Uhrik v Barata, 2023 ABKB 439
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Uhrik v Barata, 2023 ABKB 439 Date: 20230724 Docket: 2201 12047 Registry: Calgary Between: Tibor Uhrik and Lieselotte Litzius Proposed Applicants - and - Ryan Barata and Carscallen LLP Proposed Respondents _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] On April 17, 2023, Tibor Uhrik (Mr. Uhrik) and Lieselotte Litzius (Ms.
Litzius) were made subject to global court access restrictions pursuant to Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 ss 23-23.1 in a Memorandum of Decision reported as Uhrik v Terrigno , 2023 ABKB 223 ( Uhrik v Terrigno #2 ). That step meant that Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius are required to obtain permission of the Court – “leave” – prior to initiating litigation steps or proceedings, or to continuing existing litigation. [ 2 ] On July 18, 2023 Acting Associate Chief Justice Jeffery received by email a package of materials (Application) from Mr. Uhrik that seek leave to initiate a litigation process in an action where Mr.
Uhrik and Ms. Litzius have sued Ryan Barata and Carscallen LLP: Uhrik v Barata , Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Action No. 2201 12047. That leave request was then forwarded to me as the
Administrative Justice of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta who responds to abusive litigation and litigant management. [ 3 ] I will not respond to Mr. Urhik’s July 18, 2023 Application. After review of the Uhrik v Barata lawsuit, I conclude this matter has proceeded improperly and in breach of Uhrik v Terrigno #2 . This timeline explains the state of the proceeding: October 19, 2022 – The Uhrik v Barata Statement of Claim is filed, seeking $250,000 in damages. November 7, 2022 – The Defendants file a Statement of Defence. April 17, 2023 – Uhrik v Terrigno #2 issues.
One effect of that judgment is to stay all proceedings in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta that were initiated by Mr. Uhrik and/or Ms.
Litzius: Tibor Uhrik and Lieselotte Litzius are prohibited from commencing, or attempting to commence, or continuing, any appeal, action, application, or proceeding in the Alberta Court of King’s Bench , on his or her own behalf, or on behalf of any other person or estate, without an order of the Chief Justice or Associate Chief Justice of the Alberta Court of King’s Bench, or their designate … ( Uhrik v Terrigno #2 at para 69 (1), emphasis added.) May 25, 2023 – The Uhrik v Barata Defendants apply for
Summary Judgment of the Uhrik v Barata action. June 27, 2023 – The parties appear before Applications Judge Park, who issues an Order that sets timelines for taking evidence, and adjourning the
Summary Judgment Application to September 12, 2023. [ 4 ] None of the post-April 17, 2023 events should have occurred. The Uhrik v Barata lawsuit was, at that point, stayed indefinitely. The effect of Uhrik v Terrigno #2 was that the Uhrik v Barata action is presumed to be an abuse of the Court and Defendants. “... [A] person subject to court access control is presumed to engage in illegitimate litigation unless the Court is satisfied otherwise. ...”: Re Thompson , 2018 ABQB 87 at para 19 , aff’d 2018 ABCA 111 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 38204 (14 February 2019).
I infer that the Uhrik v Barata Defendants and Applications Judge Park were unaware that the Uhrik v Barata lawsuit was stayed, indefinitely, on April 17, 2023. [ 5 ] However, Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius were very well aware the Uhrik v Barata lawsuit was stayed. They received the Uhrik v Terrigno #2 Memorandum of Decision, and, in fact, have attempted to appeal that Memorandum of Decision on numerous grounds: Uhrik v Terrigno , 2023 ABCA 198 . I draw a strong negative inference from Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius continuing litigation they knew had been stayed. That is part of a broader pattern.
As Bourque J observed: ... Mr. Uhrik, as the “front man” for himself and Ms. Litzius, has engaged in persistent and repeated litigation misconduct that is intended to frustrate court and litigant steps, to inflict unnecessary and costly processes within the debt collection actions, and, broadly, that ignores court authority and the Alberta Rules of Court . ... ... Mr. Uhrik has a history of earlier abusive litigation. ... Mr. Uhrik has previously used a parallel set of strategies to frustrate litigation, then counterattack by improper, baseless legal proceedings. ...
Case management cannot operate where litigants simply do not pay any attention to this Court’s instructions and orders. The record clearly establishes that Mr. Uhrik does what he wants, and then barrages opposing parties and the Court with repetitious paperwork, applications, demands, and complaints. ... ... Mr. Uhrik has demonstrated that he is a creative litigant who will counterattack so as to expand disputes.
He uses novel and unusual steps to initiate and continue litigation. ... ( Uhrik v Terrigno #2 at paras 64-67 .) [ 6 ] Unfortunately, this Court and the Uhrik v Barata Defendants have been put to unnecessary expense and expenditure of resources by Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius continuing their lawsuit when it had been indefinitely stayed and found, in law, to be presumptively an abuse of the Court and its processes. In light of these circumstances, I Order: 1. The September 12, 2023
Summary Judgment Application is adjourned sine die ; 2. Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius have until August 25, 2023 to submit to my office an application for leave to resume the stayed Uhrik v Barata lawsuit, pursuant to Uhrik v Terrigno #2 ; and 3. if no leave application is received from Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius by August 25, 2023, then the Uhrik v Barata lawsuit will be struck out, and costs assessed against Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius. [ 7 ] I direct that a copy of this Memorandum of Decision is provided to Counsel for the Defendants.
Counsel for the Defendants shall prepare the Order giving effect of this Memorandum of Decision. Mr. Uhrik’s and Ms. Litzius’ approval of that Order is dispensed with pursuant to r 9.4(2)(
c) of the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 . Mr. Uhrik and Ms. Litzius shall be served by email to: petertiborjackson@me.com . Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 24 th day of July, 2023.
K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances by Submissions: Tibor Uhrik for the Self-represented Litigants Tibor Uhrik and Lieselotte Litzius Zul Verjee, KC – No Appearance for the Proposed Respondents Ryan Barata and Carscallen LLP
Loading document…