Warner (County) v Waddell, 2023 ABKB 142
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Warner (County) v Waddell, 2023 ABKB 142 Date: 202303010 Docket: 2106 00807 Registry: Lethbridge Between: County of Warner No. 5 Applicant - and - Cori Lynn Waddell Respondent - and - County of Warner No. 5, Shane Rodeback, Elodie Rodeback Respondents by Cross-Application _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice D.V. Hartigan _______________________________________________________ Introduction
[ 1 ] This case involves the validity of an auction sale of land due to outstanding property taxes. Cori Lynn Waddell (the “Respondent”) was the owner of that property (the “Property”) who failed to pay the taxes. The Applicant, the County of Warner No. 5 (the “County”), applies to confirm the sale; the Respondent seeks to have the sale set aside. The fact that the taxes were outstanding is not at issue.
The County seeks an Order confirming the sale of the land to the purchasers at auction, Shane and Elodie Rodeback, as well as direction with respect to ancillary matters. [ 2 ] The Respondent challenges the sale on the basis due to the following alleged deficiencies in the sale process: 1. The Respondent did not receive proper notice of the sale. 2. The County did not provide proper notice to the holder of a certificate of lis pendens on the Property, Mr. Edward Waddell. 3.
The reserve bid for the Property was not set “as close as reasonably possible to the market value of the parcel” pursuant to s. 419 of the Municipal Government Act , RSA 2000, c M-26 [ MGA ]. 4. The purchasers of the Property at auction were not bona fide purchasers. [ 3 ] I will deal with each of these alleged deficiencies in turn. Issues 1.
Was proper notice given to the Respondent? [ 4 ] The Respondent contends that she did not receive notice of the sale, and furthermore that the County, aware that the notices were returned unopened, should have taken further steps to ensure she was notified. [ 5 ] Notices of the sale were sent to the address provided by the Respondent on the Certificate of Title. Since 2019, letters sent by the County to that address have been returned and marked as “moved/unknown”.
The land itself, a recreational property, does not have a municipal address. [ 6 ] The notice requirements in relation to tax arrears/sales are set out in the MGA are: o s. 412(3) – which states that the municipality must notify persons liable to pay tax arrears that the arrears list has been sent to the Registrar; o s. 417(1) – which states that the Registrar must send notice of the proposed sale to the owner of the property; and o s. 421(4) – which states that the municipality must send a copy of the auction advertisement to the owner of the property. [ 7 ] Furthermore, s. 337 of the MGA states that the tax notice is deemed to be received 7 days after it is sent by regular mail to the mailing address of the property.
Section 215 of the Land Titles Act , RSA 2000, c L-4 [ LTA ], states that any notice required to be given by the Registrar under the LTA or any other enactment is deemed to have been duly served upon the notice being sent by regular mail to the person’s address as shown on the registered instruments. [ 8 ] The Respondent’s contention that she needed to be served the notice fails to take into account the clear distinction between sending notice and serving notice in tax recovery legislation ( Cwalina Estate v Parkland (County) , 2012 ABQB 430 at para 31 [ Parkland ] , aff’d 2013 ABCA 343 ).
The requirement under the MGA is “to “send a copy”, not to “serve or to ensure receipt” ( Parkland , at para 31 ). The County is entitled to rely upon the information filed at the Land Titles Office. There is no requirement for the County to take any additional steps to ascertain if the information is correct or take steps to locate the correct information. The Court places value on Land Titles registry, and there are requirements to keep information up to date, which obligation falls upon the title holder who bears the risk of not receiving notice.
Any other system would be unreliable, cumbersome and defeat the purpose of a centralized system ( Parkland , at paras 28-35 ). [ 9 ] Therefore, I find proper notice of the sale was provided to the Respondent. 2. Should the holder of the certificate of lis pendens , Edward Waddell, have been served with notice of the arrears or sale? [ 10 ] The MGA provides as follows: 417(1) Not later than the August 1 following receipt of a copy of the tax arrears list, the Registrar must, in respect of each parcel of land shown on the tax arrears list, send a notice to (
a) the owner of the parcel of land, (
b) any person who has an interest in the parcel that is evidenced by a caveat registered by the Registrar, and (
c) each encumbrancee shown on the certificate of title for the parcel.
(2) The notice must state
(
a) that if the tax arrears in respect of the parcel of land are not paid before March 31 in the next year, the municipality will offer the parcel for sale at a public auction, and (
b) that the municipality may become the owner of the parcel after the public auction if the parcel is not sold at the public auction.
(3) The notice must be sent to the address shown on the records of the Land Titles Office for each person referred to in subsection (1). 421(1) The municipality must advertise the public auction (
a) in one issue of The Alberta Gazette, not less than 40 days and not more than 90 days before the date on which the public auction is to be held, and (
b) in one issue of a newspaper having general circulation in the municipality, not less than 10 days and not more than 20 days before the date on which the public auction is to be held.
(2) The advertisement must specify the date, time and location of the public auction, the conditions of sale and a description of each parcel of land to be offered for sale.
(3) The advertisement must state that the municipality may, after the public auction, become the owner of any parcel of land not sold at the public auction.
(4) Not less than 4 weeks before the date of the public auction, the municipality must send a copy of the advertisement referred to in subsection (1)(
a) to (
a) the owner of each parcel of land to be offered for sale, (
b) each person who has an interest in any parcel to be offered for sale that is evidenced by a caveat registered by the Registrar, and (
c) each encumbrancee shown on the certificate of title for each parcel to be offered for sale. [ 11 ] Edward Waddell filed his Certificate of Lis Pendens (“CLP”) in relation to his interests in the land pursuant to the Family Property Act, RSA 2000, c F-4.7 [ Family Property Act ].
He, and the Respondent, contend he should have been notified of the sale as he had a registered encumbrance on the land. [ 12 ] There is a clear requirement in the MGA that the owner, anyone who has an interest registered by a caveat, and each encumbrancee be notified of the possibility of a sale for the recovery of taxes. [ 13 ] As Mr.
Waddell is clearly not an owner of the Property, to be entitled to notice under the MGA he must either have an interest in the land or be an encumbrancee. [ 14 ] A CLP is not an interest in land - rather, it is merely a notice that a claim to an interest in land is being made ( Alberta Drywall & Stucco Supply Inc v Tilt-Tech Construction Ltd , 2017 ABQB 325 [ Alberta Drywall ]). Therefore, since Mr. Waddell does not have an interest in land created by his CLP, he is not entitled to notice under s. 417(1)(
b) nor s. 421(4) (
b) of the MGA . [ 15 ] The MGA uses the LTA ’s definition of an encumbrance – “any charge on land created or effected for any purpose whatever, inclusive of mortgage, mechanics’ or builders’ liens, when authorized by statute, and executions against land, unless expressly distinguished” ( LTA , at s. 1 (e)). The question is whether Mr.
Waddell’s CLP is a charge on the land such that he is an encumbrancee requiring notice per sections 417 or 421 of the MGA . [ 16 ] In Alberta (Registrar of Land Titles) v Mackenzie (County) , 2012 ABQB 447 , Justice Sulyma determined that a CLP was not a charge on land and did not fall within the definition of an encumbrance, as an encumbrance is a charge on land, which means the land is security for the payment of a debt or performance of an obligation. [ 17 ] Therefore, I find that Mr. Waddell was not an encumbrance, and that Mr.
Waddell was not entitled to notice of the arrears or the sale pursuant to the provisions of the MGA . 3. Was the reserve bid on the property properly set by the County? [ 18 ] The Respondent argues that the reserve bid set for the Property at auction, which ultimately became the sale price, was improperly set too low by the County. In support of that position, she provides a realtor’s estimate of the market value of the Property. [ 19 ] The reserve bid was set at $34,400.00. Shane and Elodie Rodeback were the only people to attend the auction.
They bid the reserve, which was accepted. [ 20 ] The MGA sets out the requirements for a municipality to set a reserve bid in a tax arrears sale: 419 The council must set (
a) for each parcel of land to be offered for sale at a public auction, a reserve bid that is as close as reasonably possible to the market value of the parcel, and (
b) any conditions that apply to the sale.
[ 21 ] In the MGA, “market value” is defined as “the amount that a property... might be expected to realize if it is sold on the open market by a willing seller to a willing buyer”. There is no definition or clarification as to what “as close as reasonably possible to the market value” means, nor does the MGA set out a method by which a municipal council is to investigate market value. [ 22 ] The reserve bid in the present case was set by the tax assessor. The MGA ’ s taxation regime requires property taxes to be based upon market value: Sections 5 - 7 , MGA .
The assessed value for tax purposes was $34,400.00. [ 23 ] The Respondent has provided a Residential Land Appraisal Report which estimates the market value of the property at $60,000.00, using a direct comparison approach to valuation based on similar property sales. [ 24 ] As stated above, the County is required to assess properties for taxation purposes at “market value”. Should an owner disagree with the assessment, they may do so in accordance with s. 460 of the MGA . The Respondent did not engage this process. While this
section is generally used by owners attempting to lower their taxes by seeking a lower assessment, there are circumstances in which an owner may wish to have the assessed value of their property increased, for example, to secure financing. [ 25 ] Further, the municipality has an interest in having the assessed value of properties as close to market value as they can, as this would maximize their tax revenue. [ 26 ] The appraisal provided by the Respondent is predicated on a property free and clear of detrimental encumbrances, liens, and restrictions.
While the property tax and Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) charges would be removed upon sale, Mr. Waddell’s CLP would potentially remain. Also, the appraisal presumed a listing period of 30-90 days, with appropriate marketing. This was an auction sale. By its nature, an auction, the only manner of sale permitted in the circumstances by the MGA , involves a much shorter time frame than a 90-day listing.
Further, the appraisal does not take into account realtor fees. [ 27 ] Finally, it is simply not logical that the reserve bid at an auction, the floor of bidding, if you will, should be the same as the ceiling: that is, the best price that could be achieved in a 90-day market listing by a realtor. As an aside, it must be noted that a properly advertised auction of the Property attracted only one bidder, which itself suggests demand for the Property may have been overestimated by the appraisal. [ 28 ] I find the reserve bid was properly set in this case by the County. 4.
Were the purchasers prohibited from purchasing the property? [ 29 ] The Respondent claims the purchasers were not “truly arms length purchasers”. The MGA sets out prohibited bidders in a tax sale auction: 429(1) When a municipality holds a public auction or another sale under
section 425, the auctioneer, the councillors, the chief administrative officer and the designated officers and employees of the municipality must not bid for or buy, or act as an agent in buying, any parcel of land offered for sale ... [ 30 ] Apart from a suggestion that they are inappropriate purchasers, the evidence before me in an Affidavit provided by the purchasers clearly indicates they do not fall within s. 429(1). Mr. Rodeback operates an excavation company, and last provided gravel to the applicant County in 2010, and last did contract work for the County in 2017.
There is no evidence of significant ties between the purchasers and the County to conclude they were not bona fide purchasers for value or that their involvement in the tax sale was not at arms length. Conclusions [ 31 ] In answer to the four issues raised by the Respondent, I find the following: 1. The Respondent was given proper notice of the tax arrears and the auction sale of the Property by the County. 2. The holder of the Certificate of Lis Pendens , Mr. Waddell, was not entitled to notice of the arrears or the auction sale. 3.
The reserve bid at the auction for sale of the Property was set “as close as reasonably possible to the market value of the parcel” and therefore complied with the MGA . 4. The successful bidders, Mr. and Ms. Rodeback, were bona fide purchasers and not prohibited buyers under s. 429 of the MGA . Other Issues Mr. Waddell’s CLP [ 32 ] The Court has been asked by the County for direction with respect to the status of the CLP placed on title by Mr. Waddell. The CLP was in relation to his claim for family property pursuant to s. 35 of the Family Property Act . [ 33 ]
Section 190 of the LTA provides as follows: 190(1) In any proceeding respecting land or in respect of any transaction or contract relating to it, or in respect of any instrument, caveat, memorandum or entry affecting land, the judge by decree or order may direct the Registrar to cancel, correct, substitute or issue any
certificate of title or make any memorandum or entry on it and otherwise to do every act necessary to give effect to the decree or order.
(2) In particular and without limiting the generality of subsection (1), in any case where a title to land has been issued and the owner has entered into any contract relating to the sale or disposition of the land and if it can be shown to the satisfaction of the judge that (
a) the applicant is entitled to a transfer of the land and to be registered as its owner and the registered owner has no further interest in the land, and (
b) the registered owner is dead and no transfer of the land to the purchaser has been made or the registered owner has not been located after a reasonable inquiry and no transfer of the land to the purchaser has been made, the judge on the giving of any notice to any persons that the judge may require, may by order direct the Registrar to cancel the existing certificate of title and issue a new certificate of title in the name of the purchaser. [ 34 ] In Alberta Drywall , the Court stated that s. 190 of the LTA “explicitly allows a court to consider whether even a CLP which has been properly filed... should remain on title.
In doing so, the court is entitled to consider the equities of the situation.” ( Alberta Drywall , at para 57 ). [ 35 ] In this case, even presuming the CLP was properly filed, the CLP’s claim came after that of the CRA. The total owed to CRA vastly exceeds the sale value of the Property in this auction, in fact, it similarly exceeds the value of the Property proposed by the Respondent. As a consequence, the CLP is of no benefit to Mr. Waddell. [ 36 ] Therefore, I order the Registrar to cancel the CLP of Mr. Waddell.
Taxes for the years 2021-2022 [ 37 ] Although I am given to understand the County and the CRA have come to an agreement with respect to distribution of the proceeds of the sale of the Property, for the purposes of certainty, the County may receive from the proceeds outstanding taxes up to and including those owed for 2022.
Removal of items from the Property [ 38 ] The items on the Property, including a holiday trailer and boat, shall be removed within 90 days of this judgment or such other time as may be agreed upon between the parties. [ 39 ] In the event the items are not removed, the County may apply to this Court for further direction. Costs [ 40 ] If the parties cannot agree to costs, they may advise the Court Coordinator within 30 days of this judgment to arrange to have the matter brought before me.
Necessary Orders [ 41 ] The County may apply to the Court on an ex parte basis for any Orders necessary to effect the Transfer of Land and removal of the CLP as may be required by the Registrar of Land Titles. Heard on the 7 th day of November, 2022. Dated at the City of Lethbridge, Alberta this 10 th day of March, 2023. D.V. Hartigan J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Kerry Gellrich
for the Applicant Rockwell Pollock for the Respondent Gregor Carlton for Shane Rodeback & Elodie Rodeback
Loading document…