Christopher L. Hooge - v. -, 2023 ABKB 28
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Hooge v Hooge, 2023 ABKB 028 Between: Christopher L. Hooge - and - Jennyka C. Hooge Date: 20230117 Docket: 4803 185560 Registry: Edmonton Plaintiff/Respondent Defendant/Applicant _______________________________________________________ Supplementary Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice T.G. Rothwell _______________________________________________________ Background [1] I issued written Reasons for Judgment on December 7, 2022 in this matter reported at Hooge v Hooge, 2022 ABKB 824 .
Thereafter, some issues arose with respect to finalizing the terms of the resulting Corollary Relief Order. As well, I did not directly address ongoing s 7 expenses in my Reasons. On January 11, 2023, I received further submissions from the parties via Webex. Chris also wrote the Court on January 13, 2023 noting that Justice Richardson’s Order in 2019 modified Jennyka’s parenting time.
Page: 2 [2] I make the below outlined changes to my Reasons for Judgment dated December 7 th , 2022 ( “Reasons”) and address the payment of Jennyka’s arrears of child support, ongoing s 7 expenses, the parties’ respective income in 2022 and an oversight with respect to a debt owing on a 2013 snowmobile sold by Chris post-separation.
Correction of Judgment [3] The second sentence in paragraph 8 shall be replaced with the following: He proposes that Jennyka’s access remain similar (i .e. statutory long weekends, adjoining professional development days, shared/alternating holidays and 4 weeks in the summer). [4] The first bullet under paragraph 53 of my Reasons and the 3 208 of my Reasons shall be replaced with the following: rd and 5 th bullets at paragraph Jennyka shall have the children every second weekend from Friday evening to Sunday afternoon.
If the Monday or Friday associated with her weekend parenting time is a statutory holiday or school holiday, she shall have the children for the Monday or Friday and the drop off shall occur on Thursday evening and/or the pick up shall be on Monday evening. The drop off and pick up of B and K shall occur at the Crossfield Esso on the east side of Queen Elizabeth II Highway as this represents a closer half-way point. The drop off time shall be 7 pm and the pick up time shall be 4 pm. [5] This amendment to paragraph 53 clarifies my ruling on parenting time for Jennyka.
The Order of Justice Mah dated July 5, 2021 incorporated a number of prior Orders and I have considered those Orders. Jennyka is a capable parent, and this clarification ensures that both parents are able to spend long weekends with B and K and allows Jennyka meaningful time with the children. I decline to continue Jennyka’s access on statutory holiday weekends given the amount of driving involved between the parties’ respective locations and because she will have the children every second weekend.
I also provided Jennyka with an additional week of parenting time during the children’s summer break from school given that she does not have primary care of the children. [6] The fourth bullet under paragraph 53 of my Reasons and the fifth bullet under paragraph 208 of my Reasons shall be replaced with the following: Jennyka shall be entitled to have B and K for one 21-day block of time and one 14-day block of time during the months of July and August, with the two blocks not to be consecutive, and Chris shall have them for the remainder of July and August.
Jennyka shall advise Chris of her 21 day block of time on or before February 1 and Chris shall advise Jennyka of his 21 day block of time on or before February 7; Jennyka shall be required to select her remaining 14 day block on or before February 9. All communication shall be in writing. Chris is entitled to the remaining time in July and/or August. [7] This change is made to ensure both parties are able to select time that accords with their
schedule and recognizes Jennyka’s priority given that she does not have primary care of the children. I have also changed it from 15 and 10 day blocks to 21 and 14 day blocks as a result of a typographical error as my intent was to provide Jennyka with 5 weeks during the children’s summer break from school and Chris with 3 weeks to 4 weeks. Page: 3 [8] The parties agreed that Chris would have the children for Easter in 2023 and the rotation, as contemplated under Justice Mah’s order at para 4(
a) and 4(b), shall continue based upon Chris having the children in 2023.
Ongoing
Section 7 expenses [9] In my Reasons, I dealt with retroactive s 7 child support and ongoing s 3 child support; however, I did not address ongoing s 7 expenses. [10] Justice R.A. Graesser, by his Order dated March 12, 2020, ordered that effective March 1, 2020, s 7 expenses would be shared on a 63.10% (Chris) and 36.90% (Jennyka) basis. He ordered that the following s 7 expenses would be eligible: (
a) swimming, Scouts and childcare, (
b) medical/dental premiums; net health related expenses; physiotherapist; chiropractor over $100.00. Justice Grasser further ordered that each party provide copies of any receipts within 30 days. [11] I reviewed the extracurricular expenses incurred to date, considered the parties evidence regarding plans for extracurricular expenses and considered the parties’ incomes and I do not find that swimming, scouts or introductory golf qualify as extraordinary expenses for extracurricular activities. However, I order that the following s 7 expenses be shared on a proportionate basis: (
a) Childcare expenses incurred as a result of the employment, illness, disability or education or training for employment of the parties; (
b) That portion of the medical and dental insurance premiums attributable to the child; (
c) Health-related expenses that exceed reimbursement by at least $100 annually as set out in
section s 7(1)(
c) of the Federal Child Support Guidelines, SOR/97-175 . [12] My order with respect to ongoing s 7 expenses shall take effect January 1, 2023. The proportionate shares shall be 70.79% (Chris) and 29.21% (Jennyka) , based upon Chris’ 2021 income of $178,176 and Jennyka’s estimated income of $73,258. I order that any receipts be provided to the other party within 30 days of the expense being incurred. [13] Should the parties begin incurring more substantial s 7 expenses for extracurricular activities or post-secondary activities, they may bring an application seeking a variation. I am not seized with this matter.
Repayment of Arrears by Jennyka [14] I invited the parties to make submissions regarding the payment of Jennyka’s child support arrears. Jennyka requested that she be allowed to repay the outstanding arrears over a period of 48 months. Chris requested that they be repaid over a period of 24 months. I have had regard to Jennyka’s current income and current s 3 and s 7 childcare expenses and also noted that she did not make s 3 child support payments for significant periods of time.
Having regard to all of the circumstances, I order that Jennyka is entitled to pay the arrears over a period of 48 months in equal installments. There shall be a stay of enforcement on the arrears by the Alberta Maintenance Enforcement Program so long as she continues to pay the arrears and her ongoing s 3 and s 7 expenses. Page: 4 Parties’ Respective Income in 2022 [15] In my Reasons, I determined that Jennyka’s 2022 child support obligations will be based upon her estimated income of $73,528. I based this determination upon Jennyka’s own projection of what she believed her income would be in 2022.
During her submissions on January 11, 2023, Jennyka submitted that she overestimated what her income would be in 2022. [16] I am not prepared to alter my finding regarding Jennyka’s income for the year 2022. [17] I am prepared, however, to include a term in the Divorce Judgment and Corollary Relief Order that provides that both s 3 child support and s 7 expenses for the year 2022 can be adjusted after the parties have exchanged their respective tax documents so that the amounts payable are based upon their actual incomes earned in 2022.
For the purpose of determining Jennyka’s Guideline income in 2022, she shall not include in the calculation of her net self-employment income, any business expenses which have a personal component or provide her with a personal benefit. Division of Matrimonial Property [18] At paragraph 155 of my Reasons, I dealt with the disposition of a 2013 snowmobile by Chris. During submissions Chris noted that I did not take into account the outstanding debt on this snowmobile of $4,338 when I attributed an $8,000 adjustment to him in
Schedule “A” to my Reasons. During submissions, Chris requested a $2,000 adjustment in his favour. [19] In response, Jennyka raised the issue of a quad that was purchased for B. Reference was made to this quad during the trial; however, it was not included in either party’s sworn Matrimonial Property Statement (MPS) . [20] I am prepared to adjust the calculation regarding the 2013 snowmobile as it constitutes a calculation oversight on my part and the debt was included in the Chris’ MPS.
The equalization payment that Chris owes Jennyka shall be reduced to $4,625.60, which reflects an approximate adjustment for the outstanding debt. I am not prepared to make an adjustment regarding B’s quad given that it was purchased for B and is not included in either party’s sworn MPS. Heard on the 19 th to 23 rd day of September, 2022 and the 11th day of January 2023. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 17 th day of January, 2023. T.G. Rothwell J.C.Q.B.A. Appearances: Christopher L. Hooge for the Self-Represented Litigant Jennyka C. Hooge for the Self-Represented Litigant Page: 5
Loading document…