Ford v Jivraj, 2023 ABKB 92
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: Ford v Jivraj, 2023 ABKB 92 Date: 20230221 Docket: 1901 16301 Registry: Calgary Between: Caylan Ford Plaintiff - and - Karim A. Jivraj Defendant _______________________________________________________ Memorandum of Decision of the Honourable Justice Robert A. Graesser _______________________________________________________ A. Introduction [ 1 ] This is the decision from the trial of Karim A.
Jivraj’s application to set aside a restraining order granted to Caylan Ford against him by Madam Justice Nixon on July 29, 2020 and filed August 18, 2020 (the “Nixon Order”) and the hearing of Caylan Ford’s application to hold Mr. Jivraj in contempt of the Nixon order arising out of an email sent to Tyler Dawson of the National Post on October 8, 2020. [ 2 ] The underlying lawsuit arises out of a failed friendship, Ms. Ford’s failed political aspirations and Mr. Jivraj’s claimed loss of a political future.
[ 3 ] On November 19, 2019, Ms. Ford issued a statement of claim against Mr. Jivraj seeking a restraining order restricting him from being within 200 meters of her and preventing him from interfering with or contacting her. She filed an application seeking an interim order, and she also filed an affidavit in support of her claim for on November 19. [ 4 ] On November 25, 2019, Mr. Jivraj filed a Statement of Defence denying Ms. Ford’s allegations and counterclaiming for a restraining order against Ms. Ford from making public comments about him and from contacting him. He filed an affidavit opposing Ms.
Ford’s application and an affidavit in support of his own application for an order against Ms. Ford. [ 5 ] The parties entered into a mutual no contact order on December 18, 2019 and started cross-examinations on their respective affidavits. [ 6 ] In June 2020, Mr. Jivraj’s lawyers ceased to act for him. Ms. Ford’s lawyers filed a new application for an order restraining Mr. Jivraj from: a. Making public comments about the Plaintiff in any forum; b. Being within 200 meters of her or her residence or place of employment; c.
Interfering with her or contacting her directly or indirectly either personally or by agent; d. Communicating about her with her family and associates. [ 7 ] The notice of application was served on Mr. Jivraj at the address provided in the notice of ceasing to act that was served on Ms. Ford’s solicitors. The registered mail to the address provided was returned to Ms. Ford’s solicitors “undeliverable”. [ 8 ] Mr. Jivraj did not appear at the application and maintains that he did not get notice of it. [ 9 ] The application proceeded in Mr.
Jivraj’s absence, and Madam Justice Nixon granted an order on July 29, 2020 and filed August 18, 2020, which: a. Enjoined Mr. Jivraj from contacting Ms. Ford or being within 200 meters from her, her home, and her place of business; and b. Enjoined Mr. Jivraj from: i. Making, disseminating or promoting statements about Ms. Ford, either in his own capacity, or through pseudo anonymous accounts; ii. Engaging third parties to make, disseminate or promote statements about the Ms. Ford; iii. Engaging third parties (other than legal counsel) to contact or follow her; and iv. Contacting Ms.
Ford’s friends or family, including engaging third parties to contact or follow her friends or family. [ 10 ] Mr. Jivraj was also ordered to “remove false and defamatory content published by (him) and under (his) control” including a blog post entitled “Hell Hath No Fury…A Very Unfortunate Ordeal” and any hyperlinks to a “cease and desist letter” that had been written to Ms. Ford by Mr. Jivraj’s former counsel in August 2019 (the “JSS letter”). [ 11 ] Mr.
Jivraj was served with the Nixon Order via email on September 25, 2020 and has acknowledged that he actually became aware of the Nixon Order on October 1, 2020. [ 12 ] On October 13, 2020, Mr. Jivraj filed an application to set aside the Nixon Order, asserting that he had not been properly served with the notice of application for the July 29 hearing before Justice Nixon. He maintains that Ms.
Ford’s counsel was aware of his email address and should have served him with the notice of application after he became aware that service by mail had not been effected. [ 13 ] On November 20, 2020, Justice Jones adjourned Mr. Jivraj’s application so that it could be heard by Madam Justice Nixon. On November 25, Madam Justice Nixon directed that the application could be heard by any judge. [ 14 ] Before Mr. Jivraj’s application could be scheduled, Ms. Ford learned of a letter sent by Eric Bailey to Tyler Dawson at the National Post on October 8, 2020 (the “Bailey letter”).
On the belief that the Bailey letter had in fact been written and sent by Mr. Jivraj, or that Mr. Jivraj had asked Mr. Bailey to send the letter to Mr. Dawson, Ms. Ford brought an application returnable May 12, 2021, to have Mr.
Jivraj declared in contempt of the Nixon Order. [ 15 ] That application was adjourned and eventually Madam Justice Hunt MacDonald by Order dated July 6, 2021, directing that the two outstanding applications be set down together. [ 16 ] The two applications were finally set down for a 3-day viva voce hearing after an order dated September 2, 2021, from Justice Neufeld. [ 17 ] Both the Hunt MacDonald and Neufeld’s Orders specifically reference Mr. Jivraj’s application to set aside the Nixon Order and Ms. Ford’s application to hold Mr. Jivraj in contempt for breach of that Order.
[ 18 ] The hearing was set for March 2022. Mr. Jivraj planned to attend in Calgary rather than through Webex, but Covid-19 issues apparently prevented that from happening. He sought an adjournment at that time as he was not prepared to attend by Webex. The matter was rescheduled for a three day in person hearing in July. Mr. Jivraj did not appear in Calgary for the July hearing and a Webex connection was quickly arranged for him. Mr. Jivraj remained in Toronto and participated through Webex, although the trial was conducted in person at the Calgary Court Centre. Ms. Ford, Mr. Bailey and Mr.
Parker testified in person. [ 19 ] It is clear from the Orders setting the matters down for hearing that what was before me in July 2022 was only to be Mr. Jivraj’s application to set aside the Nixon Order, and Ms. Ford’s application for contempt against Mr. Jivraj. [ 20 ] At the commencement of the hearing, Mr. Jivraj asked to have the hearing include his November 2019 application for a civil restraining order against Ms. Ford, as that had never been dealt with and was part of his counterclaim. [ 21 ] Mr. Harrison for Ms. Ford objected. He said that Mr.
Jivraj had not complied with all his undertakings from questioning in early 2020 and that Mr. Jivraj had taken no steps to have his application for an order against Ms. Ford set down. [ 22 ] I agreed with Mr. Harrison’s submissions and dismissed Mr. Jivraj’s application to expand the proceedings before me to include his restraining order application against Ms. Ford. B. Background [ 23 ] Ms. Ford claims that Mr. Jivraj defamed her and has harassed her since March 2019. This has caused her severe emotional anxiety as well as financial loss. She says that if Mr.
Jivraj is not restrained by a court order, he will commit further acts against her, and cause her more harm. [ 24 ] Ms. Ford also seeks an order holding Mr. Jivraj in contempt for breaching the Nixon Order of July 29, 2020, which had directed that Mr. Jivraj not publish any further comments about Ms. Ford. The alleged contempt relates entirely to the Bailey letter, which was sent to Tyler Dawson on October 8, 2020, shortly after Mr. Jivraj had been served with the Nixon Order. [ 25 ] Mr. Jivraj denies having made any defamatory statements about Ms. Ford and that he intended to cause Ms. Ford any emotional harm.
He says his actions were justified. He complains in his counterclaim that Ms. Ford has posted false statements about Mr. Jivraj since March 2019. [ 26 ] Mr. Jivraj denies that he sent the Bailey letter to Tyler Dawson. He claims that Mr. Bailey did so on his own initiative. [ 27 ] By way of a brief introduction to this case, Ms. Ford had been nominated to run for the United Conservative Party in the April 2019 Provincial election in the Calgary Mountain View constituency.
As a result of media reports branding her as a white nationalist, white supremacist, and racist, pressure from the opposition parties, pressure from the UCP leadership, and pressure from various media outlets, Ms. Ford stepped down from the race. [ 28 ] She blames all of the adverse publicity on Mr. Jivraj. She claims he embarked on a plan to discredit her and to force the UCP to stop her from running in the election in an attempt to ruin her chances of being elected. [ 29 ] A collateral and concurrent fight between the parties is a defamation lawsuit commenced by Ms. Ford against Mr.
Jivraj, The Broadbent Institute, Press Progress , the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, and others. That lawsuit is proceeding through the Court of King’s Bench and will ultimately determine whether Ms. Ford was defamed by any of the defendants in that lawsuit. [ 30 ] Defamation is not an issue expressly before me. Mr. Jivraj has been noted in default in the defamation lawsuit and his statement of defence has been struck. [ 31 ] My tasks here are to determine whether the interim restraining order against Mr. Jivraj should be continued or discharged and whether Mr. Jivraj has committed a contempt of court. C.
Testimony [ 32 ] I do not intend to review all of the testimony given by the witnesses. I will only deal with testimony and issues that I believe are important for this decision on the issues before me. There is no need to resolve all of the differences in testimony. [ 33 ] Ms. Ford testified that she and Mr. Jivraj met at a political function in Toronto in early 2017. They struck up a friendship based on a mutual respect for each other’s intelligence and interest in politics. Both testified that there were no romantic attachments and that this was an entirely platonic friendship.
There is nothing in the evidence to suggest otherwise. [ 34 ] Ms. Ford testified that Mr. Jivraj told her that he is a Hamilton native. He obtained a “licence” from the Sorbonne, which is apparently equivalent to an LLB or JD. He specialized in public international law, human rights, and international treaty law. He followed that with a program in political science at Paris Institution of Social Sciences, and then studied law at Cornell before returning to Paris to get a Master’s degree in French public law. [ 35 ] Mr.
Jivraj did some work assisting friends and others write entrance exams, and he taught English as well as pursuing his studies. [ 36 ] Instead of accepting a position with an American law firm in Paris, Mr. Jivraj decided to return to Canada to pursue a political career. He was nominated to run for Parliament in a Toronto riding and unsuccessfully ran in the 2015 Federal election against Chrystia
Freeland. [ 37 ] Apart from political activities, Ms. Ford understood that the only work Mr. Jivraj had done to the time he and Ms. Ford met was running a business helping aspiring students write entrance essays for universities they were applying for. She amplified on what he had told her about that business later in her testimony. [ 38 ] Ms. Ford said she is a Calgary native who left Calgary for a number of years for education and work purposes.
She completed Master’s degree studies in comparative politics and international securities at George Washington University in Washington DC and obtained another Master’s degree from Oxford University in international human rights. After completing her formal education she began working for Global Affairs Canada in Toronto. [ 39 ] The parties met at a Progressive Conservative Party (“PCP”) Chinese New Year function in February 2017. Ms. Ford had been invited to attend by a friend, and she was curious about it. There she met Mr. Jivraj and a number of former PCP Members of Parliament. Ms.
Ford was thinking of entering politics herself and eventually running for public office. Mr. Jivraj was introduced to her as a rising star in the PCP, and she learned he had previously run for Parliament. [ 40 ] Ms. Ford testified that Mr. Jivraj seemed very interested in her. They had a wide- ranging discussion and Ms. Ford said that this was the most interesting conversation she’d had that evening. She described him as “gifted in rhetoric, well read, and interested in ideas”. Following their meeting, he sent her an
article on Confucianism. [ 41 ] They began a friendship. It was largely an online friendship with them frequently exchanging ideas on a range of cultural, philosophical, and political questions using Facebook Messenger. Ms. Ford said that it was “useful to have people with whom I can converse and give me different perspectives, and play devil’s advocate”. [ 42 ] She also admitted that she was keen on his flattery of her intellectual abilities and that was one of the things that attracted her to him. [ 43 ] Sometime later, Mr. Jivraj invited her to attend a political event with him.
It was PC constituency meeting to elect its next president. Mr. Jivraj was keen to attend because there was a person running that he wanted to make sure was not elected. [ 44 ] Mr. Jivraj showed her an email from a “John Downs” that was “viciously disparaging” of the candidate, Ms. Saltani. The candidate was not successful. After the election, she approached Mr. Jivraj and told him to leave her alone. Ms. Ford testified that Mr. Jivraj did not appear concerned by this and said something to the effect “that’s politics”. Mr. Jivraj told Ms. Ford that he had asked John Downs to circulate the email. [ 45 ] Ms.
Ford said that she was upset by all of this and told Mr. Jivraj that what he’d done was cruel and unjustified. She said did not end the friendship then because she felt that she could remonstrate Mr. Jivraj if necessary. [ 46 ] Ms. Ford testified that after this event, they met on about a dozen other occasions, mainly at political events. During one of these discussions, Mr. Jivraj told her more about his work in France before he returned to Canada. He was running an operation that wrote entrance papers for students aspiring to get accepted at prestigious universities.
He or one of his employees would write the application materials for a fee of some 6000 euros. The materials provided were essays and fake references. Mr. Jivraj told her that he eventually stopped doing this but had not returned some of the fees that had been prepaid. [ 47 ] Mr. Jivraj told her he believed there were claims against him resulting from that, although he did not give her details of those claims. Mr. Jivraj expressed concern that if this financial situation ever came out, it might come back to haunt him in his political career. [ 48 ] After he told her about this, Ms. Ford says that Mr.
Jivraj then expressed concern that Ms. Ford might someday use this against him, so he asked her for some “dirt” about herself. This was to presumably be used against her if she used the entrance scam against him. [ 49 ] Ms. Ford said that she declined to provide any information about herself to him. [ 50 ] Mr. Jivraj encouraged her to follow a Facebook page “Teamblue2018”, which was devoted to exposing alleged corruption in the PCP Don Valley riding association and targeting a specific candidate. She said that when it was discovered that Mr.
Jivraj was the person behind Teamblue2018, he was told by a senior party official that he would not have a political career in Ontario. [ 51 ] Ms. Ford testified that she had been offered $500 by Mr. Jivraj to do some background research on a federal PCP nomination candidate. Mr. Jivraj told her this candidate had some suspected ties to the Chinese Communist Party. Ms. Ford says that she subcontracted the work to a researcher she knew. When she later provided Mr. Jivraj the results of the research, which included some information confirming such a connection, Mr.
Jirvaj refused to pay her, telling her that it wasn’t the information he was looking for. Ms. Ford says she bore the cost of the research herself. [ 52 ] Ms. Ford testified that she later learned that Mr. Jivraj was helping that same person with his nomination campaign. This scenario led to Mr. Jivraj later suggested that Ms. Ford was alleging that Mr. Jivraj was colluding with the Chinese Communist Party himself and had suppressed the information for that reason. [ 53 ] She said that at some time in the spring of 2018, Mr. Jivraj decided to move to Calgary. As Ms.
Ford was from Calgary and had family and friends there, she helped Mr. Jivraj find a place to stay, and her father helped Mr. Jivraj find a law firm in which to article. He left for Calgary in July of 2017. [ 54 ] By then, the friendship was waning. Ms. Ford testified that their conversations had become less interesting, and Mr. Jivraj was sometimes accusing her of taking positions that she had not expressed. At some point, Mr. Jivraj blocked her on social media.
[ 55 ] They remained cordial however, and when Ms. Ford told Mr. Jivraj she was planning a trip to Calgary in September 2017, Mr. Jivraj told her that Premier Jason Kenney was holding a “meet and greet”. Ms. Ford joined him at the meeting and met Mr. Kenney. Apparently, Mr. Kenney encouraged her to run in the next Provincial election and suggested she might be a good education minister. [ 56 ] Mr. Jivraj later told her that he learned from his political connections in Alberta that the meeting with Mr. Kenney had gone well. [ 57 ] At this time in Ms.
Ford’s life, she was married and pregnant with their second child. She had always planned to move back to Calgary at some stage. As at the time Mr. Jivraj moved to Calgary in 2017, Ms. Ford had not made any specific plans to move. She was happy with her job and was taking courses. [ 58 ] She testified that Mr. Jivraj was aware of her plan to eventually move to Calgary. In July 2017 she and her husband purchased a home in Calgary. The then planned their physical move, and actually moved to Calgary in February 2018. None of this had anything to do with Mr.
Jivraj being there. [ 59 ] She obtained a UCP party membership some 3 weeks before her physical move. Ms. Ford had been in Calgary for a few days in December 2017 and applied for her Alberta driver’s licence and registered with Alberta Health on that brief trip. [ 60 ] Things between Ms. Ford and Mr. Jivraj went rapidly downhill once she moved to Calgary. In early March, Ms. Ford got a telephone call from Phillip Schuman, a UCP candidate in a Calgary riding. He invited her for coffee, and when they met, he said that Mr. Jivraj told him that she had made allegations that he had sexually harassed her. Ms.
Ford told Mr. Schuman that was false, and she offered to provide him with an affidavit to that effect if he needed it. Ms. Ford advised a senior party official that the allegations made against her by Mr. Jivraj were false. [ 61 ] Exhibit 4 confirms that Mr. Jivraj told Mr. Schuman that Ms. Ford had said Mr. Schuman had made “inappropriate advances” on her. [ 62 ] Shortly after that, at Mr. Jivraj’s request, Ms. Ford met with him and Mr. Schuman ostensibly to “clear the “air”. Before the meeting, Mr.
Jivraj had told her that his life was a mess and that he was leaving the Calgary law firm at which she had helped him find articles. [ 63 ] She said Mr. Jivraj told her that he had accused her of making the sexual harassment allegation partly because of alcoholism, and partly because of his envy of her. He felt he was being ignored by the UCP and his talent and potential were not being acknowledged. He felt he was being unfairly treated. He was resentful of the success she was having. [ 64 ] About 3 am in the morning following this meeting, Mr. Jivraj sent Ms.
Ford email messages about her being a traitor, a terrible friend, and a terrible mother. He also asked her to delete their Facebook and text message history. [ 65 ] For some inexplicable reason, Ms. Ford deleted the messages and most records of their communications. Thereafter, she distanced herself from Mr. Jivraj. She declined his request to attend an AA meeting with him, which upset Mr. Jivraj. That resulted in more angry messages from him to her. [ 66 ] At a political event on April 27, 2018, the launch of Tamara Loiselle’s campaign, Ms. Ford testified that Mr.
Jivraj approached her as she was leaving and asked her to go out for drinks with him. She said that two of the men she was with at the event sensed her discomfort and asked her if she wanted them to accompany her to her car. She accepted their offer, and when the men were leaving with her, Mr. Jivraj tried to start a fight with them. At some time during this altercation, Mr. Jivraj made “lewd comments” about Ms. Ford’s breasts. [ 67 ] Ms. Ford testified that in September 2018, she became concerned that Mr. Jivraj was somehow stalking her.
He sent her a message about knowing about a meeting at her mother’s residence in Calgary. She complained about him to the UCP. [ 68 ] She said that shortly after this, an unknown person entered her home through the unlocked front door. The person left when Ms. Ford’s daughter ran to the door. Ms. Ford called the police, and when they asked her if there were any individuals she was concerned about, she gave them Mr. Jivraj’s name. Nothing came from that investigation and there were no similar incidents. [ 69 ] Ms. Ford testified that in late 2018 she received a text from Mr.
Jivraj telling her that he was “consumed by resentment and envy” that she had been asked to run and he had not. [ 70 ] In January 2019, Ms. Ford filed a police report complaining that Mr. Jivraj was harassing her. A month later, when she went to her usual coffee place one morning, she found Mr. Jivraj there. She said she put her hand on her shoulder and warned him that she intended to pursue a defamation claim against her. She later learned that Mr. Jivraj had complained to police about this “assault”. It was apparently never pursued by the police. [ 71 ] Despite all of this, Mr. Jivraj reached out to Ms.
Ford in early 2019. It appears that he was seeking to repair the relationship between them. He asked her to attend the launch of his campaign to seek the PCP nomination for a federal riding in downtown Calgary for the upcoming Federal election. He told her that it would mean a lot to him if she came to show support for him. Ms. Ford declined the invitation. That led to further unpleasant emails to her from Mr. Jivraj. [ 72 ] Ms. Ford testified that on a couple of other occasions they happened to be at the same place or event and Mr. Jivraj asked to meet with her. Ms.
Ford declined those invitations as well. [ 73 ] Ms. Ford decided to seek the UCP nomination in Calgary Mountain View in April 2018. She filed nomination papers in June or July. Shortly after that, Mr. Jivraj ran for constituency president of the Mountain View UCP and was successful. Ms. Ford was aware that Mr. Jivraj was encouraging others to run against her.
[ 74 ] Unknown to Ms. Ford at the time, Mr. Jivraj had purchased the domain name “Caylanford.ca”. To get the domain name for herself, Ms. Ford had to commence dispute resolution proceedings between herself and Mr. Jivraj in September 2018. Mr. Jivraj ultimately did not oppose the transfer of the domain name, but he refused to reimburse Ms. Ford for the costs she incurred in arranging the resolution process. [ 75 ] By this time, there was no friendship left between Ms. Ford and Mr. Jivraj. One of the exhibits at trial is an email from Ms. Ford with the addressee’s name removed. It was forwarded to Mr.
Jivraj by a friend of his. The email is undated, although the forwarding email is dated September 6, 2018. The email chronicles some of the events described above. It was obviously written by Ms Ford. It states, “Karim will go to extraordinary lengths to seek vengeance…against anyone who has the potential to threaten his ambitions”. It concludes, “I hope you will agree that this is not behaviour befitting an aspiring member of parliament.” [ 76 ] On October 1, 2018, a letter was sent to the UCP Executive Director complaining about Ms. Ford’s candidacy.
The letter was signed by 9 Constituency Board members seeking an investigation as to her eligibility for membership and to seek office. The basis of the complaint was that Ms. Ford had not been a resident of Alberta for 6 months before she obtained her UCP membership and that she was ineligible for membership at the time she applied, and that she was also ineligible to run in the upcoming Provincial election under the UCP banner. [ 77 ] The letter described this as “residency fraud” and suggested Ms.
Ford had “deliberately lied or tried to conceal her residency status”. [ 78 ] Despite being the author of this letter and the person who mustered up the signatures for it, Mr. Jivraj did not sign it himself. [ 79 ] The letter was not only sent to party headquarters, but it was also sent to some 1300 Mountainview constituency members and “leaked” to various members of the press. [ 80 ] The letter received considerable attention in the press, and in particular the NDP-oriented paper “ Press Progress ”. The headline for the Press Progress
article was “Handpicked “Parachute Candidate” (accused) of Breaking Party Rules”. [ 81 ] After the media storm following their receipt of the letter, Mr. Jivraj sent a letter to his “Fellow Board Members” referring to the letter as “a private complaint apparently filed by individuals who happen to be board members”. The letter warns them “no internal party correspondence should be shared outside the Board.” He cautioned them that they had a fiduciary duty to protect the Board’s and the Party’s interests. [ 82 ] Once it was discovered that it was Mr.
Jivraj who had authored the letter and then leaked it to the to the media, he was asked to resign his office as president of the riding association. He did so. [ 83 ] After losing his position in the Party, Mr. Jivraj continued his campaign against Ms. Ford. In November 2018, he sent an anonymous email using the email account “mountainviewconservatives” and signed “Mountain View Grassroots Conservatives” to various constituents. It was entitled “Too Good To Live Here” and referencing various complaints about Ms. Ford including comments attributed to her disparaging the Mountain View area of Calgary.
The email urged readers to “vote for someone with integrity”. [ 84 ] Mr. Jivraj also purchased “attack” ads on Google urging readers to reject Ms. Ford’s candidacy. The ads contained a hyperlink to the Press Progress
article about the residency controversy. [ 85 ] He also posted messages on Twitter under the name “Serena” saying derogatory things about Ms. Ford. [ 86 ] Ultimately, the UCP dismissed the residency complaint and accepted Ms. Ford’s candidacy. She was successful in winning the nomination in Mountain View for the upcoming Provincial election. [ 87 ] In January 2019, Mr. Jivraj sent excerpts from some of the text and Facebook messages he and Ms. Ford had exchanged between early 2017 and early 2018 to a number of media outlets, including Press Progress . [ 88 ] On March 18, 2019, Press Progress wrote an
article entitled “Star Candidate Complains White Supremacist Terrorists Treated Unfairly, Leaked Messages Show”. The “whistleblower” is quoted as saying “Kenney needs to disqualify her immediately… These comments alone could ruin the campaign”. The
article purports to quote verbatim some of the excerpts the anonymous source had sent to them. [ 89 ] That day, Ms. Ford had her lawyer write a “cease and desist” letter to Mr. Jivraj. The letter alleges that he had been engaging in a “personal campaign of disparagement, defamation, and misinformation” against her. The letter referenced the residency complaint letter to the UCP authored by Mr.
Jivraj; his having sent the letter to Press Progress ; his having sent the disparaging email to Mountain View constituents under the banner “Mountain View Grass Roots”; his paying for Google advertisements during the nomination campaign directing readers to the Press Progress article; that Mr. Jivraj had spread a rumour that Ms. Ford had complained about sexual harassment by another candidate; and other things. [ 90 ] The letter said, “(s)imply put, leave Ms. Ford alone.” [ 91 ] The Press Progress
article had started a media frenzy. Other media outlets across Calgary, Alberta, and Canada picked up the Press Progress story. Ms. Ford was branded as a white supremacist and racist. Ms. Ford testified that she learned that there were stories about this in international media publications. She was immediately subjected to a huge amount of scorn and abuse in the media, online, and from acquaintances and even strangers. Other political parties called for her dismissal as a candidate. [ 92 ] Following a discussion with Premier Kenney, Ms. Ford announced her resignation as a candidate.
That did not stop the scorn and abuse. Ms. Ford retreated to her residence as was afraid to leave it and go out in public. She feared being confronted by strangers who recognized her from the publicity and calling her out.
[ 93 ] It was obvious to Ms. Ford who had leaked the messages to the press. The story itself spoke of the anonymous informant being a prominent Muslim conservative “with deep ties to the party”. She wanted to try to clear her name and to fight back against the allegations being made against her. Her resignation letter to the UCP denied the allegations that she was a white supremacist or anti- Muslim. It was widely circulated by her. [ 94 ] Ms. Ford said she had some discussions with Stuart Thomson, a reporter with Post Media, who was interested in doing an
article on her and what she said Mr. Jivraj had done to her. On March 27, the reporter wrote Mr. Jivraj asking him questions about many of the events referred to in the narrative above. [ 95 ] In a recorded conversation with the reporter, Mr. Jivraj referenced that there had been a “personal relationship” between him and Ms. Ford, saying “you know she has a family…and I wouldn’t want to bring this story if it could provide some context.” [ 96 ] Mr. Jivraj responded to Mr. Thomson’s inquiry by offering to have Ms. Loiselle provide an affidavit denying that any lewd comments had been made by Mr.
Jivraj at her campaign launch. He also threatened to disclose that he and Ms. Ford had a previous relationship. Ms. Loiselle did write a letter to Mr. Thomson supporting Mr. Jivraj. As a result of these things, the National Post declined to print the story. [ 97 ] On March 29, 2019, Ms. Ford was interviewed by Danielle Smith on her radio show. Ms. Ford discussed her relationship with Mr. Jivraj and presented her side of the story, including information about Mr.
Jivraj’s background and his underhanded dealings as Mountain View riding association president. [ 98 ] The interview was removed from the radio station’s website after complaints and threats by Mr. Jivraj had been made to them. [ 99 ] Ms. Ford published an
article “ Apologia ” on her personal website on April 6, 2019. The
article contained similar allegations about Mr. Jivraj as were made by Ms. Ford on the Danielle Smith radio show. It also explained Ms. Ford’s views and how the emails quoted in the media were take out of context. Apologia is still on Ms. Ford’s website. [ 100 ] She was also interviewed by “Windward Psychological”, who apparently posted a podcast airing Ms. Ford’s complaints about Mr. Jivraj to its readers. There was a story unfavourable to Mr. Jivraj printed in Rebel Media . [ 101 ] In August 2019, Ms. Ford received a 13-page letter from JSS Barristers, Mr. Jivraj’s then lawyers (the “JSS letter”).
The JSS letter alleged that she had made false and defamatory allegations about Mr. Jivraj, including that she had alleged Mr. Jivraj stalked her, harassed her, harassed other individuals, was the likely culprit for a break and enter of her home, and had committed electoral fraud, amongst other things. [ 102 ] It referred to their being no evidence that Mr. Jivraj was the source of the information sent to Press Progress and stated that Ms. Ford’s allegation that Mr. Jivraj had sent a “pseudoanonymous” email to a young political activist (referring to the nomination meeting Mr. Jivraj had invited Ms.
Ford to attend in Toronto in February 2017) and the John Downs email to Ms. Saltani) was false and defamatory. It claimed that Ms. Ford had broken off their relationship Mr. Jivraj because of his discomfort with her political views. It also dealt with Ms. Ford having reported Mr. Jivraj to Calgary Police in connection with the break and enter incident she reported in late 2018. It repeated Mr. Jivraj’s allegation that Ms. Ford had “aggressively touched him” in a coffee shop. [ 103 ] The letter refuted a number of other statements Ms.
Ford made during the interview with Danielle Smith. [ 104 ] The JSS letter was for some reason redated and sent to Ms. Ford again on October 28, 2019. [ 105 ] Mr. Jivraj disseminated the JSS letter widely, including sending it to a Florida podcast producer Ms. Ford was working with to publicize her side of the story about the failure of her political career. In an email to the producer, Mr. Jivraj denies Ms. Ford’s allegations that he is a “sexual predator, a stalker, a violent and dangerous criminal, and a many who may have attempted to break into Ms. Ford’s residence” and tells him that Ms.
Ford’s allegations were completely false. He says his lawyer had advised him to “serve you with papers and to sue you”. [ 106 ] Mr. Jivraj also sent the JSS letter to a prominent UCP member in Calgary asking him to keep the letter confidential. He also sought advice from this person as to what he should do as a result of this situation he was in with Ms. Ford. [ 107 ] On November 19, 2019, Ms Ford commenced this action, seeking a civil restraining order against Mr. Jivraj. She also filed an application for an interim injunction and an affidavit in support of that application.
Her affidavit outlines in detail her complaints about Mr. Jivraj’s conduct which lead to her stepping down as a UCP candidate. [ 108 ] Mr. Jivraj filed a statement of defence and counterclaim seeking a restraining against Ms. Ford. On November 25, 2019 he filed an application for a civil restraining order as a cross-application to Ms. Ford’s application filed He filed a lengthy affidavit dealing with the harm he had suffered from the Danielle Smith interview, the Apologia
article posted on Ms. Ford’s website, and the Rebel Media interview, amongst other things. [ 109 ] Mr. Jivraj alleges that Ms. Ford’s actions have cost him any future as a political candidate, his career as a lawyer, his reputation, his physical and mental health, and numerous personal and professional relationships. His affidavit in support of his application attached several emails or Facebook postings as examples of what he has been subjected to as a result of Ms. Ford’s public allegations against him. [ 110 ] On December 18, 2019, the parties consented to an interim mutual restraining order. Ms.
Ford alleges that Mr. Jivraj sent copies of the restraining order to a reporter and the National Post .
[ 111 ] At some time in the early summer of 2020, Mr. Jivraj’s lawyers ceased to act for him. Ms. Ford applied for a broader restraining order and obtained the Nixon Order on July 29. The Order was not filed until August 18 as Mr. Harrison and Justice Nixon exchanged correspondence after the application relating to the specific wording of the Order. Mr. Jivraj did not appear on the application, and he alleges that he did not have any notice of the application. Ms. Ford’s lawyers had served Mr. Jivraj at the “last known address” provided by Mr.
Jivraj’s former lawyers in their Notice of Ceasing to Act. [ 112 ] That was apparently an incomplete address, and Mr. Jivraj claims that Ms. Ford’s lawyers should have known that and also that they should have emailed him the documents instead of trying to serve him by mail. He says they were aware of his email address at the time. [ 113 ] Mr. Jivraj was served with the Nixon Order by email sent to his email address dated September 25. At the time, Mr. Jivraj was living in Toronto. On October 8, 2020, a lengthy letter was emailed to Tyler Dawson at the National Post .
The letter attaches the defamation notice sent by JSS to Ms. Ford in October 2019 and other materials, and it says the writer believes that the National Post was close to “doing a hit piece on Karim Jivraj based on former UCP candidate Caylan Ford’s elaborate narrative that Jivraj is some sort of violent and dangerous criminal.” [ 114 ] The letter was signed by “Eric Bailey” and was sent to Mr. Dawson on Mr. Bailey’s email account. Ms. Ford believes it was authored and sent by Mr. Jivraj. Mr. Jivraj denies that he sent the letter. Ms. Ford commenced an application to hold Mr.
Jivraj in contempt of court for sending the letter to Mr. Dawson. Mr. Bailey provided an affidavit in support of Ms. Ford’s contempt application swearing that the letter was authored and sent by Mr. Jivraj, using Mr. Bailey’s computer or cell phone. [ 115 ] This is the act Ms. Ford characterizes as a contempt of court on Mr. Jivraj’s part. [ 116 ] During the trial, Ms. Ford acknowledged that she is in the process of completing a documentary film about her political career and Mr. Jivraj’s actions in ruining it, and she hopes it will be broadcast in the near future. Cross-examination [ 117 ] Mr.
Jivraj cross-examined Ms. Ford on a number of issues. She confirmed that he had not contacted her for nearly 2 years and there had been no face-to-face contact for some 3 years. They fenced on the circumstances of the 2017 Toronto nomination event and Mr. Jivraj’s role in the John Downs email sent to the constituency board members. Ms. Ford agreed that Mr. Jivraj told her that he had not sent it out, but she said that Mr. Jivraj told her he had Mr. Downs send it. Ms. Ford agreed that at the time she suspected that Mr. Downs was not a real person and that Mr. Jivraj had simply made him up. [ 118 ] Mr.
Jivraj questioned her as to why she would remain friends with someone she felt was an “ethically unmoored person”. Ms Ford said that she had no real answer other than that she had allowed herself to get flattered by him. She also felt that despite his character flaws he was “redeemable”. [ 119 ] He spent some time trying to cross-examine Ms. Ford about a Law Society complaint. Mr. Jivraj was frustrated that I did not allow a Law Society decision to be put in evidence, and following Mr. Harrison’s objection, I did not allow her to be questioned on a Law Society proceeding against one of Mr.
Jivraj’s former lawyers. [ 120 ] Mr. Jivraj asked her whether she had believed what he told her about the Weston Ivy essay work and put it to her that the complaint was that he hadn’t delivered the promised services. Ms. Ford responded that she had checked it out on the internet and found out that what he told her was true. [ 121 ] He challenged her on why, if she had such serious concerns about him, she would help him find an articling position in Calgary. She replied that she thought articling would be good for him and that he could likely do well practicing law. She denied having anything to do with Mr.
Jivraj losing that job in 2018. [ 122 ] Ms. Ford agreed that while she suspected that Mr. Jivraj wanted to be president of the Mountain View riding association to keep her from being nominated, she was not aware of his actual motives. She acknowledged that he won the presidency with a substantial majority over the other candidates. [ 123 ] Mr. Jivraj questioned her on her fears that he was monitoring her. She replied that her fears were because he was telling her things he knew things about her and she felt that was unusual. [ 124 ] Ms.
Ford also confirmed that she had told Danielle Smith and Stuart Thomson that Mr. Jivraj had made lewd comments about her. She denied spreading this allegation in political circles until after she had become a candidate for office. [ 125 ] She agreed that she did not know what his motives were when he moved to Calgary but when pressed she said she thought it was more likely mercenary than following her. [ 126 ] Mr. Jivraj sought to question her on an affidavit from a Thomas Code.
I did not allow the affidavit to go into evidence on the basis of it being hearsay but did allow questions as to what she may have said to Mr. Code. [ 127 ] It is fair to say that Mr. Jivraj was frustrated during his cross-examination of Ms. Ford by Mr. Harrison’s objections and many of my rulings on points of evidence. Ms. Ford was in several cases unwilling to acknowledge the authenticity of emails sent by her to various third parties or received by her from other parties.
David John Parker [ 128 ] David John Parker testified next. He described himself as a political organizer with experience running campaigns, managing volunteers, doing fundraising, and carrying out communications work. He had been an acquaintance of Mr. Jivraj’s since 2017 and said they had a brief friendship between December 2019 and February 2020. [ 129 ] Mr. Parker was the campaign manager of one of Ms. Ford’s opponents for the Mountain View nomination. Mr. Parker testified that Mr. Jivraj was very interested in Ms. Ford not winning the nomination and that he had proposed a strategy to try to make that happen.
Mr. Jivraj provided forms of messages disparaging Ms. Ford to distribute for the campaign he was managing. [ 130 ] Mr. Parker testified that the campaign did not follow Mr. Jivraj’s strategy as they felt the messages were ‘not as honest as they wanted to be for the type of campaign they wanted to run”, as the messages “painted things in a light that didn’t align with the facts.” [ 131 ] Mr. Parker said that after the election results came out and Ms. Ford had won, Mr. Jivraj expressed rage, anger, and frustration, and sent many abusive texts to him. [ 132 ] He said that Mr.
Jivraj discussed the Nixon Order with him in December and January 2020. Mr. Parker testified that one night in early 2021 Mr. Jivraj showed up at his house around 11:30 pm. Mr. Jivraj was drunk and over a bottle of whiskey Mr. Jivraj told him about an upcoming court hearing. Mr. Jivraj said he needed Mr. Parker to sign an affidavit swearing that Ms. Ford had talked to someone about the case and had broken the court order. [ 133 ] Mr. Jivraj told him he wanted to try to bankrupt Ms. Ford and wanted some evidence that she had breached the Nixon Order. Mr. Parker said that when he refused, Mr.
Jivraj called him a traitor, a Judas, and not a real friend. Mr. Jivraj then offered to have his father pay him $10,000 to swear such an affidavit. Mr. Parker says he still refused. [ 134 ] Mr. Parker later contacted Ms. Ford about this, and he was asked to swear an affidavit in these proceedings. He did so. [ 135 ] He was cross-examined on his affidavit in March 2021. He testified that after his cross-examination on the affidavit. Mr. Jivraj leaked private emails between them to reporters, Mr. Jivraj posted these emails in a blog and then sent them to officials in the Erin O’Toole campaign for leader of the PCP.
At the time, Mr. Parker was working on Mr. O’Toole’s campaign. The leak of these emails resulted in Mr. Parker being excluded from that campaign. Cross-examination [ 136 ] Cross-examination by Mr. Jivraj initially focused on their friendship starting in 2018 and that Mr. Parker was inebriated each time they met. He agreed with Mr. Jivraj that he was upset when Mr. Jivraj told a mutual friend that Mr. Parker was drinking too much. [ 137 ] Mr. Parker agreed with Mr. Jivraj that Mr. Parker’s career in politics involved being a somewhat “ruthless operator” and some vindictiveness.
Settling scores was a factor, although Mr. Parker said he was trying to be better. He denied that his memory of the events he testified to was clouded by the drinking surrounding their conversations. [ 138 ] Mr. Parker agreed that during a two-week period when they were discussing Ms. Ford, Mr. Jivraj was genuinely distressed about the situation between them and that Mr. Jivraj had told him this was ruining his life. [ 139 ] Mr. Parker denied contacting Ms. Ford at the time and said that only happened after Mr. Jivraj had him fired from the O’Toole campaign. He agreed with Mr.
Jivraj that their conversations at this time included the possibility of Mr. Jivraj suing Ms. Ford for defamation. They had also talked about the Nixon Order and Mr. Parker agreed that he wasn’t aware of Mr. Jivraj having breached that Order. [ 140 ] When asked why Mr. Parker contacted Ms. Ford, Mr. Parker said he felt he needed to help protect Ms. Ford from Mr. Jivraj and he was not trying to “exact revenge” on Mr. Jivraj when their friendship failed. [ 141 ] Mr. Parker denied being inebriated on the day Mr. Jivraj asked him to swear the affidavit and said that Mr. Jivraj was not sober.
Eric Bailey [ 142 ] The next witness was Eric Bailey. He testified that he and Mr. Jivraj were roommates in July 2020. Mr. Bailey’s testimony focused on the email sent on his email account to Tyler Dawson. Mr. Bailey said he did not send the email and he did not know who Tyler Dawson was. [ 143 ] Mr. Bailey testified that Mr. Jivraj told him that Ms. Ford had obtained a “bogus” restraining order against him. They were sitting in the communal kitchen in their rooming house and Mr. Jivraj asked if he could use Mr. Bailey’s phone to write an email. Mr.
Jivraj explained that he could not have direct contact with Ms Ford. He persuaded Mr. Bailey to allow him to use his smartphone. [ 144 ] Mr. Bailey said that Mr. Jivraj agreed to let him see what he was going to send before it went out, but Mr. Jivraj sent it before showing it to Mr. Bailey. [ 145 ] Sometime later, Mr. Bailey got in touch with Ms. Ford through her website after his relationship with Mr. Jivraj ended. Mr. Bailey testified about a couple of physical fight between them that led to Mr. Jivraj giving a peace bond requiring him to stay away from Mr. Bailey.
Cross-examination [ 146 ] During Mr. Jivraj’s cross-examination of Mr. Bailey, Mr. Bailey agreed that he had made a deal with Mr. Jivraj to let him type up something on his computer or cell phone. He emphasized that Mr. Jivraj had to let him review whatever was written before it was sent out to anyone. According to Mr. Bailey, Mr. Jivraj broke that agreement by sending out the email before letting Mr. Bailey review it. [ 147 ] Mr. Bailey denied being upset by this and said that he looked at the email and agreed that it could be sent out a second time. He believes that Mr. Jivraj sent the email out again after Mr.
Bailey consented to that. [ 148 ] Mr. Bailey agreed with Mr. Jivraj that he had not reported the first alleged assault to the police but responded that he did go to the police after the second assault. Mr. Jivraj asked him why he contacted Ms. Ford after a peace bond had been ordered. Mr. Bailey replied that he understood that Mr. Jivraj worked through lawyers and that he didn’t know what to do in the situation. He knew Ms. Ford was in conflict with Mr. Jivraj so he contacted Ms. Ford for guidance. Ms. Ford referred him to Mr. Harrison. [ 149 ] Mr. Jivraj asked him why Mr.
Bailey swore an affidavit about this, and Mr. Bailey testified that he felt that he had done something wrong and felt that he needed to let the world know that he hadn’t written the email. [ 150 ] Mr. Jivraj pointed out that Mr. Bailey was being paid to come to Calgary to testify. Mr. Bailey agreed that he had threatened Mr. Jivraj that he would speak to Ms. Ford after the first assault on him, but he said that he did so in response to Mr. Jivraj’s threat to go to Mr. Bailey’s father about Mr. Bailey’s drinking and drug use. Karim Jivraj [ 151 ] Mr. Jivraj gave evidence in two tranches.
He completed his testimony in chief on July 28, and cross-examination of him began. However, we ran out of time in July and the trial could not continue until December 13. [ 152 ] In direct, Mr. Jivraj spoke of his meeting Ms. Ford in Toronto in early 2017 and discussed many of their interactions. He quickly went to Ms. Ford’s testimony about him sending a disparaging email regarding Ms. Saltani’s candidacy for riding president in Toronto. He denied that he had sent the email himself or that he had posted anything using the name “John Downs”. He said that he knew Mr. Downs and that Mr.
Downs was opposed to that candidate and that it was Mr. Downs who sent out the email Ms. Ford complained about. [ 153 ] Mr. Jivraj testified that there had been a complaint to the Law Society over this email and particularly the allegation that the email about Ms. Saltani had been sent “pseudoanonymously” by Mr. Jivraj. He testified that he had been cleared by the Law Society. [ 154 ] Mr. Jivraj denied telling anything to Ms. Ford about running a university entrance “essay mill”.
He said he told he had helped some friends with entrance essays, and that eventually turned into a money-making venture, but that he never said anything to her about it being a taking payment and not providing the essays, or about being sued by unhappy clients. He testified that he got out of that business after an unhappy client started sending him “very unhappy emails” when Mr. Jivraj told him he couldn’t change his grades and academic history in the client’s attempt to get into Harvard Law School. [ 155 ] Mr. Jivraj acknowledged that he owned and operated the site “Teamblue” while in Ontario.
He said that he used that account to “shed light on Patrick Brown’s leadership”. Mr. Jivraj said that in hindsight he feels stupid about the and is “not particularly thrilled about that fact”. He testified that using anonymous email accounts was something he stopped doing, but he also emphasized that it was not illegal in politics for people to create accounts like that one. [ 156 ] Mr. Jivraj denied that he was driven out of Ontario because of the Teamblue account but acknowledged that there was on colleague in Conservative circles who was very upset with him.
He noted that he had never been sued for defamation in Ontario. He said that he now regrets owning and operating that account. Mr. Jivraj said that he was very upset by the allegation that he used that email account to target women and that he was misogynistic. Those allegations are not true. He said he also used the account to target many male candidates. [ 157 ] Mr. Jivraj said he moved to Calgary around July 1, 2017. He had talked to Ms. Ford about a possible move there, and she was supportive. He denied “following” her to Calgary. Mr.
Jivraj immediately became active in politics and worked on campaigns supporting the merger of the PCs and the Wildrose party. One of his objectives in moving to Calgary was to run for the Federal PC party and he immediately began work on seeking the nomination in Calgary Centre. [ 158 ] Mr. Jivraj discussed Eric Bailey’s testimony about the email sent to Tyler Dawson. Mr. Jivraj said that almost all of Mr. Bailey’s testimony was false. He said he did not discuss Ms. Ford with Mr. Bailey. He did say that he had spoken to Mr. Parker about his issues with Ms. Ford. [ 159 ] Mr.
Jivraj testified that the Nixon Order only came to his attention in a September 25, 2020 email, which he thinks he read on October 1. He was surprised by the Order as he had not heard of the July 29 application. He said he did not fully understand the Nixon Order and that he did not have a lawyer at the time. He says he spoke with friend who was lawyer and recalled the lawyer telling him that the order was “a little ambiguous, that it probably barred public dissemination”.
[ 160 ] He said he received an email from Tyler Dawson from the National Post on October 7, which referenced Ms. Ford’s complaints about him. Mr. Jivraj was not sure why Mr. Dawson was contacting him at that time. Mr. Jivraj said he did not think he had been served with the defamation claim at that stage. He did want to defend himself from Ms. Ford’s allegations. [ 161 ] Mr. Jivraj thought that Mr. Dawson’s email may have been connected to the communications he had with Mr. Dawson in March 2019 about an
article Ms. Ford was urging Mr. Dawson to get published in the National Post . At that time, Mr. Jivraj had threatened to sue Mr. Dawson and his paper for defamation if they published Ms. Ford’s allegations, and Mr. Dawson and the National Post had backed down and published nothing about her allegations against him. [ 162 ] Mr. Jivraj testified that he began to write something to Mr. Dawson on his computer. He said that Mr. Bailey overheard a conversation he had with his father, and Mr. Bailey had told him that he wanted to do something about the situation with Ms. Ford. Mr.
Bailey stated that the gag order did not apply to him. Mr. Jivraj said that Mr. Bailey wanted to assist him and that he had to talk Mr. Bailey out of going to the National Post himself to support Mr. Jivraj. Ultimately, he said he saw Mr. Bailey doing something with his computer, but he denied that he had anything to do with sending the letter out. [ 163 ] He testified that he “went back and forth” about having Mr. Bailey write something but said that he could “say under oath that I did not send the email, I did not instruct Mr.
Bailey to send the email, and on discovering he had done so, my reaction was that he may have put me in some jeopardy.” [ 164 ] Mr. Jivraj described Mr. Bailey as a very troubled person who was at the time very unstable and using hard drugs. He said that Mr. Bailey began asking him for money, and then started threatening that he would use “this knowledge” against him. [ 165 ] Mr. Jivraj denied that there were any altercations with Mr. Bailey that resulted in a peace bond. He said they fell out over Mr. Bailey’s drug use. [ 166 ] Mr. Jivraj commented on Mr.
Parker’s testimony about having been offered a bribe to swear a false affidavit. Mr. Jivraj acknowledged asking Mr. Parker to provide an affidavit to the effect that Ms. Ford had breached the no contact order. This was in the context that an affidavit, or the offer of an affidavit, from Ms. Loiselle concerning the allegations about him making lewd comments about Ms. Ford had the National Post back off publishing anything about him in March 2019. Mr. Jivraj thought that an affidavit from Mr. Parker might be helpful in preventing any planned publications by the National Post at that time. [ 167 ] Mr.
Jivraj said Mr. Parker asked him why he wanted an affidavit, and Mr. Jivraj did not tell him. Initially Mr. Parker refused to swear any affidavit. Mr. Jivraj says that sometime later he told Mr. Parker that such an affidavit would be very helpful to him. Mr. Parker asked him what his price was. Mr. Jivraj says he replied, “the cost of what you’re drinking”, to which Mr. Parker said, “I’m not that cheap; get me a cheque from your rich old man.” [ 168 ] Mr. Jivraj said that this was a joking sort of conversation and he never offered Mr. Parker a bribe. All of these conversations took place while he and Mr.
Parker were drinking. [ 169 ] He discussed his eventual falling out with Mr. Parker and also Mr. Parker’s relationship with the Western Standard . That paper had published a number of articles critical of Mr. Jivraj. He had considered Mr. Parker to be a friend and was concerned that Mr. Parker might use things he’d said to Mr. Parker against him. [ 170 ] Mr. Jivraj commented that his refusal to respond to later inquiries from the Western Standard about him and Ms. Ford shows that he has “moved on”. [ 171 ] Mr. Jivraj acknowledged helping write the letter from the Mountain View board members complaining about Ms.
Ford’s residency. He said that some of the board members were professionals and that he didn’t force them to write the letter. Mr. Jivraj defended the contents of the letter and said that he believes the factual contents of it to be true. He testified that he was of the opinion that Ms. Ford was deceiving other people about her residency and eligibility to run for office. He came to the conclusion that Ms. Ford was duplicitous and deceptive and that she was “trying to pull a fast one and misrepresenting her history unnecessarily.” [ 172 ] Mr. Jivraj then spoke of the tenor of the communications he and Ms.
Ford had after he moved to Calgary in July 2017. They continued to message each other regularly. Mr. Jivraj spoke at length about conversations they had about the recent New Zealand mosque shootings and the riots in the United States following the Charlottesville “Unite the Right” rally. In some of these discussions, Ms. Ford discussed what Mr. Jivraj described as “white nationalist theories.” [ 173 ] He testified that these communications troubled him and led to him regretting having introducing Ms. Ford to UCP politicians in Alberta.
He said that he sent some of these emails to the media sometime In July or August 2019 after he and Ms. Ford had a falling out and he had blocked her from messaging him. [ 174 ] Mr. Jivraj denies editing or making any changes to the emails or messages he shared with the media and in particular Press Progress . He testified that what the media did with these messages after he sent them to them were “not his decisions to make”. [ 175 ] He did not know if he asked Ms. Ford to delete all the messages they had exchanged after an incident between them. He has no memory of doing so.
He said that he continued to have access to the messages at the time of the Press Progress article. [ 176 ] After Ms. Ford's resignation as UCP candidate in March 2020 and when she went on the offensive against him, Mr. Jivraj felt he had to defend himself. After the Danielle Smith interview, he retained counsel to defend him. He testified that he took some screen shots of some of the messages exchanged between Ms. Ford and himself and sent them to his lawyer. These included the messages that were quoted in the JSS letter. [ 177 ] Mr.
Jivraj testified that they were successful in having the Danielle Smith interview removed from the internet as a result of communications from his lawyer to the radio station.
[ 178 ] He then talked about the issue with Mr. Schuman and Ms. Ford’s allegations that he told Mr. Schuman that Ms. Ford was complaining that Mr. Schuman had sexually harassed her. Mr. Schuman was running for office and Mr. Jivraj was wondering at the time if Ms. Ford was interested in running in the same riding. [ 179 ] Mr. Jivraj testified that he and Mr. Schuman were at a function together. Ms. Ford also attended the function. She was several months pregnant at the time. Mr. Jivraj said that Mr. Schuman has a “potty mouth” and said that Mr.
Schuman made comments that went “way beyond locker room talk” about Ms. Ford and other women. [ 180 ] Mr. Jivraj says he told Ms. Ford about Mr. Schuman’s behavior and testified that Ms. Ford commented on that and used the words “sexual harassment” in her comments. Mr. Jivraj testified he should have chosen his words better when he spoke to Mr. Schuman about this but that the incident had been “blown way out of proportion.” He denied any “Machiavellian plot” about talking to Mr. Schuman about Ms. Ford’s comments. [ 181 ] Mr. Jivraj denied that he was jealous about Ms.
Ford’s success in political politics, commenting that “it’s the B team” and he was not sure why he would have been jealous of her. He was pursuing Federal office. [ 182 ] Mr. Jivraj denied making a lewd comment himself to Ms. Ford at the Tamara Loiselle campaign launch on April 18. He said that he had badgered Ms. Ford for drinks and conducted himself poorly, but he did not make any lewd comment and he did not detain her. He thinks that he suggested that they clear the air by getting coffee right away or in the future, and because she didn’t want to grab coffee, he felt rebuffed. [ 183 ] Mr.
Jivraj acknowledged that he had purchased the domain name “Caylanford”. He testified that it was a “stupid idea, done years ago” when his state of mind was that he was scared, and he feared that Ms. Ford would harm his political aspirations. [ 184 ] He discussed three “pseudoanonymous” email accounts he had set up. He acknowledged that he posted derogatory things about himself on the “Mr. Wilson” account. At the time, he was dealing with Ms. Ford’s allegations against him. Mr. Jivraj testified that he “reasoned stupidly” that if he posted even more outrageous statements about himself than Ms.
Ford was making, he would make Ms. Ford’s allegations of criminality against him look silly. He explained that this had taken place years ago, he was stressed at the time, and he was scared for his future as a result of the allegations against him being circulated. [ 185 ] Mr. Jivraj says that he did post ads on Google during the Mountain View nomination campaign and that he authored the ads and disseminated them, but they were only posted “for a few days.” [ 186 ] He testified that he could “fairly comfortably say that based on what had been done to (him, he) didn’t think (Ms. Ford) was fit for office.
She was deceptive.” He said that he had also complained to Elections Alberta about Ms. Ford’s residency status and not just to the UCP. [ 187 ] Mr. Jivraj said he posted from the “Serena” email account about political things. He had re-tweeted things about Ms. Ford using that account. He testified that his comments and re-tweets were done in the context of Ms. Ford posting her “ Apologia ”
article on her website and the various broadcasts she was involved in claiming that he was responsible for the death of her political career. [ 188 ] In connection with these activities, Mr. Jivraj testified that anonymous accounts are not illegal, and they are used in politics. He felt that Ms. Ford had presented herself in her campaign in a way that wasn’t consistent with the views that she had given to me. He felt the felt the public had a right to know about these inconsistencies. [ 189 ] He testified that he did not believe Ms.
Ford was a white supremacist or a Nazi, but he did feel that there were some views that were political in nature, and these offended him. According to Mr. Jivraj, the public had a right to know about all of this and he feels that he is now being blamed for what the media chose to publish. [ 190 ] Mr. Jivraj feels that any comments and criticisms in the political realm are fair game, regardless of whether Ms. Ford feels they are offensive. He contrasted these with the allegations Ms.
Ford has made about him of harassing or stalking her, his having made lewd comments, and that he had broken into her home. [ 191 ] Some of his testimony focused on service issues surrounding the Nixon Order. He said that the building he was staying in at the time had no individual suite numbers as it was still somewhat under construction. He didn’t explain why he had given that address to his former lawyers. He knew they had used that address as his last known address when they sent out a notice of ceasing to act and served the notice on Ms. Ford’s solicitors. He was aware that following that, Ms.
Ford’s lawyers used that address for service of documents (including that interim injunction application) on him. He felt that was wrong. [ 192 ] Mr. Jivraj talked about the impact Ms. Ford’s campaign against him has had on him. Initially, he lost his articling position with the law firm in Calgary. He has spent over $100,000 dealing with these issues. Mr. Jivraj gets panic attacks and has from time to time become physically ill. He is upset that Ms.
Ford has raised over $100,000 in an ongoing GoFundMe campaign to assist her with financing the litigation against him and the media. [ 193 ] He emphatically denied that he was any kind of physical threat to Ms. Ford and noted that he has not contacted her in any way since the Nixon Order. [ 194 ] Mr. Jivraj is very concerned about his inability to defend himself against Ms. Ford’s ongoing attacks against him and is worried about the documentary she says will be released soon. [ 195 ] He said that he was never obsessed with Ms. Ford; rather, he was upset with her. Mr.
Jivraj testified that he regrets a lot of the things he did but wants to frame those regrets in the context of his fear that he couldn’t fight against Ms. Ford’s allegations and that this might ruin his career.
Cross-examination [ 196 ] Cross-examination was extensive. Mr. Harrison reviewed much of Ms. Ford’s testimony and many of the records with Mr. Jivraj. In the main, the cross-examination could be described as argumentative. Mr. Harrison had difficulty getting a straight answer to many of his questions. Mr. Jivraj responded, but frequently gave an explanation or excuse rather than an answer. [ 197 ] Shortly before cross-examination was adjourned in July, Mr. Harrison sought leave to question Mr. Jivraj on messages Mr. Jivraj provided to Press Progress in 2019. Mr. Harrison maintained that Mr.
Jivraj had perjured himself, and he wanted to ask Mr. Jivraj on communications between him and Luke LeBrun of Press Progress . Mr. Harrison had learned of these communications in the defamation action and had copies of these communications with him. He asked for relief from the implied undertaking of confidentiality under Rule 5.33(1) for permission to cross-examine Mr. Jivraj on these. [ 198 ] I accepted Mr. Harrison’s arguments as these were communications that Mr. Jivraj was obviously aware of and should have produced them in this litigation. I did not see a difficulty with Mr.
Harrison using communications Mr. Jivraj had been involved in during his cross-examination, and I thus allowed Mr. Harrison to question Mr. Jivraj on these. [ 199 ] Mr. Jivraj confirmed that he had initially sent the messages on which the March 18, 2019 Press Progress
article was based to them in January 2019. When asked why it took until March for Press Progress to publish them, Mr. Jivraj responded that he didn’t know. [ 200 ] Mr. Harrison asked Mr. Jivraj if he asked Press Progress not to publish them at that time, and Mr. Jivraj said, no. When asked why Press Progress hadn’t published the messages until March, Mr. Jivraj responded that he didn’t know. [ 201 ] Mr. Harrison again asked if Mr. Jivraj had asked Press Progress to hold off publishing the messages, and Mr.
Jivraj responded that he had no control over this. [ 202 ] Cross-examination was adjourned shortly after this line of questioning. It was late on the 4 th day of a 3-day trial. Because of scheduling issues, cross-examination and final argument did not take place until December 13. This was all arranged to take place remotely on Webex. [ 203 ] Before cross-examination resumed, Mr. Harrison submitted a package of additional records that he wanted to introduce for cross-examination purposes.
These records were communications between “Whistleblower” and Luke LeBrun of Press Progress , and recorded telephone calls between Mr. LeBrun and Mr. Jivraj, as well as transcripts of the recordings. As noted above, Press Progress and Mr. LeBrun are Defendants in Ms. Ford’s defamation action, as is Mr. Jivraj. I was asked not to look at the documents until counsel for Press Progress in the defamation action were given an opportunity to address me about them. [ 204 ] Counsel for Press Progress and Mr. LeBrun were present when Court convened.
Counsel advised that her clients did not object to these records being used in this trial but wanted to ensure that I understood that only limited use of these records should be made as Mr. LeBrun was not called to testify about them and could not put them in context for Press Progress . I noted the caution. [ 205 ] When cross-examination of Mr. Jivraj resumed, Mr. Harrison first asked Mr. Jivraj about his previous testimony about the timing of the Press Progress
article in March 2019. Mr. Jivraj said that he had been flustered, and he did not now recall what he said then. [ 206 ] Mr. Harrison confronted Mr. Jivraj with emails he sent to Mr. LeBrun of Press Progress , and transcripts of telephone conversations between Mr. Jivraj and Mr. LeBrun. The first email is dated January 15 from “Whistleblower” asking “Possible to hold off publication of this story for a few days?” Mr. Jivraj acknowledged that he was “Whistleblower”. [ 207 ] The next, dated March 17 attached a photograph of Ms. Ford and Premier Kenney standing together.
That photograph appears in the subsequent Press Progress story on the messages. Mr. Jivraj acknowledged sending that to Mr. LeBrun. [ 208 ] Later on March 17, Whistleblower sent Mr. LeBrun additional information on Ms. Ford and asks, “perhaps I can help find a couple of quotes from “important” people”.
He suggests getting a quote from an imam. [ 209 ] That email ends: The party will come after me relentlessly so this is the one chance to go hard. [ 210 ] After that email, Whistleblower offered to be anonymously quoted saying, amongst other offered quotes: These comments, even privately expressed, are far worse than the “lake of fire” comments. (Referring to homophobic comments made by a Wildrose candidate during the previous Provincial Election that may have cost the Wildrose victory in that election). I know Kenney personally recruited Caylan Ford from Ontario. She was a star candidate, absolutely.
But this is bad. Kenney needs to disqualify her immediately. These comments alone could ruin the campaign. [ 211 ] Mr. Jivraj continued: These comments are without a doubt worse than…anything we have seen to date. Even if elegantly packaged, these words show base anti-Muslim bigotry, period. [ 212 ] When asked about the recorded telephone conversations between him and Mr. LeBrun, Mr. Jivraj acknowledged that the transcripts were accurate.
[ 213 ] In the first telephone conversation, Mr. LeBrun asks Mr. Jivraj if he should release the information “now so Mr. Kenney could disqualify Ms. Ford, or if he should wait”. Mr. Jivraj tells him to hold off and release the information on the eve of the writ drop (the actual calling of the election) “when it will be devastating” and do the most damage. Mr. Jivraj tells Mr. LeBrun “there must be bombshells”. [ 214 ] On redirect, Mr. Jivraj said that Ms. Ford’s narrative suggested that there had been some sort of romantic relationship between them.
He said that had never been the case and he had never suggested that. [ 215 ] He again spoke of the harm done to him by Ms. Ford’s interview on the Danielle Smith show, and the
article “ Apologia ” she had posted on her website. [ 216 ] He stated that he would agree to the entire chain of messages exchanged between himself and Ms. Ford going into evidence. There was a discussion about that and my understanding from that discussion was that the Facebook message exchange had been received from Facebook after a court order was granted directing Facebook to do so. [ 217 ] Mr. Harrison and Mr. Jivraj were directed to review the Facebook messages and attempt to come to agreement on which ones, if any, were relevant and should be put in evidence. [ 218 ] Mr.
Jivraj also wanted to introduce a number of other records that had not been put in evidence. Mr. Harrison objected to this as being too late. [ 219 ] I directed Mr. Jivraj to provide these records to Mr. Harrison by December 21 so that Mr. Harrison could review them and determine if their introduction was acceptable to him. The documents referenced by Mr. Jivraj were given tentative Exhibit numbers to assist with Court record-keeping. [ 220 ] I directed that the parties were to agree on which (if any) of the messages should be put before me.
Any disagreements over these messages were to be resolved by further application before me, if necessary. [ 221 ] Mr. Harrison wrote on December 22 that he had not heard from Mr. Jivraj and he proposed that I conclude the trial without accepting any further evidence. [ 222 ] On December 23, Mr. Jivraj sent Mr. Harrison the proposed exhibits, copying me with his letter and the records he had. With respect to the message exchange, Mr. Jivraj wrote: With regards to Exhibit 14 (Facebook messages exchanged between your client and myself), this would seem to be the Exhibit that will likely be the most contested.
As you will tell, these are select messages from the entire message history. During trial, you were averse to transmitting the entire message history to the Hon. Justice Graesser claiming that it "was over 1300 pages" which I believe to be false, and an attempt to have the most important evidence excluded from this trial. What I would suggest is that you send me the full record of correspondence and we attempt to agree on which pages or excerpts are relevant. [ 223 ] Mr. Harrison wrote me on January 2, 2023 responding to Mr. Jivraj’s email of December 23.
He objected to the introduction of the affidavit from Thomas Code, on the bases that it was hearsay and that had that I had previously refused to allow this to be entered during the trial proper. [ 224 ] Mr. Harrison objected to all of the Facebook messages (proposed Exhibit 14) being admitted on the basis that they were not relevant and were not material. He objected to an October 22, 2022
article from the Western Standard dealing with aspects of the ongoing defamation lawsuit brought by Ms. Ford against Mr. Jivraj and others, on the basis of relevance. Mr. Harrison agreed to admit various postings from Ms. Ford’s website and some Twitter postings by Ms. Ford. [ 225 ] On January 15, Mr. Harrison wrote to me, saying: Mr. Jivraj last communicated on this matter on January 4, 2023. At that time, he said he would furnish a response to our January 2, 2023 letter by January 6, 2023. We did not receive a response from Mr. Jivraj.
I write to request a conference with your Lordship to discuss the foregoing and to conclude the trial. [ 226 ] I replied to Mr. Harrison’s letter on January 24 advising that I would not enter the Thomas Code correspondence. I allowed the Western Standard
article to be admitted on the basis that I interpreted the
article to contain recent comments by Ms. Ford about Mr. Jivraj. [ 227 ] As for the messages between Mr. Jivraj and Ms. Ford, I stated: From the absence of communications between Mr. Jivraj and Mr. Harrison on proposed Exhibit 18, I am assuming that Mr. Jivraj does not intend to pursue entry of these document for the purposes of the trial. [ 228 ] Mr. Harrison wrote back immediately and advised that the comments attributed to Ms. Ford in the Western Standard
article dated back to 2019. [ 229 ] On January 26, Mr. Jivraj wrote to me complaining about my having allowed Mr. Harrison to cross-examine him on the communications he had with Mr. LeBrun at Press Progress about the emails from Ms. Ford that Mr. Jivraj had sent to Press Progress and other media outlets. Mr. Jivraj claimed that my ruling waiving the implied undertaking under Rule 5.33 for these records was unfair and prejudicial to him. He claimed that he was ambushed by this and that he should have been able to question Ms. Ford on records from the defamation action. Mr. Jivraj complained that my ruling in favour of Mr. Harrison’s
application was inconsistent with my not having allowed him to do the same thing in his cross-examination of Ms. Ford. [ 230 ] Mr. Jivraj stated: Given that the trial has not formally concluded, and that functus officio does not apply, the perceived procedural defect may still be cured. I do not seek to delay proceedings or reopen matters already litigated. I simply request the same opportunity afforded to Ms. Ford – namely that I be allowed to rely on the same body of evidence from the parallel action.
I believe the foregoing can be accomplished in a half-day or less, allowing me the opportunity to briefly cross-examine Ms. Ford and to present my own testimony with regards to the evidence I could not previously rely upon. While I am sensitive to concerns about the already prolonged nature of the proceedings, I respectfully submit that a further half-day or less is a reasonable measure to avoid the present trial being tainted by procedural concerns and is a less onerous alternative to both parties having to deal with the very same concerns in the context of an appeal. [ 231 ] Mr.
Jivraj referenced his status as a self-represented litigant and the disadvantages he faces because of his lack of procedural knowledge. He explained that his law degree was in civil law and that he had never been admitted to practice law in any jurisdiction. His articling position in Calgary had been of short duration. [ 232 ] Before replying to Mr. Jivraj, I asked for Mr. Harrison’s comments on Mr. Jivraj’s request. Mr. Harrison wrote me on January 27, opposing the re-opening of the trial. He maintained his opposition to the admission of any of proposed Exhibit 14. Mr. Jivraj responded to Mr.
Harrison’s reply, and Mr. Harrison provided a sur-response. [ 233 ] I wrote the parties on January 30 advising: I have received Mr. Harrison’s response dated January 27, Mr. Jivraj’s reply, and Mr. Harrison’s sur-reply also dated January 27. I do not need any further communications from the parties. I do not see any proper basis for me to open up the trial and permit Mr. Jivraj to call any further evidence. I also do not see any proper basis for me to re-visit any rulings I made during the trial. [ 234 ] I also responded to Mr. Harrison’s objection to the Western Standard
article going into evidence, noting that it may provide context to the action in the context of Mr. Jivraj’s counterclaim for a restraining order against Ms. Ford. [ 235 ] I concluded that letter by saying: I agree with Mr. Harrison’s concerns about the trial continuing through emails. There is no need for any further communications to me until after I have issued a decision in the matter. For record-keeping purposes, I will ensure that the emails exchanged since the trial concluded on December 13 are made an administrative exhibit and placed on the court file. [ 236 ] Notwithstanding that last direction, Mr.
Harrison immediately wrote me noting that Mr. Jivraj’s counterclaim was expressly not part of the hearing before me, referencing the Neufeld and Hunt MacDonald Orders. He maintained that the Western Standard
article should not be admitted. [ 237 ] Mr. Jivraj also wrote to me on January 31. He sought to have 7 other articles from the Western Standard exhibited as he had learned that the
article provided with his letter of December 23 was the last of a series of 8 articles in that publication. Mr. Jivraj sought a hearing before me to deal with the admission of the messages exchanged between him and Ms. Ford in 2017 and 2018. He repeated his request for an opportunity to use materials from the defamation lawsuit in this proceeding. He said that I had denied him that right during the trial and it was improper that I had later allowed Mr. Harrison to do so for cross-examination purposes. [ 238 ] Mr. Ji
[…]
Loading document…