Worbeck v G.E.F. Seniors Housing, 2023 ABKB 516
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Worbeck v G.E.F. Seniors Housing, 2023 ABKB 516 Date: 20230911 Docket: 2203 12196 Registry: Edmonton Between: Henry Orest Worbeck Plaintiff - and - G.E.F. Seniors Housing Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of Associate Chief Justice K.G. Nielsen _______________________________________________________ I. Introduction [ 1 ] On August 10, 2022, Henry Orest Worbeck (Mr. Worbeck) filed a handwritten Statement of Claim naming the GEF Seniors Housing (GEF) as the Defendant ( Lawsuit ). Mr.
Worbeck is a tenant in the Bethany Senior Citizens Home in Edmonton Alberta. GEF operates that facility. Mr. Worbeck is a self-represented litigant (SRL). [ 2 ] Mr. Worbeck’s Statement of Claim is difficult to read and understand. When GEF filed its Statement of Defence on August 29, 2022, GEF summarized Mr. Worbeck’s allegation of GEF’s misconduct as:
1) payment of rent by cheque was refused; 2) keys were removed from a “lock box” without permission; 3) Mr. Worbeck was forced to pay for snow and ice removal, or had to do so personally; 4) window cleaners damaged Mr. Worbeck’s unit; and 5) Mr. Worbeck was in a contract to provide services to GEF. [ 3 ] Mr. Worbeck seeks damages of $175,000. GEF denies it is liable. [ 4 ] No litigation steps have been taken since the Statement of Defence was filed. However, that does not mean nothing else has occurred. Starting in 2022 and continuing to the present, Mr.
Worbeck has very frequently, sometimes several times a day, either by Canada Post mail, or in person, delivered envelopes to the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. Sometimes these envelopes are directed to a specific person, such as a named Clerk of the Court, or to myself. Other times envelopes are simply titled “To Court of Queen’s Bench ... FOR ALL JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS TO READ + LEARN”. [ 5 ] Since commencing the Lawsuit , Mr. Worbeck has submitted at least 124 envelopes 16 of those envelopes have been delivered in the last three weeks. The contents of these envelopes are both varied yet very similar.
None take the form of a document that is consistent with or that complies to the Alberta Rules of Court , Alta Reg 124/2010 . Instead, the envelopes contain one or more pages covered with Mr. Worbeck’s handwriting. Sometimes those pages are very large and folded multiple times.
Other times the pages also include in addition to the handwriting: • photographs of building interiors and exteriors, or the grounds of those buildings; • scanned images of snack food packaging; • correspondence, notices, bulletins, and administrative documents from GEF; • notices that were apparently posted in the Bethany Senior Citizens Home that Mr. Worbeck appears to have removed and annotated; and • pages from calendars of a business that Mr. Worbeck operated decades ago. Sometimes these envelopes also include a holiday greeting from Mr.
Worbeck, apparently directed to the Court and its personnel. [ 6 ] The stereotypic Worbeck document includes much handwriting, that tightly fills all spaces on the page. What appear to be initial text in a document is sometimes written in a larger size and in ordered lines, then additional passages are added in increasingly small print in remaining white spaces. Words and passages are underlined and circled repeatedly, sometimes also highlighted or coloured in multiple ways and patterns. The result is documents that are extremely difficult to read and interpret, on which essentially no empty space remains.
Appendix “A” illustrates an example of the materials that Mr. Warbeck is submitting to the Court, in this case a document that combines images and Mr. Worbeck’s handwriting. This example is one of the most legible and comprehensible documents submitted by Mr. Worbeck. [ 7 ] The content of Mr. Worbeck’s documents is very difficult to understand and interpret. Some of what he writes appears to describe specific complaints about GEF and its employees and independent contractors. Mr. Worbeck comments on specific aspects of the Bethany Senior Citizens Home facility. Mr.
Worbeck describes improper conduct by GEF staff, such as intoxication and a failure to discharge their duties. Other times Mr. Worbeck seems to express concerns about broader issues experienced by senior citizens. Some such claims are much more serious, for example that very large numbers of senior citizens are being killed in the Bethany Senior Citizens Home, and perhaps elsewhere. Mr. Worbeck calls this a “genocide”. I believe it is fair that, to the degree it is possible to evaluate Mr. Worbeck’s materials, at least some describe extraordinary and unlikely claims. [ 8 ] Many of Mr.
Worbeck’s documents received via irregular routes reference the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Action Number for the Lawsuit . Some of Mr. Worbeck’s documents also mention other Canadian and international Courts, and that Mr. Warbeck is, apparently, directing his correspondence to many governments and political personalities. [ 9 ] The large majority of Mr. Worbeck’s envelopes were submitted to the Court Clerks. I first received correspondence from Mr. Worbeck on June 8, 2023.
Though the June 8, 2023 documents were difficult to understand, I eventually determined that these materials were in some way related to Mr. Worbeck’s action against GEF. In response I wrote: I have received on June 8, 2023 a three-page handwritten document, a copy of which is enclosed. I believe the document relates to Worbeck v G.E.F. Seniors Housing, Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Action No. 2203 12196.
The Court of King’s Bench of Alberta is not able to take any steps in Action No. 2203 12196 unless you file a formal application or other document with the Court Clerks, as provided for in the Alberta Rules of Court, Alta Reg 124/2010 . If you require assistance, and cannot afford to hire a lawyer, you may wish to contact Edmonton Community Legal Centre for assistance, at (780) 702-1725, or Student Legal Services of Edmonton, at (780) 492-2226. [ 10 ] Mr. Worbeck then continued to deliver to the Court envelopes addressed to myself, that followed the same pattern. On July 19, 2023, I again wrote to Mr.
Worbeck to instruct him that my office would not respond further to his materials, but only to documents that comply with the Alberta Rules of Court . Mr. Worbeck has therefore been made aware that his materials are non-compliant with the Alberta Rules of Court , and will not be accepted or responded to by the Court. Mr. Worbeck’s delivery of envelopes has, nevertheless, continued.
II. Responding to Mr. Worbeck’s Irregular Documents [ 11 ] Mr. Worbeck’s correspondence provides no legal or functional benefit to Mr. Worbeck. To the extent his documents can be interpreted, these materials are not legitimate Court filings and, generally, there is little reason to believe Mr. Worbeck intends they would function that way. [ 12 ] Unfortunately, Mr. Worbeck’s materials create a substantial and non-beneficial cost to the Court and Court workers.
Sometimes his materials are voluminous, and the documents he submits to the Court are always extremely difficult to interpret. [ 13 ] The Supreme Court of Canada in Pintea v Johns , 2017 SCC 23 imposed a broad range of obligations on how Canadian judges and Court staff interact with SRLs, in response to what is perceived as disadvantages experienced by SRLs when faced with Court processes. As a consequence, the Rules and procedures for SRLs are “loosened” somewhat. This has meant that workers in this Court are required to give special attention to materials from an SRL such as Mr.
Worbeck. [ 14 ] Given the volume of Mr. Worbeck’s envelopes and their content, the consistent failure of Mr. Worbeck to raise legal issues in his irregular materials, and Mr. Worbeck never submitting documents that comply with the Alberta Rules of Court , I conclude some resource management steps are currently appropriate in response to the large volume of essentially irrelevant documents received from Mr. Worbeck. I therefore Order that: 1. When a Clerk, Judicial Assistant, Court Coordinator, or Justice of the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta receives an envelope from Mr.
Worbeck, they should examine the contents of that envelope; 2. If the contents of the envelope are not documents that conform to the formal requirements and structure set out in the Alberta Rules of Court , then those documents shall be discarded without further review; and 3. If the documents received do conform to the formal requirements and structure set out in the Alberta Rules of Court , then those documents should be treated following the usual processes of this Court. [ 15 ] Mr.
Worbeck will not suffer any legal disadvantage as a result of this approach, and his burden on Court resources will hopefully be minimized. Mr. Worbeck’s 124 envelopes received to date have been reviewed, and, on that basis, there is no plausible reason to expect any further irregular material received from Mr. Worbeck will warrant a Court legal response. III. The Lawsuit [ 16 ] Mr.
Worbeck’s conduct of the Lawsuit also has implications for whether that action should or should not continue. r 3.68 of the Alberta Rules of Court provides jurisdiction for this Court to terminate certain legal processes: 3.68(1) If the circumstances warrant and a condition under subrule (2) applies, the Court may order one or more of the following: (
a) that all or any part of a claim or defence be struck out; ...
(2) The conditions for the order are one or more of the following: ... (
c) a commencement document or pleading is frivolous, irrelevant or improper; (
d) a commencement document or pleading constitutes an abuse of process; [ 17 ] The categories identified in r 3.68(2)(c-
d) of the Alberta Rules of Court use labels that can be captured under a single category - abusive litigation - litigation that misuses the Court: Unrau v National Dental Examining Board , 2019 ABQB 283 at paras 64-85 ( Unrau #2 ).
Often, a lawsuit struck out pursuant to r 3.68 of the Alberta Rules of Court is a proceeding that is abusive because the originating document exhibits one or more fatal defects, surveyed in Unrau #2 . [ 18 ] However, the jurisdiction to terminate abusive litigation includes where at first there was an apparently good cause of action: Dykun v Odinshaw , 2000 ABQB 548 at para 42 , affirmed 2001 ABCA 204 , leave to appeal to SCC refused, 28784 (31 January 2002); Del Bianco v 935074 Alberta Ltd , 2007 ABQB 150 at para 39 ; Chutskoff v Bonora , 2014 ABQB 389 at paras 88 , 94, aff’d 2014 ABCA 444 .
The way a proceeding is conducted may make that an abusive proceeding, e.g., Paraniuk v Pierce , 2018 ABQB 1015 at paras 75- 99 . The Lawsuit appears to have become an abusive proceeding. Since he filed the Statement of Claim, Mr. Worbeck has not taken any apparent steps to pursue the Lawsuit that comply with the Alberta Rules of Court . Instead, Mr.
Worbeck has submitted to the Court a very large volume of materials that often bear the Action No. of the Lawsuit , but that: 1) do not conform with the Alberta Rules of Court ; 2) more broadly, do not advance the Lawsuit in any way; 3) include allegations and claims that are much broader than the grounds of the Lawsuit ;
4) to the degree that Mr. Worbeck’s allegations in the documents can be evaluated, sometimes make extraordinary claims without evidence; and 5) are not directed to the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta, but towards a much broader national and international court and political context. This pattern matches abusive litigation criteria reviewed in Unrau #2 . [ 19 ] As I have previously indicated, Mr. Worbeck’s activities also cause unnecessary and unproductive diversion of Court resources that otherwise would be directed to meritorious litigation. Given these observations, I request that Mr.
Worbeck by October 13, 2023 submit to my office written argument and/or affidavit evidence to establish that the Lawsuit has a reasonable basis and should not be struck out pursuant to r 3.68 of the Alberta Rules of Court as an abusive proceeding. I caution Mr. Worbeck that his materials should be compliant with the Alberta Rules of Court , and that if Mr. Worbeck submits materials that do not take that formal structure, then his documents will be discarded. IV. Conclusion [ 20 ] The Court shall prepare the Order giving effect to this Memorandum of Decision. Mr.
Worbeck’s approval of that Order is dispensed with, pursuant to the Alberta Rules of Court . A copy of this Memorandum of Decision and corresponding Order shall be delivered to counsel for GEF. [ 21 ] Mindful of the Pintea v Johns instruction that Canadian judges shall provide information on litigation alternatives to persons not represented by lawyers, if Mr. Worbeck seeks to challenge steps imposed in this Memorandum of Decision, then the appropriate procedure is an appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta. [ 22 ] I very strongly recommend to Mr.
Worbeck that he seek legal assistance when replying to this Memorandum of Decision. Mr. Worbeck should speak to a lawyer or a public legal assistance resource such as Legal Aid Alberta, the Edmonton Community Legal Centre, or Student Legal Services of Edmonton. This assistance will very strongly benefit Mr. Worbeck in relation to the Lawsuit . Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 11 th day of September, 2023. K.G. Nielsen A.C.J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Henry Orest Worbeck Self-represented Litigant James Work for the Defendant GEF Senior’s Housing Appendix “A” – Example Worbeck Document
Loading document…