Rana v Rana, 2023 ABKB 295
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Rana v Rana, 2023 ABKB 295 Date: 20230515 Docket: 1501 02369 Registry: Calgary Between: Salim Rana Proposed Applicant - and - Zahir Rana, Attorney for Gulzar Rana Proposed Respondent _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Salim Rana (Mr. S.
Rana), was made subject to indefinite and global court access restriction gatekeeping pursuant to Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 ss 23-23.1 in a Memorandum of Decision reported as Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 139 , that has been confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 172 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 378 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40580 (30 March 2023). The effect of those court access restrictions is that Mr. S. Rana must seek permission – “leave” – prior to initiating litigation and litigation steps. [ 2 ] Mr. S.
Rana is in a dispute with his brother, Zahir Rana (Mr. Z Rana) over Mr. Z. Rana’s conduct of his mother Gulzar’s affairs: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 455 [ Rana Setting Trial Decision ]. After many years of pre-trial applications and decisions, and two
and half years of case management, on June 20, 2022 Devlin J issued Reasons and an Order to Set Trial of the inter-sibling dispute: Rana Setting Trial Decision . The Rana v Rana trial is now scheduled for February 5-9, 2024. Throughout the protracted process that led to the June 20, 2022 Reasons, Mr. S. Rana engaged in numerous unsuccessful applications and collateral proceedings to the central dispute. That abusive conduct led to the court access restrictions now in force against Mr. S. Rana. Mr. S. Rana has been consistently both persistent and aggressive in his conduct of this litigation. For example, Mr. S.
Rana has sought leave from the Supreme Court of Canada on no less than 23 occasions. In each instance, Mr. S. Rana’s leave application was dismissed. [ 3 ] In the Rana Setting Trial Decision at paras 21-23, Justice Devlin ordered that Mr. S. Rana pay into Court outstanding costs awards made against Mr. S. Rana: ... Salim presently owes over $90,000 in outstanding cost awards. In previous reasons, reported at 2021 ABQB 154 , I awarded Zahir security for costs in the amount of $25,000, which has been paid into Court. As explained in those reasons, Salim does not reside in Alberta and has no assets here.
The Court has every reason to believe that will continue to be the case up to and after trial. Zahir has little hope of recovering any costs awarded above what is secured in Court. In light of the apparent merits of Salim’s claim, given that the promissory note was signed at a time when Gulzar had lost capacity and Zahir was acting under a power of attorney, it would be unjust to require Zahir to incur the further costs of a five-day trial with such large costs awards already outstanding. ...
The security posted in the pre-trial process will go only a small distance toward ameliorating the financial injustice he may face if successful at trial. I am mindful that Zahir acts as attorney for Gulzar and that it is her resources that have been and will continue to be depleted by this litigation. ... Therefore, I find that it is appropriate that Salim be compelled to post security for any outstanding cost awards prior to trial. [ 4 ] On May 2, 2023, the Court received from Mr. S.
Rana an “Application for Leave to File Application for Waiver of Costs to Proceed to Trial” (Application), also accompanied by a 145 page Affidavit of Mr. S. Rana, sworn on April 29, 2023. As I understand the Application, Mr. S. Rana seeks leave of the Court to file an “application for waiver of costs” that would have the effect of negating the Order of Justice Devlin in Rana Setting Trial Decision at paras 21-23. Mr. S. Rana in the Application is explicit that he believes Justice Devlin erred in taking this step on multiple bases. Mr. S Rana also seeks “[c]osts of this Application on a full indemnity basis ...”.
II. Test for Leave to Initiate Litigation [ 5 ] “... [A] person subject to court access control is presumed to engage in illegitimate litigation unless the Court is satisfied otherwise. ...”: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at para 19 , aff’d 2018 ABCA 111 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38204 (14 February 2019). [ 6 ] Permission to initiate litigation or continue stayed litigation both test the merit of Court activities on the same standard.
A person subject to court access restrictions must: 1) establish reasonable grounds for the litigation; and 2) depose fully and completely as to the facts and circumstances surrounding the proposed claim or proceeding. ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 27; VWW v Wasylyshen , 2013 ABQB 327 at para 42 , aff’d 2014 ABCA 121 .) [ 7 ] This threshold, that must be established on a balance of probabilities, is not a high one, and, in many ways, parallels the test for
Summary Judgment: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 19 , 26.
The person subject to Court access leave restrictions is expected to put his or her “best foot forward” to establish the basis to initiate or continue an Action: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at paras 26-27. [ 8 ] The documents necessary to seek leave are an affidavit to provide evidence, and, in the case of a new Action, Application, Appeal, or other litigation step, a copy of the proposed initiating filing: e.g., Re Moore , 2018 ABQB 261 ; Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 . [ 9 ] Leave may be granted in part: Latham (Re) , 2018 ABQB 906 ; Belway v Lalande-Weber , 2017 ABCA 108 at para 10 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 37708 (21 December 2017). [ 10 ] Leave submissions to initiate or continue litigation may be rejected: 1) where the materials do not satisfy the criteria set out in the Court Access Restriction Order ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38267 (31 January 2019); Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38266 (31 January 2019); Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta v Drover , 2021 ABQB 511 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ); 2) if the submissions exhibit indicia of abusive litigation ( ET v Calgary Catholic School District No 1 , 2017 ABCA 349 at para 12 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38081 (8 November 2018); Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Thompson v Alberta Labour Relations Board , 2018 ABQB 220 ; Re Botar , 2018 ABQB 193 ; Trinity Place Foundation of Alberta v Templanza , 2019 ABQB 45 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Fletcher v Davidson & Williams LLP , 2019 ABQB 396 ; Ubah v Canadian Natural Resources Limited , 2021 ABQB 208 ; Knutson (Re) , 2021 ABQB 367 ; McMunn v Hok , 2021 ABQB 550 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40284 (4 May 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 79 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 97 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40284 (4 May 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Fiset v Feeney , 2022 ABQB 211 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Richardson v MacDonald , 2022 ABQB 274 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2022 ABQB 498 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ; Hayden v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce , 2023 ABKB 100 ; Ubah v Ubah , 2023 ABKB 111 );
3) where the abusive litigant refuses to provide the proposed filing ( Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 355 ; Onischuk (Re) , 2019 ABQB 229 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); 4) where the abusive litigant provides false information or fails to provide necessary information ( Re Gauthier , 2018 ABQB 99 ; Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 ; Bissky v MacDonald , 2022 ABKB 774 ); 5) where the abusive litigant fails to provide materials that are required to evaluate the proposed litigation step, such as a transcript of a proceeding proposed for appeal ( Alberta Treasury Branches v Hok , 2018 ABQB 316 ; Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Hayden , 2021 ABQB 985 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40284 (4 May 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 ; Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ); and 6) where the Court has no jurisdiction over the matter ( Hayden v Alberta Health Services , 2022 ABQB 335 ; Ubah v Ubah , 2023 ABKB 111 ). [ 11 ] There is no appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta of a decision to deny leave to initiate or continue litigation: r 14.5(4) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 ; Re Gauthier , 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8 .
A litigant who is denied leave to initiate or continue litigation by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta may, however, seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. III. Analysis [ 12 ] Mr. S. Rana’s Application is dismissed. Mr. S. Rana is re-litigating a settled issue that he has appealed to the final Court of Canada. The Application is a collateral attack on decisions of courts whose authority is binding on the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. [ 13 ] Mr. S.
Rana appealed the Rana Setting Trial Decision : Rana v Rana , Calgary 2201-0182AC (Alta CA), that led to leave to appeal Reasons for Decision issued by Veldhuis JA: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 314 ( Rana Setting Trial Appeal ).
The issue of the payment into court of costs is explicitly identified as an issue on appeal: The applicant now seeks permission to appeal some of the terms of the order, specifically ... [t]he term that he pay into court the full outstanding amount of all orders for costs against him in favour of the defendants, 90 days prior to trial, failing which his action and application will be dismissed and the caveat removed. ( Rana Setting Trial Appeal at para 8.) [ 14 ] Justice Veldhuis refused to grant leave to Mr. S. Rana on all grounds of appeal, including the security payment of costs issue, observing that Mr. S.
Rana had not established that the deference owed to Justice Devlin as the Case Management Justice should be overruled, as this was not a “clearest of case” where appellate interference is warranted: Rana Setting Trial Appeal at paras 10-12. [ 15 ] Mr. S. Rana then on October 26, 2022 challenged the Rana Setting Trial Appeal by seeking leave from the Supreme Court of Canada: Rana v Rana , Ottawa 40503 (SCC). That leave application was dismissed on March 9, 2023. The
summary of Mr. S. Rana’s leave to appeal application, as published in the March 10, 2023 Supreme Court of Canada Bulletin, makes it clear that Mr. S.
Rana argued the security for costs issue before the Supreme Court of Canada: Charter of Rights — Access to justice — Civil procedure — Case management — Case management judge granting order for peremptory trial with conditions, including the payment of previous costs awards made against applicant — Whether further examination and submission of material records is required — Whether case management judge erred in reducing time for trial without reducing amount paid into court as security for costs and in requiring previous costs awards to be paid into court as a precondition for trial to proceed — Whether the imposition of excessive costs awards prior to trial impeded the applicant’s fundamental right to access justice, while the applicant’s appeal of the varied vexatious litigant order was still pending in the Court of Appeal. (Emphasis added.) [ 16 ] I, therefore, conclude that the issue that Mr.
S. Rana proposes to raise in his Application has already been addressed and rejected by two courts that are superior to the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. That makes the Application a collateral attack on the Rana Setting Trial Decision , the Rana Setting Trial Appeal , and the Supreme Court of Canada Rana v Rana (9 March 2023), Ottawa 40503 (SCC) leave to appeal decision. This conclusion is a first basis on which I reject Mr. S. Rana’s Application. [ 17 ] Second, after the Rana Setting Trial Appeal , the Court of Appeal of Alberta in Rana v Rana , 2023 ABCA 112 refused to grant leave to appeal to Mr. S.
Rana, and, instead, granted the cross-application of Mr. Z. Rana “... to prohibit further applications in the Court of Appeal unless all Court of Appeal cost awards in the amount of [$7,932.00] are paid in full.” Velhuis JA stated: ... when litigants choose the public court process, they are bound by the remedies imposed by the court, including the payment of costs by the unsuccessful party to the successful party. [ 18 ] This finding of the Court of Appeal of Alberta is a strong legal authority that Mr. S. Rana is properly required to satisfy, in some manner, costs awards as a precursor to litigation.
So while the Rana v Rana , 2023 ABCA 112 decision does not directly relate to the security for costs payment imposed in the Rana Setting Trial Decision , I conclude that this consistent approach to Mr. S. Rana by the Court of Appeal of Alberta means that Mr. S. Rana has not established a reasonable basis to re-open Justice Devlin’s Order in the Rana Setting Trial Decision . That is a second separate basis on which I conclude Mr. S. Rana’s Application should be dismissed and leave not granted. IV. Conclusion
[ 19 ] Mr. S. Rana’s proposed Application is rejected. The Application is clearly and obviously an abuse of this Court and the leave process. Mr. S. Rana has previously been made subject to r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court penalties in response to Mr. S.
Rana’s abuse of this Court’s leave process: e.g., Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 111 , leave denied 2022 ABCA 172 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 114 , leave denied 2022 ABCA 172, leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 139 , leave denied 2022 ABCA 172, leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 141 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023). [ 20 ] In light of Mr. S.
Rana’s continuing and persistent practice of abusing the leave process of this Court, I impose a $5,000 r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court penalty that is to be paid to the Clerk of the Court forthwith. Counsel for Mr. Z. Rana shall prepare that Order. Mr. S. Rana’s approval of that Order is dispensed with pursuant to r 9.4(2)(
c) of the Alberta Rules of Court . [ 21 ] Mr. S. Rana shall be served this Memorandum of Decision and corresponding Order by email. I direct a copy of this Memorandum of Decision is provided to Counsel for Mr. Z. Rana. As indicated above, if Mr. S. Rana disagrees with the outcome of his leave Application, then Mr. S. Rana should seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 15 th day of May, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances by Written Submission: Salim Rana Self-Represented Litigant Andrew Wilson and Erin Baker JSS Barristers No appearance
Loading document…