Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden, 2023 ABKB 152
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden, 2023 ABKB 152 Date: 20230315 Docket: 2101 08260 Registry: Calgary Between: Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce Proposed Respondent / Plaintiff - and - Ingrid Hayden Proposed Applicant / Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ I. Introduction [ 1 ] Ingrid Hayden (Ms.
Hayden) is a person who has engaged in extensive litigation that involves many different opposing parties in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, the Court of Appeal of Alberta, and who has on six occasions sought leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of Canada. On November 17, 2020, Ms. Hayden was made subject to prospective court access gatekeeping in a decision of Neufeld J reported as Hayden v Hayden , 2020 ABQB 700 , leave to appeal denied 2021 ABCA 202 ( Hayden v Hayden #1 ). The effect of Hayden v Hayden #1 is that Ms.
Hayden must obtain permission - “leave” - prior to initiating litigation in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. Ms. Hayden has to date made six unsuccessful leave to file applications with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. Ms. Hayden also has a record of simply ignoring the leave requirement: Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 593 ; Hayden v Hayden , 2022 ABKB 648 .
[ 2 ] Ms. Hayden’s residence is the subject of protracted foreclosure litigation initiated by the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) to collect outstanding debts. The redemption period for the property debt has expired, and the most recent step in that proceeding is that on November 21, 2022, Applications Judge Prowse ordered sale and vesting of the property with the new owner. [ 3 ] On February 24, 2023, this Court received an email from Ms. Hayden that stated: “Please find attached an application as well as an affidavit, asking for permission to have two taxation done. ...” (sic). Ms.
Hayden’s email attaches an unsworn “Affidavit of Ingrid Hayden”, whose relevant passages are: 2. I am submitting this affidavit to support a application for two tax assessment on the Plaintiff bill of cost, Exhibit A, dated February 15, 2023. 3. I am also asking for a tax assessment of the Plaintiff Redemption Order listing, heard on November 18, 2021, Exhibit B. A cost assessment was suppose to be done before filing the redemption Order, but this was not done. 4.
I am asking for a cost assessment because I am not able to clean from the documents submitted to the court, the total amount of cost claimed by the Plaintiff, for the following reasons: 5. A. I have not received a pay/out discharge/distribution of funds of both mortgages that the Plaintiff was suppose to payout with the proceeds of selling my home, Mortgage Number 055 094 041. The home was sold to pay out Mortgage Number 3584308641, (the mortgage in default). This was a line of credit, secured by a mortgage, Exhibit C. 6.
The July 26, discharge/payout statement do not add up to the bill of cost, dated February 26, 2022, Exhibit D 7. The Court appointed realtor fee was not on the bill of cost, Exhibit E 8. There is no funds that was supposed to be paid out, in the bill of cost, and as I said above, I have not received both mortgage payout/discharge statements from the Plaintiff, to verify that the Order is completed. Therefore, justifying the cost assessment of amount claimed for Counsel fees, Exhibit F. (Sic.) [ 4 ] I am responding to Ms.
Hayden’s leave to file Application as an Administrative Justice of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. I dismiss that Application on multiple bases. II. Test for Leave to File [ 5 ] “... [A] person subject to court access control is presumed to engage in illegitimate litigation unless the Court is satisfied otherwise. ...”: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at para 19 , aff’d 2018 ABCA 111 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38204 (14 February 2019). [ 6 ] Permission to initiate litigation or continue stayed litigation both test the merit of Court activities on the same standard.
A person subject to Court Access Restrictions must: 1) establish reasonable grounds for the litigation; and 2) depose fully and completely as to the facts and circumstances surrounding the proposed claim or proceeding. ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 27; VWW v Wasylyshen , 2013 ABQB 327 at para 42 , aff’d 2014 ABCA 121 .) [ 7 ] This threshold, which must be established on a balance of probabilities, is not a high one, and, in many ways, parallels the test for
Summary Judgment: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 26.
The person subject to Court access leave restrictions is expected to put his or her “best foot forward” to establish the basis to initiate or continue an Action: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 26-27. [ 8 ] The documents necessary to seek leave are an affidavit to provide evidence, and, in the case of a new Action, Application, or other litigation step, a copy of the proposed initiating filing: e.g., Re Moore , 2018 ABQB 261 ; Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 . [ 9 ] Leave may be granted in part: Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 ; Belway v Lalande-Weber , 2017 ABCA 108 at para 10 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 37708 (21 December 2017). [ 10 ] Leave submissions to initiate or continue litigation may also be rejected: 1) where the materials do not satisfy the criteria set out in the Court Access Restriction Order ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38267 (31 January 2019); Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38266 (31 January 2019); Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta v Drover , 2021 ABQB 511 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ); 2) if the submissions exhibit indicia of abusive litigation ( ET v Calgary Catholic School District No 1 , 2017 ABCA 349 at para 12 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38081 (8 November 2018); Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Trinity Place Foundation of Alberta v Templanza , 2019 ABQB 45 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Fletcher v Davidson & Williams LLP , 2019 ABQB 396 ; Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2021 ABQB 208 ; Knutson (Re) , 2021 ABQB 367 ; McMunn v Hok , 2021 ABQB 550 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 79 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 97 ; Rana v
Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Fiset v Feeney , 2022 ABQB 211 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 498 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ; Hayden v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce , 2023 ABKB 100 ; Ubah v Ubah , 2023 ABKB 111 ); 3) where the abusive litigant refuses to provide the proposed filing ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); 4) where the abusive litigant provides false information or fails to provide necessary information ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 5) where the abusive litigant fails to provide materials that are required to evaluate the proposed litigation step, such as a transcript of a proceeding proposed for appeal ( Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); and 6) where the Court has no jurisdiction over the matter ( Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Ubah v Ubah , 2023 ABKB 111 ). [ 11 ] There is no appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta of a decision to deny leave: r 14.5(4) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 ; Re Gauthier , 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8 .
A litigant who is denied leave by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta may, however, seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. III. Analysis [ 12 ] Ms. Hayden’s leave to file Application is rejected on multiple, independent bases. A. No Proposed Filings [ 13 ] To the extent that Ms. Hayden’s materials provide guidance as to what she seeks, Ms. Hayden says she seeks “taxation” of a proposed bill of costs from counsel for CIBC, that includes time and disbursements. The proposed bill of costs accompanied a February 15, 2023 letter to Ms. Hayden from counsel for CIBC. I am presuming that what Ms.
Hayden seeks is that the Court grant her permission to initiate a review of the proposed bill of costs by the “Assessment Officer”, pursuant to
Part 10 of the Alberta Rules of Court . [ 14 ] Ms. Hayden’s materials include what I believe is her proposed “Application for Taxation”, a Form 27 document. However, the document to initiate an Assessment Officer review of a bill of costs is Form 45. Thus, the Court does not have the proposed Application by Ms. Hayden. B. No Reasonable Basis [ 15 ] Second, I conclude that Ms. Hayden has not provided a reasonable basis for her complaints, to the degree those are identified and particularized. For example, Ms. Hayden says she wants a “tax assessment of the Plaintiff Redemption Order listing” of November 18, 2021.
What she then identifies in her Affidavit as the problematic document is a November 18, 2021 Order of Applications Judge (then Master) Mason. That makes no sense, because the Order referenced has nothing to do with a bill of costs. There is nothing here that an Assessment Officer would review. [ 16 ] Second, it appears Ms.
Hayden is confusing two different processes, 1) calculation of the solicitor/client costs she is due to pay because she is the unsuccessful party in the foreclosure, versus, 2) calculation of how the funds recovered via the purchase approved by Applications Judge Prowse in his November 18, 2022 Court Order are allocated. Ms. Hayden, for example, complains she has “... not received a pay/out discharge/distribution of funds ...”, but that is because that step in the foreclosure has not yet completed. Her complaint, viewed in the best light, is premature. C.
The Proposed Taxation Duplicates Mandatory Litigation Processes [ 17 ] Furthermore, Ms. Hayden’s proposed litigation steps are unnecessary because r 9.35 of the Alberta Rules of Court requires an automatic review by the Assessment Officer prior to completion of a foreclosure action. That includes “... the assessment officer must assess the reasonable and proper costs ...”, the Assessment Officer will check CIBC’s calculations prior to distribution of funds, and review Ms. Hayden’s submissions on these points, if any. This process is followed except by an Order of the Court: r 9.35(1)(
b) of the Alberta Rules of Court . Ms. Hayden has not indicated that any such exception is in effect. [ 18 ] Since I see no reason why the existing r 9.35 of the Alberta Rules of Court procedure would not operate in the CIBC foreclosure of Ms. Hayden’s former property, what Ms. Hayden has proposed duplicates standard procedures already put in place by the Alberta Rules of Court . I, therefore, conclude that Ms. Hayden has no reasonable basis for her proposed Application(s), because if she does have any valid concerns, those will be addressed in the normal course of the foreclosure’s resolution. IV.
Conclusion [ 19 ] Ms. Hayden’s February 24, 2023 leave to file Application is rejected. Associate Chief Justice Rooke and I have concluded that Ms. Hayden has a “... pattern of persistent, repeated, abusive, litigation activities ...”, and that prior attempts to control Ms. Hayden’s
bad litigation conduct have simply failed: Hayden v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce , 2023 ABKB 100 at paras 27-30 . [ 20 ] On February 22, 2023, I predicted: “... The result is Ms. Hayden is effectively unmanageable, and will, in all likelihood, make yet further hopeless and abusive leave applications.” Two days later I was proven correct with the current proposed litigation. There are no further steps this Court can take to meaningfully respond to or deter Ms. Hayden’s abuse of the leave to file process. [ 21 ] Ms. Hayden should seek professional legal assistance.
A range of public legal assistance resources are available to Ms. Hayden, such as Legal Aid Alberta, Calgary Legal Guidance, the University of Calgary Student Legal Assistance, or Student Legal Services of Edmonton (contact information is available on the Canadian Judicial Council’s Self-Represented Litigant Civil Handbook, under “Resources” and Alberta (pp 92-95, cjc-ccm.ca/sites/default/files/documents/2021/Civil%20Handbook%20- %20EN%20MASTER%202021-10-19.pdf). I believe Ms. Hayden would very much benefit from obtaining assistance. The fact is that Ms.
Hayden’s aggressive, abusive, confrontational, and ineffective tactics during this foreclosure unnecessarily consumed the Court and CIBC’s resources, but the net effect is also that Ms. Hayden has significantly reduced what proceeds she may recover from the sale of her home. I recommend, that Ms. Hayden only make future leave to file applications after consulting with a legal professional. [ 22 ] Ms. Hayden shall be served this Memorandum of Decision by email. I direct a copy of this Memorandum of Decision is provided to Counsel for CIBC. As previously indicated, if Ms.
Hayden disagrees with the outcome of her leave to file Application, she should seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 15 th day of March, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Ingrid Hayden Self-Represented Litigant by submissions Stuart Weatherill Emery Jamieson LLP for Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (no appearance)
Loading document…