Ford v Jivraj, 2023 ABKB 331
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Ford v Jivraj, 2023 ABKB 331 Date: 20230601 Docket: 1901 16301 Registry: Calgary Between: Caylan Ford Plaintiff - and - Karim A. Jivraj Defendant _______________________________________________________ Sentencing Decision of the Honourable Justice Robert A. Graesser _______________________________________________________ Introduction [ 1 ] On February 21, 2023, I found Karim Jivraj guilty of contempt for breaching K Nixon J’s order of July 29, 2020 (the “Nixon Order”).
My decision on that and other issues is Ford v Jivraj , 2023 ABKB 92 . [ 2 ] I asked the parties for submissions on sentencing, and received a lengthy submission from Mr. Harrison, counsel for Caylan Ford, dated March 9, 2023. Mr. Jivraj responded by way of a written submission dated April 11. Mr. Harrison replied to Mr. Jivraj’s submissions on April 14.
[3] I am now ready to give my decision on sanctions against Mr. Jivraj. Background [4] Mr. Jivraj’s offence was in using a friend’s computer or cell phone to send a letter to Tyler Dawson of the National Post onOctober 8, 2020 (the “Dawson Letter”) containing derogatory things about Ms. Ford. K Nixon J’s order dated July 29, 2020 directed thatMr. Jivraj not publish any comments about Ms. Ford to anyone by any method, directly or indirectly. [5] It is not necessary for me to review the facts or circumstances of the offence in this decision, other than to say that when Mr.Jivraj sent the letter to Mr.
Dawson, he was well aware of Justice Nixon’s order, and he used his former friend Eric Bailey and Mr.Bailey’s email account to try to circumvent the Nixon Order or to avoid the consequences of any breach. [6] Mr. Jivraj has no previous criminal record to the extent that is relevant on a civil contempt matter, and at the time of theoffence had no record for civil contempt. Submissions [7] Mr. Harrison submits that Mr.
Jivraj should be fined $30,000 and in default of payment, imprisonment for two months. [8] He cites: • Law Society of Alberta v Beaver, 2021 ABCA 163; • Alberta Health Services v Pawlowski, 2021 ABQB 813; • 336239 Alberta Ltd (Dave’s Diesel Repair) v Mella, 2016 ABQB 174; • Makis v Alberta Health Services, 2020 ABCA 168; • Kossert v Busswood, 2018 BCSC 425; • Zelazo v Masson, (ABKB); • Coleman v Bihis, (1997), (ABKB); • Marshall v Reid, 2018 ONSC 648; and • Wakeel v Moustafa, 2016 ABQB 475. [9] Mr.
Harrison notes that sanctions for contempt of court have two purposes: encourage compliance with court orders and topunish the contemptor (Law Society v Beaver at para 78). [10] As for aggravating and mitigating factors, Mr. Harrison submits that it is aggravating that the act of contempt, sending theletter to Mr. Dawson, was damaging to Ms. Ford and was defamatory of her. He also references a second contempt committed by Mr.Jivraj in the defamation action Ms. Ford is pursuing against Mr. Jivraj, Press Progress and others. [11] In that action, Mr.
Jivraj was held in contempt by Justice Harris on August 19, 2022 relating to questioning issues. [12] Mr. Harrison points out that Mr. Jivraj has a law degree and in the early part of his time living in Calgary, he was articling at aCalgary law firm. As someone with legal training and being part of the legal profession, at least for a time, Mr. Harrison says this is anaggravating factor and should be taken account of in sentencing Mr. Jivraj. [13] Mr. Harrison also references collection proceedings Ms. Ford has taken against Mr. Jivraj to enforce various cost awards inher favour in the litigation.
In those proceedings, Mr. Jivraj provided a Financial Statement of Debtor dated December 2, 2021, in whichhe disclosed income of $85,600. Mr. Harrison says that evidences an ability to pay a significant fine. [14] Mr. Harrison argues that there are no mitigating features in Mr. Jivraj’s failure as there has been no apology and noacceptance of responsibility by him. [15] He urges the Court to direct that any fine imposed against Mr. Jivraj be made available to his creditors, citing Kossert vBusswood. He also urges the Court to impose a term of imprisonment if the fine is not paid. [16] Mr.
Jivraj argues that a fine of $750 - $1500 is appropriate, with 90 days within which to pay the fine. He points to his poorfinancial position and suggests that any greater fine would be unduly punitive. He attributes his poor financial position to commentsabout him on Ms. Ford’s website and various media reports about his campaign to destroy Ms. Ford’s political career. Mr. Jivraj says hehas recently lost his employment and has received a notice of eviction from his rental accommodation.
He says that he has beenhumiliated by this process and has attached several news reports commenting on my decision and my findings in relation to his conduct.The news reports, and my decision, are highly unfavourable of Mr. Jivraj. Mr. Jivraj says he is now virtually unemployable and hishopes of becoming a lawyer have probably been frustrated. [17] Mr. Jivraj’s submission includes an unreserved apology to the Court for his actions, and to Ms. Ford for any “emotional painsuffering, or anxiety” arising from his breach of the Nixon Order.
[18] In his lengthy submissions, Mr.
Jivraj cites: • R v Gardiner, (SCC), [1982] 2 SCR 368; • Carey v Laiken, 2015 SCC 17; • R v M(CA) (SCC), [1996] 1 SCR 500; • R v Bissonette, 2022 SCC 23; • Ouellet v BM, 2010 ABCA 240; • Builders Energy Services Ltd v Paddock, 2008 ABQB 617 and 2009 ABCA 153; • Ruby v Canada (Solicitor General), 2002 SCC 75; • JM v EM, 2022 ABCA 49; • Schitthelm v Keleman, 2013 ABQB 42; • Braun (Trustee of) v Braun, 2006 ABCA 23; • R v Pearson, (SCC), [1992] 3 SCR 665; • Alberta Health Services v Pawlowski, 2022 ABCA 254; • R v National Post, 2010 SCC 16; • FIC Real Estate Ltd v Lennie, 2014 ABQB 105; • Alston v Foothills No 31 (District of), 2022 ABCA 408; • Law Society of Alberta v Beaver, 2021 ABCA 163; • Zelazo v Masson, (ABKB); • Coleman v Bihis, (ABKB); • Chiang (Re), 2009 ONCA 3; • Business Development Bank of Canada v Cavalon Inc, 2017 ONCA 663; • Marshall v Reid, 2018 ONSC 648; • JLZ v CMZ, 2021 ABCA 200; • Mella v 336239 Alberta Ltd (Dave’s Diesel Repair), 2016 ABCA 226; • Alberta Dental Assn v Unrau, 2001 ABQB 315; • Pro Swing Inc v Elta Golf Inc, 2006 SCC 52; • R v Wust, 2000 SCC 18; • R v Bunn, 2000 SCC 9; • R v Friesen, 2022 ABCA 147; • Globe and Mail v Canada (Attorney General), 2010 SCC 41; • Hill v Church of Scientology of Toronto, (SCC), [1995] 2 SCR 1130; • Ontario (Attorney General) v Paul Magder Furs Ltd, (ONCA); • R v Nur, 2015 SCC 15; • Kossert v Busswood, 2018 BCSC 425; • Makis v Alberta Health Services, 2020 ABCA 168; • Alberta Health Services v Scott, 2021 ABQB 812; and • B(RM) v B(DT), 2019 ABQB 826. [19] Mr.
Jivraj argues that Justice Harris’s finding of contempt in a related action should not be considered by me. Firstly, heargues that the contempt order may have been improperly obtained and in any event he had not been given an opportunity to purge his
contempt before being found guilty. He also notes that the contempt finding was after the circumstances leading to my finding of guilt. [ 20 ] Mr. Jivraj notes that the contents of the letter sent to Mr. Dawson should not be considered as defamatory or aggravating on this sentencing. He references my decision where I expressly made no comments on whether Ms. Ford had been defamed. That is before the Court of King’s Bench in a separate action. He also notes that the letter to Mr.
Dawson was not made public. [ 21 ] He says his apology, which he says is sincere, should be considered as a mitigating factor. [ 22 ] Mr. Jivraj argues against any period of incarceration and says that would be inappropriate having regard to his circumstances and the nature of the contempt.
He argues against a sentence that would be harsh and unfit and points to the “jump” principle in sentencing. [ 23 ] In particular, he emphasizes the public humiliation that has been visited on him by his actions and cites authorities including R v Bunn where the Lamer CJ agreed with the Ontario Court of Appeal finding that that the “ruin and humiliation” Mr. Bunn had brought upon himself and his family should be considered sufficient denunciation and deterrence for sentencing purposes. [ 24 ] In Mr. Harrison’s April 14 reply to Mr.
Jivraj’s submissions, he takes issue with the quality and sincerity of the apology Mr. Jivraj offered to the Court and to Ms. Ford. He argues that no weight should be given to it. [ 25 ] Mr. Harrison notes that Mr. Jivraj has filed a notice of appeal from my decision, and the apology offered in these proceedings is very much at odds with the contents of the notice of appeal. [ 26 ] He also points out that Mr. Jivraj’s denial at trial that he neither authored nor sent the Dawson Letter was rejected by me. Mr. Jivraj had sworn affidavits before trial denying involvement with that letter. [ 27 ] Mr.
Harrison describes Mr. Jivraj as a “serial offender” and says that the only way to stop him from continuing to harm Ms. Ford is to “impose a punishment severe enough to harm him”. Analysis [ 28 ] The consequences for a finding of civil contempt are set out in Rule 10.53: 10.53
(1) Every person declared to be in civil contempt of Court is liable to any one or more of the following penalties or sanctions in the discretion of a judge: (
a) imprisonment until the person has purged the person’s contempt; (
b) imprisonment for not more than 2 years; (
c) a fine and, in default of paying the fine, imprisonment for not more than 6 months; (
d) if the person is a party to an action, application or proceeding, an order that (
i) or part of a commencement document, affidavit or pleading be struck out, (ii) an action or an application be stayed, (iii) a claim, action, defence, application or proceeding be dismissed, or judgment be entered or an order be made, or (iv) a record or evidence be prohibited from being used or entered in an application, proceeding or at trial.
(2) The Court may also make a costs award against a person declared to be in civil contempt of Court.
(3) If a person declared to be in civil contempt of Court purges the person’s contempt, the Court may waive or suspend any penalty or sanction.
(4) The judge who imposed a penalty or sanction for civil contempt may, on notice to the person concerned, increase, vary or remit the penalty or sanction. [ 29 ] The Court obviously has a very wide discretion in determining what is a fit and proper consequence for a contemptor.
There are very few circumstances where a person found guilty of civil contempt has been imprisoned in the first instance, although breaches of restraining orders and emergency protection orders frequently involve the contemptor being held in custody after being arrested for breach of the order and kept in custody until they have been brought to Court to answer for the breach.
In those cases, the focus is usually on the safety of the party in whose favour the order was granted, and not the disregard for the administration of justice. [ 30 ] The fact that consequences for such breaches often result in a de facto finding of time served and a warning that dire consequences will befall the contemptor the next time should not be seen as any trivialization of any breach of any court order. [ 31 ] Here, I do not intend to impose a period of imprisonment on Mr. Jivraj at this time. [ 32 ] It is not necessary for me to spend much time with the case law cited to me.
Recent Alberta Court of Appeal decisions such as Law Society of Alberta v Beaver , Alberta Health Services v Pawlowski , and Alston v MD of Foothills are the most relevant cases, as well as being some of the most current authorities.
[ 33 ] In Law Society v Beaver , the contemptor was a disbarred lawyer. His contempt was breaching an injunction against him providing legal services at a time when he had been suspended from practice pending an investigation into a shortage in his trust account. Following a finding of contempt, Mr. Beaver was sentenced to a one-year period of imprisonment. He had been previously found guilty of breaching the same injunction. [ 34 ] The Court of Appeal recognized the purposes of sentencing for civil contempt as being to ensure compliance with court orders and to punish the contemptor.
It added at para 78 that the sentencing court needs to take into account the proportionality of the sentence to the wrongdoing, the prevalence of aggravating and mitigating circumstances, deterrence, the reasonableness of a fine and the appropriateness of incarceration. [ 35 ] They also added the “jump principle” to this list at para 79. [ 36 ] The Court of Appeal noted that the first time Mr. Beaver had been found guilty of contempt for breaching the injunction he had been ordered to pay costs and that could be considered as punishment as well as a fine. [ 37 ] In reviewing these factors and Mr.
Beaver’s circumstances, the Court reduced the sentence to 3 months’ incarceration. He was allowed to serve that sentence intermittently. No fine was imposed. Mr. Beaver was also directed to pay the Law Society’s solicitor and client costs in relation to the court proceedings. [ 38 ] Another recent Court of Appeal decision is Alberta Health Services v Pawlowski . There, the Court of Appeal dealt with appeals from three persons who had been sanctioned for contempt of an injunction to prevent illegal public gatherings in contravention of public health orders aimed at protecting Albertans from COVID-19.
The Pawlowskis had conducted church services in violation of various orders obtained by Alberta Health Services. Mr. Scott had held a protest meeting targeting Alberta Health’s COVID rules at his café that was attended by 300-400 people. [ 39 ] Artur Pawlowski had been sentenced to 3 days in prison, fined $20,000 and placed on probation for 18 months. Dawid Pawlowski was sentenced to 3 days in prison, fined $10,000, and placed on probation for 12 months. They were jointly ordered to pay costs of nearly $16,000. [ 40 ] Mr.
Scott was sentenced to 3 days in prison, which was satisfied by the time he had served immediately following his arrest. He was put on probation for 18 months and was ordered to pay costs of nearly $11,000. [ 41 ] The Court of Appeal noted at para 39 that a period of incarceration was appropriate for Mr. Scott, as his conduct was a deliberate disregard for the authority of the Court, and it was a blatant contempt of court process. [ 42 ] They upheld the incarceration provision but reduced the fine to $10,000. Mr. Scott’s probation period was reduced to 8 months.
He was allowed to pay the fine at a rate of $500 per month. The cost award, based on 2.5 times column one, was upheld. [ 43 ] The Pawlowskis were successful in their appeal from the contempt finding, so the sanctions against them were set aside. [ 44 ] Mr. Jivraj cites Alston v Municipal District of Foothills as an example of how the Court treated a party whose contempt was a deliberate breach of a court order. There, Ms.
Alston breached an order prohibiting her from directly or indirectly contacting the managing partner of the law firm acting for Foothills in litigation over contaminated ground water, as well as any other member or employee of that firm. [ 45 ] Ms. Alston had sent an email to Foothills Council accusing the law firm of lying to their clients, Foothills Council, and copied it to the managing partner and two other lawyers at the firm. She also wrote directly to the firm alleging that they were involved in criminal negligence and fraud.
The sentence of a fine of $1000 and full indemnity solicitor and client costs was upheld by the Court of Appeal. [ 46 ] Here, it is significant that Mr. Jivraj deliberately set out to circumvent the potential consequences of breaching the Nixon Order by using Mr. Bailey’s name and cell phone or computer to send the letter to Mr. Dawson. It followed a pattern of sending or posting anonymous or “pseudo anonymous” communications critical of Ms. Ford. [ 47 ] The Dawson Letter was clearly sent to cause harm to Ms.
Ford, her reputation and her wellbeing. [ 48 ] In granting the injunction, Nixon J had concluded that the only way of stopping Mr. Jivraj from his campaign of discrediting Ms. Ford was to grant an injunction against him. [ 49 ] It is not my role to determine if Mr. Jivraj defamed Ms. Ford during his campaign. That will be determined in the defamation action in which Mr. Jivraj has been noted in default. It is proceeding against others and the judge trying that case will have the benefit of all of the available evidence. As such, I do not consider defamation or falsehoods to be germane to my task here.
It is germane, however, that Mr. Jivraj’s campaign against Ms. Ford was motivated by any sense of duty to correct her political record. I found that Mr. Jivraj’s campaign was a deliberate attempt to cause harm to a former friend based largely on jealously of her successful political career and his failures. His malice towards Ms. Ford is the reason the injunction was continued by me. [ 50 ] It is significant that Mr. Jivraj is a highly educated individual whose degrees include a law degree.
He cannot credibly claim that he did not understand the Nixon Order or the consequences of committing a civil contempt of Court. That is not aggravating, but removes potential mitigating circumstances. [ 51 ] Mr. Jivraj has never taken responsibility for his actions, although he has apologized to Ms. Ford for the consequences to her of the letter to Mr. Dawson. [ 52 ] This apology is mitigating, but “last minute” apologies or expressions of remorse after a full trial and conviction and in the
face of an immediate sentencing are far less mitigating than early ones. I do not suggest that taking a matter to trial is aggravating as that is a person’s right, but early apologies are quite mitigating, and it is also mitigating that a victim does not have to testify at trial and be cross-examined. [ 53 ] I do find that the circumstances are somewhat similar to those in Ahlston v Foothills in that they both involve deliberate and inexcusable breaches of no contact orders. [ 54 ] I agree with Mr.
Jivraj’s submissions that his case is very different from Law Society v Beaver , where a suspended and then disbarred lawyer who had misappropriated trust funds flagrantly continued to practice law. It is also different from Alberta Health Services v Pawlowski , where the contemptors very publicly flouted court orders aimed at protecting the public from the COVID-19 epidemic. [ 55 ] I am also mindful that Mr. Jivraj is in poor financial circumstances, but I think his claim that these proceedings have resulted in him being unemployable are exaggerated.
If anything has made him unemployable, it is his exposure as a jealous ex-friend bent on destroying Ms. Ford’s reputation and using underhanded means to do so. I am doubtful that his circumstances will remain as dire as he presently claims, although he has been noted in default in Ms. Ford’s defamation action and potentially faces a damage award against him if his publications concerning Ms. Ford are found defamatory.
He apparently has outstanding cost awards against him and an unsatisfied civil judgment. [ 56 ] This said, the punishment must fit the crime and the personal circumstances of someone facing a fine are relevant to amount of the fine and any time given in which to pay the fine. The Alberta Court of Appeal has reiterated that one of the purposes of imposing consequences on a contemptor is to punish them, and a small fine on a wealthy contemptor is hardly punishment (see in particular Cote JA’s comments at para 20 in Zelazo v Masson ).
A large fine on someone who is indigent is undoubtedly more punitive on that person than a significantly larger fine on a wealthy offender. [ 57 ] I concluded that a permanent injunction is necessary to protect Ms. Ford from Mr. Jivraj. If unrestrained, I have little doubt that Mr. Jivraj will use any possible opportunity to harass and vilify Ms. Ford.
A token consequence for a first offence or a slap on the wrist could well be viewed as a licence fee and that would not satisfy the other main objective of consequences for contempt: ensuring compliance with court orders. [ 58 ] It would be inappropriate to send Mr. Jivraj to jail for a first offence. The Dawson Letter ultimately caused no serious harm to Ms. Ford, as Mr. Dawson did not use it in any way, at least in any way that I was made aware of. There is no evidence that anyone saw the letter other than Mr. Jivraj, Mr. Bailey, Mr. Dawson, and then Ms. Ford and her counsel when Mr.
Bailey made them aware of it some months after it had been sent. [ 59 ] However, it was sent with the clear intent to do harm to Ms. Ford. It was also a deliberate and serious breach of the Nixon Order. Mr. Jivraj must be made to understand that Court orders are to be obeyed. Disagreements with them are to be dealt with by appealing them, rather than using subterfuge to try to get around them. [ 60 ] Mr. Harrison’s reply submissions express the frustration he and Ms. Ford have experienced dealing with Mr. Jivraj in this and the defamation litigation. However, I must be careful to sanction Mr.
Jivraj for the civil contempt I found him guilty of, and not for other behavior that might be worthy of sanction in other circumstances. [ 61 ] Here, a fine of $10,000 is appropriate. If Mr. Jivraj is being honest about his financial situation, a fine in that magnitude will drive home the seriousness of his contempt. Mr. Jivraj himself referenced the “jump principle” and knows that any subsequent breach of any court order will necessarily be punished more seriously than has been the case here and by Justice Harris. [ 62 ] I will give Mr. Jivraj one year in which to pay the fine.
If the fine has not been paid within that time, I reserve the right to vary, increase, or remit the sanction, which may include a period of incarceration in default of payment, in accordance with Rule 10.53(4). If Mr. Jivraj’s circumstances are such that he has been unable to satisfy the fine in that period, he should make an application for an extension or other relief before the time has expired. [ 63 ] The fine is payable to the Clerk of the Court.
Kossett v Busswood , a decision from the British Columbia Supreme Court, has no application in Alberta, as the Court of Appeal made it clear in Alberta Health Services v Makis that fines for civil contempt are to be paid to the Court, not to the contemptor’s creditors: [66] The chambers judge found that Dr. Makis was in contempt of court for having failed to attend questioning. In accordance with R. 10.53(1)(c), he imposed a penalty of $1,000: reasons at para. 94. The formal order provided that the penalty was to be paid to Alberta Health Services, but penalties under R. 10.49(1) or R. 10.53(1)(
c) are to be paid to the Government of Alberta: Susin v Susin , 2014 ONCA 733 at para. 39 , 379 DLR (4th) 308. Sanctions for contempt of court are directed at the public interest in the due administration of justice, not any private interest.
Sanctions for contempt are as much to coerce compliance as they are to punish… [ 64 ] I note that at para 22 of 336239 Alberta Ltd v Mella , Schutz JA referenced various Alberta Queen’s Bench decisions where fines for civil contempt had been directed to others instead of the Clerk of the Court, but those Queen’s Bench decisions were made before there was Alberta Court of Appeal authority to the contrary. [ 65 ] It is interesting to note that Mr. Mella did not comply with Justice Shelley’s order and he was ultimately sentenced to 12 months imprisonment for his civil contempt.
That sentence was not appealed and was ultimately served (see R v Mella , 2022 ABQB 68 at para 29 ). The jump principle was clearly applied in that case. [ 66 ] I am also mindful that costs have not yet been spoken to, and I expect that Ms. Ford will be looking for enhanced costs for successfully pursuing a contempt remedy against Mr. Jivraj. Costs are the mechanism by which an aggrieved party may be assisted, not a fine.
[ 67 ] I would ask that Mr. Harrison prepare a form of judgment dealing with this decision. Additionally, I would ask for his written submissions on costs, to be provided by June 30. Mr. Jivraj will have a month from the date he receives Mr. Harrison’s submissions to reply. Mr. Harrison may reply within two weeks from receiving Mr. Jivraj’s response if he feels it necessary to respond. Heard by way of written submissions. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 1 st day of June, 2023. Robert A. Graesser J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Richard E. Harrison Wilson Laycraft for the Plaintiff Karim A. Jivraj Self Represented for the Defendant
Loading document…