1933748 Alberta Ltd Appellant/Respondent (Defendant) - v. -, 2023 ABKB 206
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: 1933748 Alberta Ltd v Engel, 2023 ABKB 206 Date: 20230411 Docket: 2103 08898 Registry: Edmonton Between: 1933748 Alberta Ltd Appellant/Respondent (Defendant) - and - Alex Engel Respondent/ Cross Appellant (Plaintiff) - and - 1933748 Alberta Ltd and McCor Management (AB) Inc Respondents on Cross Appeal (Defendants)
_______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice G.R. Fraser _______________________________________________________ Appeal from the Decision by J.L. Skitsko The Honourable Judge Dated the 29 th day of June, 2022 and July 22, 2021 ( Docket: P1890300255) [ 1 ] This matter is an appeal and cross-appeal of a decision made by Judge Skitko on June 29, 2021. 1933748 (“193”) Alberta raises three issues on its appeal:
a) Did the Trial Judge err in interpreting the Prices as monthly payments rather than amounts which covered the entire terms of the Contracts?
b) Did the Trial Judge err by holding 193 could not rely on the Termination Clause to limit its liability and granting damages for the entire remaining terms of the Contracts?
c) Did the Trial Judge err in granting Mr. Engel damages for the full amount payable under the Contracts rather than deducting for expenses to determine Mr. Engel’s actual loss of profit? [ 2 ] This appeal is centred on an
interpretation of three contracts for snow maintenance, essentially clearing sidewalks. On September 5, 2017 the parties executed three separate contracts for snow maintenance at three separate residential properties in Edmonton, AB. One is described as Holyrood Boulevard; addresses 8312 90 Avenue Northwest to 9375 85 Street Northwest. There is a second contract related to the Holyrood Boulevard complex. The contract is for the addresses 8423 95 Avenue Northwest to 9383 95 Street Northwest. The other property is described as Glenora Patio Homes; addresses 13803 109 Avenue Northwest to 10929 135 Street Northwest.
These properties are large, multi-unit developments. The contracts were for six month terms starting November 1, 2017. Regarding payment, the first Holyrood Boulevard contract states “as per estimate $4900 plus GST”. The second Holyrood Boulevard contract states “as per estimate $2000 plus GST”. The Glenora Patio Homes contract states “as per estimate $3900 plus GST”. Melissa Autenbach signed the contracts on behalf of 193.
A stamp next to her signature indicates that she was a property manager for McCor Management. [ 3 ] The contracts also contained a clause outlining what the charges would be for services in either October or May, or if extra services were required. Of note in this clause is that the rate for a worker using a shovel was $65 per hour and the rate for a worker using a sweeper was $75 per hour. There would be a three-hour minimum along with a 30-minute travel charge.
It is unclear what the travel charge would be. [ 4 ] The contracts all contained a termination clause which read: This agreement is cancelable upon written 60 day notification by registered mail. Payments for services are due and payable upon cancellation. [ 5 ] All three contracts were terminated in writing by 193 on November 27, 2017, effective November 30, 2017. In the letter, 193 outlined six reasons for terminating the contract. Those reasons were: 1. Failure to provide proof of contractor's insurance. 2. Failure to provide proof of Workers' Compensation Board coverage. 3.
Failure to adequately clear walkways and city sidewalks.
4. Failure to clear snow pursuant to City of Edmonton Bylaw number 14600. 5. Failure to perform services as promised. 6. Failure to respond to emergency service requests on November 23, 2017 [ 6 ] After terminating the contract, 193 sent three payments to Mr. Engel. The amounts were: $4095 for Glenora, $5145 and $2100 for Holyrood. [ 7 ] In his decision, Judge Skitko found that the parties had entered into a six-month fixed term contract. He also found that 193 breached the contract. It did so by dismissing Mr. Engel for not responding to emergency service requests on November 23, 2017.
Judge Skitko found that Mr. Engel had 12 hours to respond to the request. Instead of waiting 12 hours, 193 hired somebody else to deal with the problem after only four hours. Judge Skitko also found that there was no breach by Mr. Engel for failure to provide proof of contractor insurance or WCB coverage and also no breach for noncompliance with the City Bylaw. [ 8 ] No evidence was ever presented at the trial to allow a determination of exactly what were the terms of the estimates. Ms. Autenbach did testify that she had requested monthly quotes from three contractors. Mr.
Engel’s estimate was between that of the other two. She also testified that monthly payments were usual in the business, as it provided incentive to the contractor to complete the work to ensure payment. [ 9 ] Mr. Engel testified that the contract amounts were based on monthly payments for the six-month term. He gave evidence that his cost to fulfil the three contracts would likely be somewhere between $5000 and $6000 per month. [ 10 ] Both parties agree that the standard of review is correctness regarding questions of law and palpable and overriding error regarding findings of fact.
Issue 1 Monthly or Total Remuneration [ 11 ] The parties disagree whether the compensation stated in the contract was monthly remuneration, or a price for the entire term of the contract. The three contracts were identical, except for the price. Under the heading “Pricing”, each contract stated, “as per estimate” and then the amount plus GST. [ 12 ] No actual estimates were produced at the trial. Instead, evidence was given regarding the estimates and the parties understanding of them. [ 13 ] Mr. Engel testified that he intended the price and the contract to be monthly compensation.
He set the monthly price using an estimate of 9 to 10 days work on each site during the period of the contract. He also testified that shortly after the contracts were terminated, 193 paid him $11,340. [ 14 ] A second witness, Ms. Aulenback, testified that she told Mr. Engel the contracts would be negotiated on a monthly payment basis for a fixed term of six months. She also testified that she told Mr. Engel his contract price had to be under $8400 per month and that Mr. Engel’s bid price was between the other two bids. [ 15 ] Daniel Barron testified on behalf of 193.
He was the senior property manager with McCor Management, the property management company for all the properties. He testified that he had reviewed previous snow maintenance contracts for the properties.
Combined, those contracts offered snow maintenance at the three properties for $6900 per month. [ 16 ] Although not specifically stated, Judge Skitko weighed the evidence and found that the amount in the contracts represented monthly compensation. [ 17 ] 193 submits that wording of the contracts clearly stipulates that the prices are not monthly payments, but rather amounts intended to cover the entire contractual term. [ 18 ] The Defendant relies on the term stated in the contract, “one six-month service effective November 1, 2017, expiring April 30, 2018”.
Those words come under the heading “Terms” and appear after the heading “Pricing”. As stated above, under the heading “Pricing”, each contract states, “as per estimate” and then an amount. [ 19 ] Neither party was able to produce the estimates. A reasonable person reading the entire contracts as a whole would understand that the estimate would be relevant to determining the nature of the contract. Unless one knows that terms of the estimate, there is ambiguity in the contract. [ 20 ] Parole evidence may be used to solve ambiguity in a contract.
Judge Skitko heard evidence from both parties regarding the estimates. This gave him a factual matrix to provide him with the opportunity to make an objective evaluation of the terms of the contract. [ 21 ] Post-contract evidence can also be used to solve ambiguity [1] . In this case, the payment of $11,300 at the end of November supports a finding that the contracts represented monthly payments. If the price in the contracts represented the entire compensation for the term of the contract, the entire compensation due to Mr. Engel would be $10,800. This is $500 less than what they paid Mr.
Engel for one month of work. [ 22 ] Judge Skitko’s objective evaluation was that the price quoted in the contracts was for monthly remuneration, not for the entire six months of the contract. This was a finding of fact. There is evidence to support such a finding. Findings of fact are entitled to deference unless there is palpable and overriding error. I find no such error.
Issue 2 Reliance on the Termination Clause [23] I find that Judge Skitko made no error in finding that 193 breached the three contracts. His findings of fact regarding theissues raised in the termination letter are entitled to deference unless there is palpable and overriding error. I find no such error. JudgeSkitko heard the evidence and made reasonable conclusions from that evidence. He then applied those facts to the law of contract andfound a breach by 193. [24] The evidence is clear that Mr. Engel was not given 12 hours to respond to the request for additional services.
Judge Skitko didfind that there was no evidence the WCB coverage was in place by November 1, 2017 as the contract required. He found that the lack ofWCB coverage entitled 193 to either revoke the contract or deny Mr. Engel’s company access to the properties. By doing neither, andinstead allowing access for snow removal, 193 did not have grounds to terminate the contract. Judge Skitko also found that there wasinsufficient evidence to support the allegation that Mr.
Engel’s company did not properly clear the sidewalks. [25] Having found that 193 breached the contract, Judge Skitko then made findings regarding the application of the 60-daytermination clause contained in the contract. He found that 193 could not rely on the termination clause because it had breached thecontract. He based this finding at least in part on the decisions of Southern Foundries
(1926) Ltd v Shirlaw, [1940] AC 701 andPetroplus Marketing AG v Shell Trading International Ltd, [2009] EWHC 1024. [26] Both of these decisions come from Great Britain. Although they may be persuasive, they are not binding on any level ofCanadian Court. From the transcript, it does not seem that Judge Skitko was ever provided with the case of Hamilton v Open WindowBakery Ltd, 2004 SCC 9. This case is binding on Canadian Courts. The facts are quite similar to the case at bar, in that the partiesentered into a contract that contained a termination clause.
Open Window Bakery terminated the contract, alleging a breach by Hamilton.It also sent a letter invoking the termination clause. At trial, it was found that Hamilton did not breach the contract. [27] In assessing damages, the trial judge awarded Hamilton the amount she would have received if the contract had continuedthrough the remainder of its term. The Ontario Court of Appeal disagreed with this approach. Instead, it awarded damages in accordancewith the termination clause.
In agreeing with the Court of Appeal’s decision, Justice Arbour wrote at para 20: The assessment of damages required only a determination of the minimum performance the plaintiff was entitled to under the contract,i.e., the performance which was least burdensome for the defendant. The plaintiff agreed at the outset that she was entitled to no moreby contracting for a contractual term that could be truncated with notice entirely at the discretion of the defendant. [28] The contract between 193 and Mr. Engel contained a termination clause that allowed either party to terminate the contract on60 days notice.
Applying the reasoning from Hamilton, the maximum award to Mr. Engel is 60 days compensation. [29] I find that Judge Skitko erred in law when he found that Mr. Engel should be entitled to compensation for the entire term ofthe contract. He should only be entitled to two months compensation. Issue 3 Determination of Damages [30] Having found that Mr. Engel is only entitled to compensation for two months, the question then becomes what is theappropriate amount of compensation?
Is it $21,600, representing full payment for two months, or a lesser amount representing Mr.Engel’s net profit for the two months? [31] It is clear from case law that in breach of contract cases, the injured party is only entitled to receive the net profit. Such anaward puts the injured party the same position the party would have been in if the contract had been completed. Both parties agree thatJudge Skitko erred by awarding the full monthly price instead of an amount representing the net monthly profit. [32] The onus is on Mr. Engel to prove his loss of profit.
This is a difficult task, as it requires a considerable amount ofspeculation. Mr. Engel’s business was essentially brand-new. The three terminated contracts were its first contracts. It had no trackrecord of profit and loss. No evidence was given regarding the number of snow days in the two months following Mr. Engel’stermination. Mr. Engel testified that his monthly expenses were between $5000 and $6000. This was based on nine snow days per month.Fewer snow days would likely increase is profit; more snow days would decrease his profit.
No other evidence was given to confirm hisprofit estimate. [33] It would be preferable to have a more precise calculation of lost profit. However, lack of precision is not fatal. In Murano vBank of Montreal, (ON SC), Justice Adams wrote at paragraph 170, “But once a defendant has been shown to havecaused a loss, liability should not be escaped because the amount of the loss cannot be proven with precision.” [34] Mr. Engel estimated that his expenses might be as high as $6000 per month. I find that this number should be used to calculatehis net profit.
According to the contracts, he would receive $10,800 per month. Deducting $6000 leaves $4800 per month in net profit.This means Mr. Engel’s loss of profit for two months would be $9600. In addition, the parties agree that there is another $735 owed toMr. Engel for a rock removal job. The total 193 owes to Mr. Engel is $10,335+ GST. Costs [35] Mr. Engel seeks solicitor client costs based on a term in the contracts. It is unclear if Mr. Engel is seeking interest pursuant tothe contracts. 193 seeks to have costs awarded against Mr. Engel.
Judge Skitko declined to order solicitor client costs, instead ordering atotal of $9150 in costs plus $100 for disbursements. He also ordered interest in accordance with the Judgment Interest Act.
[ 36 ] If the parties cannot agree on costs, they may make written submissions to me. Submissions can be no more than five pages and must be submitted within 30 days of this decision. Heard on the 10 th day of November, 2022. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 11 th day of April, 2023. G.R. Fraser J.C.Q.B.A. Appearances: Murray L. Engelking, Engelking Law for 1933748 Alberta Ltd and McCor Management (AB) Inc Tom Engel, Engel Law Office for Alex Engel
Loading document…