R v EF, 2021 ABQB 114
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: R v EF, 2021 ABQB 114 Date: 20230529 Docket: 181377235Q1 Registry: Edmonton Between: His Majesty the King - and - E.F. Accused Restriction on Publication Identification Ban – See the Criminal Code ,
section 486.4 . By Court Order, information that could identify the Complainant who is referred to as AB in these Reasons, or the young person who is referred to as CD in these reasons, must not be published, broadcast, or transmitted in any way. NOTE: Identifying information has been removed from this judgment to comply with the ban so that it may be published. Corrected judgment: A corrigendum was issued on May 29, 2023; the corrections have been made to the text and the corrigendum is appended to this judgment.
Corrected judgment: A Corrected Judgment was issued on March 23, 2021; the corrections have been made to the text and the corrections are appended to this judgment. _______________________________________________________ Reasons for Judgment on Charter s. 10(
b) Application of the Honourable Mr. Justice B.R.
Burrows _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] EF is charged with 11 offences arising out of contact the Crown alleges he had with a 15-year-old female between November 6 and 7, 2018 at Edmonton. [ 2 ] The charges include two counts of sexual assault ( CC s 271), two counts of sexual interference ( CC s 151), invitation to sexual touching ( CC s 152), luring a child under 18 ( CC s 172.1(1)(a)) luring a child under 16 ( CC s 172.1(1)(b), making child pornography ( CC s 163.1(2), transmitting child pornography ( CC s 163.1(3)), possessing child pornography ( CC s 163.1(4), and obtaining sexual services for consideration ( CC s 286.1(2)).
[ 3 ] EF applies in advance of his trial for the exclusion of evidence obtained by the police on the night of his arrest by means of a penile swab. He contends that the police violated his Charter s. 10(
b) right to retain and instruct counsel without delay by not facilitating his phoning a lawyer though he had stated that he wanted to phone a lawyer on two occasions after his arrest. He submits that the evidence from the penile swab should be excluded pursuant to Charter s. 24(2). [ 4 ] EF does not allege that there was any breach of his Charter s. 8 right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure arising from the manner in which the police obtained the penile swab. [ 5 ] Three police witnesses testified on this application. Two were directly involved in taking the penile swab.
The third arrested EF prior to the penile swab being obtained. [ 6 ] That third witness, Cst. Colin Holben, testified that on November 7, 2018, at about 21:00 he was dispatched to a hotel in Edmonton to which the police believed EF was taking a 15-year-old female with whom he had previously communicated electronically. The police believed that EF intended to have sexual relations with the underage female. On arrival at the hotel, Cst. Holben awaited receipt of information that EF and the female had arrived at the hotel. Once Cst.
Holben was so advised, he and other officers went to the room which was registered to EF and knocked. There was no response. The police opened the door using the key which hotel management had provided and announced their presence. When they entered the hotel room, EF was approaching the door. He was doing up the belt on his pants. He was not wearing a shirt. He was immediately arrested. The arrest occurred at 21:45. [ 7 ] Cst. Holben testified that he advised EF that he was under arrest for child luring. Cst. Holben then advised EF of his Charter s. 10(
b) right to counsel. He told EF that he had the right to contact a lawyer “without delay” and that before proceeding with the investigation, the police would provide him with a phone and the information he might require to contact a lawyer. Cst. Holben asked EF if he wanted to contact a lawyer and EF responded, “Yes”. [ 8 ] Cst. Holben then transported EF to EPS SW Division arriving there at 22:14. EF was asked to remove his clothes, which were seized, and to put on a jumpsuit made of a paper-like material. He was placed in a “dry” cell – that is a cell without a sink, toilet or any other source of water.
The intention was to obtain a penile swab from EF. [ 9 ] At 23:15, an hour after EF arrived at EPS SW Division, the EPS officers who were to obtain the penile swab, Cst. Park and Cst. Katchur, were summoned from there office in a different building. They arrived at EPS SW Division at 23:53. Both testified on this application. [ 10 ] As I understand Cst. Park ’s evidence, he advised the EPS officer who was in charge that the EPS protocol with regard to taking a penile swab required that the procedure be used only where the offence charged involved sexual contact between the accused and another person.
Child luring is not such an offence. But Cst. Park was advised that EF and the female had been found naked in the hotel room bed and that police believed sexual contact had occurred. Charges of sexual assault and sexual interference therefore appeared justified. [ 11 ] At 00:32, November 8, 2018, about 2 hours and 45 minutes after he was arrested, EF was rearrested for sexual assault and sexual interference while in the dry cell and was again advised of his Charter s. 10(
b) right to counsel in the same words as had been previously read to him. The information provided included that he had the right to immediately contact a lawyer, that police would facilitate such contact, and that police would not proceed with their investigation until he had exercised that right, if he wanted to exercise it. Again, EF said that he wanted to contact a lawyer. [ 12 ] EF was not however given access to a telephone at that point. Rather, Cst. Katchur, assisted by Cst.
Park, took the penile swab. [ 13 ] EF was placed in a phone room and allowed to call a lawyer at 00:51 more than 3 hours after he was initially arrested, and 2.5 hours after he arrived at EPS SW Division. [ 14 ] In his submissions, Mr. Nicholls for the Crown conceded that the delay in giving EF access to a telephone so he could call a lawyer was a violation of his Charter s. 10(
b) right to Counsel. [ 15 ] The issue on this application therefore is whether Charter s. 24(2) applies in these circumstances to render the evidence gathered by means of the penile swab inadmissible. [ 16 ] Counsel differed on the issue of whether it can be said that the evidence obtained by means of the penile swab was “evidence obtained in a manner that infringed or denied” EF’s Charter s. 10(
b) right to counsel – the first branch of Charter s. 24(2). [ 17 ] Mr. Nicholls submitted that the obtaining of the penile swab evidence had no connection to the breach of the Charter right to counsel – that there was no nexus between the Charter breach and the evidence sought to be excluded. Ms.
Labahn submitted that the authorities do not require that there be such a nexus before it can be said that the evidence sought to be excluded was obtained in a manner that infringed or denied the Charter right. [ 18 ] In my view, it is not necessary for me to resolve this issue because I am satisfied that whether or not a nexus is required, the second branch of Charter s. 24(2) – that admission of the evidence in EF’s trial would bring the administration of justice into disrepute – is not present in these circumstances. [ 19 ] I reach that conclusion by balancing the three elements of a Charter s. 24(2) analysis set out by the Supreme Court in R v.
Grant 2009 SCC 32 . [ 20 ] As to the first Grant element – the seriousness of the Charter breach – in my view, this was a serious breach. No first-hand explanation as to why EF was not given access to telephone within a few minutes of his arriving at the EPS SW Division has been offered. The police officer who decided that access to a phone should be delayed was not called. In my view, if there was a reasonable
explanation, it was for the Crown to provide that evidence. [ 21 ] Both Cst. Park and Cst. Katchur offered hearsay evidence as to what they understood the reason for the delay in giving EF’s access to the phone to have been. Their understanding had nothing to do with any need to have the penile swab taken before access to a phone was provided.
And, as far as the evidence goes, the circumstances which, according to their understanding, required the delay still existed at the time EF actually was given access to the phone. [ 22 ] As far as the evidence goes, it appears that the police violated EF’s right to counsel cavalierly – for no good reason. A cavalier denial by police of an arrested person’s right to counsel is a serious breach of the person’s Charter rights. It is to be clearly and strongly denounced.
Even so, it is to be balanced with the other Grant elements. [ 23 ] As to the second Grant element – the impact of the Charter breach on EF’s interests – I accept the Crown’s submission that vis a vis the evidence sought to be excluded, the impact was modest. It is not disputed that the taking of the penile swab was a search incidental to arrest. In the vast majority of situations, a search incidental to arrest occurs before the detained person’s access to a lawyer is facilitated.
EF cooperated with the taking of the penile swab in this case – but the evidence was that, had he not cooperated, the swab would have been taken by force. As the evidence obtained through the swab was not his DNA but, rather, was the young female’s DNA, he was not being obliged to self incriminate. It is difficult to imagine anything that a lawyer might have advised him that would have prevented the police from taking the swab. [ 24 ] As to the third Grant element – society’s interest in having the case tried on its merits – Ms.
Labahn submitted that there is no reason to believe that exclusion of the evidence obtained through the penile swab would make it impossible for the Crown to prove its case. That may be so, but I think it is also clear that the evidence is important – otherwise this application would not have been brought and the Crown would not have opposed it.
At this point, I have no certain knowledge of the other evidence the Crown has to support its theory, or of the weight that it will be possible to assign to that evidence, when it is presented. [ 25 ] I am satisfied, however, that the offences charged are very serious – that the allegation made against EF is that he engaged in conduct which the vast majority of Canadians would consider simply unacceptable and obviously justifying diligent investigation and prosecution by the authorities.
Society’s interest in having the charges against EF tried on their merits is extremely high. [ 26 ] Balancing the three Grant elements, I conclude that admission of the evidence obtained by means of the penile swab, though it was obtained in the context of a serious breach of EF’s Charter right to counsel, will not bring the administration of justice into disrepute. [ 27 ] I dismiss the application. Heard on February 9 and 11, 2021. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 12 th day of February, 2021. B.R. Burrows J.C.Q.B.A.
Appearances: Keith Nicholls for the Crown Samantha Labahn for EF _______________________________________________________
Corrigendum of the Reasons for Judgment of The Honourable Mr. Justice B.R. Burrows _______________________________________________________ 1. The insertion of the Restriction on Publication Ban,
section 486.4 of the Criminal Code . 2. The Accused’s name has been deleted and replaced with the initials “EF”. 3. The removal of the Accused’s name in the Corrigendum dated March 23, 2021 and replaced with the initials “EF”. _______________________________________________________ Corrections to the Reasons for Judgment of The Honourable Mr. Justice B.R. Burrows _______________________________________________________ In paragraphs [25], [26] and in the Appearances, the spelling of EF’s name has been corrected.
Loading document…