McDermott (Re), 2023 ABKB 33
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: McDermott (Re), 2023 ABKB 33 Date: 20230118 Docket: B103 555781, B103 555764 Registry: Edmonton Docket: B103 555781 In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Marcia Susan McDermott (Ordinary Administration) AND Docket: B103 555764 In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Robert Allan John McDermott (Ordinary Administration) Between: Moses Advisory Group Inc Applicant - and - The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Respondent _______________________________________________________ Endorsement of W.S. Schlosser , Registrar in Bankruptcy _______________________________________________________
[ 1 ] This began as a contested taxation after significant delay on the part of the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) to provide their comment letter. [ 2 ] I am satisfied from the materials on this file, including the detailed submissions from both sides, that a proposal would have been viable and that this estate should be taxed as such. The trustee owes a primary duty to the creditors to realize as much as possible from the estate. The bankrupts’ desire for a speedy exit at the lowest cost is not an overriding consideration. Refusal to choose a proposal can be a reason for refusing a discharge ( BIA s 173(1)(n)) [ 3 ] Both estates started as
summary administration estates on October 31, 2011. They were later converted to ordinary administration. Ms. McDermott received her absolute discharge October 6, 2017. Mr. McDermott was discharged November 3, 2016. [ 4 ] On the Final Statement of Receipts and Disbursements, total receipts in Mr. McDermott’s estate were $30,013.47, as against claimed disbursements of $27,494.55; of which $24,935.50 were trustee’s fees. Total proved unsecured claims were $208,515.83. [ 5 ] Total receipts in Mrs.
McDermott's estate were $37,806.47, as against disbursements totaling $29,284.82; of which $26,649.00 are claimed trustee’s fees. Total unsecured proved claims in Ms. McDermott's estate were $75,350.39. [ 6 ] To date, there have been interim draws of $12,399.00 plus GST from Ms. McDermott's estate and $10,000 plus GST from Mr. McDermott's estate. [ 7 ] My view is that a much higher return would have been achieved in a proposal than the $67,819.94 that was achieved, largely through surplus payments.
Even a proposal payable over 60 months at the surplus rate would have generated a greater return to creditors, because the costs of administration are agreed in a proposal and are typically much lower; usually about 20% of recovery plus expenses. In this case, the administration of the estates took about the same time as a usual Division I proposal, which is typically 60 months. [ 8 ] In the circumstances, however, I am not going to reduce the fees below the interim draws to 20% of the actual recovery.
In the Statement of Disbursements, a total of $260.00 is to be removed from both accounts, consisting of $25.00 for fax charges, $35.00 for internet and e-mail and a $200.00 banking charge. The difference may be recovered as fees. [ 9 ] The trustee may also charge interest to the estate at the Judgment Interest Act rate on the allowed fee amount from the respective dates of discharge to today's date. The application for costs against the OSB is denied. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 18th day of January, 2023. W.S. Schlosser Registrar in Bankruptcy Appearances: James R.
Moses for the Trustee Scott Guertin for the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy
Loading document…