British Columbia Committee Hansard (Blues) — 26 June 2020, p.m., Issue 3 (41st Parliament, 5th Session) (20200626am CommitteeA n3)

20200626am CommitteeA n3

British Columbia — Debates (Hansard)

Fifth Session, 41st Parliament REPORT OF PROCEEDINGS (HANSARD) COMMITTEE OF SUPPLY ,

SECTION A Virtual Meeting Friday, June 26, 2020 Morning Meeting Issue No. 3 Presiding Officers: RAJ CHOUHAN, DEPUTY SPEAKER SPENCER CHANDRA HERBERT, DEPUTY CHAIR, COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE ISSN 2563-3511

PROVINCE OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Entered Confederation July 20, 1871) LIEUTENANT-GOVERNOR Her Honour the Honourable Janet Austin, OBC Fifth Session, 41st Parliament SPEAKER OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Honourable Darryl Plecas EXECUTIVE COUNCIL Premier and President of the Executive Council ............................................................................................................... Hon. John Horgan Deputy Premier and Minister of Finance............................................................................................................................Hon.

Carole James Minister of Advanced Education, Skills and Training..................................................................................................... Hon. Melanie Mark Minister of Agriculture.........................................................................................................................................................Hon. Lana Popham Attorney General.................................................................................................................................................................Hon.

David Eby, QC Minister of Children and Family Development ............................................................................................................ Hon. Katrine Conroy Minister of State for Child Care...................................................................................................................................... Hon. Katrina Chen Minister of Citizens’ Services...................................................................................................................................................Hon.

Anne Kang Minister of Education ............................................................................................................................................................ Hon. Rob Fleming Minister of Energy, Mines and Petroleum Resources ..................................................................................................... Hon. Bruce Ralston Minister of Environment and Climate Change Strategy............................................................................................. Hon.

George Heyman Minister of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development ..............................................Hon. Doug Donaldson Minister of Health .....................................................................................................................................................................Hon. Adrian Dix Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation ......................................................................................................... Hon.

Scott Fraser Minister of Jobs, Economic Development and Competitiveness.............................................................................Hon. Michelle Mungall Minister of State for Trade...............................................................................................................................................Hon. George Chow Minister of Labour ...................................................................................................................................................................Hon.

Harry Bains Minister of Mental Health and Addictions............................................................................................................................ Hon. Judy Darcy Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing.................................................................................................................. Hon. Selina Robinson Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General ........................................................................................................... Hon.

Mike Farnworth Minister of Social Development and Poverty Reduction..............................................................................................Hon. Shane Simpson Minister of Tourism, Arts and Culture.....................................................................................................................................Hon. Lisa Beare Minister of Transportation and Infrastructure................................................................................................................ Hon.

Claire Trevena LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Leader of the Official Opposition................................................................................................................................Andrew Wilkinson, QC Leader of the Third Party .................................................................................................................................................................Adam Olsen Deputy Speaker................................................................................................................................................................................

Raj Chouhan Assistant Deputy Speaker............................................................................................................................................................. Simon Gibson Deputy Chair, Committee of the Whole ................................................................................................................ Spencer Chandra Herbert Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ...........................................................................................................................................

Kate Ryan-Lloyd Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel.............................................................................................................................. Seunghee Suzie Seo Clerk Assistant, Parliamentary Services...........................................................................................................................

Artour Sogomonian Clerk Assistant, Committees and Interparliamentary Relations ..............................................................................................Susan Sourial Senior Research Analyst ................................................................................................................................................................. Jennifer Arril Senior Research Analyst ...................................................................................................................................................................

Karan Riarh Acting Sergeant-at-Arms..................................................................................................................................................................Greg Nelson

ALPHABETICAL LIST OF MEMBERS Ashton, Dan (BC Liberal) ......................................................................... Penticton Bains, Hon. Harry (NDP)................................................................ Surrey-Newton Barnett, Donna (BC Liberal) .....................................................Cariboo-Chilcotin Beare, Hon. Lisa (NDP)..............................................

Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows Begg, Garry (NDP) .......................................................................Surrey-Guildford Bernier, Mike (BC Liberal) .........................................................Peace River South Bond, Shirley (BC Liberal)...........................................Prince George–Valemount Brar, Jagrup (NDP).......................................................................Surrey-Fleetwood Cadieux, Stephanie (BC Liberal)........................................................

Surrey South Chandra Herbert, Spencer (NDP) .......................................Vancouver–West End Chen, Hon. Katrina (NDP)...................................................... Burnaby-Lougheed Chouhan, Raj (NDP) .................................................................Burnaby-Edmonds Chow, Hon. George (NDP).................................................Vancouver-Fraserview Clovechok, Doug (BC Liberal) ..................................Columbia River–Revelstoke Coleman, Rich (BC Liberal) ................................................................ Langley East Conroy, Hon.

Katrine (NDP)...........................................................Kootenay West Darcy, Hon. Judy (NDP) ............................................................. New Westminster Davies, Dan (BC Liberal) ........................................................... Peace River North de Jong, Michael, QC (BC Liberal) ..............................................Abbotsford West Dean, Mitzi (NDP)................................................................ Esquimalt-Metchosin D’Eith, Bob (NDP) ................................................................Maple Ridge–Mission Dix, Hon.

Adrian (NDP)....................................................... Vancouver-Kingsway Donaldson, Hon. Doug (NDP)...................................................................... Stikine Eby, Hon. David, QC (NDP).............................................. Vancouver–Point Grey Elmore, Mable (NDP).........................................................Vancouver-Kensington Farnworth, Hon. Mike (NDP) ........................................................Port Coquitlam Fleming, Hon. Rob (NDP) ......................................................

Victoria–Swan Lake Foster, Eric (BC Liberal).............................................................Vernon-Monashee Fraser, Hon. Scott (NDP) ..................................................Mid Island–Pacific Rim Furstenau, Sonia (BC Green Party) .............................................Cowichan Valley Gibson, Simon (BC Liberal) ...................................................Abbotsford-Mission Glumac, Rick (NDP).........................................................Port Moody–Coquitlam Heyman, Hon. George (NDP) ................................................Vancouver-Fairview Horgan, Hon.

John (NDP) ................................................ Langford–Juan de Fuca Hunt, Marvin (BC Liberal) ........................................................ Surrey-Cloverdale Isaacs, Joan (BC Liberal) .......................................... Coquitlam–Burke Mountain James, Hon. Carole (NDP).................................................... Victoria–Beacon Hill Johal, Jas (BC Liberal).................................................Richmond-Queensborough Kahlon, Ravi (NDP)............................................................................... Delta North Kang, Hon.

Anne (NDP)......................................................... Burnaby–Deer Lake Kyllo, Greg (BC Liberal)..............................................................................Shuswap Larson, Linda (BC Liberal) .............................................. Boundary-Similkameen Lee, Michael (BC Liberal) ........................................................Vancouver-Langara Leonard, Ronna-Rae (NDP) ..................................................... Courtenay-Comox Letnick, Norm (BC Liberal).............................................

Kelowna–Lake Country Ma, Bowinn (NDP) .....................................................North Vancouver–Lonsdale Malcolmson, Sheila (NDP) ........................................................................Nanaimo Mark, Hon. Melanie (NDP) .......................................Vancouver–Mount Pleasant Martin, John (BC Liberal)....................................................................... Chilliwack Milobar, Peter (BC Liberal)..................................... Kamloops–North Thompson Morris, Mike (BC Liberal) ........................................... Prince George–Mackenzie Mungall, Hon.

Michelle (NDP)......................................................Nelson-Creston Oakes, Coralee (BC Liberal) ............................................................ Cariboo North Olsen, Adam (BC Green Party)............................ Saanich North and the Islands Paton, Ian (BC Liberal).......................................................................... Delta South Plecas, Hon. Darryl (Ind.) ........................................................... Abbotsford South Polak, Mary (BC Liberal) ............................................................................. Langley Popham, Hon.

Lana (NDP)............................................................... Saanich South Ralston, Hon. Bruce (NDP) ............................................................Surrey-Whalley Redies, Tracy (BC Liberal) .......................................................Surrey–White Rock Reid, Linda (BC Liberal) ................................................. Richmond South Centre Rice, Jennifer (NDP) ............................................................................. North Coast Robinson, Hon.

Selina (NDP) .........................................Coquitlam-Maillardville Ross, Ellis (BC Liberal)................................................................................... Skeena Routledge, Janet (NDP) ....................................................................Burnaby North Routley, Doug (NDP) ................................................. Nanaimo–North Cowichan Rustad, John (BC Liberal) ................................................................Nechako Lakes Shypitka, Tom (BC Liberal) ..............................................................

Kootenay East Simons, Nicholas (NDP) ......................................... Powell River–Sunshine Coast Simpson, Hon. Shane (NDP)..................................................Vancouver-Hastings Sims, Jinny (NDP) ........................................................................ Surrey-Panorama Singh, Rachna (NDP) .........................................................Surrey–Green Timbers Stewart, Ben (BC Liberal) ................................................................. Kelowna West Stilwell, Michelle (BC Liberal)...............................................

Parksville-Qualicum Stone, Todd (BC Liberal)..........................................Kamloops–South Thompson Sturdy, Jordan (BC Liberal)........................................ West Vancouver–Sea to Sky Sullivan, Sam (BC Liberal)................................................ Vancouver–False Creek Sultan, Ralph (BC Liberal) ...........................................West Vancouver–Capilano Tegart, Jackie (BC Liberal) ................................................................. Fraser-Nicola Thomson, Steve (BC Liberal)......................................................

Kelowna-Mission Thornthwaite, Jane (BC Liberal) ...............................North Vancouver–Seymour Throness, Laurie (BC Liberal) .......................................................Chilliwack-Kent Trevena, Hon. Claire (NDP) ................................................................North Island Wat, Teresa (BC Liberal) ................................................. Richmond North Centre Weaver, Dr.

Andrew (Ind.)................................................Oak Bay–Gordon Head Wilkinson, Andrew, QC (BC Liberal) ................................Vancouver-Quilchena Y ap, John (BC Liberal)............................................................Richmond-Steveston LIST OF MEMBERS BY RIDING Abbotsford-Mission............................................................................Simon Gibson Abbotsford South....................................................................... Hon. Darryl Plecas Abbotsford West......................................................................

Michael de Jong, QC Boundary-Similkameen...................................................................... Linda Larson Burnaby–Deer Lake....................................................................... Hon. Anne Kang Burnaby-Edmonds................................................................................Raj Chouhan Burnaby-Lougheed .................................................................... Hon. Katrina Chen Burnaby North .................................................................................

Janet Routledge Cariboo-Chilcotin .............................................................................Donna Barnett Cariboo North.................................................................................... Coralee Oakes Chilliwack ............................................................................................... John Martin Chilliwack-Kent ...............................................................................Laurie Throness Columbia River–Revelstoke .........................................................

Doug Clovechok Coquitlam–Burke Mountain.................................................................. Joan Isaacs Coquitlam-Maillardville ...................................................... Hon. Selina Robinson Courtenay-Comox................................................................... Ronna-Rae Leonard Cowichan Valley .............................................................................

Sonia Furstenau Delta North.............................................................................................Ravi Kahlon Delta South ..................................................................................................Ian Paton Esquimalt-Metchosin ..............................................................................Mitzi Dean Fraser-Nicola .........................................................................................

Jackie Tegart Kamloops–North Thompson .............................................................Peter Milobar Kamloops–South Thompson..................................................................Todd Stone Kelowna–Lake Country .....................................................................Norm Letnick Kelowna-Mission ..............................................................................

Steve Thomson Kelowna West ..........................................................................................Ben Stewart Kootenay East.......................................................................................Tom Shypitka Kootenay West........................................................................ Hon. Katrine Conroy Langford–Juan de Fuca .............................................................. Hon. John Horgan Langley .....................................................................................................

Mary Polak Langley East.........................................................................................Rich Coleman Maple Ridge–Mission.............................................................................. Bob D’Eith Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows............................................................Hon. Lisa Beare Mid Island–Pacific Rim................................................................ Hon. Scott Fraser Nanaimo......................................................................................

Sheila Malcolmson Nanaimo–North Cowichan............................................................... Doug Routley Nechako Lakes........................................................................................ John Rustad Nelson-Creston ................................................................... Hon. Michelle Mungall New Westminster........................................................................... Hon. Judy Darcy North Coast ...........................................................................................

Jennifer Rice North Island.............................................................................. Hon. Claire Trevena North Vancouver–Lonsdale................................................................... Bowinn Ma North Vancouver–Seymour........................................................Jane Thornthwaite Oak Bay–Gordon Head............................................................Dr.

Andrew Weaver Parksville-Qualicum.......................................................................Michelle Stilwell Peace River North ................................................................................... Dan Davies Peace River South ................................................................................ Mike Bernier Penticton ................................................................................................. Dan Ashton Port Coquitlam...................................................................... Hon.

Mike Farnworth Port Moody–Coquitlam.......................................................................Rick Glumac Powell River–Sunshine Coast....................................................... Nicholas Simons Prince George–Mackenzie....................................................................Mike Morris Prince George–Valemount ..................................................................

Shirley Bond Richmond North Centre..........................................................................Teresa Wat Richmond-Queensborough.........................................................................Jas Johal Richmond South Centre ......................................................................... Linda Reid Richmond-Steveston ...................................................................................

John Y ap Saanich North and the Islands .............................................................Adam Olsen Saanich South .............................................................................Hon. Lana Popham Shuswap...................................................................................................... Greg Kyllo Skeena........................................................................................................... Ellis Ross Stikine....................................................................................Hon.

Doug Donaldson Surrey-Cloverdale ................................................................................ Marvin Hunt Surrey-Fleetwood.....................................................................................Jagrup Brar Surrey–Green Timbers........................................................................Rachna Singh Surrey-Guildford......................................................................................Garry Begg Surrey-Newton ..............................................................................Hon.

Harry Bains Surrey-Panorama ...................................................................................... Jinny Sims Surrey South ................................................................................ Stephanie Cadieux Surrey-Whalley ......................................................................... Hon. Bruce Ralston Surrey–White Rock .............................................................................. Tracy Redies Vancouver-Fairview.............................................................. Hon.

George Heyman Vancouver–False Creek........................................................................ Sam Sullivan Vancouver-Fraserview...............................................................Hon. George Chow Vancouver-Hastings ............................................................... Hon. Shane Simpson Vancouver-Kensington....................................................................... Mable Elmore Vancouver-Kingsway..................................................................... Hon.

Adrian Dix Vancouver-Langara................................................................................ Michael Lee Vancouver–Mount Pleasant..................................................... Hon. Melanie Mark Vancouver–Point Grey ............................................................Hon.

David Eby, QC Vancouver-Quilchena........................................................Andrew Wilkinson, QC Vancouver–West End .....................................................Spencer Chandra Herbert Vernon-Monashee ....................................................................................Eric Foster Victoria–Beacon Hill.................................................................. Hon. Carole James Victoria–Swan Lake.................................................................... Hon. Rob Fleming West Vancouver–Capilano...................................................................

Ralph Sultan West Vancouver–Sea to Sky................................................................Jordan Sturdy Party Standings: BC Liberal 42; NDP 41; Independent 2; BC Green Party 2

CONTENTS Friday, June 26, 2020 Morning Meeting Page Committee of Supply Proceedings in

Section A ............................................................................................................................................................43 Estimates: Ministry of Education(continued) Hon. R. Fleming D. Davies Estimates: Ministry of Labour Hon. H. Bains J. Martin S. Furstenau

FRIDAY , JUNE 26, 2020 The committee met at 9:37 a.m. [S. Malcolmson in the chair.] Committee of Supply Proceedings in

Section A ESTIMATES: MINISTRY OF EDUCATION (continued) On Vote 21: ministry operations, $6,657,927,000 (continued). The Chair:Good morning, everybody. I want to rec- ognize that we are participating today here, me and the Clerks, in Victoria at the Legislature buildings from the homeland of the Lək̓ ʷəŋin̓ əŋ-speaking people, today known as the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. We extend our appreciation to them for their stewardship and for the opportunity to undertake the work before us on their land.

Members are meeting from traditional territories all over the province in this new digital way that we are con- tinuing the work of the people but also keeping people safe. We are meeting today to continue consideration of the estimates of the Ministry of Education. Hon. R. Fleming:Thank you, Madam Chair, for getting us underway with that territorial acknowledgment. D. Davies: Good morning, Chair. Good morning, everybody. I look forward to getting back. I think we’ve got about four or five hours remaining of our estimates. That is a joke. As much as I have many questions that probably could go on, I won’t.

I think we’ve got about an hour or so left, and we should be able to wrap it up. I’ d like to start off with a few questions around what the fall looks like for returning back to school. I know that the government put out a release yesterday: “June School Restart Sets the Stage for September. ” I know that there’s some information in there. I’ve received a number of emails from teachers and par- ents and notes from kids over the past number of months — lots of concerns, lots of good stories as well.

I think parents are just kind of looking for some sort of certainty when it comes to what September might look like. I’m just wondering if the minister could give us a bit of a rundown on what he envisions. [9:40 a.m.] I know a lot of it depends on how the pandemic goes, but if we’re expecting the stage 2 full return as laid out in the news release…. I just wanted to get a few comments from the minister on that. The Chair:For the benefit of the public, because I’m sure people from all over B.C. are tuning in on cable TV or online to watch our proceedings, this is a process called the spending estimates.

Each minister comes before this committee and takes questions from the opposition about their budget and their programs — how they’ve spent the money, how they will spend the money. And this goes on for weeks. Usually it’s happening parallel to the main chamber, so you’re watching bills being debated in the legislative cham- ber. But in one or sometimes two and sometimes even three committee rooms like this, this work is going on.

At the end of all the questions and the back and forth which may, in some cases, take days and days or even a week, there will be a vote as to whether the minister’s budget and spending estimates are approved. In between, the minister is conferring with his advisers. So that’s why we have very long pauses in between. Usually in the committee room, there would be a huddle of the minister and his advisers. But in this case, they may be in a separate city. I’m talking to them online, so it’s slow. Thanks for hanging in there with us. Hon. R. Fleming: Y eah.

As we explained in the news release and on previous occasions with the daily updates and frequent media questions to Dr. Bonnie Henry and news conferences that I’ve done myself, the goal is to have even more students in class in September, as long as it’s safe to do so. We’ll continue to work under the direction and science-based leadership of the provincial health officer. It’s too early to say exactly what September 8 will look like, of course, and I know the member will understand that. I also appreciate that people are looking for certainty in an uncertain time.

We have 74 days to September 8, so it’s too soon to say exactly what the restart will look like. But what we have committed to and the public and par- ents can expect is [audio interrupted] the pandemic and the public [audio interrupted] will continue on a daily or near daily basis in British Columbia. There will be lots of information about schools that is shared with the public on a timely basis. We have a steering committee that is composed of all the K-to-12 education partners working on the September restart. We talked about that yesterday in estimates and the representation there.

I communicated yesterday through BCCPAC in a letter jointly signed with their president to all parents in British Columbia reminding folks what the stages document looks like, what we’re aiming for and what steps they might want to take immediately. We talked in estimates yesterday as well about it being advisable for parents to re-register their child where they would normally place them in school and await further information both from the 43

school, the district and the ministry and the steering com- mittee that we have. [9:45 a.m.] D. Davies:Thank you, Minister, for that. Certainly, we understand that parents…. Everybody is looking for some sort of clarity and comfort in this time, and we understand that it is unknown as we move forward. So I appreciate that and hope we can get more information on it. I want to talk a little bit about the steering committee. I know it was canvassed a little bit by my colleague from Cariboo-Chilcotin yesterday.

To reiterate the importance of having representation from not just the larger urban centres but members on that committee that make up some of the smaller school districts, the rural, remote, northern districts to be on that…. So I’ d like to reiterate that first of all. Secondly, the steering committee. I see that it is also mentioned in the news release. What is their role directly? Is it to provide advice back to the ministry on what the school opening should look like? Or is it bringing to the table just a number of recommendations on different areas that they’ve been assigned to?

I guess the second question is: what kind of a timeline do we have on hearing back about these recommendations? Hon. R. Fleming: Thank you to the member for the question. A couple of things here. There is a president’s group that I chair that meets biweekly that’s composed of all of the presidents and executive directors and staff lead- ership of the major K-to-12 organizations, partner organ- izations. In fact, we have a meeting coming up. The steering committee that was referenced in the press release that the member cited is composed of a number of working groups that are getting established now.

As you can appreciate, we are getting a flood of infor- mation about the June restart from all 60 school districts and the independent schools around the province which is [audio interrupted] steering committee deliberations. They meet weekly. They review materials that have been produced. [9:50 a.m.] There will be a substantive update in July to the public, another substantive update in August and regular commu- nication in between, as needed.

In terms of giving the member a sense of some of the things that the steering committee will be working on and where they will provide advice and guidance [audio inter- rupted] things like emerging practices and consideration [audio interrupted] sector during the COVID-19 pandem- ic, things like the [audio interrupted] from March to June 2020, both stages 4 and 3 that we’ve been through, identi- fication of issues that need to be addressed and resolution of those mitigations. They will be tasked with updating the operating guidelines for stages 1 to 5 well in advance of the 2020-21 school year.

The emphasis will be on implementation plans for a variety of scenarios, stages 1, 2 and 3. The other area that the steering committee will focus on is review and development of additional teacher and par- ent resources that will support the school system in any of the contingencies, either stages 1, 2 or 3. We have, as I mentioned yesterday to the critic’s col- league, received very robust voices from rural British Col- umbia. I think they’re well represented in all of the K- to-12 partner organizations.

We expect people who live in diverse parts of [audio interrupted] to be directly repres- ented at the steering committee. I don’t think that’s going to be an issue, but I certainly want to say that the Ministry of Education wants to hear about rural and remote schools. We have had direct chan- nels throughout the pandemic health emergency with rur- al and remote school districts, where they have needs that urban district do not have around connectivity, around transportation, around delivery of services that may be a considerable distance from where the school is.

We’ve also had conversations with them about exemp- tions for their specific circumstances in stage 3. Some schools in rural and remote communities actually oper- ated at 100 percent of capacity because the density of kids in those schools was limited, and it was [audio interrup- ted] to do so. We’ve been very flexible and willing to work with the rural and remote districts on putting in place reg- ulations or amending regulations and health and safety [audio interrupted]. The Chair:Members, I think we’re experiencing some technical difficulties. I’m going to suggest that we recess for five minutes.

We’re in recess for five minutes to check this technical problem. Thanks for your patience. The committee recessed from 9:53 a.m. to 10:06 a.m. [S. Malcolmson in the chair.] The Chair:We are currently reviewing the budget estimates of the Ministry of Education. We’ve just, with thanks to Hansard, gotten ourselves and the minister’s microphone glitch-free. I’m going to recognize the minister first and hope that you can get your closing comment on the reply to the member for Peace River North so that we are sure we’ve got it all on the record. Then I’ll return back to the oppo- sition critic. Hon. R.

Fleming:The response was around the presid- ent’s group in the K-to-12 sector that I chair bi-weekly. We talked about the steering committee, which was outlined in the news release that the member cited. How they meet weekly and how they’re divided into a number of working groups on important areas. Then, maybe, where I finished 44 Committee of Supply,

Section A Friday, June 26, 2020

was around the plan for the steering committee, govern- ments and the PHO, if necessary, to provide substantive updates in July, an additional one in August and regular communication on an as-needed basis. Again, we’re 74 days out from September 8, the first day of scheduled school for the 2020-2021 school year. That’s roughly the timeline that the member was inquiring about for communications from the committee and the working groups. That is inclusive of all the major K-to-12 organiza- tions. D. Davies:Thank you, Minister, for the response.

In the event of a second wave, which I know has been discussed and talked about, what is the ministry’s plan to manage that? [10:10 a.m.] Hon. R. Fleming: Thank you to the member for the question. As he is familiar with, we have the five stages document that was released by the ministry, which was developed with the provincial health organization, WorkSafeBC and all of the K-to-12 partners. We have been in stages 5, 4 and most recently, for the month of June, stage 3.

We were one of a handful of jurisdictions in North America that resumed in-class instruction over the last month, which I think puts us at a very good advantage to both move forward and, in the scenario the member describes, to move backwards if we need to, depending on what’s going on in the province as it relates to COVID-19 transmission next year. I think the detail that the member might seek is well documented in the stages document. We’ve talked about where we hope to be for the September restart, which is stage 2 [audio interrupted].

The steering committee is charged with, among other things, providing additional direction on what those stages might look like. We intend to keep moving forward as long as it’s deemed safe to do so by the provincial health office. The way we have out- lined the stages for pandemic management in the K-to-12 schools is that we can move backwards if we need to do so. It’s quite nimble and flexible. There would obviously be a number of signals that would be at the call of the provincial health officer in terms of where we are, what community outbreaks are looking like, what transmission rates are and new cases.

Those sorts of things would inform us if we need to move back- wards. Just as we hope that over the summer, they will con- tinue to help us move forward to a stronger restart with more kids in school [audio interrupted]. D. Davies:I appreciate that. The next question I have here is on autism funding. I’ve had discussions and had a number of parents reach out. I’ve met with a couple of the different organizations in the province, as well, over the last little while. With the fund- ing dollars that the families get on autism, of course, lots of that money is used for therapies and interventions and other programs.

During the last few months, though, with the pandemic, parents have not been able to utilize these therapies. I know they’ve been asking to see if that money can be rolled over into next year. So far, they’ve been told no. I’m just wondering why that is and if the ministry is reconsid- ering allowing that money to roll over. Hon. R. Fleming:To the member, he’ll know that aut- ism funding for children is distributed. It goes directly to families. It’s distributed by the Ministry of Children and Family Development, so he might want to take those ques- tions there.

Autism funding that the Ministry of Education is responsible for is directly funded to schools. There are, really, two levels of support, with different ministry responsibilities for them. So I would suggest he maybe hold those questions for the Minister of Children and Family Development. D. Davies:Okay, thank you for that. I’ve got a question, and I’m going to use an example from my school district, which is a similar situation in many rural communities across the province. It’s around the funding review and some of the busing issues that many of the larger rural ridings face.

I’m just going to read a little bit here from a budget consultation presentation that was made. [10:15 a.m.] It’s regarding the student location factor, and I’m going to use the example for school district 60. Provincially, dis- tricts spend about 1.9 percent of operating expenses on transportation. Given the geography of the school district for Peace River North, 6 percent of their operating expenses go toward transporting students to schools. They were hoping that this would have been addressed in the funding formula. It wasn’t.

It still has significant consequences and, again, this isn’t just school district 60 that’s facing this challenge. It’s lots of the larger, more remote districts. I’m just wondering if there is a plan to review that, and when school districts that this impacts would expect to hear about that? [10:20 a.m.] Hon. R. Fleming:I’ll try and give the member as much information at once, because I know he wants to conclude estimates as scheduled.

He asked about the student location factor that is typic- ally used to recognize where students live within a district, the unique geographic challenges, recognizing the costs — including transportation — in communities and districts like district 60. In terms of where funding will increase in Budget 2020, most immediately in the ’19-20 year, the budget we discussed at estimates last year, that fund, the Friday, June 26, 2020 Committee of Supply,

Section A 45

student location factor fund, was at $88.184 million for the province in ’20-21, up $3 million to $91.1 million. That is of assistance to districts like 60 and other com- munities and districts that have rural and remote com- munities where they serve students.

As it relates to district 60 specifically, through a number of other funds that help that district in particular and others like it, we have within the funding formula a small community factor, a low enrolment factor, a rural factor, a climate factor, a cold weather and a sparseness factor looking at the distribution of students across a large geographic area. [10:25 a.m.] District 60, for those funds, received $8.8 million in the ’19-20 budget distribution to the district. That will increase in the 2020-21 year to $9.5 million, so that should assist with the issues he mentioned.

I would note, too, that school district 60, at the current time, has about 7.5 per- cent of its annual budget in surplus, so they’re in a pretty healthy fiscal position. D. Davies:Thank you, Minister. With that, I think that concludes all of my remarks. Just in closing, I wanted to reiterate a quick comment that my colleague from Prince George–Valemount made yesterday about the shoulder tap program, how important that program is. And I believe that you said that you’ d be looking into that, so I look forward to hearing that from the ministry.

I just wanted to thank the minister for his time on the estimates for the 2020 budget. Thank your staff. I know there’s a lot of work that goes into preparing this, of course. And all the Hansard people, the chairs that have made this fairly easy, actually. I was kind of surprised how easy it was and didn’t know what to expect.

I want to close by thanking all of the teachers and school districts, trustees, support staff, parents and, last but not least, the students for how they’ve managed and moved throughout this pandemic — as all of us have — and look- ing forward to seeing what September looks like and mostly looking forward to this pandemic being over and moving on to some form of normalcy. As a final remark, certainly, again an enormous congrat- ulations to all of the graduates of 2020.

They did not expect to see the graduation that they saw this year, so this will be something that they will look back on for the rest of their lives, I’m sure, as they move on. So with that being said, that does conclude my remarks. The Chair:Seeing no further questions, I’ll ask the min- ister whether he’ d like to make any closing remarks before I call the vote. Hon. R. Fleming: Thank you very much, Chair, and thank you to you and others who have chaired these estim- ates proceedings. They’ve gone without a hitch, but for about 15 minutes ago. The technology clearly works.

We’re living in the new normal, both at the Legislative Assembly and in industries and occupations and work settings throughout the province of British Columbia. I feel very fortunate — and I know this will be shared by British Columbians in every part of the province — that we live in a jurisdiction that has shown that the public health care system, the pandemic management here, is among the best in the world, in our province. Clearly that shows in the results of keeping British Col- umbians safe thus far.

Certainly, that leadership has been instructive and incredibly valuable for this school sys- tem and how important that is to community and family life in British Columbia. I would echo the critic’s thanks to the school system. Just to put it in perspective, we have in excess of 70,000 people who work on behalf of kids and families in the school system. So it’s everything from…. It’s janitorial staff, who have met and exceeded the new cleaning protocols, the health and safety protocols. It’s the teachers who’ve gone above and beyond, creating a brand-new system for continuous online learning.

It’s the principals and vice- principals, who have communicated with families on a regular basis. It’s those voluntary organizations in the community who have stepped up — some of them are restaurateurs and community service clubs — to help feed kids who are facing hunger and uncertainty in the pandemic and brought into being meal programs that serve 75,000 meals a week. It’s Internet service providers and others who work with First Nations in remote communities to make sure that connectivity was possible, and we’ll keep working on those efforts.

It’s the teachers who came back into the classroom after they’ d set up their remote online learning systems to put smiles on the faces of kids again. I think we’ve had over- whelmingly positive responses to the four successful weeks of returning to school. [10:30 a.m.] I think B.C. can be proud of the leadership we have been able to exercise in North America; it’s certainly being rec- ognized across this continent.

We’ve had inquiries from the departments of education in Washington state and Oregon and California and provinces and territories across Canada, asking for everything that we’ve done in terms of planning and creating a safe return to school. That leadership, I think, is something that all of us can share some pride in.

They normally shy away from getting thanked, but I really want to thank the ministry staff, from the deputy minister on down — all of my ADMs, executive directors and staff — who have been putting in incredibly long hours ever since we made the difficult call to suspend in- class instruction on March 17. These people haven’t had much by way of a day of rest in the weeks and months that are now behind us. In wishing everybody a safe and happy summer — the families and kids in the school system, everybody who 46 Committee of Supply,

Section A Friday, June 26, 2020

works in the field in the public and independent school sectors — I want to maybe share the last thanks for every member of the staff at the Ministry of Education who have been working incredibly hard alongside those in the school system on the landscape of British Columbia. We’ve done it together by being in it together. We’ve stayed safe. I think that everybody has, hopefully, the ability to have a well-deserved break ahead of them as we get ready for a strong September start-up. Thank you to the critic and his colleagues for the ques- tions.

Thank you to Hansard and the Legislative Assembly for being able to arrange this new means of conducting estimates. The Chair:Thank you, Minister. I’ll echo the critic and the minister’s congratulations to graduating students who have come through a really hard time. To the tens of thou- sands of people across British Columbia working in the school system and working for students: it’s been an incredible spring, and you’ve done well. Seeing no further questions, thanks to the minister and the members. Vote 21: ministry operations, $6,657,927,000 — approved. The Chair:We are going to recess for the next minister.

Let’s come back to work in ten minutes. So if the commit- tee agrees, we will recess for ten minutes for the purpose of inviting the next minister to join us. Thanks, everybody. The committee recessed from 10:33 a.m. to 10:49 a.m. [S. Malcolmson in the chair.] ESTIMATES: MINISTRY OF LABOUR On Vote 35: ministry operations, $17,185,000. [10:50 a.m.] The Chair:Minister, do you have any opening state- ments you’ d like to make? Hon. H. Bains:Y es. Thank you, Chair. Good morning, everyone.

I would like to acknowledge that I am appearing by video from the Songhees territory, which the Legis- lature stands on, and I’m grateful to be here. I am suppor- ted by staff who are working remotely. It is a privilege to call this beautiful province our home. While we participate in estimates differently this year, one thing remains the same: I start this introduction with my ministry’s budget. For the fiscal year 2020-2021, the Ministry of Labour has been allocated $17.185 million. This reflects an increase over last year due to a lift related to the employment standards branch modernization pro- ject.

With a modest budget, the ministry has accomplished a lot of good for the people of British Columbia, especially now, during the COVID-19 pandemic. It’s as important as ever to make sure British Colum- bians are supported by their government. My ministry and staff have worked hard over the last several months to make this so. We have passed emergency legislation to give people job-protected leave during the pandemic if it’s related to COVID-19 reasons. As well, WorkSafeBC has created reopening guidelines for a wide range of busi- nesses so they can open in a safe way.

COVID-19 has changed the province in a way we never thought possible. But some problems existed before the pandemic. Our government is acting to fix those problems while protecting people and keeping them safe. Just this week our domestic and sexual violence leave bill passed second reading in the House. This bill allows survivors to take up to five days of paid leave to care for themselves and their families. We continue to make strides in improving the employ- ment standards branch.

We have provided and will contin- ue to provide incredibly important support for our forestry workers hardest hit by mill closures. Modernizing Work- SafeBC and shifting the workers compensation system to better support injured workers remain an important prior- ity for us as well. In closing, I would like to thank everyone who is sup- porting me here today. These are very hard-working staff of my ministry. We have tried everything that we could, but we put them through a lot in the last few months. So much was expected of our ministry, and our staff delivered.

Those joining with me are: Trevor Hughes, deputy min- ister; Joanna White, acting assistant deputy minister and executive financial officer of the management services division; Danine Leduc, assistant deputy minister; John Blakely, executive director of the labour, policy and legis- lation branch; and Michael Tanner, the director of the labour policy and legislation branch. Joining me from WorkSafeBC, we have Brian Erickson, head of assessments, finance and corporate operations, and Al Johnson, head of prevention services.

Also with us are Joe Pinto, the head of claims and rehabilitation ser- vices, and Ian Shaw, head of law and policy. I look forward to your questions. Thank you very much for the opportunity for the opening remarks. The Chair:Thank you, Minister. I now recognize the opposition critic for Labour, the member for Chilliwack. Would you like to make any opening statements? J. Martin:Thank you very much, and good morning to everybody. I would like to take this opportunity to give a shout-out to the Clerk and the staff at the Legislative Assembly and everyone at Hansard.

It’s amazing what has been pulled together in such a short period of time and Friday, June 26, 2020 Committee of Supply,

Section A 47

how this week’s sessions, the hybrid sessions, have basic- ally gone off with very, very few speed bumps. A couple hiccups here and there. Incredible hard work and it’s much appreciated, allowing those of us who are members of the Legislative Assembly to continue serving the people of British Columbia. Thank you. [10:55 a.m.] If I may begin a round of questioning with the minister. The first handful of questions are going to be general inquiries to get a better understanding of the true depth of the financial impacts of COVID-19, particularly on this specific ministry. Perhaps we could begin….

If the minister could speak a little bit about how COVID-19 has impacted revenues within the scope of this ministry and how it might have impacted expenses within this ministry. Hon. H. Bains:On the impact of revenue and expenses to our ministry, there hasn’t been much impact. On the revenue side, we maintain our revenue as it was in the beginning of the year, and on the expense side, we have cut back on some of the expenses. So overall, there’s not much impact on revenue or expenses. J. Martin:Thank you very much for that, Minister.

In a similar line of questioning, can you describe how COV- ID-19 may have impacted capital expenses and capital timelines in your ministry? Hon. H. Bains:On the capital expenditure, we have no impact. J. Martin:Thank you for that. So with the province surely now in a state of deficit, how will the ministerial holdbacks be impacted? Hon. H.

Bains:At this time, we have no information as far as the finances are concerned, and that would impact our holdback. [11:00 a.m.] The Chair:I’ll say to the member for Chilliwack that the previous minister we had encouraged that that ques- tion be directed to the Minister of Finance when she takes her seat. J. Martin:Thank you for the comment, Chair. Were any additional funds provided to the ministry for COVID-19, specifically? If so, how were these allocated within different departments? Hon. H. Bains:No additional finances have been for- warded to the ministry due to COVID-19. J.

Martin:Have assumptions as described in Budget 2020 for the employment standards branch changed? Have they gone up? Have they gone down? How does this impact the ministry budget overall? Hon. H. Bains:We’re in the second year of reformation of the employment standard branch, and nothing has changed in these two years. J. Martin:Have any of the key service plan targets for this ministry changed as a consequence of COVID-19, and will they still be met? Hon. H. Bains: No change to our target, in general terms, and no change to those targets due to the COV- ID-19. J.

Martin:Has the Labour Ministry been hampered in its ability to process applications or to interact with stake- holders? And if there has been some impact, can the min- ister describe it, please? [11:05 a.m.] Hon. H. Bains: The ministry has maintained its key strategic functions amidst the COVID-19 emergency. All ministry services have remained operational, with tem- porary limits to some in-person service delivery in order to control the spread of the virus.

All offices are providing virtual service delivery, and most remain physically open to provide in-person service to clients, with appropriate precautions in place. So we continue to function during the COVID-19. And yes, the delivery of service sometimes has changed during the virus. J. Martin:Can the minister be specific in terms of which stakeholders have…? Has there been a change in the interaction with them, and what’s been done to mitigate it? Hon. H. Bains:We continue to engage with our stake- holders, as we always have done pre-COVID-19.

As I have said, the way we interact with our stakeholders sometimes changed in certain areas of our delivery. Overall, there’s hardly any change. J. Martin:And just one final question in this particular round. Can the minister cite the single biggest disruption that COVID-19 has impacted within his ministry? Hon. H. Bains: The biggest change, I would suggest, due to COVID-19 is like everywhere else. In-person inter- action that people are used to, that the stakeholders are used to — going into the employment standards branch, or going into the WCB office, the W AO office — has changed.

Sometimes they had to do virtual meetings. I think that probably is the biggest change during the COVID-19 in our ministry. Overall, all of our depart- ments continue to operate, continue to provide service, when they are approached. 48 Committee of Supply,

Section A Friday, June 26, 2020

[11:10 a.m.] I would suggest that that is the biggest change, as we are seeing right now. The way we used to do estimates was in person, face to face. But now we are going virtual. I think this is the new normal that people went through with COVID-19. That’s what happened in our ministry as well. J. Martin:Thank you for that, once again. That con- cludes the opening round of general inquiries. I wanted to move now to WorkSafe, if I may. Can we begin with…? Perhaps the minister could provide an update on the review that was conducted last year by Janet Patterson. Hon. H.

Bains:A number of reviews were conducted in the last three years. Paul Petrie — the WCB hired a con- sultant to do a review of their policies and practices. They also engaged Mr. Bogyo to deal with the surplus, and Lisa Helps to deal with how we investigate major injuries and deaths in workplaces. Those reports are being…. Some of them are being looked at, at WCB to proceed with. Others require legislative changes. Then there was Janet Patterson, as the member has mentioned. That report was also to look at the inner work- ings of WorkSafeBC. That report, we are still considering.

Then we will make an announcement in due course about that. J. Martin:With respect to the review by Janet Patterson, when will the public be able to see the report and recom- mendations? Hon. H. Bains:Our intention is to release the report. We are still considering it. It will be released in due course. J. Martin:How will the ministry consult with stake- holders regarding the implementation of any such recom- mendations in that report? Hon. H. Bains:As the member knows, sometimes we are accused that we are consulting too much.

I just want to assure the member that once we make the decision to release the Janet Patterson report, then the consultation process will begin. We will take the input from those con- cerned with the report, especially stakeholders and others, and then we will take into consideration how we move for- ward, based on the consultation feedback. [11:15 a.m.] J. Martin:Will there be any effort to prevent certain stakeholders from feeling left out of the process, such as what is alleged to have happened during the consultation for the review? Hon. H.

Bains: Member, we have demonstrated with our actions in the last three years that we want to include everyone possible, especially those who would be impacted by the recommendations and by the policies of the government when we are considering those policy changes. Certainly, we would encourage everyone to participate — those who would be impacted by it, even others. We’ve done it in the past. The other three reports also went for consultation, and we received good feedback from those three reports. I expect the same thing: robust consultation and feedback from our stakeholders.

And then we will consider the feedback before we move forward. J. Martin: Does the minister anticipate any of the recommendations being impacted or modified as a con- sequence of COVID-19? Hon. H. Bains:Member, I think that would be part of the consultation process: has anything changed since the report was delivered to me on any area of those recom- mendations that Janet Patterson has listed? So I think we will watch it. We will monitor it.

If there are areas that need to be looked at because of the input through the consulta- tion from the stakeholders, then we will certainly seriously look at it and consider it. J. Martin:Thank you. Can the minister tell us what WorkSafeBC’s current surplus is in light of COVID-19? [11:20 a.m.] Hon. H. Bains: As you know, Member, the market has fluctuated during this springtime due to COVID-19. I could tell you that at the end of last year, the assets over liabilities for the WorkSafe accident fund was sit- ting at 152 percent. And as I said, with the fluctuation in the market….

We have since seen the improvement in the market. We are sitting at approximately 145 percent under right now. J. Martin:Is the minister considering ways to use the existing surplus or unappropriated balance during the COVID-19 pandemic? Hon. H. Bains:Member, I think the WCB and all of us must be very, very careful, especially the way the market has gone due to COVID-19. Their main mandate is to pro- tect the workers’ health and safety and to look after them when they are injured or they become ill at the workplace. We want to make sure there’s a sufficient fund to pay for the past, current and future claims.

Having said that, due to the growth in the economy in the last number of years and, also, a good return on the investment, WCB and their investment team were able to realize really good assets over liabilities over the years. Their mandate is to maintain 130 percent just to make sure Friday, June 26, 2020 Committee of Supply,

Section A 49

that there is a cushion in case the market fluctuates, but now they’re sitting at 145 percent. There’s always that opportunity to look at how we improve the workers’ side of the equation and also how we make sure that, for the employer, the system is affordable and that we keep that balance. I think there is expectation from the workers’ side. Since 2002, 2003, there have been cuts to the benefits. There have been reductions in benefits. At the same time, the employers…. The WCB board has decided to give them a premium break since 2006. I think they’ve been very prudent over the years.

They are very prudent, and that’s why they are in a very good financial situation. They were before COVID-19. They are now still very strong financially, and that’s important. When there’s opportunity as…. The board has engaged Mr. Bogyo to look at what can be done with this surplus. When we talk about a surplus, we’re talking about any funds that are over and above 130 percent. They want to maintain 130 percent. Anything over and above — there’s always the opportunity to look at how we improve the workers’ benefits side and also, at the same time, help the employers’ side as well. J.

Martin:Can the minister elaborate just exactly how that surplus might be used to the relief of workers and/or employers? [11:25 a.m.] Hon. H. Bains:I think the right answer would be that we are watching the market very carefully. Certainly, there is demand from both sides, and I think there always would be an opportunity. As I said before, the board engaged Mr. Bogyo to look at what can be done with that extra surplus — over and above 130 percent — that can be utilized to help the workers and also make sure that it’s a system that will continue to be affordable for the employer as well.

We haven’t made any decisions, as you know. If we change any part of the benefit side of the workers, it requires legislative changes. It requires changes to the Workers Compensation Act, so the member will see when and if we bring that legislation. There are those reports that require certain legislative changes. We haven’t considered Janet Patterson yet, but others we are considering, as I said before. Once we finalize, the member will see the intro- duction of legislation to that effect. J.

Martin:Changing topics slightly to workers com- pensation and claims: given that so many workplaces have been shut down for several months, has the minister seen a reduction in WCB claims? Hon. H. Bains:The member knows that during the last three or four months, the workforce all across British Col- umbia was reduced — decreased. And as a result, there were fewer claims during the height of COVID-19. I would say March, April. [11:30 a.m.] Those claims are starting to go up again and on both sides — on no time-lost claims and the time-lost claims.

The current trend is that as the workforce decreased due to COVID-19, plants were shut down, workers were laid off and claims went down. But as the economy is starting to pick up again, we are restarting the economy again, claims are starting to go up again. J. Martin:Is the minister able to give us a rough approx- imation of how much was saved in the last three or 3½ months with the reduction in claims? Hon. H. Bains:The net impact during this time is insig- nificant.

What I’m advised is that, yes, the overall claim volume was reduced, but at the same time, the per-claim cost was higher, because it’s difficult for injured workers to get back to work during these tough times. Having said that, it’s too early to see what impact it will have on the overall claims and claim costs for WorkSafe- BC. We have, still, a number of months to go. I think we will be in a better position at the end of the year to see exactly what the real impact on the total number of claims and the cost of claims will be by that time. S. Furstenau:Thanks to the opposition critic.

This is the time we’ve organized for some of our questions. I appre- ciate the opportunity to ask the Minister of Labour some questions at this time. [11:35 a.m.] I want to start with the precarious work question for the minister. Anything outside of full-time, permanent, benefits-associated work is increasingly becoming the new normal in British Columbia. Gig workers, contrac- ted workers, part-time employees, seasonal, temporary work, irregular hours and more aspects of our modern workforce now make up a significant majority of employment in our province.

These workers are those without a sufficient safety net in terms of employment benefits like health care and sick pay; lesser financial security, like the ability to secure a mortgage; and sometimes the inability to qualify for fed- eral programs like employment insurance. There exists a very significant disparity across the range of workers from those in truly precarious positions, like those who are underpaid without benefits, to those who may be making in excess of six figures by consulting independently. So it doesn’t fit into a single category, this type of work.

I would be interested to know from the Minister of Labour: how does his government define precarious work? Hon. H. Bains:Thanks to the member for the question. It is, I think, a very, very important question. As the eco- nomy changes, the way we do work changes, and it brings 50 Committee of Supply,

Section A Friday, June 26, 2020

its own challenges as a result of that. The member knows that. We’ve seen more and more precarious work. We have no definition in my ministry of how to describe precarious work. Others may have. But we all know that there are people who are working two, three, maybe more jobs in order to make ends meet. In our ministry, we are making changes to make sure that the people who are at the lowest end of the financial rung are supported. That’s how we made the changes to the minimum wage. We’re going to be at $15.20 on June 1, 2021. Right now I believe we’re sitting at about second or third highest in the country.

At the same time, we have some other vulnerable work- ers like temporary foreign workers. We brought in legisla- tion to protect those workers. Recruiters now have to be licensed, and we are working on having the employer also register with the employment standards branch. We added resources to the employment standards branch to ensure that we are on the proactive side of the enforcement rather than reactive, as it was in the last 16 years. I think we’re doing everything that we can in our min- istry, within our mandate, to help those people who need the most help. Many of those precarious workers….

I might add that the member may have heard a story today; a decision may be coming from the Supreme Court of Canada. I think those precarious workers have won a huge victory at the Supreme Court of Canada,Heller v. Uber, where they were told that in order to resolve your dispute, you need to go to the Netherlands for mediation and arbitration. Y ou know it would be almost impossible for any workers to travel to the Netherlands to deal with their issues. We are doing everything we can to make sure that we remove the roadblocks, the barriers to justice for workers.

In fact, we got rid of the self-help kit, in addition to all the other things that we are saying. So I think we’re doing everything we can right now. [11:40 a.m.] But it’s not lost on us. It’s certainly not lost on me that the precarious workers need protection, and we are not there yet. It is very live with me and for our government. S. Furstenau:I appreciate the minister’s comments on this.

I think it’s interesting to note that if precarious work- ers, as in the case you cite just now, the case at the Supreme Court of Canada, have to find themselves using the courts in order to fight for their rights as workers, that is a very strong indication that there is legislative work to be done to protect these workers. That is not how people should have to get protection for their rights as workers, by going to the Supreme Court. As the minister would know, that would be unavailable to a lot of people, to be able to pursue that as an avenue. It’s an excellent indication that there’s legislative work to do.

Further, on the question about…. The minister does not have a clear definition. I think one of the challenges with that is that it’s very hard to start to collect really effective data that can then inform the decisions that need to be made legislatively. Has the government, in any way, been collecting data on how the impacts of COVID-19 have been specifically impacting precarious workers in B.C.? If not, is there any plan to start collecting that data? If there has been data col- lected, how granular is it — year-to-year-based trends over time, or is it just a beginning?

It’s a lot of questions packed into one, but I’m hoping the minister can let us know what kinds of efforts are being made to really track the impacts on precarious workers as a result of COVID-19. Hon. H. Bains:Let me answer this question this way. Our ministry does not collect data as far as the impact of COVID-19 and its impact on jobs. Other ministries are doing it. Advanced Education and the Ministry of Jobs col- lect data. As we all know, though, the hardest hit areas during COVID-19 are the hospitality, tourism, retail and restaur- ant industries.

As you know, many of those are lower-paid and part-time workers. Certainly, it has the biggest impact on those workers. I think as the economy improves, as we reopen, as the Premier announced phase 3…. I think the first priority of all the government ministries was to make sure that we maintained health and safety and protected the health and safety of our citizens. Then, under the guidelines of Dr.

Bonnie Henry and the guidelines prepared in conjunction with the WCB, we open up the economy in a safe manner so that when we move forward, we continue to slow the spread of COVID-19 and the virus. [11:45 a.m.] I think we’ve been successful so far. But like I said before, and as you have suggested, the precarious work, the part-time work…. I came to know anecdotally that ride-hailing drivers were not working. Not very many were working during the pandemic. But now, as the economy opens up, and people feel more comfortable with their health, they are starting to utilize those services.

We, actually, especially in my ministry…. I’m looking at how we make sure that the people in every sector, wheth- er they are full-time workers, part-time workers, precari- ous workers, the new economy…. How do we, one, protect their health and safety, and two, that they are paid fair wages…? I think that’s where we are going to go. We had a lot to do in the last three years. We’ve been here, as you know, only three years. We have achieved much, and much more to do. Also, another area — I will leave it with you — is the exclusions.

Y ou may know that there are a number of occupations that are excluded from employment stand- ards. We will be looking at that. We haven’t had real time to delve into that. Then there are areas of the new economy Friday, June 26, 2020 Committee of Supply,

Section A 51

and how people work — as you have mentioned, precari- ous work. We will be looking at that as we move forward. Thank you for the question. S. Furstenau:A little bit further on this, picking up on the comments that the minister made about protecting health and safety. Another very significant issue that has arisen as a result of COVID-19 and the impacts has been around workers who do not feel that they can take sick days. Here in British Columbia, obviously, we saw an outbreak in a poultry-pro- cessing facility as a result of workers feeling that they wer- en’t able to take sick days.

As we continue in this pandem- ic and the uncertainty that it brings with it, paid sick leave and security for workers are going to be really essential to be able to ensure that people are following the directives of the health officer to not go out and to not work when they’re sick. My question for the minister is: can he give us some insight into where things are at with implementing sick pay for employees in B.C. and whether changes that he sees at this time would be permanent? Who does he expect would be covering the costs associated with sick pay — the employers, the province, the federal government?

It would be great to get some insight into where we’re at with that conversation. Hon. H. Bains:Another very good question and very timely. As the member knows, we’ve seen cases where workers were working when they were sick, when they should not have been working. That caused a lot of prob- lems and also helped spread the virus. It’s not the workers’ fault. I think they’re torn. They stay home, and then they get hit economically. They go to work, and then the virus is spread and transmitted to oth- er workers. It hits the employer and their ability to oper- ate.

The business ended up being shut down, in one case. I think it was a lose-lose situation. That’s why we felt it was important that workers who are sick, who are showing signs, flu-like symptoms, should have stayed home. Again, it’s an economic hardship that they face. They know the rent still has to be paid. They know the mortgage still has to be paid. They know there are other expenses — groceries and clothes for children. [11:50 a.m.] They still need an income, and they can’t afford to stay home. I think those are very, very challenging times for the workers and for the employers, for that matter.

They both were hurting as a result of that. The Premier, as you know, was very, very persistent, and he fought hard with the federal government, trying to bring other colleagues from other jurisdictions along. Finally, the federal government announced the $14 bil- lion package. Part of that was sick leave. We were happy that the federal government listened and that, finally, that relief is there. Right now the details of how it’s going to be imple- mented are being worked out between the federal govern- ment and the provinces.

Once more details are worked out and the terms are worked out, we will be making that announcement. It will be a federal plan, paid for by the federal government, coming out of the $14 billion. S. Furstenau:Can I just follow up on that very quickly with the minister? It will be a federal plan. But can the minister speak to the permanence of this plan? Is this just for right now, or does the minister see this as a permanent shift to guarantee that workers have access to sick pay? Hon. H.

Bains: As the federal government and the provinces are involved in this, I see this as time-limited to deal with the COVID-19 virus. I’m not sure whether we can make it permanent. I think we will continue to work with the federal government to see if we could put some permanency to it. The Premier was very clear that we want to see that there are paid sick days available to workers here in B.C. and all across Canada for obvious reasons. But he also sug- gested that we don’t want to add more burdens onto the employers, because they’re also hurting already. I think we have to find a solution.

How do we make it permanent? Those dialogues, hopefully, will continue dur- ing the discussions that are taking place between the fed- eral government and the province. What the outcome is, I think we’ll see. S. Furstenau:Just switching gears to a topic that is of great interest for the B.C. Green caucus: the emerging eco- nomy. As we begin an economic recovery from COV- ID-19, we really feel strongly that all efforts need to be for- ward-looking and investing in the emerging economy as opposed to the economy of the past and really focusing on bringing prosperity to people and to future generations.

Supporting the provincial workforce in the recovery from COVID-19 will take investment in new sectors that will result in more resilience for communities and for the whole province. My question…. It’s a big one for the min- ister. If he could give us some insight into what kind of planning and what kind of work he’s doing to ensure that recovery efforts are focused on the forward-looking, emer- ging economy in B.C. [11:55 a.m.] Hon. H. Bains:I think, as the member may know, that the emerging economy task force, under the Ministry of Jobs, is working on this particular area.

It shows that the government is very, very serious and keen in this partic- ular area. We agree with the member that this is where I think our future lies. So we need to pay attention to this particular area. The second piece is the Premier’s economic recovery task force. They have businesses, labour representatives, 52 Committee of Supply,

Section A Friday, June 26, 2020

NGOs and others, who discuss: “How do we utilize the $1.5 billion that is set aside to restart the economy?” I think those discussions take place there but, at the same time, also at the Ministry of Jobs. Member, maybe you need to inquire during those estimates and see where that ministry is, as far as the report on the emerging economy task force. I move that the committee rise, report resolution and completion of the estimates of the Ministry of Education and report progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Labour. Motion approved. The Chair:Thank you, Members. This committee now stands adjourned.

For members of the public, we’re back at 1:30. The committee adjourned at 11:57 a.m. Friday, June 26, 2020 Committee of Supply,

Section A 53

Hansard Services, Reporting and Publishing DIRECTOR Robert Sutherland MANAGER OF REPORTING SERVICES Laurel Bernard MANAGER OF PUBLISHING SYSTEMS Dan Kerr TEAM LEADERS Mike Beninger, Kim Christie, Barb Horricks, Julie McClung, Karol Morris, Amy Reiswig, Glenn Wigmore EDITORS Erin Beattie, Janet Brazier, Heather Gleboff, Jane Grainger, Betsy Gray, Iris Gray, Mary Beth Hall, Louis Henderson, Bill Hrick, Genevieve Kirk, Catherine Lang, Paula Lee, Quinn MacDonald, Anne Maclean, Claire Matthews, Jill Milkert, Linda Miller, Sarah Mitenko, Erik Pedersen, Janet Pink, Robyn Swanson, Antoinette Warren, Heather Warren, Kim Westad INDEXERS Shannon Ash, Robin Rohrmoser RESEARCHERS Joshua Hazelbower, Brooke Isherwood, David Mattison, Murray Sinclair TECHNICAL OPERATIONS Pamela Holmes, Daniel Powell, Patrick Stobbe Copyright © 2020 Legislative Assembly of British Columbia TheReport of Proceedings (Hansard)and webcasts of committee proceedings are available at www.leg.bc.ca.

For inquiries contact: Hansard Services 612 Government Street Victoria, BC V8V 1X4 Telephone: 250-387-3681 Email: hansardservices@leg.bc.ca Published by Hansard Services under the authority of the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.

Document details

Collection	British Columbia — Debates (Hansard)
Citation	20200626am CommitteeA n3
Type	hansard
Volume / chapter	20200626am CommitteeA n3
Language	en
Format	pdf
Source	PROVINCIAL
Identifier	f98283737d670c2c163c9fd51e22aa6e3c5b7ad2

Source file is stored in the law ingest library (pdf).