Christofi v Kahane Law Office, 2023 ABKB 122
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Christofi v Kahane Law Office, 2023 ABKB 122 Date: 20230302 Dockets: 2101 02852, 2201 05668 Registry: Calgary Between: Docket 2101 02852 Mike Christofi and Quality Painting Proposed Appellant - and - Kahane Law Office Proposed Respondent And between: Docket 2201 05668 Mike Christofi and Quality Painting Proposed Applicant - and - Chad Newcombe and Kahane Law Office Proposed Respondents
_______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ I. Introduction [ 1 ] On February 17-21, 2023, the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta received three emails from Mike Christofi (Mr. Christofi). These were directed to me for review. Mr. Christofi is required to obtain permission of the Court - “leave” - because in July 2022, Mr. Christofi was made subject to court access gatekeeping pursuant to Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 ss 23-23.1.
Those gatekeeping steps were subsequently confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta: Christofi v Jeffrey V Kahane Professional Corporation, 2022 ABCA 284 . [ 2 ] Mr. Christofi’s three emails seem to indicate Mr. Christofi is making two separate leave Applications: one of a recent decision of Applications Judge Mason, and the second broadly challenging a wide array of court and tribunal proceedings.
February 17, 2023 - subject: “Request for permision to file a notice of appeal File 2101-02852” (sic) ... this a request for permission to file a notice of appeal against judge J Mason's court order feb 16 2023 case file 2101-02852 because judge j D Rooks ordered restriction access against me in this court for no reason because i filed a complaint against him,and Chadwick Newcombe, in CJC and a court order against Mr Newcombe to set aside All JD Rooks court orders and allow my case to be heard in court in a fair hearing and allow me to show the evidence in court because i am a low-income 68 years senior and Chadwick Newcombe is causing me a lot of damage i try to file the notice of appeal in the court of appeal but they send me a letter directing the case to Kings Bench based on rule 6.14 all court orders are under appeal in the court of appeal and justice Petelechuk told Mr Newcombe that he could not use them i am attaching the court order and supreme court Notice of Appeal file 40507 which Mr Newcombe did not respond thank you Kindly respectfully Submitted M Christofi (Sic.) February 18, 2023 - subject: “Request for permision to file an aplication to remove a various misconduct and consiracy actions against me by JD Rooks and Chadwick Newmbebe” (sic) ...
This is a request for permission to file an application with evidence to remove various court orders against me By Chadwick Newcombe and Justice JD Rooks under Misconduct and conspiracy against Me file 2201-05668 Cjc file 220169 court of appeal file 2101-0089AC -2101-0253AC -2101-0295AC -2201-2201-0027AC-2201-149AC-2201-174AC supreme court file 40507 i am attaching CJC evidence and supreme court Notice of Appeal thank you kindly and respectfully submitting Mike Christofi (Sic.) February 21, 2023 - subject: “Request for permision to file an aplication to remove a various misconduct and consiracy actions against me by JD Rooks and Chadwick Newmbebe” (sic) ...
More evidence to my request to file evidence against Chadwick Newcombe proving misconduct and conspiracy against me By Chadwick Newcombe and Honorable judge JD Rooks thank you respectfully Submitted M Christofi (Sic.) [ 3 ] Mr. Christofi’s emails attach a number of documents: • February 17 and 18, 2023 emails : - a 93-page document that appears to be a leave application for the Supreme Court of Canada, Action No. 40507. Review of the corresponding Supreme Court of Canada docket indicates this is a live leave to appeal application, with the file opened on December 22, 2022.
However, the cover page of the Supreme Court of Canada filing is, for no apparent reason, marked as having been filed with the Court of Appeal of Alberta on January 9, 2023. • February 17, 2023 email - a February 16, 2023 Order of Applications Judge Mason in Action No. 2101 02852 that orders Mr. Christofi “... shall complete and swear a Financial Statement of Debtor (Individual) ...” by March 9, 2023, and that imposes $500 in costs against Mr. Christofi. • February 18, 2023 email - A two-page letter from the Canadian Judicial Council (CJC) dated August 3, 2022, in which the CJC rejected demands by Mr.
Christofi that now retired Associate Chief Justice Rooke had acted illegally and must be removed/prohibited from being involved with Mr. Christofi’s litigation. The CJC rejected Mr. Christofi’s complaint at an “early screening” stage, as the complaint did not raise “any issue of conduct.”
• February 21, 2023 email - A two-page letter, dated May 19, 2022, from Chadwick Newcombe and the Kahane Law Office in the Action No. 2201 05668 proceeding. Those parties argue that an application by Mr. Christofi that Associate Chief Justice Rooke recuse himself is hopeless re-litigation of prior duplicate complaints. The authors request instructions for how to conduct a Judicature Act ss 23- 23.1 Application to impose court access gatekeeping on Mr. Christofi. This letter attaches a number of documents filed in the Courts of King’s Bench of Alberta and the Court of Appeal of Alberta. [ 4 ] I interpret Mr.
Christofi’s materials to indicate he seeks permission to file two processes: 1) an appeal of Applications Judge Mason’s February 16, 2023 Order; and 2) a global application that would invalidate, reverse, and/or nullify unfavourable results in multiple Court proceedings and the CJC complaint against former Associate Chief Justice Rooke. II.
Test for Leave to File [ 5 ] “... [A] person subject to court access control is presumed to engage in illegitimate litigation unless the Court is satisfied otherwise. ...”: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at para 19 , aff’d 2018 ABCA 111 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38204 (14 February 2019). [ 6 ] Permission to initiate litigation or continue stayed litigation both test the merit of Court activities on the same standard.
A person subject to court access restrictions must: 1) establish reasonable grounds for the litigation; and 2) depose fully and completely as to the facts and circumstances surrounding the proposed claim or proceeding. ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 27; VWW v Wasylyshen , 2013 ABQB 327 at para 42 , aff’d 2014 ABCA 121 .) [ 7 ] This threshold, which must be established on a balance of probabilities, is not a high one, and, in many ways, parallels the test for
Summary Judgment: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 26.
The person subject to court access leave restrictions is expected to put his or her “best foot forward” to establish the basis to initiate or continue an action: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 26-27. [ 8 ] The documents necessary to seek leave are an affidavit to provide evidence, and, in the case of a new Action, Application, or other litigation step, a copy of the proposed initiating filing: e.g., Re Moore , 2018 ABQB 261 ; Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 . [ 9 ] Leave may be granted in part: Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 ; Belway v Lalande-Weber , 2017 ABCA 108 at para 10 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 37708 (21 December 2017). [ 10 ] Leave submissions to initiate or continue litigation may also be rejected: 1) where the materials do not satisfy the criteria set out in the court access restriction order ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38267 (31 January 2019); Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38266 (31 January 2019); Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta v Drover , 2021 ABQB 511 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ); 2) if the submissions exhibit indicia of abusive litigation ( ET v Calgary Catholic School District No 1 , 2017 ABCA 349 at para 12 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38081 (8 November 2018); Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Trinity Place Foundation of Alberta v Templanza , 2019 ABQB 45 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Fletcher v Davidson & Williams LLP , 2019 ABQB 396 ; Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2021 ABQB 208 ; Knutson (Re) , 2021 ABQB 367 ; McMunn v Hok , 2021 ABQB 550 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 79 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 97 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Fiset v Feeney , 2022 ABQB 211 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 498 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 3) where the abusive litigant refuses to provide the proposed filing ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); 4) where the abusive litigant provides false information or fails to provide necessary information ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 5) where the abusive litigant fails to provide materials that are required to evaluate the proposed litigation step, such as a transcript of a proceeding proposed for appeal ( Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); and 6) where the Court has no jurisdiction over the matter ( Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ). [ 11 ] There is no appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta of a decision to deny leave: r 14.5(4) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 ; Re Gauthier , 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8 .
A litigant who is denied leave by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta may, however, seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada.
III. Analysis [ 12 ] I conclude Mr. Christofi’s leave requests should be rejected on multiple grounds. A. No Candidate Filings [ 13 ] Mr. Christofi has not provided the Court with the candidate filings that he proposes to file. The Court therefore cannot substantively evaluate whether Mr. Christofi’s leave requests are or are not reasonable: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 . That is a first independent basis on which I reject both leave to file Applications. B. No Evidence the Proposed Litigation is Reasonable [ 14 ] Mr.
Christofi has provided no information or evidence for either leave to file Application. That means Mr. Christofi has not established reasonable grounds for his proposed litigation. That is a second independent basis on which I reject both leave to file Applications. C. Necessary Materials are Not Provided [ 15 ] This Court can only evaluate whether Applications Judge Mason’s February 16, 2023 Order should be subject to appeal by evaluating Applications Judge Mason’s decision and reasons. That means a transcript of the February 16, 2023 hearing is necessary for this Court to evaluate Mr.
Christofi’s February 17, 2023 leave Application. This failure to provide necessary materials is a third independent basis on which I reject Mr. Christofi’s proposed leave to appeal Application. D. Collateral Attack [ 16 ] Mr. Christofi’s February 18 and 21, 2023 emails appear intended to create some kind of process that would affect, reverse, and/or nullify litigation in multiple Court proceedings, and a CJC complaint. Many of the identified processes are at the Court of Appeal of Alberta. The “file 2201-05668” is a Court of King’s Bench of Alberta process that has now completed and terminated.
The outcome of that proceeding was then confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Mr. Christofi also targets “supreme court file 40507”, which, as noted above, is a live leave to appeal application by Mr. Christofi before the Supreme Court of Canada. [ 17 ] Because Mr. Christofi has not provided a candidate filing in relation to the February 18 and 21, 2023 emails, nor explained what, specifically, he seeks in relation to these matters, I cannot evaluate exactly what Mr. Christofi intends to do. However, what I can conclude is that the matters Mr.
Christofi has identified either are: 1) now completed litigation; and/or 2) proceedings in superior Canadian Courts, that are not subject to review or the jurisdiction of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. [ 18 ] In either instance, I conclude what Mr. Christofi proposes are collateral attacks, as defined in Unrau v National Dental Examining Board , 2019 ABQB 283 at paras 612-613 : ... A collateral attack is a litigation step or proceeding that challenges, directly or indirectly, a prior court decision or result. ... ...
Examples of prohibited collateral attacks include: 1. bringing proceedings to determine an issue that has already been determined by a court of competent jurisdiction, 2. using previously raised grounds and issues improperly in a subsequent proceedings, 3. conducting a proceeding to circumvent the effect of a court order, and 4. conducting multiple proceedings with the same litigation objective. [ 19 ] Since what Mr. Christofi proposes is abusive litigation, this is the fourth independent basis on which I reject both leave to file Applications. IV. Conclusion [ 20 ] Mr.
Christofi’s leave Applications are rejected. [ 21 ] I caution Mr.
Christofi that abuse of this Court’s leave processes may lead to negative consequences, such as penalties pursuant to r. 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court : McMunn v Hok , 2021 ABQB 601 , leave to appeal refused 2021 ABCA 321 ; Fletcher v Davidson & Williams LLP , 2021 ABQB 842 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 97 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 , leave to appeal refused 2022 ABCA 172 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 , leave to appeal refused 2022 ABCA 172; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB
354 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 498 ; Ubah v Ubah , 2022 ABQB 534 , leave to appeal refused 2022 ABCA 329 . [ 22 ] I very strongly recommend Mr. Christofi retain counsel to assist him in the preparation of any future Court of King’s Bench of Alberta leave Applications. I believe Mr. Christofi would benefit from that assistance. [ 23 ] Mindful of the Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 instruction that Canadian judges shall provide information on litigation alternatives to self-represented litigants, such as Mr. Christofi, if Mr.
Christofi disagrees with the result of this Memorandum of Decision, he may seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. [ 24 ] This Memorandum of Decision will be served upon Mr. Christofi and the proposed Respondents by email. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 2 nd day of March, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances by Application: Mike Christofi Self-Represented Litigant
Loading document…