R v AM, 2023 ABKB 312
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: R v AM, 2023 ABKB 312 Date: 20230525 Docket: 210000592Q1 Registry: Calgary Between: His Majesty the King Crown - and - AM Young Person Restriction on Publication Identification Ban – See the Youth Criminal Justice Act , section 110(1) . No person shall publish the name of a young person or any other information that may identify a young person as having been dealt with under the Youth Criminal Justice Act .
NOTE: Identifying information has been removed from this judgment to comply with the ban so that it may be published. _______________________________________________________ Reasons of Decision of the Honourable Justice A. Loparco _______________________________________________________ Table of Contents
I. Brief Conclusion . 3 II. Background . 4 III. The YCJA .. 5
a) Crown onus . 6
b) Persuasive burden . 7 IV. Issue . 9
a) Position of the Crown . 9
b) Position of AM ... 10 V. The Evidence . 10
a) The PSR .. 10
b) The CPR .. 11
c) The Ennis Report 12 VI. Analysis . 15 a) Section 72(1)(a) 15 Circumstances of the Offender 18 i. Age . 18 ii. Background and antecedents . 19 iii. Whether at the time of the offence AM was – by choice – living like an adult 20 iv. Previous offences . 22 v. Any indicia of dependence on others or vulnerability to the influence of others . 23 vi. Cognitive limitations or emotional/mental health issues . 24 vii. Whether the young person’s personal growth (or lack thereof) indicates anything about him or her at the time of the offence . 25 viii.
Whether the young person took responsibility/demonstrated remorse . 27 ix. Diminished empathy . 29 x. Heightened impulsiveness . 29 xi. Susceptibility to peer pressure . 29 xii. Diminished ability to reason and appreciate the consequences of one's actions . 29 Circumstances of the Offence . 30 Conclusion on Section 72(1)(
a) of the test 31 b) Section 72(1)(b) 32 i. Available sentencing options – the IRCS suggestion . 34 ii. Proposal of an IRCS-like sentence . 36 iii. Adequacy of a youth sentence . 38 VII. Conclusion . 49 I. Brief Conclusion [ 1 ] On November 14, 2022, I found Mr. AM [1] , a young person as defined in the Youth Criminal Justice Act , SC 2002, c 1 ( YCJA ), guilty of manslaughter.
[ 2 ] As part of the sentencing process, the Crown seeks to have AM sentenced as an adult. [ 3 ] For the following Reasons, I find that AM must be sentenced as an adult. [ 4 ] Defence counsel has asked me to conclude that rendering justice in this situation – to the Harnett family, to AM, and to the community – requires me to sentence AM as a youth so that he can have the best chance to rehabilitate. However, in taking a holistic approach, I have had to balance several factors to make the difficult decision that he should be sentenced as an adult. As reflected in the sobering words of Dr.
Ennis, there is “no satisfactory outcome” in this case. [ 5 ] Today, after nearly two and a half years in custody, AM is assessed to be at the second highest risk level to reoffend violently. Despite AM’s failure to recognize any need for rehabilitation, Dr. Ennis stressed that as a high risk, high needs offender, AM requires high intensity programming and supervision. He recommends a program of work skills and education to keep him focused on pro-social goals. Dr.
Ennis cautioned this Court that AM has little hope of rehabilitation if I sentence AM to an adult penitentiary because his psychological profile is such that this will lead him to ‘glom’ onto a negative peer group that will lead him to re-offend upon release, despite good program availability. [ 6 ] As many other courts have stated, sentencing is the most difficult task for a trial judge. In either case – whether sentenced as an adult or youth – there is no guarantee that AM will be rehabilitated such that his risk of reoffending is lowered.
Moreover, my analysis is multi-factorial, individualized, circumstance-driven, and broader than what is in AM’s best interest. [ 7 ] The YCJA provides a two-prong test in determining whether a young person should receive an adult sentence. [ 8 ] The first prong of the test (presumption element) requires me to determine whether the Crown has rebutted the presumption that AM had diminished moral culpability at the time of the index offence, a presumption accorded to every person who has committed a crime while under the age of 18 (even if they are under 18 by mere days, as AM was).
Only if the first question is answered in the affirmative, do I move to the second prong of the test (accountability element), which requires me to assess whether a youth sentence would be of insufficient length to hold AM accountable for his offending behaviour. [ 9 ] I am persuaded that the Crown has rebutted the presumption that AM had diminished moral blameworthiness at the time of the index offence. I find that AM displayed certain indicia of mature behaviour and other indicia of immature behaviour.
Overall, I am satisfied that AM had demonstrated a level of maturity equivalent to an adult at the time of the index offence. [ 10 ] On the second (accountability) prong of the test, I am not satisfied that a youth sentence would be of sufficient length to hold AM accountable.
A youth sentence, which is limited to three years maximum (in any combination available under the YCJA ), would not provide the necessary structure and supervision to achieve the objectives of rehabilitation, reintegration, and accountability, while protecting the public from harm. [ 11 ] According to the Pre-Sentence Report and Custodial Progress Report, while some improvements in AM’s conduct and disposition are noted - likely due to the structured environment he is in - they are far from being transformative.
AM continues to display risk-taking behaviour, defiance of authority figures, chicanery, and lack of accountability. I find these behaviours, rooted in personality traits explained by Dr. Ennis as narcissism and deceptiveness, continue to persist today. [ 12 ] While I acknowledge that sending AM to an adult penitentiary may result in him associating with a pro-criminal peer group, I do not accept that rehabilitation is futile. AM has demonstrated the capacity to make mature choices and associate with positive peer influences, including his mother, siblings, and staff at the youth detention centres.
Transformation is therefore possible if AM chooses to adhere to the program. [ 13 ] Given AM’s psychological makeup, Dr. Ennis opined that he needs structure, routine, intensive programming, a graduated release with conditions, close monitoring, and a long period of supervision in the community to maintain a pro-social trajectory. A meaningful sentence with long-term hope of rehabilitation for AM will take patience and buy-in by AM, which is lacking at the present time. I do not believe that a sentence under the YCJA can be crafted to achieve this result. II.
Background [ 14 ] AM was charged with first degree murder arising from events which followed a traffic stop on New Year’s Eve, 2020. The evidence is laid out in some detail in my Reasons: 2022 ABKB 754 (“Trial Reasons”). The following
summary is sufficient for sentencing purposes. [ 15 ] AM was the driver of a vehicle which had been pulled over by Sgt. Harnett of the Calgary Police Service (CPS) for driving without activated headlights. AM had a front seat and a backseat passenger with him when he was pulled over. A second police cruiser with Constables Desroches and Osmond arrived to provide backup to Sgt. Harnett, who was on patrol alone. [ 16 ] The police computer systems were not functioning properly at the time, and it took much longer than usual to process the identification information provided by both AM and his front seat passenger.
When Sgt. Harnett eventually returned to the vehicle to issue AM tickets for the driving infractions, AM drove off. Sgt. Harnett attempted to prevent flight by grabbing hold of the vehicle’s front door and steering wheel. [ 17 ] AM drove through the parking lot while dragging Sgt. Harnett until the vehicle became temporarily stuck on a snow berm. When the vehicle regained traction, AM took off eastbound down Falconridge Drive, a busy roadway, with Sgt. Harnett still hanging off the vehicle. As the vehicle sped down Falconridge Drive, AM attempted to dislodge Sgt. Harnett from the vehicle.
He first applied direct force to Sgt. Harnett’s arm and then he pushed and kicked the driver’s side door, causing it to sway away from the body of the vehicle. Finally, he executed a jerking maneuver of the steering wheel, which caused the vehicle to “zig zag” back and forth. Following this last maneuver, Sgt. Harnett was dislodged from the vehicle and rolled into the oncoming traffic lane. He was hit by an oncoming car and died
later in hospital because of his injuries. After Sgt. Harnett fell away from the vehicle, AM fled the scene. The entirety of the flight lasted 36 seconds from the point when Sgt. Harnett grabbed onto the vehicle to the time he fell into oncoming traffic. [ 18 ] In finding AM not guilty of murder but guilty of the lesser included offence of manslaughter, I found that the Crown had established the commission of the actus reus - that AM’s conduct caused the death of Sgt. Harnett- beyond a reasonable doubt.
Turning next to the mens rea analysis, I found that the Crown had established that AM meant to cause bodily harm, but that a reasonable doubt existed as to whether AM knew that his actions in attempting to dislodge Sgt. Harnett from the vehicle were likely to cause death. The question of recklessness was not in issue on the facts. [ 19 ] Having found that a reasonable doubt existed as to whether AM knew that the bodily harm he inflicted would probably be fatal, subjective knowledge had not been established on the required burden.
Nevertheless, the elements for manslaughter had been established, as objectively, a reasonable person would have possessed such knowledge. [ 20 ] AM returns before this Court for sentencing. As stated, the Crown has made a preliminary application pursuant to s 64 of the YCJA to have him sentenced as an adult. Further relevant sections of the YCJA are discussed below. [ 21 ] The difference between the adult and youth sentencing regimes in cases involving the offence of manslaughter can be significant. Under the YCJA , manslaughter is considered a “serious violent offence”: s 2(1).
An offender receiving a youth sentence for the offence of manslaughter may be subject to a custody and supervision order for a term not exceeding three years: s 42(2)(o). Conversely, under the Criminal Code , an individual who has committed manslaughter is liable to imprisonment for life: s 236(b). [ 22 ] AM was remanded into custody to the Calgary Young Offender Centre on January 2, 2021. Since that time, he has been held on remand status between both the Calgary Young Offender Centre (CYOC) and the Edmonton Young Offender Centre (EYOC) continuously, moving back and forth between both centres.
He has spent approximately one year at each centre. III. The YCJA [ 23 ] Historically, for certain enumerated “presumptive” offences, including the offence of manslaughter, the court was required to impose an adult sentence upon a youthful offender unless the offender could demonstrate that a youth sentence was appropriate. Following the Supreme Court’s decision in R v B(D), 2008 SCC 25 ( B(D) ), the presumption of diminished moral culpability in youths was identified as a principle of fundamental justice. As such, the majority found the reverse onus unconstitutional.
It commented that a separate legal and sentencing regime existed for young people: ... because of their age, young people have heightened vulnerability, less maturity and a reduced capacity for moral judgment. This entitles them to a presumption of diminished moral blameworthiness or culpability: para 41 [emphasis in original]. [ 24 ] The majority further held that one of the primary purposes of the YCJA was to restrict the use of incarceration for young offenders.
It relied on the following observation by Justice Gilles Renaud in Speaking to Sentence: A Practical Guide (Toronto: Thomson Carswell, 2004), at p 10: Stated simply, offenders who act out of immaturity, impulsiveness, or other ill-considered motivation are not to be dealt with as if they were proceeding with the same degree of insight into their wrongdoing as more mature, reflective, or considered individuals. The less elevated the degree of moral blameworthiness, the greater the reach of leniency.
By way of limited example, the relative youth of an offender will be emphasized in those cases in which an individualized disposition is selected ....: B(
D) at para 63 . [ 25 ] This does not mean that for serious offences, an adult sentence will not be appropriate in certain circumstances. As noted by the majority at paras 93-94: This does not make young persons less accountable for serious offences; it makes them differently accountable. Nor does it mean that a court cannot impose an adult sentence on a young person.
It means that before a court can do so, the Crown, not the young person, should have the burden of showing that the presumption of diminished moral culpability has been rebutted and that the young person is no longer entitled to its protection. ...The Crown may still persuade a youth court judge that an adult sentence...is warranted where a serious crime has been committed. And young persons will continue to be accountable in accordance with their personal circumstances and the seriousness of the offence... [emphasis in original] [ 26 ] Ultimately, the majority’s reasons in B(
D) led to amendments to the (then) YCJA in October of 2012. Not only did the amendments remove “presumptive” offences and expressly place the onus of establishing that an adult sentence was appropriate on the Crown, but they also revised the factors to be considered by the court in determining whether an adult sentence should be imposed.
a) Crown onus [ 27 ]
Section 72 of the YCJA now requires a distinct two-step process be followed: 72.
(1) The youth justice court shall order that an adult sentence be imposed if it is satisfied that (
a) the presumption of diminished moral blameworthiness or culpability of the young person is rebutted; and (
b) a youth sentence imposed in accordance with the purpose and principles set out in subparagraph 3(1)(b)(ii) and
section 38 would not be of sufficient length to hold the young person accountable for his or her offending behaviour.
[ 28 ] The onus of satisfying the court that each of the above has been satisfied lies entirely with the Crown: s 72(2). If the court is not satisfied that an order should be made under subsection (1), the assessment of the Crown’s application comes to an end, and it shall order that a youth sentence must be imposed: s 72(1.1).
b) Persuasive burden [ 29 ] In discussing the Crown’s burden in R v AWB , 2018 ABCA 159 ( AWB ), the Court stated, at para 21 that: The Crown has the "onus of satisfying" the judge that an adult sentence is required: s 72(1.1). "Satisfaction" is the standard of proof, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt or on a balance of probabilities: R. v. T. (D.D.), 2010 ABCA 365 (Alta. C.A.) at paras 6-7 , (2010), 493 A.R. 167 (Alta.
C.A.). [ 30 ] A comprehensive explanation of the onus and standard of proof was provided by (then) Moreau J in R v M(C), 2015 ABQB 134 at para 7 ( CM 2015 ), which remains instructive notwithstanding it addressed the YCJA as it read prior to the October 2012 amendments. She stated that: … s. 72 of the YCJA requires the youth court justice to weigh and balance the enumerated factors and decide whether a youth sentence is sufficiently long to hold a young person accountable for his or her offending behaviour.
This type of evaluative decision — making an informed judgment — does not lend itself to proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden on the Crown is a persuasive burden, balancing the relevant factors under s. 72(1) and considering the purpose and principles of the YCJA set out in ss. 3(1) (
b) and 38 . The decision to impose an adult sentence on a young person is "a very serious one and should only be taken after careful consideration of all the relevant factors" and "when necessary to fulfill the objectives of the YCJA". [Emphasis added] [ 31 ] If the Crown wishes to rely on any aggravating factors, they must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt: see R v McKnight , 2023 ABCA 72 at para 3 ; Criminal Code , s 724(3)(e). [ 32 ] While there may be some degree of overlap in the factors to be considered under s 72(1)(
a) and (b), the
section must be addressed using a distinct two-step approach. In R v H(TJ) and C(ADW) , 2023 MBKB 5 , Martin J reviewed a number of decisions from a variety of jurisdictions and concluded, at para 55 that: Courts of Appeal are now consistent that s. 72(1) YCJA creates a two-part, two-step test, requiring separate or discrete analyses of the two parts of s. 72(1) (
a) and (
b) YCJA. The analyses must not blend the parts, even though some factors or facts will likely overlap…. [ 33 ] While accepting the need for a two-step process, I also note that, as per R v CM , 2018 ABCA 214 ( CM 2018 ), some intermingling or overlap in the analysis may necessarily occur: para 91. [ 34 ] Prior to moving to the analysis of whether the Crown has met its burden, I will first review additional sections of the YCJA , which are also instructive. [ 35 ] Historically, manslaughter was considered a “presumptive offence” under the former YCJA .
Following B(D) , the presumptive offence classification was eliminated. Now, pursuant to the legislation, manslaughter is considered a “serious violent offence”. [ 36 ] Secondly, sentences under the YCJA are presumed to be non-custodial, unless they relate to certain enumerated offences in the Act. Violent offences are included in the types of offence for which a court may impose a custodial sentence: ss 39(1) and s 42. [ 37 ] Further, s 50 of the YCJA expressly provides that
Part XXIII (sentencing) of the Criminal Code does not apply to youth sentencing. In addition, the fundamental principles outlined in s 3 of the YCJA must be considered in arriving at a just sentence, whether AM is sentenced as a youth or an adult: R v JMO , 2017 MBCA 59 at para 121 .
Section 3 of the YCJA states: 3
(1) The following principles apply in this Act: (
a) the youth criminal justice system is intended to protect the public by (
i) holding young persons accountable through measures that are proportionate to the seriousness of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the young person, (ii) promoting the rehabilitation and reintegration of young persons who have committed offences, and (iii) supporting the prevention of crime by referring young persons to programs or agencies in the community to address the circumstances underlying their offending behaviour; (
b) the criminal justice system for young persons must be separate from that of adults, must be based on the principle of diminished moral blameworthiness or culpability and must emphasize the following: (
i) rehabilitation and reintegration, (ii) fair and proportionate accountability that is consistent with the greater dependency of young persons and their reduced level of maturity , (iii) enhanced procedural protection to ensure that young persons are treated fairly and that their rights, including their right to privacy, are protected,
(iv) timely intervention that reinforces the link between the offending behaviour and its consequences, and (
v) the promptness and speed with which persons responsible for enforcing this Act must act, given young persons' perception of time; (
c) within the limits of fair and proportionate accountability, the measures taken against young persons who commit offences should (
i) reinforce respect for societal values, (ii) encourage the repair of harm done to victims and the community, (iii) be meaningful for the individual young person given his or her needs and level of development and, where appropriate, involve the parents, the extended family, the community and social or other agencies in the young person's rehabilitation and reintegration, and (iv) respect gender, ethnic, cultural and linguistic differences and respond to the needs of aboriginal young persons and of young persons with special requirements; and […]
(2) This Act shall be liberally construed so as to ensure that young persons are dealt with in accordance with the principles set out in subsection (1). [emphasis added] [ 38 ] Although a blended sentencing procedure including both the s 64 application by the Crown and the ultimate sentencing by the Court is common (see R v ASD , 2019 BCSC 147 para 4 , aff’d 2020 BCCA 208 ), in the matter before me, on request by Defence counsel, I have decided to not proceed as such. I will first rule on the Crown’s s 64 adult application.
The parties will then return to make separate sentencing submissions, even though the Crown has already provided their preliminary position. They will be given the opportunity to reply to the Defence submissions at a later date. [ 39 ] As such, these preliminary Reasons only deal with whether AM should be sentenced as a youth or as an adult. His actual sentence will be deferred to a later date after complete oral and written submissions have been made. IV. Issue [ 40 ] As noted, the sole issue before me at this stage is whether AM should be sentenced as an adult.
a) Position of the Crown [ 41 ] The Crown argues that it has rebutted the legislative presumption of reduced moral blameworthiness and established that, given the personal circumstances of AM and this violent offence, a youth sentence would not be long enough to hold AM accountable for his crime. The Crown submits that an adult penitentiary sentence in the range of 11-13 years should be imposed.
b) Position of AM [ 42 ] The Defence takes the position that the Crown has failed to satisfy the onus under s 72 of the YCJA and that as a result, the presumption of diminished moral culpability remains applicable. It asserts that a meaningful youth sentence can be crafted to hold AM accountable, while at the same time promoting the goals of rehabilitation and reintegration into society.
The Defence asserts that the concept of justice, including justice for the young person, the victim’s family, and society at large, will best be achieved through a youth sentence reflecting the fundamental principles underlying the YCJA . [ 43 ] Counsel submits that a youth sentence with a strong focus on rehabilitative programming will best achieve all the relevant sentencing goals in the YCJA . V.
The Evidence [ 44 ] The evidence in this Application consists of this Court’s findings of fact contained in my Trial Reasons, as well as a Custodial Progress Report dated January 6, 2023 (CPR), a Pre-Sentence Report dated January 4, 2023 (PSR), and the Expert Report of Dr. Liam Ennis, dated January 27, 2023 (Ennis Report), and his oral testimony. It also consists of the Victim Impact Statements, which bear on the second stage of the analysis.
In addition, I have considered a bound book of Defence materials provided at the hearing, which include a telephone message for AM, a list of treatment and courses AM took and is currently enrolled in, certificates of completion, his high school transcript, reference and support letters, publication of the case and identity of AM and failed attempts to have media outlets comply with the publication ban, and the Statement of Claim naming AM as a defendant . [ 45 ] While the salient elements of the evidence in this Application will be discussed in conjunction with my analysis of the matter, I believe it is instructive to briefly summarize the three reports.
a) The PSR [ 46 ] AM was interviewed by the author of the PSR on two separate occasions in December of 2022. Information from AM’s family, as well as corrections/community workers was also incorporated into the Report. AM’s PSR is generally favourable. It notes that AM’s perspective since custody has changed and that he now accepts increased personal responsibility for his actions. The PSR states
that overall, AM has demonstrated personal growth and has made strides towards adopting a more positive attitude when dealing with authority figures. It notes that he took a number of programs and has adopted a leadership role. The Report indicated that the access to these programs, “…along with his maturity and growth, have allowed him to have a more positive, supported and productive experience, especially in this past year”. The PSR indicates that AM has a positive family support network and that he acknowledges the need to stay away from negative peer influences.
It further notes that as his time in the young offender centers progressed, he demonstrated an increased ability to accept consequences stemming from his actions. Finally, it notes that he has reconnected with his Muslim faith. [ 47 ] In
summary, the PSR concludes that AM has demonstrated increased personal growth and maturity over the last year. The Report reflects that AM’s words and actions are reflective of regret and remorse and that he is making efforts to better himself through the programs available to him. Given the serious nature of the offence, the PSR recommends a custodial sentence.
b) The CPR [ 48 ] The CPR was somewhat less complimentary than the PSR. It noted numerous difficulties with AM’s behaviour, although these difficulties appeared more prominent at the outset of his custody. His initial behaviour when remanded into CYOC exhibited a disinclination to follow rules, and a reluctance to accept responsibility, mainly by claiming ignorance of rules he had just been informed of. During the first three months of custody, AM was involved in three behavioural incidents requiring staff intervention.
During this time, he was consistently rated as a level one or two, on a four-tiered behavioural level system, with a level “four” being the highest level indicating good behaviour. AM was confrontational with staff and other inmates and consistently misused the telephone system. [ 49 ] Between April and December of 2021, AM’s behavioural rating continued to fluctuate as he continued to behave inconsistently. During this period of time, he was again involved in three behavioural incidents requiring staff interventions.
He was noted as being disrespectful to his teachers and having difficulty following certain rules. He continued to misuse the telephone system. By December of 2021, his behaviour had more or less stabilized at a level three rating. [ 50 ] At the end of December of 2021, AM was transferred to the EYOC. He was then transferred back and forth between CYOC and EYOC to accommodate meetings with his counsel as well as court appearances. He maintained a level three rating for some time but was noted in February of 2022 to be typically oscillating between a level two and three.
He continued to be argumentative with staff and exhibited behavioral issues. It was noted that he did not take responsibility for these actions. [ 51 ] Between Spring and Fall of 2022, which I note was just prior to his trial, AM was able to maintain a level four rating. Positive comments and appropriate interactions were noted in the Report during this time. However, in each of October, November, and December of 2022, AM was involved in a behavioural incident requiring staff intervention.
The Report’s author notes that due to AM’s ongoing non-compliance with the telephone system and lack of initiative, he has remained at a level two to three rating since December 2022, which I note as being after his conviction in November 2022. [ 52 ] On December 13, 2022, AM was involved in a behavioural incident requiring staff intervention. His approved call list included a phone number associated with AM’s lawyer, but it was later determined to be the number of a peer who had been readmitted to EYOC that day.
The author of the PSR interviewed AM on December 8 and December 15, at which point in time AM acknowledged his issues with a negative peer group and advised that he had “cut ties” with these individuals. [ 53 ] The CPR detailed a number of rehabilitative programs offered while in custody, which AM participated in, and which focused on making positive change, enhancing decision-making, accepting responsibility, anger-management, coping and life skills. The programs and the goals to which they ascribe are explained in detail in the Report and do not require repetition.
AM was noted to have behaved appropriately while engaged in these programs. He demonstrated leadership by approaching EYOC staff about developing a sharing circle program. [ 54 ] AM’s intervention worker, Ms. Nadia Fix, was contacted for the purposes of both the PSR and the CPR. Ms. Fix indicated that over time, AM has demonstrated a mature sense of interaction and personal growth.
c) The Ennis Report [ 55 ] The only expert evidence report tendered was the January 27, 2023 Report of Dr. Ennis, for the young person. The Crown relied in part upon the Report and its cross-examination of Dr. Ennis. [ 56 ] The Crown is not required to adduce its own expert evidence in order to meet its burden: AWB at para 23 . Counsel for AM suggests that the Crown solely relied on the potential inferences that might be drawn from the Trial Decision. I disagree. The Crown certainly referenced these findings, but it also relied upon the Custodial Reports, as well as Dr.
Ennis’s Report and his oral testimony. [ 57 ] I acknowledge that no expert evidence was tendered proffering an opinion as to whether AM was likely functioning as a youth or as an adult at the time of the offence. While such expert evidence would have been useful to my analysis, its absence is not fatal to the Crown’s application given the entirety of the evidence before me. [ 58 ] Dr. Ennis was qualified following a voir dire . His CV was impressive; he has a breadth of relevant experience and exhibited a dedication to ongoing education on performing risk assessments.
He was qualified as an expert in criminal forensic behavioural psychology and, in particular, to opine on risk assessment, criminal recidivism, and provide assistance on the topic of criminality over the span of an individual’s life. The Crown did not oppose his qualifications. [ 59 ] During the voir dire , Dr.
Ennis stated that he specifically worked with adolescents during his graduate studies, as well when he was with EIFW, but that he currently takes on only “a handful” of adolescent referrals each year with his current practice. [ 60 ] Overall, I was satisfied under the White Burgess test that he was properly qualified to give evidence within the scope noted
above: White Burgess Langille Inman v Abbott and Haliburton Co , 2015 SCC 23 . [ 61 ] Given the nature of his expertise, Dr. Ennis’s evidence did not bear directly on whether the presumption of diminished moral culpability would have been applicable to AM at the time of the indexed offence. Rather, he focused on AM’s likelihood of recidivism and how that risk might best be managed. [ 62 ] In his Report, Dr. Ennis summarized both the PSR and the CPR in evaluating AM’s in-custody behaviour.
He noted trends whereby AM would receive a higher behavioural rating but would not be able to stay at that increased rating permanently. Dr. Ennis noted that AM’s non-compliance with the telephone system and “lack of initiative” has resulted in a level two or three rating since December of 2022. Dr. Ennis noted that AM’s biggest ongoing behavioral issue appeared to be his continuing misuse of the telephone system, but that this was indicative of a pattern of behaviour that partly informs his overall opinion of him. [ 63 ] Dr Ennis reported that AM shared the following personal insights.
AM describes himself as a very different person in 2023 than he was at the time the offence occurred. He stated that doing jail time really “woke him up”; he stated that in the past he would react impulsively, but now at age 20, he does not act without thinking. In describing himself at the time of the offence, AM indicted that: • He used to act tough and macho; the mistreatment he experienced in childhood made him angry and he used to act based on emotions, rather than using his brain; • He used to reject authority and continued doing so when first remanded. Spending time in jail has been a wake-up call for him.
He now wants to facilitate a group assisting younger offenders in changing their anti-authority attitudes; • His historical conflicts with the law stemmed from his willingness to engage in antisocial behavior and the negative influence of the peer group he was associated with; • In speaking of the offence – AM stated that he could not process things – he was young, stupid, and scared and he just wanted to leave; and • He does not believe that he requires any additional rehabilitation or therapy. [ 64 ] Dr.
Ennis’s Report then summarized AM’s performance on a number of standard psychological tests, including the WASI-II, the PAI, and the JI-R. These tests were largely unremarkable, although Dr. Ennis noted that under the PAI, AM tends to portray himself as relatively free of common shortcomings and has difficulties acknowledging negative or unpleasant aspects of himself . Conversely, he placed a greater emphasis on the impact of traumatic events and a history of antisocial behaviours. Dr.
Ennis also noted that despite AM’s recognition that several areas of his life are not going well, he is not motivated to pursue ongoing treatment and that he may resist the idea that personal changes are needed . [ 65 ] In discussing the JI-R results, Dr. Ennis noted that AM’s profile is that of a “conformist” and that as such, he may be inclined to perform to the standards of those whom he feels are in control. Conformists may exhibit anxiety. Conformists may feel little concern about their past behaviour and be disinclined to look critically at themselves or regard themselves as delinquent .
For “conformists” interactions with delinquent peers should be minimized. [ 66 ] In assessing AM’s risk of future violence (revised VRAG-R), Dr. Ennis assessed AM’s score of +25 as placing him in the second highest of nine ascending risk categories (i.e., a score of 8 out of 9). This places his result as equal to or higher than 89% of the violent offenders in his comparison group. Fifty-eight percent of individuals in AM’s category were charged with a new violent offence within an average of 5 years following release into the community.
Over a 12-year span, this rate of recidivism rose to 78%. [ 67 ] In discussing AM’s LS/CMI score results, Dr. Ennis noted that AM ranked either “high” or “very high” on the following risk/needs factors: companions, pro-criminal attitudes, antisocial patterns, and overall risk/need level. Dr, Ennis notes that: [AM] is a high risk, high needs offender, as indicated by high scores on two well-validated measures of criminal and violent recidivism. As a high risk, high needs offender, [AM] requires high intensity treatment and supervision . [ 68 ] In concluding on the risks of an adult sentence, Dr.
Ennis was deeply concerned about AM’s inability to avoid pro-criminal peer influences in an adult custodial institution, which he opines would undermine any rehabilitative and reintegration objectives. He referenced AM’s 2019 work with Dr. Day wherein AM acknowledged how engagement with a negative peer group impacted his behaviour. He claimed to have ended these relationships. However, Dr. Ennis noted that this claim turned out to be “untrue, or only temporarily true” as AM reconnected with antisocial peers. Dr.
Ennis stated that: I am willing to take [AM] at his word when he asserts his desire to refrain from relationships with antisocial peers henceforth; however, I do not believe [AM] has the psychological or social skills to establish and maintain such relationships at present. I believe [AM] is overly self-congratulatory in his appraisal of the progress he has made in custody thus far. Although his behaviour has improved over the past two years he continues to engage in manipulative and evasive behaviour (e.g., listing a delinquent peer's number on his professional call list).
Although I am dubious of the notion that he has progressed to the point that he is able to provide guidance about antiauthority attitudes to younger offenders, [AM] does appear to have come to identify with staff more than with delinquent peers at EYOC. Given his need for affiliation and his tendency to adopt the norms and values of the group, his identification with staff rather than peers may be viewed as a positive. [ 69 ] Despite the above, Dr. Ennis has expressed the opinion that AM will continue to benefit from additional rehabilitative programming.
He noted that although relevant programming is available in both the adult and youth correctional systems, the intensive
programming within – and graduated release from – the youth correctional system is more likely to prepare AM for a pro-social future. Dr. Ennis opined that given that AM’s primary risk factor is influence of negative peers, the adult correctional system would be a poor placement for AM from a recidivism standpoint, given what would be an increased exposure to inmate subculture and criminal attitudes . [ 70 ] Dr. Ennis concluded that AM’s poor insight into the causes of his problems and his inflated belief that he can maintain a pro- social and crime-free lifestyle without any additional supports is problematic.
He states that AM will require imposed restrictions and conditions as well as close monitoring upon his return to the community. [ 71 ] Dr. Ennis was clear that in his view, peer influence is the single biggest risk to AM re-offending upon release from any sort of custodial setting. He opined that given AM’s high need to be accepted by a peer group, if he falls in with the wrong people, he will return to criminality. [ 72 ] In discussing how the risk of recidivism might be reduced, Dr.
Ennis opined that AM would benefit most from a rehabilitative program that focuses on education and work skills, which will allow AM to operate productively in society. Dr. Ennis indicated that AM’s identity and self-esteem are built through his accomplishments and that as such, an approach which stresses job and people skills as a part of the rehabilitative aspect of sentencing will lead to the best long-term outcome from a pro-social stance. [ 73 ] During his testimony, Dr.
Ennis indicated that AM could benefit from programs which develop work/life skills at either an adult federal or provincial institution, although he does not favour either option given the related exposure to anti-social influences. Dr. Ennis opined that although the federal penal system probably offers more of what AM requires vis-à-vis job training, this system comes with the related “poison pill” of exposure to extreme criminal peers.
In his view, AM’s risk is best addressed through a placement which includes a combination of job skills training coupled with a lengthy period of supervision in a context where AM is not deeply embedded with highly criminalized individuals . [ 74 ] The element of ongoing supervision in any post-custody release program was repeatedly emphasized by Dr. Ennis. [ 75 ] Given the risk of negative peer influence attached to rehabilitation in a custodial setting, Dr.
Ennis concluded that: [AM] appears to have benefited from the interventions that have been introduced thus far, including the overall structure and routine of the institution, educational programming, and his participation and engagement in low intensity rehabilitative programs. Although relevant programming is available in both the adult and youth correctional systems, intensive programming within, and graduated release from youth corrections, is the path most likely to prepare [AM] for a pro-social life upon his inevitable release.
My rationale for this opinion is that [AM]'s primary risk factor is negative peer influences, particularly those who are older and whom he views as authorities.
In adult corrections, [AM] is likely to be indoctrinated into the inmate subculture, reinforcing criminal attitudes, establishing more and new criminal associations , and limiting his opportunities for prosocial endeavors and opportunities post-release. [ 76 ] With the above in mind, I turn to the core issue of whether the Crown has rebutted the presumption of diminished moral culpability and established that a youth sentence would not be of a sufficient length to impart the accountability required. VI.
Analysis a) Section 72(1)(a) [ 77 ] There appears to be varying approaches as to which factors should be considered when assessing whether the burden under s 72(1)(
a) has been met. As noted above, the wording of s 72(1) of the YCJA was amended in 2012. The prior version required the Court to assess the following factors in determining the Crown’s Application for an adult sentence: the seriousness and circumstances of the offence, the young person's age, maturity, character, background and previous record, as well as any other factors deemed to be relevant in determining whether a youth sentence would be of sufficient length to hold the young person accountable for their behaviour.
In R v M(C) , 2013 ABPC 30 , our Provincial Court held that while the consideration of these matters is no longer mandated, they nevertheless remain relevant: para 38. See also R v X , 2014 NSPC 95 para 7 . [ 78 ] Following the presumption established in B(D) , Rowbotham JA, in R v R(JF) , 2016 ABCA 340 ( R(JF) ), highlighted three factors to be determined in analysing whether the presumption of diminished moral culpability has been rebutted. These factors are: (
i) heightened vulnerability; (ii) reduced maturity level, and; (iii) reduced capacity for moral judgment (at para 19). The interplay between these factors and the presumption was reiterated by our Court of Appeal in CM 2018 , as follows at para 93: In this respect, it should be recalled that Abella J in R. v. B. (D.) …observed that Canada's separate legal regime for young people, arose for the reason that " because of their age, young people have heightened vulnerability, less maturity and a reduced capacity for moral judgment .
This entitles them to a presumption of diminished moral blameworthiness or culpability."… [Emphasis in original]. [ 79 ] In R(JF) , Berger JA, concurring in the result, wrote that the foundational factors of heightened vulnerability, immaturity and decreased capacity for moral judgment are variable factors and are always a matter of relative degree.
He went on to indicate that the foundational factors are not exhaustive and that: …The components of the trio of indicia cited by Abella, J., I suggest, include: diminished empathy, heightened impulsiveness, susceptibility to peer pressure and diminished ability to reason and appreciate the consequences of one's actions.
All of these must be assessed on an individualized basis by the sentencing judge whose task is both delicate and difficult: para 37. [Emphasis added] [ 80 ] This test has also been restated to mean that I must determine whether AM possessed the level of maturity, moral sophistication, and capacity for independent judgment of an adult: R v W(M) , 2017 ONCA 22 at para 98 ( W(M) ). As stated in CM 2018
at para 92: … In a sense, Parliament has said that if a young person is to be sentenced as an adult, it must be because the sentencing court issatisfied that, in the relevant respects, the culpability and degree of responsibility of the young person are equivalent in agerelated culpability and responsibility to the situation of an adult and that failure to impose an adult sentence would fail to hold theyoung person accountable in light of that situation.[Emphasis added] [81] More recently, the Court of Appeal in R v WM, 2021 SKCA 103 (WM) stated that under s 72(1)(a), I should assess: …whether the presumption of reduced moral blameworthiness common to all young people because of their youth has been rebutted so asto make an adult sentence appropriate.
Thus, s 72(1)(
a) involves a threshold-type inquiry focused specifically on what might be called thelevel of moral maturity of the young person: at para 32. [82] Other Canadian Courts of Appeal have espoused approaches focusing on a more expansive consideration of B(
D) factors.
Forexample, in R v Chol, 2018 BCCA 179 (Chol), the Court proposed an approach whereby it would take into account the following non-exhaustive list of considerations in analyzing the circumstances of the young person: their age, their background and antecedents;whether at the time of the offence they were – by choice – living like an adult; any previous offences; any indicia of dependence onothers or vulnerability to the influence of others; any Gladue factors, and; any cognitive limitations or emotional/mental healthissues (para 61). [83] The Chol Court went on to suggest that regard could also be had to whether the young person tookresponsibility/demonstrated remorse and whether the young person’s personal growth (or lack thereof) indicates anything about him orher at the time of the offence.
Crown and counsel for the young person agreed that the Chol factors are informative to my analysis. [84] While the list of factors to be considered are non-exhaustive and each of them non-determinative, a global assessment of themtogether may assist the Court in determining whether the young person possessed the trio of indicia of a youthful offender: heightenedvulnerability; less maturity; and reduced capacity for moral judgment. [85] A combination of the factors identified by Berger JA in R(JF), as well as those identified by Stromberg-Stein JA in Chol, willinform my analysis.
The Crown must demonstrate on this application that based upon a holistic examination of these factors, theculpability and degree of responsibility of the young person at the time of the index offence were equivalent to that of an adult. [86] The Crown submits, and I accept, that the comparator bar between being a youth and being an adult must not be set too high.The Crown cautions against setting a standard of an “ideal” adult, as this would elevate the onus placed upon the Crown.
It states that ayouthful offender is not to be measured against a fully functioning middle-aged adult without a criminal record. [87] I accept the Crown’s submissions on this point. As noted by Schultes J in R v ASD, 2019 BCSC 147 (aff’d 2020 BCCA 208;application for leave dismissed (SCC)) at paras 513-514: However, I do agree with the Crown's submission that the hypothetical "adult" to whom the maturity of the offender is to be comparedwhen applying s-s (
a) does not need to be a person of especially advanced maturity, judgment or sophistication. It is simply a person whohas matured to a point that the deficits in those qualities that the YCJA presumes all young persons have are no longer present.Comparing youthful offenders to a more ideal level of maturity would require the Crown to prove that they are more maturethan many of their adult counterparts, which I conclude cannot have been the intention of the legislation.
As is obvious from the fact that the presumption can be rebutted, the developmental process described in B.(D.) does not apply invariablyand uniformly to all youthful offenders. In addition to those offenders who progress more rapidly in a purely developmental sense, thereare also those who have demonstrated that they possess "the level of maturity, moral sophistication and capacity for independentjudgment of an adult" through the lifestyle and actions in which they engaged, in the commission of the offence itself and/or in theirlives more generally.
It also seems clear that the demonstration of those qualities for criminal purposes may indicate their presence justas clearly as prosocial purposes. [Emphasis added] Circumstances of the Offender [88] In evaluating whether AM had heightened vulnerability, immaturity, and a reduced capacity for moral judgment at the time ofthe offence, I turn first to his personal circumstances. This information was provided through the PSR, the CPR, Dr. Ennis’s Report andthrough testimony given during trial. i. Age [89] AM is currently 20 years old.
He was 11 days away from his 18th birthday when he committed the offence. [90] Counsel for AM submits that age is not a determinative factor in this analysis. I agree. However, this does not mean that anoffender’s age plays no role in the analysis. While no longer an express factor, age continues to play a role in the analysis of maturityand, by association, the moral blameworthiness of an offender. [91] That is not to say young offenders who are approaching their 18th birthday are to be treated differently or somehow affordedless protection under the YCJA.
The presumption afforded to young persons under the YCJA does not become increasingly diluted thecloser one gets to the age of majority.
[ 92 ] It is axiomatic to state that sentencing under the YCJA remains offender-centric and multi-factorial despite one’s relative age: AWB at para 56 . Indeed, one only need look to the matter of R v M(
C) reported at 2014 ABQB 701 ( T(M) ) and 2015 ABQB 134 to find support for the position that age relative to adulthood is but one factor, and not determinative of the analysis. [ 93 ] M(
C) involved twin brothers who were 17 years and 353 days old at the time they participated in the commission of a homicide. Despite being exactly the same age, this Court determined that one brother (TM), who had been found guilty of manslaughter, should be sentenced within the youth sentencing regime ( 2014 ABQB 701 ) and that the other brother (CM), who had been found guilty of murder, should be sentenced as an adult ( 2015 ABQB 134 ; aff’d 2018 ABCA 214 ).
In discussing the fact that the crime had been committed while the offenders were days away from turning 18, the Court noted in both decisions, that: …He was 12 days away from becoming an adult at the time of the offence. As noted in B.(D.) at paras 61-62 , age plays a role in the development of judgment and moral sophistication . Williams J. noted, in R. v. S. (C.) , 2008 NSPC 22 (N.S. Prov. Ct.), cited in R. v. H. (N.L.) , 2009 ABCA 168 (Alta.
C.A.), at para 86 , that "maturity ... should be considered from two perspectives, behaviourally as exhibited by her words, thoughts and actions and chronologically by looking at her actual state of development.
" ( CM 2015 at para 78). [Emphasis added] [ 94 ] In B(D) , the majority provided the common-sense observation at para 76 that: No one seriously disputes that there are wide variations in the maturity and sophistication of young persons over the age of 14 who commit serious offences… [ 95 ] Further, I accept and adopt the comments of our Court of Appeal that “[i]t is widely acknowledged that age plays a role in the development of judgment and moral sophistication”: R(JF) at para 25 . [ 96 ] While chronologically AM was nearly an adult at the time the offence occurred, the parties take different positions as to his maturity and sophistication within the s 72(1) analysis. ii.
Background and antecedents Family History and support [ 97 ] AM is the youngest of 10 children. All of the other children are his half-siblings. His biological father was an alcoholic and was violent toward AM’s mother and the family. AM recounted approximately 15 relocations between Montreal, Calgary, and Toronto, sometimes staying in women’s shelters. Calgary Child and Family Services confirmed prior investigations into allegations of domestic violence. At one point, AM’s parents separated, although different timelines for when this occurred have been provided.
AM has had minimal contact with his father and lived with his mother after the family separation. His parents were formally divorced in 2020. [ 98 ] AM’s upbringing was highly disruptive and lacked parental stability. This, in turn, influenced how he made friends at various new schools, how he performed academically, and how he established “attachment bonds” - being his relationship with other people and how he viewed himself and his self-worth. [ 99 ] In the Spring of 2018, AM went to live with his older half-brother, S, in Montreal for approximately six months.
AM indicated that his mother wanted him to do so as he had become mixed up in a peer group that was into crime. S testified on AM’s behalf. He indicated that AM behaved well under his guidance during this period and that he is confident that AM can do so again. [ 100 ] In 2020, AM rented a basement suite in a home located somewhere in the community of Skyview. He stated that he was able to afford to do so as he was receiving Covid-19 benefits, as well as employment insurance.
However, he often returned to his mother’s home for meals, laundry, and to spend time with her. [ 101 ] AM maintains a good relationship with his mother, whom he speaks to almost daily and who frequently visits him. AM appears to also have consistent contact with a half-brother who resides with his mother in Calgary. Both his mother and half-brother are committed to providing AM with ongoing support upon his release from custody, including assisting him with employment. Certain members of AM’s support team (namely Mr. Roberge and Mr. Khan) have also expressed a desire to continue providing support to AM.
S also indicated that he is willing to house and supervise AM upon his release. S also relayed that he believes he is a “father figure” to AM, and that a family plan has been put in place to remove AM from any negative peer environment in the future and to work with the justice system to instill effective rehabilitation. [ 102 ] At the time of the offence, AM had a girlfriend, but the relationship was not long term. It ended upon his arrest. AM stated that he hung out with his girlfriend in the basement suite as his Muslim culture made it inappropriate for him to bring a girl to the family home.
Education [ 103 ] AM attended several different schools, largely as a result of his mother’s various relocation attempts. He self-reported having a hard time adjusting to these changes and that this caused his bad behaviour. He did not perform well academically and had been historically suspended on more than one occasion for behavioural issues. His school record indicated numerous unexplained absences. He had completed credits up to around a grade 10 level at the time he was remanded. [ 104 ] Dr. Ennis provided insight into AM’s poor academic performance.
He indicated that because AM struggled socially and was marginalized, school eventually took on less importance for him, as he looked for an alternate place where he might fit in and feel good about himself. When AM became socially accepted by negative peers and found his ‘tribe’, he no longer cared about school. [ 105 ] While in custody, AM attended the Kennedale Institutional School Program and although he was initially discouraged, he
ultimately improved his attitude and work ethic and graduated with his high school diploma in June of 2022. He continues to upgrade certain courses and wishes to attend university and become a lawyer or work in real estate. However, I note that AM was caught cheating and plagiarising on schoolwork, and on several occasions, swore at staff. [ 106 ] Dr. Ennis opined that AM’s ability to perform better educationally since custody could be due to an increase in maturity, or due to the fact that school in a custodial setting is highly regimented, as well as tailored, or a combination of both.
Employment [ 107 ] Given his age, it is unsurprising that AM had a limited employment history prior to his detention. During the six-month period when AM lived with his brother in Montreal, he worked as a busboy in a restaurant. While in Calgary, he worked alongside his mother for a 25-week period in 2019 at the Saddledome, washing dishes, until the onset of the Covid pandemic. He was receiving CERB payments at the time of the offence. iii.
Whether at the time of the offence AM was – by choice – living like an adult [ 108 ] In my Trial Decision, I accepted that the Crown had demonstrated that AM was living a very mature, adult-life lifestyle while noting that against these observations, opposite indications of a less mature individual likewise existed.
As Defence counsel points out, in my Trial Decision I found the following behaviour to be reflective of a less mature individual: • AM still relied upon his mother for certain forms of care - he returned home for meals; she did his laundry and took care of administrative tasks, such as school registration; • AM expressed a lack of solemnity of occasion when testifying; • AM enjoyed typical “teenage” activities, such as playing basketball, hanging out with friends or spending time on social media; • AM appeared unwilling or unable to learn from past mistakes and persisted in continued action despite past negative consequences, including reversing his decision to change schools to avoid a negative peer group; and • AM appeared to lack any insight into how his crime affected others. [ 109 ] Not surprisingly, the Crown focused on AM’s more adult-like qualities, as found in my Trial Decision, including: • AM has lived separate from his mother when he moved to Montreal; • AM had his own basement suite; • AM had a girlfriend; • AM owned, and insured, a car; • AM has had previous employment, and later, applied for and received Covid benefits: • AM presented as calm and assured during his interaction with Sgt.
Harnett; • AM socialized with an older crowd; and • AM displayed confidence – both while testifying in court and when initially dealing with Sgt. Harnett at the outset of the traffic stop. [ 110 ] In addition to the evidence that was before me at trial, additional evidence was tendered during the s 64 Application which helped further inform my analysis. For example, during the trial, I heard evidence that AM continued to partially rely upon his mother to meet his needs. She prepared meals for him and did his laundry.
However, subsequent evidence also demonstrated that he often “stepped up” and assisted in providing for her. AM’s half-brother, K indicated that AM took care of his mother when she was ill. His half-sister, M, notes that when his mother would face a financial hurdle, AM would go out and find work to contribute financially to the family.
While these are the actions of a caring and dedicated son, they are also the actions of a mature and responsible individual. [ 111 ] I also note that all the support letters tendered in this proceeding indicate that AM was a mature, respectful, and thoughtful young person prior to the offence, tend to support the Crown’s position that AM was living a life with a maturity level comparable to that of a young adult. Despite this level of maturity, AM engaged in criminal behaviour. [ 112 ] In my view, AM was living more of an adult-type life than that of a youth.
He worked at various jobs, and when he could afford it, he bought his own vehicle and got his own basement suite. While AM’s counsel suggested that AM rented the suite in order to keep his girlfriend “hidden” and that this was a sign of immaturity, I disagree. AM indicated that in his culture, it would be disrespectful to bring a girlfriend to his mother’s home. AM, at times, spent the night with his girlfriend and his choice to obtain a private space where they could be together without insulting his mother’s values is a considerate one.
The fact that it was sparsely decorated and that he also played video games there is more superficial in comparison. [ 113 ] Moreover, despite having his mother meet certain needs, AM demonstrated independence during times of stress. He did not return to the family home following his flight from police. Rather, he went to his own suite and monitored the situation on social media.
When he discovered Sgt. Harnett had died, he did not involve his family; rather he called Mr. Abdulrahman to inform him about this occurrence. AM’s evidence was that he had decided to turn himself in at this point and that he urged Mr. Abdulrahman to do the same. AM reached this conclusion on his own. He then independently began searching for legal counsel. When he went to report to the police station later that day, he called a friend for a ride. [ 114 ] Of note, during his cross-examination at trial, AM agreed that he turned himself in because it was “the right thing to do”.
Leaving aside the fact that Canada-wide arrest warrants had been publicly issued for both AM and Mr. Abdulrahman featuring their photographs, this decision indicative of an adult-like capacity for moral judgment. Indeed, it is AM who calls an adult (Mr. Abdulrahman) and advises the adult of what he should do and not the other way around. [ 115 ] In my view, AM’s response to what would objectively have been an overwhelming and emotional experience – finding out one has taken a life and is wanted by law enforcement – is very telling. When his media watch reported Sgt.
Harnett’s death, AM acted swiftly and independently. He alone reached the conclusion that he must turn himself in. He then urged his passenger to do the same. He thereafter took it upon himself to engage in a process to find legal representation.
These actions – at the height of personal stress – reflect adult-like maturity and are not indicative of an individual who, due to youth, requires the protection afforded to persons due to decreased maturity, increased vulnerability and a reduced capacity for moral judgment. [ 116 ] By way of comparison, I note that in R v M(F) , 2008 BCCA 111 (referred to in my Trial Decision) there was evidence that minutes after the young offender’s participation in a deadly attack upon the victim, he began to cry and called his father, which demonstrated youthful immaturity: at paras 26 – 27. [ 117 ] I view these actions as particularly informative on the issue of AM’s maturity as they are direct evidence of his maturity and discernment at the time of the index offence, as they demonstrate his acumen just hours after the incident occurred.
In my view, they are reflective of the independent judgment seen in adults. [ 118 ] Other indicia include AM’s rejection of drugs and alcohol. Although AM had previously been mixed up in a negative peer group (resulting in his participation in the 2018 crime spree), he made a reasoned decision not to use or abuse substances. While he admitted to using marijuana historically for a brief period, he explained that he did not wish to expose himself to the negative consequences he saw manifest in other people – namely having witnessed a friend for whom drug use triggered schizophrenia.
In what I view as a further display of maturity, I note AM informed Dr. Ennis that his aversion to alcohol is informed in part by his experiences with his alcoholic and abusive father. This demonstrates some insight into AM’s appreciation of consequences and the effect of one’s actions upon others. iv. Previous offences [ 119 ] AM had a violent youth criminal record at the time of the index offence. The convictions stem from a “crime spree” that AM engaged in with co-offenders spanning from January 2018 – February 2018.
They are as follows: • Robbery (CC s 344(1)(b)) • Disguise with intent (CC s 351(2) – two counts) • Unlawful confinement (CC s 279(2) • Theft under $5,000 (CC s 334(b) – two counts); and • Assault (CC s 266) [ 120 ] On February 13, 2018, he was sentenced to six months deferred custody and supervision, and six months of probation. He was thereafter convicted of a Failure to Comply after being found in the company of a co-accused with whom he was prohibited contact: CC s 145(5.1). v.
Any indicia of dependence on others or vulnerability to the influence of others [ 121 ] In assessing vulnerability, I start by noting that AM does not present with any intellectual disabilities that might make him generally more vulnerable as a person. While AM did score below normal in his historical IQ testing with Dr. Day, I am satisfied that this was a result of either a language issue – or more likely an effort issue, as suggested by Dr. Ennis. Subsequent testing was normal. From a cognitive perspective, there was nothing which might make AM more dependent on others.
Although AM experienced security and attachment issues as a child, he was (and remains) supported by a loving family. As noted, AM was dependent upon his mother for certain things, but also assisted in providing for her as well. [ 122 ] One of the key issues, both from a rehabilitation/recidivism standpoint, as well as in relation to an assessment of the young person’s vulnerability, is that of AM’s peer group and the influence it had upon him. It is clear that prior to the 2018 crime spree, AM had joined a group of peers who were involved in the commission of property crimes.
AM testified that he had gotten “caught up” with some negative peers at this point and that he “followed them” and participated in the robberies which took place. Following his conviction, he went to live with his half-brother, S, on a temporary basis in Montreal. [ 123 ] The fact that when AM returned to Calgary, he enrolled in a different high school to stay away from those peers suggests that perhaps these peers were in high school as well. However, the evidence is unclear on this point. What is clear is that upon his return to Calgary, AM re-engaged with a pro-criminal group. I accept Dr.
Ennis’s opinion that AM is a “joiner” and that his need to belong to a group is very strong.
[ 124 ] At some point, AM befriended an individual named Moayed through a shared interest in basketball. Moayed was two years older than AM. AM then met Mr. Abdulrahman through Moayed. Mr. Abdulrahman was 19 years old at the time of the offence. AM indicated that Moayed was the same age as Mr. Abdulrahman. When asked who his closest friends were during trial, AM indicated that they were Moayed and Mr. Abdulrahman. [ 125 ] While it is clear that AM was friends with slightly older individuals, there was nothing to indicate that the fact that his friends were older reflected a heightened vulnerability on AM’s part.
Unlike previous occasions were AM testified to having “followed” his peer group into the 2018 crime spree, there was no evidence of AM being influenced by his peers at or around the date of the index offence. He did not make any mention of being negatively pressured by these individuals or of otherwise feeling that he needed to partake in any particular course of action. It appears that he enjoyed playing sports and otherwise “hanging out” with Moayed and Mr. Abdulrahman. They were friends because they had common interests.
I accept the Crown’s submission that AM easily clicked with an older crowd and that his ability to operate on this social plane is demonstrative of a more mature individual. [ 126 ] Moreover, and contrary to Dr. Ennis’s opinion, there is nothing to indicate that AM even knew about Mr. Abdulrahman’s criminal history or the warrant for his arrest. Dr. Ennis testified that he did not believe AM on this point. However, in the Trial Decision, I accepted this evidence as true. I note also that AM was, literally, in the driver’s seat at the relevant time.
This suggests a position amongst peers of equal status travelling together. While I accept Dr. Ennis’s evidence that AM tends to be a follower or a “team joiner” as opposed to a leader, he, as driver, was leading the team (at least in one sense) on the night in question. [ 127 ] I take Dr. Ennis’s point that when he speaks of “criminality” he is talking about peers/individuals who have been in conflict with the law, not necessarily persons who are pushing AM to engage in certain behaviour.
This distinction becomes more relevant in determining the type of sentence in relation to rehabilitation/recidivism and is less informative on the issue of vulnerability. I agree with the Crown that the age gap between AM and his “adult” friends was slight, and that they interacted as peers. I reject any suggestion that AM was being used as a tool of older criminals. [ 128 ] In so finding, I acknowledge AM’s statement in his PSR that at the time of the offence, he was “significantly influenced by older friends and the need to be accepted”. While I do accept Dr.
Ennis’s opinion that AM gloms on to available peer groups in an attempt to define his identity, I am concerned that this statement may be simply self-serving and a part of AM’s attempt to portray himself as a formerly immature and impulsive youth, but now a sage and responsible adult. It is, in my view, an attempt at manipulation. Of note, AM makes no real mention of any influence/impressionability during the relevant timeframe. In fact, he denied any discussion (let alone any pressure to flee by his peers) even took place within the vehicle prior to flight.
I found that his testimony regarding any lack of plan did not accord with other evidence. [ 129 ] While AM presents as high needs and with attachment issues which make him likely to “glom” onto others, there is no evidence that he was vulnerable to the influence of his slightly older peer group. vi. Cognitive limitations or emotional/mental health issues [ 130 ] AM has not recently been diagnosed with any learning or behavioral/developmental disorder. He self-described an ADHD diagnosis in grade two.
He denies any substance abuse and states that he briefly used marijuana over an approximate three-month period in 2018. [ 131 ] Following his string of criminal activity in the winter of 2018, AM underwent a Psychological and Risk Assessment Report authored by Mr. Ryan Day dated February 6, 2019. The significant findings of that assessment are contained in the Report of Dr. Ennis. The testing noted that AM may have scored lower than was indicated on the IQ test due to the fact that English is not his first language. Dr.
Day could not confirm any ADHD diagnosis, but did note that AM demonstrated a level of impulsivity consistent with many youths who suffer from ADHD. Dr. Ennis stated that AM received medication for ADHD as a child, but that no benefit from this medication was reported. Dr. Ennis further noted that AM’s current presentation for ADHD was “ambiguous” and that he did not observe much direct indication of ADHD presently. He opined that this was something that AM may have grown out of/improved, or that it could have been a manifestation of his childhood circumstances. Dr.
Ennis testified that “cognitive function is not an issue” in evaluating AM, and that to the extent any ADHD might still be present, it is not relevant. [ 132 ] Dr. Day opined that AM’s recidivism risk would most likely be tied to his continued interaction with a negative peer group. Dr. Day assessed AM at a “moderate” risk for recidivism in 2018 and opined that any future violence would likely be impulsive and reactionary to a perceived threat or insult. Dr. Day also indicated that anti-social personality traits were present. However, as Dr.
Ennis’ subsequent assessment provides, there are no relevant cognitive issues that bear on his current presentation. vii. Whether the young person’s personal growth (or lack thereof) indicates anything about him or her at the time of the offence [ 133 ] In both the PSR and the Ennis Report, AM describes himself as having experienced much personal growth since being in custody, especially over the prior year. In the Ennis Report, AM reported that “he is a very different person in 2023 than he was on December 31, 2020”.
He ascribes much of his recent growth to the “wake up call” he received from spending time in custody. [ 134 ] AM is not alone in making these observations. As noted in the PSR, correctional staff, collateral contacts and family have noted recent personal growth and increased maturity. The inference that the Court is invited to draw is that AM has grown into this maturity, which was less developed at the time of the offence. [ 135 ] There is little doubt AM has matured, at least to some extent, since being remanded into custody.
He has spent over two years back and forth between the Calgary and the Edmonton Young Offender Centres. He has participated in several programs available at these Centres. He has gone on to obtain his high school degree and has expressed a desire to complete post-secondary education. I am encouraged by some of what I see in AM’s sentencing and custodial reports. The Court also heard about AM’s growth from his half- brother, S, who lives in Montreal.
[ 136 ] I accept that AM has undergone some personal growth, and that this growth has been commented on by support personnel working with the offender. For example, Ms. Fix stated that AM has demonstrated a mature sense of introspection and personal growth. Ms. Reid has reported an increase in AM’s ability to take accountability for his actions. Ms. Donlevy (Department Head of Institutional Schools) indicated that AM’s work ethic and attitude improved, resulting in AM obtaining his high school diploma. EYOC keyworker, Mr.
Tiemstra indicated that AM uses reasoning in explaining his behaviour to staff and will accept consequences received without further incident. [ 137 ] An evaluation of maturity at the time of the offence is – of course – essential in determining a s 64 application. While accepting that some growth has occurred since the offence, my concern when looking at the whole of the evidence is that AM was engaged in some form of “impression management” while reporting his transformation into a more mature and pro-social individual post-offence.
This concern stems directly from my personal observations of AM during trial, wherein he was very much engaged in the same sort of impression management, as well as from Dr. Ennis’s rejection of AM’s professed transformation. I note Dr. Ennis’s opinion that he could not say that AM’s behaviour is as improved as the CPR seems to suggest. [ 138 ] While independent third parties support AM’s assertion of recent growth, I note that much of AM’s professed recent maturing is self-reported.
As noted at p 8 of his PSR: [AM] reflected he has experienced much personal growth over the past two years; that the youth he was at the time of the offence simply is not who he sees himself to currently be. He suggested two years ago he was significantly influenced by older friends and the need to be accepted and to fit in. He acknowledged at the time being impulsive, immature, angry, and a poor listener…[AM] described himself as now being calmer, more respectful and presenting with leadership qualities. [ 139 ] In giving his testimony, Dr.
Ennis confirmed the frailties of accepting subjective reporting from an individual who has a vested interest in the result. Dr. Ennis observed that AM has a gratuitously high opinion of himself and an inflated ego. He believed that certain areas of AM’s reporting concerning his personal growth were overstated and unreliable. Dr. Ennis expressed concerns over what he viewed as continuing manipulative behaviour. [ 140 ] I therefore have several reservations about relying on subjective assessments based on AM’s self-reporting. [ 141 ] One concern arises in relation to AM’s self-described “wake up call”.
While I have no doubt that spending significant time in youth custody demonstrates that one’s actions do carry consequences, I have difficulty accepting that AM’s reported change in attitude regarding respect for authority and pro-social disposition is anything but ephemeral.
This is particularly so since it has not led to his realization that ongoing programming and monitoring is required for him to be successful long-term. [ 142 ] Moreover, I note that the Trial Decision was rendered on November 14, 2022, and that since December 2022, AM has remained at a level two or three rating (noting he was able to maintain a level four somewhat consistently in the time prior to trial) as a result of his ongoing non-compliance with the telephone system and his “lack of initiative”.
Again, this factor is difficult to reconcile with AM’s portrayal of himself as having undergone a metamorphosis during his youth custody experience. I note further Dr. Ennis’s opinion that he “does not put any faith” in “wake-up calls”, per se. [ 143 ] In attempting to reconcile this apparent dichotomy in AM’s presentation, I echo Dr. Ennis’s comments and concerns. I would add to his list of manipulative behaviour the October 2022 infraction where AM was observed breaking a rule in class and when confronted, requested that the teacher keep it a secret. During cross-examination, Dr.
Ennis agreed that compliance with youth custody centre rules is important in the risk assessment. He stated that breaches of these rules are not just technical; they are indications as to whether AM is capable of living a law-abiding lifestyle. Dr. Ennis stated that these breaches are indicators that a criminal lifestyle mindset still exists.
I also note that AM’s misdemeanors go beyond his misuse of the phone privileges, and include cheating, plagiarism, and swearing at staff and teachers – all indicative of an intractable pro-criminal mindset. [ 144 ] This behaviour also undermines AM’s attempt to portray himself as more mature now and by comparison, necessarily less mature at the time of the index offence. [ 145 ] Another example of AM’s actions not necessarily aligning with his self-reporting is noted in relation to his claim that he is no longer interested in maintaining relationships with a negative peer group.
As noted in his PSR, AM recognized the harm associated with a negative peer group and stated he has “cut ties with past friends”. AM must have made this statement to the writer of the PSR at some point during his interview, which occurred between December 8 – 20, 2022. Yet on December 13, 2022, precisely within the interview period, AM was reprimanded for using a telephone number that had been approved within the institution as a legal counsel listing to contact a former peer who had just been readmitted to EYOC that day. As Dr.
Ennis described during his testimony, this type of behaviour is consistent with underlying pro-criminal behavior. [ 146 ] Defence counsel produced a telephone message for AM that seems to indicate that on November 14, 2022, AM received a call ostensibly from his lawyer but with the return phone number of the peer he called in December. Counsel invites me to conclude that there was a mix-up of some sort and that AM mistakenly listed this number as belonging to his lawyer.
Although the rules of evidence are relaxed in sentencing hearings, I cannot reach any conclusions on this matter as it would require more evidence and a credibility assessment, which was not made available in this hearing. [ 147 ] Even though I acknowledge that the telephone message raises some doubt as to whe
[…]
Loading document…