LC v Alberta (Child Welfare), 2023 ABKB 334
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: LC v Alberta (Child Welfare), 2023 ABKB 334 Date: 20230601 Docket: 0703 10836 Registry: Edmonton Between: LC and EMP Plaintiffs - and - His Majesty the King in Right of Alberta As Represented by the Director of Child Welfare Defendants Restriction on Publication Identification Ban – See the Child, Youth and Family Enhancement Act ,
section 126.2. No person shall publish the name or photograph of a child or of the child's parent or guardian in a manner that reveals that the child is receiving, or has received, intervention services. NOTE: Identifying information has been removed from this judgment to comply with the ban so that it may be published. _______________________________________________________ Decision on Costs of the Honourable Justice Robert A. Graesser _______________________________________________________
Introduction [ 1 ] In LC v Alberta , 2023 ABKB 99 , I issued a decision on an application by several prospective witnesses to cancel or postpone scheduled questioning. The witnesses are former employees or officers of the Alberta Government. [ 2 ] The position taken on their behalf was that counsel for the Plaintiffs had not proven that any of these proposed witnesses had anything relevant and material to say in this action.
Counsel argued that the application was premature, and that before questioning any of these witnesses, Plaintiffs’ counsel should first question the Government’s officer and obtain undertakings to obtain any relevant and material information from these people. [ 3 ] I dismissed the application and directed that questioning proceed. My decision was silent on costs. Mr. Lee prepared an order, which included an amount for costs. He submits that the Plaintiffs were successful on the application and the ordinary rule of costs following the event should apply.
He seeks costs of some $2,600. [ 4 ] Counsel for the witnesses objects to payment of any costs, submitting that the normal rule is that witnesses neither pay nor receive costs when the become involved in other peoples’ litigation. Authorities [ 5 ] Rule 10.29(1) provides the “general rule” for costs in litigation: 10.29
(1) A successful party to an application, a proceeding or an action is entitled to a costs award against the unsuccessful party, and the unsuccessful party must pay the costs forthwith, notwithstanding the final determination of the application, proceeding or action, subject to… [ 6 ] It is clear that the cost Rules apply only to the parties, and as between the parties. They are frequently referred to as “party- party costs”.
The Rules do not deal with costs in favour of witnesses who have been dragged into other people’s litigation to compensate them for the value of the time spent, the inconvenience to them, or for other things such as anxiety or embarrassment.
All they are entitled to is conduct money, witness fees, and reimbursement for the reasonable costs of their attendance for travel, accommodation, and meals. [ 7 ] There is nothing in the Rules that expressly makes a non-party such as a witness liable for costs. [ 8 ] Counsel for the witnesses referred me to 358427 Alberta Inc v Monenco Advisory Services Limited , 1998 ABQB 16 and paras 13-17 in particular: [13] On reading the material provided to me by counsel, my view is that the ‘test’ as such does not clearly exist.
Rather, circumstances arise out of a variety of fact situations which can lead to an award of costs against a non party. Some conditions must always be present.
Others arise out of the nature of the circumstances before the court. [14] It is always the case that the litigant seeking costs from the non party has the onus of proving the costs are properly recoverable from the non party. [15] It is always the case that an award of costs against a non party is exceptional and must be approached with caution. [16] It is always the case that an award for costs against a non party motivated by resentment arising from the inability to collect from the party to the action cannot in and of itself justify such an award.
No such motivation is alleged here. [17] It is always the case that if costs are sought against a non party, and that party could have been made a party to the litigation, but was not, then the failure to safeguard the non party’s right to procedural fairness will preclude the award. For example, the non party must receive adequate warning (usually by being made a party to the action) of the claim for costs.
If evidence adduced at trial supports a finding of fact in favor of an award against the non party in the absence of the prior warning and procedural fairness, then the claim will be denied. [ 9 ] In that case, the successful defendant sought costs of the action against two non-parties on the basis they were the real litigants in the action because they were the holders of assignments of rents and leases and the action was being pursued for their benefit. [ 10 ] The unsuccessful plaintiff was not expected to be able to pay the Defendant’s costs.
PLJ Smith, J concluded that on the evidence before her, she was unable to conclude that the third parties were the “real promotors” of the litigation, and dismissed the application for costs. [ 11 ] No other cases were cited to me by counsel. Analysis [ 12 ] The Court’s jurisdiction to award costs against a non-party was discussed in Shefsky v California Gold Mining Inc, 2015 ABQB 525 . In that case, the successful defendant sought leave to claim costs from a non-party who was alleged by the defendant to be the “true promotor” of the litigation. Thomas, J noted at para 37:
[37] The common law has developed certain tests that courts consider when a party seeks costs against a non-party to litigation. According to Stevenson & Côté’s commentary under r 10.33(2) in the Civil Procedure Handbook , this can occur in three scenarios:
a) Where the non-party is the person ultimately liable, or
b) Where he or she was the real instigator of the litigation and the one which would have received the fruits, or
c) Where the non-party was guilty of serious misconduct relating to the suit. [ 13 ] From a review of these cases, I am satisfied that there is no “normal rule” relating to cost awards against non-parties. I agree with Thomas J’s conclusion quoted above in Shefsky v California Cold Mining Inc , which goes further than 358427 Alberta Inc v Monenco Advisory Services Limited on the subject. [ 14 ] The Rules of Court are silent in this issue, but it is trite law to say that costs are always in the discretion of the Court.
The examples of situations were cost awards against non-parties may be appropriate as articulated in Shefsky are very helpful, but I would consider them to be non-exhaustive.
I would not attempt to fetter the Court’s discretion to award such costs in appropriate circumstances and do not think it is appropriate to limit those circumstances to “exceptional” ones. [ 15 ] In my view, there is no reason to exempt a third party who interferes in the conduct of litigation from liability for costs in the event they are unsuccessful on an application, or to bar them from receiving costs if they are successful in resisting an application made against them. [ 16 ] In the ordinary course, people served with notices to attend simply attend, bring with them the records they are required to bring, and answer all proper questions.
If there is an objection to that witness’s attendance for some reason, it is generally left to the opposite party to object, not the witness. [ 17 ] Where a witness involves themself by way of bringing or opposing applications, they are generally pursuing their own interests, not the litigants’ interests. Such involvement increases the actual parties’ costs, with no obvious benefit to either party. [ 18 ] Here, the witnesses filed their own application and submitted their own brief. Their former employer, the Alberta Government, took no position on the application.
At the end of the day, I see no good reason why the Government as a party should be ultimately responsible for the Plaintiffs’ costs on the application as potential “costs in the cause” if the Plaintiffs are ultimately successful. Conclusion [ 19 ] I am satisfied that the witnesses should be responsible for one set of costs for the application itself, on Column 1. No costs are awarded for this costs application. Heard by way of written submissions. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 1st day of June, 2023. Robert A. Graesser J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Robert P.
Lee Victims Rights Law for the Plaintiffs Damian Shepherd Chomicki Baril Mah LLP for the Witnesses
Luciana Brasil, Branch McMaster Alberta Justice for the Defendants (took no position on application)
Loading document…