Edmonton (City) v Andrews, 2017 ABQB 747
Opinion
In the Alberta Court of Justice Citation: Edmonton (City) v Andrews, 2023 ABPC 220 , 2023 ABCJ 220 Date: 20230713 Docket: A99412412R Registry: Edmonton Between: The City of Edmonton - and - Thomasa Andrews and Lindsay R. Lamouche Decision of his Worship Justice of the Peace D. Lefebvre Introduction [1] The Respondents are the owners of a dog, “Buddy”. Buddy is a restricted dog pursuant to Bylaw 13145 because of two priorowner convictions under section 14(1)(
b) dated January 20, 2021, and June 8, 2022. [2] On September 9, 2022, Buddy attacked and injured another dog. [3] On January 3, 2023, Buddy was involved in dog-at-large incident. [4] On January 16, 2023, and on February 14, 2023, Buddy attacked and injured a person. [5] The City of Edmonton (the “City”) brings an application for an order pursuant to section 2(1) of the Dangerous Dogs Act, RSA2000, c D-3 (the “Act”). Procedural Background [6] The City filed its application on April 12, 2023 (the “Application”), which included the following affidavits in support of thesame: (
a) Affidavit of Christopher Linney, animal control officer; (
b) Affidavit of Robert Moor, animal control officer; (
c) Affidavit of Matthew York, animal control officer; (
d) Affidavit of Ray Rebman, complainant;
(
e) Affidavit of Jean Buffi, complainant; and (
f) Affidavit of Cynthia Sandra Melnychuk, complainant. [ 7 ] On April 13, 2023, the Respondents were personally served with the Application and supporting affidavits. Steven Lewicki’s affidavit of service was filed on April 25, 2023. [ 8 ] The Respondents did not file a response to the Application. [ 9 ] The Application was heard Wednesday, May 24, 2023. Ms. J. Afonne, counsel for the City, made submissions. The Respondents did not attend the hearing, nor were they represented by counsel or an agent. Legal Issues [ 10 ] The legal issues in this matter are as follows: (
a) What is the standard of proof? (
b) Are the Respondents the owners of Buddy? (
c) Is Buddy a dangerous dog? (
d) If (
c) above is answered in the affirmative, what is the appropriate remedy pursuant to the Act ? Facts Evidence of Christopher Linney [ 11 ] Linney is an animal control officer with the City. [ 12 ] On September 9, 2022, Linney received notification of an alleged dog attack on a citizen and his service dog. The attack took place in northwest Edmonton . He met with the victim, Jacques Boulet, to gather information. He learned that victim’s dog, Festus, suffered deep lacerations from the dog attack and required emergency veterinary care.
Photos of the dog’s injuries are attached to Linney’s affidavit as Exhibit “A”. [ 13 ] On September 24, 2022, Linney attended the Respondents’ residence. He spoke with the Respondent, Lamouche, and advised him that based on witness statements he had received, and without solid evidence to the contrary, he believed Buddy was involved in a dog attack. [ 14 ] Linney requested identification.
Lamouche provided a government issued Alberta driver’s license. [ 15 ] After verifying Lamouche’s identity, Linney returned to his patrol car and conducted a search on the history of the property as well as on the Respondents’ dog, Buddy. Linney learned that Buddy was listed as a restricted dog. [ 16 ] Linney issued and personally served Lamouche with three violation tickets under bylaw 13145: (
a) A98844723R - Failing to control a restricted dog pursuant to s 16; (
b) A9844712R - Failing to obtain a restricted dog licence pursuant to s 4(2); and (
c) A98844745R - Restricted dog attack causing injury pursuant to s 18(1). [ 17 ] True copies of the violation tickets are attached as Exhibit “B” to Linney’s affidavit. Evidence of Robert Moore [ 18 ] Moore is an animal control officer with the City. [ 19 ] On January 4, 2023, Moore was notified of a dog-at-large incident occurring in northwest Edmonton.
He spoke with the complainant, Cynthia Melnychuk (“Melnychuk”) and learned that on January 3, 2023, at approximately 5:04 PM, the dog, identified as Buddy, entered the complainant's property and jumped on the planter near the front window of her home. [ 20 ] Moore conducted a cursory search of the City’s database and found that Buddy was a restricted dog with an extensive history.
He reviewed the contents of the witness statement and proceeded with an investigation. [ 21 ] On January 11, 2023, at approximately 2:00 PM, Moore attended at the Respondent’s residence with fellow Animal Control Officer Ashley Blanchard. Upon their arrival at the residence, they were greeted by a voice coming from the doorbell camera. Moore and Blanchard were advised to wait approximately five minutes, and someone would be there to speak with them. [ 22 ] Shortly thereafter, a truck pulled up and a male exited the vehicle. Moore approached the individual and introduced himself and his department.
The male identified himself as Lindsay. Moore was able to later confirm that the individual was the Respondent, Lindsay Lamouche by reviewing previous violations involving the Respondent and his dog, Buddy.
[ 23 ] Moore advised Lamouche that he had received a complaint about Buddy running onto a neighbour’s property. He also advised Lamouche that Buddy’s restricted dog licence had expired. [ 24 ] Moore issued two violation tickets: (
a) A99410485R - Failing to control a restricted dog pursuant to s 16; and (
b) A99410474R - Failing to obtain a restricted dog licence pursuant to s 4(2). [ 25 ] The tickets are attached to Moore’s affidavit as Exhibit “A”. [ 26 ] The tickets were served upon the Respondents by leaving them in the residence’s mailbox. Evidence of Matthew Yorke [ 27 ] Yorke is an animal control officer with the City. [ 28 ] On January 16, 2023, he received notification of a dog attack in northwest Edmonton.
He also received a witness statement from the victim, Jean Buffi. [ 29 ] He learned from the evidence he gathered that the victim suffered no injuries from the dog attack. [ 30 ] On Monday, January 23, 2023, at approximately 2:00 PM, he attended at the Respondent’s residence, to gather more information. He knocked on the door and heard a dog barking with movement from within the property, but no one opened the door. The doorbell camera was activated, and a man stated that no one was home.
He left the property and returned to his patrol vehicle. [ 31 ] On February 14, 2023, Yorke received a second notification of a dog attack, which occurred near the same location as the notification on January 16, 2023. He obtained photos and a witness statement from the victim, Ray Rebman.
Based on the evidence Yorke gathered, he learned that the victim suffered injuries and required medical attention at Grey Nuns hospital. [ 32 ] On February 18, 2023, at approximately 2:07 PM, Yorke attended the Respondent’s residence, to speak with the Respondents to obtain more information regarding the dog attacks of January 16 and February 14, 2023. He knocked on the door and heard noise from within the residence. However, no one answered. The doorbell camera was activated, and a man identified himself as Lindsay Lamouche. Yorke advised him of the purpose of his visit.
Lamouche retorted that he does not own a dog and Yorke should leave his property immediately. Yorke explained that he will be issuing violation tickets in relation to two dog attacks. Lamouche told him to “throw them in the mailbox” and “leave [his] property immediately.” [ 33 ] Yorke returned to his patrol vehicle and prepared three (3) violation tickets under City bylaw 13145: (
a) A99412331R (dated Jan 16, 2023) – Failing to obtain a restricted dog licence pursuant to s 4(2); (
b) A99412386R (dated February 14, 2023) - Failing to control a restricted dog pursuant to s 16; and (
c) A99412412R (dated February 14, 2023) - Restricted dog attack causing injury pursuant to s 18(1)(c). [ 34 ] The tickets are attached to Yorke’s affidavit as Exhibit “A”. [ 35 ] Due to the Respondents’ history, a copy of Lindsay Lamouche’s driver’s licence was attached to the file by Animal Control Officer Linney, who had issued violation tickets in September 2022.
Yorke noticed that the name on the copy of the licence a matched the name of the individual who verbally identified himself to him. [ 36 ] Once the tickets were issued, Yorke returned to the property and placed them in the mailbox. [ 37 ] The City of Edmonton’s animal licensing records indicate that the Respondents are the owners of the offending dog, Buddy. A copy of the animal licensing record is attached to Yorke’s affidavit as Exhibit “B”. [ 38 ] On March 21, 2023, Yorke visited the neighbourhood where the residence is located. He took a picture of current state of the property where Buddy lives.
A true copy of the photo is attached to Yorke’s affidavit as Exhibit “C”. Evidence of Cynthia Sandra Melnychuk [ 39 ] Melnychuk is a witness to a dog-at-large incident. [ 40 ] On January 3, 2023, at approximately 5:03 PM, Melnychuk was at her residence in Edmonton, which is next to the Respondents’ residence. She was sitting in her living room with the front window drapes open. [ 41 ] A dog named Buddy ran down her sidewalk then came into her yard. The dog came from the neighbouring property in Edmonton. Buddy ran up to her window and placed its paw on her front planter while barking at her.
Buddy continued to bark at her as he made its way to the front doorway and back down to the front planter. [ 42 ] After a while, a teenage girl walked over from the Respondents’ residence. However, it continued to bark and did not respond to her calls. She was able to retrieve Buddy, dragging him by the collar. [ 43 ] The following day, she filed a complaint with the City, as this was not the first time Buddy was seen at large on her property and in
her neighbourhood, being aggressive toward other dogs and pedestrians. [ 44 ] At the time of the incident, she was afraid of exiting her front door or having her elderly parents over for fear of an encounter with Buddy. Evidence of Jean Buffi [ 45 ] Jean Buffi is a victim of a dog attack. [ 46 ] On January 16, 2023, she was walking her dog, Gus, along her residence which is close to the Respondent’s residence. At approximately 3:45 PM, as she was returning from the mailbox, she was walking past the Respondents’ residence.
She was halfway past the Respondents’ house when Buddy approached her from behind and attempted to attack Gus. [ 47 ] Buffi screamed and tried to get between the two dogs, but Buddy continued to come at Gus from all angles. As she was trying to protect Gus from Buddy, two teenagers emerged from the Respondents’ residence, calling out to Buddy; he did not respond. [ 48 ] Buffi was finally able to pick up Gus and walked briskly away when Buddy came behind her −she felt its paws on her back.
By then, the teenagers had gotten a hold of Buddy and she continued to walk as quickly as she could away from them. [ 49 ] Although there were no injuries, Buffi and Gus suffered from some soreness from this incident. Evidence of Ray Rebman [ 50 ] Rebman is a senior citizen.
He was a victim of a dog attack. [ 51 ] On February 14, 2023, at approximately 2:00 PM, he walked to the mailbox to retrieve his daughter’s mail. [ 52 ] His daughter’s residence is directly across the street from the Respondents’ residence. [ 53 ] As he was returning from the mailbox, he got to the bottom of his daughter’s driveway when he heard the owner of the dog at the residence across the street yelling at Buddy. By the time he turned around to look, the dog had lunged at him and attacked, biting him on the arm. [ 54 ] Two young adults exited the Respondents’ property and tried to get the dog off him.
One of them managed to do so and both returned with Buddy to the Respondents’ residence without making any enquiries as to whether Rebman was okay. [ 55 ] Rebman was quite seriously injured and bleeding. He required medical attention. Five photos of the injuries sustained during the dog attack are attached to Rebman’s affidavit as Exhibit “A”. His attendance at Grey Nuns Hospital is substantiated by attaching a treatment card to his affidavit as Exhibit “B”. [ 56 ] He later contacted the police and animal control to make a complaint.
Applicable Law and Analysis Issue No. 1: What is the standard of proof? [ 57 ] Proceedings pursuant to ss 1 and 2(1) the Act are not quasi-criminal
summary conviction proceedings under the Provincial Offences Procedures Act, RSA 2000, c P-34 ( POPA ) but are civil proceedings, which fall under the Alberta Court of Justice Act, RSA 2000, c C-30.5 and the Regulations thereunder. In Calgary (City) v Bagaric, 2022 ABKP 635 [ Bagaric ], the Honourable Justice Colin C.J.
Feasby stated the following at para 21: POPA s 2(1) provides that it “applies to every case in which a person commits or is suspected of having committed an offence under an enactment for which that person may be liable to imprisonment, fine, penalty, or other punishment.” The destruction of a dangerous dog pursuant to the [ Act ] s 1 and s 2(1) is not imprisonment, a fine, or a penalty.
The only question is whether the destruction of a dangerous dog is “other punishment.” The Supreme Court in Canada (Attorney General) v Whaling , 2014 SCC 20 at para 52 explained that when considering whether something is a “punishment” under s 11(
h) of the Charter the Court must ask “whether a discrete sanction ... has characteristics of a criminal sanction, and thus constitutes ‘punishment.’” The Whaling approach to determining what is punishment is equally applicable in the context of POPA . The destruction of a dangerous dog under the [ Act ] does not have the characteristics of a criminal sanction against the owner; rather, it is a public safety measure. [ 58 ] It is trite law that the standard of proof with respect to civil matters is on the balance of probabilities. Accordingly, the City must prove its case on that standard.
Issue No. 2: Are the Respondents the owner of Buddy? [ 59 ] Since the Respondents have not participated in any way in these proceedings, it only seems logical that the first matter to be dealt with is whether the Respondents are the rightful owners of the offending dog, Buddy. [ 60 ] Animal Control Officer Yorke deposed that “the City of Edmonton’s animal licensing records indicate that the Respondents are the owners of the offending dog.” A copy of the record is attached to his affidavit as Exhibit “B”. A review of the record shows that Buddy, a border collie, resides at the Respondent’s residence in Edmonton.
The last page of the record also indicates that the Respondent, Thomasa Andrews, is the licensee for Buddy’s pet licence, which was obtained on November 5, 2020. The address
associated with the licence and licensee is the same address as the Respondent’s. [ 61 ] Animal Control Officer Linney stated in his affidavit that he attended at Respondent’s residence and spoke with the Respondent Lamouche.
Linney confirmed Lamouche’s ID via a government issued Alberta Driver’s licence. [ 62 ] The Complainant of a dog-at-large incident, Melnychuk, deposed that she resides at a residence right next the Respondents’ property and has personal knowledge of Buddy. [ 63 ] Complainant Buffi, who was a victim of dog attack, deposed, based on personal knowledge, that the offending dog, Buddy, came from the Respondent’s property. [ 64 ] Complainant Rebman, who was a victim of a dog attack, deposed that he has personal knowledge of the fact that Buddy and the owners of Buddy resides at the Respondents’ address. [ 65 ] Section 3(1) of the Act states as follows: 3(1) The occupier of a house or premises where a dog was kept or permitted to live or remain at the time of a complaint shall be presumed to the owner of the dog unless the occupier proves that the occupier was not the owner of the dog at the time. [ 66 ] I am satisfied that, at all material times, Buddy was kept or was permitted to live at and with both Respondents who were occupiers of the residence at the northwest Edmonton address. [ 67 ] Neither of the Respondents has provided evidence that they are not the owner of the dog. [ 68 ] Given the foregoing, the Respondents are, on the balance of probabilities, the owners of Buddy.
Issue No. 3: Is Buddy a dangerous dog? [ 69 ] Section 2(1) of the Act reads as follows: Complaint as to Dangerous Dogs 2(1) A justice may take cognizance of a complaint that a dog is dangerous and not kept under proper control and if it appears to the justice that the dog is dangerous, the justice may make an order in a
summary way directing the dog to be kept by the owner in a proper way or to be destroyed. [ 70 ] Unfortunately, there is no definition for the term “dangerous dog” in the Act . [ 71 ] In the case of The City of Prince George v MacLeod , 2004 BCPC 8 , the City of Prince George applied for an order under the Local Government Act, RSBC 1996 c 323 , to have the respondent’s Rottweiler (named Kai Kai) destroyed. The definition of “dangerous dog” pursuant to s 707.1(1) of the Local Government Act reads as follows: “ dangerous dog ” means a dog that (
a) has killed or seriously injured a person, (
b) that an animal control officer has reasonable grounds to believe is likely to kill or seriously injure a person, or (
c) while in a public place or while on private property, other than property owned or occupied by the person responsible for the dog, has killed or seriously injured a companion animal or a domestic animal. [ 72 ] In that same case , Judge K.D Skilnick referred to R v Kucera, 2001 BCPC 360 [ Kucera ], where Judge Burdette stated that the legal test “should also involve a consideration of the dog’s past behaviour, current state, and an examination of the owner’s care of the dog and ability to control it” (at para 4). [ 73 ] In Whitehorse (City) v Parry, 2007 YKTC 31 [ Parry ], Judge Faulkner referred to the definition of “Dangerous Dog” found in the City of Whitehorse’s Animal Control Bylaw 2001-01, which reads as follows:
DEFINITIONS 2. In this bylaw, “DANGEROUS DOG” means any individual dog that:
(1) Has bitten, injured, attacked or killed a domestic animal, without provocation, on public or private property; or
(2) Has bitten, injured, or attacked a human being, without provocation, on public or private property; or
(3) Is kept for the purpose of providing security or protection to persons or property; or
(4) Has shown the disposition or tendency to be threatening or aggressive. [ 74 ] Parry was an appeal from a decision of the City of Whitehorse’s Manager who had declared the offending dog a “dangerous dog” pursuant to the city’s bylaws. On appeal, the court upheld the manager’s decision; it found that there was clear and cogent evidence that the offending dog suddenly, and without provocation, attacked and seriously injured a smaller dog being walked by its owner.
[ 75 ] In Burnaby (City) v Nagra , 2010 BCPC 34 , a pit bull named Cujo was being walked on-leash when, without provocation, it escaped control of its owner and jumped on an elderly man holding a small dog named Max, knocking him down. Cujo attached Max and killed it. Cujo also injured Max’s owner. The Judge found Cujo to be a dangerous dog under the s 49 of the city’s Community Charter , SBC 2003,
Chapter 26 (the “ Charter ”). The definition of “dangerous dog” under the Charter reads as follows: " dangerous dog " means a dog that (
a) has killed or seriously injured a person, (
b) has killed or seriously injured a domestic animal, while in a public place or while on private property, other than property owned or occupied by the person responsible for the dog, or (
c) an animal control officer has reasonable grounds to believe is likely to kill or seriously injure a person. [ 76 ] The judge also referred to Kucera for the legal test in assessing dogs for dangerousness. [ 77 ] In Rogier v Halifax (Regional Municipality) , 2009 NSSC 14 , the court heard an application to quash the decision of a municipal officer to seize the applicant’s dog and order it destroyed. The court found that a
section of the bylaw was ultra vires and the decision purportedly made by the officer in reliance of that
section was quashed. However, the
section of the bylaw that was not affected was the definition of “dangerous dog”. The
interpretation
section of By-Law No. A-300 reads as follows:
Interpretation 2
(1) In this By-Law, … (g) “dangerous dog” means any dog which: (
i) attacks or demonstrates a propensity, tendency or disposition to attack a human being or animal either on public or private property; (ii) has caused injury to or otherwise endangered the safety of a human being or animal; (iii) threatens any human being or animal; (iv) is owned or harboured primarily or in part for the purpose of dog fighting; (
v) is trained for dog fighting; or (vi) is a dog for which a muzzle order has been made; Provided that no dog shall be deemed a “dangerous dog” solely because it attacks or threatens a trespasser on the property of its owner, harms or menaces anyone who has tormented or abused it, was at the time of its aggressive behaviour acting in defence to an attack from a person or animal, acting in defence of its young or is a professionally trained guard do for law enforcement or guard duties. [ 78 ] The above-cited
definitions of “dangerous dog” share some commonalities in that a dangerous dog: has injured or killed a person or animal; shows aggressive tendencies and/or has threatened the safety and security of a person or animal; presents an imminent danger; was unprovoked; and was either on public or private property. [ 79 ] While I agree that the legal test could also include a consideration of the dog’s past behaviour, current state and an examination of the owner’s care of the dog and ability to control it (per Kucera ), I am of the view that these factors should go to remedy rather that determining whether a dog should be declared a “dangerous dog.” [ 80 ] Based on the foregoing, I define a “dangerous dog” to mean any dog that: (
a) has injured or killed a person or animal, without provocation, whether on public or private property; (
b) has threatened or endangered the safety and security of a person or animal, without provocation, whether on public or private property; or (
c) shows aggressive tendencies toward persons or animals, without provocation, whether on public or private property, and presents an imminent danger. [ 81 ] In the application before me, The City contends that Buddy was the offending dog involved in the following incidents: (
a) A dog attack on a person and service dog on September 9, 2022; (
b) A dog-at-large incident on January 3, 2023; (
c) A dog attack on a person on January 16, 2023; and (
d) A dog attack on a person on February 14, 2023. [ 82 ] I must first determine whether the City has, on the balance of probabilities, proven that Buddy was the offending dog in each of the
above-noted incidents. Secondly, I must review the circumstances of those incidents to determine if they meet the test for finding whether Buddy is a “dangerous dog.” [ 83 ] It is noted that the Respondents have not provided any response to the City’s application. As such, the City’s evidence is uncontradicted. Having said that, the City’s evidence is still subject to evidentiary rules, such as the rule against hearsay. [ 84 ] With respect to the September 9, 2022, dog attack, only Animal Control Officer Linney provided evidence.
In his affidavit, Linney has relied on statements and photos provided by the victim/complainant, Jacques Boulet, to conclude that Buddy was the offending dog. However, this evidence is hearsay evidence.
Moreover, Linney’s statement, “...and without solid evidence to the contrary, I believe that his dog; BUDDY, had been involved in a dog attack and I would be issuing violation tickets,” is problematic –it effectively reverses the onus of proof onto the Respondents. [ 85 ] Hence, it would have been necessary for the victim, Jacques Boulet, to have sworn an affidavit chronicling his and his dog’s encounter with Buddy. [ 86 ] Consequently, the City has not proven the September 9, 2022, dog attack on the balance of probabilities. [ 87 ] With respect to the January 3, 2023 dog-at-large incident, the witness, Melnychuk, provides compelling testimony.
Not only did Melnychuk witness first-hand, Buddy’s at-large behaviour that day, but as a neighbour of the Respondents, she also has personal knowledge of other instances where Buddy was at large, effectively terrorizing the neighbourhood. She stated that the dog was aggressive toward other dogs and persons, including other instances where Buddy was on her property. She expressed a fear of exiting her own home.
It is, in my view, quite disconcerting when a resident is fearful of an encounter with a dog when leaving her own house, or when she is having company over. [ 88 ] I find that the City has proven that Buddy was the offending dog during the January 3, 2023 dog-at-large incident on the balance of probabilities. [ 89 ] The Complainant, Buffi, deposed that she and her dog, Gus, were the victim of a dog attack on January 16, 2023.
Her first-hand evidence, too, is compelling – while there were no injuries, the sudden, unprovoked, and relentless assault by Buddy could have been much worse had it not been for her ability to pick up her dog and leave the area in earnest. [ 90 ] I find that the City has proven, on the balance of probabilities, that Buddy was the offending dog during the January 16, 2023, dog attack. [ 91 ] With respect to the February 14, 2023 incident, the victim of a dog attack, Rebman, is a senior citizen. He suffered serious injuries after Buddy, unprovoked, severely bit him on the arm.
The photos of the deep wounds on his arm are chilling, to say the least (see Exhibit “A”). As a result, Rebman required hospital treatment because of the attack. [ 92 ] I find that the City has proven, on the balance of probabilities, that Buddy was the offending dog during the February 14, 2023, dog attack. [ 93 ] Based on the foregoing, I find that Buddy’s actions and behaviour during the attacks were sudden and unprovoked. His attack on Rebman was particularly frightening on account of his injuries.
I also find that Buddy, while at large, posed a threat to other animals and persons and presented an imminent danger. I am satisfied that the City has proven its case in support of a dangerous dog finding pursuant to the Act . I therefore find Buddy to be a dangerous dog. Issue No. 4: What is the appropriate remedy? [ 94 ] Section 2(1) of the Act reads as follows: 2(1) ... and if it appears to the justice that the dog is dangerous, the justice may make an order in a
summary way directing the dog to be kept by the owner in a proper way or to be destroyed. [ 95 ] In its application, the City is not seeking to have the dog destroyed. [ 96 ] Given the dangerousness of the attacks, I find that I should exercise my discretion in favour of having Buddy destroyed. However, there are many unknowns that would make such an order unreasonable. For example, this Court has not had the benefit of receiving evidence from an expert as to what triggers Buddy, and whether Buddy could benefit from behavioural modification through a regiment of training by a qualified dog trainer.
I also suspect the City, in preparing its application, has come to a similar reasoning and conclusion. [ 97 ] Accordingly, I will order that the dog be kept by the Respondents in a proper way. Conclusion [ 98 ] Having found Buddy to be a dangerous dog, I make the following Order: [ 99 ] The Respondents (referred to as the “Owners”) shall comply with all provisions of City Bylaw 13145 applicable to dogs and, in particular, to owners of a restricted dog. [ 100 ] In addition to the requirements pursuant to s 17 (
a) to (
c) of Bylaw 13145, I will add that the Owners could let Buddy off-leash in their backyard, provided the fence is secure and high enough to prevent Buddy from escaping. I make this addition because dogs (especially border collies) do need to run around freely without a leash from time to time. Furthermore, an animal control officer for the City must approve the pen and/or the fencing before Buddy can be allowed outdoors on the Owners’ property.
[ 101 ] The Owners shall display signage on the front and rear entrances to their residence and on the fence or the dog’s pen, indicating that it contains a dangerous dog, as may be directed by an animal control officer for the City. [ 102 ] Within 30 days of the date of this Order, Buddy must be microchipped for permanent identification purposes. Proof of the same shall be provided to an animal control officer for the City. [ 103 ] Within 60 days of the Order, the Owners shall have Buddy’s behaviour assessed by a qualified dog trainer or qualified behaviour consultant.
The trainer/consultant must be approved by an animal control officer for the City. Following the assessment, The Owners shall enrol Buddy in a training program designed for aggressive dogs, as recommended by the trainer/consultant. This means that they must commence this program with the trainer/consultant within the next 60 days. The Owners shall provide proof of successful completion of the program to an animal control officer for the City within five days of completion.
Any requests for extensions must be received by an animal control officer for the City prior to the 60-day period expiring. [ 104 ] The Owners will immediately notify an animal control officer for the City of any changes to their residential address. If the Owners move to another jurisdiction in the Province of Alberta, a copy of this Order must be provided to the local animal enforcement authority within five days of relocation. [ 105 ] The Owners shall not sell or give away Buddy, or otherwise transfer ownership of Buddy to a third party without prior written approval of this court.
This is to ensure that if there is a transfer ownership, the new owner can comply with the Order. [ 106 ] Either party may bring an application on notice to have this Order varied. [ 107 ] The City has asked for costs of the Application. Pursuant to s 37.1 of the Alberta Court of Justice Act, I have the discretion to consider an award of costs in respect to the Application. Based on ss 38 and 39 of the Provincial Court Procedure Regulations , as well as the Provincial Court Fees and Costs Regulations, and
Schedule C of the Alberta Rules of Court, I award costs in the amount of $750.00 based on the following: Filing fee ($100.00), process server fees ($250.00), and costs for an uncontested application ($400). [ 108 ] The City has also asked for a clause in the Order that would authorize the City (or other local animal control authority) to seize Buddy without further notice to the Respondents in the event Buddy is found at large or attacks, bites, or otherwise harms an animal or person.
The court cannot make such an order. [ 109 ] Should Buddy be found at large, for example, the Respondents would be in breach of the Order. Per Bagaric, the Court of King’s Bench drew a distinction between s 2(1) and 2(2) of the Act at para 22: [The Act ] s 2(2), by contrast, creates a
summary conviction offence for non-compliance with an order granted pursuant to s.2(1) . This aligns with POPA s 2(2), which provides that “[w]here a contravention under an enactment is enforced under this Act , the contravention is deemed to be an offence under that enactment and for the purposes of this Act .” [ 110 ] As such, any breach of this Order will require the City to follow the procedures for
summary convictions pursuant to Provincial Offences Procedures Act. _________________________________ D. Lefebvre Justice of the Peace Alberta Court of Justice Appearances J. Afonne For the Edmonton (City)
Loading document…