TransAlta Corporation v Alberta (Minister of Environment and Parks), 2023 ABKB 459
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: TransAlta Corporation v Alberta (Minister of Environment and Parks), 2023 ABKB 459 Date: 20230810 Docket: 2201 10255 Registry: Calgary Between: TransAlta Corporation, TransAlta Generation Partnership, and TA Alberta Hydro LP Plaintiff - and - His Majesty the King in Right of Alberta as represented by The Minister of Environment and Parks Defendant _______________________________________________________ Reasons for Decision of the Honourable Justice R.A. Neufeld _______________________________________________________ I.
The Application [ 1 ] Cenovus Energy Inc (“Cenovus”) holds extensive oil and gas leases in the Brazeau area of west central Alberta.
As the largest producer in that area, it has actively participated in proceedings before the Alberta Energy Regulator (“AER”), taking the position that hydraulic fracturing of well of oil and gas formations in the area is safe, and in the public interest. [ 2 ] Cenovus now applies for intervenor status in an action brought by TransAlta Corporation, TransAlta Generation Partnership and TA Alberta Hydro LP (collectively, referred to herein as “TransAlta”) against the Government of Alberta (“Alberta”).
The application is made pursuant to Rule 2.10 of the Alberta Rules of Court (Alta Reg 124/210). [ 3 ] The action by TransAlta alleges that Alberta has breached a contract entered into between it and TransAlta’s predecessor in 1960 relating to the construction and operation of the Brazeau River water storage and hydro-electric development.
In particular TransAlta alleges that Alberta has wrongly issued mineral leases in the vicinity of the development without ensuring that oil and gas production (including hydraulic fracturing) can be done without imperiling the safety of the dam and associated structures. [ 4 ] Alberta denies that it has breached the 1960 agreement. [ 5 ] A
summary trial is scheduled for February, 2024. Cenovus seeks permission to intervene in that trial to provide argument and limited evidence in the form of an affidavit describing Cenovus’ operations and oil and gas rights in the area, together with answers given by the Affiant of that affidavit under questioning by TransAlta. II. General Principles
[ 6 ] The process to be used and factors to be considered in respect of deciding an application for intervenor status were articulated by our Court of Appeal in Orphan Wells Association v Grant Thornton , 2016 ABCA 238 at paragraphs 8 and 10 . [ 7 ] A two-step process is used: (
a) Determine the subject matter of the proceedings; and (
b) Determine the proposed intervenor's interest in the subject matter, including whether the intervenor will be directly and significantly affected by the outcome, and whether the intervenor will provide some expertise or fresh perspective on the subject matter that will be helpful. [ 8 ] Eight factors are identified in determining whether the second step has been satisfied: (
a) Will the intervenor be directly affected by the outcome of the matter? (
b) Is the presence of the intervenor necessary for the court to properly decide the matter? (
c) Might the intervenor's interest in the proceedings not be fully protected by the parties? (
d) Will the intervenor's submission be useful and different or bring particular expertise to the subject matter of the appeal? (
e) Will the intervention unduly delay the proceedings? (
f) Will there possibly be prejudice to the parties if intervention is granted? (
g) Will intervention widen the /is between the parties? (
h) Will the intervention transform the court into a political arena? [ 9 ] Cenovus seeks limited participation in the proceeding. It does not intend to adduce oral evidence, but it will rely on the trial record created by TransAlta and Alberta, and an affidavit sworn by David White describing Cenovus’ oil and gas leases, wells and production facilities in the area. It will argue that: (
a) The Brazeau River Development Act did not grant Alberta any authority to regulate or constrain oil and gas activities through the Brazeau Agreement; (
b) Given the absence of a legislative grant of authority for the regulation of oil and gas activities in The Brazeau River Development Act , the Brazeau Agreement cannot ground a right to contractual or equitable relief that would interfere with the Legislature's jurisdiction to regulate oil and gas activities, including hydraulic fracturing, and the statutory mandate delegated to the AER through the Responsible Energy Development Act, among other legislation; (
c) The Brazeau Agreement must be interpreted in accordance with these limitations on the authority granted to Alberta to enter into the Brazeau Agreement, which formed part of the factual matrix existing at the time it was concluded, to exclude the availability of the prohibition by declaration that TransAlta is seeking. [ 10 ] By focusing its participation on these issues of law, Cenovus seeks to address concerns regarding delay, prejudice to other parties, widening of the lis between the parties and politicization of the court proceedings.
At the same time, it argues, such participation is necessary to protect Cenovus from being adversely affected by the outcome and will bring useful and necessary perspective beyond that presented by TransAlta and Alberta. [ 11 ] Alberta supports the Cenovus application. It says that as a matter of fairness Cenovus should have the opportunity to present its position on these legal issues, and that Cenovus can do so without simply duplicating Alberta’s arguments.
Alberta also cautions that between now and the end of trial the positions of the parties may evolve, such that current similarities between Alberta and Cenovus may not continue. [ 12 ] TransAlta argues that Cenovus mischaracterizes the subject matter of the civil action. It says that the matter before the Court is whether Alberta has breached the Brazeau Agreement. If a declaration to that effect is made, Alberta will need to make a policy decision regarding next steps. Some of the options available to Alberta would have no effect on oil and gas producers such as Cenovus.
It is therefore unnecessary and inappropriate for Cenovus to participate in the action, as it is not directly affected. TransAlta also says that the legal arguments produced by Cenovus have already been advanced in Alberta’s Statement of Defence and can ably be made by Alberta at trial without assistance from Cenovus. III. Assessment A. Subject Matter [ 13 ] The TransAlta Statement of Claim alleges that Alberta breached the Brazeau Agreement by granting mineral leases in or under or adjacent to the Brazeau Agreement.
Such leases cannot be granted except on such terms that will not restrict or in any way interfere with the construction or operation of, or imperil the safety of the Brazeau Storage and Power Development (“the Development”). [ 14 ] TransAlta claims that Alberta has breached this promise by failing to restrict or prevent oil and gas activity in a manner that
ensures such activity will not restrict or in any way interfere with the construction of the operation of or imperil the safety of the Development.
Specifically, TransAlta says that Alberta failed to implement adequate policies or regulations relating to hydraulic fracturing of operations within a five kilometer “Restricted Area” adjacent to the development. [ 15 ] Paragraph 73 of the Statement of Claim alleges that “In breach of the Brazeau Agreement, and despite its many assurances to TransAlta, the Province has not developed, implemented, or enacted any clear policy directives that will protect the Brazeau Power and Storage Development for “unacceptable” risks posed by hydraulic fracturing in close proximity to the facility. [ 16 ] Paragraph 81 pleads that: 81.
Determination of the questions at issue in this proceeding will significantly affect the Parties' rights. They go to the core of how the provisions of the Brazeau Agreement are to be properly interpreted and to the scope of TransAlta's rights and the Province's obligations, which in turn will directly affect rights of the Parties under the Brazeau Agreement now and for decades to come. It is therefore appropriate – and necessary – for this Honourable Court to grant declaratory relief. [ 17 ] The remedies sought by TransAlta are set out in paragraphs 83-86: 83.
A declaration that it is a breach of the Brazeau Agreement for the Province to grant, lease, or make any other disposition of the mineral rights, or any interest therein, in the Restricted Area that has or will have the effect of restricting or in any way interfering with the operation of, or that imperils the safety of, the Brazeau Storage and Power Development. 84.
A declaration that it is a breach of the Brazeau Agreement for the Province to grant the right to explore for and produce hydrocarbons in the Restricted Area without prohibiting the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques within that Restricted Area. 85. A declaration that the Province is required to indemnify TransAlta for:
a) Any and all costs associated with increased monitoring, mitigation and modifications or upgrades to the Brazeau Storage and Power Development that are required to address the risks of increased seismic activity posed by the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques in the Restricted Area.
b) Any loss of use or reduced generation capacity of the Brazeau Storage and Power Development resulting from or caused by the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques in the Restricted Area, including any requirements to reduce water levels or change the way in which TransAlta is required or permitted to operate, manage, maintain, and make use of the Brazeau Storage and Power Development.
c) Any damage to the Brazeau Storage and Power Development caused or contributed to by the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques in the Restricted Area.
d) Any and all amounts payable by TransAlta to any third parties as a result of damage to, failure of, or implementing mitigation and making necessary modifications to the Brazeau Storage and Power Development or any part thereof. 86. Damages including but not limited to the losses, damages, and costs TransAlta may suffer or incur in connection with the above. [ 18 ] Alberta denies that it has breached the Brazeau Agreement.
It contends that the regulation of oil and gas exploration and production activities is entrusted to the Alberta Energy Regulator, which has and can be expected to continue to ensure that such operations will be undertaken in a safe and responsible manner, and further that specific actions have been taken to regulate hydraulic fracturing in the vicinity of the Brazeau Development. [ 19 ] The breach of contract claim advanced by TransAlta is made against Alberta alone.
The determination of the objective intentions of Alberta and TransAlta’s contractual predecessor in entering into the 1960 agreement will present challenges at trial, but such challenges are not insurmountable. They also do not directly engage the interests of third parties such as Cenovus. [ 20 ] The breach of contract claim extends beyond a mere declaration of rights and obligations, however.
It also asserts that the Province has breached its contractual duty by failing to satisfactorily regulate hydraulic fracturing activities in the vicinity of the Brazeau Development and in entering into oil and gas leases in the area without due regard for the Province’s obligations under the Brazeau Agreement. [ 21 ] While TransAlta and Alberta are the only parties to the Brazeau Agreement, and Alberta would be solely liable for the alleged breach, the breach alleged by TransAlta (a failure to regulate oil and gas production activities by third parties in a particular fashion) has a broader dimension.
The inescapable corollary of that allegation is that Alberta is obliged as a matter of contract to alter the way that oil and gas production is regulated in the vicinity of the Brazeau Development. B. Interest of Cenovus [ 22 ] Cenovus seeks to intervene in the Action to preserve its opportunity to recover oil and gas under mineral leases granted by the Crown to Cenovus and its predecessors.
Cenovus had identified 480 potential drilling locations within a ten-kilometer radius of the Brazeau Development, half of which are within the five-kilometer radius (referred to the in Statement of Claim as the “Restricted Area”) of concern to TransAlta. [ 23 ] TransAlta argues that Cenovus is not directly affected by the Action. It says that if granted, the declaratory relief sought would not bind the Crown to any particular course of action. Rather, it would result in the Crown reassessing its obligations in light of the Court’s decision and determining a path forward.
That could include a revised policy relating to hydraulic fracturing; reimbursing TransAlta for the cost of structural upgrading to the Brazeau Development components; providing a specific indemnification to TransAlta for the cost of future impacts; or some combination thereof.
[ 24 ] The scope of declaratory relief in this Action, if any, would be affected by the Court’s findings as to the obligations under the Agreement and Alberta’s performance of its obligations. Although those remain to be determined it can safely be said that if the Court agrees that the Agreement compelled (and compels) Alberta to prohibit hydraulic fracturing with five kilometers of the Brazeau Development, regardless of the depth of the formation being fractured, Cenovus will be directly affected.
Although declaratory in nature, it is expected that the Crown will comply with its obligations as articulated by the Court, if possible. [ 25 ] This Action therefore places Cenovus at financial risk, just as hydraulic fracturing in the vicinity of the Brazeau Development places TransAlta at financial risk of needing to voluntarily invest in structural modifications at its facility to mitigate the risks created, or being ordered to do so. C.
Is Participation by Cenovus Necessary and Helpful? [ 26 ] To grant intervenor status, the Court must be satisfied that the proposed intervenor can make a useful contribution to the proceeding and will not unduly delay or widen the litigation between the parties. An important consideration is whether arguments proposed cannot adequately be made by one of the parties to the cation. [ 27 ] I generally agree with TransAlta that Cenovus’s arguments regarding the unavailability of a declaration prohibiting hydraulic fracturing can be advanced by Alberta.
I do not consider, however, that participation by Cenovus would be an exercise in providing “second counsel” to Alberta nor that its evidence would be duplicative and unhelpful. [ 28 ] The evidence regarding the scope of oil and gas investment in the area as set out in the Affidavit of Mr. White provides useful background regarding the circumstances in which Alberta’s obligations under s.6(1) of the Brazeau Agreement have (or have not) been performed, from the perspective of the major producer in the area and has been subject to questioning by TransAlta.
Cenovus does not seek to adduce additional evidence. [ 29 ] As for argument, no matter how efficiently the trial of this action is conducted, important and perhaps novel questions of law will need to be addressed. While not constitutional in nature, those questions will have a clear public dimension.
Argument from Cenovus would bring a different perspective to those questions, beyond that provided by Alberta. [ 30 ] The argument of Cenovus regarding the interrelationship of the Brazeau River Development Act ; the Brazeau Agreement and the Responsible Development Act (and its predecessors) may duplicate one another. If they do, TransAlta will have no need to reply those arguments separately. If they do not, the merits of Cenovus’ position can, and I am sure will be capably responded to by TransAlta. This can be accommodated without unduly prolonging or complicating the trial.
If necessary, a direction will be made at trial regarding the sequencing of written argument, and page limits, to ensure efficiency of process in keeping with Cenovus’ subordinate status in the Action. [ 31 ] The request by Cenovus to be allowed oral argument is not granted at this time, but may be addressed at the conclusion of trial. IV.
Conclusion [ 32 ] I am satisfied that Cenovus would be directly affected by at least one of the declarations sought by TransAlta – that Alberta has breached its contractual obligation to TransAlta by not restricting or prohibiting hydraulic fracturing within five kilometers of the Brazeau Development. An intervention by Cenovus can assist the Court by providing useful context for evaluation of Alberta’s obligations under the Brazeau Agreement, and performance of such obligations, and is necessary to properly decide the issues before the Court.
The risk of duplication, undue prolonging or widening of the litigation between the parties can be accommodated through restrictions on participation at trial. TransAlta will not therefore be prejudiced by the participation of Cenovus. [ 33 ] On that basis, and with such restrictions in mind, the application is granted. Heard on the 23rd day of May, 2023. Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 10 th day of August, 2023. R.A. Neufeld J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Laura K. Estep and David P. Konkin for Cenovus Brad Nattrass
for His Majesty the King M.J. Donaldson, KC and Shannon K. Hayes for TransAlta Corporation
Loading document…