Wang and Li v Alberta Health Services, 2023 ABKB 0083
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Wang and Li v Alberta Health Services, 2023 ABKB 0083 Date: 20230214 Docket: 1401 10235 Registry: Calgary Between: Xiaoli Lily Wang and Daiming Robert Li Applicants - and - Alberta Health Services Respondent Corrected judgment: A corrigendum was issued on February 28, 2023; the corrections have been made to the text and the corrigendum is appended to this judgment. _______________________________________________________ Reasons for Decision of the Honourable Justice Eleanor J.
Funk _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Since first releasing my reasons on February 14, 2023, Counsel for AHS has brought to my attention some additional information that was not previously in evidence before me. This information is in relation to the steps the Applicants took after
receiving the Statement of Proposed Distribution in November of 2022, addressed in paragraphs 28-35 of my original reasons. [ 2 ] With this updated information, and pursuant to Rule 9.13(a), I have revised and corrected that portion of my reasons. My final conclusions remain unchanged. Introduction [ 3 ] There is a long history of litigation between the Applicants and Alberta Heath Services (AHS), dating back to 2014.
In the course of this history, there have been a number of costs awards in favour of AHS. [ 4 ] This application involves a dispute over a Bill of Costs, for over $300,000 that resulted from a 2019 Costs Award and an Assessment Officer’s decision to uphold this Bill of Costs (the 2019 Costs Award). An appeal of the Assessment Officer’s decision was scheduled to take place in this Court in late November 2019 (the Bill of Costs Appeal).
That appeal date was cancelled when, two weeks before it was scheduled to be heard, the Applicants were the subject of an Interim Court Filing Restriction Order, issued by Associate Chief Justice Rooke, as he then was (the Interim Restriction Order). In 2020, ACJ Rooke vacated that Order.
Since then, the Applicants have taken no steps to restore or reschedule the Bill of Costs Appeal, until now. [ 5 ] The Applicants now bring this application in which they seek an Order allowing them to object to the distribution of funds; a stay of enforcement of the 2019 Costs Award; and that a Special Chambers hearing be set for the Bill of Costs Appeal. [ 6 ] The real issue before me is whether the Applicants have established a reason to now set aside or interfere with the enforcement of the 2019 Costs Award and to simply restore their appeal. In my view, they have not.
For the reasons below, the application is dismissed. Background [ 7 ] In the disputed 2019 Bill of Costs, the Applicants took issue with the fact that the Bill included costs associated with work done by 32 individuals, in a private law firm, identified only by their initials, without any description of the work that these individuals performed. The Applicants believe this is suspicious and improper and, at the hearing before an Assessment Officer, sought an unredacted Bill of Costs.
The Assessment Officer did not accede to this request. [ 8 ] The Applicants sought to appeal the decision of the Assessment Officer. To that end, a half day Special Chambers hearing was scheduled to take place in this Court in late November 2019 (the Bill of Costs Appeal). [ 9 ] Two weeks before the hearing date for the Bill of Costs Appeal, ACJ Rooke found a Statement of Claim filed by the Applicants was an Apparently Vexatious Application or Proceeding (AVAP).
As part of this finding, ACJ Rooke issued the Interim Restriction Order that, among other things, prohibited the Applicants from continuing with any applications, appeals or other proceedings in any Court in Alberta, without leave of the Court. The effect of this Order was that the Bill of Costs Appeal was cancelled. [ 10 ] The Applicants allege that AHS “unilaterally cancelled” the Bill of Costs Appeal and acted in violation of the Court Order that set the matter down for the hearing of that appeal in 2019.
The Court record clearly reflects that the QB Special Chambers Coordinator cancelled the Bill of Costs Appeal, pursuant to the Interim Restriction Order issued by ACJ Rooke. The Applicants’ continued allegations against AHS in this regard are simply not supported by the facts as revealed on the Court record. [ 11 ] In response to correspondence sent by the Applicants to ACJ Rooke, in November 2019, ACJ Rooke examined the Court file, including the Brief the Applicants had filed in support of the Bill of Costs Appeal.
He determined the Brief largely consisted of “re- hashing” previous grievances and was not relevant to the merits of the Assessment Officer’s decision: Wang v Alberta Health Services , 2019 ABQB 907 , at paras 2-6 . [ 12 ] ACJ Rooke acknowledged that his Interim Restriction Order prevented the Bill of Costs Appeal from proceeding. Based on his review of the Applicants’ Brief, he declined to grant leave for the appeal to proceed. Acknowledging the issue of the redacted Bill of Costs remained unsettled, he granted the Applicants leave to proceed to a hearing before him for advice and direction, under Rule 4.10.
At that hearing, and subject to its outcomes, the Court may grant leave for the appeal to proceed (the Bill of Costs Appeal Order): Wang , at para 14-16 . I have no evidence as to whether the Applicants ever appeared before ACJ Rooke for advice and directions. [ 13 ] Following the Alberta Court of Appeal decision of Jonsson v Lymer , 2020 ABCA 167 , ACJ Rooke vacated the Interim Restriction Order in 2020. Since then, the Applicants have taken no steps to restore or reschedule the Bill of Costs Appeal. [ 14 ] In 2022, AHS filed a Writ of Enforcement in relation to the 2019 Costs Award.
The enforcement of this Writ has resulted in funds being garnished directly from the Applicants’ bank accounts. In September 2022, the Applicants wrote to counsel for AHS and requested, among other things, an unredacted Bill of Costs and that AHS take no further steps to enforce the 2019 Costs Order until the dispute over the Bill of Costs was determined by the Court. In response, counsel for AHS indicated it would not provide an unredacted Bill of Costs and that its instructions were to continue the enforcement proceedings. [ 15 ] In early November 2022, the Accounting
Section of this Court sent to the Applicants a statement of proposed distribution of funds received into the Court pursuant to the Writ of Enforcement. Within this statement, the Applicants were advised that any objection to the proposed distribution must be filed with the Court in writing within 15 days, pursuant to s 101(1)(
b) of the Civil Enforcement Act . On the updated information I received, the Applicants filed a Notice of Objection in accordance with these provisions of the CEA . [ 16 ] The Applicants now bring this application. While they have not framed their application in terms of seeking leave to extend the time for their appeal, that is essentially the remedy they seek. They also seek an Order allowing them to object to the distribution of funds along with a stay of enforcement. [ 17 ] AHS takes the position that there is no reason to object to the distribution and that the Applicants are ‘out of time’ to appeal
the decision of the Assessment Officer. AHS suggests the proper course of action for the Applicants is to seek leave to extend the timefor the Bill of Costs Appeal and to seek a Stay of Enforcement of the Costs Award, pending any appeal. Law and Analysis Should a Special Chambers date be set for the Bill of Costs Appeal? [18] This application marks the first time, in more than two years, that the Applicants have taken any steps in relation to restoringthe Bill of Costs Appeal. [19] The test for extending time to file an appeal was established in Cairns v Cairns, (ABCA). Under this test,the Applicants must establish: (
a) There was a bona fide intention to appeal while the right to appeal existed; (
b) That there was an explanation for the delay including some special circumstance that would excuse or justify the delay; (
c) That the other party was not so prejudiced by the delay that allowing an appeal would create injustice; (
d) That the applicant has not benefitted from the judgment being appealed from; and (
e) That the appeal would have a reasonable chance of success if allowed to proceed. [20] While I am not deciding here whether leave to extend the time for the appeal should be granted, or not, the factors articulatedin this test inform my decision in relation to the request to set a Special Chambers hearing. [21] When I consider this request, I cannot ignore that I have no evidence of the Applicants having a bona fide intention to pursuethe Bill of Costs Appeal in 2020, after ACJ Rooke vacated the Interim Restriction Order.
I have no explanation for the Applicants’ delayfrom 2020 to now in bringing this application. And, while I have not reviewed any materials in relation to the merits of the appeal, I noteACJ Rooke’s comments in relation to its merits, as stated in Wang, at paragraphs 2-6. [22] Against this background, I am not persuaded that it is appropriate now to simply set a new Special Chambers date.
Instead, ifthe Applicants wish to continue with the Bill of Costs Appeal, they should first bring an application seeking leave to extend the time forthat appeal, keeping in mind the appropriate legal test for extending that time. [23] For these reasons, the Applicants’ request for a Special Chambers hearing is denied. Should there be a stay of enforcement pending the Bill of Costs Appeal? [24] The legal test for granting a stay pending appeal is set out in RJR-MacDonald Inc v Canada (Attorney General), (SCC). The Applicant has the burden of showing that
i) there is a serious question to be tried, meaning there in an arguableissue that is not frivolous or vexatious; ii) there will be irreparable harm if the stay is not granted; and iii) the balance of conveniencefavours granting a stay: Gould v Gould, 2022 ABCA 204 at para 8. [25] On the first branch of this test, while the Applicants sincerely believe the issues in the Bill of Costs Appeal are arguable, I ammindful of ACJ Rooke’s comments, noted above, in which he refused to grant leave for the appeal to proceed based on the material theApplicants had filed in in 2019.
It does not appear that the Applicants have raised any new arguments here in relation to the merits of theappeal. [26] On the second branch, the Applicants have not raised any issue in relation to there being irreparable harm if the stay were notgranted.
Presumably, if the Applicants were successful at any future Bill of Costs Appeal, any financial harm they suffer now throughcontinued enforcement of the 2019 Costs Order could be compensated later. [27] Finally, the Applicants have not demonstrated that the balance of convenience favours granting a stay of enforcement.Because they have taken no steps to advance the appeal in more than two years, the Applicants must now seek leave to extend the timefor that appeal, and they must satisfy the test for extending that time.
I am not satisfied that the balance of convenience weighs in favourof keeping in abeyance the enforcement of the 2019 Costs Award while the future of the Bill of Costs Appeal is so uncertain. [28] The Applicants have not satisfied me, on any of the three branches of the test, that a stay of enforcement should be granted.For these reasons, their application for a stay is dismissed. [29] Should the Applicants choose to seek leave to extend the time for the appeal, they may renew their application for a stay ofenforcement at that time, keeping in mind the legal test for granting a stay.
Should the Applicants be allowed to object to the distribution of funds? [30] The procedure for objecting to the distribution of funds is set out in the Civil Enforcement Act. [31] Section 101(1)(
a) of the CEA states that a distributing authority must serve a statement setting out the proposed distributionon the enforcement debtor and creditor who have writs at the time the statement is given. On the evidence before me, the Applicantswere served with a statement of proposed distribution in November of 2022. [32] Under subsection (b), if a person wishes to object to the proposed distribution, that person must serve the distributingauthority with a written notice of the objection within 15 days from the date of being served with the statement. On the updatedinformation I received, the Applicants filed a Notice of Objection within this 15-day period.
[ 33 ] Subsection (
c) provides that if no objection is filed, or if an objection is withdrawn, the statement of distribution is final and conclusive among all parties and the distributing authority must distribute the funds in accordance with the statement. [ 34 ] Under subsections (
d) and (e), a person who makes an objection must, within 15 days from the date of serving the notice of objection, file and serve an application returnable in court within 30 days, for an order determining the matter in respect of which the objection was made.
On the updated information, the Applicants did file and serve an application within this 15-day period. [ 35 ] Where an objection is made, the distributing authority must distribute in accordance with the proposed distribution as much of the funds as will not prejudice the effect of the objection if the objection is upheld by the court. [ 36 ] In their Notice of Objection, the Applicants continue to register their disapproval in relation to the redacted Bill of Costs and continue to allege that AHS “unilaterally cancelled” the Bill of Costs Appeal in 2019.
They request the funds not be distributed until these disputes can be resolved in Court. [ 37 ] In other words, in objecting to the proposed distribution of funds, the Applicants make the same arguments they made in support of their application for a stay of enforcement pending appeal. I have already dismissed that application on all three branches of the RJR-MacDonald test. Where the Applicants have not satisfied the legal requirements for a stay of enforcement, I am not persuaded that a stay should effectively be granted through these provisions of the Civil Enforcement Act .
For these reasons, this part of the application is also dismissed. Conclusion [ 38 ] As stated, I am not satisfied the Bill of Costs Appeal should now simply be set down to a Special Chambers hearing. Nor am I satisfied, on any branch of the test, that a stay of enforcement is appropriate at this time. Finally, I am not satisfied that the distribution of the funds should be put on hold through the mechanisms provided in the Civil Enforcement Act pending the outcome of any future Bill of Costs Appeal. For these reasons, the application is dismissed. [ 39 ] The Applicants are self-represented litigants, “SRLs”.
The Supreme Court of Canada in Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 , set instructions to judges concerning their interactions with SRLs. Mindful of that instruction from the Supreme Court, I provide the following information in response to the Applicants current application: 1. Should the Applicants choose to pursue the Bill of Costs Appeal, they must first seek leave of this Court to extend the time for that appeal. The test for that application has been set out in these reasons (paragraph 19, above); 2.
Should the Applicants bring an application to extend the time for the Bill of Costs Appeal, they may renew at that time their application for a stay of enforcement, pending appeal, in the event their application to renew their appeal is granted. The test for granting a stay of enforcement is set out in paragraph 24 of these reasons. [ 40 ] The parties may address me on the issue of costs by written submission, of no more than three (3) pages, within 30 days of the receipt of these reasons. Heard on the 30 th day of January, 2023. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 14 th day of February, 2023. “E.J.
Funk” E.J. Funk J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Xiaoli Wang and Daiming Li for the Applicants Stephen Torscher for the Respondent
_______________________________________________________ Corrigendum of the Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Eleanor J. Funk _______________________________________________________ On Page 1, new paragraph #[1] added and reads: [1] “Since first releasing my reasons on February 14, 2023, Counsel for AHS has brought to my attention some additional information that was not previously in evidence before me.
This information is in relation to the steps the Applicants took after receiving the Statement of Proposed Distribution in November of 2022, addressed in paragraphs 28-35 of my original reasons.” Page 2, new paragraph #[2] added and reads: [2] “With this updated information, and pursuant to Rule 9.13(a), I have revised and corrected that portion of my reasons. My final conclusions remain unchanged.” On Page 3: • Paragraph 15 (formerly paragraph 13), the last sentence now reads: o On the updated information I received, the Applicants filed a Notice of Objection in accordance with these provisions of the CEA .
On Page 5: • Paragraph 32 (formerly paragraph 30), the last sentence is changed to read: o On the updated information I received, the Applicants filed a Notice of Objection within this 15-day period. • Paragraph 34 (formerly paragraph 32).
Additional sentence added at the end of the paragraph: o “On the updated information, the Applicants did file and serve an application within this 15-day period.” • Paragraph 36 (formerly paragraph 34), has been changed to read: o “In their Notice of Objection, the Applicants continue to register their disapproval in relation to the redacted Bill of Costs and continue to allege that AHS “unilaterally cancelled” the Bill of Costs Appeal in 2019.
They request the funds not be distributed until these disputes can be resolved in Court.” • Paragraph 37 (formerly paragraph 35) has been changed to read: o “In other words, in objecting to the proposed distribution of funds, the Applicants make the same arguments they made in support of their application for a stay of enforcement pending appeal. I have already dismissed that application on all three branches of the RJR- MacDonald test.
Where the Applicants have not satisfied the legal requirements for a stay of enforcement, I am not persuaded that a stay should effectively be granted through these provisions of the Civil Enforcement Act . For these reasons, this part of the application is also dismissed.” On Page 6: • Paragraph 38 (formerly paragraph 36) has been changed to read: o “ As stated, I am not satisfied the Bill of Costs Appeal should now simply be set down to a Special Chambers hearing. Nor am I satisfied, on any branch of the test, that a stay of enforcement is appropriate at this time.
Finally, I am not satisfied that the distribution of the funds should be put on hold through the mechanisms provided in the Civil Enforcement Act pending the outcome of any future Bill of Costs Appeal. For these reasons, the application is dismissed. ” • Paragraph 39 (formerly paragraph 37), the following changes have been made: o Numbered paragraph 1, last sentence: “ (paragraph 17, above)” now reads “(paragraph 19, above)”. o Numbered paragraph 2, last sentence: “ is set out in paragraph 22” now reads “is set out in paragraph 24”.
Loading document…