Christofi v Taing, 2023 ABKB 376
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Christofi v Taing, 2023 ABKB 376 Date: 20230621 Docket: 1901 15377, 2101 02852 Registry: Calgary Between: Mike Christofi and quality painting Proposed Applicants - and - Marie Taing, Kahane Law Office, and Chadwick Newcombe Proposed Respondents _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Mike Christofi (Mr.
Christofi) in July 2022 was made subject to court access gatekeeping pursuant to Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 ss 23-23.1 as a consequence of Mr. Christofi’s pattern of persistent, repeated abusive litigation. That litigant gatekeeping step was subsequently confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta, then the Supreme Court of Canada denied leave to appeal: Christofi v Jeffrey V Kahane Professional Corporation , 2022 ABCA 284 , leave to appeal refused, 40507 (4 May 2023). Mr.
Christofi has previously been refused leave to initiate proceedings before the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta: e.g., Christofi v Kahane Law Office , 2023 ABKB 122 ( Christofi v Kahane #5 ); Christofi v Taing , 2023 ABKB 162 ( Christofi v Kahane #6 ); Christofi v Taing , 2023 ABKB 344 ( Christofi v Kahane #7 ).
[ 2 ] Mr. Christofi is therefore familiar with this Court’s leave to file process. Despite that, on June 2, 2023, Mr. Christofi emailed the Civil Coordinator of the Calgary Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, seeking “... a half-day special hearing ...”. The Civil Coordinator instructed Mr. Christofi to make a leave to file request. Instead of directing that request to me, Mr. Christofi emailed a number of Calgary Court of King’s Bench of Alberta judicial assistants. Ultimately, Mr. Christofi’s request was forwarded to my office.
The document attached to that email (Application #1) is identical to a candidate filing that was refused leave and rejected by this Court in Christofi v Kahane #6 at paras 3-4 . [ 3 ] Four days later, on June 5, 2023, Mr. Christofi again attempted to book a special chambers hearing, and, again, Mr. Christofi’s email and a second unfiled document (Application #2) was forwarded to my office.
In this case, the apparently proposed filing is not identified as an Application of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, but, instead is titled: “Application of mike Christofi to restore Appeal 2101-0295AC”, and is formatted as a filing in the Court of Appeal of Alberta in Action No. 2101-0295AC.
The body of Application #2 reads: Nature of Application and Relief Sought: 1. to dismiss court orders against me and to declare Kahane law office responsible for damages for abuse of process fraud and intensional tort by kahane law lawyers Kimberly Holland and Alie Laurent this alegation are not defeated by the general principal the lawyer owes no duty to an opposing party Grounds for making this application: 2. Affidavit of mike Christofi march 6 2023 research about similar cases about fraud abuse of process intensional tort were granted by the court EXH 7 Material or evidence to be relied on: 3.
Affidavit of Mike Christofi march 8 and may 30 2023 research about lawyers liability for damages to an opposing party shows that similar cases against lawyers about fraud abuse of process conspiracy intensional tort were granted exh 7 Applicable Acts, regulations and rules: 4. my claim against Kahane Law office is based on fraud Abuse of process conspiracy intensional tort are not defeated by the general principal the lawyer owes no duty to an opposing party the claim file 2101-02852 and 1901-15337 is against Kimperly Holland and Marie Taing Kimperly Holland Withdrew from lawyer of Records and Marie Taing was Found responsible for damages by Justice JT Eamons And Mr Newcombe doesn’t belong in this case research on Exh 7 shows similar cases were granted by the court about fraud abuse of process conspiracy intensional tort thats what my claim against kahane law is about (Sic, emphasis in original.) [ 4 ] In the interests of judicial efficiency, I will respond to these materials as two Applications by Mr.
Christofi to obtain permission - “leave” - to file and initiate proceedings, although, factually, Mr. Christofi has simply attempted to bypass that process. The principles that govern how the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta evaluates leave to initiate or continue litigation processes were recently reviewed in Christofi v Kahane #5 at paras 5-11 . Mr. Christofi is, therefore, well aware of the requirements for a valid leave application. [ 5 ] Application #1 is rejected as a collateral attack on Christofi v Kahane #6 . All leave to file decisions are final. Mr.
Christofi is simply attempting to re-litigate the same matter, repeatedly, with duplicate documents. Mr. Christofi is very well aware of the rule that litigants get one chance to bring an issue before the Courts. I, therefore, conclude that Mr. Christofi submitting Application #1 is a deliberate step to flout Court authority and procedures, and harm the proposed Respondents. [ 6 ] Application #2 is rejected because to whatever extent this document can be evaluated, Application #2 appears intended to affect litigation in the Court of Appeal of Alberta.
The Court of King’s Bench of Alberta has no authority in relation to that Court. [ 7 ] Furthermore, to the degree the subjects that Mr. Christofi seeks to litigate pursuant to Application #1 and Application #2 can be identified and evaluated, these are matters that have been previously repeatedly evaluated: Christofi v Kahane #5 at paras 16-19 ; Christofi v Kahane #6 at para 6 ; Christofi v Kahane #7 at para 5 . That is a second global reason why Mr. Christofi’s Applications are an abuse of the Court. [ 8 ] Application #1 and Application #2 continue a pattern in which Mr.
Christofi responds to any negative outcome by immediately submitting additional materials that, to the degree these materials can be evaluated, simply challenge prior settled outcomes: Christofi v Kahane #7 at paras 6-7 . In this instance, Mr. Christofi had two Applications to continue proceedings in the Court of Appeal of Alberta rejected by Hughes JA on June 1, 2023: Christofi v Kahane Law Office (1 June 2023), Calgary 2201-0089AC (Alta CA); Christofi v Newcombe (1 June 2023), Calgary 2201-0149AC (Alta CA). Mr.
Christofi then immediately made new filing attempts at the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta to reopen and resume terminated litigation. [ 9 ] I make several negative findings of fact. First, I conclude that Mr. Christofi is simply unmanageable with the tools available to this Court. In Jonsson v Lymer , 2020 ABCA 167 , the Court of Appeal of Alberta determined preconditions to litigation such as payment of costs or penalties, and mandatory lawyer representation, could not be imposed. Thus, there is little to stop Mr. Christofi from hijacking the processes of this Court. Mr.
Christofi’s now four-year pattern of unrelenting, repeated litigation predicts that the abusive litigation by Mr. Christofi will never end, wasting Court time and resources. There is nothing to stop Mr. Christofi from repeating his pointless, abusive, Court activities. [ 10 ] Second, I find that Mr. Christofi has intentionally tried to file his abusive litigation with the Court to bypass the litigation and litigant management steps imposed by this Court. I further find that Mr.
Christofi knowingly misdirected Application #1 and Application #2 to a different Justice in an attempt to “judge shop” and avoid my litigation management function as the Administrative Justice for
abusive litigation management in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. [ 11 ] Given these conclusions, and Mr. Christofi being effectively unmanageable, I conclude the best approach to Mr. Christofi is to structure how Mr. Christofi interacts with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. I, therefore, Order: 1. Mr. Christofi is prohibited from any direct or indirect communication with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, except:
a) in documentary form and by registered mail to my office, or the office of my designate; or
b) by filing or submitting documents via a member in good standing of the Law Society of Alberta, or another person authorized to represent Mr. Christofi in the Court of King’s Bench, pursuant to the Legal Professions Act , RSA 2000, c L-8 . 2. To avoid any confusion, point one above means that Mr. Christofi is prohibited from any communication with any Court of King’s Bench of Alberta staff and decision makers, for example by email, telephone, letters or other correspondence, and faxes. 3. Mr.
Christofi is prohibited from filing any documents with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, except according to paragraph 1(b), and, unless Mr. Christofi engages the services of a lawyer, the only way that Mr. Christofi may file any documents with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta is if:
a) those documents are received by my office, or my designate, by registered mail;
b) after review, those documents are determined to be legally valid and not an abuse of the Court, and then;
c) Mr. Christofi pays any filing fees, and potentially security for costs, as set by the Court. 4. Mr. Christofi is prohibited from any attendance at Clerk's Counters of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, except when Mr. Christofi is authorized to file a document, pursuant to paragraph 3, above. [ 12 ] Any email, document, or other material from Mr.
Christofi that is received by the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, will be deleted and/or discarded, with no response, except where that email, document, or other communication is permitted by this Memorandum of Decision. [ 13 ] In Christofi v Kahane #7 at para 9 I repeated my earlier cautions to Mr. Christofi that if he continued to abuse the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta leave to file processes, then Mr. Christofi can anticipate he will be the target of r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 penalties: This Memorandum of Decision is Mr.
Christofi’s final warning: if he continues to file hopeless and abusive leave applications with the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, he can expect r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 penalties to be imposed. [ 14 ] Despite that, I will not impose a r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court penalty in response to Application #1 and Application #2. Christofi v Kahane #7 issued just after Application #1 and Application #2 were received, so Mr. Christofi had not had the warning reproduced above. However, Mr.
Christofi can now expect that if he abuses the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta leave to file process in the future, he will be subject to monetary penalties imposed by the Court. [ 15 ] The Court will prepare the Order giving effect to this Memorandum of Decision. Mr. Christofi’s approval of the form and content of that Order is dispensed with. This Memorandum of Decision and corresponding Order shall be served on Mr.
Christofi by email to the address: Michalis54@yahoo.com . [ 16 ] Mindful of the Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 instruction that Canadian judges shall provide information on litigation alternatives to self-represented litigants, such as Mr. Christofi, if Mr. Christofi disagrees with the Court refusing leave to file Application #1 and Application #2, then Mr. Christofi may seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada. If Mr. Christofi disagrees with the litigation and litigant management steps imposed in paragraph 11 of this Memorandum of Decision, then Mr.
Christofi may appeal those steps to the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 21 st day of June, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances by document: Mike Christofi
Self-represented Litigant
Loading document…