Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson, 2023 ABKB 75
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson, 2023 ABKB 75 Date: Dockets: 2101 07946, 2101 10576, ES01 119128 Registry: Calgary Between: Docket 2101 07946 Royal Bank of Canada Plaintiff - and - Sandra Ann Anderson A.K.A. Sandra-ann, Authorized representative A.K.A. Sandra-Ann: Anderson, A.K.A. SANDRA ANDERSON, WOMAN SANDRA OF THE ANDERSON FAMILY, A.K.A. i woman sandra-ann, acting as agent for and on behalf of SANDRA ANDERSON, A.K.A. sandra-ann:woman, A.K.A. Sandra-Ann, Executor, A.K.A. sandra-ann, A.K.A.
Sandra-Ann: Anderson All Rights Reserve Cestui Que Use, Principal Beneficial Owner, A.K.A. Sandra-Ann Ambassador, A.K.A. I: Sandra-Ann: Anderson, child of god, A.K.A. :Sandra-Ann: from the house of Anderson, A.K.A. :Sandra-Ann: Anderson Authorized Agent and Beneficial Owner of the trust known as ANDERSON, SANDRA ANN©, Trust and Estate Defendant and between: Docket 2101 10576 Royal Bank of Canada Plaintiff - and - Sandra Ann Anderson Defendant and
Docket ES01 119128 Estate of James Carl Anderson also known as Anderson J.C. and Anderson, James C. _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice C.M. Jones _______________________________________________________ [ 1 ] Royal Bank of Canada [RBC] on June 16, 2021 filed a Statement of Claim [ Foreclosure Action ] seeking foreclosure of a Calgary condo owned by Sandra Ann Anderson [Ms. Anderson] along with the collection of other debts. Judgment was granted by Master Farrington on November 10, 2021, who ordered: (
a) the condo would be subject to judicial sale after a six-month redemption period, and (
b) Ms. Anderson shall pay a credit card debt of $4,257.38. [ 2 ] On February 9, 2022 RBC obtained a default judgment against Ms. Anderson for an additional debt of $35,725.22 that has not to date been satisfied. [ 3 ] At the expiry of the redemption period the condo was sold for $248,480.95. An Affidavit of Accounting filed with the Court on December 23, 2022 states $35,944.39 remains as a surplus after the payout to RBC of the outstanding mortgage amount, real estate commissions, municipal taxes, and other expenses.
I direct RBC pay the remaining $35,944.39 into Count. [ 4 ] This foreclosure proved complex and problematic because Ms. Anderson is a highly active, abusive Organized Pseudolaw Commercial Argument [OPCA] ( Meads v Meads , 2012 ABQB 571 ) litigant. Ms. Anderson’s record of repeated and persistent abuse of this Court and litigants led Associate Chief Justice Rooke to on April 26, 2022 impose court access restrictions on Ms. Anderson following a Judicature Act , RSA 2000, c J-2 , ss 23-23.1 Application by the Attorney General of Canada: Canada (Attorney General) v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 310 .
However, that step had little impact on Ms. Anderson’s abusive activities in the Foreclosure Action , since court access restrictions only affect litigation and litigation steps initiated by Ms. Anderson. [ 5 ] In Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 525 [ RBC v Anderson #2 ], Associate Chief Justice Rooke at paras 31- 32 described Ms. Anderson this way: ... Ms. Anderson is an unrepentant, disruptive, greedy, uncooperative, abusive scofflaw. That has now been her uniform approach to legal rights and obligations, and the Courts, for years. Her misconduct is expanding into multiple subjects and disputes. Ms.
Anderson cannot be trusted. When she is pointed to the actual law, she reliably rejects that, and claims to unilaterally impose something else. ... Unlike many pseudolaw litigants, Ms. Anderson has significant and substantial resources. She has already demonstrated that she will use unorthodox vigilante processes against those who simply are engaged in their legal duties. All these factors, and Ms. Anderson’s dismal record of pseudolaw misconduct, mean that Ms. Anderson is an appropriate target for unusual and intrusive litigation and litigant management steps by this Court.
Doing otherwise simply guarantees more trouble ahead. [ 6 ] Those “substantial resources” include a multi-million-dollar inheritance from the Estate of James Carl Anderson, Ms. Anderson’s father. That Anderson Estate (Docket No. ES01 119128) proceeding is currently before this Court. So, despite Ms. Anderson having the means to readily pay her court and debt obligations, Associate Chief Justice Rooke in Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 577 [ RBC v Anderson #4 ] at para 23 and Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 733 [ RBC v Anderson #5 ] at para 18 concluded that “... Ms.
Anderson has made it very clear she will never voluntarily pay any penalty amount. ...”. Instead, Ms. Anderson has counterattacked with baseless OPCA claims against government actors, Crown Prosecutors, lawyers, bank officials, court staff, and judges. Ms. Anderson has recruited other legal professionals to assist in those steps: Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABQB 354 [ RBC v Anderson #1 ] at paras 54-68 ; RBC v Anderson #4 at paras 13-16 ; RBC v Anderson #6 at paras 10-17. [ 7 ] During the Foreclosure Action Ms.
Anderson attempted to sabotage, frustrate, and disrupt the foreclosure with a range of pseudolaw-based misconduct and illegal activities that are documented in RBC v Anderson #1 ; RBC Anderson #2 ; RBC v Anderson #4 ; RBC v Anderson #5 ; Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2022 ABKB 838 [ RBC v Anderson #6 ]; and Royal Bank of Canada v Anderson , 2023 ABKB 24 [ RBC v Anderson #7 ]. [ 8 ] Ms. Anderson’s bad litigation conduct in the Foreclosure Action resulted in this Court taking steps to mitigate the effects of Ms. Anderson’s malicious litigation.
In RBC v Anderson #1 at paras 71-72 , Associate Chief Justice Rooke imposed a $10,000 Rule 10.49(1) penalty against Ms. Anderson that, if not voluntarily paid, “... shall be recovered and paid to the Court as part Ms. Anderson’s
unpaid debts resulting from the foreclosure, in a manner analogous to cost awards to the Plaintiff RBC ...”. The condo being foreclosed was being rented by Ms. Anderson, and, in RBC v Anderson #2 at paras 52-57 , Associate Chief Justice Rooke classified those tenants as “victims of Ms. Anderson”, and authorized the tenants of the condo “... to file with the Court by affidavit any claims that [the tenants] wishes to make to compensate [them] for costs resulting from the foreclosure ...”. [ 9 ] In light of Ms.
Anderson’s complete refusal to follow the instructions of this Court and Canadian law, Associate Chief Justice Rooke subsequently ordered that a number of penalties imposed on Ms. Anderson were paid from Ms. Anderson’s share of the Anderson Estate , that is being held in trust by Royal Trust of Canada: RBC v Anderson #4 at paras 7-18 ; RBC v Anderson #5 at paras 7- 11 . Anticipating further illegal conduct by Ms. Anderson, and Ms.
Anderson’s continued refusal to satisfy any unfavourable award or order, Associate Chief Justice Rooke also in RBC v Anderson #5 at paras 20-21 ordered Royal Trust to pay $250,000 of Ms. Anderson’s inheritance into Court as security for costs: This security for costs payment will be used as the source for additional unsatisfied fines, costs, and other expenses that result from Ms. Anderson’s future abusive conduct before the Alberta Court of King’s Bench. Ms. Anderson may apply to this Court for release of those security for costs funds, or what remains of them, by establishing that Ms.
Anderson has discontinued her pattern of abuse of the Court, the Court’s decision makers and staff, and opposing litigants. [ 10 ] Subsequent and continued litigation misconduct by Ms. Anderson has led to additional Rule 10.49(1) penalties that were paid from the RBC v Anderson #5 $250,000 security for costs pool: • RBC v Anderson #6 at para 9 - $20,000 paid to the Court, and • RBC v Anderson #7 at para 14 - $30,000 paid to the Court.
Thus, the Court continues to hold as security for costs $200,000 from the RBC v Anderson #5 order to be potentially distributed in response to unsatisfied court-imposed obligations, costs, and penalties against Ms. Anderson. [ 11 ] On January 6, 2023, counsel for RBC by letter provided information and documents on the status of the Foreclosure Action and summarized claims made against the residue of the condo’s sale: • the November 10, 2021 RBC judgment against Ms. Anderson for her credit card debt of $4,257.38; • the February 9, 2022 RBC default judgment against Ms. Anderson for $35,725.22; • a claim by Ms.
Anderson’s former tenants for $33,231.11, pursuant to RBC v Anderson #2 at paras 52-57 ; and • the RBC v Anderson #1 at paras 71-72 $10,000 Rule 10.49(1) penalty to be paid to the Court. These amounts are greater than the proceeds of the condo sale: $35,944.39. Counsel for RBC requested directions on payment of the Foreclosure Action proceeds. As indicated above, those funds shall be paid into court by RBC. [ 12 ] The RBC v Anderson #5 security for costs funds separately held by the Court are explicitly intended as a source to pay for penalties against Ms. Anderson imposed under Rule 10.49(1).
I, therefore, order, that payment of the RBC v Anderson #1 $10,000 Rule 10.49(1) penalty will be implemented by paying $10,000 from the remaining $200,000 security for cost pool. [ 13 ] The other three claims against Ms. Anderson will be evaluated as potentially sourced both from the remainder of the condo sale and the RBC v Anderson #5 security for costs funds. I direct that a copy of this Decision and its corresponding Order are sent to counsel to the RBC, the former condo tenants, and Ms. Anderson.
RBC and the former condo tenants have until February 28, 2023 to apply and provide written argument to my office in support of payment of funds from these two sources. If Ms. Anderson seeks to make submissions in relation to these claims, those are due on March 7, 2023, after which this Court will issue a final concluding decision in relation to the Foreclosure Action . [ 14 ] I remind Ms. Anderson that she is subject to strict litigation and litigant management steps for submitting documents to this Court: RBC Anderson #2 at para 62. Ms.
Anderson is cautioned against engaging in further OPCA litigation misconduct. That will very likely result in further Rule 10.49(1) penalties. As Associate Chief Justice Rooke has repeatedly observed, Ms. Anderson would benefit from professional and qualified legal advice. Ms. Anderson should consult with a lawyer. [ 15 ] The Court will prepare and file the Order giving effect to this Decision. Ms. Anderson’s approval of that Order is dispensed with, pursuant to Rule 9.4(2)(c). Ms. Anderson shall be served this Decision and the corresponding Order to the email address used by Ms. Anderson.
Dated at the City of Calgary, Alberta this 9 th day of February, 2023. C.M. Jones J.C.K.B.A. Appearances:
None
Loading document…