Docken v Anderson, 2023 ABKB 291
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Docken v Anderson, 2023 ABKB 291 Date: 20230512 Docket: 2201 08392 Registry: Calgary Between: Clint Docken and Guardian Law Group LLP Plaintiffs - and - Sandra Anderson and Susan Anderson Defendants _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice C.M. Jones _______________________________________________________ I. Introduction [ 1 ] Sandra Ann Anderson [Ms. Anderson] is a problematic litigant with an extended record of inappropriate and abusive
litigation conduct that now extends back years. Ms. Anderson is a highly active, abusive Organized Pseudolaw Commercial Argument [OPCA] ( Meads v Meads , 2012 ABQB 571 ) litigant. Ms. Anderson’s record of repeated and persistent abuse of this Court and litigants led Associate Chief Justice Rooke to on April 26, 2022 impose court access restrictions on Ms. Anderson following a Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 , ss 23-23.1 Application by the Attorney General of Canada: Canada (Attorney General) v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 310 . However, that step had a restricted impact on Ms. Anderson’s abusive activities where Ms.
Anderson is a responding party, since court access restrictions only affect litigation and litigation steps initiated by Ms. Anderson. Furthermore, Ms. Anderson has engaged a wide variety of irregular and illegal steps to frustrate litigation directed against her. [ 2 ] In Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 525 [ RBC v Anderson #2 ], Associate Chief Justice Rooke at paras 31- 32 described Ms. Anderson this way: ... Ms. Anderson is an unrepentant, disruptive, greedy, uncooperative, abusive scofflaw. That has now been her uniform approach to legal rights and obligations, and the Courts, for years.
Her misconduct is expanding into multiple subjects and disputes. Ms. Anderson cannot be trusted. When she is pointed to the actual law, she reliably rejects that, and claims to unilaterally impose something else. ... Unlike many pseudolaw litigants, Ms. Anderson has significant and substantial resources. She has already demonstrated that she will use unorthodox vigilante processes against those who simply are engaged in their legal duties. All these factors, and Ms. Anderson’s dismal record of pseudolaw misconduct, mean that Ms.
Anderson is an appropriate target for unusual and intrusive litigation and litigant management steps by this Court. Doing otherwise simply guarantees more trouble ahead. [ 3 ] In response to Ms. Anderson’s relentless abuse of the Court, its staff, and opposing and third parties, on August 3, 2022, Associate Chief Justice Rooke imposed on Ms. Anderson extremely stringent communications and filing restrictions: RBC v Anderson #2 at para 62 . The relevant components of that litigation and communications management scheme are: 1. Ms.
Anderson is prohibited from any direct or indirect communication with the Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench, except:
a) in documentary form and by registered mail to [the office of Associate Chief Justice Rooke, or his designate], or
b) by filing or submitting documents via a member in good standing of the Law Society of Alberta, or another person authorized to represent Ms. Anderson in the Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench, pursuant to the Legal Professions Act , RSA 2000, c L-8 . ... 3. Ms. Anderson is prohibited from filing any documents with the Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench, except according to paragraph 1(b), and, unless Ms. Anderson engages the services of a lawyer, the only way that Ms. Anderson may file any documents with the Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench is if:
a) those documents are received by [Associate Chief Justice Rooke], or [Associate Chief Justice Rooke’s designate], by registered mail,
b) after review, those documents are determined to be legally valid and not an abuse of the court, and then,
c) Ms. Anderson then pays a filing and document review payment set by the Court. 4. Ms. Anderson may only communicate with my office and file documents using the name “Sandra Ann Anderson”, and not using initials, an alternative name structure, or a pseudonym. ... 6. When a document submitted by Ms. Anderson is rejected pursuant to this Decision, Ms. Anderson may be required to pay a penalty amount. [ 4 ] Ms. Anderson on April 11, 2023 and May 2, 2023 took steps that breached both this communication and litigant management structure, and her Judicature Act ss 23-23.1 court access restrictions.
Since Associate Chief Justice Rooke retired in December 2022, the Clerk of the Court informed Associate Chief Justice Nielsen of the events of April 11, 2023 and May 2, 2023. That matter was then referred to me, since I have previously been involved in management of Ms.
Anderson’s litigation activities, and, most recently, have administered a security for costs and penalty scheme imposed by Associate Chief Justice Rooke in Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 733 [ RBC v Anderson #5 ], see Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2023 ABKB 24 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2023 ABKB 75 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2023 ABKB 180 [ RBC v Anderson #9 ] . II. Docken v Anderson , Alberta Court of King’s Bench Docket No. 2201 08392 [ 5 ] Ms.
Anderson’s latest abuses of the Court are her first activities in a lawsuit filed on July 22, 2022 by Clint Docken and Guardian Law Group LLP [Plaintiffs], and that names as Defendants Ms. Anderson and her sister, Susan Anderson. The substance of this lawsuit is irrelevant to my analysis that follows, but, briefly, the Plaintiffs allege the Andersons defamed the Plaintiffs. On March 7, 2023, Counsel for the Plaintiffs noted the Andersons in default. III. Ms. Anderson’s Illegal Conduct A. April 11, 2023 Events
[ 6 ] That triggered a response from Ms. Anderson. On April 11, 2023, an unidentified person approached the Calgary Alberta Court of King’s Bench civil counter, and attempted to file a document. This person also wrote a note and slid that note to the Clerk at the counter. The note stated the unknown person was filming their interactions.
The Clerk examined the candidate filing, and concluded that this document could not be filed because the document included prohibited “formal defects”, unique OPCA-specific characteristics that are a mandatory ground for the Clerk of the Court to reject attempted filings at the Alberta Court of King’s Bench.
The “Revised Master Order For Organized Pseudolegal Commercial Arguments (“OPCA”) Documents” of Chief Justice Moreau, dated January 21, 2019, that imposes this document rejection process, is reproduced in Babb v Parrish & Heimbecker Limited , 2019 ABQB 687 . [ 7 ] The Clerk copied the first page of the rejected filing, that was then ultimately forwarded to me. This document exhibits multiple pseudolaw characteristics that not only establish multiple breaches of the RBC v Anderson #2 litigation and litigant management Order, but also demonstrate this attempted filing was for an illegal, OPCA-based purpose.
The document is titled “APPLICATION TO DISMISS STATEMENT OF CLAIM WITH PREJUDICE”. [ 8 ] The attempted filing is a clear and deliberate breach of the RBC v Anderson #2 at para 62 requirement that Ms. Anderson obtain permission prior to filing any document with the Alberta Court of King’s Bench. Further, to the degree Ms. Anderson’s document can be classified, the document is an “Application”, which means Ms. Anderson is also in breach of the Canada (Attorney General) v Anderson court access restrictions. [ 9 ] Second, the named “Applicant” is “TRUSTEE(
S) for the REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST OF SANDRA ANN ANDERSON”. That breaches the RBC v Anderson #2 requirement that Ms. Anderson only self-identify as “Sandra Ann Anderson”. [ 10 ] Further, this document purports to involve a number of “Trustees”. First, there is SANDRA ANDERSON, however the “Applicant” is not Ms.
Anderson, but, instead, an apparent third-party to the Docken v Anderson proceeding: Comes now on special appearance, The APPLICANT, Estella Meza, a private free-living, warm-blooded breathing woman, not an entity, as Trustee of the SANDRA ANN ANDERSON LIVING TRUST (Revocable) on behalf of SANDRA ANDERSON, and submits a Commercial Affidavit of Notice and opposition to the RESPONDENTS STATEMENT OF CLAIM and in support of the APPLICANT OPPOSITION ... [Sic.] The “Application” provides a service address for “Estella Meza”: a post office box in Rochelle, Illinois.
The language “special appearance” is used in American courts to indicate the party rejects the authority of the court. [ 11 ] The use of upper- and lower-case letter names, the claims that there are both SANDRA ANDERSON, and some kind of trust with the same name, are attempts to implement Strawman Theory, a commonplace pseudolaw concept that persons exist in a kind of duality with a flesh and blood half, and then a legal and immaterial doppelganger, such as a trust, a corporation, a “person”, or a “Strawman”.
Strawman Theory is so notoriously false that anyone who employs Strawman Theory is presumed to do so in bad faith, and for abusive, ulterior purposes: Fiander v Mills , 2015 NLCA 31 at paras 37-40 ; Rothweiler v Payette , 2018 ABQB 288 at paras 6-21 ; Unrau v National Dental Examining Board , 2019 ABQB 283 at para 180 . Ms.
Anderson knows that, because she has been repeatedly cautioned and informed on this very point: e.g., Anderson (Re) , 2022 ABQB 35 at para 12 ; RBC v Anderson #2 at para 25 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2023 ABKB 24 at paras 9-11 . [ 12 ] Other nonsensical pseudolaw aspects of the Application include a text box in the upper right corner of the first page that reads: A SECURITY (15 USC) COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT U.S. S.E.C.
TRACER FLAG NOT A POINT OF LAW To the degree this text is comprehensible, this notation appears to claim this filing is some kind of document subject to US law, which is false, since the Docken v Anderson action is in a Canadian court. [ 13 ] The document also features a five-cent Canada postage stamp in the lower right corner, that has been signed across. This postage stamp is a “formal defect” that requires the Clerk reject this candidate filing: Babb v Parrish & Heimbecker Limited .
The strange postage stamp motif has been identified as a legally meaningless ritual “cargo cult” behaviour used by pseudolaw litigants: Donald J Netolitzky, “Organized Pseudolegal Commercial Arguments and Magic and Ceremony” (2018) 55:4 Alta L Rev 1045 at 1057- 1068. [ 14 ] While the exact mechanism by which the Application is purported to operate is not obvious, what is clear is that rather than apply to unwind the default judgment against Ms. Anderson, Ms. Anderson has instead sought to defeat that claim with an OPCA document that purports to “Reject” and “Dismiss” the Plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim. Ms.
Anderson has involved a person from outside Canada, “Estella Meza”, who has intruded into litigation where Meza has no potential role. Thus, Ms. Anderson continues her pattern of prima facie contempt of this Court’s orders, and attempts to introduce legally false and abusive OPCA strategies into litigation, all as a “get out of court free” mechanism. B.
May 2, 2023 Attempted Filing [ 15 ] On May 2, 2023, the Alberta Court of King’s Bench email filing address, and the personal email address of a Clerk of this Court received an email from the address “saalivingtrust@gmail.com” (the same email address on the rejected April 11, 2023 document)
that attached a seven-page packet of what are obviously pseudolaw materials.
The first document, a so-called “COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH FOR SPECIAL TRUST DEPOSIT - CONFIDENTIAL”, dated April 30, 2023, is from “Estella Meza-Trustee for SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Revocable Trust”, titled “COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH FOR SPECIAL TRUST DEPOSIT – CONFIDENTIAL”, is reproduced as Appendix A. [ 16 ] Briefly, this document appears to claim that Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz are Trustees for “SANDRA ANN ANDERSON”, a “Living Trust”, and demands: 1. “Oaths of Office” of court clerks, supervisors, and “every Judge that has issued an Order for/against the named SANDRA ANN ANDERSON idem sonans”; 2. law, but “not Staute or Code” [sic] that is the basis for the refusal to file Ms.
Anderson’s materials on April 11, 2023; and 3. all orders and warrants against “SANDRA ANDERSON”. [ 17 ] Failure to comply will lead to: ... “judicial enforcement” against any and all individuals at a personal and professional level and seek monetary compensation from the COURTS and acting Clerks. [ 18 ] This document is rife with pseudolaw indicia as indicated above. The “Request for Oath(s)” exhibits Strawman Theory claims that Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz are trustees for a non-existent Strawwoman “SANDRA ANN ANDERSON”.
The law in Canada is clear that demands for an “Oath of Office” are meaningless and are irrelevant to exercise of court and judicial authority: Meads v Meads at paras 287-292 . The basis for why Ms. Anderson (or the imaginary SANDRA ANN ANDERSON) are prohibited from filing without leave of the Alberta Court of King’s Bench is clearly explained in detail in this Court’s Canada (Attorney General) v Anderson and RBC v Anderson #2 Decisions. [ 19 ] The Court has no obligation to provide documents to anyone, but those can be obtained from the Clerk of the Court with payment of the appropriate fees.
In any case, I conclude the request for court filings here is not genuine. Instead, Ms. Anderson, and “Trustees” Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz will announce that any court filing does not relate to the correct Anderson, ANDERSON, or some other variation on Strawman Theory concepts. I conclude that the “COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT” is abusive pseudolaw document, and that the attempt to file it was in breach of the court access restrictions imposed on Ms.
Anderson. [ 20 ] A second document in this packet is an undated “AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH / SERVICE – Basil Panidisz; Co-Trustee of The Sandra Ann Anderson Living Trust (Revocable)”. I have no idea whether this “Sandra Ann Anderson Living Trust (Revocable)” is intended to be different from the “SANDRA ANN ANDERSON LIVING REVOCABLE TRUST”, or whether the person who prepared the “Affidavit of Truth” simply forgot to capitalize the Strawwoman’s name. [ 21 ] In the Affidavit, Basil Panidisz discloses that he was the one who attempted to file Ms. Anderson’s April 11, 2023 package.
Basil Panidisz says he was given no valid reason to reject those documents, he warned the Clerk “this was a Trust Matter”, and then repeated three times to “... see and speak to the Magistrate three (3) times, invoking my common law due process ...”. After this unorthodox ceremony, Basil Panidisz deposes that the Clerk “... refused to let me speak to the Magistrate ... a violation of common law due process ...”.
A more plausible answer is that no “Magistrate” was summoned because there are no officials or decision-makers called “Magistrates” at the Alberta Court of King’s Bench. [ 22 ] The “Affidavit of Truth” concludes with the statement “An unrebutted affidavit stands as truth, fact and evidence.” Ms. Anderson has previously been informed that the “unrebutted affidavit” rule is a false OPCA concept: Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 at paras 51 , 66.
As Associate Chief Justice Rooke concluded in Rothweiler v Payette , 2018 ABQB 288 at para 10 , this claim “... is just nonsense, and there is no such legal principle. A court may always reject any affidavit evidence as unworthy of belief to establish a fact(s).” IV. Penalties [ 23 ] Ms. Anderson has been repeatedly penalized with fines pursuant to Rule 10.49(1) for her employing pseudolaw, despite Ms.
Anderson being fully informed those concepts are invalid, and in response to her scofflaw engagement with the Court and litigation in this jurisdiction: Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 at paras 71-72 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 577 at para 22 [ RBC v Anderson #4 ]; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 733 at para 16 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 838 [ RBC v Anderson #6 ]. As the events of April 11, 2023 and May 2, 2023 illustrate, none of that has altered Ms.
Anderson’s misconduct, not the slightest. [ 24 ] Associate Chief Justice Rooke in RBC v Anderson #4 at para 25 ruled that Ms. Anderson “... should also anticipate that additional penalties will increase, stepwise, until Ms. Anderson discontinues her misconduct.”. The most recent “baseline” penalty imposed for Ms. Anderson’s bad conduct was $20,000: RBC v Anderson #6 at para 9 . [ 25 ] Ms. Anderson has been entirely clear she will never voluntarily pay any penalty amount: RBC v Anderson #4 at para 23 . Subsequent events have confirmed that; Ms. Anderson never acknowledges and pays any of her legal obligations.
Instead, she counterattacks by whatever means possible, to frustrate government, court, and legal authority. Anticipating further illegal conduct by Ms. Anderson, and Ms. Anderson’s continued refusal to satisfy any unfavourable award or order, Associate Chief Justice Rooke in RBC v Anderson #5 at paras 20-21 ordered Royal Trust pay $250,000 of Ms. Anderson’s inheritance from her father’s estate into Court as security for costs. At present $169,730.68 remains of that pool of funds: RBC v Anderson #9 at para 19. [ 26 ] I conclude further Rule 10.49(1) penalties should be imposed in response to Ms.
Anderson’s continued abusive pseudolaw
activities, her defiance of Canadian law, and rejection of Canadian law and court authority. A. The April 11, 2023 Rejected Filing [ 27 ] As I have previously explained, Ms. Anderson’s attempt to file the “APPLICATION TO DISMISS STATEMENT OF CLAIM WITH PREJUDICE” on April 11, 2023 is a clear and obvious breach of the court access restrictions and litigant management steps imposed by the Court. The “APPLICATION TO DISMISS STATEMENT OF CLAIM WITH PREJUDICE” document is also an obvious OPCA filing that is, by definition, an abuse of the Court.
The April 11, 2023 incident also involved a number of serious aggravating factors: 1. The attempt to intimidate the Clerk who received and rejected Ms. Anderson’s Application by stating the interaction was being filmed, which is a prohibited activity at the Court’s counters. 2. The insertion of an unrelated third party, “Estella Meza”, who appears intended to operate as a litigation proxy for Ms. Anderson. Furthermore, I conclude on a balance of probabilities that “Estella Meza” is not a legitimate representative, either as a lawyer or “trustee” of a non-existent “Strawwoman” trust. 3. Ms.
Anderson had legitimate mechanisms to respond to the Docken v Anderson Statement of Claim and being noted in default. Instead, she elected to respond with a Strawman Theory scheme to “get out of court free”, in bad faith, and for abusive, ulterior purposes. [ 28 ] Given these aggravating factors, and Ms. Anderson’s relentless, defiant rejection of Canadian law and this Court’s authority, I order that a further $35,000 Rule 10.49(1) penalty is imposed on Ms. Anderson. B. The May 2, 2023 Rejected Filing [ 29 ] The attempted filing of the May 2, 2023 materials is another clear instance of abusive litigation by Ms.
Anderson, via her litigation proxies Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz. I conclude the May 2, 2023 materials warrant a second Rule 10.49(1) penalty because Ms. Anderson and her proxies had the opportunity after the clear document rejection on April 11, 2023 to abandon pseudolaw, and instead challenge the Docken v Anderson default judgment by conventional, legitimate means. Instead, Ms.
Anderson and her proxies “doubled down”, and continued their abusive pseudolaw schemes. [ 30 ] The May 2, 2023 rejected filing also exhibits aggravating factors: 1. demands for “Oaths of Office”, which I conclude are an attempt to intimidate the named recipients of the “COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT”; 2. demands for court document outside the procedures established by this Court to access files and file materials; 3. threats of “judicial enforcement” against court staff and the Court itself, for “monetary compensation”; 4. further employment of proxy actors by Ms.
Anderson to avoid the litigation and litigant management steps imposed by the Court; and 5. continuing to employ Strawman Theory schemes that Ms. Anderson knows very well are not accepted by Canadian law, with the negative inferences that follow from that. [ 31 ] Given these aggravating factors I order a further $35,000 Rule 10.49(1) penalty is imposed on Ms. Anderson for the May 2, 2023 rejected document filing. C. Penalty Payment [ 32 ] This decision therefore imposes a total of $70,000 in Rule 10.49(1) penalties on Ms. Anderson.
This sum will be paid by the Clerk of the Court from the RBC v Anderson #5 security for costs pool, reducing the remaining funds to $99,730.68. [ 33 ] I remind Ms. Anderson that if she continues to abuse this Court’s processes that she will receive additional Rule 10.49(1) penalties, and the quantity of those penalties will continue to increase. This Court will release the remaining funds to Ms. Anderson if she discontinues her abuse pseudolaw litigation misconduct. V. The Litigation Proxies: Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz [ 34 ] Ms.
Anderson employing litigation proxies has no effect on this Court’s existing steps to manage Ms. Anderson’s persistent, aggressive, defiant litigation misconduct. While the May 2, 2023 materials claim there is a distinction between Ms. Anderson, and her proxies, that makes no difference to the operation of the court access restrictions and litigation management steps imposed in Canada (Attorney General) v Anderson and RBC v Anderson #2 . First, those decisions explicitly prohibit Ms.
Anderson from litigating on behalf of something else, even if her Strawwoman SANDRA ANN ANDERSON and its so-called estate is nothing but a pseudolaw phantasm. Second, RBC v Anderson #2 directs that “Ms. Anderson is prohibited from any direct or indirect communication” [emphasis added] with the Court. I therefore conclude that the involvement of Ms. Anderson’s litigation proxies, Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz, did not and does not provide any basis for Ms. Anderson to evade her existing litigation and litigant management steps.
[35] Both Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz have already engaged in serious litigation misconduct by their obvious and transparentattempts to circumvent the litigation and litigant management steps this Court has imposed on Ms. Anderson. Neither is a proper legalrepresentative in matters before the Alberta Court of King’s Bench. Basil Panidisz has self-identified as the unknown person whoappeared at the Calgary Alberta Court of King’s civil litigation counter, and who: 1) announced he was recording the Clerks, which isprohibited; and 2) attempted to illegally file Ms. Anderson’s materials.
I have commented already on how the “COMMERCIALAFFIDAVIT” is an illegal filing, and is intended to intimidate and abuse court staff and decision-makers. [36] Ms. Anderson deploying litigation proxies is a serious escalation of her abuse of the Court.
The law in Canada is clear thatwhen an abusive litigant deploys litigation proxies, then: 1. litigation and litigant management steps taken in relation to the “primary” actor should also apply to their proxies (Virgo vCanada (Attorney General), 2019 FCA 167; Onischuk v Edmonton (City), 2017 ABQB 647 at para 24; Richardson v MacDonald,2022 ABQB 274 at para 29; Richardson v Richardson, 2022 SKCA 142 at paras 26, 29); and 2. the deployment of litigation proxies to evade court litigation and litigant management steps is a very serious escalation ofthe “primary” actor’s abuse of court (Virgo v Canada (Attorney General), 2019 FCA 167; Richardson v MacDonald, 2022 ABQB 274at para 29; Richardson v Richardson, 2022 SKCA 142 at para 26; Richardson v MacDonald, 2022 ABKB 732 at para 32). [37] I now take a number of steps in response to Ms.
Anderson’s escalating her litigation misconduct by deploying Estella Mezaand Basil Panidisz as litigation proxies. [38] The first is to caution Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz. If they in the future breach the terms that I impose below inconjunction with Ms. Anderson, then Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz can anticipate that they will be penalized just like Ms. Andersonfor that abusive litigation misconduct. Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz have made themselves accomplices of Ms. Anderson. Thisdecision is their one warning before they will find themselves treated just the same as Ms.
Anderson. [39] I have this advice for Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz: 1. Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz should immediately consult with licenced and accredited legal counsel. If they continue on thispath with Ms. Anderson, Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz can expect negative and escalating outcomes. 2. Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz should familiarize themselves with Ms. Anderson’s litigation record. That can be reviewed bysearching the website with the search term “Sandra Ann Anderson”. Ms. Anderson may not havedisclosed just how unsuccessful Ms. Anderson has been before this Court.
For example, by my calculation, Ms. Anderson now has beenfined $152,000 for her illegal and pseudolegal activities. Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz should be aware those fines were not simplyimposed by the Court, but also those amounts have been collected from Ms. Anderson multimillion dollar inheritance from her father’sestate. Those funds now are part of the Province of Alberta’s general revenue. 3. Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz should familiarize themselves with how Canadian courts have universally rejected OPCA schemes,and how those who have used these schemes have met with very negative outcomes.
For example, in a recent British ColumbiaProvincial Court decision, R v Hardy, 2023 BCPC 65, Patterson PCJ imposed a one-year jail sentence upon an accused person when thatindividual attempted to disrupt legal proceedings with OPCA strategies. [40] Second, Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz should anticipate that if they are involved in abusive court-related steps that result inMs. Anderson receiving a Rule 10.49(1) penalty, that Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz will also receive Rule 10.49(1) penalties. If anysuch penalty is not paid by Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz, then those amounts will be collected from Ms.
Anderson. [41] Third, the prohibitions imposed on Ms. Anderson in RBC v Anderson #2 at para 62 now also apply to Estella Meza and BasilPanidisz, if Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz purport to act in any role that involves Ms.
Anderson, or any purported trust, corporation, orother legal entity that has or includes the name “Sandra Ann Anderson”, “SANDRA ANN ANDERSON”, or some permutation of either. [42] Fourth, the Court immediately imposes interim court access restrictions on Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz. [43] Fifth, a copy of this decision will be directed to counsel for the Plaintiffs in this Action and the Minister as identified inJudicature Act s 1(b).
The Court requests that the Plaintiffs in this lawsuit initiate an application pursuant to Judicature Act s 23.1(4) thatall court access restrictions imposed by this Court against Ms. Anderson also apply to Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz.
This requestaccords with the process set in Jonsson v Lymer, 2020 ABCA 167, see also Dmyterko v Nissan Canada Inc, 2021 ABQB 286; Feeney vTD General Insurance Company, 2021 ABQB 604; Wu v Canada (Attorney General), 2021 ABQB 749; Sun v Allwest InsuranceServices Ltd, 2022 ABQB 18; Anderson (Re), 2022 ABQB 35; Richardson v MacDonald, 2022 ABQB 317; Christofi v Newcombe,2022 ABQB 429; Wolf v Oasis Mobile Home Park, 2022 ABQB 529. The Court requests that the Plaintiffs indicate by June 16, 2023whether or not the Plaintiffs will take this step. VI.
Notarization of OPCA Documents [44] Disturbingly, Basil Panidisz’s undated “Affidavit of Truth” appears to have been witnessed remotely and notarized on May 1,2023, with the notary stamp that reads: CHRISTINE WONG Paralegal Notary Public & Commission of Oaths in and for the Province of Ontario
My commission is of unlimited duration: LSA #P08921 Search of the Law Society of Ontario “Lawyer and Paralegal Directory” discloses an individual with this name, operating as a “Paralegal (P1), located in Markham Ontario. [ 45 ] As was recently reviewed in detail by Associate Chief Justice Rooke in R v Ayyazi , 2022 ABKB 836 , in Alberta notarizing OPCA documents is prohibited by legislation, instructions of the Law Society of Alberta, and by decisions of this Court and the Alberta Court of Appeal.
In R v Ayyazi , a lawyer who improperly notarized pseudolaw documents that purported to terminate a criminal proceeding and that threatened court personnel and Crown Prosecutors was fined $10,000. Subsequently, an Alberta lawyer who notarized pseudolaw documents for Ms. Anderson was fined $5,000 for that: Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 838 . [ 46 ] I am deeply troubled by the fact a Canadian paralegal authorized by a Law Society would provide notorial certification for an obviously pseudolaw document.
However, since this activity occurred in a jurisdiction subject to other legislation and professional certification, I will limit my response to directing copies of this decision to the Law Society of Ontario and Christine Wong, personally.
If the Law Society of Ontario has not done so previously, I very strongly recommend that the Law Society of Ontario caution its members about notarizing OPCA documents, noting the commentary in R v Ayyazi at paras 40-55 , and Donald J Netolitzky, “Humdrum Becomes a Headache: Lawyers Notarizing Organized Pseudolegal Commercial Argument Documents” (2019) 49:3 Advocates’ Quarterly 279. VII.
Conclusion [ 47 ] The Court orders the Clerk of the Court to satisfy the Rule 10.49(1) penalties imposed in this Memorandum of Decision by paying $70,000 of the funds held by the Court pursuant to RBC v Anderson #5 at paras 19-21 . [ 48 ] The Court imposes interim and indefinite litigation and litigant management steps on Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz, as identified above. [ 49 ] The Plaintiffs in this matter are instructed to indicate by June 16, 2023 whether the Plaintiffs will file a Judicature Act s 23.1(4) application to impose court access restrictions on Estella Meza and Basil Panidisz. [ 50 ] Mindful of the Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 instruction that Canadian judges shall provide information on litigation alternatives to self-represented litigants, such as Ms.
Anderson, if Ms. Anderson disagrees with the result of this Memorandum of Decision, she should appeal to the Alberta Court of Appeal. [ 51 ] The Court will prepare and file the Order giving effect to this Memorandum of Decision. The approval of Ms. Anderson, Estella Meza, and Basil Panidisz of that Order is dispensed with, pursuant to Rule 9.4(2)(c). Ms. Anderson, Estella Meza, and Basil Panidisz shall be served this Decision and the corresponding Order to the email address used by Ms Anderson, and the “saalivingtrust@gmail.com” email address.
The Court will also serve Counsel for the Plaintiffs, the Minister, the Law Society of Ontario, and Christine Wong a copy of this Memorandum of Decision and the corresponding Order. [ 52 ] Susan Anderson, Ms. Anderson’s sister has not apparently to date been involved in any of her sister’s activities in the Docken v Anderson lawsuit. I very strongly recommend Susan Anderson, as a co-Defendant to Ms. Anderson, immediately seek legal advice from a lawyer certified to practice law in Alberta by the Law Society of Alberta. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 12 th day of May, 2023. C.M. Jones J.C.K.B.A.
Appearances: None Appendix A: “COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH FOR SPECIAL TRUST DEPOSIT – CONFIDENTIAL” Notice to Agent is Notice to Principal; Notice to Principal Is Notice to Agent A SECURITY (15 USC)
COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT U.S. S.E.C.
TRACER FLAG NOT A POINT OF LAW [Crown and Estella Meza-Trustee for laurel design SANDRA ANN ANDERSON graphic] Living Revocable Trust c/o PO Box 99900 CA 253 239 RPO Old Town Okotoks, Alberta [T1S 0N6] 210-274-3409 saalivingtrust@gmail.com HEAD CLERK OF COURT, ALBERTA COURT OF KING'S BENCH (KB) and THE PROVINCIAL COURT OF ALBERTA (PC) [redacted], acting as Court clerk Supervisor (KB) [redacted], acting as Court Clerk (KB) [redacted] (PC) and all other Court Clerks for the ALBERTA COURT OF KINGS BENCH and THE PROVINCIAL COURT OF ALBERTA (COURTS) 601 5th Street Calgary Alberta T 2P-5P7 Ph: 403-297-3122 (PC) & 403-297-7538 (KB) Email (KB) [redacted]@gov.ab.ca Email (PC): [redacted]@just.gov.ab April 30th, 2023 Re: Request for Oath(
s) of Office for Clerks and Judges and Copies of any an all orders for SANDRA ANN ANDERSON idem sonans and SANDRA ANN ANDERSON LIVING TRUST (REVOCABLE) COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH FOR SPECIAL TRUST DEPOSIT – CONFIDENTIAL Greetings [redacted] and [redacted], As the Trustee(
s) for the SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Trust (Revocable), we are responsible for handling all matters pertaining to the Trust and have a fiduciary duty to protect and ensure no harm is brought upon the Beneficiary. 1- Request-Oath/Orders Sandra Ann Anderson Living Revocable Trust Page 1 of 3 Estimated Fault $1,000,000.00
[5 cent postage stamp with illegible gold handwriting] Notice to Agent is Notice to Principal; Notice to Principal Is Notice to Agent A SECURITY (15 USC) COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT U.S. S.E.C.
TRACER FLAG NOT A POINT OF LAW Basil Panidisz, co-Trustee, attempted to file some documents into the Court of King's Bench on April 11 th , 2023 on behalf of the SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Trust (Revocable) but was denied by an acting clerk named [redacted]. (See Affidavit enclosed) As Fiduciaries we are required to follow up on this denial and request the following actions and information from the Clerks and the COURTS: 1) A certified true copy of the Oath of Office for the following: a. the Head Clerk of the COURT OF KING'S BENCH ALBERTA, b. [redacted], acting a Clerk of Court c. [redacted], acting as Clerk of Court d.
A man Clerk, whom refused to disclose his name to the Trustee, but whom is reported, by other Clerks of the Court, to be named [redacted] (last name not provided) acting Supervisor for the PROVINCIAL COURT OF ALBERTA-CALGARY e. and all other individuals acting as Supervising Clerks of the same COURTS listed in a and d; and 2) A copy of the law, not Staute or Code, that allows the Clerks to deny the Trustee(
s) filing documents into the COURT OF KING'S BENCH ALBERTA on behalf of the SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Trust (Revocable); and 3) A certified true copy of any and all Order(
s) that show/state the Trustee(
s) on behalf of the SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Trust (Revocable) are refrained from filing documents into the COURTS; and 4) A certified true Copy of any and all Order(
s) made for/against the named SANDRA ANN ANDERSON idem sonans; and 5) A certified true Copy ofthe Oath of Office from every Judge that has issued an Order for/against the named SANDRA ANN ANDERSON idem sonans; and 6) A certified true Copy of any and all Warrants and supporting Documentation (Affidavit, bond etc) for SANDRA ANDERSON idem sonans. NOTE: The Trustee(
s) are requesting the warrants (#6 above) from you and the COURT OF KING'S BENCH as we have been told by the Government of Alberta's Justice of Alberta's FOIP (Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act) division that we are to submit our request to the COURT OF KING’S BENCH (See enclosures) 1- Request-Oath/Orders Sandra Ann Anderson Living Revocable Trust Page 2 of 3 Estimated Fault $1,000,000.00 [5 cent postage stamp with illegible gold handwriting]
Notice to Agent is Notice to Principal; Notice to Principal Is Notice to Agent A SECURITY (15 USC) COMMERCIAL AFFIDAVIT U.S. S.E.C. TRACER FLAG NOT A POINT OF LAW The Trustee(
s) require this information to be provided, via email or registered mail to the address on page 1, within 10 calendar days from the date of this notice. Should you or your office chose not to provide the requested information, the Trustee(
s) require the law that allows your refusal and if no lawful reason can be provided this is a goodwill warning the Trustee(
s) will have no choice but to implement "judicial enforcement" against any and all individuals at a personal and professional level and seek monetary compensation from the COURTS and acting Clerks. The Trustee(
s) wish to keep this matter amicable, non-combatant and non-aggressive as the Trustee(
s) have a fiduciary duty to ensure no additional harm is brought to the Beneficiary. We look forward to receipt of the requested documents. Govern yourself accordingly, [handwritten signature Estella Meza] Estella Meza Trustee of SANDRA ANN ANDERSON Living Trust (revocable) ENCLOSURES: Affidavit of Basil Panidisz, Trustee FOIP Request April 27th, 2023 1- Request-Oath/Orders Sandra Ann Anderson Living Revocable Trust Page 3 of 3 Estimated Fault $1,000,000.00 [5 cent postage stamp with illegible gold handwriting]
Loading document…