Couch v Olatiregun, 2023 ABKB 104
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Couch v Olatiregun, 2023 ABKB 104 Date: 20230224 Docket: 1801 07070 Registry: Calgary Between: Terence Gerrard Couch Plaintiff - and - Gabriel Kehinde Olatiregun Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice W.P. Sullivan _______________________________________________________ Introduction [ 1 ] The plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries caused by a motor vehicle accident. At the time of the accident both parties resided at Calgary. [ 2 ] The allegations are straightforward.
On the 13 th of April, 2017 at about 9:05 p.m. the plaintiff was driving his 2011 Ford automobile in a northerly direction on 19 th Street N.E. in Calgary at the intersection with Airport Trail N.E. Both parties were in the left turning lane when the advance to proceed signal at the intersection turned to a flashing green to indicate a safe left hand turn motion for
the vehicles in that turning lane. The plaintiff proceeded but stopped after advancing when the light indicating a safe left turn, turned amber. At that time he was struck in the rear of his vehicle by the defendant’s motor vehicle owned and driven by Mr. Olatiregun. [ 3 ] The plaintiff alleges negligence on the part of the defendant and particularizes that negligence at some length. [ 4 ] The defendant, unrepresented, alleges in his statement of defence as follows: I was behind the plaintiff at the stop sign by 19 th Street NE and Airport Trial NE going from 19 th Street by the airport.
When the arrow turned green, [indicating the advancing green light] all cars started making the left turn; he [plaintiff] made a sudden stop because the light turned amber without any car on the other side of the street proceeding southbound. [ 5 ] The defendant goes on in para 3 of his statement of defence to allege “there was no physical damage to his car and mine had a minor damage from the plastic grill”.
The defendant denies liability for the accident. [ 6 ] The defendant notwithstanding knowledge of the time and date set for trial of this action failed to attend in person or by agent. [ 7 ] On a review of the evidence I have found that the defendant is liable and that he is responsible for the motor vehicle accident, notwithstanding the abrupt stop of the plaintiff’s motor vehicle. [ 8 ] As a result of the motor vehicle accident the plaintiff claims that on impact he was bounced back in the seat of his motor vehicle; that the back of his head hit the head rest for his position and then his head rebounded forward rapidly when he pressed on the brakes.
He was wearing a standard seatbelt and shoulder belt. The air bag was not activated. He claims whiplash plus two ribs were injured. Issue [ 9 ] Having found that the defendant is liable for the action and there being no claim for loss of income or personal property damage the only issue as alleged in the statement of claim is for personal injury and for some disbursement costs as a result thereof. [ 10 ] The plaintiff is 59 years of age and at the time of the accident was 53. He is married and the father of three. At the time of the accident his three children resided at home with him.
There are now only three living in the home, the plaintiff, his wife and one daughter. The two older girls have moved away from the family home. The plaintiff while testifying indicated that he suffered neck and upper back stiffness as a result of this injury, the stiffness moving into his shoulders; that his neck was extremely sore and that as a result of this accident he suffered headaches and had difficulty lifting. He said “this accident slowed me down”. He indicated some unspecified mid back damage on the right to his ribs in the spine area.
The headaches were low level with dull pain occurring intermittently two or three times a week, around the top of his head in the hat band area. He said the pain was from a 6 to an 8 out of 10 on a scale of 1-10 for pain and he had to take extra strength Tylenol to ease the pain. He indicated that it was 10 weeks before he was comfortable at work. The headaches occurred up until December of 2017. He does not have any headaches now. He indicated at one point that prior to this accident he would have intermittent neck pain, which was a 2 or 3 out of 10.
One year after the accident he was back to normal. [ 11 ] With respect to his ribs he said that he had an “odd feeling” at the time of the accident and that it was “extremely painful”. He said that his ability to lift was so seriously impacted that he had difficulty carrying groceries.
He was not able to carry his camera bag and that walking the dogs would be difficult for him as they would pull on their leash. [ 12 ] With respect to housekeeping he indicated that he had shared all duties in the home, including laundry, dishes and bedmaking and that overall he would spend 3 to 3 ½ hours a week working in the home as his share of duties with the other four members of his family in residence. [ 13 ] He claims fuel for going to and from his chiropractor, Dr. Woo, whose office is 22 kilometres away from his residence, three or four times a week.
He also makes a claim for painkillers as well as a claim for $250 for hiring a low trailer with a van to move his daughter back from Lethbridge to Calgary when she finished her college year in 2017, although he admitted that his car insurance had paid for some of this cost. [ 14 ] The only witness in this case to give testimony in court was the plaintiff.
The plaintiff however, submitted a detailed medical history going back many years and an Alberta Collision Report Form containing the following information; that the severity of the collision was identified as property damage only; that there were two vehicles involved in the accident identified; that there were no persons injured and that the scene was not visited by Calgary City Police Service. It was identified as a rear end motor vehicle accident. [ 15 ] On attendance at the chiropractor, Dr.
Woo, whose treatment reports are all included and admitted in evidence, her diagnosis of the injury to the plaintiff was a WAD 2. Dr. Woo found the plaintiff had decreased range of motion in his neck and had “point tenderness” in his neck and mid back. She also noted that, regarding his ribs, there was some “joint play”. She identified that she expected that the number of visits that he would require to her would be 21, but this was dependant upon how he would respond to her treatments. In her concluding report to the initial analysis of Mr. Couch on the 17 th of April, 2017 Dr.
Woo indicated that he should, “continue with chiro two times a week for four to eight weeks”, receive some acupuncture treatments and that he continue with stretching and strengthening of his muscles. In a further concluding report to the insurer on August 10 th , 2017 Dr. Woo noted that Mr. Couch had improved, that he should continue with chiropractic for another four to six weeks, twice a week; that he should continue with massage for two weeks and continue with his exercises and stretching. She noted that he was working full time. Mr.
Couch had no work or training restrictions and that he had returned to a pre accident level of activity outside work. He was not referred to any other health care provider and that he had partial recovery as of that date. By October 17, 2017 Dr. Woo indicated that he should continue with his stretches and exercises and that he had improved moderately. By the 30 th of January, 2018 she was recommending continued massage
and acupuncture and chiropractic care. The History of Some of Mr. Couch’s Medical Claims [ 16 ] On September 15 th , 2014 Mr. Couch, on the recommendation of Dr. Cindy Woo, underwent an elbow ultrasound on his left arm which demonstrated no abnormalities. On July 11, 2017 he had an ankle x-ray on his right leg which demonstrated a normal response on examination. [ 17 ] Prior to the accident on April 17, 2017 Mr. Couch had repeatedly attended on Dr. Woo for chiropractic care. Ten visits in 2016, 17 visits in 2015, 28 in 2014, 36 visits in 2013, 39 visits in 2012 and numerous more visits prior to that date.
He was examined on his right elbow at EFW Radiology on July 26, 2006 for elbow joint effusion and no deformity was identified. On the 27 th of January, 2006 he was sent for radiology examination at the same clinic with respect to a knee problem and there was no known problem identified as a result of the examination. [ 18 ] In 2015 he received massage and/or acupuncture treatments for pain in his upper back and neck and pain in his left calf after lots of walking. On May 10, 2016 he had pain in his quads and low and mid back and received treatment.
In December of 2012 he received treatment for upper shoulders, neck and the fact that his work was stressful. He had low back pain in his erector muscles. In July of 2013 the pain was as usual in his upper shoulders and neck and in his right leg. Massage was used for his back and leg treatment. In August of 2012 he had full body deep pressure treatments. In October of that year he also had tight lower back and shoulders. Also with respect to his erector muscles in the thoracic area. [ 19 ] On an appointment date of the 29 th of March, 2019 Dr. Woo reports that overall the subject is pretty good. [ 20 ] Mr.
Couch works at the airport for Garda Security and checks passengers going through the security check prior to entering into the lounge for boarding on aircraft. Does the Minor Injury Regulation (MIR) Cap Limit the Recovery of Mr. Couch for General Damages for Pain and Suffering and Loss of Enjoyment of Life? [ 21 ] Yes. [ 22 ] Mr. Justice Kraus dealt with this issue at length in Jackson v Cooper , 2022 ABKB 609 :
(44) As the accident occurred in 2015, the version of the MIR that was in force on that date governs. With that in mind, the MIR defines a minor injury as follows: “minor injury”, in respect of an accident, means (
i) a sprain, (ii) a strain, or (iii) a WAD injury caused by that accident that does not result in a serious impairment; (s 1(1)(h)).
(45) As this definition suggests, to determine whether an injury is minor requires a determination of whether an injury is a sprain, strain, or WAD injury and, then, whether the injury results in a serious impairment: MIR, s 4(1).
In other words, an individual who is diagnosed with a sprain, strain, or WAD I/II injury may fall outside the MIR cap if their injury results in “serious impairment” of their physical or cognitive function. [46] Sprain, strain, and WAD injury are all defined terms under the MIR: “sprain” means an injury to one or more tendons or ligaments, or to both; “strain” means an injury to one or more muscles; “WAD injury” means a whiplash-associated disorder other than one that exhibits one or both of the following: objective, demonstrable, definable and clinically relevant neurological signs; a fracture to or a dislocation of the spine. (ss 1(1)(k), (l), n)). [47] Under the MIR, the determination of whether an injury is a sprain, strain, or WAD injury must be based on an individual
assessment of the claimant in accordance with the diagnostic protocols established under the Diagnostic and Treatment Protocols Regulation: s 4(2). [48] The term “serious impairment” is defined under section 1(1)(
j) of the MIR: “serious impairment”, in respect of a claimant, means an impairment of a physical or cognitive function (
i) that results in a substantial inability to perform the (
A) essential tasks of the claimant’s regular employment, occupation or profession, despite reasonable efforts to accommodate the claimant’s impairment and the claimant’s reasonable efforts to use the accommodation to allow the claimant to continue the claimant’s employment, occupation or profession, (
B) essential tasks of the claimant’s training or education … , or (
C) normal activities of the claimant’s daily living, (ii) that has been ongoing since the accident, and (iii) that is expected not to improve substantially; [49] Under the MIR, the determination of whether a sprain, strain or WAD injury results in a serious impairment must take into account the claimant’s pre-existing medical history and the matters listed in s 1(j)(
i) that relate to the claimant: s 4(3). Moreover, the sprain, strain, or WAD injury must be the primary factor contributing to an impairment for the injury to result in a serious impairment: MIR, s 3. [ 23 ] There is no chronic pain issue in this case.
It is clear that he has not suffered a serious impairment and that he had ongoing and pre existing medical history relevant to and consistent with his post accident treatment modality. [ 24 ] With respect to Justice Shelley’s analysis in Sparrowhawk v Zapoltinsky , 2012 ABQB 34 , I find that there is no physical or cognitive function impairment, that the sprain, strain or WAD injury was a primary factor for a minor injury of limited duration as a result of the motor vehicle accident.
The impairment did not cause substantial inability, in fact did not cause any inability to perform essential work tasks, essential facets of training or education, or normal activities of the plaintiff’s daily living. With some minor exception the impairment has terminated. In all it is important to note that his training at work and his work was not impaired as a result of this accident. His employment required minimal physical activity, generally sitting and observing computer screens for x-ray analysis of carry-on baggage. Some minor pre accident household chores were impacted, but minimally.
There does not appear to be much in terms of sporting or leisure activity that was interrupted, nor were physical relations with his wife, nor caring for or playing with his children, although there appears to be some minor inconvenience with respect to walking his dogs. [ 25 ] Therefore, I find that Mr. Couch has suffered a minimal inability and has not suffered any whole person impairment. I find that there has been an injury within the WAD 1 level and that the MIR does capture Mr. Couch’s claim for general damages for pain suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. I fix that amount at $3,000.
I am not in a position to be able to substantiate for loss of housekeeping. There does not appear to be any evidence of any quantifiable loss to him or the members of his family in residence with him. [ 26 ] I do find that there were some special damages with respect to travel to and from his chiropractic clinic and there were 76 visits at .50 per kilometre I fix that at $1,672. I am not satisfied that the claim to move his daughter back to Calgary can be justified and associated or attributed to the motor vehicle accident.
I award him $50.00 for painkillers. [ 27 ] Costs may be addressed in writing not to exceed five (5) pages within thirty (30) days. Heard on the 16 th day of January, 2023. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 24 th day of February, 2023. W.P. Sullivan J.C.K.B.A.
Appearances: C.R. Suntjens for the Plaintiff No One Appeared for the Self-Represented Litigant
Loading document…