Seguin v. MacDonald, 2011 NSSC 26
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Seguin v. MacDonald, 2011 NSSC 26 Date: 20110114 Docket: SFHF-13113 Registry: Halifax Between: Tabitha Seguin Petitioner v. Ricky MacDonald and Angela MacDonald Respondents LIBRARY HEADING Judge: The Honourable Justice Elizabeth Jollimore Heard: January 14, 2011 Written Decision: January 26, 2011 Subject : Application to vary summer access terms Result : Variation application granted to specify summer access weeks while request to increase interval of alternation from one week to two weeks denied. THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET .
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Seguin v. MacDonald, 2011 NSSC 26 Date: 20110114 Docket: SFHF-13113 Registry: Halifax Between: Tabitha Seguin Petitioner v. Ricky MacDonald and Angela MacDonald Respondent Judge: The Honourable Justice Elizabeth Jollimore Heard: January 14, 2011 Written Decision: January 26, 2011 Counsel: Tabitha Seguin Ricky MacDonald and Angela MacDonald By the Court: Introduction [ 1 ] Early in the summer of 2010, Tabitha Seguin applied to vary the terms of an order relating to the summer access that she has with her daughter, Jewel MacDonald.
Summer access last year was resolved by an emergency application. Ms. Seguin, Ricky MacDonald (Jewel's father) and Angela MacDonald (Jewel's stepmother) participated in a settlement conference where they were able to resolve other matters relating to Jewel's parenting. However, they were unable to resolve the matter of future summer access, so I heard
Ms. Seguin's application. [2] Each of the parties filed more than one affidavit addressing summer access. None of the parties wanted to question anyoneabout the affidavits that were filed, so the application proceeded on the basis of the filed documents and submissions by Ms. Seguin andby Ms. MacDonald, who spoke on behalf of her husband and herself. [3] I rendered an oral decision at the conclusion of the hearing. Neither party has counsel and each had questions and commentsduring my decision. I am providing this written decision to make clear my decision and the reasons for it.
Applying to vary a parenting order [4] I'm governed by Gordon v. Goertz, (S.C.C.) in making a decision to vary parenting arrangements. Atparagraph 10 of the majority reasons, then-Justice McLachlin instructs me that before I can consider the merits of a variation application,I must be satisfied there has been a material change in Jewel's circumstances that has occurred since the last custody order was made. [5] At paragraph 13, Justice McLachlin was more specific in identifying the three requirements that must be satisfied before I canconsider an application to vary a parenting order.
The requirements are: 1. there must be a change in the condition, means, needs or circumstances of the child or the ability of the parents to meet the needs ofthe child; 2. the change must materially affect the child; and 3. the change was either not foreseen or could not have been reasonably contemplated by the judge who made the initial order. [6] Material change is more than a threshold to be crossed before varying a parenting order. All parenting applications, includingvariation applications, are determined on the basis of a child's best interests.
Initially proving that there has been a material changeestablishes that the current order is no longer in the child's best interests. Then, section 17(5) of the Divorce Act, R.S.C. 1985 (2ndSupp.), c. 3 instructs me that in making the variation order, I shall consider only the best interests of the child as determined by referenceto that change. I note this particularly because of its importance in terms of the case a parent must make when applying to vary aparenting order. [7] While this application is made pursuant to the Maintenance and Custody Act, R.S.N.S. 1989, c. 160, as I have noted inHarrison v.
MacKinnon, 2010 NSSC 445 at paragraph 7, the consideration of best interests mandated by the Divorce Act is equallyrelevant to this application and parents' marital status is no reason to analyse the cases differently:
section 18 of the Maintenance andCustody Act requires that "[i]n any proceeding under this Act concerning care and custody or access and visiting privileges in relation to achild, the court shall apply the principle that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration." [8] On her own behalf and on behalf of her husband, Ms. MacDonald argued there has been no material change since the lastorder relating to summer access was granted. Ms.
Seguin says there is a need to change the summer access to be more strictly definedbecause, while it had been possible in the past to arrange summer access flexibly, this has not occurred in the last few summers with theresult that her time with Jewel has been compromised by the need to
schedule and re-schedule time at the requests of the MacDonalds. She also described, as did Mr. MacDonald, instances of conflict between the parties that arose because of the scheduling difficulties. [9] Ms. MacDonald referred me to my own decision in Giffin v. Lunn, 2010 NSSC 413 in support of her submission that therewas no material change in circumstances. In Giffin v. Lunn, 2010 NSSC 413, Mr. Lunn argued that conflict between the adults involvedin the girls' lives was a material change.
I rejected this and, at paragraph 11 of that decision, said I wasn't persuaded that a single instanceof conflict in the presence of the children proved that the girls' needs or the parents' ability to meet them had materially changed.
[10] In contrast with the circumstances in Giffin v. Lunn, 2010 NSSC 413, this is a case where the conflict between the parties issufficient to warrant a change to the current order. The current order requires that the parties, in essence, negotiate the terms of eachsummer's access within a context of weekly alternation. Even within that context, which would seem to limit the amount of conflictwhich could arise, conflict does arise. It arises over the exchange time. It arises over the date when an exchange will occur. It arisesover where exchanges will occur. It arises in the frequent efforts to change the
schedule once it has been set. The level of mistrust issuch that even after last summer's access
schedule was resolved by this court, Ms. MacDonald twice required the police to visit Ms.Seguin's home last summer to check on Jewel. I am told that the parties cannot communicate openly with each other. This is consistentwith my observations in the courtroom, where the parties could not even look at each other, let alone make eye contact. Their animosityis palpable and Jewel ought not be exposed to it. [11] An additional change which has occurred since the last summer access order was made is that, in the context of her father'shousehold, Jewel is the big sister to Justice and Jaxon.
Her younger brothers are, I believe, aged 5 and 1. I was not provided with theirbirthdates. Variation of prior order [12] Having found that there has been a material change since the making of the last order, my task is to put in place a new orderwhich provides for Jewel's best interests in the new circumstances. Those new circumstances are ones of conflict and where Jewel ispart of a sibling group. [13] Where increased parental conflict is a material change, my decision about Jewel's summer access should modify her access sothat conflict is minimized or avoided.
In the past, the parties had to determine how the summer weeks would be alternated; how toaccommodate Mr. MacDonald's birthday; when to
schedule exchanges and where to have exchanges. [14] Ms. Seguin wants an order that will allow Jewel to alternate between homes at intervals of two weeks. She says this will bemore convenient for her in transporting Jewel to Enfield where the MacDonalds live because it will require less travelling back and forth. [15] Ms. MacDonald argues, and I agree, that the amount of back and forth travel during the summer is already far reduced fromthat which occurs during the school year. This is a matter of Ms. Seguin's convenience.
It doesn't relate to Jewel's best interests. [16] In Foley, (NS S.C.) at paragraph 16, Justice Goodfellow outlined a number of factors that may beconsidered in determining a child's best interests in a parenting application. His list was not exhaustive. While not listed by HisLordship, I consider the presence of other family members, such as step-siblings, to be a relevant factor in determining a child's bestinterests. Here, Jewel has two younger brothers and I find it to be in Jewel's best interests that she not be absent from their lives for morethan one week at a time.
At one year old, her younger brother, Jaxon, is rapidly developing new skills and abilities. It is important thatJewel be part of the family's shared experience of watching and helping Jaxon grow. So, I dismiss Ms. Seguin's request that Jewel'ssummer access alternate at bi-weekly intervals. Weekly alternation shall continue. [17] To minimize the conflict to which Jewel is exposed I am making a number of directions with regard to her summer access: 1. I order that Ms. Seguin will be responsible for transporting Jewel at the beginning and end of visits. 2. Visits will begin and end at 4:30 on Friday. 3.
Jewel will be picked up from and dropped off to her father and step-mother's home in Enfield. 4. Every summer, Jewel's first week of access with her mother will start on the first Friday following the end of school and, if schoolends on a Friday, it will start that day.
5. Throughout the summer until the Friday before school resumes, Jewel will alternate weeks between her mother's home and her father and step-mother's home. My calendar review confirms that this should place Jewel with her father on his birthday every year. Mr. MacDonald's birthday is August 21.
If school resumes on a Friday, the pattern of weekly alternation shall end at 4:30 p.m. on the previous Friday when, in any event, Jewel shall be with her father and step-mother. [ 18 ] While I was giving my decision I was asked both if each household was to continue to have two, two week periods with Jewel in each of July and August and what if Jewel was in one household for more weeks during the summer than the other. I believe the arrangement I am ordering is one which will continue to provide that Jewel will spend two weeks of each month in her mother's home and in her father and step-mother's home.
Depending on when school ends and starts, the division of summer vacation weeks may favour one household or the other in any particular year, but it will generally be roughly equal over time. I do not expect it will be exactly equal over time, but that lack of equality is a price I am prepared to see paid for the reduction of conflict over scheduling.
It is acceptable if Jewel spends more time at one household than the other over the summer months as a result of this schedule. [ 19 ] All of the parties have attended the Parent Information Program and I encourage them to consider and employ the knowledge they gained from the Program. _____________________________ Elizabeth Jollimore, J.S.C. (F.D.) Halifax, Nova Scotia
Loading document…