Grimes v Governors of the University of Lethbridge, 2023 ABKB 287
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Grimes v Governors of the University of Lethbridge, 2023 ABKB 287 Date: 20230509 Docket: 2206 00498 Registry: Lethbridge Between: Austin Grimes Plaintiff - and - The Governors of the University of Lethbridge Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice Robert A. Graesser _______________________________________________________ I.
Introduction [ 1 ] Austin Grimes (the “Applicant”) seeks judicial review of a decision of the Appeal Committee of the Governors of the University of Lethbridge (the “Appeal Committee”) that upheld a one-year suspension of the Applicant from the University of Lethbridge, along with other sanctions. [ 2 ] The Appeal Committee’s decision resulted from an appeal by the Applicant of a decision of the University General Faculties
Council Academic Appeal Committee (“GFC”). The GFC decision resulted from a hearing to consider a joint recommendation from the University’s Chief Safety Officer (the “Safety Officer”) and the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences (the “Dean”) that the Applicant be suspended from registering from courses at the University for one year. [ 3 ] The discipline proceedings against the Applicant resulted from a dispute between the Applicant and one of the Applicant’s professors (the “Professor”) about her marking of an assignment handed in by the Applicant. II.
Background [ 4 ] The underlying facts are not in dispute. Almost all of them come from text and email communications from or to the Applicant, the Professor, and various University officials including the Safety Officer and the Dean or the Dean’s Office. [ 5 ] In this decision, I will not describe all of the communications between the Applicant and the Professor. The Record of the proceedings before the Appeal Committee is comprehensive. There is no suggestion that there are missing communications or records relevant to this matter.
The Applicant’s argument concerning non-disclosure of records relates to the Board of Governor’s internal Appeal Procedures, which I will deal with in my analysis. My analysis includes only the communications I consider important to this application. [ 6 ] In the fall of 2021, the Applicant was a student in the faculty of Arts and Sciences. One of the Applicant’s courses was Social and Political Philosophy, taught by the Professor.
During this period, classes were being conducted online because of the Covid- 19 epidemic. [ 7 ] The Applicant enjoyed the course and was impressed by the Professor, frequently meeting with the Professor after class to discuss the course. After receiving a poor mark on an assignment, the Applicant emailed the Professor on November 6, 2021, expressing the Applicant’s disagreement with the grade, which the Applicant believed to be unwarranted and unfair.
The Professor advised that she had marked the assignment down because it was handed in late and exceeded the mandated length for the paper. [ 8 ] The Applicant continued the email exchange, leading to the Professor to advise the Applicant as to the appropriate appeal process for a disputed grade. The Applicant persisted in emailing the Professor, who eventually advised that she “considered the matter closed” and advising the Applicant to contact the Associate Dean of Arts and Sciences to
schedule a meeting with her if the Applicant wanted to pursue the matter further. [ 9 ] Not satisfied with that response, the Applicant continued to email the Professor, initially requesting a Zoom meeting.
The Professor continued to reply that she considered the matter closed, and continuing to advise the Applicant as to the University’s grade appeal process. [ 10 ] The Applicant’s emails continued that day, ending with telling the Professor she was a “heartless tyrant”. [ 11 ] The Professor immediately consulted the Dean’s office with her concerns about the tone of the Applicant’s emails, and ultimately advised the Applicant that the tone and the number of the Applicant’s emails were inappropriate, and that henceforth she would require a third party to be present at any office hour meetings with her.
She also advised that any such meetings would be restricted to 15 minutes in length. The Professor warned that further inappropriate emails or inappropriate behaviour by the Applicant would give her reason to file a formal complaint against the Applicant under the University’s Student Citizenship Policy. [ 12 ] Before this dispute arose, the office meetings between the Professor and the Applicant had been one-on-one with no time limits. Many of the after-class meetings had apparently been quite lengthy. [ 13 ] The Applicant emailed the Professor asking for an office meeting.
On November 8, the Professor emailed the Applicant asking for potential times for the meeting and advising the Applicant that she had found a suitable third party to attend this meeting with the Applicant. [ 14 ] The Applicant took offence to these restrictions on contact and emailed the Professor that the Applicant found them “humiliating” and asked her to reconsider the “punishment”. The Professor responded that the arrangement was an “effective way to create boundaries”. [ 15 ] The Applicant’s response was: I will need you to apply a punishment more suitable to the misbehavior.
I am a reasonable person who acted under the heat of passion. But passion, however, that was not one of rage, nor of any sort of aggressive emotion. It was my feeling of disappointment from a volition of admiration of your person. I cannot atone unless by dessert corresponding suitability. [ 16 ] The Professor replied that she was not issuing a punishment but rather was drawing boundaries. She repeated that she was not willing to discuss the matter any further.
She also repeated that she would only meet the Applicant with another person present and told the Applicant that she would no longer answer any of the Applicant’s emails to her. [ 17 ] The Professor’s response resulted in a number of emails from the Applicant including a flattering email followed by telling her to stop acting like an asshole. [ 18 ] As a result of these emails, the Professor went to the Dean’s office to see if arrangements could be made so that she would no longer have to have any contact with the Applicant. Dr.
Rodriguez, the Associate Dean, arranged a meeting with the Applicant for November 23, at which time the Applicant was advised that the Professor wanted no further contact with the Applicant, but she was not pursuing discipline proceedings.
[ 19 ] The Applicant was told the Applicant would be able to complete the philosophy course he was taking with the Professor but would not be able to take any further courses from her. The next day the Applicant was given a letter outlining these directions and advising that the Applicant could complete the course by watching the recordings of the online classes, but that the Applicant could not attend the live broadcasts. The Applicant promptly replied that the Applicant would act according to the requirements in the letter. [ 20 ] Later that day, the Applicant signed into the Professor’s online class. Dr.
Rodriguez quickly emailed the Applicant reiterating the requirements that had been imposed, but the Applicant would not sign out and was ultimately removed from the broadcast. [ 21 ] Because of this, on November 26 Doug Mackie, the University’s Chief Safety Officer, emailed the Applicant advising that there needed to be a meeting between them to address the restrictions imposed by the Dean’s Office and what repercussions there would be if there were any further breaches.
He scheduled a meeting for November 29. [ 22 ] The Applicant responded saying that the Applicant “would not be meeting with anyone that Monday” but would be available on Tuesday. Mr. Mackie wrote back saying that the Applicant should reschedule whatever was planned for November 29 and attend the meeting set for that day. [ 23 ] The Applicant responded to that email saying, “I have been provided with no information supporting my duty as a student to act on this urgency”. [ 24 ] Mr.
Mackie then sent the Applicant a copy of the University’s Student Discipline Policy, and advised the Applicant that because the Applicant had disrupted the Professor and her class and disregarded the restrictions on contact with the Professor after having been given them and agreeing to abide by them, a decision regarding discipline would be made on November 29, and the meeting would proceed in the Applicants absence if the Applicant did not attend. [ 25 ] On November 27, the Applicant emails the Professor saying, “I understand that I am violating your instructions by sending you this email, but it must be done.” The Applicant offered to comply with the restrictions if the Professor communicated them to the Applicant directly and not through a third party. [ 26 ] The Applicant also stated “(
I) will do my best to not communicate” with the Professor, but if the Applicant did need to make any additional communications with her, it would be to promote her well-being. [ 27 ] The Professor did not respond to the email, and the Applicant sent 2 further emails to her on November 28, threatening to make a human rights complaint against her unless she contacted the University Administration to convince them to have all disciplinary proceedings against the Applicant terminated.
The Applicant’s email concluded: If you do not contact the Chief Safety Officer, the Executive Director of Student Services, and the Arts & Science Associate Dean, explain to them that there has been a misunderstanding, and then have them retract and apologize for their negligence, I will explain to the Albert Human Rights Commission EXACTLY how you have manipulated them. After this, we will deal with some of your other misbehavior. [ 28 ] On receipt of these emails, the Professor went to see Doug Mackie as she felt afraid and harassed. [ 29 ] The Applicant did not attend the meeting with Mr.
Mackie on November 29. On November 30, the Applicant was provided with a letter advising that it was clear that the Applicant’s behaviour was disruptive of, and a threat to, the teaching and learning environment at the University of Lethbridge and that Mr. Mackie and Dean Matt Letts would be submitting a joint recommendation to the Associate Vice-President (Students) that the Applicant be suspended.
The letter further advised that if the Associate Vice-President found the recommendation for suspension to be appropriate, the matter would be heard by the GFC Appeal Committee. [ 30 ] The letter also advised that the Applicant could still complete the philosophy course but was still required to follow the previous restrictions on communications with the Professor. [ 31 ] The Applicant immediately emailed the Professor saying: I need you to know that I am being suspended because of your misconduct…I am going to see a doctor soon for the trauma I have incurred.
I still believe you are someone that would help me recover from it. If you said sorry it would really help. [ 32 ] On December 2, a letter of discipline was sent to the Applicant excluding the Applicant from entering onto the University of Lethbridge campus and restricting the Applicant’s University email address from being able to deliver emails to the Professor. [ 33 ] The Applicant continued to email the Professor between December 8 and December 17, advising her that she had violated University procedures by imposing a penalty.
The Applicant threatened to make a human rights complaint that the Professor had incited others at the University to harass the Applicant, and the Applicant threatened to make further human rights complaints unless the Applicant could be enrolled in one of her courses. [ 34 ] On December 21 a designate for the Associate Vice-President (Students) sent a joint recommendation letter to the Chair of the GFC Appeal Committee advising that she considered the recommendation for suspension to be in order.
The letter from the Associate Vice-President (Students) noted that there had been previous behaviour concerns in the past and summarized additional concerns about the Applicant that the Professor had expressed in a November 15 interview between the Professor and Campus Safety. Copies of the letter and the suspension recommendation were sent to the Applicant. [ 35 ] Later that day, the Applicant sent 3 emails to the Professor enclosing a draft human rights complaint against her.
The Applicant also wrote to the Associate Vice-President (Students) advising that the Applicant would not be attending the GFC Appeal Committee hearing as the Applicant “didn’t feel safe providing any more correspondences to any more members of the University Community until the decision is made”. The Applicant requested a Zoom meeting with the Professor.
[ 36 ] On December 22, the Applicant emailed Doug Mackie and Dr. Letts: I advise both of you to step down beginning in the new year to avoid legal action being taken against the both of you. Charges: Breach of Contract, Nuisance, Mental Suffer Caused Willfully, Decit (sic), Fraud, Breach of Duty to Care, Breach of Standard of Care, Harassment, and Discrimination, and others to come.
Given the lack of communication from Lets during this altercation, I will offer him the chance to issue me a letter of apology CC’s to (the Professor) retracting each and every statement issued in your jointed (sic) letter of recommendation and thereafter his taking leave for the 2022 Spring semester. I will expect this letter by Friday. This is the last and only communication I will provide to the either of you.
All future correspondence will be redirected to (the Professor) to inform her of the untrue allegations you made against her. [ 37 ] Four more emails were sent to the Professor by the Applicant on January 5 and 6, 2022, one of which stated, “students aren’t safe with you”. [ 38 ] On January 7, 2022, the Applicant was notified of that the hearing before the GFC Appeal Committee would be held on January 21. The Applicant was advised that submissions could be made in person or via written submissions.
Details were provided as to how the Applicant might access all materials that would be considered by the GFC Appeal Committee.
The Applicant was advised that all emails sent by the Applicant to or regarding the Professor would form part of the evidence the GFC Appeal Committee would consider. [ 39 ] On January 12, 2022, the Applicant sent an email to 5 of the Professor’s colleagues accusing her of breaching the collective agreement and the Post-Secondary Learning Act , SA 2003, c P-19.05 (the “ Act ”) as well as engaging in harassment against the Applicant. [ 40 ] Doug Mackie emailed the Applicant advising that the email to the Professor’s colleagues breached the University’s harassment policy. [ 41 ] The Applicant submitted written arguments to the GFC Appeals Committee on January 16 and 19, objecting to the proceedings against him on several grounds: 1.
The suspension was a violation of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights ; 2. The Professor’s decision to require a third party to be present at meetings and other limitations on contact were forms of discipline under the Post-Secondary Learning Act that were beyond the Professor’s powers; 3. The discipline imposed breached a contract between the Applicant and the Professor; and 4. The discipline violated the Applicant’s human rights. [ 42 ] The GFC Appeals Committee met on January 21 and considered the matter. The Applicant was not present.
A written decision was given on January 27 and directed that the Applicant be suspended from the University for one year, along with other conditions which included a restriction from communications with the Professor during the suspension. [ 43 ] The decision was emailed to the Applicant on January 27. The email also advised the Applicant of the right to appeal the decision to the Board of Governors Appeal Committee within 30 days, [ 44 ] After receiving the decision, the Applicant emailed an instructor seeking assistance in challenging the suspension.
In the email, the Applicant wrote: So, what’s left for me now? I need A LOT in return. First of all, I need her to be punished, and not even to promote any good, but as a good in-itself.
Second of all, I need almost every member of the university community who has any morsal of authority to undergo some form of mutilation, literally or figuratively: I don’t’ want their money, I want their humanity. [ 45 ] The Applicant emailed the Professor on January 29 accusing her of denying the Applicant’s humanity, calling her a heartless tyrant, and inviting her to have a video call. [ 46 ] On February 8, the Applicant emailed materials to the University constituting an appeal of the Suspension Decision.
The gist of the objections to the BOG Appeal Committee were that: • The GFC Appeal Committee did not integrate the Applicant’s written responses; • Alternatively, the GFC Appeal Committee did not read the responses; • The Professor should have been required to attend the hearing; • The Applicant was a student in high standing and this was the first complain made about the Applicant; and • The Professor retaliated against the Applicant for following the University’s Harassment and Discrimination Policy’s recommendation for affected members to “let the other member of the University Community know that their conduct is of concern.” [ 47 ] The BOG Appeal Committee met on February 22 and 23, 2022.
The appeal proceeded on the basis of the written materials submitted by the Applicant and the record of the proceedings before the GFC Appeal Committee.
[48] In a written decision dated February 24, the BOG Appeal Committee upheld the decision of the GFC Appeal Committee. [49] The Applicant emailed the University on February 25 disagreeing with the decision, stating the proceedings were a mistrial,and seeking a new hearing.
The response sent to the Applicant that day advised the Applicant that all processes available through theUniversity were now concluded, and the GFC Appeal Committee decision was final. [50] The Applicant filed this application for Judicial Review on August 24, 2022, returnable September 21, 2022. [51] The Applicant filed a brief of argument on September 20, 2022. On September 21, the application was adjourned to a specialchambers application, which was ultimately heard by me on March 21, 2023. [52] The University filed its response brief on February 21, 2023.
On March 20, the Applicant filed an affidavit dealing withvarious email issues. Grounds for review [53] The Applicant’s Originating Application states the following grounds: 1. That the Appeal Committee failed to consider the two procedural fairness issues raised before them, namely: a. It established most or all of its facts without evidence; and b. The proceedings were vexatious. 2. That the Appeal Committee failed to comply with the duty of procedural fairness because: a.
The BOG Appeal Procedures Policy and the standard of review and procedural fairness and natural justice pillars establishedwithin that policy were not disclosed to the Applicant beforehand; and b. The Appeal Committee did not follow the procedural fairness and natural justice pillars established in the BOG Appeal ProceduresPolicy; 3. That the Academic Appeals Committee did not comply with the duty of procedural fairness for establishing most or all of its factswithout evidence; 4.
That the Appeal Committee’s decision that decision makers who are “progressive disciplinary” decisions (and in particular theProfessor) afforded the appropriate level of fairness is incorrect; 5. Alternatively, the Appeal Committee’s decision entails the retraction of the Academic Appeal Committee’s decision that theProfessor had triggered the duty of fairness, then the Appeal Committee’s decision entails an abuse of the decision-making process aswell as the fundamental breakdown of the University’s orderly exercise of authority to the point that bad faith can be presumed; and 6.
The progressive discipline was an abuse of process. III. Standard of Review [54] The parties do not disagree over the principles of standard of review. Rather, they disagree on the characterization of some ofthe issues. [55] The Applicant appropriately cites Law Society of Saskatchewan v Abrametz, 2022 SCC 29 in in the context of judicial reviewof disciplinary decisions.
The Applicant also refers to Andres v University of Lethbridge, 2021 ABQB 551. [56] The University relies on Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65, Karri v University ofCalgary, 2021 ABQB 117, and Andres v University of Lethbridge, 2021 ABQB 551. [57] The basic principles for judicial review come from Vavilov: 1. The presumptive standard for judicial review of an administrative tribunal’s decision on errors of fact or errors of mixed fact andlaw is the deferential standard of reasonableness, provided the tribunal passes the standard set out in Pushpanathan v.
Canada (Ministerof Citizenship and Immigration), (SCC), [1998] 1 SCR 1222; and 2. The non-deferential correctness standard of review applies to: a. Legislation specifying a different standard of review; b. Breaches of natural justice such as procedural fairness, abuse of process, and bias; c. Questions of law; and d.
Interpretation of the tribunal’s “home statute” except where issues of importance to the general legal community are involved; [58] Karri and Andres demonstrate that a fresh Pushpanathan analysis is not necessary on judicial review of decisions from the
Board of Governors of an Alberta post-secondary institution. [ 59 ] It is clear from Vavilov that where the reasonableness standard applies, the onus is on the party challenging the ruling to prove its unreasonableness. [ 60 ] Legislation specifying a different standard of review includes legislation that provides for an appeal to a court. The Post- Secondary Institutions Act , SA 2003, c P-19.5 (the “ Act ”) is silent on reviews or appeals from decisions of a Board of Governors, thus the appellate standard of review does not apply here.
The Act is also silent on standards of review to be applied on judicial review from such decisions, so the reasonableness standard clearly applies to judicial review from an Appeal Committee decision. [ 61 ] CUPE v Ontario (Minister of Labour), 2003 SCC 29 clearly defines the distinction between substantive issues (the end review of the decision itself) and procedural fairness (the manner in which the tribunal went about making its decision) at para 102.
Judicial review standards apply to the decision itself, while common law principles apply to the procedural issues having regard to their context. [ 62 ] Abrametz involved a judicial review where the applicable legislation provided for an appeal to the Court.
In that situation, the standard of review was determined to be the same standards as applied in a provincial court of appeal: correctness for questions of law, and palpable and overriding error for questions of fact or questions of mixed fact and law. [ 63 ] Relying on Cote J’s dissent, the Applicant argues that Abrametz should be interpreted as changing the standard of review for procedural fairness to one of reasonableness.
I must admit that I do not understand the Applicant’s position on this, as the reasonableness standard is the deferential standard which is usually the most problematic standard for applicants on judicial review. Additionally, little can be taken from Cote J’s dissent. Her opinions are of interest but not binding. It was also not a close case: the majority consisted of the other 8 judges on the Court. [ 64 ] I do not fault the Applicant for having difficulties with standard of review issues. They are complicated and have for decades been moving targets in the courts.
The “nutshell” approach for now is as described above. The challenge for the courts is to correctly characterize the issue as either a question of law, a question of mixed fact and law, or a question of fact. Questions of mixed fact and law are essentially questions as to whether the facts as found were correctly applied to the law. Questions of law are whether the law was correctly applied to the facts as found.
I do not see that this case helps the Applicant in any way. [ 65 ] The Applicant cites Cote J’s decision at para 179 relating to the duty of procedural fairness: [179] This Court’s jurisprudence on procedural fairness review may thus be synthesized as follows. The reviewing court must apply the correctness standard to questions of compliance with the duty of procedural fairness as defined by the common law or by statute. The requirements of fairness are context-dependent, and deference is owed to the administrative decision maker’s underlying findings of fact.
In reviewing procedural issues, the court’s role is to determine whether the proceedings comport with minimum fairness requirements in a particular situation. Stated differently, the court must refrain from dictating what it considers to be the optimal procedure among the options that meet this standard. [ 66 ] This is a useful description of how to approach this task. Cote J’s dissent was based on her disagreement turned on her views of administrative delay and not basic principles as articulated above. IV. Positions A. Applicant [ 67 ] The Applicant’s position became clearer in oral argument.
Basically, the Applicant complains that the Professor had a duty to the Applicant to meet with the Applicant outside class and to respond to written communications. The Applicant draws these duties from the University’s Undergraduate Calendar and Course Catalogue, which affords students classroom privileges and course-related privileges. [ 68 ] Those duties are not included in any University materials on student rights. The Applicant draws from the Student Enrolment and Registrar Services form for requesting to audit a course.
That form advises that to audit a course: …a student must have permission from the instructor to attend classes on the understanding that the student may not participate in class discussions (except by invitation of the instructor), submit assignments or sit for examinations. [ 69 ] The Applicant argues that by implication, students actually taking the course may participate in class discussions, and those were taken away from the Applicant by the direction from the Chief Safety Officer. [ 70 ] The Applicant also refers to the Collective Agreement between the University and the Academic Staff, which provides: Members shall be reasonably available for out of class discussions with students.
Students shall have equal opportunity for such discussions. [ 71 ] The Applicant says that refusing to meet with the Applicant unless a third party was present, limiting the length of any such meetings to 15 minutes, and refusing to respond to non-course related issues by email amounted to discipline against the Applicant and a breach of the Professor’s obligations under the Collective Agreement. [ 72 ] As a result, the Applicant argues that before imposing any disciplinary measures, the Professor should have met with the Applicant, notified the Applicant as to the specific behaviour she found objectionable, and afforded the Applicant an opportunity to
respond to her concerns. That was not done, and the process against the Applicant should be returned to that stage of the proceedings. [ 73 ] Alternatively, if the Professor did not impose discipline on the Applicant, the Applicant argues that all subsequent proceedings were marred by bad faith, they were abusive, and the proceedings were procedurally unfair, including making fact findings without supporting evidence or without sufficient evidence, failure to disclose relevant materials to the Applicant, and by failing to consider relevant factors. B.
University [ 74 ] At the outset, the University objects to the inclusion of the Applicant’s Affidavits of August 24, 2022 and March 20 , 2023. They argue that the Applicant did not seek the Court’s leave for the introduction of either affidavit, and introduction is usually permitted only on exceptional circumstances. [ 75 ] On the merits, the University denies that there was any procedural unfairness leading to the Applicant’s suspension or want of statutory authority from the outset. [ 76 ] It argues that the Professor did not impose any disciplinary measures on the Applicant.
Instead, the measures were “boundaries” imposed on the Applicant because of the Applicant’s conduct. [ 77 ] The University argues that nothing in the calendar, or even the Collective Agreement (which it denies being applicable to the student-instructor relationship) that gives a student the right to one-on-one office hours meetings with the student without a third party being present.
Nowhere is it stated that students have a right to communicate with an instructor on non-course related issues. [ 78 ] Even if it could be argued that the Collective Agreement applies here, the University argues that the measures taken by the Professor were reasonable. [ 79 ] As for procedural fairness, the University submits that the Appeal Committee’s appeal process and the original suspension decision by GFC were procedurally fair. The University notes that it is the BOG Appeal Committee Decision that is being reviewed here, not the GFC decision.
The Appeal Committee Decision was based solely on the record before it and the Appeal Committee followed its usual procedures. It was not a hearing de novo such that no new investigation was conducted. [ 80 ] The University argues that the Appeal Committee decision was reasonable and that it was not required, contrary to the Applicant’s submissions, to individually address the Applicant’s “objections to fact”. They characterize the Applicant’s arguments about making fact findings without evidence as referring to hearsay.
The University points out that administrative tribunals are not generally bound by the rules of evidence, such that hearsay may be considered. [ 81 ] As for not providing the Applicant with the Appeal Committee Appeal Procedures, the University disagrees that this amounted to a denial of the Applicant’s right to procedural fairness or a breach of
section 4 of the Administrative Procedures and Jurisdiction Act , RSA 2000, c A-3 . [ 82 ] The University also denies that the proceedings were in any way vexatious, an abuse of process, or were carried out in bad faith. Legislative Provisions [ 83 ]
Section 31 of the Act gives GFC the power over student discipline: Student discipline 31
(1) The general faculties council has general supervision of student affairs at a university and in particular, but without restricting the generality of the foregoing, the general faculties council may (
a) subject to a right of appeal to the board, discipline students attending the university, and the power to discipline includes the power (
i) to fine students, (ii) to suspend the right of students to attend the university or to participate in any student activities, or both, and (iii) to expel students from the university; (
b) delegate its power to discipline students in any particular case or generally to any person or body of persons, subject to any conditions with respect to the exercise of any delegated power that it considers proper; (
c) give to a student organization of the university the powers to govern the conduct of students it represents that the general faculties council considers proper.
(2) Any powers to govern the conduct of students given to a student organization pursuant to subsection (1)(
c) are subject to the overriding control of the board, the president and the general faculties council. [ 84 ] The powers of deans are set out in para 21:
Deans 21(1) The board of a university shall appoint a dean for each faculty of the university.
(2) A dean of a faculty (
a) repealed 2008 c25 s3 , (
b) has general supervision over and direction of the academic work and instructional staff of the faculty and of the officers and employees employed in connection with that work, and (
c) has the other powers, duties and functions that are assigned to the dean by the president.
(3) The president may appoint a member of the instructional staff of a faculty who shall act as dean in the event of the absence or inability to act of the dean of the faculty or during any vacancy in the office of a dean.
(4) A dean may delegate any of the dean’s powers, duties and functions as the dean considers appropriate and may prescribe conditions governing the exercise or performance of any delegated power, duty or function, including the power of subdelegation. [ 85 ]
Section 4 of the Administrative Procedures and Jurisdiction Act states: Evidence and representations 4 Before an authority, in the exercise of a statutory power, refuses the application of or makes a decision or order adversely affecting the rights of a party, the authority (
a) shall give the party a reasonable opportunity of furnishing relevant evidence to the authority, (
b) shall inform the party of the facts in its possession or the allegations made to it contrary to the interests of the party in sufficient detail (
i) to permit the party to understand the facts or allegations, and (ii) to afford the party a reasonable opportunity to furnish relevant evidence to contradict or explain the facts or allegations, and (
c) shall give the party an adequate opportunity of making representations by way of argument to the authority. [ 86 ] As submitted by the Applicant, discipline for student “non-academic misconduct” is dealt with under the “Student Discipline Policy – Non Academic Offences Undergraduate and Graduate Students”. That Policy is attached hereto as
Schedule “1”. [ 87 ] What is most noteworthy in the guidelines is the procedure specified in appendix A-1, Procedures: Non-Academic Offences in Instructional Space, Research Facilities or Library. If a student is disruptive, the instructor has the right to immediately exclude the student from instructional space and/or from future scheduled instructional meetings of that course pending further actions by the Dean. The procedure provides: The instructor must immediately notify the Dean of the Faculty or School in which the course is offered or in which the research is being undertaken. Such notification must be by means of a signed statement as per
Section 7.2 above. Once the statement is received, the Dean will notify both the Chief Safety Officer and the Associate Vice-President (Students) or designate and provide each of them with a copy of the signed statement. [ 88 ] The procedure requires the Dean to meet with the Student to refer to the Non-Academic Policy; to consult with Campus Safety, the Associate Vice-President (Students) and others as required; and to place a letter of reprimand in the Student’s file in the Registrar’s office. [ 89 ] A.4 allows the Student to appeal either the charge or the penalty to the Vice-President (Academic). V.
Analysis [ 90 ] The Applicant argues that the Professor imposed discipline by restricting communications and putting restrictions on meetings during office time. That has been a central complaint throughout all of the proceedings.
The Applicant also takes issue with the process involving the Dean’s Office and Campus Safety that lead to the joint recommendation to the Associate Vice-President (Students) that the Applicant be suspended. [ 91 ] The substance of this judicial review, however, is not concerned with what the Professor did or didn’t do, or what the Dean’s Office and Campus Safety did or didn’t do, but rather what the BOG Appeal Committee did or did not do.
The Appeal Committee’s mandate was to hear the Applicant’s appeal from the decision of the GFC Academic Appeal Committee, not from the Professor’s directions or those from the Dean and Campus Safety. [ 92 ] To be successful on this application, the Applicant must demonstrate that the decision of the BOG Appeal Committee did not meet the required standard of review on the various issues raised. The BOG Appeal Committee did not conduct a fresh hearing; their
responsibility was to review the record of what transpired at the GFC Appeal Committee and decide whether to intervene or not. [ 93 ] In other words, this application reviews only the BOG Appeal Committee’s decision and it is not a review of the GFC Appeal (see Yee v Chartered Professional Accountants of Alberta , 2020 ABCA 58 . [ 94 ] This is where Abrametz may be of some assistance, in that the appeal to the BOG Appeal Committee is analogous to a statutory right of appeal, where normal appellate standards of review would apply: correctness on issues of law and procedural fairness, and palpable and overriding error on issues of fact and mixed fact and law. [ 95 ] In turn, the appeal to the BOG Appeal Committee substitutes “reasonableness” for “palpable and overriding error” on issues of fact and mixed fact and law. [ 96 ] It should be noted that the Applicant did not attend the discipline meeting with Campus Safety and the Dean’s Office.
The Applicant did not attend the GFC Appeal Committee hearing, although made written submissions which were included in the evidence before the GFC Appeal Committee. [ 97 ] Those submissions included a claim that the proposed suspension would violate the Applicant’s human rights as set out in
Article 5 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) relating to torture or to cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment, and
Article 25.1 relating to security. [ 98 ] The Applicant objected to the inclusion in the record of a 2019 incident involving the Applicant but unrelated to the Professor. [ 99 ] The Applicant argued that the restrictions imposed by the Professor and by Campus Safety were unlawful because discipline could only be imposed by GFC.
The Applicant argued that the result of these actions as a violation of the Applicant’s classroom privileges and course-related privileges. [ 100 ] The Applicant appears to have recognized that an instructor could take certain actions in the face of disruption, as could the Dean under the Student Discipline Policy.
However, the Applicant suggested that there were other things that could have been done to address the situation. [ 101 ] The Applicant stated: …instructors who suspend the classroom or course-related privileges of students in any other way or without referring a corresponding complaint to the Dean AAP would thereby violate the student’s right to have their right to participate in student activities suspended only by the General Faculties Council and those persons it has delegated its power to. [ 102 ] The Applicant noted that at the beginning of the course, the Professor emailed the 40 students taking the class (during Covid) about her office hours and advising that she would have 30 minutes of open office on zoom at 8 PM, one day a week.
However, during the course she apparently “revoked” those hours for the Applicant because the Applicant was attending the course in person and often met with her for 40 minutes or so after class. [ 103 ] The Applicant complains that the Professor “expelled” his student rights, thereby violating the Applicant’s civil rights. [ 104 ] The facts summarized in GFC’s January 27 decision start with the Professor seeking assistance with the developing situation by contacting the Dean’s Office on November 12, 2021, noting: …where the Instructor had not been overly concerned for their personal safety before, the Instructor was not concerned due to the frequency and increasingly aggressive comments and behaviours of the Student, despite reasonable requests from the Instructor to balance instructor and student rights. [ 105 ] The Decision itself states: The Committee finds that there was ample evidence supporting the determination that the behaviour displayed is troubling and worrisome. … The Committee finds there was ample opportunity for the Student to fully understand the seriousness of complying by the condition if not contacting the Instructor and understanding that it was wrong, and that the behaviour continued with increasing escalation, including the Student continually contacting the Instructor and also the Instructor’s colleagues about the Instructor. [ 106 ] The Applicant appealed the GFC decision to the BOG Appeal Committee.
In the Applicant’s appeal submissions sent February 14, 2022, the Applicant focused entirely on the Applicant’s version of the dispute with the Professor, characterizing her as “abusive, fraudulent, vexatious, and malicious”. [ 107 ] The Applicant objected to GFC’s fact findings, largely on the basis that there was no evidence for those facts. An example was the fact finding that there had been discussions between the Applicant and the Professor about “boundaries”.
The Applicant’s objection is that there was no request by the Professor, “she declared that she would not talk to me.” [ 108 ] Another example was consideration of the unrelated 2019 incident, which the Applicant disputed, saying the Applicant had not taken a course from a female instructor in the spring 2019 term as recited in the GFC decision. The Applicant stated that there was no evidence to support the description that it was a “remarkably similar set of circumstances”.
Curiously, the Applicant did not deny the circumstances, pointing only to the date being wrong. [ 109 ] Another objection was how GFC had characterized a letter to the Applicant from Dr. Rodriguez dated November 24. The
Applicant also objected to how the Applicant’s previous relationship with the Professor had been characterized. [ 110 ] The Applicant complained about bias on the part of the Chief Safety Officer, whom the Applicant says was not impartial because he presumed guilt before hearing the Applicant’s side of the story. [ 111 ] The Applicant also complained about bias on the part of the Professor, whom the Applicant says yelled at the Applicant in front of the class about a comment made concerning a potential additional reading. [ 112 ] The Applicant characterized the Professor’s actions as “fraud” and suggested that her behaviour demonstrated that she may not be fit to be an instructor.
The Applicant also described the Professor’s behaviours towards the Applicant as retaliation. [ 113 ] The Appeal Committee’s Decision was based on the record before GFC. The decision was contained in a letter to the Applicant dated February 24, 2022 advising: The decision of the General Faculties Council Committee has been upheld…due to repeat non-academic offences, being a pattern of disruptive behaviours. Attached to the letter was a 2 page
summary of the Board of Governors Appeal Committee Process. [ 114 ] The Attachment noted that the Appeal would focus on what they considered to be the “4 areas of objection” raised by the Applicant in the February 14 submissions: • The Committee did not integrate the (Applicant’
s) written responses of simply did not read them; • The instructor should have been summoned to clarify the problem; • The Applicant was a student in high standing and this was the first complaint about the Applicant; and • The instructor had retaliated against the Applicant. [ 115 ] The Attachment provided a
summary of the rational around the Applicant’s concerns, concluding: • The Appeal Committee did not find any evidence that the written responses were not received or considered in the final decision; • The Appeal Committee felt that the instructor was not required to attend; • The Appeal Committee felt that appropriate progressive discipline was recommended; and • The Appeal Committee found no evidence of the Applicant’s concern about retaliation.
Procedural fairness issues “It established most or all of its facts without evidence” [ 116 ] Claiming that there were procedural fairness issues is very different from proving that those occurred. The Applicant bears the burden of proof on this application. [ 117 ] To the extent the Applicant’s allegation here relates to the use of hearsay evidence and not direct testimony or other forms of commonly admissible evidence, hearsay is generally admissible in administrative proceedings.
See Pridgen v University of Calgary , 2012 ABCA 139 , for example. [ 118 ] One example of hearsay that the Applicant found objectionable was reference to a previous complaint made about the Applicant. Not only is the hearsay nature of this information unobjectionable, but it is also relevant in the context of penalties that might be imposed under
section A.3. [ 119 ] The Appeal Committee’s Decision does not address the Applicant’s objections that GFC made fact findings without evidence. In judicial review, this is only of concern if a particular fact finding was material to the decision. The Applicant essentially argues over the
interpretation of individual emails or information provided to GFC. GFC was entitled to interpret the emails without additional evidence on each, and to make their own
interpretation in the face of competing
interpretations. [ 120 ] No doubt it would have been helpful if the Appeal Committee had expressly dealt with the Applicant’s complaints about GFC’s fact findings. To interfere with their fact findings, however, the BOG Appeal Committee would have had to find the facts as found to be tainted by palpable and overriding error. [ 121 ] It is clear from Vavilov that judicial reviews are not “a treasure hunt for error”: [102] To be reasonable, a decision must be based on reasoning that is both rational and logical.
It follows that a failure in this respect may lead a reviewing court to conclude that a decision must be set aside. Reasonableness review is not a “line-by-line treasure hunt for error”: Irving Pulp & Paper , at para. 54, citing Newfoundland Nurses , at para. 14.
However, the reviewing court must be able to trace the decision maker’s reasoning without encountering any fatal flaws in its overarching logic, and it must be satisfied that “there is [a] line of analysis within the given reasons that could reasonably lead the tribunal from the evidence before it to the conclusion at which it arrived”: Ryan , at para. 55 ; Southam , at para. 56.
Reasons that “simply repeat statutory language, summarize arguments made, and then state a peremptory conclusion” will rarely assist a reviewing court in understanding the rationale underlying a decision and “are no substitute for statements of fact, analysis, inference and judgment”: [ 122 ] A reviewing court is entitled to supplement the tribunal’s reasons by looking at reasons that might be offered to support the
decision. This was recognized in Dunsmuir v New Brunswick , 2008 SCC 9 and in Newfoundland and Labrador Nurses’ Union v Newfoundland and Labrador (Treasury Board) , 2011 SCC 62 . That case held at para 12: [12] It is important to emphasize the Court’s endorsement of Professor Dyzenhaus’s observation that the notion of deference to administrative tribunal decision-making requires “a respectful attention to the reasons offered or which could be offered in support of a decision”.
In his cited article, Professor Dyzenhaus explains how reasonableness applies to reasons as follows: “Reasonable” means here that the reasons do in fact or in principle support the conclusion reached. That is, even if the reasons in fact given do not seem wholly adequate to support the decision, the court must first seek to supplement them before it seeks to subvert them .
For if it is right that among the reasons for deference are the appointment of the tribunal and not the court as the front line adjudicator, the tribunal’s proximity to the dispute, its expertise, etc, then it is also the case that its decision should be presumed to be correct even if its reasons are in some respects defective. [Emphasis added.] [ 123 ] My conclusion on this ground of appeal is that the Applicant has not demonstrated that any of the complained-about facts were material to the Decision, so the failure of the BOG Appeal Committee to expressly deal with the concerns expressed in the Applicant’s February 14, 2021, submissions is inconsequential.
Secondly, to the extent that the Applicant’s submissions can be understood, I would observe that the inferences of fact from the emails made by the Appeal Committee were reasonable inferences.
The Applicant did not expand on the expressed concerns about there being “no evidence”, and that is simply not accurate, as GFC was entitled to consider all of the documents placed before it, as well as information provided to it including hearsay information. [ 124 ] Supplementing the Appeal Committee decision, if necessary, is relatively simple: the Applicant did not satisfy the Appeal Committee that any of the facts found by it were unsupported by the evidence before them, and even if that had been established, none of the complained of facts were material to the overall conclusion that the Applicant had embarked on a pattern of disruptive behaviour.
That is amply made out by the email communications in the Record. “The proceedings were vexatious” [ 125 ] There is nothing in the Record or indeed the Applicant’s submissions to support the argument that the proceedings against the Applicant were vexatious. Following a disagreement over the marking of an assignment, the Applicant became increasingly aggressive in the Applicant’s chain of emails. The Applicant refused to accede to the Professor’s request that emails be limited to course-related matters and that office hours meetings be limited to 15 minutes and take place with a third-party present.
Despite requests to stop the email flow, the Applicant continued relentlessly. When directed to stop contacting the Professor by Campus Safety, the Applicant ignored that direction. When directed by Campus Safety to attend classes only by viewing recordings of the online classes, the Applicant ignored that.
When GFC issued a suspension and told the Applicant to stop contacting the Professor, the Applicant ignored that. [ 126 ] There is no merit to this ground. “The BOG Appeal Procedures Policy and the standard of review and procedural fairness and natural justice pillars established within that policy were not disclosed to the Applicant beforehand” [ 127 ] The only issue of non-disclosure on the part of the BOG Appeal Committee argued by the Applicant was it not having provided the Applicant with its Appeal Procedures in advance of the Appeal. These Appeal Procedures are attached as
Schedule 2. [ 128 ] There is nothing in these procedures that would assist an Appellant regarding the merits of the appeal.
The Appeal is on the record below, and the Committee sets its own procedures. [ 129 ] The Procedures emphasize that their “Principles of Natural Justice and Procedural Fairness” are to be followed. [ 130 ] While procedural policies should ideally be made available to an appellant, there is nothing in the record of these proceedings or the Appeal Committee’s Decision to suggest that the Applicant was prejudiced or disadvantaged in any way by not having this document. [ 131 ] The Applicant references s 4 of the Administrative Procedures and Jurisdiction Act , which specifies various procedures for an “authority”.
The University notes that
section 4 applies only to an “authority” designated as such by Regulation, and that the University of Lethbridge has not been so designated. That does not by itself remove any common law procedural fairness obligations of the BOG Appeal Committee. However, the Applicant has not demonstrated any breach of any duty of procedural fairness by not having the Appeal Procedures Policy in advance of the appeal, whether under
section 4 or at common law. [ 132 ] There is no merit to the Applicant’s complaint in this regard. “The Appeal Committee did not follow the procedural fairness and natural justice pillars established in the BOG Appeal Procedures Policy” [ 133 ] Those “Pillars” are: • Opportunity to know the allegations; • Lack of bias; • Lack of evidence to support a decision; • Clear reasoned decision-making.
[ 134 ] There is nothing in the Record or the submissions to support any suggestion that the Applicant was not made aware of the allegations. [ 135 ] There is nothing in the record or the Appeal Committee’s Decision to suggest that there was any bias that affected the process or the Decision. While the Applicant felt that the Director of Campus Safety did not conduct an independent investigation and did not get the Applicant’s side of the story, the emails in the Record tell a different story. Mr. Mackie contacted the Applicant to meet to discuss the situation between the Applicant and the Professor.
The Applicant refused to meet with Mr. Mackie as requested. No particulars of any alleged bias on Mr. Mackie’s part have been provided, let alone made out. [ 136 ] Lack of evidence to support the decision has been dealt with above. [ 137 ] Clear reasoned decision-making will be dealt with in the context of my reasonableness assessment below. “The Appeal Committee Failed to Consider Relevant Factors” [ 138 ] In the Applicant’s Brief, the Applicant argues that the Appeal Committee did not consider relevant factors or issues.
The basis for that is that the Appendix to the Appeal Committee’s Decision stated that they would consider 4 sentences on page 5 of the Applicant’s written submissions to them, but they did not consider the submissions on “fact findings without evidence.” I have dealt with that with my
section above on “facts without evidence”. “The Academic Appeals Committee did not comply with the duty of procedural fairness for establishing most or all of its facts without evidence” [ 139 ] This complaint is not made out in the Record, the submissions or the decision itself. The BOG Appeals Committee made no fact findings. That was not its mandate. The Appeal to them was an appeal on the Record.
This ground of review is without merit. “The Appeal Committee’s decision that decision makers who are “progressive disciplinary” decisions (and in particular the Professor) afforded the appropriate level of fairness is incorrect” [ 140 ] Whether progressive discipline was used or not used is a question of fact. The issue as to whether the Professor “disciplined” the Applicant by imposing the restrictions she did was irrelevant to the proceedings before GFC and the BOG Appeal Committee with the possible exception as to remedy.
The Professor followed the process in the Student Discipline Policy in the face of perceived disruption. She imposed restrictions on the Applicant’s further attendances at instructional meetings. Initially, the only restrictions related to after class meetings. If the Applicant was entitled to have reasonable out of class meetings with the Professor, those would undoubtedly be considered to be “instructional meetings”.
There would be no other reason for a Professor to be meetings with a student in the context of the student-instructor relationship. [ 141 ] Undoubtedly professors and students are entitled to socialize and participate in extra-curricular activities.
But any such activities would have to be consensual rather than obligatory on the part of the instructor. [ 142 ] Here, however the Professor’s restrictions on the Applicant might be characterized, she was entitled to impose such restrictions under the Student Discipline Policy without any obligation to debate the issues with the student before imposing restrictions, or having any kind of hearing or meeting with the student. The student’s remedies are clearly spelled out in the Student Discipline Policy [ 143 ] Curiously, the Applicant never appealed the Professor’s restrictions.
Indeed, the proceedings before GFC related to what the Dean had done with the concurrence of Campus Safety What was before GFC and ultimately before the BOG Appeal Committee was the Applicant’s refusal to comply with any requests made to modify the Applicant’s behaviour by the Dean. [ 144 ] The GFC proceedings did not focus on whether the Professor was right to impose the restrictions she tried to put in place.
The proceedings resulted from the Applicant’s refusal to accept the restrictions and the Applicant’s behaviour after the restrictions had been imposed. [ 145 ] I do not disagree with the characterization of what the Professor tried to do as balancing instructor and student rights or putting limits on their interactions. She obviously had a right to do so if she considered the Applicant’s behaviour to be disruptive. She obviously felt that to be the case. [ 146 ] The proceedings before GFC did not arise in a vacuum, however.
What the Professor did was relevant to the narrative and was clear evidence that the Applicant would not comply with requests the Applicant felt were not reasonable or justified. The real story began when the Applicant ignored the directives of Campus Safety and the Dean. That is what ultimately led to the proceedings before GFC. [ 147 ] It is also significant that in all of this, Campus Safety and the Dean and the Vice President and GFC attempted to ensure that the Applicant could still complete the course and get any earned credits. [ 148 ] There is no factual basis for this complaint.
Alternatively, the Appeal Committee’s decision entails the retraction of the Academic Appeal Committee’s decision that the Professor had triggered the duty of fairness, then the Appeal Committee’s decision entails an abuse of the decision-making process as well as the fundamental breakdown of the University’s orderly exercise of authority to the point that bad faith can be presumed [ 149 ] I see no merit with this argument. It assumes that the Professor had a duty of fairness to the Applicant which is not made out in
the Record or in any of the University’s policies. No abuse of decision-making process or bad faith has been established and none can be presumed. The progressive discipline was an abuse of process. [ 150 ] It is not clear on the Record or in either the GFC decision or the Appeals Committee Decision how progressive discipline was an abuse of process. The ultimate sanction imposed by GFC does not on its face seem at all unreasonable having regard to the Applicant’s conduct as demonstrated by the Applicant’s email messages. Additional Considerations [ 151 ] There are two additional areas that need to be addressed.
The first is a “reasonableness” analysis. The second relates to the adequacy of the BOG Appeal Committee’s reasons. Reasonableness [ 152 ] It is abundantly clear on this application that the BOG Appeal Committee Decision on the substantive issues was reasonable. Its decision meets the objectives of transparency and intelligibility, and it is justified. Indeed, I agree with the University’s submission that the decision was the inevitable consequence of the Applicant’s actions.
Comments on Correctness [ 153 ] Applicants for judicial review are frequently disappointed in the results of their application, as they are generally looking for a correct decision rather than one that is “transparent, intelligible, and justifiable.” Because of the deferential standard of review afforded to most administrative tribunals, there may be a sense that they have lost their application on a technicality and that the real issues have never been properly determined. [ 154 ] Here, there is no question that the standard of review for the decision itself is reasonableness, and that the Appeal Committee’s Decision meets that standard.
In my view, it is also the correct decision. [ 155 ] The Applicant’s real concern is that the Applicant has never had a full opportunity to resolve the issues that arose on November 6, 2021 directly with the Professor. The Applicant would simply not take “no” for an answer to ongoing communications with the Professor. This case is more about the Applicant’s obsession with the Professor than administrative law. Despite countless directions from the Professor and Campus Safety to leave the Professor alone, the Applicant continued to attempt to engage her even after the GFC decision.
The Applicant still seeks direct contact with the Professor as a preferred remedy on this application. [ 156 ] The Applicant’s position appears to be that the Professor could only impose disciplinary measures resulting from the Applicant’s behaviour by going through the student discipline process described in the Student Discipline Policy. [ 157 ] The Applicant is partly right. Policy gives an instructor the right to immediately exclude disruptive students from the instructional environment, and to exclude them from future instructional meetings.
The instructor must then refer the matter to the Dean for any further action, and the Dean is to then notify Chief Safety Officer and the Associate Vice-President (Students). [ 158 ] Essentially, once the instructor has excluded a disruptive student, the matter is turned over to the Dean, the Chief Safety Officer and the Associate Vice-President (Students).
The instructor has no further role, except as a possible witness in any proceedings. [ 159 ] The Applicant is incorrect in suggesting that the Professor had a duty to deal with the Applicant after the exclusion decision was made. [ 160 ] An expulsion starts the disciplinary process. There are a number of safety valves for students in the event of alleged misconduct on the part of an instructor. The Dean has oversight over the instructor and has the ability to direct the instructor to take a different course of action.
The Chief Safety Officer has a role in this, as does the VP for Students. [ 161 ] If a formal process is required, that is dealt with in the Policy. That Policy was followed. The Professor provided the Dean with the email record between her and the Applicant. The Dean involved the Chief Safety Officer. [ 162 ] I do not see that the Professor owed the Applicant any duty of fairness in the administrative law context. If the Professor felt that the Applicant was being disruptive, she had the right to remove the Applicant from class and cancel any future meetings without any input from the Applicant.
In reality, she did neither. She initially only advised the Applicant that she would not respond to non-course related emails; she limited the Applicant’s office hours meetings to 15 minutes; and she stipulated that there had to be a third-party present during any such meetings. [ 163 ] None of those actions took away any of the Applicant’s rights as a student.
I do not go so far as to say that a student has a “right” to meet with an instructor after class, and do not ascribe to the Applicant’s argument that the collective agreement creates a duty on an instructors enforceable by students to have office hours and make themselves available to students for private meetings. The University has the right under the collective agreement to require that, but there is nothing in the record that purports to entitle students to insist on that let alone enforce that.
From a student-instructor perspective, I would characterize communications out of the classroom as a privilege, not a right. [ 164 ] In any event, even if a student could be considered to be a third-party beneficiary of that obligation, any obligation is tempered by “reasonable” office hours contact. The instructor is in the first instance the arbiter of “reasonableness”. A 15-minute limitation on meetings does not seem unreasonable, and requiring a third party to be present can be easily justified for any number of reasons. Limiting
written communications to course-related topics is eminently reasonable. [165] In my view, the Professor took nothing away from the Applicant that the Applicant had an enforceable right to receive. TheProfessor did nothing to interfere with the Applicant’s right to complete the course. She did not take away the Applicant’s ability tocommunicate to her, but instead imposed a reasonable restriction: that the subject of the communications be course-related. She did nottake away the Applicant’s ability to meet with her during office hours, but imposed a time limit and a third-party presence during anysuch meetings.
The third-party requirement was eminently reasonable having regard to the Applicant’s escalating behavior. Instructorsdo not have to take abusive or harassing conduct. [166] The restrictions imposed by the Professor were described by her as “boundaries”. She felt the Applicant had crossed appropriateboundaries by the content and frequency of the Applicant’s emails to her. [167] The Applicant had adequate remedies available if the Applicant felt that the Professor had improperly denied any of theApplicant’s course-related privileges. That right was to make a complaint to the Dean about the Professor’s conduct.
The Applicant alsohad rights under the University’s Harassment and Discrimination Policy to complain about the Professor’s conduct. The Applicantreferenced this policy when providing a draft complaint letter to members of the University Philosophy Department on January 12, 2022. [168] Instead of following those procedures, the Applicant chose to ignore the Professor’s requests and the directions from the SafetyOfficer, provoking the University into taking more steps against the Applicant.
Those steps were necessary to protect the Professor fromthe Applicant’s campaign of harassment. [169] The result imposed by the Appeal Committee was the inevitable consequence of the Applicant’s misconduct. Sufficiency of Reasons [170] Although not specifically raised, some of the Applicant’s arguments could be interpreted as complaining about the sufficiencyof the BOG Appeal Committee’s reasons.
As noted above in my treatment of the Applicant’s argument that there were fact findingsmade without evidence, the Appeal Committee’s reasons could have been more fulsome in dealing with the Applicant’s objections to theGFC fact findings. As noted above, any arguable failing to address these arguments was not significant in the result. [171] Andre v Bentley, 2011 BCSC 641 describes the test for sufficiency at para 24: [24] To be adequate, reasons must be sufficiently clear and intelligible to allow the parties and others to know why the tribunaldecided as it did.
In particular there needs to be a sufficient explanation of why the losing party lost, sufficient reasoning to disclosewhether there exist grounds to challenge the decision, and sufficient analysis to allow a reviewing body to test the validity of thedecision. The Supreme Court of Canada has helpfully set out the functions of the reasons of tribunals in Northwestern Utilities Ltd. et al.v. Edmonton, (SCC), [1979] 1 S.C.R. 684 at 706-07: The law reports are replete with cases affirming the desirability if not the legal obligation at common law of giving reasons for decisions[citations omitted].
This obligation is a salutary one. It reduces to a considerable degree the chances of arbitrary or capricious decisions,reinforces public confidence in the judgment and fairness of administrative tribunals, and affords parties to administrative proceedings anopportunity to assess the question of appeal and if taken, the opportunity in the reviewing or appellate tribunal of a full hearing whichmay well be denied where the basis of the decision has not been disclosed.
This is not to say, however, that absent a requirement bystatute or regulation a disposition by an administrative tribunal would be reviewable solely by reason of a failure to disclose its reasonsfor such disposition. [172] I am satisfied that the BOG Appeal Committee’s Decision sufficiently explains to the Applicant why it did what it did indismissing the Applicant’s appeal from the GFC Decision. VI. Conclusion [173] The Applicant’s application for judicial review is dismissed. If the parties cannot agree on costs, they may address that issuewith me by submissions in writing.
Heard on the 21st day of March, 2023. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 9th day of May, 2023. Robert A. Graesser J.C.K.B.A.
“Schedule 1” Appearances: Austin Grimes, self represented litigant Taylor Thiesen, Reynolds Mirth Richards & Farmer LLP, for the University of Lethbridge A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A close-up of a paper Description automatically generated with low confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with low confidence
A close-up of a paper Description automatically generated with low confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A picture containing text, font, screenshot, document Description automatically generated
A picture containing text, screenshot, font Description automatically generated
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with low confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with low confidence
“Schedule 2” A close-up of a paper Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with low confidence
A close-up of a document Description automatically generated with medium confidence
A picture containing text, font, screenshot, letter Description automatically generated
Loading document…