2012 QCCQ 5631, 2012 QCCQ 5631

Böder c.

Lloyd 2012 QCCQ 5631 COURT OF QUEBEC Small Claims Division CANADA PROVINCE OF QUEBEC DISTRICT OF montreal TOWN OF montreal Civil Division No: 500-32-120410-099 DATE: June 1, 2012 ______________________________________________________________________ BY THE HONOURABLE sylvain coutlée ______________________________________________________________________ dirk böder Plaintiff v. derek lloyd Defendant ______________________________________________________________________ JUDGMENT ______________________________________________________________________ [ 1 ] The Plaintiff claims the amount of 3 285,64 $ from the Defendant, which represents unpaid invoices for services rendered (the restoration of the Defendant's culture protected home). [ 2 ] The Defendant contests the claim and makes a counter-claim for the amount of 2 700 $.

The Defendant alleges that the Plaintiff exaggerated the hours he worked. [ 3 ] Therefore, the Defendant refuses to pay any additional labour invoices on the grounds that the hours worked are unjustified. [ 4 ] Considering the parties testimony; [ 5 ] Considering that the Plaintiff did not meet his burden of proof; [ 6 ] Considering that the Defendant did not meet his burden of proof in his cross-demand; [ 7 ] CONSIDERING the motives of this judgment have been given orally and recorded numerically; For these reasons, the court : rejects the demand; Rejects the counter-claim; Both parties paying its own cost. __________________________________ sylvain coutlée, j.c.q.

Date of hearing: June 1, 2012