Ubah v Ubah, 2023 ABKB 111
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Ubah v Ubah, 2023 ABKB 111 Date: 20230227 Dockets: FL01 37992; 4801 194949 Registry: Calgary Between: Chinedu Gideon Ubah Proposed Plaintiff/Applicant - and - Geraldine Chiderah Ubah Proposed Defendant/Respondent _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ I. Introduction [ 1 ] My office was referred a package of documents received by registered mail from Chinedu Gideon Ubah (Mr. Ubah). The cover letter, dated January 16, 2023, indicates Mr.
Ubah seeks permission of the Court - “leave” - to file a proposed Application titled “Application by CHINEDU GIDEON UBAH (Applicant)” (proposed Application). The remedies sought in the proposed Application are: 1. A Declaration pursuant to s 52 of The Constitution Act, 1982,
Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11 , that the November 28, 2022 decision/order (Access restriction Order) of this Court in this file infringes s 7, 12, 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
Part 1 of The Constitution Act, 1982 , and that the
section is incapable of being saved pursuant to s 1 of the
Charter . 2. A Declaration pursuant to s 52 of The Constitution Act, 1982,
Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11 , that the November 14, 2022 decision/order - (Supplementary Order) of this Court in this file infringes s 7, 12, 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
Part 1 of The Constitution Act, 1982 , and that the
section is incapable of being saved pursuant to s 1 of the Charter . 3. A Declaration pursuant to s 52 of The Constitution Act, 1982,
Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11 , that the August 09, 2022 decision/order - (Contempt Order) of this Court in this file infringes s 7, 12, 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
Part 1 of The Constitution Act, 1982 , and that the
section is incapable of being saved pursuant to s 1 of the Charter . 4. A declaration that a court inherent motion or resulting decision/order thereof that is conflict with the Judicature Act unauthorized or invalid. 5. A declaration that a vexatious order issued without notice to the Alberta Minister of Justice and Solicitor General is invalid and unconstitutional and Rule 14.5j(4) does not apply (Sic.) [ 2 ] Mr. Ubah in his cover letter indicated he chose to not include an affidavit and written submissions, but, despite that statement, Mr.
Ubah’s materials were accompanied by an “AFFIDAVIT OF CHINEDU GIDEON UBAH”, dated January 17, 2023. [ 3 ] Mr. Ubah is an abusive litigant active in the Alberta and Federal Courts, which has led to Mr. Ubah being declared a vexatious litigant in both jurisdictions: Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2019 ABQB 692 at para 183 , leave to appeal denied in
part 2020 ABCA 209 , court access restrictions varied in
part 2021 ABCA 5 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 39757 (13 January 2021) ( Ubah #4 ); Canada (Attorney General) v Ubah , 2021 FC 1466 , aff’d 2023 FCA 26 . Recently, Mr. Ubah’s court access restrictions before the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta were updated and revised in two Memorandums of Decision reported as Ubah v Ubah , 2022 ABKB 753 ( Ubah #16 ) and Ubah v Ubah , 2022 ABKB 789 ( Ubah #17 ). [ 4 ] While not obvious from the language of the proposed Application, the proposed Application is designated to be filed in a high conflict family law dispute between Mr.
Ubah and his spouse, Geraldine Chiderah Ubah. Those family law subject proceedings are under Case Management by Justice Kuchar: Ubah #16 at paras 27-36. The usual practice of this Court is that when a person subject to court access restrictions seeks leave to file an application or proceeding, and that process is part of, or involves, a case managed proceeding, then the leave to file application is delegated to the Case Management Justice. However, on close examination of Mr.
Ubah’s materials, I have concluded these do not, actually, relate to the family subject dispute between the Ubahs, but, instead, to general court-imposed litigation and litigant management steps that applied to Mr. Ubah in all his Court of King’s Bench of Alberta processes, as those steps have evolved since 2018 in response to Mr. Ubah’s persistent and repeated pattern of abusive behaviour and litigation misconduct. Given that, as an Administrative Justice for the Court, I have decided that I will determine how to respond to the proposed Application. II.
Test for Leave to File [ 5 ] “... [A] person subject to court access control is presumed to engage in illegitimate litigation unless the Court is satisfied otherwise. ...”: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at para 19 , aff’d 2018 ABCA 111 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38204 (14 February 2019). [ 6 ] Permission to initiate litigation or continue stayed litigation both test the merit of court activities on the same standard.
A person subject to court access restrictions must: 1) establish reasonable grounds for the litigation; and 2) depose fully and completely as to the facts and circumstances surrounding the proposed claim or proceeding. ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 27; VWW v Wasylyshen , 2013 ABQB 327 at para 42 , aff’d 2014 ABCA 121 .) [ 7 ] This threshold, which must be established on a balance of probabilities, is not a high one, and, in many ways, parallels the test for
Summary Judgment: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 26.
The person subject to court access leave restrictions is expected to put his or her “best foot forward” to establish the basis to initiate or continue an action: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 26-27. [ 8 ] The documents necessary to seek leave are an affidavit to provide evidence, and, in the case of a new Action, Application, or other litigation step, a copy of the proposed initiating filing: e.g., Re Moore , 2018 ABQB 261 ; Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 . [ 9 ] Leave may be granted in part: Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 ; Belway v Lalande-Weber , 2017 ABCA 108 at para 10 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 37708 (21 December 2017). [ 10 ] Leave submissions to initiate or continue litigation may also be rejected: 1) where the materials do not satisfy the criteria set out in the court access restriction order ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38267 (31 January 2019); Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38266 (31 January 2019); Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta v Drover , 2021 ABQB 511 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 );
2) if the submissions exhibit indicia of abusive litigation ( ET v Calgary Catholic School District No 1 , 2017 ABCA 349 at para 12 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38081 (8 November 2018); Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Trinity Place Foundation of Alberta v Templanza , 2019 ABQB 45 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Fletcher v Davidson & Williams LLP , 2019 ABQB 396 ; Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2021 ABQB 208 ; Knutson (Re) , 2021 ABQB 367 ; McMunn v Hok , 2021 ABQB 550 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 79 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 97 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Fiset v Feeney , 2022 ABQB 211 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 498 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 3) where the abusive litigant refuses to provide the proposed filing ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); 4) where the abusive litigant provides false information or fails to provide necessary information ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 5) where the abusive litigant fails to provide materials that are required to evaluate the proposed litigation step, such as a transcript of a proceeding proposed for appeal ( Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); and 6) where the Court has no jurisdiction over the matter ( Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ). [ 11 ] There is no appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta of a decision to deny leave: r 14.5(4) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 ; Re Gauthier , 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8 .
A litigant who is denied leave by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta may, however, seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. III. Analysis [ 12 ] While the remedies in the proposed Application are somewhat obscure, several points are clear. First, the proposed Application is based on alleged breaches of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms ( The Constitution Act , 1982,
Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK) , 1982, c 11 ( Charter ). Second, what Mr. Ubah appears to chiefly challenge are three of this Court’s Decisions: 1) “August 09, 2022 decision/order” is Ubah v Ubah , 2022 ABQB 534 ( Ubah #15 ); 2) “November 14, 2022 decision/order” is Ubah #16 ; and 3) “November 28, 2022 decision/order” is Ubah #17 . [ 13 ] Third, the proposed Application paragraph 4 remedy is not a comprehensible sentence, so I will not evaluate that paragraph further. The declaration identified in paragraph 5 of the proposed Application will be addressed below in
part III(
B) as a question of jurisdiction. [ 14 ] I conclude Mr. Ubah’s leave to file Application should be rejected on multiple independent grounds. A. Collateral Attack / No Jurisdiction [ 15 ] First, two fatal defects co-exist in Mr. Ubah’s proposed litigation. All three of the judgments ( Ubah #15, Ubah #16 and Ubah #17 ) targeted in the proposed Application have already been appealed by Mr. Ubah to the Court of Appeal of Alberta: Ubah v Ubah , 2022 ABCA 329 - Antonio JA refused Mr.
Ubah permission to appeal Ubah #15 , including Charter -based remedies, and concluded at paras 9-11: ... the applicant disputes the validity of the vexatious litigant order and that provides the springboard for many of his other arguments. The applicant’s vexatious litigant order was subject to appeal and largely upheld: Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2021 ABCA 5 . Any enforcement of this order against the applicant is not illegal or biased. ... The applicant has not satisfied me that permission is warranted.
His arguments are premised on the frailties of old orders, which are not before me and for which the appeal period has long expired. ... He disputes findings of fact that attract deference from the Court of Appeal. There is little prospect that this Court will interfere with the chambers judge’s assessment of the facts and circumstances. While the applicant cites legal principles, he has done little to explain how they have been misapplied in the granting of these orders. Any potential issue of law would have a meager chance of success on appeal and would not be of general importance. ...
Ubah v Ubah , 2023 ABCA 15 - Ho JA refused Mr. Ubah permission to appeal Ubah #16 and Ubah #17 , including claims of infringement on Mr. Ubah’s Charter rights, concluding at paras 16-22: ... I am not satisfied that the applicant has met the test for permission to appeal because I am not satisfied that he has a reasonable chance of success on the appeal given the standard of review, and there are no important questions of law or precedent posed. ... ... the applicant’s attempt to obtain permission to appeal may be viewed as an attempt to re-litigate issues already determined. ...
... the applicant submits that procedural fairness was breached because he was never given an opportunity to respond ... there was noneed for a reply because the applicant’s requested relief was granted. ... ... it is highly unlikely that this Court would interfere with the ACJ’s exercise of discretion in appointing a CMJ to preside over theapplicant’s family law proceedings ... it was appropriate for the ACJ to issue the November 14, 2022 Order to account for the family lawproceedings especially given the importance of parenting issues that need to be determined. ... ...
I also do not accept that the application for permission to appeal raises important issues of law or precedent warranting appellatereview. Although the applicant cites general principles of natural justice and procedural fairness, the application of those principles turnson the specific facts and circumstances of this case, which the ACJ had familiarity with. His findings of fact would be treated withdeference on appeal. [16] The grounds of appeal in these two Court of Appeal of Alberta Reasons for Decision are broadly the same as those in Mr.Ubah’s January 17, 2023 Affidavit.
The Court of Appeal of Alberta considered and rejected Charter-based remedies in these twoappeals. [17] Thus, the proposed Application is a collateral attack on decisions of this Court that Mr. Ubah unsuccessfully sought to appealto a superior Court. This Court is bound by the Reasons for Decision of Justices Antonio and Ho. Re-litigation is an abuse of the Court,and a basis to dismiss litigation. Here, that is occurring two-fold: 1) with respect to Ubah #15, Ubah #16 and Ubah #17, and 2) thesubsequent Court of Appeal of Alberta Reasons for Decision. That is the first independent ground on which I reject Mr.
Ubah’s leave tofile Application. [18] Second, this Court simply has no jurisdiction to review its own decisions, particularly where those have had appeals dismissedby the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Res judicata blocks Mr. Ubah’s proposed litigation. Mr. Ubah does not appear to have initiatedSupreme Court of Canada proceedings following the two decisions of the Court of Appeal of Alberta. If Mr. Ubah has a remedy, that iswith the Supreme Court of Canada. That is a second independent basis on which I reject Mr. Ubah’s leave to file Application. B.
No Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Jurisdiction [19] Paragraph 5 of Mr. Ubah’s proposed Application is difficult to understand: A declaration that a vexatious order issued without notice to the Alberta Minister of Justice and Solicitor General is invalid andunconstitutional and Rule 14.5j(4) does not apply What is clear is that Mr. Ubah is seeking that this Court evaluate “Rule 14.5j(4)” of the Alberta Rules of Court. First, there is no suchrule. There is a r 14.5(1)j, and a r 14.5(4), so what Mr.
Ubah is targeting is unclear. [20] Beyond that, r 14.5 is located in “Part 14” “Appeals”, of the Alberta Rules of Court.
Part 14 of the Alberta Rules of Court arethe provisions that regulate conduct of litigation and operations at the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Rule 14.5 of the Alberta Rules ofCourt is a provision of the Alberta Rules of Court that is never applied by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. What Mr. Ubah istherefore seeking, in the proposed Application, is that this Court interpret the constitutionality and/or operation of legislation that is onlyapplied by a higher, superior court. If the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta were to interpret a component of
Part 14 of the Alberta Rulesof Court, that would have the strange result of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta purporting to interpret legislation so as to bind theoperation and procedures a higher, superior Court. [21] Furthermore, if this Court were to decide that paragraph 5 of the proposed Application is not a basis for a potentially validCharter challenge, and then denied leave, the result is that Mr.
Ubah could not appeal that conclusion to the Court that would apply therule in question: Re Gauthier, 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8. [22] I conclude in these specific circumstances that this Court should not take jurisdiction over the proposed litigation captured inparagraph 5 of the proposed Application. If Mr. Ubah seeks to pursue this component of his proposed litigation, he should do so beforethe Court of Appeal of Alberta. C. Inadequate Pleadings [23] To the extent that the proposed Application can be evaluated, he appears to allege breaches of Charter ss 7, 12 and 15(1).
TheSupreme Court of Canada, in Mackay v Manitoba, (SCC), [1989] 2 SCR 357, 61 DLR (4th) 485, instructed that afactual foundation, or an alleged factual foundation, is an absolute requirement for pleadings that seek potential relief pursuant to theCharter. [24] Mr. Ubah provides no facts or alleged facts at all in support of his claims.
Pleadings must provide a basis for the Court andother litigants to make a meaningful response, and indicate to the responding parties the “... who, when, where, how and what gave riseto its liability.”: Mancuso v Canada (National Health and Welfare), 2015 FCA 227 at paras 16-20. [25] For example, Mr.
Ubah appears to indicate he was in some manner discriminated against, because he invokes Charter s 15(1): 15(1) Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law withoutdiscrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental orphysical disability. However, nowhere in Mr. Ubah’s materials is there any allegation or explanation of how he was discriminated against, in breach ofCharter s 15(1).
In fact, his materials never even use the words “discrimination” or “discriminate”, anywhere.
[ 26 ] This defect is a third separate basis on which I reject Mr. Ubah’s leave to file Application as hopeless and abusive litigation. Mr. Ubah has not satisfied the absolute pleadings requirement set in Mackay v Manitoba for a valid Charter -based action. D. Inapplicable Processes [ 27 ] Mr. Ubah seeks “Declarations pursuant to s 52 of the ( Charter ) ...” that three Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Memorandums of Decision “... infringe ...” the Charter , and “... that the
section is uncapable of being saved pursuant to s 1 of the Charter .” That language is what is used to allege that legislation enacted by Parliament, the provincial Legislatures, and other Canadian governments, breaches the Constitution of Canada. But what Mr. Ubah is challenging is not legislation, but Memorandums of Decision of this Court. In law, those are entirely separate things. [ 28 ] That makes the proposed Application a kind of procedural non sequitur. If Mr. Ubah concluded that Ubah #15, Ubah #16 and Ubah #17 were in breach of his Charter rights, in some undefined and unspecified manner, then Mr.
Ubah’s remedy was an appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta. That is exactly what happened, and Mr. Ubah’s Charter -based allegations were rejected. [ 29 ] I conclude that the proposed Application is inconsistent and inapplicable with the processes he appears to be attempting to conduct. That is a fourth independent basis on which I reject Mr. Ubah’s leave to file Application. Mr. Ubah is not exercising rights known in Canadian law. IV. Conclusion [ 30 ] Aside from the remedy indicated in paragraph 5 of the proposed Application, Mr. Ubah’s leave to file Application is rejected.
This Court refuses to take jurisdiction over the proposed litigation indicated in paragraph 5 of the proposed Application. [ 31 ] As noted above, and pursuant to my obligations to provide information to self-represented persons ( Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 ), concerning their litigation options, if Mr. Ubah disagrees with this Memordum of Decision, then his remedies are to: 1) seek leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of Canada, and/or 2) pursue the constitutional issue(
s) captured in paragraph 5 of the proposed Application before the Court of Appeal of Alberta. [ 32 ] Associate Chief Justice Rooke in Ubah #16 at paras 13-18 reviewed Mr. Ubah’s litigation record. Associate Chief Justice Rooke observed: “... To date, Mr. Ubah has conducted himself as a no-holds barred, dirty-tricks, always combative litigant, for whom the rules are optional, unless it is him who chooses to impose them. ...”: Ubah #15 at para 38. Those conclusions are amply supported by Mr. Ubah’s past and current litigation, and have been repeatedly affirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Mr.
Ubah badly needs professional legal assistance and advice. Despite him being repeatedly instructed and cautioned on the correct lawful approach to his litigation, Mr. Ubah has not followed the instructions of Canadian Courts. [ 33 ] Mr. Ubah has disclosed that he has a government-funded lawyer who was assigned by Legal Aid Alberta: Ubah #17 at para 8. While this Court is prohibited from requiring any person to be represented by a lawyer, since the right to self-represent is absolute in Alberta ( Jonsson v Lymer , 2020 ABCA 167 ), I very strongly recommend that Mr.
Ubah cease on his own making leave to file Applications to the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, and instead employ the services of the lawyer who has apparently been retained. [ 34 ] This Memorandum of Decision shall be served on Mr. Ubah to the email address on the proposed Application: ubah.chinedu@yahoo.com Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 27 th day of February, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances by submissions: Chinedu Gideon Ubah Self-Represented Litigant
Loading document…