LC v Alberta (Child Welfare), 2023 ABKB 99
Opinion
Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Citation: LC v Alberta (Child Welfare), 2023 ABKB 99 Date: 20230222 Docket: 0703 10836 Registry: Edmonton Between: LC and EMP Plaintiffs - and - His Majesty the King in Right of Alberta As Represented by the Director of Child Welfare Defendants Restriction on Publication Identification Ban – See the Child, Youth and Family Enhancement Act ,
section 126.2. No person shall publish the name or photograph of a child or of the child's parent or guardian in a manner that reveals that the child is receiving, or has received, intervention services. NOTE: Identifying information has been removed from this judgment to comply with the ban so that it may be published. _______________________________________________________ Reasons for Decision of the Honourable Justice Robert A. Graesser _______________________________________________________
Introduction [ 1 ] This is an application to cancel or postpone notices to attend for questioning that had been served on 3 of Defendant’s former employees or officers. The former employees argue that it is premature to have them questioned in the lawsuit. They also refer to a November 2022 decision of Wilson J in this action dealing with similar applications by other former employees and officers. The Applicants argue that the Plaintiff has not demonstrated that any of them has anything relevant and material to say about the lawsuit.
Background [ 2 ] This action is a class proceeding related to the alleged failure of Child Welfare employees and officials to file care plans in a timely way with respect to children under Temporary Guardianship Orders. [ 3 ] The lawsuit has a lengthy history and despite being filed in 2007, questioning has not yet begun. [ 4 ] I have been case managing this action since 2010.
The Government has only recently filed an amended statement of defence, and its affidavit of records was filed on January 31, 2023. [ 5 ] Previous case management meetings set target completion dates for the Government’s statement of defence and affidavit of records. Relying on those dates, it had been arranged between Mr. Lee and Ms. MacDonald that the Government’s officer would be cross-examined on his affidavit of records shortly after it was completed and filed. [ 6 ] Anxious to get the lawsuit moving, Mr.
Lee, Plaintiff’s counsel served notices to attend for questioning on Iris Evans, Neil Dunne KC, Susan Rankin, and Justice Susan Bercov later the same week as was scheduled for the cross-examination of the Government’s officer. [ 7 ] The proposed examinees brought applications to set aside the notice to attend for questioning. [ 8 ] Because one of the proposed examinees is now an Edmonton King’s Bench judge, I felt it was more appropriate to have the application regarding her to be heard by a Calgary judge.
It also made sense to have the other applications heard by the same judge as they raised common issues. [ 9 ] By that time, the Government had filed its amended statement of defence, but had not yet filed its affidavit of records. The Government was also in the process of transferring the defence of the action to outside counsel. [ 10 ] I am not familiar with the materials before Justice Wilson and do not know if affidavits were filed by either side. He cancelled the notices to attend, holding that the notices were premature.
He directed that no further proceedings be taken against these examinees until after the Government had filed its affidavit of records, and proceedings over the completeness of the affidavit had been determined, as well as privilege claims that might be made by the Government.
He also directed that no steps be taken to question the proposed examinees until after the Plaintiff had brought any applications to challenge the sufficiency of the Government’s response to interrogatories. [ 11 ] Justice Wilson seized himself with any issues in connection with the questioning of the Edmonton Justice. [ 12 ] At a case management conference with me in December 2023, new counsel for the Government attended. It was agreed that the Government’s affidavit of records would be filed by January 31. Dates were arranged between Mr. Lee and Ms.
Brasil, new counsel for the Government, for the cross-examination of the Government’s officer. Other dates were tentatively set aside for the commencement of questioning generally. Mr. Lee then served notices to attend for questioning on Gordon Johnston, Richard Ouellet and Nora Diesman. [ 13 ] Those proposed examinees now bring an application to have their notices to attend set aside on the same bases as the previous examinees raised before Justice Wilson. [ 14 ] I heard argument on these motions on January 31, 2023. I was advised that the Government had provided Mr.
Lee with a sworn but unfiled copy of the Government’s affidavit of records. Positions [ 15 ] Mr. Lee argues that he has a right to question whomever he chooses so long as they are subject to questioning under the Rules of Court . He says that each of the proposed examinees is a former employee of the Government, each having worked in a senior position in Child and Family Services at relevant times. There is no issue that each of these people are former employees. I did not require Mr. Lee to provide affidavit evidence as to the roles each of these proposed witnesses played.
I did not require the Applicants to provide affidavit evidence about their positions. The application arose in case management, and in my view, a practical approach should be taken in case management so long as any ultimate process is ultimately fair to all concerned. [ 16 ] Ms.
Kostek, for the witnesses, argues the Plaintiff has not satisfied the onus to demonstrate that the Applicant examinees be questioned in the action. [ 17 ] She also notes that the conditions imposed by Wilson J relating to the proposed examinees he dealt with in December have not yet been complied with. [ 18 ] She submits that the appropriate procedure should be for Mr. Lee to fully question the Government’s officer. Undertakings
should be obtained from the officer requiring him to obtain any requested information from former employees and officers. Only after that has occurred might the Plaintiff be permitted to question any of the former employees. [ 19 ] Ms. Kostek also notes that Mr. Lee has not yet completed the process described by Justice Wilson in his order relating to the Government’s record production, privilege and interrogatories. As such, she argues that it is at a minimum premature for the Plaintiff to begin questioning any witnesses. [ 20 ] Mr.
Lee objects to any requirement being imposed on him as to who he should question and when. He recognizes that if he begins questioning of anyone other than the Government’s officer before all records have been produced, he runs the risk of not being able to question these witnesses on any records produced in the future as a result of any applications for the production of further documents and records. Law [ 21 ] Rule 5.17 governs questioning. It provides: 5.17
(1) A party is entitled to ask the following persons questions under oath about relevant and material records and relevant and material information: (
a) each of the other parties who is adverse in interest; (
b) if the party adverse in interest is a corporation, (
i) one or more officers or former officers of the corporation who have or appear to have relevant and material information that was acquired because they are or were officers of the corporation, and (ii) the corporate representative; (
c) if a litigation representative is appointed for a party, (
i) the litigation representative, and (ii) with the Court’s permission, the person on whose behalf the litigation representative is appointed if that person is competent to give evidence; (
d) one or more other persons who are or were employees of the party adverse in interest who have or appear to have relevant and material information that was acquired because of the employment; (
e) an auditor or former auditor engaged by a party adverse in interest, but not an auditor or former auditor engaged solely for the purpose of the action; (
f) if a partnership is a party adverse in interest, a partner or former partner of the partnership; (
g) in an action with respect to a negotiable instrument or chose in action, (
i) an assignor of the negotiable instrument or chose in action, (ii) a prior endorser, drawer, holder or maker of the negotiable instrument, and (iii) an employee or former employee of an assignor of the negotiable instrument or chose in action, and if the assignor is a corporation, an officer or former officer of the corporation.
(2) If a questioning party questions more than one person of a party adverse in interest under subrule (1) and the person questioned is (
a) an officer or former officer of a corporation described in subrule (1)(b)(i), (
b) an employee or former employee of the party adverse in interest described in subrule (1)(d), (
c) an auditor or former auditor described in subrule (1)(e), (
d) a partner or former partner of a partnership referred to in subrule (1)(f), or (
e) an employee, former employee, officer or former officer described in subrule (1)(g)(iii), other than a corporate representative, the costs of questioning the second and subsequent persons are to be paid by the questioning party unless (
f) the parties otherwise agree, or (
g) the Court otherwise orders.
(3) This rule applies whether the person to be questioned is within or outside the Court’s jurisdiction. [ 22 ] Counsel for the Applicants cites:
a. Alberta-Pacific Forest Industries Inc v Ingersoll-Rand Canada Inc, 2002 ABQB 791; b. Cana Construction Co v Calgary Centre for the Performing Arts, 1996 CarswellAlta 165, 1986 ABCA 175; c. Elliott v Holmwood & Holmwood Ltd, (1915), (BC SC), 9 WWR 490 (ABSC); d. Bell v Klein, (1954), (BC CA), 13 WWR 193 (BCCA); e. Rennie v Elma, (SK KB), [1946] 1 WWR 411 (SKCA); and f. Neon Prod. Ltd v Wiebe, [1974] 3 WWR 567 (MBCC), Analysis [23] There is nothing in the Rules that purports to limit the number of employees or officers or former employees or officers of acorporate party who may be questioned.
That was the conclusion of Master Schlosser in Graham Group Ltd v Labas Estate, 2018ABQB 848, with which I agree. Rule 5.17 only deals with the costs of questioning. A party may question the corporate officer and oneemployee or officer or former employee or officer without cost consequences. [24] Rule 5.19 states: 5.19 On application, the Court may do either or both of the following: (
a) limit the number of persons subject to questioning by a party; (
b) cancel an appointment for questioning that the Court considers unnecessary, improper or vexatious. [25] That Rule was considered by Justice Romaine in Pembina Pipeline Corporation v Coney, 2019 ABQB 699. Initially, thePlaintiff proposed to question 27 employees. The Defendant said that the Plaintiff could question the officer plus 3 additional witnesses.The Plaintiff ultimately wanted to question 7.
The disagreement came to Justice Romaine. [26] It appears that an affidavit had been filed by the Defendant’s officer in the application to limit the number of witnesses to bequestioned. [27] Justice Romaine was the case management judge in that action. She did a careful analysis of some of the issues in that case,admissions that had been previously made, and the stated purpose for wanting to question each of the employees. After doing so, sheconcluded that the Plaintiff had not established that 4 of the proposed witnesses likely had any relevant and material information on theissues in the lawsuit.
The notices to attend on those 4 were cancelled. [28] In this case, The Plaintiff served notices to attend for questioning on these 3 witnesses, presumably with appropriate conductmoney. The examinees hired counsel to set aside the notices to attend. They provided no evidence or information suggesting that theydid not have relevant and material information. Rather, they seek to set aside the notices on the basis that the Plaintiff has not satisfiedthe onus on them to demonstrate that the examinees might have such knowledge.
The Plaintiff did not respond to the application withaffidavit evidence as to what the Plaintiff hoped to accomplish in questioning these witnesses. [29] There are two possible courses of action in a situation like this. If proposed examinees wish to set aside the notices to attend,they may bring an application. Or the party for whom the proposed examinees work or worked can bring an application to limit thenumber of witnesses to be examined. Here, the Defendant Government has essentially taken a neutral position.
They have, for example,not assisted the Plaintiff in locating any of these witnesses, nor has the Government accepted service of any of the notices to attend. ThePlaintiff has been on its own to arrange this. But they have not actively supported the Applicants in this application. I do not know whattheir position was before Justice Wilson. [30] The Government is not representing these witnesses on the application. Importantly, they have not brought any application tolimit the number of witnesses the Plaintiff may question in this lawsuit.
That does not mean that they will not do so at some stage,especially if they think the Plaintiffs’ questioning is straying outside relevance and materiality and getting into improper or vexatiousconduct. [31] My
interpretation of the Rules is that only a party may bring an application under Rule 5.19(a). An employee or formeremployee is not a party to the litigation and has no status to bring such an application. That is a choice for the party to make or theparty’s lawyer, not the choice of an employee or a former employee. Former employees cannot meddle in the underlying litigation. Theyare merely witnesses. The parties themselves control the overall process. [32] With applications under Rule 5.19(b), either the party or the proposed witness may make such an application.
In most cases itwill likely be the opposing party bringing the application. In either case, the onus is on the applicant to satisfy the Court that theproposed questioning is unnecessary, vexatious, or improper. In the first instance the questioning party does not have to demonstrateanything. Serving a notice to attend for questioning with appropriate conduct money is enough to require a witness to attend, unless theCourt intervenes.
Counsel are officers of the Court and in my view should be assumed to be acting properly until the contrary is proven. [33] When a witness makes an application under Rule 5.19(b), the onus is on the witness to demonstrate that their questioningwould be unnecessary, improper or vexatious. The witness, not the party wishing to question the witness, bears the burden of proof. [34] Here, there is no affidavit in support of the application to cancel the notices to attend. The grounds are set out in the notice ofapplication. I am of the view that it is not always necessary for an applicant under Rule 5.19(
a) to file affidavit evidence in support of the
application. It may be possible to establish a lack of necessity, or vexatious or improper conduct without affidavit evidence. [ 35 ] Indeed, a person opposing questioning would probably be reluctant to provide affidavit evidence as to why they should not be questioned. Alberta’s Rules of Court and civil practice give a near right to cross-examine anyone who swears an affidavit in support of a motion.
Someone opposing being questioned would essentially offer themselves up for cross-examination. [ 36 ] There are of course differences between questioning and cross-examination and the causes that can be put to answers but having to file an affidavit in support of an application to cancel a notice to attend would in many circumstances be counterproductive. [ 37 ] Applications such as this should be done quickly and hopefully before the specified date for the questioning. Otherwise, there will be delay. Outside case management, there needs to be a notice of application specifying the grounds for the application.
In most cases, this process should be completed in morning chambers with the normal notice requirement. The parties should argue their positions and the applications judge or chambers judge should make a call. [ 38 ] I am reluctant to see a process as simple as trying to cancel a notice to attend turn into a special chambers application with affidavits, cross-examinations on affidavits, and opposing briefs. Doing so in application judges’ special chambers or judges’ special chambers will inevitably add a minimum of six months to a process that is already languid.
That is contrary to the foundational rules of efficiency and economy. [ 39 ] Here, the application was made in case management. The case management judge is required to hear all applications unless they allow or direct the application to be heard by another judge or an application judge. Case management allows for some informality in the process because the case management judge is familiar with the lawsuit and the necessary background and context for the application.
The case management judge is also well positioned to understand the dynamics between counsel and the parties themselves. [ 40 ] Counsel are officers of the Court. If someone wants to set aside a notice to attend, or respond to that application, it is not always necessary for affidavits to be filed for all applications in case management. Indeed, it is not always necessary for there to be a formal notice of application.
Depending on the particular style and requirements of the case management judge, it may suffice to have a case management meeting arranged, and for there to be an agenda of the topics to be discussed. [ 41 ] Many things in case management are achieved by consensus, or by a direction from the case management judge after discussion of the issue. Orders are not always taken out. Sometimes there are minutes, and in other cases, the judge may confirm what has been agreed or directed. [ 42 ] In many cases, counsel can simply state their positions.
Counsel should be trusted to have been forthright and accurate in their submissions and responses, unless there is reason not to do so. Not everything needs to be done so that there is a complete record for the Court of Appeal to review. If counsel wants to set aside a notice to attend for questioning of an employee or former employee, I do not think it is usually necessary for there to be affidavits setting out why the person should not be questioned or for examining counsel to putting in affidavit form their reasons for wanting to question the person and what information counsel expects the person to have.
A discussion in case management should in most cases be capable of resolving that. [ 43 ] Case management is now almost always conducted in a courtroom with the FTR running, so a record of the proceedings can always be obtained if necessary for the purpose of settling any disagreements over what was agreed, directed, or ordered, and for the purposes of any appeals. [ 44 ] The application before Romaine J in Pembina Pipelines v Coney demonstrates how an application to limit the number of witnesses might proceed. There, the parties had discussions themselves as to the scope of questioning.
The Defendants initially said they wanted to question 28 employees and former employees. Pembina objected. Ultimately the Defendants settled on 7 witnesses. Pembina objected to 4 of them and brought an application before the case management judge. [ 45 ] From the decision, it is clear that Mr. Coney swore an affidavit opposing Pembina’s application. It is not clear if Pembina filed an affidavit in support of their application. Instead, they may simply have relied on Mr. Coney’s affidavit and cross-examination and their submissions to the case management judge.
I assume that Justice Romaine concluded that Pembina met the primary onus on them before placing any onus on the Defendants. [ 46 ] I do not read that decision as holding that the respondent to an application under Rule 5.19(
a) bears the onus on the application. The case may demonstrate that an applicant is not always required to file affidavit evidence on this type of application. Each case, especially cases in case management, will have their own dynamics and a case management judge is usually in the best position to decide what they need to make a fair decision. [ 47 ] In any event, I will treat the application before me as an application under Rule 5.19(
b) as I have concluded that the Applicants here do not have the status to make an application to limit the number of witnesses. [ 48 ] As I have said, the applicant bears the onus of proof on this application, at least at the initial stage. Onuses are transient things. [ 49 ] Here, neither party provided any affidavit evidence. The Applicants did not file a notice of application. Rather, they contacted me as case management judge to set down a hearing so their application to set aside the notices of application could be heard.
The Applicants provided a written brief and made oral submissions; the Plaintiffs relied on their oral submissions at the case management conference. [ 50 ] The process used here did not and does not trouble me. I do not think case management requires formalities so long as matters can be dealt with informally but fairly. [ 51 ] It was never suggested that the Applicants were not former employees, or that they did not have relevant and material
information they might properly be questioned on at some stage of the proceedings. [ 52 ] Instead, they argued that there might be other people with more or better knowledge than they had. With respect, that is not the test. The examining party is entitled to select those people they want to question, at least in the first instance.
There may well be people with more knowledge, but it is not for the opposing party to say who should be questioned. [ 53 ] They also argued that in a similar application before Justice Wilson, he directed that no applications be made to question the former employees before him until objections to the sufficiency of the Defendant’s affidavit of records had been resolved, and issues over the sufficiency of the Defendant’s response to interrogatories had been resolved. [ 54 ] With respect, that was the conclusion Justice Wilson came to on the evidence and submissions before him, the status of the litigation at the time of the application, and the particular witnesses before him.
I do not think he was planning on setting any precedents; rather he was dealing with a somewhat urgent application that needed a prompt decision. [ 55 ] On an ongoing basis, once the parties have filed affidavits of records, there are a lot of steps that can take place concurrently.
The step-by-step approach, where one step has to be fully completed before the next step begins, will undoubtedly cause unnecessary delays [ 56 ] The condition for questioning specified by the Rules is that the employee or officer or former employee “have or appear to have relevant and material information that was acquired because of the employment”. [ 57 ] There is a very low threshold for determining that qualification. In almost all cases, the examining party simply serves a notice to attend.
No affidavit or evidence supporting the notice to attend is required. [ 58 ] There is also nothing in the Rules that specifies or directs the order of questioning of the other side’s officer and employees and former employees. That is generally a matter for counsel’s strategic determination. There are sometimes good reasons to question a corporate officer first, to get an overview of the party’s case as well as to canvas admissions. There are also good reasons to wait to question the officer until after other witnesses for that party have been questioned [ 59 ] The cases referenced by Ms.
Kostek are all cases dealing with the questioning of “near employees” such as independent contractors and advisors. They have no application to the questioning of former employees and officers and I need not deal with them further. [ 60 ] There is also no basis under the Rules of Court or under Alberta law to require opposing counsel to request that the corporate officer get information from a current or former employee or officer by way of undertaking.
That can certainly be done (subject to relevance and materiality) but opposing counsel has a right to question the employee or officer themselves, and not to get answers to the undertakings crafted by counsel and not the actual words of the employee or officer. [ 61 ] These basic principles are subject to the foundational rules. Those rules are particularly significant when lawsuits are being case managed. Case management generally arises when the parties are not able to manage the litigation efficiently and effectively themselves and need a judge to direct things.
Class proceedings are by statute required to be case managed, although even in class proceedings, active case management is not necessary unless or until the parties need the Court’s assistance. Judges do not usually force themselves on the parties and instead wait for the parties to come to Court when they cannot resolve things themselves. It is often forgotten that one of the objectives of the 2010 rules of Court was to respect party autonomy and to reinforce that control of the litigation was the parties’ responsibility.
Decision [ 62 ] Here, it is obvious from the myriad of issues that have arisen in this lawsuit over the past 16 years that case management has been necessary. I can fairly observe that counsel have been able to agree on very little. [ 63 ] I have no issue with Justice Wilson’s determination in December 2022 that any questioning was premature. The Government was changing counsel. New counsel obviously needed time to get up to speed. The long-awaited affidavit of records had not been filed, and new counsel needed more time to do so. [ 64 ] Efficiency alone dictated that it was too soon to start questioning.
Setting aside the notices to attend that were before him was the right thing to do at the time. That said, I do not see that Justice Wilson’s order binds me to apply the same terms and conditions to the questioning of other witnesses. [ 65 ] I am satisfied that the proposed examinees are all former employees of the Government. That was not challenged by their counsel. In the context of employees or former employees, I do not think that examining counsel needs to provide any detail in advance as to what they want to question the employee about.
There is a presumptive right to question employees and former employees so long as examining counsel has an honest belief that the witness may have some information that is relevant and material to one or more of the issues in the lawsuit. [ 66 ] If an employee believes that they have absolutely no knowledge or information of any aspect of the lawsuit, or believe that their questioning would be frivolous, vexatious or an abuse of process, they may make an application to set aside the notice to attend on that basis.
That is what a happened here. [ 67 ] I am not satisfied that the proposed questioning of any of these witnesses falls into any of the categories under Rule 5.19(b). There is nothing improper about a Plaintiff wanting to question a variety of employees of a corporate defendant where the lawsuit has many issues and relates to a large number of acts committed by a large number of employees and officers to a large number of people over a number of years. This is not a simple breach of contract case or wrongful dismissal case.
[ 68 ] I might draw an analogy to a medical malpractice case. The plaintiff may have been treated by a number of staff doctors. There may have been nurses’ notes prepared by dozens of nurses. Tests may have been ordered on numerous occasions and results interpreted by numerous technologists and radiologists. I cannot imagine a situation where the court might order that the plaintiff complete its questioning of the officer before permitting questioning of the actual treating personnel.
I also cannot imagine a situation where the court might order the plaintiff to funnel all of its questions of the various doctors, nurses, radiologists and technologists through the corporate officer. Defendants should not be able to tell Plaintiffs who they can examine and in what order they should be examined and require a roadmap of each questioning in advance.
This is an adversarial system and the rules need to be balanced and fair to both sides. [ 69 ] Here, this is a lawsuit that involves hundreds if not thousands of plaintiffs in the two certified classes and it deals with practices and policies that were developed over a number of years by a number of Government employees and officers. These practices and policies were interpreted and applied by any number of other employees and officers.
Each of the child plaintiffs was in the system and likely dealt with a number of child protection workers who believed they were acting in accordance with policies and procedures set in their office and overseen by management in their particular office as well as higher up in the organization. [ 70 ] At this stage in the litigation, I see no reason to limit the Plaintiff’s ability to question employees and former employees as they select. There is in any event no application before me to do so.
I see no valid reason to direct that the Government’s officer be questioned first, and I do not think it is appropriate for me to direct the Plaintiff to seek information from the officer before directly questioning other witnesses who are prima facie subject to being questioned under the Rules. [ 71 ] This of course may change as questioning progresses, but at this stage I believe it would be inappropriate to impose any limitations beyond those that are already present in the Rules. [ 72 ] Mr.
Lee is well aware of the risks he takes by questioning witnesses before all records have been produced, but he is also entitled to rely on the Government’s affidavit of records to contain all relevant and material records in the Government’s possession or control relating to the matters in issue. There is no requirement on a party to ever acknowledge that they are satisfied with the other party’s record production.
Silence or the absence of applications for further record production creates no estoppel on the receiving party. [ 73 ] All of these are strategic decisions for counsel, and the Court should be slow to interfere with these and would need sound reasons to do so. As a result, I dismiss the application to strike the notices to attend. Questioning of these former employees should proceed without any preconditions. Heard on the 31 st day of January, 2023. Dated at the City of Edmonton, Alberta this 22 nd day of February, 2023. Robert A. Graesser J.C.K.B.A. Appearances: Robert P.
Lee Victims Rights Law for the Plaintiffs Luciana Brasil, Branch McMaster Alberta Justice for the Defendants
Amanda Kostek, CBM LLP, for the Proposed Examinees
Loading document…