R v Clifford, 2023 ABKB 67
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: R v Clifford, 2023 ABKB 67 Date: 20230203 Docket: 171225923Q1 Registry: Edmonton Between: His Majesty The King - and - Robert Dean Clifford _______________________________________________________ Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Justice N.E. Devlin _______________________________________________________ 1. Overview [1] On the night of February 23, 2017, Robert Clifford stabbed his estranged wife Nichole to death in the basement of what hadbeen there family home.
I convicted him of second-degree murder for this crime and now must impose a fit and proportional sentence. [2] The mandatory punishment for second-degree murder is life imprisonment. Additionally, however, the Court must set theminimum period of incarceration before Mr. Clifford is eligible to apply for parole. That term is not to be less than 10 years and cannotexceed 25 years. This number does not determine when Mr. Clifford will be conditionally released back into the community.
Rather, hewill be under supervision and jurisdiction of the Correctional Service of Canada for life, and it is the Parole Board who must decidewhen and if it is safe for his reintegration into society to begin. The number I set today determines only when Mr. Clifford may first askthe Parole Board to consider his case. 2. The guiding principles [3] The factors governing this Court’s determination of parole eligibility are set out in
section 745.4 of the Criminal Code. Theyinclude the nature of the offence, the circumstances surrounding its commission, and the character of the accused. The correct approachto applying these factors was laid out in the Supreme Court’s leading decision of R v Shropshire, (SCC), 1995 4 SCR227. [4] The determination of parole ineligibility is guided by the same principles applicable to sentencing generally, as enumeratedin
section 718 of the Criminal Code. The minimum 10-year ineligibility is the starting point, but an increase from it does not requirespecial or unusual circumstances and need not be used sparingly: Shropshire at paras 26-31. [5] In R v Ryan, 2015 ABCA 286 at para 57, Justice Picard laid out a series of factors potentially impacting ineligibility forsecond-degree murder.
I expressly apply and consider those factors, which include gratuitous violence, targeting/luring of the victim,murder committed while on bail or probation, abuse of trust, obstructing justice in service of the murder or cover-up, and murdercommitted in the course of committing other crimes. Also in Ryan, Justice Wakeling outlines a parallel but also helpful approach to the745.4 task.
An exhaustive and principled review of the relevant jurisprudence led him to characterize the murder of an intimate partner,in circumstances such as the present case, being in a more serious category of offence, warranting parole ineligibility in the 16-to-20-year
range. 3. Evidence on Sentence [ 6 ] The Court received limited evidence on sentence. No pre-sentencing reports regarding Mr. Clifford were requested or prepared. (
i) Victim Impact Statements [ 7 ] This Court received 19 victim impact statements from the family and friends of Nichole who were harmed by this crime. These were eloquent, impassioned, sincere, and devastating. I want each person who shared their experience with the Court to know that your words have been heard and your hurt has been seen. [ 8 ] Beyond the pain and grief that the people who loved Nichole have felt since her death, the resonant theme of in the victim impact statements is the loss of the fundamental sense of safety in life that these people have suffered.
The basic order, where good people go about their daily lives, go to school, do their work, see and spend time with their friends, and live with their loved ones in a sense of calm and safety has been shattered by this crime. The fact that this is true in every case where a member of our society is taken in a violent and terrible way does not diminish the significance of the impact for the victims of this crime. [ 9 ] A few of these impacts bare specific mention. For Nichole’s mother, life has changed fundamentally.
She has lost her retirement and now works, under severe financial pressure, to keep the family going and raise her grandchildren. Her grief has damaged her emotionally and physically as well, having a daily impact. [ 10 ] She is exhausted because she does not sleep, she lives in fear, with safety plans and security measures in every facet of her life.
She wrote, “some days the pain of losing my daughter is so overwhelming it honestly feels like you will not make it out alive by the end of each day with a broken heart.” [ 11 ] Nichole’s father described with grace the endless pain he feels and the impact on his family’s financial situation, something we often forget about in crimes such as this. Someone has to be there to pick up the pieces, both emotionally and financially, and the McKeiths are doing that, to their great credit. [ 12 ] Nichole’s friends, especially those closest to these events, have borne a heavy toll.
Other friends highlighted the impact of the murder on their children, who were friends of the victim’s children. They watched a violent loss unfold and felt the impact on their lives and the lives of their peers, all at far too young an age. As Nichole’s friend Ashley wrote, “this is not just an isolated incident. This tore through every single person who knew and loved Nichole. The unthinkable happened and you start to think, what could happen next?” [ 13 ] Nichole’s friend Jill paid tribute to her in words warranting public acknowledgement by this Court.
She wrote, “Nichole had a rare instinctive gift of making everyone feel like they were important, no matter their situation in life. She was a beautiful person, she deserved better.” [ 14 ] The Clifford’s young son drew picture of himself and his mother. He said, “why would you do that to your wife? If she was still alive you should say you’re sorry you big jerk.” All the legal phrases I will utter today cannot rival the pure simple truth of this young man’s words. More concerningly, he also said, “I feel safer he’s going away and can’t get out.
I was afraid if he gets out he would yell at me.” This is a potent indicator that the anger Mr. Clifford demonstrated in this crime is not a new or passing feature. [ 15 ] His daughter wrote pained but also selfless words, “I feel unsafe all the time. I don’t like being alone. Other people also make me feel unsafe. I also worry about my family and friends.” This is the absolute antithesis of the psychological legacy a parent owes their child. (ii) Criminal Record of the accused [ 16 ] Mr. Clifford was convicted of Mischief in 2015 and received a discharge with probation.
He has also pled guilty to the breaches of release he was charged with at the end of January 2017. He effectively has no criminal record for the purposes of sentencing. 4. Position of the parties [ 17 ] This case is somewhat unusual, in that the Crown and defence have come forward with a joint submission that a 16-year period of parole ineligibility be imposed.
Like all joint submissions, this should be given significant deference and departed from only where the administration of justice requires, and then only after proper process: Baptiste c R , 2021 QCCA 1064 at paras 70-74 . [ 18 ] Coming after a contested trial, however, at which a full set of factual findings were made upon the Crown being put to its burden of proof, this joint submission is different in nature than, and does not attract the same heightened level of deference as, a “true” joint submission on a guilty plea: Blondeau c R, 2018 QCCA 1250 , para 60 . [ 19 ] There is far less of a mutual compromise and expression of remorse on this event than with a joint submission on a plea of guilt.
Rather, this is primarily an expression that both counsel, as officers of the Court, have come to the same conclusion – informed by their unique understanding of the file – as to the correct sentence on the legal and factual matrix of the case. [ 20 ] While there is some mutually negotiated benefit to this joint submission, and the proper administration of justice requires the Court to pay it due heed, the Court may be less reluctant to depart from a joint submission in this circumstance to ensure that substantive justice, aligning with its findings, is done.
5. Analysis (iii) The nature of the offence and the circumstances surrounding its commission [ 21 ] The Cliffords were married in 2010 and had two children. They lived and worked in Wainwright, Alberta. Nichole was a support worker for developmentally challenged individuals and had taken on increasing management responsibilities with the social agency that employed her. Robert worked in the oilfield service sector. [ 22 ] The marriage had ceased to be a happy one and the couple separated shortly after New Year’s Day 2017. The separation was initiated by Nichole. She was done with the relationship. Mr.
Clifford was not. At the time of Nichole’s killing, Mr. Clifford was living in the spare room of a friend not far from the former matrimonial home. He repeatedly expressed a desire for the relationship to continue and had complained to friends that she was withholding the children from him. [ 23 ] In late January, Mr. Clifford was charged for harassment in respect of certain communications he sent to Nichole between January 11 and 27 th .
His release on those charges required him to refrain from contacting her and barred him from going to the house where she continued to reside with their children. [ 24 ] Just over a week after the initial charges were laid, Mr. Clifford was arrested for breaching the terms of his release by going to the house. The evidence at trial revealed that he had entered the home through a basement window and was found hiding under a bed. He was arrested and charged with breaking and entering and breach of recognizance, resulting in him being held in custody for just over a week.
He was released on bail and return to Wainwright. His bail conditions again included that he does not communicate with Nichole or go to the house. [ 25 ] Mr. Clifford persistently, even pathologically, breached these conditions. The evidence at trial demonstrated that he had covertly spent the majority of the 72-hour period preceding Nichole’s death at or very near the residence, in flagrant breach of a Court order issued to protect her. I find that he likely spent most of his time hiding in the basement as he had before. Despite being unaware of the extent of his intrusions, Nichole was plainly concerned by Mr.
Clifford behaviour, despite the lack of any overt acts of violence or threats. She largely avoided the residence during this period, staying primarily with friends of hers who lived nearby and had children of a similar age. [ 26 ] On the night of her death, Nichole returned home alone from those friends’ residence at just after 10 PM. She left her children with her friends, in the hopes of getting a good night’s sleep ahead of an important day at work. Her phone never left her zipped-up purse, which was found on the couch in the front room. She never replied to a good night text from a friend.
She never changed out of her clothing to go to bed. She was found stabbed to death at the bottom of the basement stairs the next morning. [ 27 ] At trial, I found as a fact that Mr. Clifford was inside the house when she returned home, a confrontation ensued, and he stabbed her to death with an ersatz weapon, being a two-edged object such as a pair of scissors. The medical evidence revealed 17 stab wounds to her chest and neck. At least two were fatal. Her hands were covered in blood and had extensive defensive bruising. Mr.
Clifford’s DNA was found on or under one of her fingernails as well as on a bloody belt which lay inches from her body. [ 28 ] The technical evidence demonstrated that Mr. Clifford left the residence approximately 40 minutes after Nichole came home. His actual movements following her death are unknown, but he surfaced at his parents’ farm in a nearby community the following day. [ 29 ] His cell phone and the murder weapon were never found. The Cliffords’ wedding album was found entangled in the unmade bed Mr. Clifford slept in at his friend’s house. [ 30 ] When questioned by the police, Mr.
Clifford told an elaborate lie regarding his whereabouts, centered on having been at his parents’ farm during the time of the murder. This was a lie initially propagated by his father when police called looking for Mr. Clifford on the day Nichole was discovered. Mr. Clifford contributed a wealth of false detail to the story he told to the investigating officers in an attempt to deflect suspicion from himself. [ 31 ] I found as a fact at trial that Mr. Clifford was not prepared to accept the end of his marriage and exhibited an obsessive, transgressive focus on Nichole after their separation.
His continual attendance at their residence, in the face of multiple conditions and orders that he not go there, demonstrated the intense and disordered thinking that led to this crime. [ 32 ] What he did to Nichole after their separation can only be described as a form of stalking behaviour. The evidence made it plain that this was a nightmare for Nichole. She sought and obtained what she believed to be the protection of the justice system. Tragically, this made no difference. [ 33 ] The killing itself was a savage, rage-fueled act of violence.
While the fatal wounds led Nichole to lose consciousness and pass away quickly, without prolonged suffering, the fatal encounter must have been terrifying for her. [ 34 ] Nichole’s murder has had a shattering impact on the lives of those closest to her. Most significantly this includes the Cliffords’ two children. By murdering their mother, Mr. Clifford orphaned them. While they have been taken in by loving relatives, their lives will forever be scarred by the knowledge that their father murdered their mother in their own home. (iv) Character of the offender [ 35 ] Mr.
Clifford was 36 years old at the time of the murder. He is now 41. He has no effectively criminal record and, from what little information I have through the trial process and submissions of counsel, has worked steadily, and supported his family. A former teacher of his, a longtime resident of the community, spoke of him in positive terms during the trial. He continues to enjoy the unflagging support of his mother who attended every day of these proceedings.
[36] Mr. Clifford declined to address the court on sentencing or to comment on the circumstances of the offence itself. [37] Throughout this record, there is only one clue as to why Mr. Clifford committed this crime. Although he testified only briefly,Mr. Clifford’s father revealed himself to be both controlling and filled with profound and irrational rage. While this explains little, andexcuses nothing, it is a factor that the correctional authorities should consider when assessing Mr. Clifford and providing rehabilitativeprogramming for him. (
v) Aggravating factors [38] There are four principal aggravating factors in this case. The killing was: (
i) the apex act of domestic abuse; (ii) brutal andcallous; (iii) the culmination of a period of stalking; (iv) caused permanent and intense harm to Mr. Clifford’s children, whose protectionwas his most sacred trust; and (
v) was committed while he was under, and in chronic breach of, a Court order to stay away from Nicholeand the house in the which murder was committed. These factors are interrelated and overlapping, and I am careful not to double-countthem, but a full denunciation of the wrongful conduct in this case requires that each of these features be individually denounced. a. Intimate partner violence [39] The single most aggravating fact in this case is that the victim of Mr. Clifford’s violence was his wife.
It is a fundamentaldictate and demand of human decency that people honour and protect their partner: R v Stone, (SCC), [1999] 2 SCR290 at para 240. In her thoughtful reasons in R v White, 2006 ABQB 909, Justice Moreau (as she then was) described a murder of thisnature as “the ultimate act of spousal abuse while occupying a position of trust”. [40] I agree with this characterization of the offence and that this sort of crime is “an extreme form of domestic violence and areprehensible abuse of power and control” against a female partner: R v Diep, 2005 ABQB 81 at para 5; R v Candeale, 2022 ABKA 605at para 124.
This elevates denunciation and deterrence as sentencing objectives: R v Shaw, 2019 ABCA 106 at para 30. [41] While domestic abuse self-evidently often takes place in the home environment, it is a further breach of trust that this act ofviolence took place in Nichole’s home, a place where she had every right to feel safe: R v Pierre, 2019 ONSC 1660 , 2019ONSC1660 at para 8. [42] In describing the severity and impact of spousal killings, I can do no better than adopt the words of Justice Feehan (as he thenwas) in R v Beglau, 2017 ABQB 133 at para 40, where he stated that: Murder of a spouse, including while separated, is one of the most horrendous forms of murder.
It destroys the institution of marriage,destroys relationships, destroys children and brings irreparable harm to the family, to the neighbourhood and to society. Nothing that thisCourt can do will address the anger, pain, loss and devastation that murder in a domestic situation causes. It breaches the fundamentalprinciples of respect for life and respect for the rule of law. This Court must denounce murder, particularly with respect to domesticsituations, express its revulsion for this crime, and take steps to deter others from taking the life of another human being.
All of thesematters have been taken into account in the Criminal Code in imposing a life sentence of imprisonment. They must also be taken intoaccount in determining the period of ineligibility for parole. [43] Regrettably, women in particular continue to be killed by those who should most closely protect them, their intimate partners,in tragic numbers. Statistics Canada records that between 2014 and 2019, there were 497 instances of intimate partner homicide, and –similar to intimate partner violence in general – 80% of the victims were women.[1] This is unacceptable and a shame on our society.
Inits compelling recent decision in R v Cunningham, 2023 ONCA 836 at paras 48-51, the Ontario Court of Appeal aptly observed that: The last two decades have seen an increase in society’s awareness of the prevalence of domestic violence and the evils itcreates….Parliament has responded to the societal problem with legislation both within and outside the criminal justice system. Within the criminal justice system, Parliament introduced Bill C-75 in 2019. A key aspect of the bill was a focus on intimate partnerviolence, which included several reforms targeting domestic violence.
The most significant changes were those made to sentencing,including the expansion of
section 718.2(a)(ii) of the Criminal Code, directing that the commission of an offensive involving abusiveand intimate partner must be considered an aggravating factor in sentencing. It is noteworthy that “intimate partner” includes current orformer spouses, common-law partners and dating partners. … Parliament also enacted
section 718.3(8) of the code, which provides discretion to the sentencing judge to impose a term of imprisonmenthigher than the maximum when the offence is committed in the context of an intimate partnership. Thus, the intention of Parliamentclearly supports enhanced penalties for perpetrators of domestic violence and denunciation and deterrence as the primary sentencingobjectives.
It also supports changes in sentencing ranges to reflect societal awareness and knowledge of the damage to society, as well asvictims, caused by domestic violence. [emphasis added] [44] Consistent with the decision in Cunningham, I am of the view that a proper contemporary contextual awareness of the harmsand severity of domestic violence require sentencing courts to sharpen their focus on denunciation when dealing with cases such as this:see R v French, 2017 ONCA 460 at para 31.
Our current social understanding, together with Parliament’s recent express directives,require sentencing courts to carefully consider whether they are paying adequate regard to the safety, security and very lives of thewomen impacted by the scourge of domestic violence. [45] The fact that this killing was
an act of intimate partner violence requires a marked increase in the period of parole ineligibility. b. A brutal killing
[ 46 ] Acts of killing, while all horrendous, fall along a spectrum of severity and moral culpability. In this case, what Mr. Clifford did was not a momentary, impetuous act. He struck Nichole 17 times. She defended herself. There was time to stop but he did not. While likely not a particularly prolonged attack, Nichole’s stabbing involved a significant use of force, the overcoming of resistance, and persistence in the face of someone he loved fighting for her life. This killing was a flow of rage that unquestionably terrified its victim.
While worse circumstances of death can be found in the jurisprudence, the nature of the crime here constitutes an aggravating factor: White at para 26 . c. The culmination of a stalking [ 47 ] The evidence at trial revealed that Mr. Clifford was effectively stalking Nichole in her final days. There is no other explanation for his incessant presence at their residence. His previous illicit presence at the home had clearly frightened and upset Nichole significantly.
Although she was unaware of the full extent of his intrusion into the sanctuary of her home, she was modifying her normal daily behaviour as a result of this concern. [ 48 ] Stalking behaviour can be a particularly pernicious sub-set of domestic violence. It is one that tragically but predictably leads to violent confrontations such as the one that resulted in Nichole’s death. While the use of scissors or a similar improvised object as the murder weapon bespeaks a lack of premeditation, the fatal encounter in this case was anything but unforeseen. Mr.
Clifford must have known that his persistent, illegal presence in the house would be detected and lead to an aggressive confrontation. [ 49 ] I specifically agree with the reasons of Justice Derrick of the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal in R v Butcher , 2020 NSCA 50 , regarding murder in the domestic context, and particularly in regard to stalking behaviour, which she described, at para 157, as “textbook behaviours of possessiveness and control that can, and in this case, did, lead to murder.” This is an aggravating factor that increases Mr. Clifford’s moral culpability and the need for denunciation. d.
The gravest breach of parental trust [ 50 ] Beyond his obligation to Nichole, Mr. Clifford owed the highest duty of care and protection to his children. Murdering their mother is one of the gravest injuries he could do to them and an absolute breach of his parental trust: White at para 26 ; Candaele at para 148. e. Murder committed in breach of Court orders of protection [ 51 ] Mr. Clifford was under conditions not to go back to his old residence after the end of January 2017. He did so anyway, resulting in at least one significant confrontation and further charges.
He was again released, with specific bail conditions not to attend at the house or have contact with Nichole. The evidence at trial revealed that he breached those conditions daily, and indeed almost perpetually, in the final days of Nichole’s life. [ 52 ] Court orders of protection, whether in the form of Emergency Protection Orders, common-law injunctions, peace bonds, or bail conditions, are only tools the law must protect vulnerable individuals who are under threat and in danger.
It is an absolute societal imperative that orders of this sort be seriously enforced and that the victims of threatening behaviours, stalking, and domestic violence have some measure of peace of mind and actual safety when such orders are granted. [ 53 ] Our Court of Appeal has expressly recognized that the killing of an intimate partner in the face of “two restraining orders is a serious aggravating circumstance” which “must be dealt with severely, as a restraining order is often only the tool the courts have to protect victims of spousal violence”: R v Radonjic , 2004 ABCA 323 at para 7 . The fact that Mr.
Clifford wantonly and repeatedly disregarded the court order imposed to protect Nichole creates both a further need for denunciation and a material concerned about his prospects for rehabilitation and safe re-integration into society. These, in turn, call for a significant increase in the period of parole ineligibility: Candaele , at para 143. [ 54 ] Moreover, where an offender persists in contact with someone they have been ordered to stay away from, the resultant harm loses any claim of spontaneity and takes on a flavor of deliberate, contemplated conduct.
Where that harm is murder, it falls closer to premeditated conduct than a sudden or random act on the spectrum of moral culpability. f. The false alibi [ 55 ] Mr. Clifford’s detailed lie in support of his false alibi is also somewhat aggravating. It does not, however, fall into the most serious categories of post-offense conduct, such as falsely participating in search attempts, or disposing of and desecrating the victim’s body. Mostly, it operates to demonstrate a lack of remorse subsequent to the killing. This does not represent an aggravating factor in itself.
Rather, it is suggestive of an entrenched mentality of ill will towards the victim and a sense of personal justification in having killed them, and contrasts with the realization of one’s wrongdoing after a momentary or impetuous act of violence. (vi) Mitigating factors [ 56 ] There are few mitigating factors in this case. Principally, Mr. Clifford was a contributing and law-abiding member of society throughout his life up until the point of his marital breakdown. This is a factor of considerable importance as it speaks to rehabilitative potential. This factor spares Mr.
Clifford from the upper end of the range on parole ineligibility. [ 57 ] Finally, the manner in which Mr. Mennie conducted the trial on Mr. Clifford’s behalf, and ostensibly upon his instructions, is worthy of mention. Every reasonable concession and admission was made, and the matter streamlined to the real essence of the issues,
resulting in a tremendous saving in judicial resources. While not strictly a sign of remorse, this factor registers favourably on Mr. Clifford’s ledger, albeit to a very limited degree: R v Kwok , 2021 ONCJ 315 at para 11 . (vii) Parity [ 58 ] It remains a foundational principle of our justice system, that offenders receive sentences that are similar to those imposed on individuals with similar characteristics who have committed similar offences: R v Lacasse , 2015 SCC 64 at para 53 . I have been provided with extensive caselaw by both parties, outlining the entire range of applicable sentences.
A number of the authorities provide exhaustive reviews of the jurisprudence, including R v Bobocel , 2014 ABQB 570 , Candaele at paras 33-88 , and R v Jolicouer , 2023 ABKB 9 . I reviewed each of these decisions closely, together with the details of the many cases summarized therein. There is no need to extensively repeat these thorough surveys of the law here. [ 59 ] The facts of this case are very similar to those in White , where Justice Moreau imposed a parole ineligibility period of 17 years.
The offence in White was worse because the offender disposed of his wife’s body in a ditch, staged a fake crime scene, and participated in the search for the woman he had killed. He was, however, still quite young, and not restrained from contact with the victim by Court orders. [ 60 ] This case also bears many similarities to Candaele . The circumstances of the murder in that case were worse, and the victim more vulnerable. The accused’s breach of his probation conditions was, however, less immediate, and pervasive than Mr. Clifford’s conduct here. Mr.
Candaele is also indigenous and appeared to suffer from some mental health issues, which assists in understanding the 16-year parole ineligibility imposed by this Court. [ 61 ] These cases serve to demonstrate that the proposed disposition is closely on par with like cases and proportional to the offence. 6. The Human impact [ 62 ] Nothing this Court can say or do today will bring Nichole back. Her loss is a scar on the community of which she was a beloved member. Her friends, her family, and above all her children will continue to miss her every day. Just as the sentence imposed on Mr.
Clifford today will last the rest of his life, the harm he has done to all the victims of this crime will last the rest of theirs. [ 63 ] Nichole was a wonderful mother and a beloved daughter, sister and friend. Her death was a tragedy. It should not have happened. She will be remembered with great love. Hopefully the closing of this
chapter today, together with the public affirmation of the goodness of her life, and the wrongfulness of her death, will bring some peace and closure to those who mourn her. 7. Conclusion [ 64 ] Mr. Clifford murdered his wife and the mother of his children in her own home. He did so while bound by bail conditions to stay away from her. The killing was the result of a predictable confrontation that he provoked with his criminal behavior. He has shown no meaningful remorse.
Having regard to all the statutory factors, the aggravating and mitigating factors, victim impact statements, and the caselaw presented, a significant increase in the period of parole ineligibility called for in this case. Specifically, I find that the range of fit sentence on these specific facts is 16-18 years. As such, the Court is justified in accepting the joint submissions of counsel on the appropriate disposition. [ 65 ] Mr. Clifford, for the murder of your wife Nichole, you are sentenced to imprisonment for life with no eligibility for parole for 16 years.
You are banned from owning firearms, explosives, or other prohibited devices pursuant to
section 109 of the Criminal Code for a period of life. You will provide a DNA sample. You are banned from contacting your children or their parents, Delilah and Daniel McKeith, directly or indirectly except with their permission, pursuant to
section 743.21 of the Criminal Code . Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 3 rd day of February, 2023. __________________________ N.E. Devlin J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Jeff Rudiak, KC for the Crown Curtis Mennie for the Robert Clifford
Loading document…