ABENA MANSA MONLOUIS Applicant v. THE MINISTER OF CITIZENSHIP, 2015 FC 24

Date: 20150108 Docket: IMM-3472-13 Citation: 2015 FC 24 Ottawa, Ontario, January 8, 2015 PRESENT: The Honourable Mr. Justice O'Reilly BETWEEN: ABENA MANSA MONLOUIS Applicant and THE MINISTER OF CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION Respondent JUDGMENT AND REASONS I. Overview [ 1 ] In 2012, Ms Abena Mansa Monlouis, a citizen of St Lucia, arrived in Canada and applied for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds (H&

C) when she was 17 years old. She hoped to live with her father who is a permanent resident of Canada. [ 2 ] An immigration officer reviewed Ms Monlouis’ application and concluded that she had had little opportunity to become established in Canada, having lived here for less than a year. Further, she would soon reach the age of 18 and would no longer be considered a minor. Finally, Ms Monlouis had provided insufficient evidence relating to her relationship with her father.

Accordingly, the officer found that Ms Monlouis had not shown she would experience unusual, undeserved or disproportionate hardship if she had to apply for permanent residence from outside Canada. [ 3 ] Ms Monlouis argues that the officer’s decision was unreasonable as it failed to take adequate account of her status as a minor. She was enrolled in school in Canada and wished to be raised and reunited with her father, a natural desire for someone in her circumstances. She maintains that the officer failed to weigh these factors.

She asks me to overturn the decision and order another officer to reconsider her application. [ 4 ] I cannot agree. The officer’s decision was responsive to the evidence and submissions before him. In the circumstances, the outcome was defensible based on the facts and the law. Therefore, I must dismiss this application for judicial review. [ 5 ] The sole issue is whether the officer’s decision was unreasonable. II.

Was the Officer’s decision unreasonable? [ 6 ] Ms Monlouis contends that the officer failed to give appropriate consideration to the fact that she was a minor when she applied for permanent residence. [ 7 ] I disagree. The officer was clearly aware that Ms Monlouis was 17 years old when she applied for her H&C. Moreover, there was simply no evidence before the officer that pointed to any particular hardship that Ms Monlouis would endure if she had to apply for permanent residence from St Lucia. [ 8 ] There was no evidence relating to her life in St Lucia.

She did not mention any family there, or describe where or with whom she had been living. She states that she would like to foster a relationship with her father, but there is no evidence emanating from him on the subject, other than a completed sponsorship form. She attends school in Canada and has apparently begun to make friends here but, again, there was no evidence before the officer relating to any significant attachments she has made. [ 9 ] Based on the paucity of evidence before the officer, I cannot conclude that his decision was unreasonable. III.

Conclusion and Disposition [ 10 ] The officer’s rejection of Ms Monlouis’ H&C application represented a defensible outcome based on the law and the evidence before him. Therefore, I must dismiss this application for judicial review. Neither party proposed a question of general importance for me to certify, and none is stated.

JUDGMENT THIS COURT’S JUDGMENT is that : 1. The application for judicial review is dismissed; and 2. No question of general importance is stated. "James W. O'Reilly" Judge FEDERAL COURT SOLICITORS OF RECORD DOCKET: IMM-3472-13 STYLE OF CAUSE: ABENA MANSA MONLOUIS v THE MINISTER OF CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION PLACE OF HEARING: Toronto, Ontario DATE OF HEARING: September 23, 2014 JUDGMENT AND REASONS: O'REILLY J.

DATED: January 8, 2015 APPEARANCES : Sina Ogunleye For The Applicant Ildikó Erdei For The Respondent SOLICITORS OF RECORD : Sina Ogunleye Barristers and Solicitors Toronto, Ontario For The Applicant William F. Pentney Deputy Attorney General of Canada Toronto, Ontario For The Respondent