Vogler v. Szendroi, 2011 NSSC 13
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: Vogler v. Szendroi, 2011 NSSC 13 Date: 20110113 Docket: Hfx No. 192712 Registry: Halifax Between: Richard Vogler Plaintiff and Christopher Szendroi and Carole Sheehan Defendants DECISION on COSTS Judge: The Honourable Justice Gerald R. P. Moir Heard: On Written Submissions Last Written Submissions: November 23, 2010 Counsel: Jason Gavras, for the plaintiff Jean McKenna, Lisa Richards, and Kyla Russell, for the defendants Moir, J. :
[1] Mr. Vogler sued for damages resulting from serious injuries he suffered in a car crash. He was awarded $373,825 inprincipal including $46,075 for medical expenses payable to the government, the amount of which had been agreed subject to acontribution for contributory negligence. [2] The injuries occurred in 2000 and the action was started in 2003. The Tariff that was adopted in 2004 does not apply. Weare under the old Tariff. [3] The "amount involved" for the purposes of the tariffs is $373,825. I would not exclude the amount recovered for thegovernment.
Quantification of that amount was agreed to, but no payment was made. [4] In my assessment, the case was of ordinary complexity and demands. I would apply the basic scale. [5] The result, under the old Tariff, would be about $16,500. It is patent that this would not provide a substantial contributiontoward "what would generally or ordinarily be charged to a client in like circumstances": Campbell v.
Jones, 2001 NSSC 139 ,[2001] N.S.J. 373 (S.C.) at para. 69 reversed on other grounds, but followed on costs, in 2002 NSCA 128 , [2002] N.S.J. 450(C.A.) para. 74 and para. 419. [6] The purpose of an award of costs is to provide the successful party with a partial but substantial indemnification. Where, ashere, it is established that the applicable Tariff fails that purpose, judges often exercise their discretion to increase or decrease costs fromthe tariff amount. I have determined to do so. [7] How much ought the increase to be?
I can look to the new Tariff for guidance in a case, like this one, in which the old Tarifffails to meet the purpose of an award of costs. The amount would be $34,750 under the new Tariff. [8] Mr. Vogler made an offer to settle under Rule 10.05 that was "not withdrawn" and that was more favourable to the otherparties than was the result at trial: Rule 10.09(1). That offer was made shortly before trial.
The offer would likely have given rise to theexercise of the discretion to increase the tariff amount by twenty-five percent: Rule 10.09(2)(d). [9] Taking into account the guidance provided by the new Tariff about what will usually provide a substantial but partialindemnification, my general knowledge of the cost of litigation, the likely demands of a case like this one, and the justice in increasingcosts for a litigant who makes a favourable offer to settle, I will order that Mr. Vogler have judgment for costs in the amount of $45,000plus disbursements. J.
Loading document…