Rana v Rana, 2023 ABKB 382
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Rana v Rana, 2023 ABKB 382 Date: 20230626 Docket: 1501 02369 Registry: Calgary Between: Salim Rana Plaintiff - and - Zahir Rana, Attorney for Gulzar Rana Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Salim Rana (Mr. S. Rana) is in a dispute with his brother, Zahir Rana (Mr. Z. Rana) over Mr. Z. Rana’s conduct of his mother Gulzar’s affairs: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 455 ( Rana Setting Trial Decision ). Mr. S.
Rana is a self-represented litigant, while Mr. Z. Rana has been represented by counsel throughout this litigation. After many years of pre-trial applications and decisions, and two and half years of case management, on June 20, 2022 Devlin J issued Reasons and an Order to Set Trial of the inter-sibling dispute: Rana Setting Trial Decision . The Rana v Rana trial is currently scheduled for February 5-9, 2024. Throughout the protracted process that led to the June 20, 2022 Reasons, Mr. S. Rana engaged in numerous unsuccessful applications and collateral proceedings to the central dispute.
That abusive conduct led to indefinite and global court access restriction gatekeeping pursuant to Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 ss 23-23.1 in a Memorandum of Decision reported as Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 139 , that has been confirmed by the Court of Appeal of Alberta: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 172 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40231 (9 March 2023); Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 378 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 40580 (30 March 2023). The effect of those court access restrictions is that Mr. S. Rana must seek permission – “leave” – prior to initiating litigation and litigation steps. [ 2 ] Mr. S.
Rana has been consistently both persistent and aggressive in his conduct of this litigation. For example, Mr. S. Rana has sought leave from the Supreme Court of Canada on no less than 23 occasions. In each instance, Mr. S. Rana’s leave application was dismissed. The Courts of King’s Bench of Alberta and the Court of Appeal of Alberta have repeatedly concluded that Mr. S. Rana engages in futile, abusive litigation, and does so to inflict harm on his brother and those affiliated with his brother. [ 3 ] Most recently Mr. S. Rana sought leave on two separate issues. First, Mr. S.
Rana sought this Court waive a requirement in the Rana Setting Trial Decision that Mr. S. Rana pay into court security for all outstanding costs awards in relation to the Rana v Rana litigation, 90 days prior to the trial. Devlin J ruled non-compliance would terminate Mr. S. Rana’s litigation: “... failing which his action
and application will be dismissed and the caveat removed.”: Rana Setting Trial Decision at para 26. In a Memorandum of Decision reported as Rana v Rana , 2023 ABKB 295 , I rejected Mr. S. Rana’s leave request as re-litigation of issues already decided by the Court of Appeal of Alberta and the Supreme Court of Canada, and imposed a $5,000 r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 penalty. [ 4 ] Next, Mr. S. Rana sought leave to pursue an Application to visit his mother, in parallel to a visit on terms granted by Justice Devlin in Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 440 ( Rana Visit Decision ). Mr. S.
Rana did not conduct the visit authorized in the Rana Visit Decision , but, instead, unsuccessfully appealed the Rana Visit Decision to the Court of Appeal of Alberta ( Rana v Rana , 2022 ABCA 270 ) and Supreme Court of Canada ( Rana v Rana (30 March 2023), Ottawa 40474 (SCC)). I granted Mr. S. Rana permission to submit a revised visit application that removed certain collateral attack arguments that had been rejected by the Court of Appeal of Alberta and the Supreme Court of Canada: Rana v Rana , 2023 ABKB 324 ( Rana Second Visit Decision ). Mr. S.
Rana was required to pay a $2,500 r 10.49(1) of the Alberta Rules of Court penalty for abusive re-litigation of settled issues, and $10,000 in security for costs. [ 5 ] The same day as the Rana Second Visit Decision was issued, May 30, 2023, Mr. S. Rana sent my office the following email: I just received the decision. This truly is a joke. I had drafted the attached letter to send it out and received your email right before sending it out. I have decided to send it and stop wasting anytime you this court. I have already drafted a federal lawsuit against the Albert Ombudsmen for damages.
Now i will file actions again the Province of Alberta and the Government of Canada. I have spent a lot of time keeping a record of your Bias and unjust Rulings. You require money before I can see my mother? You idiots already have $10,000 of my money for this! I’ll cancel my trip to Cowland. (Sic.) The “attached letter” essentially complains that the Rana Second Visit Decision was not issued in a timely enough manner. [ 6 ] Since Mr. S. Rana has now declared he will not comply with directions of this Court set to manage Mr. S.
Rana’s persistent, abusive litigation, the conditional leave to file granted in the Rana Second Visit Decision is now dismissed. Mr. S. Rana’s request for leave to file an Application to visit his mother is dismissed. This step is permanent and final: Rana v Rana , 2022 ABQB 139 at para 111 (6). The Court will not receive and consider any future leave to file requests with this subject. [ 7 ] There is no appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta of this decision to deny leave to initiate litigation: r 14.5(4) of the Alberta Rules of Court ; Re Gauthier , 2018 ABCA 14 at para 8 . Mr. S.
Rana may seek leave from the Supreme Court of Canada of this Court refusing leave. [ 8 ] In the Rana Setting Trial Decision at para 26, Devlin J ordered: ... (Mr. S. Rana) shall pay into Court the full then-outstanding amount of all Orders for costs against him in favour of the defendants 90 days prior to trial, failing which his action and application will be dismissed and the caveat removed. Nothing in this provision precludes the payment or collection of costs in the ordinary costs in the period leading up to trial ... At that time the unpaid costs owed by Mr. S. Rana to Mr. Z.
Rana were “... over $90,000 ...”: Rana Setting Trial Decision at para 21. [ 9 ] Subsequently, the Court of Appeal of Alberta in Rana v Rana , 2023 ABCA 112 refused to grant leave to appeal to Mr. S. Rana, and, instead, granted the cross-application of Mr. Z.
Rana “... to prohibit further applications in the Court of Appeal unless all Court of Appeal cost awards in the amount of ($7,932.00) are paid in full.” Veldhuis JA stated: ... when litigants choose the public court process, they are bound by the remedies imposed by the court, including the payment of costs by the unsuccessful party to the successful party. [ 10 ] Up to this point there was some tenuous argument that could be made that Mr. S. Rana’s litigation conduct had at least some badly directed but potentially legitimate basis. However, Mr. S. Rana’s May 30, 2023 email is a declaration that Mr. S.
Rana no longer seeks to litigate in a valid manner, but, instead, that Mr. S. Rana will now “forum shop” ( Unrau v National Dental Examining Board , 2019 ABQB 283 at paras 679-685 ) his litigation to a Canadian Court where he is not subject to litigation management steps, and there target government actors who are third parties to his inter-sibling dispute. [ 11 ] Mr. S. Rana’s litigation activities have consumed an inordinate volume of Alberta Court resources. The scheduled five-day trial represents a significant further commitment of scarce Court resources. I note: 1) Mr. S.
Rana states he is not resident in Canada, but instead appears to say he is now located in the UK, and Mr. S. Rana’s address for service is in Kenya; 2) Justice Devlin concluded that Mr. S. Rana paying costs as a precondition of trial is necessary to “... ameliorat(
e) financial injustice ...” since: (Mr. Z. Rana) has little hope of recovering any costs awarded above what is secured in Court. In light of the apparent merits of (Mr. S. Rana’
s) claim, given that the promissory note was signed at a time when Gulzar had lost capacity and (Mr. Z. Rana) was acting under a power of attorney, it would be unjust to require (Mr. Z. Rana) to incur the further costs of a five-day trial with such large costs awards already outstanding ... 3) Justice Devlin also observed that Mr. S. Rana’s litigation is having the effect of depleting his mother’s resources;
4) the reasoning of Justice Veldhuis in Rana v Rana , 2023 ABCA 112 concerning circumstances when Mr. S. Rana can be compelled to pay outstanding costs amounts to a precondition of initiating litigation processes; and 5) Mr. S. Rana’s stated intent that he will not engage with this Court in a legitimate, valid manner. [ 12 ] I, therefore, conclude that Mr. S. Rana should be required to pay outstanding litigation costs on a clear timeline as a precondition to the February 5-9, 2024 trial: 1) Counsel for Mr. Z. Rana shall by July 31, 2023 prepare and serve on the Court and Mr. S.
Rana an Affidavit of outstanding unpaid costs awards against Mr. S. Rana in this matter and related proceedings, including awards made by the Court of Appeal of Alberta and Supreme Court of Canada; and 2) Mr. S. Rana shall pay the total of those unpaid costs to Mr. Z. Rana by August 31, 2023. [ 13 ] If Mr. S. Rana fails to make that payment, then: 1) the Rana v Rana , Action No. 1501 02369 is struck out; 2) the February 5-9, 2024 trial is cancelled and those trial dates released; 3) the caveat filed by Mr. S. Rana on his mother’s home is removed; and 4) any funds paid by Mr. S.
Rana that are held by the Clerk of the Court as security for costs are to be applied to all costs proven by Mr. Z. Rana. [ 14 ] To date Mr. S. Rana has been self-represented in his proceedings. If Mr. S. Rana truly does intend to pursue his litigation, I very strongly recommend he immediately retain counsel to manage his lawsuit and communications with the Court and Defendant. [ 15 ] Mindful of the Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 instruction that Canadian judges shall provide information on litigation alternatives to self-represented litigants, such as Mr. S. Rana, if Mr. S.
Rana disagrees with steps imposed in paragraphs 12-13 of this Memorandum of Decision, Mr. S. Rana may appeal this outcome at the Alberta Court of Appeal. [ 16 ] Counsel for Mr. Z. Rana shall prepare the Order giving effect to this Memorandum of Decision. Mr. S. Rana’s approval of that Order is dispensed with. Mr. S. Rana shall be served this Memorandum of Decision and corresponding Order by email. I direct a copy of this Memorandum of Decision is provided to Counsel for Mr. Z. Rana. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 26 th day of June, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A.
Appearances by Written Submission: Salim Rana Self-represented Litigant Andrew Wilson and Erin Baker JSS Barristers No appearance
Loading document…