Allterrain Contracting Inc. v. Rockwork Construction Ltd., 2011 NSSC 212
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: Allterrain Contracting Inc. v. Rockwork Construction Ltd., 2011 NSSC 212 Date: 20110602 Docket: Hfx No. 344331 Registry: Halifax Between: Allterrain Contracting Inc. Applicant and Rockwork Construction Limited Respondent LIBRARY HEADING Judge : The Honourable Justice Gerald R. P. Moir Heard: May 26, 2011 Subjects: Builders' Lien Act , expiry of lien, registration of claim, repair work.
Summary: Rockwork did drilling and blasting for Allterrain under a verbal lump sum contract. Rockwork registered a claim for lien more than sixty days after Allterrain says the contract was complete. Rockwork did work later, but Allterrain says the work was for repair of deficiencies. It moved for an order declaring the lien expired. Issues: Whether claim for lien was registered in time? Result: Not all the work was for repair and, in any case, the contract was not complete when the work was done. Motion dismissed. THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE
DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET. SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: Allterrain Contracting Inc. v. Rockwork Construction Ltd., 2011 NSSC 212 Date: 20110602 Docket: Hfx No. 344331 Registry: Halifax Between: Allterrain Contracting Inc. Applicant and Rockwork Construction Limited Respondent DECISION Judge: The Honourable Justice Gerald R. P. Moir Heard: May 26, 2011 Counsel: James D. MacNeil, for applicant Douglas R. Stevenson, for respondent Moir, J. :
[ 1 ] Introduction . Rockwork Construction Limited did drilling and blasting for Allterrain Contracting Inc. at an apartment building development in Bedford. Rockwork filed a claim for lien. Allterrain applied for an order that the lien is not valid. [ 2 ] Allterrain says that the claim for lien was filed more than sixty days after the date of completion of the blasting contract and Rockwork lost its rights to a lien when the registration period expired. Rockwork says the contract was completed much later than the date suggested by Allterrain.
Allterrain replies that work done by Rockwork after the date of completion involved only repair of deficiencies. Rockwork disagrees. [ 3 ] I have to decide whether Rockwork's lien rights expired before it registered the claim for lien. [ 4 ] Evidence. I have two affidavits from a CEO of Allterrain, Mr. Andrew Rodgers, and I heard him on cross-examination. I have affidavits from the owner and manager of Rockwork, Mr. David MacDougall, and one of his employees, Mr. Joseph Bennett. I heard Mr. MacDougall on cross-examination. [ 5 ] Findings of Fact . Allterrain is in the business of preparing sites for construction.
This is its eighth year in business. Rockwork and Mr. MacDougall have been in the business of blasting rock since the early 1980s. [ 6 ] Last summer, Allterrain and Rockwork agreed that Rockwork would do necessary blasting at the Bedford development for a lump sum of $235,000. The contract was not in writing. The work required was depicted on a site plan, but the parties disagree on what plan was used and what it depicted. [ 7 ] The parties also disagree about an agreed completion date. [ 8 ] Mr.
Rodgers swore "The agreement was that Rockwork would complete the drilling and rock-blasting...between July 30, 2010 and September 2, 2010." However, in cross-examination it was established that "The execution of his work was going to take four weeks" and the drilling began before July 30, 2010, before the contract was made. Mr. Rodgers told me that he asked Mr. MacDougall what the term would be, and MacDougall said four weeks. [ 9 ] Mr.
MacDougall swears that "At no time did Rockwork agree to a completion date … ." Allterrain had to remove overburden, and otherwise expose the rock, and its surveyor had to lay out accurate grades on the exposed rock, before Rockwork could do the blasting. He could not agree to a completion date because his company was at the mercy of Allterrain. [ 10 ] On the stand, Mr. MacDougall speculated that Mr. Rodgers was referring to a conversation around the time of contracting in which Mr. Rodgers asked how long it would take Rockwork to do all the blasting and Mr.
MacDougall may have said it could be done in four weeks if the work was fully supported by Allterrain. [ 11 ] I find there was no term for completion by a specific date. It can be difficult to piece together the terms of a construction contract made verbally. What was intended to be a term and what was mere discussion? My assessment of the evidence given by the men who made the verbal contract is that they discussed the time it would take for Rockwork to do the required work, but they made no agreement for a completion date. [ 12 ] Further, I accept Mr. MacDougall's evidence about the discussion.
The parties discussed Rockwork's requirement for diligence on the part of Allterrain for Rockwork to complete the blasting quickly.
[ 13 ] Allterrain says that Rockwork caused delay. Rockwork says that Allterrain caused delay. [ 14 ] In the first of his affidavits, Mr. Rodgers says that "On September 2, 2010 ... Rockwork had only completed approximately sixty percent of the work ...". He explained in cross-examination that Rockwork used broken equipment, insufficient manpower, and incompetent staff. However, no evidentiary basis was offered for these conclusions. Also, I doubt that Mr. Rodgers had much opportunity to observe events that could found these conclusions. [ 15 ] In his affidavit, Mr.
MacDougall swears that eighty percent of the work was done by the end of August. About that time Allterrain halted work on this project to concentrate on others, according to Mr. MacDougall. He claims that later Allterrain moved men and equipment back to the site and blasting was accomplished during September, October, and early November, 2010. [ 16 ] Rockwork billed for about sixty percent of the contract amount in September. Although Mr. MacDougall estimated that eighty percent of the work was complete, his policy is to be conservative on progress billing. [ 17 ] According to Mr.
MacDougall work halted again in early November. He visited the site often after that to see whether Allterrain was making any progress with site preparation. As proof that Rockwork was ready to return, Mr. MacDougall points out that he left a blasting mat on site. [ 18 ] Mr. Rodgers says that Rockwork was not expected back on the site after early November. He says that everyone thought Rockwork's work was complete.
He cannot be certain, but he seems to recall that Allterrain was on site, breaking up larger rocks, in November and December. [ 19 ] So, once again we find these two men seriously at odds about what happened. [ 20 ] Rockwork returned to the site for four days last January. Mr. MacDougall says his firm came there to complete the contract, Allterrain having finally uncovered and graded most of the remaining rock. Mr. Rodgers says that the rock had been uncovered and graded before work stopped in early November, and that Rockwork returned to repair deficiencies in its work. [ 21 ] Mr.
MacDougall prepared an invoice for the balance of the lump sum early in December. Mr. Rodgers takes this as evidence that MacDougall thought the contract was complete. I do not see it that way. [ 22 ] The parties agree the invoice was not delivered to Allterrain until early January, just before Rockwork returned to the site. Why wait for a month after completion of the contract to bill for it? Why wait another month to deliver the bill? Mr. MacDougall explains that he has to do all of the paperwork for Rockwork, keep the books, look after such things as HST, as well as bid for and manage contracts.
He prepares an invoice when he can. Often these remain in his truck for some time before the day of completion arrives. [ 23 ] I accept that explanation. I find that Mr. MacDougall prepared the invoice and held onto it because he did not regard the contract as complete. I accept that he frequently checked the site for progress, in the hope that his firm could finish the contract and bill for it. I find that between last November and last January, Mr. MacDougall knew there was more work to be done by his firm under the contract. [ 24 ] According to Mr.
Rodgers there were serious deficiencies in the work done by Rockwork in and before November. He claims that all overburden had been removed and all lines had been surveyed and marked so as to guide Rockwork's drilling and blasting. However, Allterrain discovered that the blasting was deficient.
[ 25 ] In his affidavits, Mr. Rodgers only refers to deficiencies generally. On the stand, he said that his firm discovered the deficiencies in early January when Allterrain attempted to lay pipe. The blasting had not achieved required depths and widths. Also, places for storm drains showing on the plan had not been blasted at all. In one part, unblasted rock stood out visibly in between two lines of blasting for a thoroughfare. Clearly the surveyor must have marked the line from beginning to end. [ 26 ] I am not certain how much Mr.
Rodgers relies on personal observation for the generalizations he swore to about the work last summer. I have sound indications that his evidence about the state of affairs last winter was based to a significant degree on hearsay. [ 27 ] Mr. Rodgers relies explicitly on hearsay from his brother, and co-CEO, about discussions in January "to have Mr. MacDougall fix deficiencies". I can give this no weight. See, Rule 5.13. [ 28 ] When he was on the stand, it became clear that Mr. Rodgers had no direct knowledge about the discovery of, and response to, the "deficiencies".
He said that the pipe foeman discovered them, he got the surveyor to confirm them, and the foreman then went to Mr. Rodgers' brother. [ 29 ] Furthermore, Mr. Rodgers was only on the site in January once for sure, twice possibly. His visit, or visits, lasted an hour or two. [ 30 ] I prefer the evidence of Mr. MacDougall and Mr. Bennett on what happened in January. Mr. MacDougall was at the site frequently, and Mr. Bennett was there to supervise. [ 31 ] Mr. MacDougall swore that, in January, "Allterrain finally laid out and exposed the various work areas". Mr.
Rodgers said this was done for a second time after the insufficient blasting covered up some of the lines. However, Mr. MacDougall said that overburden was removed in January. Some trees even had to be cut. [ 32 ] Mr. MacDougall said that the visible unblasted rock was not in the path of a correctly marked thoroughfare line. Rather, Allterrain had misaligned the path the first time. Also, the catch basins were identified for future development on the site plan he says Mr. Rodgers gave to him. That work is claimed as an extra. [ 33 ] Mr.
Bennett swore that work in January on the main thoroughfare to the intended location of apartment buildings and on a
section of roadway curb was necessary because the lines for these had been laid out incorrectly by Allterrain. He swore that the storm drains had not been included in the contract and he had a conversation with the other CEO, Mr. Andrew Rodgers' brother, on January 12, 2011 in which Allterrain, through the other CEO, agreed to pay for this work as an extra. And, he says that the areas to blast three of the catch basins were never uncovered and marked before January 12, 2011. [ 34 ] As I said, Mr. Bennett supervised the work done in January.
His evidence is based on personal knowledge. [ 35 ] I find as a fact that work remained to be done under the contract between Allterrain and Rockwork after November of 2010. Whether or not Allterrain's officers thought the work was complete, I find that Mr. MacDougall knew that work remained to be done, I find that some of the work that remained to be done required excavation and survey work by Allterrain that had not been done before. I find that Rockwork remained ready to complete the work so it could submit an invoice for the balance of the lump sum price. [ 36 ] Lien Registration, Deficiencies, and Extras .
Section 6 of the Builders' Lien Act gives a contractor like Rockwork a lien on the property it works on, and it does so without requiring any formality. However, s. 25 takes the lien away when a claim for lien is not registered within the required time. [ 37 ] The time for registration of a claim for Rockwork lien was "before or during the performance of the contract, or within sixty
days after the completion or abandonment thereof", if the contract is regarded as being for both goods and services, and "at any timeduring the performance of the service or within sixty days after the completion of the service" if the contract is regarded as being forservices only: s. 24(1) and s. 24(3).
I am inclined to the view that blasting contracts of the kind between Rockwork and Allterrain arefor services only, because the required materials are incidental to the service and are consumed when the service is rendered. [38] It was submitted for Rockwork that the definition of substantial performance in s. 13(1) may assist its position. In myassessment, it has no application to the provisions about creation or expiry of the lien. The definition is controlled by the phrase "In thisSection".
Section 13 is about holdbacks, not the creation of liens, the subject of Sections 6 and 45, or the expiry of liens, the subject ofSections 25, 26, and 27. [39] Ours is not one of those jurisdictions in which a certificate of substantial completion will start a registration period to run. Theconcept of substantial performance is not relevant here.
Section 24 requires more than substantial performance for the registrationperiod to begin to run. It runs after completion or abandonment of the contract under s. 24(1) or completion of the service under s.24(3). See, Fred Pierce Ltd. v.
Troke , [1957] N.S.J. 8 (S.C. in banco) where the Chief Justice commented on the possible ("may")inapplicability of substantial performance to the running of the registration period before he embarked on a discussion of substantialperformance in relation to the release of a holdback. [40] Allterrain relies on a series of decisions to the effect that repairing deficiencies does not extend the time for filing. Mr.MacNeil refers me to David I. Bristow, Duncan W. Glaholt, R. Bruce Reynolds and Howard M.
Wise, Construction, Builders' andMechanics' Liens in Canada, looseleaf (Toronto, Carswell, 2009) at p. 6-62 where the authors say "Doing work ... to rectify defective orimproper workmanship ... will not generally extend the time for filing the Claim for Lien." They cite ten decisions including one fromNova Scotia. [41] McLanders Contractors Ltd. v. Eastern Flying Services Ltd., (NS SC), [1982] N.S.J. 69 (Co. Ct.) was adecision of Judge Peter O' Hearn. In those days the registration period was forty-five days after completion.
The claimant had not beenon the site for nearly six months before it registered the claim. [42] McLanders was the general contractor to build a hangar for Eastern Flying Services. It subcontracted Ocean Contractors to dopaving. Ocean refused to guarantee some work it was required to do in cold weather. The next Spring, the owner paid Ocean to makenecessary repairs. [43] Judge O'Hearn rejected McLanders' arguments that the work in the Spring kept the lien alive and the contract remained to befinished, albeit that it was finished under a contract between the owner and the subcontractor.
There were several bases for JudgeO'Hearn's conclusion including that the repairs were not part of the work to be completed by the contractor.
However, he went furtherand pointed out at para. 17: In general, it has been held that repairs, even when the contractor or subcontractor is fully responsible for them, do not serve to maintaina lien when the condition calling for repairs arises subsequent to the completion of the work. [44] I have read the other cases cited by the authors of Bristow but none give greater precision to the principle and many aredecided under legislation that differs from ours. [45] Judge O'Hearn's way of stating the principle is faithful to the legislation, which starts the registration period on completion ofthe contract or services.
Did the lien claimant come back to make repairs after the contract was complete, or did it do work under thecontract, before completion? [46] Conclusion. Even on Allterrain's assertion of the facts, some of the work done in January was required to complete thecontract. Blasting for the storm drains remained to be done. The visible rock protruding along what Mr. Rodgers took to be a single lineshowed unfinished work. Even on that version of events, Rockwork's labours last January could not be described as repairs aftercompletion.
[ 47 ] However, I have found that the contract was incomplete as of last November, Mr. MacDougall knew his firm had more work to do, the work could not be done until Allterrain excavated and surveyed areas it had not excavated before, and Rockwork was ready to finish the contract in January. This was not a case of repair, let alone repair after completion. [ 48 ] I will dismiss the application. Rockwork will have costs of $1500 plus disbursements. J.
Loading document…