Summer Village of South View - v. -, 2023 ABKB 662
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Summer Village of South View v Woslyng, 2023 ABKB 662 Between: Summer Village of South View - and - James Woslyng Date: Sept 19, 2023 Docket: 2203 09079 Registry: Edmonton Applicant Respondent _______________________________________________________ Endorsement of the Honourable Justice C.L. Arcand-Kootenay _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Mr.
Woslyng, the Respondent, was elected to Council for the Summer Village (the “Summer Village”) of South View, the Applicant, on July 10, 2021. [ 2 ] The Chief Administrator of the Summer Village was advised in January 2022, that Mr. Woslyng had arrears of property taxes owing to the Municipality that had accrued since April 6, 2020. Page: 2 [ 3 ] I am asked to decide whether Mr. Woslyng is disqualified from his seat on Council for property tax arrears pursuant to s 175 of the Municipal Government Act ( “MGA”), RSA 2000, c M-26 . [ 4 ] I am also asked to decide the issue of collateral attacks.
Specifically, whether Mr. Woslyng can collaterally attack the Order to Remedy and, the Enforcement Order, by way of a defence to this Action. FACTS [5] Mr. Woslyng was elected as a municipal councillor for the Summer Village in the 2021 municipal election. The nomination day was June 12, 2021, and the election day was July 10, 2021. [ 6 ] Mr. Woslyng owns a parcel of land in the Summer Village with the legal description of Plan 1720210, Block 1, Lot 12A (the “Property”). [ 7 ] 2011.
There has been a long history of development related problems with the Property since [ 8 ] The development related matter at issue in this case in an Order to Remedy which was issued by the Summer Village’s Development Office on September 4, 2019 (the “Order to Remedy”). The Order to Remedy stated that the exterior of the building on the Property was not completed (as required by a prior development approval) and stated that the exterior of the building was to be completed by September 30, 2019. It also stated that Mr. Woslyng could seek review of the Order to Remedy by Council. [ 9 ] Mr.
Woslyng requested a review of the Order to Remedy by Council on September 17, 2019, by letter. Mr. Woslyng attended a Council meeting on October 23, 2019, for this review, and the matter was deferred to a later meeting. Mr.
Woslyng attended the subsequent Council meeting on November 20, 2019, at which time Council gave him a time extension for complying with the Order to Remedy until March 1, 2020, to finish the exterior of his building. [ 10 ] No application for appeal or judicial review of Council’s decision of November 20, 2019, was served on the Summer Village. [ 11 ] In March of 2020, the Summer Village’s Development Officer advised the CAO that the Property remained non-compliant in that the exterior was still not completed.
The Summer Village CAO then instructed legal counsel to commence enforcement proceedings. [ 12 ] A demand letter was sent to Mr. Woslyng by legal counsel on March 20, 2020, demanding compliance. Within this letter, it stated as follows: The expenses and costs of action taken by the Summer Village to enforce this Enforcement Order will be amounts owing to the municipality and may be added to the tax roll.
The costs could be significant. [ 13 ] The Enforcement Order mentioned in the Demand Letter was regarding the Order to Remedy Enforcement activities taken by the Summer Village’s legal counsel included the demand letter and registration of a caveat against title to the Property. Page: 3 [ 14 ] Legal enforcement costs of $610.00 were added to Mr. Woslyng’s property tax roll on April 6, 2020. Legal costs of $484.58 were added to the tax roll on June 16, 2020. Penalties with respect to unpaid taxes thereafter totalling $703.84, were added to the tax roll between January 5, 2021, and January 1, 2022.
[ 15 ] At the time of his election to Council, Mr. Woslyng was in arrears of the legal enforcement costs that were added to his Property tax roll on April 6, 2020. [ 16 ] On June 23, 2020, Mr. Woslyng was advised by Summer Village staff, in writing, that the legal enforcement costs were added to his tax roll. A statement of his current tax account was also provided at that time. This statement of account included the legal costs. [ 17 ] The addition of enforcement costs for an Order to Remedy is expressly authorized by s 553(1)(
c) of the MGA. [ 18 ] Mr. Woslyng attended a Council meeting on March 17, 2021, and asked that the caveat be removed from his title and that the costs of enforcement be removed from his tax roll. Council deferred their decision on this to a subsequent meeting. [ 19 ] At the July 21, 2021, Council meeting, by which time Mr. Woslyng was an elected Councillor, Council denied Mr. Woslyng’s request to discharge the caveat or reverse the enforcement costs.
The Summer Village was not served with any notice of application for judicial review of that decision. [ 20 ] It was identified by the Summer Village in January of 2022 that Mr. Woslyng had an outstanding property tax balance of $1,798.41. [ 21 ] On March 4, 2022, the Summer Village CAO wrote to Mr. Woslyng to advise him that his property taxes were in arrears and to confirm that his eligibility as a councillor would be on the March 16, 2022 Meeting Agenda. [ 22 ] At the March 16, 2022, Meeting, the issue was discussed. Mr. Woslyng asked for copies of legal counsel invoices for the enforcement issues.
He also asked that the issue be deferred to the April 20, 2022 Meeting. The deferral was granted, and instructions were given to provide copies of the invoices. The (redacted) invoices were provided. [ 23 ] The issue was on the Agenda for the April 20, 2022 Council Meeting. A motion was passed by (the remainder of) Council that Mr. Woslyng was disqualified from Council and directing the CAO to instruct legal counsel to apply to the Court for an Order declaring Mr. Woslyng as disqualified. ANALYSIS OF FACTS AND LAW [24] Mr.
Woslyng paid his property taxes from May 2003 to January 2022 in total, apart from two charges on his tax statement of account, respectively $610.00 and $484.58, for legal costs. [ 25 ] Ms. Wendy Wildman stated in her Affidavit sworn on May 18, 2022, that Mr. Woslyng has repeatedly disputed the validity of these charges on his tax roll and stated that he has not paid them because he believes them to be invalid [ 26 ] Page: 4
Section 545 of the MGA provides as follows: 545(1) If a designated officer finds that a person in contravening this or any other enactment that the municipality is authorized to enforce or a bylaw, the designated officer may, by written order, require the person responsible for the contravention to remedy it if the circumstances require.
(2) The order may (
a) Direct the person to stop doing something, or to change the way in which the person is doing it; (
b) Direct a person to take any action or measure necessary to remedy the contravention of the enactment or bylaw, including the removal or demolition of a structure that has been erected or placed in contravention of a bylaw, and, if necessary, to prevent a re- occurrence of the contravention; (
c) State a time within which the person must comply with the directions; (
d) State that if the person does not comply with the directions within a specified time, the municipality will take the action or measure at the expense of the person. [ 27 ]
Section 546.1(1) of the MGA provides that a municipality may register a caveat against title in respect of an order issued under s 545. s 546.1(1) A municipality may register a caveat under the Land Titles Act in respect of an order made under
section 545 or 546 dealing with a dangerous structure, excavation or hole or unsightly property against the certificate of title for the land that is the subject of the order. [ 28 ] There is an appeal process included in the MGA for orders issues under s 545. Firstly, a review by the Municipal Council may be requested under s 547(1). On a review, the council may confirm, vary, substitute, or cancel the order.
Secondly, an appeal to the court may be lodged under s 548(1) of the MGA where the procedures required by the MGA are not followed or the decision is patently unreasonable. [ 29 ] The MGA contains provisions confirming municipalities may take actions to remedy contraventions. The former s 549(1) of the MGA in force at the relevant time provides as follows Municipality remedying contraventions s 549(3) The expenses and costs of an action or measure taken by a municipality under this
section are an amount owing to the municipality by the person who contravened the enactment or bylaw. [ 30 ] The former s 553(1) of the MGA in force at the relevant time expressly authorizes that a council may add expenses and costs of enforcement of Orders to Remedy to a property tax roll as follows: Page: 5
Adding amounts to a tax roll: s 553(1) A Council may add the following amounts to the tax roll of a parcel of land: ... (
c) unpaid expenses and costs referred to in s 549(3), if the parcel’s owner contravened the enactment or bylaw and the contravention occurred on all or part of the parcel; ...
(2) Subject to s 659, when an amount is added to the tax roll of a parcel of land under subsection (1), the amount (
a) is deemed for all purposes to be a tax imposed under Division 2 of
Part 10 from the date it was added to the tax roll, and (
b) forms a special lien against the parcel of land in favor of the municipality from the date it was added to the tax roll. [ 31 ] The Summer Village’s expenses and costs take to remedy a contravention of the MGA and/or a bylaw are an amount owing to the municipality in accordance with s 549 of the MGA. The Summer Village’s legal expenses are part of such “expenses and costs.” All such amounts owing are specifically authorized to be added to the tax roll by s 553(1)(
c) if the parcel’s owner contravened the enactment or bylaw and the contravention occurred on all or part of the parcel. This is what occurred in the matter before me. The tax roll printout from the Municipality’s records dated January 5, 2022, confirmed that Mr. Woslyng had arrears of property taxes in the amount of $1,798.41. Mr. Woslyng did not pay the following amounts on his tax roll:
a) b)
c) Legal enforcement costs in the amount of $610.00 from April 6, 2020; Legal enforcement costs in the amount $484.58 from June 16, 2020; Penalty of $197.02 applied on January 5, 2021 (arising from non-payment of the above amounts);
d) Penalty of $25.83 applied July 1, 2021;
e) Penalty of $51.66 applied August 3, 2021;
f) Penalty of $77.50 applied September 1, 2021;
g) Penalty of $77.50 applied October 1, 2021; and
h) Penalty of $274.33 applied January 1, 2022. [32] The Summer Village has the authority to apply penalties to unpaid taxes pursuant to its Bylaw 226-2021, as follows: ... 1. Where any taxes levied for the current year remain unpaid after June 30th, these outstanding taxes are subject to a penalty thereon in the amount of Page: 6 2% on the first day of July, 4% on the first day of August, 6% on the first day of September, and 6% on the first day of October. 2.
Any taxes which are not paid on or before the 31st day of December of the current year, shall be deemed to be in arrears and shall be in each subsequent calendar year, subject to a penalty of 18% on the first day of January with respect to the amount of taxes so in arrears... [ 33 ] The legal enforcement costs were added to Mr. Woslyng’s tax roll on April 6, 2020, and June 16, 2020. He was notified in writing of the addition to his tax roll on June 23, 2020. [ 34 ] I find the legal enforcement costs that were added to Mr.
Woslyng’s tax roll were properly added pursuant to the provisions of the MGA and the Summer Village’s Bylaws. [ 35 ] Section 174(1)(
b) of the MGA provides that a municipal councillor is disqualified from council if such councillor ceases to be eligible as a candidate under the Local Authorities Election Act, RSA 2000, CL-21 (the “LAEA”). [ 36 ] Pursuant to s 22(1)(
c) and 22(1)(
d) of the LAEA, a person is not eligible to be nominated as a candidate in any election under the LAEA, if on nomination day, the person is indebted to the municipality of which the person is an elector for taxes in default exceeding $50, excluding from the amount any indebtedness for current taxes, and any indebtedness for arrears of taxes for which the person has entered into a consolidation agreement with the municipality, unless the person is in default in the payment of money due under the agreement, or the person is indebted to the local jurisdiction for which the election is to be held for any debt exceeding $500 and in default for more than 90 days. [ 37 ] As Mr.
Woslyng was in arrears of property taxes owing to the Municipality, the Summer Village, in the amount of $1,798.41 on both nomination day, June 12, 2021, and indeed on election day, July 10, 2021, Mr. Woslyng is disqualified from Council pursuant to the LAEA. [ 38 ] Pursuant to s 175(1) of the MGA, a councillor that is disqualified must resign immediately. However, Mr.
Woslyng has not resigned and has refused to resign from Council. [ 39 ] Pursuant to s 175(2) of the MGA, if the councillor who is disqualified from council does not resign immediately, the council may apply to a Judge of the Court of King’s Bench for an order declaring the person to be disqualified from council. [ 40 ] Section 174(4) of the MGA confirms that a councillor who is disqualified under that
section is eligible to be elected in the next general election in the municipality if the person is eligible for nomination under LAEA. As such, Mr. Woslyng is ineligible to run in any by-election to fill a vacant position created by his disqualification because such by-election is not a “general election.” DECISION: [41] I declare that Mr. Woslyng is disqualified from Council. I also find that Mr. Woslyng is not eligible to run as a candidate in any by-election to fill any vacant council position that would be created by granting such an order.
Page: 7 [ 42 ] I also find that as Mr. Woslyng did not avail himself to further appeal or application for judicial review of the decision of the Summer Village of November 20, 2019, he is not permitted to collaterally attack the Order to Remedy by way of defence to his application. COSTS: [43] The parties may appear before me to speak to the matter of costs. Heard on the 11 th day of May, 2023. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 19 th day of September, 2023. C.L. Arcand-Kootenay J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Michelle Gallagher for the Applicant Aizlynn Regan for the Respondent
Loading document…