Fitzpatrick v Fitzpatrick, 2023 ABKB 281
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Fitzpatrick v Fitzpatrick, 2023 ABKB 281 Date: 20230510 Docket: 4801 185855 Registry: Calgary Between: Petra Fitzpatrick, Guenter and Hildegarde Doerfler Plaintiffs/Respondents - and - John Liam Fitzpatrick Defendant/Applicant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice L.K.
Harris _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Despite having already expressed my concerns regarding the behavior of the Respondents in this matter, they have continued to thwart the orderly resolution of certain matrimonial property issues between the Applicant, John Fitzpatrick, and the Respondent, Petra
Fitzpatrick. [ 2 ] Mr. Fitzpatrick has applied a second time to have Ms. Fitzpatrick and her parents, Guenter and Hildegarde Doerfler, declared to be in contempt of court for failing to abide by orders issued by the Court in this matter. He also seeks other alternative relief, including an order that the Doerflers vacate the property in question. I. Background [ 3 ] The factual background to this matter is summarized in Fitzpatrick v Fitzpatrick , 2022 ABKB 862 .
Briefly, the parties are involved in an acrimonious divorce action, and it appears that all issues, including child support, spousal support and the division of matrimonial property remain outstanding. [ 4 ] On August 18, 2022, Mr. Fitzpatrick brought an application in regular family chambers for the listing and sale of the matrimonial home and a condominium owned by him and Ms. Fitzpatrick on Arbour Lake Road, in Calgary. The Doerflers live in the condominium.
The parties disagree on the nature of the agreement giving rise to the Doerflers’ residence in the condominium, and the Doerflers have now claimed a beneficial ownership in the condominium. Regardless, the Fitzpatricks are the registered owners of the condominium. [ 5 ] After hearing the parties, I granted an order directing the listing and sale of the condominium but not the matrimonial home, with the sale proceeds to be held in trust pending the resolution of the matrimonial property dispute between the Fitzpatricks (the “August 18 th Order”). I gave Ms. Fitzpatrick a time-limited opportunity to purchase Mr.
Fitzpatrick’s interest in the condominium but she did not do so. She did not appeal my August 18 th Order. No one to my knowledge has applied for a stay of my August 18 th Order. [ 6 ] Mr. Fitzpatrick then retained a realtor to list the condominium for sale. Issues arose with respect to the realtor gaining access to the condominium to assess it for the purposes of the listing, and Mr. Fitzpatrick filed his first application to have Ms. Fitzpatrick and her parents declared in contempt of the August 18 th Order. On December 29 th , 2022, I issued my Memorandum of Decision in Fitzpatrick finding Ms.
Fitzpatrick in contempt but not the Doerflers. I could not conclude the Doerflers were in contempt, largely because the evidence relied upon by Mr. Fitzpatrick to show their contempt was hearsay evidence which could not support a contempt order. [ 7 ] In conclusion, I stated at para 62: “I concluded that the application for contempt against the Doerflers could not succeed as there was not sufficient evidence to establish contempt beyond a reasonable doubt.
However, there was sufficient evidence to cause me to have significant concern about the Doerflers’ interference in these matrimonial proceedings between the parties…” [ 8 ] I also gave further directions, including the following at para 59: “Further, Ms. Fitzpatrick and her parents will, within 7 days of their receipt of this decision, allow the listing realtor and a photographer to have access to the condominium for the purposes of a walk through, which will include permission for the realtor or her photographer to take pictures for the purposes of listing the condominium for sale.
All other terms of my August 18 th order shall remain in force.” [ 9 ] After Fitzpatrick was issued, Mr. Fitzpatrick took additional steps to list the condominium for sale. The realtor sought to do a walk-through of the condominium and take photographs and measurements for the listing. The parties disagree on the characterization of what exactly transpired but suffice it to say, the realtor did not list the property and has since withdrawn from the retainer, telling Mr. Fitzpatrick she felt threatened and intimidated by the Plaintiff and her parents.
In the meantime, the Doerflers filed a Statement of Claim advancing a claim of beneficial interest in the condominium and filed a certificate of lis pendens against title. [ 10 ] Mr. Fitzpatrick filed his second contempt application on March 3, 2023, and swore a second affidavit in support, setting out the chronology of events since Fitzpatrick was issued. He attached as exhibits a series of emails between his realtor, the Doerflers and their counsel and a series of letters between the Doerflers’ counsel and his counsel relating to access to the condominium. He argues that Ms.
Fitzpatrick and the Doerflers took active steps to thwart the listing of the condominium for sale by raising issues with the realtor taking photographs and measurements, and then when they did agree to have the realtor attend the condominium, they prevented her from accessing the entire unit, and were threatening and intimidating. [ 11 ] On the other hand, the Doerflers deny that their actions were in any way contrary to the August 18 th Order or my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision. They say that the evidence presented by Mr.
Fitzpatrick remains hearsay and cannot be relied upon as the basis for a finding of contempt against them. Because the concern about Mr. Fitzpatrick’s hearsay evidence was noted in my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision, I should award costs against Mr. Fitzpatrick for attempting to rely upon such evidence again. [ 12 ] Ms. Fitzpatrick really has little to say other than supporting her parents’ position. She expresses surprise at the realtor attending the condominium on February 8 th and does not believe she was threatening or intimidating.
She does argue that she has made attempts to resolve the issues between the parties, including by bringing an application for a litigation plan, and that Mr. Fitzpatrick has not complied with his disclosure obligations nor his obligations to pay support. Mr. Fitzpatrick disputes this, saying he is up to date on all his obligations. II. The Second Contempt Application [ 13 ] My December 29 th Memorandum of Decision provides a detailed overview of contempt proceedings and what the Applicant
must prove to succeed, and I need not repeat that here. In brief, the order in question must be clear, precise, and unambiguous, and hearsay evidence is not admissible to establish contempt: Fitzpatrick at paras 31 and 32 . [ 14 ] As with his first contempt application, Mr. Fitzpatrick relies upon emails and statements made by his realtor, without providing direct evidence by the realtor herself, describing the Doerflers’ actions. This is hearsay evidence, and I cannot rely upon it to find either Ms. Fitzpatrick or the Doerflers in contempt. [ 15 ] However, both the Doerflers and Ms.
Fitzpatrick provided affidavits in response to this second contempt application which provide some direct evidence as to what transpired. a. Are the Doerflers in Contempt of Court? [ 16 ] The Doerflers’ Affidavit includes the following: • On January 5, 2023, they received an email from the realtor asking to arrange a time to meet and view the condominium and to take photos and measurements. • The Doerflers were concerned about photos being taken for privacy reasons and on January 9 th proposed arranging for their own photographer.
The realtor indicated this was a reasonable request, but she still required a virtual tour and needed access to have floor plans and measurements taken. • The Doerflers arranged to have photographs taken on January 12 th by their own photographer and made those photographs available to the realtor. • There was an exchange of emails between counsel and then the Doerflers provided a copy of the MLS listing from 2013 when the condominium was purchased which included measurements. • There were further communications between counsel as to why the realtor needed to have her own measurements taken and whether the photographs taken on January 12 th were acceptable.
Ultimately, the Doerflers agreed that the realtor’s measurement technician could attend the condominium on February 8 th , 2023. Interestingly, the Doerflers make the following statement about this issue at para 24 of their affidavit: “we did not, and do not, understand that the August Order or the December Decision obligated us to permit Ms. Doull or a measurement technician to attend at our home for the purpose of taking measurements, but we acknowledge that permitting them to do so would facilitate the listing of the Condo in accordance with the August Order, so we co-operated.” • They were surprised when Ms.
Doull attended at the condominium along with the measurement technician on February 8 th , and although they admit they were “not happy” with her attendance they deny they were hostile or impeded them in any fashion. The Doerflers go on to state at para 28 of their affidavit: “during Ms. Doull’s visit to the Condo on February 8, 2023, she was able to view the entire Condo and ascertain that it was in good condition, though she was not permitted to enter each room so as to minimize the disturbance to our grandchildren’s schooling.” • The Doerflers then go on to provide their opinions as to the reasons why Mr.
Fitzpatrick was pursuing the sale of the condominium and to express their “deep concern” that the Court seems more concerned with “entertaining Mr.
Fitzptrick’s abusive serial contempt applications” than addressing their perceived issues with his behaviour around the transfer of funds from a HELOC and support payments. [ 17 ] The Doerflers, by virtue of my August 18 th Order, are compelled to cooperate with the listing realtor and allow access to the condominium to the listing realtor upon receiving 24 hours’ notice. [ 18 ] Further, my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision compels the Doerflers to allow the “listing realtor and a photographer to have access to the condominium for the purposes of a walk through, which will include permission for the realtor or her photographer to take pictures for the purposes of listing the condominium for sale”. [ 19 ] I find that on the Doerflers’ own Affidavit evidence, they are not in compliance with the terms of my August 18 th Order or my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision because they have failed to cooperate with the listing realtor. [ 20 ] I find that the word “cooperate” as used in the August 18 th Order, and when read in conjunction with the rest of the Order and the December 29 th Memorandum of Decision makes it clear what is expected.
The Doerflers were to allow the realtor access to the condominium on appropriate notice, which would permit her to take the steps necessary to further the listing of the condominium for sale. While the December 29 th Memorandum of Decision specifically mentions permitting photographs, it also directs that the realtor be permitted a walk-through.
The realtor explained why she required measurements to be taken on her behalf, and having measurements taken is included in the requirement that the Doerflers cooperate with the realtor and is part of the realtor performing a walk-through. [ 21 ] I find the Doerflers’ evidence that they did not understand my directions to include permission for a measurement technician to attend and their evidence expressing surprise that the realtor would attend the condominium with the measurement technician on
February 8 th to be disingenuous. It simply is not credible to assert that they expected a measurement technician to attend a residence without the listing realtor. They are asserting an unsupported and narrow
interpretation of my Orders in order to delay the listing and thwart the sale of the condominium. [ 22 ] In addition, the Doerflers acknowledge that they denied the realtor access to all the rooms within the condominium. I conclude that they impeded the realtor’s walk-through because, by the Doerflers’ own evidence, they were “not happy” about the realtor’s attendance. [ 23 ] I conclude that the Doerflers have obstructed the realtor’s access to the condominium for the purposes of conducting her walk-through and thus have failed to cooperate with her and have done so without reasonable excuse.
As such, they are in contempt of the August 18 th Order and my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision. [ 24 ] It appears that my warning to the Doerflers about interfering in these matrimonial proceedings has gone unheeded. b. Is Ms. Fitzpatrick Again in Contempt of Court? [ 25 ] Unlike the first contempt application, I cannot conclude that Ms. Fitzpatrick is in contempt a second time. It is the Doerflers who are now making decisions about how to respond to the realtor’s requests, and I do not have any non-hearsay evidence establishing that Ms.
Fitzpatrick is in breach of my directions beyond what I had concluded in my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision. III. Remedy [ 26 ] As I noted in my December 29 th Memorandum of Decision, Carey v Laiken , 2015 SCC 17 confirms that where Rules of Court do not prescribe the form of contempt proceedings, as a rule, they are bifurcated into a liability phase and, if liability is established, a penalty phase.
Having made a finding of contempt against the Doerflers here, they should be given the opportunity to purge their contempt, or, failing that, put forward an argument on penalty. [ 27 ] As I also noted in my December 29 th Memorandum, this Court has an interest in maintaining order in its proceedings and ensuring its directions are followed and have an inherent jurisdiction to control the proceedings before them. Pending any further application by Mr.
Fitzpatrick in regard to the penalty for contempt, I am compelled to address the Respondents’ behavior which has resulted in significant delay in the execution of my August 18 th Order for the listing and sale of the condominium. [ 28 ] Contrary to what was argued by the Doerflers before me, Mr. Fitzpatrick has sought alternative relief, including the eviction of the Doerflers from the condominium. Further, the Doerflers are now in a position where they have lost the benefit of the doubt in terms of cooperating with the listing process.
While I was previously prepared to accommodate the Doerflers’ concerns, their failure to abide by Court directions means that their convenience is less of a concern at this point. [ 29 ] Therefore, pending any further application on penalty, I make the following further directions: • Mr. Fitzpatrick and the realtor of his choosing will notify the Doerflers and Ms.
Fitzpatrick, through their respective counsel, no less than 24 hours in advance of the date and time the realtor will access the condominium for the purposes of a walk- through, taking photographs or measurements, or gathering any further information which in the sole opinion of the realtor is specifically required to allow the realtor to list the condominium for sale; • The Doerflers and if necessary, Ms. Fitzpatrick, will vacate the condominium suite and the building 1 hour in advance of the time chosen by the listing realtor and shall not return to the building until the listing realtor, through Mr.
Fitzpatrick’s counsel, has notified the Respondents’ counsel that the realtor has vacated the property; • Mr. Fitzpatrick and the realtor will notify the Doerflers and Ms. Fitzpatrick, through their respective counsel, no less than 24 hours in advance, of the date and time of any viewing of the condominium by a prospective buyer and their realtor; • The Doerflers, and if necessary, Ms. Fitzpatrick, will vacate the condominium suite and the building 1 hour in advance of any viewing scheduled and shall not return until the listing realtor, through Mr.
Fitzpatrick’s counsel, has notified the Respondents’ counsel that the prospective buyer or their realtor has vacated the property; • Although the Court should not have to emphasize this, given the Respondents’ behavior I will further direct that neither the Doerflers nor Ms. Fitzpatrick will interfere with or impede in any way the listing of the condominium for sale, including any access to the condominium by the listing realtor or a prospective buyer and the buyer’s realtor; • All other directions contained in my August 18 th Order and December 29 th Memorandum of Decision remain in force. IV.
Other Matters [ 30 ] The Doerflers, and to a lesser extent, Ms. Fitzpatrick, have raised two additional issues during this application. [ 31 ] First, they have suggested that addressing Mr. Fitzpatrick’s applications to list and sell the condominium and to find them in contempt in isolation from the remainder of the outstanding matrimonial issues is inappropriate, arguing that these applications should be
determined together with and in the context of the overall divorce and matrimonial property proceedings. The Doerflers critique what they perceive as the Court’s failure to address other issues within the matrimonial proceedings. [ 32 ] There are two points to be made. [ 33 ] The Doerflers are not parties to the matrimonial dispute between their daughter and Mr. Fitzpatrick. They do not have standing to challenge how the Court has addressed the issues brought before it.
Their interference in these proceedings continues to be a cause for concern to the Court and it will attract costs consequences for the increased delay, litigation and complexity arising as a result. [ 34 ] In addition, Mr. Fitzpatrick initially brought an application for the listing and sale of both the condominium and matrimonial home in regular family chambers. This Court granted his application in part based upon the evidence before it at the time. That order was not appealed by Ms. Fitzpatrick. Ms.
Fitzpatrick, who at the time was self-represented, having terminated the retainer of the latest of several counsel, did not bring any cross application for a resolution of what she says are outstanding issues. Although Ms. Fitzpatrick has pointed out that she scheduled a case conference to obtain a litigation plan and move the litigation forward as a whole, this was not done until well after Mr. Fitzpatrick’s application for listing and sale of the condominium was granted. [ 35 ] Any party has the right to bring particular issues in dispute to the Court for a determination.
The Court is bound to address such applications. While I will not comment on the other outstanding issues as they are not before me, if Ms. Fitzpatrick felt she had other issues to bring to the Court at the same time, she certainly had the right to do so, but she did not. [ 36 ] Second, the Doerflers inappropriately provide commentary in their Affidavit speculating about Mr. Fitzpatrick’s motivations in bringing his applications, characterizing them as abusive, and expressing their other “concerns” about the court process. Again, I will not comment upon the other outstanding issues and Mr.
Fitzpatrick’s actions in relation to those issues as they are not before me. Even if Mr. Fitzpatrick’s actions were worthy of comment, this does not give the Doerflers standing to interfere in the matrimonial litigation. [ 37 ] The Respondents’ intentions are to delay and thwart the Court’s orders. Their actions to date are not an appropriate way to deal with their concerns. V. Conclusion - Costs [ 38 ] The Doerflers shall pay costs of this contested application to Mr. Fitzpatrick on a solicitor-client basis. [ 39 ] I decline to award any costs in favour of Ms. Fitzpatrick. Heard on the 5 th day of April, 2023.
Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 10 th day of May, 2023. L.K. Harris J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Sonja Lusignan for the Plaintiff/Respondent Chadwick Newcombe for the Plaintiffs/Respondents (Mr. and Mrs. Doerfler)
Alex Harris for the Defendant/Applicant (Mr. Fitzpatrick)
Loading document…