30) 696 Manitoba Seniors Directorate (Supply) Opening Remarks 1015-6 Response Gaudry 1 020-1 ; Santos 1016- 20 Other Expenditures 1 021-42 Moose Lake Loggers Ltd.

Annua1Report, 1989 (S. P.71) 624 Non-Political Statements Aboriginal Honour Celebration Banquet, First annual 20-1 Hall, Gordon Death of former Manitoba Court of Appeal justice 444 Harper, Elijah

Hansard Index Downey, Hon. James - Cont.

Newsmaker of the Year 3035 Northern Association of Community Councils 392 Winnipeg Blue Bombers Grey Cup 1809 Northam Affairs, Department of Annu�Report, 198 9 (S.P. 38 ) 318 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates, (T.P. 96) 1674 Northern Affairs, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 188 7 -90 Response Gaudry 18 92; Lathlin 18 90-2 Administration and Finance Communications Other Expenditures 1894 Salaries 1894 Communities Economic Development Fund 18 94-8 Executive Support Other Expenditures 18 93-4 Salaries 1893 Financial and Administrative Services Salaries 1894 Minister's Salary 1919- 21 Northern Affairs Fund Salaries 1894 Agreements Management and Co-ordination Agreements Management Northern Rood Agreement 1903 Economic Development Canada-Manitoba Special ARDA Agreement 1904-7 Corporate Projects 1904 Other Expenditures 1904 Northern Development Co-ordination Salaries 1903 Expenditures Related to Capital Community Access and Resource Roads 1918 Cottage Sub- Divisions 191 9 Northern Communities 1918 Local Government Development Dauphin Region Salaries 1902 Emergency Response Program 1902 Intergovernmental Regional Services Salaries 1903 Programs and Operational Support Community Operations 1898-9 34 Downey, Hon.

James - Cont. Community Training 18 99-1900 General Support Grants 189 9 Grants 19 00-1 Other Expenditures 1898 Regional Services 19 00 Technical Services Other Expenditures 1902-3 Salaries 1902 Native Affairs Secretariat Aboriginal Development Programs 1916- 8 Salaries 1907-16 Oral Questions A.E. McKenzie Co. Ltd.

Announcement 2490 Funding status 704-5 Aborigin� language programs Funding 190 Aboriginal rights Hunting 16- 7 Age and Opportunity Centre Funding 2382, 2557 Bankruptcy rates Government initiatives 16 67-8 Bill C-22 Leg� challenge 14 05 Budget Impact northern Manitoba 38 9-90 Canada Post services Minister's position 223 9 Conawapa Dam Project Environmental review process 1666 Decentr�ization Equivalent employment 1807 Statistics 18 06-7 Elder abuse Legislation 2040 Report release 2040 Safe house 2041 Multicultural policy Contradictions 589 Northern tax allowance Benefit cutbacks 2951 Provincial revitalization Government initiatives 1672 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Government action 1666 Recycling programs Funding 1665 Rock Ridge, Manitoba Community hall funding 442 Community status 443 Rural Dignity of Canada

Hansard Index Downey, Hon. James - Cont. Court challenge-Canada Post 238- 9, 1555 Seniors, Minister responsible for Responsibility 2382 Throne speech Aboriginal issues 236 Treaty land entitlement Government agenda 366 Private Members' Business Resolutions Social assistance, one-tier system 1074-6 Downtown development corporations Amalgamation Carr 326, 21 05; Ducharme 326, 2105- 6 Co-o rdination Carr 1 02; Ducharme 102 Driedger, Hon.

Albert (PC, Steinbach) (Minister of Hi ghways and Transportation) (Minister of Government Services) Budget Debate 553-9 Government Services, Department of Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 36) 816 Government Services, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 15 93-4 Response Lamoureux 1594-5 Administration Human Resource Service Salaries 159 5-1601 Lieutenant Governor's Office Salaries 1601-2 Management Support Salaries 15 95 Expenditures Related to Capital Acquisition/Construction of Physical Assets 16 13 -6 Property Management Executive Administration Salaries 1602-4 Leased Properties Other Expenditures 16 07-8 Salaries 16 05-7 Physical Plant Salaries 1604-5 Property Services 35 Driedger, Hon.

Albert - Cont. Salaries 1608- 9 Security and Parking Salaries 1609-1 0 Supply and Services Fleet Vehicles Salaries 161 0-2 Office Equipment Services Salaries 1612 Postal Services Salaries 1613 Highways and Transportation, Department of Annua1Report,1 989 (S.

P. 21) 185 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 57) 119 6 Highways and Transportation, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 1715 -7, 171 9 Response Gaudry 1718; Reid 1717-8 Administration and Finance Administrative Services Other Expenditures 1721 Salaries 1721 Computer Services Salaries 1723 Executive Support Salaries 171 9-20 Financial Services Salaries 1721 Minister's Salary 1787 Occupational Health and Safety Salaries 1723 -4 Personnel Services Other Expenditures 1722- 3 Salaries 1721-2 Boards and Committees Taxicab Board 1786-7 Driver and Vehicle Licensing Licensing Salaries 178 3-5 Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Cost-Sharing Agreement 1785-6 Safety Salaries 1785 Engineering and Technical Services Government Air and Radio Services Less Recoverable 1771 Other Expenditures 1769 -71 Management Services

Driedger, Hon. Albert - Cont.

Salaries 1759- 60 Marine Services Salaries and Wages 1765-6 Materials and Research Other Expenditures 1766-7 Salaries and Wages 1766 Mechanical Equipment Services Less Recoverable 1760-3 Salaries 1760 Northam Airports Other Expenditures 1763-4 Traffic Engineering Salaries and Wages 1767-9 Warehouse Stores Purchases 1763 Operations and Maintenance Bridges and Structures Bridge Maintenance 1728 Other Expenditures 1727-8 Salaries 1726-7 District Offices Other Expenditures 1731 Salaries and Wages 1730-1 Maintenance Program 1724 Operations and Contracts Salaries and Wages 1725- 6 Other Jurisdictions Gross Expenditures 1731 Less Recoverable 1731 Transport Compliance Other Expenditures 1730 Salaries and Wages 1728-30 Winter Roads 1 00% Provincial1725 Shareable with Canada 1725 Planning and Design and Land Surveys Land Surveys Other Expenditures 1732-3 Planning and Design Other Expenditures 1732 Salaries and Wages 1731-2 Transportation Policy and Research Canada-Manitoba Churchill Agreement 1781-3 Transportation Policy and Research Salaries 1771-80 Non- Political Statements Legislative Building Christmas lights 2384 Oral Questions CN Rail Layoffs 149-50 Hansard Index 36 Driedger, Hon.

Albert - Cont.

CP Rail Line abandonment Fisher Branch elevator 891 Highways maintenance costs 89 1 Rail car inspections 1805 Crescent Creamery property Community concerns 368 Cross Lake, Manitoba Pipestone Crossing bridge 3031 Emergency Measures Organization Budget cancellation 893 Policy change 893 Training payment policy 892, 942-3 Grain Transportation Agency Trucking subsidy cuts 891 Grand Valley Road-Brandon, Manitoba Mail service 2302 Highways and Transportation, Department of Rail car inspections 1624 Railway disaster plan 1624 Legislative Building Access policy 30 Port of Churchill Grain shipments 1 01 Remand Centre construction Gasoline seepage 2949 Taxicab industry Meetingrequest 237 Transportation Commission Manitoba submission 1550-1 Transportation industry Open-sky policy 18 07, 2295, 2383 Public hearings 2669 Transportation Industry Development Advisory Committee Agreement renewal 1808 Unicity Taxi Luxury cab proposal 237-8 VIA Rail Northam route protection 584 ,1 400,1550, 1807 Railbus status 703 Route cancellations 583 Service cuts 703 Sleeper cars-Churchill route 1 01 Throne Speech Debate 62-9 Driver licenses Photo identification Driedger 17 83 -5 ; Gaudry 1785 ; Reid 1783 -4 ; Wowchuk 1784

Ducharme, Hon.

Gerry (PC, Riel) (Minister of Urban Affairs) (Minister of Housing ) Budget Debate 542-9 Housing, Department of Annua1Report,1 989 (S.P.11 ) 95 Annu�Report, 1990 1322 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 66) 1322 Housing, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 28 89-90 Response Alcock 28 93-5; Martindale 28 91-3 General Administration Planning and Information Systems Salaries 2896- 2901 Support Services Salaries 2902 Landlord and Tenant Affairs Salaries 2902-13 Operations Administration Salaries 2914-5 Property Management Salaries 2915 -20 Interim Appropriation Act, 1990 (Bill 19) CIW 342-5, 354, 356, 358, 362-3, 917-8 Messages Bill No. 13 Recommendation-Li eutenant-Governor (S.

P. 26) 185 Ombudsman Amendment Act (Bill 25) 1 r 2032; 2r 2304-5; RIS 31 29; 3r 31 29; RIA 3140 Oral Questions Aboriginal language program Funding369 Core Area Initiative Contingency funding 96 Education funding 190 Program evaluations 2040 Replacement funding 2040 Downtown development agreement Co-ordination 1 02 Downtown development corporations Amalgamation 326 Forks Renewal Corporation Chief executive officer 327 Hansard Index 37 Ducharme, Hon. Gerry - Cont.

Housing development 1 02 Heritage buildings Preservation 585 Housing, Department of Administration 590 Industrial technology Research and development 630 Landfill sites Government policy 162 0 Lauzon, Ronda Winnipeg Regional Housing 2380-1 North Portage Development Corporation South Portage initiatives 1331 Portage Avenue Commercial vacancy rate 1331 Recycling programs Government initiatives 162 0-1 Resource Recovery Institute Meetingrequest 162 0 Residential Tenancies Act Amendments 537 Delays5 37 Introduction 31, 537 Lobby Groups 32 Rive..- Winnipeg Cleanup 1672 -3 Tri-level task force 1673 Seniors' housing Shelter supplements 590 Shelter �lowances Rate increase 14 00 Social assistance Central housing registry 261 1 Housing advocacy group 2611 SAFFRISAFER benefits 261 1 Swan River Friendship Centre Housing subsidies 325-6 Urban Native Strategy Status report 1671 Winnipeg, City of Revenue opportunities 2381 Winnipeg Education Centre Government support 1672 Winnipeg Housing Rehabilitation Corp.

Unit allocations 1883 Rent Regulation Program Annu� Report on the Administration of, 1990 (S.P. 35) 318 Residential Tenancies and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 13) 1r 185 ; 2r 16 26-8; RIS 31 29; 3r 3131 ; RIA 3140

Hansard Index Ducharme, Hon. Gerry - Cont. Urban Affairs, Department of Annuw Report, 1990 1322 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 1990-91 Estimates (T.P. 65) 1322 Urban Affairs, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 1462-3 Response Carr 14 64-5; Friesen 14 63-4 Administration and Finance Administration and Anancial Services Salaries 14 68-7 0 Executive Support Salaries 1465-8 Minister's Salary 1501-2 Canada- Manitoba A.R.C.

Agreement 14 97- 8 Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area Renewal Agreement Payments to Other Implementing Jurisdictions 14 92-7 Expenditures Related to Capital Riverbank Development 1500 Shoal Lake Agreement 1499-1500 Anancial Assistance to City of Winnipeg General Support Grant 1477-9 Unconditional Current Programs Grant 147 0 Urban Transit Operating Grant 147 1-6 Riverbank Development 14 98- 9 Urban Policy and Agreement Management North Portage Redevelopment 147 9-92 Ducks Unlimited Canada Environmental licensing Cerilli 388, 1885 ; Cummings 388 , 1885 Withdrawal Cerllli 2157 ; Almon 2157 Expansion Cerilli 2157 ; Almon 2157 Letter dated July 26, 1990 to Cummings from Wayne Neily (T.P. 20) Cerilll 388 Letter dated September 7, 1990 to Cumm ings from Enns (T.P. 19 ) Cerilli 388 Letter dated September 14 , 1990 regarding mediation process (T.P. 18 ) Cerilll 388 Minister's endorsement 38 Ducks Unlimited Canada - Cont.

Cerilli 2158 ; Enns 2158 See also Oak Hammock Marsh EMO See Emergency Measures Organization ERDA agreements Renegotiation Ernst 322; Storie 322 Replacement funding Ernst 349-51 ; Storie 349-51 East Selkirk Bridge Maintenance Driedger 17 27-8; Gaudry 17 27-8 ; Reid 17 27- 8 Eastman Crisis Centre Funding Barrett 188; Gilleshammer 188 Funding delay Barrett 325; Gilleshammer 325 Funding formula Barrett 325; Gilleshammer 325 Reopening date Barrett 188; Gilleshammer 188 Eastwood School- Thompson See Mystery Lake School Division Economic Devel opment, Standing Committee on 1st Report Stefanson 1140 2nd Report Stefanson 2293 Economic growth All-party task force Manness 2795-6; Storie 2795-6 Community involvement Doer 383 ; Filmon 383 First Ministers' Conference L.

Evans 323-4; Filmon 324 Forecast Alcock 2154- 5 ; L. Evans 959; Manness 959, 2154-5 Forecast, five-year L. Evans 590; Manness 590 Forecast, Royal Bank Dacquay 631 ; Manness 631

Hansard Index Economic growth - Cont. Government initiatives Doer 31 9-20; Ernst 14 5; L. Evans 18 , 323, 18 04-5, 21 56; Filmon 319 -20; Manness 18 , 323, 18 04-5, 21 56; Storie 14 5 Job creation L. Evans 2667-8; Manness 2668, 2796; Storie 2796 Public consultations Carstairs 627; Doer 626; Filmon 626-7 Stimulation L. Evans 387, 589, 2667-8; Manness 387, 589, 2667-8 Economic reces sion All-party committee Doer 2662-3; Filmon 2663 Business/labour summit Doer 2663; Filmon 2663 Manitoba situation L.

Evans2560;Manness2560 Education, aboriginal Funding-Federal Filmon 236; Harper 236 Government commitment Carstairs 31 22; Derkach 312 2 See also Aboriginal language program Education and Training, Advisory Board for Annua1 Report, 19 89 (S.P. 78) Derkach 18 00 Education and Training, Department of Certification Review Committee Carstairs 1060-1 ; Chomiak 1061 ; Derkach 1 060-2 Five-year strategic plan Carstairs 963-5; Chomiak 887-8; Derkach 887, 963-5; Filmon 888 Planning, Research and Policy Branch Project list (T.P. 4) Derkach 868 Priorities Chomiak 1043; Derkach 1043 Pupil transportation discussion paper (T.P. 62) Derkach 12 54 Reports availability Chomiak 1043; Derkach 1043 Student records 39 Education and Training - Cont.

Carstairs 1 056; Derkach 1056 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 31 ) Derkach 696 Transportation system, pilot project Chomiak 1047-8; Derkach 1047-8 See also Strategies for Success Education and Training (Supply) Opening Remarks Derkach 851 -9 Response Carstairs 859-62; Chomiak 862-6 Administration and Finance Administration and Professional Certification Salaries Carstairs 1 056-9; Chomiak 1 059-60; Derkach 1056-60 Communications Salaries Chomiak 1055; Derkach 1055 Executive Support Salaries Chomiak 866-7; Derkach 866-7 Financial Services Salaries Carstairs 1050-3; Chomiak 1047-50, 1053-5; Derkach 1047-55 Minister's Salary Derkach 12 60-6; Plohman 12 59-65; Reid 12 65-6 Personnel Services Salaries Chomiak 1047; Derkach 1047 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Salaries Carstairs 963-7, 1 046; Chomiak 868-75, 963, 1043-7; Derkach 868-75, 963-5, 967, 1043-7 Bureau de !'education franciase Carstairs 1 13 5-8; Chomiak 11 37; Derkach 11 35-9 Expenditures Related to Capital Acquisition/Construction Red River Community College Carstairs 12 55-6; Chomiak 12 52-5; Derkach 12 52-8; Lamoureux 12 56-8 Financial Support-Schools School Grants and Other Assistance Carstairs 11 08-12, 1116 -8;

Hansard Index Education and Training - Cont.

Chomiak 1062-4, 11 06-8, 11 12 -6, 1118 ; Derkach 1 062-5, 11 06-9 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Assiniboine Community College Salaries Carstairs 1 18 8-90; Derkach 11 88-90 Executive Administration Salaries Chomiak 1184 ; Derkach 1184 Keewatin Community College Salaries Carstairs 119 2-3; Chomiak 11 90-2; Derkach 11 90-3 Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Salaries Chomiak 11 84; Derkach 1184 -5 Red River Community College Salaries Carstairs 11 86-8; Chomiak 118 5-6; Derkach 118 5-8 Student Financial Assistance Salaries Carstairs 1194 ; Chomiak 119 3; Derkach 119 3-4 Workforce 2000/Job Training for Tomorrow Salaries Carstairs 12 41 -2; Chomiak 12 40-1 ; Derkach 12 40-2 Program Development Support Services Canada-Manitoba Winnipeg Core Area Renewed Agreement-Education Development Grants Carstairs 113 3; Chomiak 113 1- 2; Derkach 11 31- 2 Child Care and Development Salaries Chomiak 11 27; Derkach 11 27 Curriculum Services Salaries Carstairs 111 9-24; Chomiak 112 2-3; Derkach 111 9-24 Distance Education and Technology Salaries Carstairs 11 28-31 ; Chomiak 1 12 8; Derkach 11 28-31 Division Administration Salaries Chomiak 1119 ; Derkach 1119 Inner-City Education Initiative Salaries 40 Education and Training - Cont.

Carstairs 11 34-5; Chomiak 1 13 3-4; Derkach 11 34-5 Instructional Resources Salaries Chomiak 11 27-8; Derkach 1 12 7-8 Manitoba School for the Deaf Salaries Carstairs 11 25-6; Derkach 1 12 5-7 Native Education Salaries Carstairs 11 25; Chomiak 11 24-5; Derkach 11 25-5 Statutory Boards and Commissions Carstairs 1060-1; Chomiak 1061 -2; Derkach 1 060-2 Universities Grants Commission Carstairs 12 49-52; Chomiak 12 42-9; Derkach 12 42-52 Education Finance Consultation paper Chomiak 2668; Derkach 2668 Education, Northern Government strategy Chomiak 873-4; Derkach 873-4 Education programs Corporate sponsorship Chomiak 1 044; Derkach 1 044-5 Special needs Program co-ordination Alcock 14 50-2; Gilleshammer 14 50-2 Edwards, Paul {Liberal, St.

James) Budget Debate 453-9 Conflict of interest Ducks Unlimited Canada Edwards 2720 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 3r 31 76-84 Environment, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Cummings 2446-8, 2453 Response 2450-3 Administration and Finance Executive Support Salaries 2458-69, 2473-7 Minister's Salary 2790-1 Planning and Innovation

Edwards, Paul - Cont.

Salaries 2480-1 , 251 9-27 Environmental Advisory Organization Clean Environment Commission Salaries 2783-4 Manitoba Environment Council Salaries 2789 Environmental Management Environmental Management Salaries 2548-50,2646-9,2731 -7, 2765-72 Environmental Operations Salaries 2541 -7 Sustainable Development, International Institute for 2790 Justice, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks McCrae 17 87-8 Response 17 89-90 Administration and Rnance Communications Salaries 18 73-4 Executive Support Salaries 17 95-9, 18 54-5 Public Inquiry into the Administration of Jus tice and Aboriginal People 18 75 Research and Development Salaries 18 56-8 Public Prosecutions Law Enforcement Administration Salaries 2371-3 Office of the Chief Medical Examiner Salaries 2367-8 Provincial Police 2368-9 Public Prosecutions Salaries 2351 -2, 2361 -7 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bi11 12 ) 2r 11 58-62; 3r 31 38 Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Enns 2833-6 Response 2836-7 Administration and Finance Minister's Salary 3058-60 Resource Integration Salaries 2838-44, 2851 -2 Non-Political Statements Aboriginal Honour Celebration Banquet, First annual 20 Crime Prevention Month 633 World Food Day 104-5 Hansard Index 41 Edwards, Paul - Cont.

Oral Questions Agassiz Youth Centre Living conditions 98 Report tabling request 99 Bill No. 24 Consultations 2554 Provincial responsibility 2553 Retroactive application 21 51- 3 Bluestem Park Pollution cleanup 368 CSIS agreement Medical record confidentiality 536 Minister's position 536 Conawapa Dam Project Delay penalties 587 Environmental impact study 13 25-6 Crescent Creamery property Community concerns 368 Crime prevention Federal authority 2553 Government initiatives 631 Criminal injuries compensation Program implementation 2609 Criminal Prosecutions Assistant Deputy Minister comments 2666 Environmental assessments Government position 194 Environmental Innovations Fund Grant limit 12 02 Environmental laws Enforcement 3029-30 Environmental programs Funding 12 01 Environmental project reviews Federal-provincial panels 586 Standards reduction 586 Firearms control Family violence 2609 Purchase restrictions 2609 Government employees Parking pass forgeries 2666-7 Lauzon, Ronda Arrest procedure 2380 Departmental review 2379-80 Trial justification 18 03 Winnipeg Regional Housing 2380 Manitoba Environmental Council Operating budget 15 48 Parent-Child Centres Government support 18 03 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Environmental hearing process 14

Hansard Index Edwards , Paul - Cont.

Government initiatives 19 3 Government position 144 legal intervention 32-3 legal opinion request 144 Manitoba interests 13 -5, 144 Remand Centre construction Contaminated soil 3029 Gasoline seepage 2949-50 Resource Recovery Institute Funding application 12 01-2 Review 154 8 Rivers-Winnipeg Cleanup 16 72 Tri-level task force 16 73 Shoal lake-Wate r quality Compensation 2798 Consolidated Professor Mines 2696-7 Consultations 2697 Environmental impact hearings 2697 Suspended drivers Police enforcement 1014 Winnipeg, City of Sewage system upgrade 2798 Winnipeg Police Department Minority representation 822 Winnipeg Remand Centre Bail assistance program 894 Quick release program 894 Points of Order P/0 by Edwards respecting casting aspersions (Filmon) 15 ; apology requested 15 ; ruled out of order 15 Private Members' Business Resolutions Bridge construction projects 2655-8 Crime Prevention Council, establishment 923-6 Re-enacted Statutes of Manitoba (Private Acts) Act, 19 90 (Bill 15 ) 2r 676-7; C/W 116 9 Statute law Amendment Act, 19 90-91 (Bill 22) 3r 3094-5 Tabled Papers Manitoba Environmental Council Memo from W.

Nelly regarding semi-annual meeting (T.P. 82) 15 48 Throne Speech Debate 253-6, 267-71 42 Edwards, Paul - Cont.

Workers Compensation (Supply) Opening Remarks Connery 3036, 3038-9 Response 3037-8 Workers Compensation 3042-3 Elder abuse See Family violence Elections Finances Act Annual Report, 198 9 (S.P. 1) Rocan 28 Elections Manitoba See legislation (Supply) Emergency Measures Organization Budget cancellation Driedger 893; Plohman 892-3 Letter dated October 18 , 19 90 from EMO to Secretary Treasurer (Dauphin) regarding conference (T.P. 44) Plohman 892 Policy change Driedger 893; Plohman 893 Training payment policy Driedger 892, 942-3; Plohman 892 Employment programs Government initiatives l.

Evans 18 ; Manness 18 -9 Employment programs, aboriginal Civil service positions lath lin 2486; Praznik 2486 Decentralization lath lin 2487; Praznik 2487 Government initiatives Lathlin 2486; Praznik 2486-7 Employment programs, youth Sub-minimum wage Martindale 18 85-6; Praznik 18 86 Employment Services and Economic Security, Department of Annua1 Report, 198 9 (S.P. 9) Gillesham mer 95

Hansard Index Employment sta ndards Night worker safety Ashton 21 51 ; Almon 21 51 Employment Standards Act Amendments Ashton 1 042-3; Barrett 16 18 -9; Filmon 14 03, 16 18 -9; Praznik 15 25; Wasylycia-Leis 15 25 Employment Standards Amendment Act (Bill 3) 1 r Ashton 18 6 Employment Standards Amendment Act (2) (811123) 1 r Praznik 2032; 2r Ashton 2866-8; Barrett 2868-9; Praznik 2864-6; referred to Standing Committee on Industrial Relations; Committee Report 31 16 -7; RIS Praznik 312 9; RIA 314 0 Endangered Spaces Program Progress Edwards 2839; Enns 2839 Endangered Species Act Board members Enns 2851 ; Plohman 2851 Energy Alternate sources Carr 18 9; Neufeld 18 9 Conservation Carr 18 9; Hickes 1010 , 15 47; Neufeld 18 9-90,1010 , 15 47 Government initiatives Carr 2282-3; Neufeld 2282-3 Government role Carr 16 21 -2; Almon 16 21 -2 Minister's role Hickes 15 48; Neufeld 15 48 Energy and Mines, Department of Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 70) Neufeld 13 95 Energy and Mines, Department of {Supply) Opening Remarks Neufeld 2270-2 Response 43 Energy and Mines (Supply) - Cont.

Carr 2273-4; Hickes 2273 Administration and Finance Administrative Services Other Expenditures Carr 2279; Neufeld 2279 Salaries Hickes 2278; Neufeld 2278 Executive Support Other Expenditures Carr 2277 -8; Hickes 2277 -8; Neufeld 2277-8 Salaries Carr 2274-6; Hickes 2274, 2276-7; Neufeld 227 4 Minister's Salary Carr 2291- 2; Hickes 2291 Energy Energy Administration Salaries Carr 2280-1 ; Hickes 227�80; Neufeld 2278-81 Energy Planning Salaries Carr 2281 -4; Hickes 2284-5; Neufeld 2281 -5 Energy Programs (Transportation) Salaries Hickes 2285-6; Neufeld 2285-6 Petroleum Salaries Carr 2285; Hickes 2285; Neufeld 2285 Manitoba Energy Authority Carr 2291 ; Neufeld 2291 Mineral Resources Geological Services Salaries Carr 2291 ; Hickes 2290; Neufeld 2290-1 Mineral Development Salaries Carr 2287-8; Hickes 2286-7; Neufeld 2286-8 Mines Salaries Hickes 2288-90; Neufeld 2288-90 Energy and Mines, Minister of Apology request Lamoureux 464-5-6; Ashton 465; Almon 466 Community concerns Carstairs 939-40; Almon 940

Hansard Index Energy and Mines, Minister of - Cont. Government apology Carstairs 940; Filmon 940 Multicultural position Santos 467; Filmon 467 See also Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Acting Minister of Energy Information Centre Closure Hickes 470; Neufeld 470 Public access Hickes 2279; Neufeld 2279 Enns, Hon.

Harry (PC, Lakeside) (Minister of Natural Resources) (Minister respons ible for The Manitoba Natural Resources Development Act (except wHh respect to Channel Area Loggers Ltd. and Moose Lake Loggers Ltd.) Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Policy and Economics Division 2080-1 Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Department of (Supply) Administration and Rnance Human Resource Services Salaries 13 76-7 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 12 ) 2r 11 57-8 Natural Resources, Department of Annual Report, 19 89 (S.P. 34) 257 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 39) 816 Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 2853-6 Response Edwards 2836-7; C.

Evans 2836 Administration and Finance Rnancial Services Salaries 2852-3 Human Resource Management Salaries 2853 Minister's Salary 3055-60 Resource Integration Salaries 2838-52 Venture Manitoba Tours ltd. 2854-6 Regional Services Administration Problem Wildlife Control 2857-63 Oral Questions 44 Enns, Hon. Harry - Cont.

Aboriginal rights Hunting 236-7 Britcher Lumber Cutting rights 15 52 Ducks Unlimited Canada Minister's endorsement 21 58 Rshing industry Diversification 2699 Fuel rebates, federal 704 Government assistance 704 Government initiatives 2698-9 Lake Winnipegosis 373-4 Price decrease 704 Rough fish market 2699 Rafferty-Alameda Dam Project Manitoba representation 18 02-3 Water quality 18 02 Repap Manitoba Inc.

Cutting rights 15 52 Renegotiation 15 52 Points of Order P/0 by Enns respecting rights of Government members to ask questions 19 14 ; ruled in order (Mcintosh) 1914 Throne Speech Debate 246-53 Environment Act-Federal Government position Cummings 194; Edwards 19 4 Environment Amendment Act Assessment applications Cerilli 271 8-9; Cummings 271 8-9 Conawapa Dam Project Cummings 2460-2; Edwards 2460-2 Conflict of Interest Cerilli 2720; Cummings 2720 Consultations Cerilli 2298, 2382-3, 2608; Cummings 2382-3, 2554; Edwards 2554; Almon 2298, 2608 Exemptions City of Winnipeg Cummings 2647-9; Edwards 2647-9 Federal-provincial discussions Cerilli 2383; Cummings 2383 Intervener funding Cerilli 2471 -3; Cummings 2471 -3 Jus tification Cerilli 22982471 ; Cummings 2471 ; Film on 2298-9

Hansard Index Environment Amendment Act - Cont.

Legal opinion Cummings 2467-70, 2473-6; Edwards 2467-70,2473-6 Manitoba Hydro assessment Cummings 2459-60; Edwards 2459-60 Public consultations Cummings 2646; Edwards 2646 Responsibility Federal Cerilli 2608; Cummings 2608; Provincial Cummings 2553; Edwards 2553 Retroactive Cummings 2458-9; Edwards 2151 -3, 2458-9; Filmon 21 52-3 Wording Cerilli 2608; Cummings 2608 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 24) 1 r Filmon 2032; 2r Ashton 2306-1 3; Cerilli 2976-8; Cummings 2979-80; Lamoureux 231 3-7; Manness 2305-6; Santos 231 7-9, 2684-8; referred to Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Committee Report 31 42-3; RIS Cummings 31 75-6; 3r Ashton 31 98-200; Carstairs 31 94-6; Cerilli 31 84-8; Cummings 3203-5; Doer 3200-3; Edwards 31 76-84; Friesen 31 89-91 ; Martindale 31 96-8; Storie 319 1- 4; RIA 3206 Environment and Workplace Safety and Health Annua1 Report, 19 88 (S.P. 95) Cummings 3026 Environment, Department of Annual report, 19 86-87 Cerilli 2457 -8; Cummings 2457-8 Staffing Cerilli 265-6, 982; Cummings 266, 982 Strategic plan Cummings 2481 -2; Edwards 2481 -2 Structure Cummings 2734-6; Edwards 2733-7 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 32) Cummings 696 45 Environment, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks Cummings 2446-8, 2453 Response Cerilli 2448-50; Edwards 2450-3 Administration and Finance Community Relations Salaries Cerilli 2538-41 ; Cummings 2538-41 Executive Support Salaries Cerilli 2453-8, 2470-3; Cummings 2453-77; Edwards 2458-69, 2473-7 Minister's Salary Edwards 2790-1 Planning and Innovation Cerilli 2477-80, 2482;, 2527-37 Cummings 2477-82, 251 9-38; Edwards 2480-1 , 251 9-27 Environmental Advisory Organization Clean Environment Commission Salaries Cerilli 2784-7; Cummings 2783-7; Edwards 2783-4 Manitoba Environment Council Salaries Cerilli 2787-9; Cummings 2787-90; Edwards 2789 Environmental Management Environmental Management Salaries Cerilli 2631 -46, 271 8-31 , 2780-2; Cummings 2548-50, 2631 -49, 271 8-36, 2765-82; Edwards 2548-50, 2646-9, 2731- 7, 2765-72; Findlay 2731 -2; McCrae 2641 ; Reid 2773-8; Santos 2778-80 Environmental Operations Salaries Cummings 2541 -8; Edwards2541 -7; Martindale 2547-8 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp.

Cerilli 2783; Cummings 2783 Sustainable Development, International Institute for Cummings 2790; Edwards 2790 Environmental assessments Federal authority Cummings 2553-4; Edwards 2553

Environ mental Innovations Fund Advocacy groups Cerilli 2534-5; Cummings 2534-5 Biomass Energy Institute Cerilli 2535-6; Cummings 2535-6 CFC recovery program Cerilli 2537; Cummings 2537 Funding cap Cummings 2520; Edwards 2520 Funding criteria Cerilli 1146 -7; Cummings 114 7 Grant limit Cummings 12 02; Edwards 12 02 Projects funded Cerilli 2477-80; Cummings 2477-80 Projects list Cummings 251 9; Edwards 251 9 Radon initiative Cerilli 2533-4; Cummings 2533-4 Recycling Council of Manitoba Cerilli 2537; Cummings 2537 Recycling hotline Cerilli 2536-7; Cummings 2536-7 Thompson Environmental Council Cerilli 2537; Cummings 2537 Environmental laws Enforcement Cerilli 2793-4; Cummings 2794, 3029-30; Edwards 3029-30 Increased fines Cerilli 981 ; Cummings 981 Informant protection Cerilli 2794; Cummings 2794 Mediation Cummings 2480; Edwards 2480 Prosecution Cerilli 2637-41 ; Cummings 2637-41 ; McCrae 2641 Reporting system Cerilli 981-2; Cummings 982 Environmental programs Funding Cerilli 1 01 ; Cummings 101 , 12 01 ; Edwards 12 01 Environmental project reviews Federal-provincial panels Cummings 586; Edwards 586 Standards reduction Cummings 586-7; Edwards 586 Hansard Index 46 Ernst, Hon.

Jim (PC, Charleswood) (Minister of Industry, Trade and Tourism) (Minister res ponsible for The De velopment Corporation Act, Manitoba Forestry Resources Limited, Sport) (Minister charged with the administra tion of The Boxing and Wrestl ing Commission Act and The Fitness and Amateur Sport Act) Budget 41 9-26 Fitness and Sport (Supply) Opening Remarks 17 01-2 Lotteries Funded Programs Sport Directorate 17 02-14 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Annual Report, 19 89 (S.P. 8) 28 Supplementary Information for Legislative Review 19 90-91 Estimates (T.P. 35) 81 6 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of (Supply) Opening Remarks 117 2-3 Response Carr 117 4-5; Gaudry 117 4; Storie 11 73-4 Administration and Rnance Finance and Administration Salaries 118 0 Grant Assistance-Faculty of Management 118 0-3 Strategic Planning Other Expenditures 11 76-80 Salaries 117 5 Canada-Manitoba Tourism Agreement-1 985-90 Salaries 12 36-8 Expenditures Related to Capital 12 39 Industry and Trade Division Business Resource Centre Salaries 12 18 -9 Financial Programs Programs 121 5-6 Health Industry Development Initiative Other Expenditures 1217 Industry Investment Promotion 12 14 -5 Sectoral Development 12 06-1 3 Trade Other Expenditures 1217 -8 Manitoba Horse Racing Commission Grant Assistance 12 38-9

Hansard Index Ernst, Hon. Jim - Cont. Technology Division Grant Assistance/Manitoba Research Council 12 21 Industrial Technology Other Expenditures 12 20-1 Tourism Division Administration Salaries 12 22-30 Corporate and Community Relations Salaries 12 34-5 Development Salaries 12 33 Marketing Salaries 12 30-3 Quality Assurance Salaries 12 33-4 Interim Appropriation Act, 19 90 {Bill 19 ) C/W 349-53 Manitoba Horse Racing Commission Annual Report, 19 90 {S.P. 37) 318 Oral Questions Bond, Dr. S.L.

Provincial audit 15 54-5 Brandon, Manitoba Industrial development plan 669 Industry closures 668-9 Burns Meats Ltd.-Brandon Alternative plant usage 669 Feasibility study 16 69 Industry incentive grants 16 70 Preferential employment policy 16 69 ERDA agreements Renegotiation 322 Economic growth Government initiatives 14 5 Food processing industry Trade deficity 671 Free Trade Agreement-Mexico Food processing industry 671 Government initiatives 13 2 Legislative review 672 Negotiations 231 Oil price policy 894 Free Trade Agreement-U.S.

Report tabling request 233-4, 322 Heritage buildings-City of Winnipeg Government initiatives 824 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Spending, Tourism 14 01 New Homes Warranty Program Replacement program 11 46 Plant closures 47 Ernst, Hon. Jim - Cont. Minister's awareness 14 5-6 Tourism agreement Renegotiation 323 Tabled Papers Bond, Dr. S.L. Proposal to Department of Industry, Trade and Tourism {T.P. 59) 12 06 Free Trade Agreement-U.S.

Manitoba trade with U.S. -1 986-89 (T.P. 4) 234 Throne Speech Debate 16 7-74 Erratum 365 Est ablished Programs Financing Government position Carstairs 18 80, 2035-6; Doer 2375; L. Evans 2484-5; Filmon 2035-6, 2375; Manness 18 80-1 , 2485 Graph: Federal expenditures for Health and Education 198 9-90 to 2004-5 {T.P. 26 Wasylycia-Leis 625 Table: Projections of transfers (T.P. 25) Wasylycia-Leis 625 Evans, Cllf (NDP, Interlake) Budget Debate 651 -3 Labour Relations Amendment Act {Bi11 12 ) 2r 2883-5 Natural Resources, Department of {Supply) Opening Remarks En

Document details

Collection	Manitoba — Debates (Hansard)
Citation	35th 1st hansardpdf 35th 1st index
Type	hansard
Volume / chapter	35th 1st hansardpdf 35th 1st index.pdf
Language	en
Format	pdf
Source	PROVINCIAL
Identifier	ba86737c48d8a2bbbd3ca53d1443a5ab819fb93c

Source file is stored in the law ingest library (pdf).