R v Borhot, 2023 ABKB 385
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: R v Borhot, 2023 ABKB 385 Date: 20230626 Docket: 200970341Q1 Registry: Calgary Between: His Majesty the King Crown - and - Jamal Taan Borhot Defendant _______________________________________________________ Voir dire Decision of the Honourable Justice N. Dilts _______________________________________________________ This is a written version of the oral decision delivered June 26 th , 2023. I have edited this written version to add citations and headings, to ensure proper punctuation, spelling, and use of language. I have not supplemented my oral reasons.
This written decision is near verbatim from the oral decision delivered. My oral decision remains the official ruling of the Court. [ 1 ] Mr. Borhot is charged with three counts of participating in the activities of a terrorist group contrary to s. 83.18(1) of the Criminal Code , RSC 1985, c C-46 . His trial is scheduled to commence October 3, 2023 and to proceed before a judge sitting alone. Background [ 2 ] In 2011, the Syrian civil war erupted with non-militant protests against the government of President Bashar al-Assad. When government forces responded with violence, militant protests erupted.
As the conflict persisted, a number of insurgent groups established themselves in Syria. Those groups acted with differing objectives and were motivated by differing ideologies. The insurgent groups included the Salafist jihadist terrorist organizations of al-Qaeda and the Islamic State or “ISIS” “IS”. [ 3 ] The Crown alleges that Mr. Borhot left Canada on May 9, 2013 and entered Syria with the intention of participating in the activities of a terrorist group. The Crown offers evidence that Mr. Borhot crossed a “green” border from Turkey into Syria and remained in Syria until April 8, 2014.
The Crown alleges that while in Syria, Mr. Borhot participated in the activities of ISIS for the purpose of enhancing the Islamic State’s ability to carry out its terrorist activities. It suggests the evidence will show that Mr. Borhot was a jihadist fighter for one or more terrorist organization.
[4] The Crown proposes to make its case against Mr. Borhot in large measure by relying on conversations and posts from whatare alleged to be Mr. Borhot’s Facebook accounts before he left Canada and while he was allegedly in Syria, and through wiretapintercept communications from 2020. [5] In addition, the Crown proposes to tender at trial the expert evidence of Dr. Guido Steinberg. Dr. Steinberg is an Islamic andMiddle East historian with a specialized focus on Islamic terrorism.
He currently works for the German Institute for InternationalSecurity and Affairs, a foreign policy think tank in Berlin whose mandate is to advise the German Parliament and German Governmenton foreign and security affairs. He has written extensively on the topic of al-Qaeda and on the history of ISIS, including the ISISideology. He has also written on a number of other Islamic organizations of varying size. [6] Dr. Steinberg holds a PhD in Islamic Studies from the Free University of Berlin and a master’s degree from the University ofCologne.
He describes himself as fluent in Arabic, having lived and studied as a language student in Syria and elsewhere. He has readand watched source materials from Islamic terrorist organizations. He has also been permitted by courts in Germany to ask questions ofaccused persons about organizational aspects of terrorist groups in Syria for the purpose of contributing to the collective understandingof the organizations and their workings. [7] Dr. Steinberg has prepared a lengthy report, entered as Exhibit VD3 on this voir dire. The report tracks ISIS and its originsand development from 2000 to 2021.
It also speaks to the Islamic State’s ideology and objectives, its governing and operating structure,its military and policing structure, and its efforts to operate as a state. Amongst other things, the report discusses the Islamic State’spublic relations and propaganda arm. [8] Dr.
Steinberg has been recognized as an expert witness in an estimated 150 terrorism trials in Germany, approximately ninetrials in Denmark, three trials in the United States, and in trials elsewhere in Europe including Switzerland, Austria, and the Netherlands.In Canada, he authored an expert report for the Crown for a prosecution in Alberta which was referred to in the offender’s sentencinghearing. [9] The Crown seeks to qualify Dr. Steinberg as an expert witness to provide expert testimony on the topic of Islamic terrorismin Syria. It maintains that Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence will provide necessary context within which to view Mr. Borhot’s alleged actions,including the history, politics and geography of Syria and the development of ISIS in Syria. The Crown maintains that without Dr.Steinberg’s expert evidence, an ordinary but informed person is unlikely to form a correct understanding of Islamic terrorism in Syria inthe relevant time frame. The Crown says that Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence is logically relevant to the issues at trial considering thecomplexity of the offence to be proved. [10] In R v Khawaja, 2012 SCC 69 the Supreme Court of Canada established the actus reus and mens rea requirements for theoffence of participating in the activity of a terrorist group under s. 83.18(1) of the Criminal Code. The elements of the offence aresuccinctly summarized at paragraph 41 of that decision. The Crown must prove that an accused person
i) knowingly; ii) participated in orcontributed to; iii) directly or indirectly; iv) any activity of a terrorist group;
v) for the purpose of enhancing the ability of any terroristgroup to facilitate or carry out a terrorist activity. [11] Underlying that simplified framework, however, is a great deal of complexity.
Section 83.18(1) applies to an accused who, bytheir acts, contributes to or participates in what they know to be activities of what they know to be a terrorist group in circumstanceswhere those acts are done for the specific purpose of enhancing the terrorist group to facilitate or carry out their terrorist activities:United States of America v Nadarajah (No. 1), 2010 ONCA 859 at para 28, cited in Khawaja at para 41. “Terrorist activities” bydefinition encompass acts that are committed for a political, religious, or ideological purpose with the intention of intimidating a segmentof the public and that intentionally cause death or bodily harm to a person by the use of violence (Criminal Code s. 83.01).
Section83.18(3) contains an inclusive list of activities that constitute participation in or contribution to the activities of a terrorist group.
Amongthose activities are “receiving … training” and “providing or offering to provide a skill or expertise for the benefit of” the terrorist group. [12] In a terrorism prosecution, the Crown’s burden is to prove not just the mens rea (knowingly participating) and actus reus(participating) of the offence; it must also prove the accused person’s ulterior intention (participating for the purpose of enhancing theability of a terrorist group to carry out terrorist activities), the motivation of the terrorist group (carrying out activities in whole or in partfor a political, religious or ideological purpose or objective), and the intended consequence (causing death by the use of violence,endangering lives, or causing serious risk to the health or safety of the public or any segment of the public). [13] The Crown suggests Dr.
Steinberg has necessary and relevant evidence that will assist the trier of fact in undertaking itsanalysis of the issues in this case, including the scope of activities that members of ISIS undertook to advance the group’s terroristagenda, how an individual entered Syria and gained membership in ISIS, and the ideology of the organization and its purpose orobjectives. [14] The Crown argues that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence satisfies the R v Mohan, (SCC), [1994] 2 SCR 9 criteria foradmissibility.
The Crown also argues that under the second stage of the admissibility framework as clarified in White Burgess LangilleInman v Abbott and Haliburton Co., 2015 SCC 23, when weighing the value of Dr. Steinberg’s proposed expert evidence against anyharm to the trial process or prejudice to Mr. Borhot, Dr. Steinberg’s evidence must be admitted as it informs some of the more significantissues at trial. It says any prejudice to Mr. Borhot from aspects of Dr.
Steinberg’s report can be addressed by redacting portions of Dr.Steinberg’s report and by clearly defining the scope of his permitted testimony. [15] The Crown proposes that I recognize Dr. Steinberg as an expert witness for trial qualified to give opinion evidence on: 1. The Islamic State, also known as ISIS or IS, particularly its origins, history, locations of operations, membership and structure,ideology, beliefs, practices, opposing forces, other names for IS, and recruitment methods; and 2.
Syria, particularly its geography, regional divisions, and political organization, and the significance of ISIS within that context. [16] The Crown urges that I take a broad view of the temporal relevance of Dr. Steinberg’s report. His report canvases the history
of ISIS from 2000 to 2021. Although Mr. Borhot was allegedly in Syria between May 2013 and April 2014, the Crown maintains that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence should not be constrained by reference to that time frame, nor necessarily by geographical boundaries. [ 17 ] Defence counsel objects to Dr. Steinberg’s evidence being admitted. Defence counsel disputes that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence is necessary. Counsel for Mr. Borhot argues that the history of ISIS in Syria in the relevant time frame of May 2013 to April 2014 is readily accessible through a review of English language sources.
In addition, he says the trial judge may take judicial notice of the social and political context in Syria in 2013 and 2014 and the existence of ISIS. Defence counsel also challenges Dr. Steinberg’s expertise as it relates to the issues in this trial, suggesting his expertise is largely derived from the study of German foreign fighters in Syria, not Canadian travelers, how Canadian fighters were recruited, or how they entered Syria in 2013. [ 18 ] Defence counsel also challenges the scope of Dr. Steinberg’s proposed evidence. Counsel for Mr. Borhot says that Dr.
Steinberg’s discussion of ISIS and its activities in years long after when Mr. Borhot is alleged to have left Syria is clearly irrelevant. Defence counsel argues that if admitted, Dr. Steinberg’s evidence must have a sharp end on April 8, 2014 when the Crown alleges that Mr. Borhot left Syria. Counsel points to examples throughout Dr. Steinberg’s evidence that they say breach this temporal boundary, including Dr. Steinberg’s evidence regarding the oath required of ISIS fighters, ISIS propaganda, and his evidence as to how foreign fighters entered Syria from Turkey. [ 19 ] In addition to arguing that Dr.
Steinberg’s opinion evidence regarding ISIS after April 8, 2014 is irrelevant, Defence counsel says there is a real risk that unless Dr. Steinberg’s evidence is contained to pre-April 2014, information regarding ISIS activities in the period after April 2014 could distort the lens through which Mr. Borhot’s alleged activities are viewed. Counsel for Mr. Borhot argues that distortion can either give rise to improper inferences being drawn or to inferences being drawn that are not supported by the evidence. They argue that the risks are many, including that the trial judge may rely on Dr.
Steinberg’s current knowledge of ISIS and invest Mr. Borhot with that knowledge as of May 8, 2013. Defence counsel also argues that the trial judge may characterize the actions of those who engaged earlier in the Syrian civil war by the actions of those who engaged later. [ 20 ] Defence counsel’s argument at its highest level is that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence risks that inferences will be drawn regarding Mr. Bohort’s knowledge and activities based on too broad a timeline, ascribing knowledge and understanding to Mr.
Borhot that we only have now, and in a way that overlooks the complex and shifting nature of what was occurring in Syria in 2013 and 2014. Defence counsel argues that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence is prejudicial in its lack of specificity, particularly in relation to issues like recruitment, border crossings, and membership, and that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence, if admitted, will lead to confusion and risks unfair inferences being drawn.
Decision [ 21 ] The case law is replete with direction to trial judges emphasizing the importance of the court’s gatekeeping function with respect to the admissibility of expert evidence. We are not only to determine its admissibility under the two-stage framework, we are to clearly articulate the permitted nature and scope of the expert evidence. We are also to be diligent throughout the trial to ensure those boundaries are observed and protected.
Vigilance is required to safeguard the trial process, to ensure the integrity of the decision-making process, and to protect against distortion by inadmissible expert opinion evidence. [ 22 ] Of course, any decision I make on this voir dire does not in any way preclude the trial judge from critically assessing the expert’s evidence and making their determination at trial as to the weight or value to be placed on that evidence in the context of the trial as a whole. The question I am to answer is not whether Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence should be accepted or what weight it should be given, but whether it is evidence that should be made available to the trial judge. [ 23 ] The admissibility of expert evidence is always anchored by questions of relevance and necessity. Necessity looks at the subject matter and whether the expert will provide information likely outside the experience and knowledge of the trier of fact: R v DD , 2000 SCC 43 at para 51 . Relevance is a question of logic: Mohan at p 21.
When considering relevance, the question is not whether the evidence is or could be determinative, but whether the evidence will usefully inform the trier of fact’s analysis of the issues before them. [ 24 ] However, even if the expert evidence is relevant and necessary, the court must consider whether the probative value of the evidence outweighs its prejudicial effect: R v Abbey , 2009 ONCA 624 at para 79 . Jurisprudence recognizes that there are inherent risks to expert evidence, particularly in the overuse of opinion evidence to support factual findings not otherwise available on the evidentiary record.
As I have considered Dr. Steinberg’s evidence, I have kept those risks in mind. [ 25 ] Considering the four-pronged test for admissibility in Mohan , there appears to be no dispute that Dr. Steinberg is an independent expert. He confirmed his independence with respect to the report prepared in this matter and in fact confirmed that he received no background or other information on Mr. Borhot before preparing his report. He also confirmed that he has been an independent witness in every trial in which he has testified in the past.
Notably, none of his previous expert testimony has been about an accused person’s guilt or innocence. Nor is there any argument that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence otherwise violates an exclusionary rule. [ 26 ] With respect to whether Dr. Steinberg possesses the necessary qualifications to speak broadly to ISIS’s recruitment methods and ideology, and to the training, enrolment and deployment of its fighters, I am satisfied that he is uniquely and highly qualified to express opinions on those topics. [ 27 ] As such, the material issues raised by Defence counsel relate to the necessity and relevance of Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence. [ 28 ] Turning first to the issue of necessity, I am asked to consider whether expert evidence on the operations, membership, structure, and ideology of ISIS is necessary to assist the trial judge or whether it is information the trial judge has or can acquire without expert assistance. According to Dr. Steinberg, there is a significant amount of available open-source information on Islamic terrorism in Syria and ISIS in particular. His evidence was that most of that literature is good and useable.
[29] However, the mere fact that open-source information on Islamic terrorism in Syria is available does not render Dr. Steinberg’sevidence unnecessary. An examination of Dr. Steinberg’s report speaks to the diversity of source materials, many of which are not inEnglish, and the complexity of the Syrian civil war and the arrival and participation of insurgent groups in Syria. [30] Terrorism based on ideology, belief systems, or religious beliefs appears particularly complex especially as the conflict inSyria progressed.
Moreover, the nature of a terrorist organization is to not lay bare its inner workings before the world. At least the moresophisticated choose what information they present for public viewing, and the reader/viewer is left to determine to what extent thecontrolled information is messaging. Much is otherwise left unknown to most. [31] In my view, the expert opinion evidence of Dr. Steinberg will provide information likely outside the experience andknowledge of the trier of fact.
I am satisfied that in the absence of fair and balanced expert testimony on the terrorist organizations thatoperated Syria, a region of the world that is largely unfamiliar to the western world, the trial judge will be left to construct anunderstanding of that complex and shifting landscape either from sources provided by the parties or from public sources.
That was thesituation faced by Justice Rutherford in the trial decision in R v Khawaja, where, in determining whether Mr.Khawaja was entitled to rely on the exclusionary “armed conflict” clause in the definition of “terrorist activity”, he noted at para 110: I must say that with the [sic] all the emphasis over the conflict in Afghanistan and Khawaja's frequent assertions in his emails and hisconversations that he wanted to get involved in it, and with the argument over the relevance of this exclusionary 'armed conflict' clause, itwould have been helpful to have had some expert evidence as to the geopolitical and military situation in Afghanistan and particularly asto the conduct of the hostilities by the insurgents opposing the Afghan and coalition forces.
Mr. McKercher urged me to simply takejudicial notice of how that conflict was being conducted, particularly by the insurgency. [32] The trial decision in Khawaja makes clear that in the absence of expert evidence, the trial judge was left to take judicial noticeof notorious facts and to construct an understanding of the geopolitical and military situation in Afghanistan from sources provided bycounsel and by reference to information available through United Nations records.
While the Supreme Court of Canada in Khawaja atpara 99 confirmed that the trial judge could take judicial notice of the ongoing war in Afghanistan and the counter-insurgency acts, thatitself is not a complete answer to the question of whether expert evidence should be available to the trial judge. [33] In concluding that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence is necessary to assist the trial judge, I am influenced by the volatility, instabilityand complexity of the insurgency in Syria at the time Mr. Borhot was alleged to be in Syria. I am also influenced by considerations oftrial efficiency.
Particularly, I am satisfied that expert testimony will aid trial efficiency in this instance rather than detract from it. In myview, careful and neutral expert evidence on the history, operations, membership, structure, ideology, beliefs, practices, opponents andallies of ISIS, including its recruitment methods, opportunities for membership, and the logistics of entering Syria, is not just helpful inthis instance, it is necessary. [34] Perhaps the most helpful illustration of this point was Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence on this voir dire when asked by Defencecounsel to distinguish amongst those groups involved in the revolution against the Syrian Government of President Bashar al-Assad. Dr.Steinberg distinguished between the peaceful protest movement and the rebel movement; and within the rebel movement, hedistinguished amongst three operators: the Free Syrian Army whose objective was to fight the ruling government, the Islamists andSalafists who fought to establish an Islamic State, and the Jihadists who wanted to fight in Syria and then expand into Turkey andelsewhere. Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence was that a well-read German, currently informed, would not be aware of these distinctions unlessthat person had a connection to Syria. That observation takes on greater significance when one considers the proximity of Germany toSyria as compared to Canada’s proximity to Syria, and the number of people who entered Syria between 2012 and 2018 that originatedfrom Germany (915) as compared to Canada (185), a disproportionate number even accounting for the population difference of the twonations. [35] What is clear from Dr.
Steinberg’s evidence is that there were a range of different insurgent organizations who controlleddifferent areas of Syria at different times between 2012 and 2014 and beyond, with shifting alliances and oppositions, some of whomjoined ISIS and some of whom remained distinct from ISIS. There were distinctions amongst insurgent groups on the basis of ideologyand structure, strategy and tactics, territory under control (including border access), and the ability to join. Those distinctions requireexpert explanation. Notably, Dr.
Steinberg has acquired his knowledge over decades of study, not just by a review of available literature,but by reviewing source documents, viewing published ISIS videos and propaganda in their original form, and interviewing personsaccused of participating in terrorist activities in Syria. [36] I am satisfied that Dr. Steinberg has specialized knowledge and that his evidence is necessary to provide the historical,political, geographic, and ideological context in which the trial judge’s analysis of the evidence against Mr.
Borhot must be undertaken. [37] Turning then to the question of relevance and whether the evidence will usefully inform the trial judge’s analysis of the issuesbefore them, I will first address whether it is appropriate under the banner of relevance to restrict Dr. Steinberg’s evidence to the dates inthe indictment and to preclude the expert from offering any evidence regarding ISIS after April 2014. [38] In answering this question, I will start by observing that much of Dr. Steinberg’s report is not definitive by way of datesexcept when discussing documented events.
In discussing when organizations took shape in Syria, or structures or governance developedwithin ISIS, Dr. Steinberg’s language is necessarily imprecise. His report contains language like “until 2014 or 2015” or “from 2013 or2014.” The report itself is a good indication not only that activities in Syria were fluid but that the global community’s knowledge andunderstanding of those activities evolved. As an example, Defence counsel submitted that the discussion in Dr. Steinberg’s reportregarding ISIS “hisba” or religious police, related solely to matters that occurred after April 2014; however, examining Dr.
Steinberg’sreport, he clearly states that a rudimentary ISIS hisba existed before the proclamation of the Caliphate in the spring of 2014. Informationabout an outcome usefully informs our understanding of the process undertaken to achieve that outcome. [39] In my view, there is no merit to the argument that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence regarding the development of ISIS after April2014 when Mr. Borhot is alleged to have returned to Canada is irrelevant. I also note that the investigation into Mr. Borhot took placebetween 2013 and 2020 and includes undercover operations and wiretap evidence.
While I do not want to overstate the importance of a
concurrent knowledge of ISIS through to the date Mr. Borhot was charged in September 2020, I am satisfied that Dr. Steinberg’s evidence regarding ISIS from 2000 to 2021 is relevant to the issues in this trial to ensure the trial judge has the geopolitical context in which to hear of the investigation and its outcomes. [ 40 ] As I am satisfied that Dr. Steinberg’s report is both necessary and relevant, I must then engage in the balancing act required in White Burgess . When I do so, I identify three areas where the prejudicial effect of Dr.
Steinberg’s proposed evidence exceeds the value it might contribute to the fact-finding process. [ 41 ] First, while I have concluded that Dr. Steinberg’s history of ISIS from 2000 to 2021 has general relevance at trial, I am concerned that certain details contained in his report run the risk of unnecessarily cluttering the record before the trial judge. Prejudice includes the detrimental impact to the trial process itself. Portions of Dr. Steinberg’s report have insufficient probative value, even when I consider the broad scope of contextual relevance that I have set. I have identified the portions of Dr.
Steinberg’s report that give rise to this concern in Category A of Appendix 1 to these reasons. [ 42 ] Second, although I have concluded that a temporal bright line cannot be drawn as a boundary to Dr. Steinberg’s evidence, I am satisfied that a geographic bright line must be drawn. Particularly, I am satisfied that ISIS efforts to expand into Libya, Afghanistan, or Lebanon have no relevance to the allegations against Mr. Borhot.
Even if relevant, I am satisfied that the prejudicial effect of the information regarding ISIS terrorist activity outside of Iraq and Syria, and particularly that in western countries, outweighs the value of that evidence. There is no allegation that Mr. Borhot participated in the activities of a terrorist group outside of Syria. I have identified the portions of Dr. Steinberg’s report that give rise to this concern in Category B of Appendix 1 to these reasons. [ 43 ] Finally, I am satisfied that there is information in Dr. Steinberg’s report where the prejudice from its inclusion outweighs its probative value.
While the Crown has argued, for example, that evidence regarding the Yazidi genocide could provide context to understand the wiretap intercept communications in 2020, the relevance of that evidence is much less clear, and on its face it is highly prejudicial. Similarly, evidence regarding the role of women and children in ISIS risks significant prejudice to Mr. Borhot that is completely unrelated to the allegations against him. I have identified the portions of Dr. Steinberg’s report that give rise to this concern in Category C of Appendix 1 to these reasons.
Summary [ 44 ] Other than those parts of Dr. Steinberg’s evidence captured in Categories A, B and C of Appendix 1, I am satisfied that Dr. Steinberg has relevant evidence that can assist the trial judge. At issue in the trial of Mr. Borhot will be the existence, structure, and organization of terrorist groups in Syria. To determine whether Mr. Borhot participated in the activities of a terrorist group requires an understanding of how and for what purpose supporters of ISIS were engaged, whether as soldiers, police, religious leaders, or media specialists as examples.
The net of what constitutes potential terrorist activity is wide and an ideological, organizational, and operational understanding of ISIS will assist the trial judge in making the determination of whether Mr. Borhot participated in activities of a terrorist group for the specific purpose of enhancing the terrorist group’s ability to carry out its terrorist activities. [ 45 ] I am also satisfied that Dr. Steinberg will have expert evidence particularly as to the distinction and development of the terrorist organizations al-Nusra, al-Qaeda and ISIS.
He can also offer his opinion as to how people from other countries entered Syria, connected into terrorist groups, and how recruits were processed, trained, and assigned to functions. He also has relevant evidence of how ISIS used propaganda and social media to attract Muslims from around the world who share its vision and ideology, including the development and circulation of propaganda on the intranet and the dark web. [ 46 ] I am satisfied that the evidence of Dr. Steinberg is relevant to the allegations against Mr. Borhot. Therefore, Dr. Steinberg is permitted to give expert opinion evidence at trial on: 1.
The Islamic State, also known as ISIS or IS, particularly its origins, history, operations within Syria and Iraq , membership and structure, ideology, beliefs, practices, opposing forces, other names for IS, and recruitment methods; and 2. Syria, particularly its geography, regional divisions, and political organization, and the significance of IS within that context. [ 47 ] As proposed by Crown, Dr. Steinberg will not be asked to express any opinion on the alleged actions of Mr. Borhot or whether Mr. Borhot participated in the activities of a terrorist organization. [ 48 ] Dr.
Steinberg’s expert report will be redacted to accord with these reasons. Heard on the 9 th and 12 th day of June, 2023. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 26 th day of June, 2023. Given orally on the 26 th day of June, 2023. N.F. Dilts J.C.K.B.A.
Appearances: Kent Brown, Domenic Puglia and Ben Rogers for the Crown Pawel Milczarek, Michael Nesbitt for Defence Appendix 1 to the voir dire decision R v Borhot Docket 200970341Q1 Category A Page Reference Required Redaction p. 13 “Baghdadi was succeeded…Baghdadi’s successor.” p. 14-15 “It is very likely that…from October 2019.” p. 22 “Chatayev managed…and the West.” Category B Page Reference Required Redaction p. 6 “During this phase, the first major attacks in Europe were perpetrated (e.g., Paris in November 2015)” p. 7 “Although IS continued…larger scale than before.” p. 7 “IS tried to keep…heights in 2015-2017.” p. 9 “More evidence emerged…and other countries.” p. 9-10 “When ISIS gained strength…public debate in France.” p. 22 “According to press reports…Central Asia.” and “Until December 2018… western countries.” p. 41 “Relations between IS and Kurdish…Mosul in 2017.” p. 49-55 Entirety of topic 13 “Terrorist Attacks in the West”; topic 14 “ISIS International”, topic 14.1 “Libya”, topic 14.2 “Afghanistan”, topic 14.3 “Lebanon” Category C Page Reference Required Redaction p. 9 “More evidence emerged…Turkey and other countries.” p. 34 “From July 2014…use of assault rifles.” p. 34-36 Entirety of topic 7 “Women”
p. 36-38 Entirety of topic 8 “Children and Child Fighters” p. 38 Heading “The Yazidi Genocide” p. 38-39 “There are no reliable numbers…Yazidis some respite.”
Loading document…