McIntosh v. Isaac Walton Killam-Grace Health Centre, 2011 NSSC 260
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: McIntosh v. Isaac Walton Killam-Grace Health Centre, 2011 NSSC 260 Date:
(20110712) Docket: Hfx. No. 264101 Registry: Halifax Between: Lisa McIntosh Plaintiff v. Isaac Walton Killam-Grace Health Centre For Children, Women and Families Defendant _________________________________________________________________ LIBRARY HEADING __________________________________________________________________ Judge: The Honourable Justice Pierre L. Muise Heard: October 18, 2010 to October 21, 2010, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Written Decision: July 12, 2011 Subject: Torts - Negligence - Standard of Care and Causation
Summary: In March of 2000, Ms. McIntosh’s first child was born in the IWK by caesarean
section after a period of pushing in an attempt to deliver vaginally. Approximately 10 days later, she became aware of pain in the area of her left hip. She had not noted problems with her hip before that. In July of 2001, diagnostic imaging revealed loose fragments within the hip. In October of 2005, she underwent arthroscopic surgery, during which the fragments were removed and other damage to her hip was noted, some of which was repaired. Her hip deteriorated to the point where she had it replaced in March of 2007. Ms.
McIntosh alleged that the way her legs were handled, by the student nurse supporting them during attempted vaginal delivery, was in breach of the requisite standard of care and caused the damage and deterioration in her hip.
Issues: Did Ms. McIntosh establish that the student nurse failed to meet the applicable standard of care? Did the nursing student’s actions cause the damage observed in Ms. McIntosh’s hip and result in it deteriorating to the point where it had to be replaced? Result: The standard of care was that expected of a registered nurse of average competence and ordinary skill facing the circumstances in question, as described by Ms. McIntosh’s expert. The court did not accept Ms. McIntosh’s description of how her legs were handled as being completely accurate. The chart notes confirmed the pushing was going well.
The movement of the feet and the resistance applied to ensure correct leg positioning were within the applicable standard of care. Ms. McIntosh failed to establish that the damage and deterioration in her hip were caused by the student nurse’s actions. She failed to show that there was enough force applied. If the damage had been caused by trauma during pushing, more likely than not, it would have caused pain that she would have noticed immediately, and continued to notice, except during the 24 hours she was under the effect of the epimorphine administered in preparation for the caesarean section.
She would not have had full range of motion in her hip when she saw the doctor 13 days after the delivery. She had a pre-existing shallow hip socket. People with that condition are more likely to develop osteoarthritis and degeneration requiring the hip to be replaced, without any intervening event. All the damage observed could arise as a result of such degeneration. The symptoms described by Ms. McIntosh were consistent with the normal progression of osteoarthritis in the hip. The cause of Ms. McIntosh’s hip condition and deterioration was more likely to have been degenerative than traumatic.
Index: INTRODUCTION para 1 LAW, EVIDENCE AND ANALYSIS 1. WHETHER MS. MCINTOSH HAS ESTABLISHED THAT THE NURSING STUDENT FAILED TO MEET THE APPLICABLE STANDARD OF CARE para 8 (
A) Applicable Standard of Care para 9 (
B) Nursing Student’s Actions During Attempted Vaginal Delivery para 16 Lisa McIntosh para 17 Nurse Margaret Duykers para 84 Cynthia Marie Mann para 119 (
C) Whether the Nursing Student’s Actions were Within the Applicable Standard of Care para 144 2. WHETHER MS. MANN’S HANDLING OF MS. MCINTOSH’S LEFT LEG CAUSED, WITHIN HER LEFT HIP, OSTEOCHONDRAL FRAGMENTS, A PARTIAL TEAR OF THE LIGAMENT TERES
AND/OR A TORN LABRUM, RESULTING IN OSTEOARTHRITIS, REQUIRING THE HIP TO BE REPLACED (
A) The Test for Causation para 159 (
B) Evidence Relating to Causation Dr. Michael Dunbar para 167 Dr. Catherine Anne Robinson para 250 Dr. Michael Gross para 267 Lisa McIntosh para 322 Chart Notes and Other Evidence para 421 (
C) Weighing the Expert Evidence on Causation para 434 (
D) Finding on Causation para 458 3. DAMAGES para 513 CONCLUSION para 514 SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: McIntosh v. Isaac Walton Killam-Grace Health Centre, 2011 NSSC 260 Date: 20110712 Docket: Hfx. No. 264101 Registry: Halifax
Between: Lisa McIntosh Plaintiff v. Isaac Walton Killam-Grace Health Centre For Children, Women and Families Defendant Judge: The Honourable Justice Pierre L. Muise Heard: October 18, 2010 to October 21, 2010, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Counsel: Colin D. Bryson, for the plaintiff Karen N. Bennett-Clayton and Tyana R. Caplan for the defendant By the Court : INTRODUCTION [ 1 ] Lisa McIntosh was admitted to the Isaac Walton Killam - Grace Health Centre for Children, Women and Families (“IWK”) for the purpose of delivering her first child. After an attempt to deliver the child vaginally, the child was delivered by caesarean
section on March 23, 2000. [ 2 ] McIntosh was discharged from the hospital on March 26, 2000. Around April 2 or 3, 2000, she became aware of pain in the area of her left hip, inner thigh and groin. She initially saw a general practitioner on April 6, 2000. She was eventually referred to an orthopaedic surgeon. [ 3 ] In December of 2000, an x-ray examination revealed that she had hip dysplasia. This is a condition she would have had since at least the time she stopped growing. The condition increases the risk of degenerative changes in the hip. However, Ms. McIntosh indicated she had no problems with her hip prior to the delivery.
[ 4 ] In July of 2001, further diagnostic imaging revealed what appeared to be loose fragments within the hip joint. [ 5 ] Arthroscopic surgery was performed on Ms. McIntosh’s left hip in October of 2005. The fragments were removed and other damage to the hip joint was repaired. However, Ms. McIntosh’s hip degenerated to the point where she had to have her hip replaced. That surgery was performed in March of 2007. It dramatically improved the function of her hip. However, she is not able to participate in all activities that she participated in prior to the delivery of her first child. [ 6 ] Ms.
McIntosh alleges that the damage to, and degeneration of, her hip was caused by the way her left leg was handled during attempted vaginal delivery. She alleges that the student nurse who was shadowing the delivery room nurse pushed against her left foot and moved her leg back towards her head in a way which failed to meet the applicable standard of care and caused the damage that was later observed in her hip. [ 7 ] The parties agree that the student nurse owed a duty to Ms. McIntosh to conform to normal nursing practices.
The parties also agree that the IWK would be vicariously liable for the nursing student’s actions. This Court must determine the following: 1. Whether Ms. McIntosh has established that the nursing student failed to meet applicable standard of care; 2. If so, whether the nursing student’s actions caused the damage that was observed in Ms. McIntosh’s left hip and resulted in it deteriorating to the point where it had to be replaced; and, 3. If so, what losses and damages Ms. McIntosh suffered as a result. LAW, EVIDENCE AND ANALYSIS 1. WHETHER MS.
MCINTOSH HAS ESTABLISHED THAT THE NURSING STUDENT FAILED TO MEET THE APPLICABLE STANDARD OF CARE [ 8 ] To answer this question I must determine: (
A) The applicable standard of care; (
B) The nursing students actions during attempted vaginal delivery; and, (
C) Whether the nursing student’s actions were within the applicable standard of care. (
A) Applicable Standard of Care
[ 9 ] The nursing student is to be held to the standard of care expected of a registered nurse of average competence and ordinary skill facing the circumstances in question. Judicial comments to that effect have been made in Tekano (Guardian ad litem of) v. Lions Gate Hospital , 1999 CarswellBC 1709 (B.C.S.C.) , at paragraph 109 , and in Dixon v. Calgary Health Region , 2006 CarswellAlta 378 (A.B.Q.B.) , at paragraph 73 . [ 10 ] The standard of care expected of nurses is dealt with in the same way as the standard of care expected of other health professionals.
Useful comments, in relation to the standard of care of health professionals generally, are contained in paragraph 6.26 of the Canadian Health Law Practice Manual (Markham: LexisNexis Canada Inc., 2000) where it is stated: “The conduct of the institution and its health professionals will be judged on whether the care provided met a reasonable standard in the particular circumstances of the case. The health practitioner is not held to a standard of perfection. The test is not whether the patient received the best care possible from the health practitioner in question.
Rather, the Court will look at what the reasonable health professional in a comparable setting would have done in like circumstances.” [ 11 ] Dr. Katherine Ann Robinson provided a report, dated November 6, 2009, in which she outlined the standard of care to be followed in supporting a patient’s leg during delivery. [ 12 ] In that report she indicated that Ms. McIntosh had an epidural during the pushing stage of her delivery. Therefore she would not have been able to provide as much feedback in relation to discomfort in her hip as she would have if she had not received the epidural. [ 13 ] Dr.
Robinson outlined her view of the applicable standard of care as follows: “It is my practice to encourage the people who are supporting the legs of the woman while pushing to hold the leg in a manner that supports the patient’s leg. The legs have to be open. That is, the hips must be abducted, the knees must be flexed and the knees may be held in a position which is slightly past the 90 degree angle of flexion.
However, the hip should not be hyperflexed with the knees towards the armpits, unless there is a difficulty shoulder delivery, which was not an issue in Lisa’s case at all because the head never descended far enough to consider vaginal delivery. It sometimes happens that patients while they are pushing, will push into their legs as though they are pushing against the wall; however, the patient, if this happens, should be encouraged to relax their legs and put all of their pushing efforts into pushing the baby out.
Pushing into their legs causes exhaustion; it causes support person fatigue because they are struggling with the patient or the position of the leg and it tightens the muscles in the pelvis and impairs descent of the baby. Also, during the pushing phase, the woman is encouraged to put her hands behind the back of her thighs and roll up as if she is doing a stomach crunch to maximize the power through the pelvis. It is not uncommon that patients require some training in order to be successful in this.
Leg holding is often a skill that is taught on site to lay family members and support people who accompany the woman in for her labour. So, teaching somebody to appropriately support a leg is something with which the staff nurse would have had lots of experience. The supported leg and a minimal amount of resistance would be standard of care. A lot of resistance or hyperflexing the legs back on the hips would not be considered the standard of care.” [ 14 ] Dr. Robinson was cross-examined in relation to these comments in her report. During cross-examination she confirmed and expanded upon her report as follows. 1.
She was describing her practice. 2. It is her practice to encourage the people who are supporting the legs of the woman while pushing to hold the leg in a manner that supports the patient’s leg. 3. The legs have to be open.
4. The hips have to be abducted which means apart or open. 5. The knees must be flexed. 6. The knees may be held in a position that is slightly past the 90 degree angle of flexion at the hip such that it slightly hyperflexes the hips. For example, if the patient was lying completely horizontally, a 90 degree angle of flexion would mean that the knees would be pointing directly towards the ceiling, and the part of the leg from the knee to the foot would be parallel to the bed. This applies to the pushing position known as the semi-sitting position. 7.
The hip should not be hyperflexed with the knees to the armpits. To hyperflex means to push a joint past its normal limit. In general, when a patient is in the semi-sitting position, they sometimes hold the knee a little further than the 90 degree angle, but not “frog-legged” into the armpits. Not all women have the same degree of flexibility. Most women have flexibility past the 90 degrees. However, unless there is an emergency, no one should have their knees in their armpits. That would constitute hyperflexing. 8. Sometimes the patient grabs the back of her legs and holds on to her own legs.
The weight of the leg is usually held by the support person, particularly if the patient has had an epidural. The woman is using her legs to roll up against. 10. If she’s not holding up her own legs, she requires someone to provide support to her legs. It sometimes happens that patients push into their legs as if they are pushing into a wall. If that happens the patient should be encouraged to relax their legs and put their pushing efforts into pushing the baby out. 11.
If a patient in the pushing phase is pushing their legs against the person holding their legs you expect the legs to move forward, unless there is sufficient counter-pressure to keep the legs where they were originally. The counter-pressure would prevent the leg from moving forward. It would keep the leg at the proper 90 degree angle or slightly past the 90 degree angle of flexion; but, the purpose is to improve pushing and not to provide counter-pressure. If it is not improving the pushing, it’s purpose would be to hold the leg in the proper position. 12.
Leg holding is often taught to lay people, such as family and other support people. Usually the holding method is demonstrated and described by the nurse. The nurse is holding one leg while the support person is holding the other. It gives the patient a chance to give some feedback and to say if one is doing it differently from the other. 13. If she were in the room and the support person was not holding the leg properly she would correct the support person. That is something she has done before. She does it to maximize the pushing effort and to minimize injury.
The most common injury would be a strain of the muscles in the back of the leg. 14. She was asked to comment on her statement that “a minimal amount of resistance would be standard of care”. When she was referring to resistance, she meant counter-pressure. The purpose of counter-pressure would be to keep the leg at a proper position if the mother was pushing with her legs and if the pushing moved her legs out of the proper position. The legs are generally not supported throughout the entire pushing phase. Generally they are put down between contractions.
This allows the patient and the support person to rest between contractions. There is usually no resistance during that period of time. The patient is encouraged to relax. However, if the baby were about to be born the legs would be held up even between contractions. 15. If the patient has their legs supported and is pushing into their legs, it is possible that the legs would move forward. The support person would move them back to the 90 degree angle. There could be a slight back and forth movement. The legs, ideally, should be limp so that all the power goes into the pelvis.
Ideally, the person holding the leg should do so such that it is like a sling which would hold the leg in the proper position. The sling would have some movement. This holding like a sling, and the slight movement, is within the standard of care. [ 15 ] The parties agree that the standard of care described by Dr. Robinson is the applicable standard of care in the case at hand.
(
B) Nursing Student’s Actions During Attempted Vaginal Delivery [ 16 ] In order to determine the nursing student’s actions during attempted vaginal delivery, I must assess the reliability of the evidence relating to what occurred during that time. Lisa McIntosh [ 17 ] In direct examination Ms. McIntosh testified about what occurred and the way that her legs were handled during attempted vaginal delivery as follows. [ 18 ] There was a shift change early in the morning of March 23, 2000. For a bit of time she did not see anyone.
Then “the nursing student and the nurse” came in and said to her “we’re going to try to push the baby down to a lower station”. [ 19 ] The nursing student was Cynthia Mann. Ms. McIntosh was able to remember Ms. Mann because she came to visit her the next day in the hospital. She recalls making a connection with Ms. Mann because Ms. Mann had just had a baby herself. In addition Ms. McIntosh used to work with Ms. Mann’s mother-in-law.
She recalls the mother-in-law talking about her first grandchild and had referred to the mother of the grandchild as Cindy or Cynthia. [ 20 ] She recalled the nurse’s name being Margaret because that is her own middle name. Through the course of these proceedings it became apparent to her that the nurse in question was Margaret Duykers. [ 21 ] Ms. McIntosh testified that: “They told me we were going to start pushing to see if we could move the baby down.” Nurse Duykers was the one giving the instructions. Ms.
Mann was consulting with her and helping her to support the pushing techniques and the plans to push the baby down. [ 22 ] She was feeling horrible and almost nauseous. She was tired and had kind of shortness of breath all the time. [ 23 ] The pushing phase took at least one hour. It was a long time. She recalled it “perfectly”. [ 24 ] She was instructed to use all the strength she could to push the baby down through her body like a bowel movement, the whole purpose being to use her internal strength to push the baby down to the opening. [ 25 ] They showed her and told her what position to be in.
They also moved her into the position she needed to be in to push. They walked her through what to do and how they would do it. They told her how it would feel. [ 26 ] The back of the bed was angled somewhere between 45 degrees and 90 degrees. The bottom of the bed was straight out. She initially sitting with her legs straight out. Her back was supported with pillows and she would have been leaning back. She was instructed to lift her knees up and back. She was told to separate her legs and bend her knees, so that her legs were basically parallel to the ceiling or to the bed.
Her legs were supported by each nurse’s hands. A nurse was on each side of her.
[ 27 ] Her knees were almost as far as she could separate them with comfort. [ 28 ] Ms. Mann was on her left and Nurse Duykers was on her right. [ 29 ] Her legs were bent. They had to hold her legs up because she had been given an epidural. She could lift them; but, she could not hold them in the air. They used one hand to support her leg or foot in the air. [ 30 ] Ms. McIntosh demonstrated with her hands how they held her legs. She showed that one hand was holding her leg up. The other hand was used to support the sole of her foot.
She showed the hand holding her leg up in the air as being palm up and the other hand having the palm up against the sole of her foot, with the hands being held at approximately 90 degrees one to the other. [ 31 ] She stated: “My legs were bent back as far as they could go.” [ 32 ] She indicated they wanted her to use their hand as resistance, so she would put as much pressure as she could with her foot on the hand. They could create like a wall. It was to give something to push against, like using a leg press.
They were trying to create something offering resistance. [ 33 ] She could also use her own hands on the side of the bed to use all her strength to push the baby down. [ 34 ] The nurses were actually pushing with their hands so that she would have something more stable. Otherwise, she would have kicked their hands freely away. She was pushing her legs out. They were using their hands to push back to create resistance. [ 35 ] She said she “pushed all night long”. [ 36 ] She recalls pushing back and forth with her foot.
There was give and take between her feet and the nurses’ hands as they tried to create that resistance, so she could stabilize and push during contractions. She compared it to trying to kick something soft and she pointed out the hand has to be strong to push back to create resistance needed to be able to push. The “give and take” was in trying to find the level of resistance needed to keep her foot stable so that she could push. [ 37 ] The hand was moving “slightly” back and forth towards her and the other way.
She agreed with the suggestion that it was from a midpoint. (The fact that it was in response to a suggestion, diminishes the weight of that evidence.) She felt that there was give and take between the ball of her foot and the hand as to where that proper resistance level lies. [ 38 ] Her knees were bent back as far as they could comfortably be with the baby and in the position they were lifted and separated. During the whole time, she felt like her diaphragm was shrunk. It was an uncomfortable position to be in. [ 39 ] She did not feel any pain in her left hip during the birth.
She felt like the epidural took away her pain. She felt pressure and discomfort. She didn’t feel any pain at all. The contractions were painful; but, mostly they were just really uncomfortable. She felt a dull pressure that increased during contractions. [ 40 ] In cross-examination, in addition to confirming some of her evidence on direct-examination, she gave the following evidence in relation to what occurred during the attempted vaginal delivery. [ 41 ] At the point of delivery she weighed approximately 202 pounds. That was approximately 56 pounds more than her weight at the beginning of her pregnancy.
She had severe swelling. Her weight gain was fluid. She gained approximately 25 pounds in four weeks. The swelling was throughout her body, including her hands, feet and face.
[ 42 ] She was fully dilated at 8:30 a.m. She had to wait until that time before she could start pushing. [ 43 ] She was shown the chart note saying that pushing started on March 23, 2000, at 9:00 a.m. She agreed that was the time-frame that she remembered starting pushing. [ 44 ] Each time she pushed, her legs were supported by two nurses. One nurse held one leg and the other nurse held the other leg. She did not help by holding her own legs by the back of the thighs. She explained she was uncomfortable and quite swollen.
Therefore, she was not sure whether she could have reached underneath her legs to be able to do that. She agreed her whole body was swollen, including her thighs. [ 45 ] The whole time she was pushing there was only the nurse and the student nurse holding her legs. No physician came in to help and hold her legs. No family member or friend helped hold her legs. [ 46 ] She is not sure whether she could still lift her legs herself after having had the epidural.
She did know that she would not be able to hold the position, even though she may have been able to lift them. [ 47 ] At the time of the first contraction to push, the nurses put her legs into position for her and instructed her how to push. With each contraction the nurse held one leg and the nursing student held the other. Both the nurse and the nursing student used the same technique. Ms. McIntosh did not hear the nurse admonish or correct the nursing student. She did not recall any conversation between the nurse and the nursing student regarding the holding technique.
However, it seemed like the nursing student was following the nurse’s lead. When they were holding her legs, they were at the end of the bed. They were facing her, not each other. [ 48 ] Her legs were held slightly off to the side. Her knees were bent. Before she started to push, her legs, from the knee to the foot, were parallel to the ground. The nurse and nursing student would hold her leg underneath her ankle or her leg. She believes it was at her ankle or her calf.
That was done with each contraction as she was trying to push. [ 49 ] Part of what the nurses were doing was supporting her legs to keep them up because she could not hold them up herself. There were no stirrups. They were acting like a human stirrup. Part of what they were doing was keeping her legs steady while she was pushing. This was to prevent her leg from moving forward or straightening out while she pushed.
If they had not done so, her leg would have kicked out at them and straightened out or fallen down to the bed. [ 50 ] What she considered to be the “starting position” was when she was positioned with her knees bent and her leg from the knee to the foot parallel to the ground. She does not recall it happening where she would kick through and restart in that position. To her it seemed like it was fairly constant. To her there was no break in the contact. At each contraction she started in the starting position. She did not feel her legs were parallel the whole time. She does not recall her leg being kicked out.
She did “feel” they were being pushed back. She does not recall her leg being pushed out so the nurse had to push it back into the starting position. [ 51 ] She was using all of her strength and the palm of their hands to keep the pressure during the contractions which seemed fairly long. It was to keep her leg in one place. [ 52 ] She felt like the whole pushing was done forcibly. However, she does not recall any instance where her left leg was pushed back forcefully to her body. She does not recall any instance where her left leg was suddenly jerked back against her body.
There was nothing traumatic like that. [ 53 ] In between contractions she was encouraged to rest with her feet on the bed and she did so. Her legs were not held up in the air between contractions. [ 54 ] There was no more pain in her hip than anywhere else. She had no specific recollection of any pain in the hip. There was no
[ 54 ] There was no more pain in her hip than anywhere else. She had no specific recollection of any pain in the hip. There was no popping sensation in her hip while she was pushing. There was no pain radiating to her femur while she was pushing. [ 55 ] She indicates that during the entire time she was pushing she was in the same sort of 45 degree to 90 degree bed angle position with her back elevated, the bed out flat, and her legs raised during each contraction.
That position was constant the whole time, other than between contractions, when she was resting. (That position was referred to as the semi-sitting position by other witnesses.) She was definitely certain that she did not push from any other position. [ 56 ] She was shown the chart note which indicated that, at 9:50 a.m., she was repositioned to sitting position and pushing well. She was asked whether that helped her remember any other position she may have been in. She indicated she did not know what the note meant; but, that the only change would have been a change in the angle of the bed to support her back.
She did not recall the angle of the bed changing. [ 57 ] She conceded that she may not have remembered everything perfectly. However, she indicated that she remembered it very well, better than most days in her life. She indicated that she did not remember if they moved her bed. Therefore, “perfectly” didn’t mean quite perfectly after ten years. [ 58 ] Ms. McIntosh stated that she and Ms. Mann had a conversation regarding the pushing phase when Ms. Mann visited her at her home. The evidence relating to that conversation is relevant to determining the nursing student’s actions during attempted vaginal delivery.
It will be examined in the course of discussing inconsistencies in Ms. McIntosh’s evidence. [ 59 ] In general, Ms. McIntosh was non-evasive and straightforward. She appeared to be intelligent and confident. She was able to make statements against interest. For example, she acknowledged that she did not feel any specific pain in her left hip during attempted vaginal delivery. She admitted that she had no specific pain in her hip during her post-delivery stay in hospital.
She did not recall any instance where her left leg was pushed back forcefully to her body, nor any sudden jerking of her leg back towards her body, nor anything else traumatic like that. She acknowledged that during the pushing she did not experience a popping sensation in her left hip nor any pain radiating down to the femur. [ 60 ] Those are factors which support a finding that she was credible. However, during the attempted vaginal delivery, she did not suspect that the nurse and the student nurse had done anything in breach of their duty and standard of care.
She had no indication that anything they did would cause her any injury. Consequently, at the time, there was nothing to bring her attention to the details of how they were handling her legs. Her mind only turned to those details at some point after her release from hospital. [ 61 ] At the time, she was only 33 years of age. She had been active and athletic. Once she started experiencing difficulty with her hip, she would have a natural inclination to attribute the cause of that difficulty to something outside her own actions or degenerative condition.
She would have a natural inclination to think back to the pushing phase of her attempted vaginal delivery and remember it in a way which would tend to identify it as the cause of her left hip difficulties. [ 62 ] I must also bear in mind that Ms. McIntosh has an interest in the outcome of this trial. [ 63 ] She gave her evidence more than ten years after the event. There was no indication that she made any notes contemporaneous with the event, nor even within a reasonable time after the event. Her evidence was based on her memory of an event that occurred more than a decade ago.
Therefore, despite her evidence that she remembered the event perfectly, her memory more likely than not, has faded over time. She is not able to recall and recount the details as she could have immediately after the event. [ 64 ] An admitted example of how she did not recall the event perfectly was that she did not recall any repositioning. She thought it probably meant that they repositioned the portion of her bed supporting her back. However, Nurse Duykers testified that, with most patients, more than one pushing position is used.
In addition, when she writes “repositioned to sitting position” in her notes, it would mean that, previous to that, she was pushing in a different position. More likely than not, that is what occurred. That indicates that Ms. McIntosh’s memory of the event is more faded than she acknowledges. She surmised that the note may simply have been to indicate that the position of the bed was changed. Even if that was the case, Ms. McIntosh did not recall it happening, which shows her memory of the
event has faded. [ 65 ] In addition, she indicated that she was not sure whether or not she could lift her own legs after the epidural. That is obviously something that would come up during the pushing phase. It would have been repeated multiple times during the pushing phase. Her inability to recall that shows that she does not recall the pushing phase nearly as perfectly as she says she does. [ 66 ] In addition, her evidence was internally inconsistent in relation to whether or not she could lift her legs. On direct examination she said she could lift them; but, she could not hold them in the air.
On cross-examination she said she was not sure whether she could lift her legs herself. [ 67 ] She testified on direct examination, at one point, that she pushed all night long. At another point in her direct examination she said it was at least one hour and that it was a long time. On cross-examination she indicated that the pushing started around 9:00 a.m., not at the beginning of the night, Those are further internal inconsistencies within her own evidence at trial. [ 68 ] She gave evidence at trial in relation to a conversation she had at her home with Ms. Mann in relation to the pushing.
That evidence was inconsistent with the evidence she gave at discoveries about that conversation. [ 69 ] Ms. McIntosh’s evidence was as follows. [ 70 ] Ms. Mann visited her in her home with a supervisor. The visit was after the MABLE nurse visit [which, according to the hospital records, occurred on March 27, 2000]. She thought it was in the first week after the MABLE nurse visit. It was more of a social visit. It was mostly conversation. They mostly talked about nursing. The visit had been pre-arranged at Ms.Mann’s request as part of her nursing student program. [ 71 ] Ms. McIntosh was moving around slowly. Ms.
Mann asked if she was limping. Ms. McIntosh responded: “Yes cause I’m still really sore from the cesarean”. At that time she wasn’t really thinking anything was unusual about her recovery from the C-section. She was still not physically back to herself and knew that would take a while. Ms. Mann stood in front of her and said: “Is that the left side?” Ms. Mann said “that’s the side I was on, I hope I didn’t push too hard”, or something to that effect. Ms. Mann was concerned she may have done something wrong. At the time, Ms. McIntosh was not overly concerned.
She expected it was something which would go away in a few days. She thought it was just part of the normal recovery. [ 72 ] Ms. McIntosh admitted on cross-examination she did not specifically recall what Ms. Mann said to her when she was standing in front of her. The way she recalled it was that Ms. Mann said “I hope I didn’t push ... or push back too hard ... or push too hard”. She was asked whether Ms. Mann could have said: “I hope nothing happened while we were pushing?” Ms. McIntosh responded that that was very similar. Ms. McIntosh was asked whether Ms.
Mann could have said: “Maybe it’s sore because of pushing”. Ms. McIntosh confirmed that she may have said that. She confirmed that she did not recall for sure. According to Ms. Mann’s last comment, she was indicating it was something she had done, as she was on that particular side. It was not a comment about the pushing generally. It was more of a concern that it was something that she had caused by pushing. She appeared concerned. Ms. Mann did not specifically say she was concerned; but, Ms.
McIntosh knew she was concerned when she followed up with a phone call a week or two after that when she asked about it. [ 73 ] When Ms. Mann used the word pushing, Ms. McIntosh did not ask what she meant by pushing. However, she knew what she meant. Ms. McIntosh was aware what the positioning was, and they both were in agreement with what that position was. Ms. McIntosh did not think to ask what was meant by the word pushing since Mann was in the same room with her. She believed that she had the same understanding of what the word pushing was.
She knows she didn’t mean pushing for the baby to come out, because the baby didn’t come out. She was pushing on the bottom of Ms. McIntosh’s foot. Ms. McIntosh thought they had a mutual understanding about what was meant by “pushing” because they were both in the room when it occurred and it was about how it would have affected her leg or hip. [ 74 ] Ms. McIntosh agreed with the suggestion that the nurse, at the time of the attempted vaginal delivery, explained what “we” were going to do to push the baby out. Ms.
McIntosh understood that meant what she and the nurses were going to do to push the baby out or to lower the baby.
[ 75 ] A portion of the transcript of the discovery examination of Ms. McIntosh was submitted as evidence of the truth of its contents and marked Exhibit number 6. That portion of the transcript reveals that, during discoveries, Ms. McIntosh gave the following evidence in relation to the comments made by Ms. Mann in the course of the home visit. [ 76 ] She stated: “[Ms. Mann] said that was the side I was on I hope this isn’t an injury that happened while you were pushing. ... [S]he also said, I hope nothing happened during ... when we were pushing.
It may have been something that happened while we were pushing, maybe it’s sore because of the pushing.” [ 77 ] Looking at Ms. McIntosh’s evidence as a whole, it is clear that when she refers to the nurses saying “ we ” it is a reference to something Ms. McIntosh would have to do with their assistance. Comparing the discovery transcript with the evidence on direct examination reveals a clear shift in how McIntosh remembered or interpreted Ms. Mann’s references to pushing. At discoveries, in my view, Ms. McIntosh was interpreting the pushing as being Ms.
McIntosh’s pushing to get the baby out with the assistance of the nurse and the student nurse. At trial, she had changed her recollection or
interpretation of the reference to pushing as being a reference to Ms. Mann pushing on something. [ 78 ] In my view, her discovery evidence is not consistent with her evidence at trial. The shift reveals a tendency on Ms. McIntosh’s part to recall or interpret things in a way which bolsters her case. That is a natural inclination which is hard to resist. Further, there is natural inclination for her to interpret and recall things in a manner which points to a cause other than innate degeneration of her own body. [ 79 ] It is agreed that she was experiencing severe swelling.
She delivered a baby that was over nine pounds. She testified that the whole time she felt like her diaphragm was shrunk. She indicated that because of her swelling and the baby inside her she did not think that she could even grab her own thighs. If her legs had indeed been pushed back as far as they could go, more likely than not, she would have been able to grab her thighs. However, it is understandable that in her swollen and pregnant condition, she would have felt like her legs were being pushed back as far as they could go.
If the whole time she felt like her diaphragm was shrunk and she felt discomfort the whole time, it is easy to see how she would feel like her legs were pushed way back. [ 80 ] There was no explanation from any witness as to how Ms. McIntosh could push hard with her feet against the hands of the nurse and nursing student if she could not even lift her own legs, or, at least, would have had difficulty doing so. If the epidural masked the pain of the contractions to the point where it was mostly not painful, but merely a dull sensation or discomfort, it would be difficult to see how Ms.
McIntosh could tell how hard she was pushing with her feet or even if she was pushing with her feet. [ 81 ] She acknowledged that she had been instructed to push the baby through with her whole body like a bowel movement. That description indicates she understood that the force was to be directed towards pushing the baby out and not pushing her feet out. [ 82 ] Nurse Duykers testified that when a patient is pushing with her feet the patient is told to push into her pelvis to push the baby out. More likely than not, if Ms. McIntosh had been pushing with her feet, the nurse would have corrected that.
There is nothing in the chart notes indicating that Ms. McIntosh was pushing with her feet. The chart notes say she was pushing well. Ms. McIntosh’s recollection of the pushing is inconsistent with those chart notes. [ 83 ] More likely than not, Ms.McIntosh’s recollection of how her legs were handled by the nurse and nursing student during the pushing phase is not completely accurate. However, I do accept that there would have been some back and forth movement of the feet, as well as some resistance, which would have been for the purpose of ensuring that her legs and feet were in the correct position.
Nurse Margaret Duykers
[ 84 ] Margaret Duykers testified on direct examination as follows. [ 85 ] She started work in the birth unit at the IWK in February, 1999. Prior to starting work there, she completed a six week preceptorship program in which she was taught the skills needed to provide care for a patient in labour. The program includes a daily evaluation as well as a formal written evaluation at the end of the six weeks. [ 86 ] Day-to-day work on the birth unit has not changed since she started there. [ 87 ] She does not recall having Ms. McIntosh as a patient. However, according to the hospital chart she did care for her.
As much as possible, she makes her chart notes contemporaneously to assure that they are accurate and timely. Occasionally, she has to add notes after-the-fact. She would note that as being a late entry. She is able to tell which notes are made at the time and which ones were added later.
It is a practice that is taught to all nursing students and nurses in training. [ 88 ] Her notes in the IWK patient chart in relation to Lisa McIntosh, located in Exhibit 1, Tab 1, at page 36, start at the notation where it says “(07:02) shift change”. [ 89 ] The role of a student nurse depends on the year of nursing that they are in. Second and third year nursing students are usually in an observer type role. They do things that family members or friends could do. For instance, they would hold legs during pushing phase. The role of the nurse being shadowed is patient care.
However, as opportunities arise, they are used to teach to or demonstrate for the student nurse. [ 90 ] Based on her review of the records, there was nothing unusual about the progression of Ms. McIntosh’s labour. It was very routine. According to the chart, she progressed to the second stage (meaning her cervix was fully dilated) and she began the pushing stage. The usual positions that a mother would use in trying to deliver vaginally include the left or right side-lying position, the squatting position, and the semi-sitting position. All of those positions are used depending on individual situations.
Most times, more than one position is used. She charted that, at 9:50 a.m., Ms. McIntosh was repositioned into the semi-sitting position. She would have wrote that note because she would have changed Ms. McIntosh from one position to another. When she writes about repositioning in her notes, it means changing from one specific position to another, such as changing from side-lying to squatting, or squatting to semi-sitting. [ 91 ] There are no notes regarding what position Ms. McIntosh was in before 9:50 a.m. [ 92 ] In the semi-sitting position, the head of the bed is elevated to approximately 45 degrees.
The bottom part of the bed is flat. The patient’s legs are flat out on the bed. [ 93 ] Based on general practice, while Ms. McIntosh was pushing from a semi-sitting position, Nurse Duykers would have been supporting one of her legs and coaching her in proper pushing techniques. Her leg would just be supported during contractions and, when there were no contractions, the leg would generally be put down on the bed. [ 94 ] When she is coaching a labouring mother, she tells her to take both hands behind her thighs and that someone will support her legs on each side to hold the weight of her legs.
She tells her that she needs to pull behind her legs, almost to a sit-up type position, and to push down into her bottom, not into her legs. Pushing into her bottom is to lower the baby into the pelvis. [ 95 ] The notation which she made in Ms. McIntosh’s patient chart, stating “pushing well”, means that a mother is: in a good position; pushing into her bottom; not using her legs; and, not pushing with little effort, or that they are seeing some good signs. [ 96 ] She described the mechanics of how legs are supported as follows. The legs are spread wide apart and the knees are bent.
With one hand, she supports under the heel, and the other hand is under the calf. The same thing happens with someone on the other side. The
mother generally has her hands behind her thighs to help with the pushing effort. There are no other ways to place your hands on the mother’s foot or leg. [ 97 ] According to the chart notes, McIntosh laboured for vaginal delivery in Room 8. The layout of Room 8 is such that she would have been on Ms. McIntosh’s right side. [ 98 ] While Ms. McIntosh was pushing during contractions, the student nurse would have been holding the leg as Ms. Duykers demonstrated and explained to her to do.
While the student nurse was supporting the patient’s leg, she would explain to the student that: they were going to support the mother’s leg while she’s pushing because the legs are heavy from the epidural medication; and, they would provide support under the heel and under the calf with their two hands, and with the mother’s knees being bent. She further explained that they were not pushing or straining on the legs, they were just providing support. She gave that instruction verbally.
She would also explain and show how she would be holding the legs so the student could see. [ 99 ] Every time she works they have to show a partner, husband, family member or a student how to provide that support. [ 100 ] They always tell the person providing the support that they are not straining the leg or pushing on the leg. They are just providing support to help the mother because her legs are really heavy from the epidural. The patients often have epidurals. [ 101 ] She described one circumstance when it would be appropriate to push the mother’s leg back towards her body further than the normal.
That would be during what is called shoulder dystocia, which is an obstetrical emergency. It occurs when the baby’s head has delivered but the shoulders are stuck. When that happens they lay the bed flat. She presses the emergency button. She calls for the obstetrical team and the neonatal team to come in. Pressure is applied above the pubic area and the legs are pushed back as much as possible. In such an emergency, they want the mother to push as hard as she can. [ 102 ] This would not have been used with Ms. McIntosh because the baby had never descended that far into the pelvis, according to the notes.
The manoeuvre is never used for anything but shoulder dystocia. [ 103 ] The chart indicates that Ms. McIntosh stopped pushing at 10:10 a.m., when they decided they were going to deliver the baby by cesarean section. [ 104 ] Nurse Duykers has never had her technique corrected by another nurse nor a physician. She has to correct family members, partners, and friends all the time and demonstrate how to do it properly. [ 105 ] In cross-examination, Nurse Duykers provided the following additional evidence. [ 106 ] She agreed she was out of the room from 8:45 a.m. to 9:30 a.m., on break.
She agreed that would’ve been approximately the first half of the pushing stage. [ 107 ] She vaguely remembers a day that Ms. Mann was shadowing her because Ms. Mann started as a staff member nurse after that. [ 108 ] If the nursing student were only providing a support role it wouldn’t be noted in the charts. The types of things they would note in the charts about a nursing student is if they were preparing an IV or a Foley catheter.
The nurse would comment that it was being done by a student under nurse supervision. [ 109 ] She was asked whether the chart note regarding repositioning could have been in relation to repositioning the patient from resting position. She indicated the resting position is just the legs being down flat. They would never have the bed flat with a pregnant woman. They always have the woman either lying on her side or in a semi-sitting position. It is most often lying on her side. When the
contractions start there are a variety of those positions used. [ 110 ] She agreed with Robinson’s evidence that the legs should not be pushed beyond slightly past a 90 degree angle. She agreed that it can cause injury and discomfort for the mother.
She agreed that sometimes, with the epidural , the labouring mother does not have strength or sensation, so they are always very careful they are just supporting the legs and not hyper-extending them. [ 111 ] She indicated that the note about pushing well was made at the time. [ 112 ] Approximately two pages of the transcript of Nurse Duykers discovery examination were read to her.
The two page excerpt contains comments from Nurse Duykers about it occurring sometimes that the patient will push away at the hand that is supporting the foot, making it that, sometimes, you have to get the leg back into the right position. You have to bend the knee back if they have sort of straightened their legs to push you away. Your hand could use some resistance against the foot to get back into the knee-bent position which would not be a forceful push. Then the following question was put to her: “I wasn’t even thinking forceful as much as providing resistance.
Pushing it ... like pushing against the wall ... you know in that sense. Would that have been ... is that consistent with what your practice could’ve been in that circumstance?” Her answer was that she was not sure. She was then asked to look at the records and, based on those records, asked if she could say that it “ would not have occurred, could not have occurred, possibly could have occurred?” Her answer was that it probably didn’t occur because she’s noted that Ms. MsIntosh was pushing well. [ 113 ] At trial she expanded upon those points. She indicated she did not recall that situation with Ms.
McIntosh whatsoever. However, to put someone’s leg back into position if they straighten out the leg or push into you involves: putting the leg back into the knee-bent position; supporting the leg; and, encouraging the mother to put her hands behind her thighs, hold the back of her legs, and push into her bottom. To put someone’s leg back into position, if your hand is under the heel and under the calf, and the position changes, and you want to get it back into position, so you would move it back to the knee bent position.
Your hand could possibly touch the bottom of the foot; but, it doesn’t mean that you’re pushing back. You’re just pushing it back into what they call the pushing position (which is the knees being bent and the leg being supported). However, it’s not in any way a forcible pushing of the leg back. It’s just placing it back into the knee bent position. [ 114 ] Ms. McIntosh could not have been instructed to push against the nurse’s and nursing student’s hand with her foot. Nurse Duykers’ supports under the heel and under the calf. All that they are doing is supporting the weight.
They don’t want the patient to push into her legs. They want them to push into their bottom. You would not push back. [ 115 ] Nurse Duykers frankly and without hesitation acknowledged that she did not recall the event. However, her notes were made at the time. She was trained in the taking of those notes. She knows what they mean. At the time that the notes were taken, there was no indication that any injury to or claim by Ms. McIntosh would result. There was no reason for Nurse Duykers to stray from the note- taking practice she had been taught.
As a professional nurse, she has been referring to chart notes and knows how to make them. She knows what they mean. It is reasonable to expect that nurses are taught note-taking techniques to ensure consistent and accurate
interpretation of those notes. [ 116 ] The suggestion by Ms. McIntosh’s lawyer that Nurse Duyker’s note-taking habits may have changed since she made those notes in 2000 is speculation only. There was nothing in the evidence from which I could infer that was the case. She was testifying about her note-taking in the context of discussing the chart notes she made in 2000. There was no indication of any change in note-taking techniques and procedures. [ 117 ] In the circumstances, in my view, Nurse Duykers’ notes, and her
interpretation of those notes, are reliable. Nurse Duykers is not a party in these proceedings. She does not stand to lose anything depending on the outcome. Her personal interest in the outcome would be limited to a judicial statement on whether or not the nursing student who was under her supervision breached the requisite standard of care. [ 118 ] Nurse Duykers frequently repeated her message about how the delivery room nurse ensures that the patient is not pushing into her legs. Many of her answers reverted to that message. However, she made no attempt to evade the questions.
She answered them in a straightforward manner. As a general comment, her evidence was internally consistent and externally consistent with that of Ms. Mann. I
find her evidence to be both credible and reliable. Cynthia Marie Mann [ 119 ] In direct examination, Cynthia Marie Mann provided the following evidence relating to her actions during attempted vaginal delivery. [ 120 ] She graduated with a Bachelor of Science degree in nursing from Dalhousie University in 2001. Approximately two years later she began a certificate program in perinatal nursing with the Canadian Nursing Association. She received her certificate from that program in 2003. The certificate must be renewed every five years.
It is an acknowledgement of the nurse’s clinical experience and theoretical knowledge. The field of perinatal nursing involves working with the child bearing population, including throughout the pregnancy, throughout the labour and birth, and in the postpartum period. [ 121 ] She began working in the postpartum unit of the IWK in the spring of 2001. She was then cross-trained in the birth unit. For a while she was part of a small group of nurses who would go back and forth between the postpartum unit and the birth unit as needed. Since 2003 she has been in the birth unit full-time.
Her duties in the birth unit include providing care to the patient pre-birth and immediately post-birth. [ 122 ] She had a vague memory of a home visit with Ms. McIntosh. However, she had no memory of caring for her during her hospital stay at the IWK in March of 2000. [ 123 ] She indicated that they do not do many home visits as nursing students. She recalls going to Ms. McIntosh’s home with her clinical instructor. She vaguely recalls being there. She does not remember much detail about the visit.
She does not specifically recall the conversation which took place. [ 124 ] Her visit was one of the requirements of the clinical component of her nursing program. It’s one of the things that they do in the maternity care portion of their training, to see how a patient adjusts to being at home. [ 125 ] She did not recall anything about Ms. McIntosh’s physical condition during the visit. [ 126 ] In March of 2000, she was a third year nursing student. She recalls attending the IWK as part of the maternity component of her nursing studies.
She recalls spending time in the postpartum unit and spending a day in the perinatal centre. [ 127 ] She has no memory of attending the birth unit; but, she knows it is a requirement to spend one day in the birth unit for the maternity course. So she knows she did one 12 hour shift in that unit. [ 128 ] In March of 2000, in the maternity course itself, they would have been taught the theoretical or classroom component in relation to providing nursing care to a labouring mother. However, because they only do one shift in the birth unit, there is no practical training component and no lab work.
Since there is only one shift and limited time, you “really do shadow an RN in the birth unit”. [ 129 ] In the birth unit, a third year nursing student shadows the registered nurse and stays with him or her throughout. The nursing student goes where the registered nurse goes. It essentially gives the nursing student a sense of the role. Nursing students can do things under the instruction of a nurse. They can do things that a family member would do. For example, when the woman is pushing they could support her legs.
[ 130 ] She recalled shadowing Margaret Duykers. She did not recall the specific day nor any conversation with Nurse Duykers that day. She does not recall what Nurse Duykers would have taught her or what they would have been doing. [ 131 ] As a nurse who has worked at the IWK since 2001, she imagines she has attended thousands of births. She frequently has third year nursing students shadow her. [ 132 ] In March of 2000, the way that she would have known how to hold a labouring mother’s leg was by being told how to do it by the registered nurse in the room she was shadowing.
A third year student shadowing a nurse would be instructed like a family member. She described the instructions you give the student in essentially the same way Nurse Duykers did. [ 133 ] The only time she was given different instructions on how to hold the leg during pushing is in the event of an obstetrical emergency known as shoulder dystocia. She described the shoulder dystocia emergency situation in essentially the same way as Nurse Duykers and added the following. The labouring mother’s legs are pushed quite forcefully back towards her body.
In a shoulder dystocia situation, it is more of a forceful pushing back towards the body. It is not a holding of the legs up off the bed. Neither a support person nor a student nurse would be involved in that situation. They haven’t been taught how to do it. [ 134 ] She recalled the first time that she saw a shoulder dystocia situation quite clearly. It was in 2003. She was working independently. She and Dr. Lee were alone with the patient. She remembers the crowd that came. She remembers the manoeuvre that released the baby. She was the primary nurse.
She pushed back on the legs and she is also the one who pushed on the pubic bone. [ 135 ] She has no recollection of witnessing shoulder dystocia before that event in 2003. She has no recollection of using that method of handling a mother’s leg prior to 2003. She has no other recollection of applying any kind of force to a woman’s leg during support. [ 136 ] She does not recall ever having her technique for supporting a labouring mother’s leg corrected. She does clearly recall other nursing techniques of hers being corrected on two occasions.
She indicates that she works very hard to do things right, and that she’s very sensitive when she’s made a mistake. So she clearly remembers being corrected those two times. Neither of them had anything to do with leg support technique. She has never been corrected by a physician. [ 137 ] In cross-examination, Cynthia Mann gave the following additional evidence. [ 138 ] A nursing student could be in the delivery unit one day and the postpartum unit the next. Records show that she was in the postpartum unit on March 24.
Her attention was brought to the entry for March 24, 2000, at 11:00 a.m., on page 52 of Exhibit 1. She confirmed that the “C. Mann” written at the end of that entry was her, and that she was dealing with Ms. McIntosh. [ 139 ] She does not recall the fact that Ms. McIntosh worked with her mother-in-law as being part of the conversation. However, she indicated that, in her testimony, Ms.
McIntosh: did get her mother-in-law’s name right; and, was correct that her daughter was her mother-in-law’s first grandchild. [ 140 ] She did not recall whether or not the training she received in her course on labour and delivery was extensive. She did not recall whether she received that training before or after the time she spent in the birth unit. [ 141 ] Ms. Mann, although she is not a party to this action, does have a personal interest in the outcome because it involves a finding in relation to whether or not she did anything wrong.
However, she freely admitted that she did not recall what occurred in the delivery room. It is reasonable that she would not remember that over a decade after-the-fact. She was not evasive. She answered the questions in a straightforward fashion. Her evidence was internally consistent. It was also externally consistent with that of Nurse Duykers.
[ 142 ] It is reasonable, given the place and circumstances she was in at the time, that she would have been shadowing Nurse Duykers and following her lead and instructions. [ 143 ] I found her to be credible. Her evidence was reliable. (
C) Whether the Nursing Student’s Actions were Within the Applicable Standard of Care [ 144 ] In the post-trial memorandum submitted on behalf of Ms. McIntosh there are a number of submissions related to an unidentified nurse being present during the first half of the pushing phase. It is argued that this nurse did not testify and there is no evidence of her practice, nor of what might have occurred while she was there.
It is suggested that, since the defendant had the ability to provide this evidence, the Court should draw an adverse inference from it not having been provided. [ 145 ] As pointed out in the Defendant’s rebuttal, the name of the nurse in question is clearly noted in the hospital chart. Her initials, DC, are included at the end of the chart notes she made. The name of the nurse associated with those initials is identified on the very next page as being D. Calder. Consequently, the nurse was not unidentified.
There was no evidence in relation to whether or not it was in the power of the Defendant to present that witness. In addition, if it was in the power of the Defendant to present that witness, there was no evidence upon which the Court could infer that it would not also have been in the power of the Plaintiff to do so. [ 146 ] More importantly, there is nothing in the evidence which calls into question anything that happened while Nurse Calder was present. As such, her evidence would be irrelevant. The evidence of Ms. McIntosh was that Ms. Mann’s handling of her left leg had been in the presence of Nurse Duykers.
Further, the evidence of Nurse Duykers and Ms. Mann was that Ms. Mann would have shadowed and stayed with Nurse Duykers at all times. [ 147 ] The evidence of Ms. McIntosh shows that the only actions of Ms. Mann that are in issue are those which occurred while she was in the presence of Nurse Duykers. That evidence includes the following. [ 148 ] The nurses had changed. She didn’t see anyone for a bit. Then the nursing student and the nurse came in and told her they were going to push the baby down to a lower station. The nursing student in question was Cynthia Mann. The nurse’s name was Margaret.
She later found out that the nurse was Margaret Duykers. [ 149 ] At some point before the shift change, there was a nurse by the name of Lisa also. However, there was no evidence she was in any way involved with the pushing phase of her attempted vaginal delivery. [ 150 ] She was asked the role Ms. Mann and Margaret played in the delivery. She said: “They told me we were going to start pushing to see if we could move the baby down”. Obviously Margaret was the nurse. She was the one giving instructions.
Cynthia was the student and was consulting with her and helping her to support the techniques and what they were planning to do (that is push the baby down). She indicated her husband David was present during the pushing phase. She indicated Ms. Mann was present. She indicated she believed Margaret was there. She stated that the whole time she was pushing those two were there. She stated that Ms. Mann was on her left side and Ms. Duykers was on her right side. [ 151 ] She indicated that no one other than the nurse and the student nurse held her legs.
On the first contraction, the nurse put her legs in a position for her and instructed her how to push. She did not, at any point, indicate that any other nurse besides Nurse Duykers was there with Ms. Mann, while pushing in an attempt to lower the baby. [ 152 ] In my view, the only handling of Ms. McIntosh’s legs that is in issue is that which occurred while both Ms. Mann and Nurse Duykers were present. Consequently, what happened in the presence of Nurse Calder is not in issue. [ 153 ] For the reasons noted during my assessment of the reliability of Lisa McIntosh’s evidence, I am unable to accept that Ms. Mann
[153] For the reasons noted during my assessment of the reliability of Lisa McIntosh’s evidence, I am unable to accept that Ms. Mannpushed back on Ms. McIntosh’s left leg so as to hyper-flex it on the hip. More likely than not, Ms. Mann only provided a minimalamount of resistance to ensure that Ms. McIntosh’s leg remained in the correct position or to reposition it where it should remain. Iaccept that there would’ve been some back and forth movement, similar to the movement that would be experienced if Ms.
McIntosh’sleg had been in a sling. [154] Although Nurse Duykers had no independent recollection of the event, she did make a comment that Ms. McIntosh was pushingwell. It is clear from the evidence of Dr. Robinson, Nurse Duykers and Ms. Mann that, if there is pushing out with her legs, that is notconsidered pushing well. It is a counterproductive way of pushing. It tightens the muscles of the pelvis. It does not help bring the babydown. The comment that Ms. McIntosh was pushing well, in my view, indicates that, more likely than not, she was not pushing out withher feet. [155] More likely than not, Ms.
McIntosh’s recollection, or
interpretation, that her legs were pushed back too far are based on twothings. First of all she felt discomfort and felt like her diaphragm was shrunk the whole time. She was severely swollen. Therefore, even a90 degree angle of flexion, with the back of the bed raised approximately 45 degrees, would, more likely than not, caused her to feel likeher legs were pushed back against her body. Secondly, she, more likely than not, fell into the trap of recalling what occurred in a waywhich pointed to a cause for her condition other than an innate degenerative process.
It would be difficult for an active 33 year oldwoman to accept that her body was naturally degenerating to the extent which was discovered. [156] Based on the foregoing, I find that the plaintiff has not established, on a balance of probabilities, that the student nurse, CynthiaMann, breached the applicable standard of care. [157] However, in the event that I have erred in coming to this conclusion, I will determine whether the plaintiff has established on abalance of probabilities, that Ms. Mann’s handling of Ms. McIntosh’s leg caused the damage that was observed in Ms.
McIntosh’s hipand resulted in her developing osteoarthritis, requiring a hip replacement. [158] The damage observed in Ms. McIntosh’s left hip included osteochondral fragments, a tear of the ligament teres and a tornlabrum. The medical terminology for the damage observed will be explained in the course of discussing the expert evidence oncausation. 2. WHETHER MS. MANN’S HANDLING OF MS. MCINTOSH’S LEFT LEG CAUSED, WITHIN HER LEFT HIP,OSTEOCHONDRAL FRAGMENTS, A PARTIAL TEAR OF THE LIGAMENT TERES AND/OR A TORN LABRUM,RESULTING IN OSTEOARTHRITIS, REQUIRING THE HIP TO BE REPLACED (
A) The Test for Causation [159] The parties agree that the test to be used determining causation in the case at hand is the “but for” test. In my view, the “but for”test is the appropriate test to be applied. This is not one of those rare cases where the “material contribution” test is to be applied. Even ifit were clear that the Defendant breached a duty of care owed to the Plaintiff, and thereby exposed her to an unreasonable risk of injury ofthe type alleged, there is no indication that it is impossible for the Plaintiff, due to factors outside her control, to prove that Ms.
Mann’sactions caused her injuries. [160] Under the “but for” test, “[t]he plaintiff bears the burden of showing that ‘but for’ the negligent act or omission of eachdefendant, the injury would not have occurred”. The plaintiff must establish that on a balance of probabilities. The “but for” test “ensuresthat the defendant will not be held liable for the plaintiff’s injuries where they ‘may very well be due to factors unconnected to thedefendant and not the fault of anyone’ ”. [Hanke v.
Resurfice Corp., 2007 SCC 7, at paragraphs 21 to 23]. [161] “[I]n the absence of evidence to the contrary adduced by the defendant, an inference of causation may be drawn althoughpositive or scientific proof of causation has not been adduced.” The amount of affirmative evidence required to justify drawing aninference of causation, in the absence of positive or scientific proof, depends upon the knowledge possessed by the respective parties andthe evidence which one party has the ability to produce, in addition to the ability the other party has to contradict that evidence. [Snell v.Farrell, (SCC), [1990] 2 S.C.R. 311, at paragraphs 30 to 35]
[ 162 ] In the case at hand, the nurse and the nursing student have very little recollection of the event. Their evidence is heavily reliant on the patient chart notes. The Plaintiff has copies of them. [ 163 ] The Plaintiff’s causation expert, Dr. Michael Dunbar, had the ability to access all of the materials the Defendant’s causation expert, Dr. Michael Gross, accessed to prepare his opinion. The Defendant is in no better position than the Plaintiff to lead evidence of causation. In addition, although Ms. McIntosh’s sensation may have been numbed by the epidural she received, she was conscious during the event.
It is not a situation where the Plaintiff was unconscious during the event in question and unable to provide any evidence of what occurred. [ 164 ] In the case at hand, it cannot be said that “the facts lie particularly within the knowledge of the defendant”. Therefore, it is not one of the cases where “very little affirmative evidence on the part of the plaintiff will justify the drawing of an inference of causation in the absence of evidence to the contrary”. [ Snell v. Farrell , paragraph 31] [ 165 ] As submitted by the Plaintiff, in her post-trial memorandum, based on Bohun v.
Sennewald , 2008 BCCA 23 , the “Plaintiff has to establish that it is more likely than not that the Defendants caused the Plaintiffs injury”. As submitted in the closing arguments of the Defendant, “there must be a substantial connection between the Plaintiff’s injury and the Defendant’s conduct”. [ 166 ] I will now turn to the evidence that is relevant to the issue of causation. (
B) Evidence Relating to Causation Dr. Michael Dunbar [ 167 ] On direct examination, Dr. Michael Dunbar provided the following evidence relating to causation. [ 168 ] He confirmed that the document in Exhibit 1, Tab 2, at page 87, was the consult report he prepared following his initial consultation with Ms. McIntosh on July 16, 2001. That consultation was 16 months past the birth in question. [ 169 ] In preparing the report, he reviewed the documentation on file, interviewed the patient, examined the patient, reviewed and interpreted the radiographs.
He had a discussion with the patient regarding her history, including her history in the lithotomy position. He described the lithotomy position as being her lying on her back, with both hips and knees flexed. [ 170 ] The consult report referred to the difficulty with her hip being “related to an episode of forced flexion of the left hip during a trialed labour for delivery of a child in March of 2000". He explained what he meant by “forced flexion” by stating that he understood that, in some circumstances, it is necessary to open the birth canal.
To do that the knees are brought up towards the head and closer to the chest, past, for example, “the 90 degree angle”. [ 171 ] His consult report went on to state: “At that time, while in the lithotomy position, she had both legs forcefully flexed and she felt a pop in her left hip.” Exhibit 2, Tab 6, is a letter dated June 1, 2009 from him to Colin Bryson, solicitor for Lisa McIntosh. That report included the following: “In my note regarding the history of Ms. Lisa McIntosh’s present condition dated April 26, 2002, I stated Ms.
McIntosh specifically felt a ‘popping’ sensation in the left hip resulting in pain in the groin area. It has come to my attention that this was not specifically the case and Ms. McIntosh did not experience this popping sensation or immediate onset of pain in the hip. I am writing to inform you, in my opinion, this does not affect the rest of my statements with the report and it continues to be my opinion that the injury to her hip was sustained during the delivery in question.”
[ 172 ] His letter of June 1, 2009 to Mr. Bryson was to correct the error he had made. It was his understanding that the popping sensation alluded to was the sensation of “crunching” in the hip Ms. McIntosh began to feel at some point after delivery. That error did not change his opinion. [ 173 ] The absence of pain immediately in the delivery room and the fact that the pain was only felt subsequently, did not affect his opinion either. [ 174 ] When you’re taking a history from a patient, a lot of information is exchanged between the patient and the consultant in a short time. His
interpretation was that something happened during delivery. He doesn’t think that the popping relates directly to there being a problem. It is insignificant to the specific episode because the patient was under spinal anaesthesia. Consequently, he doesn’t think that whether or not she sensed the pain at the time is relevant. [ 175 ] Part of the natural physiology of delivering a baby is that the body produces endorphins. These also arise when breastfeeding. Immediately postpartum, the symptoms may be masked by the physiological effects of having a baby. [ 176 ] It is noteworthy that, by agreement, Dr.
Dunbar was qualified as an expert in “orthopaedics, capable of giving evidence in that field of expertise, including the cause of hip injuries, notably a labral tear, a partial tear of the ligament teres and the presence of osteochondrial fragments in a hip, the treatment required and the resulting prognosis and medical restrictions”. Nowhere in those qualifications was there any specific indication of capability of giving expert evidence relating to the physiological effects of having a baby.
As a medical doctor he can assist the Court in assessing what if any part the physiological effects of having a baby may have played. However, that portion of his opinion carries little or no weight. [ 177 ] Exhibit 2, Tab 3, is a report from him to Mr. Bryson dated April 26, 2002. On the second page, at the third and fourth full paragraphs, it states: “Review of radiographs demonstrated essentially normal plain films. However, the bone scan of the region showed a diffuse uptake around the hip joint, indicative of pathology within the region.
A CT scan compared to MR arthrogram demonstrated two osteochondral fragments within the synovium of the left hip, which had migrated to the inferior recesses, out of the weight-bearing dome. Unfortunately, due to the lack of resolution on the MR arthrogram and CT scan, we were unable to see the bony beds from which they came. These were, however, definitely intraarticular osteochondral fragments. I have had several frank discussions with Ms. McIntosh regarding what this means. In my professional opinion, these two lesions did occur at the time of childbirth and the mechanism is in keeping with such an injury.
As to whether or not this is common or a foreseeable complication of childbirth, I would have to say that in my opinion it is not, as certainly this is the first case such as this that I have seen in my practice and in my surgical training. Furthermore, I have not come across this in my surgical readings as a cause for hip pathology in a young patient.” [ 178 ] The meaning of “diffuse uptake” is explained as follows. When conducting a bone scan, a radioactive isotope is introduced into the hip. That radioactive isotope goes to the area of increased bone activity.
Increased bone activity results in increased uptake. It indicates a general area of insult. For instance, it can occur if you have a trauma to that area. [ 179 ] Osteochondral fragments are composed of both cartilage and bone bed. Such fragments are unique to an articular surface. When osteochondral fragments become detached, it leaves lesions in the articular surface, similar to a golf divot. [ 180 ] The socket in the pelvis in which the head of the femur sits is called the acetabulum. [ 181 ] Osteochondral fragments in the hip are most often caused by some sort of trauma.
[ 182 ] “Lesions” could be osteochondral lesions and labral tears. [ 183 ] The meaning of a “labral tear” was explained as follows. The labrum is the gasket around the hip socket. It is made of fibrous cartilage and holds a capsule or wall that goes around the acetabulum. On occasion, particularly if there is forced flexion, the neck of the femur can impinge on the bony rim of the acetabulum as the femur is flexed. The gasket of cartilage will be between the bony rim of femur and the acetabulum. They deduce that the mechanism is that this impingement leads to the detachment of that labrum or gasket.
Once it is detached, it does not repair itself. [ 184 ] He deduced, through a train of logic, that the labral tear was in keeping with an injury at the time of childbirth. In his view, forced flexion leads to impingement of the labrum and subsequent subluxation of the hip joint, which means it becomes nonconcentric, and through that process damage is created in the weight-bearing joint of the acetabulum. [ 185 ] He was asked to comment on his statement that he had not come across this before.
His answer was that this was something which was rare and it is not something you see of often. [ 186 ] The fifth full paragraph, on page two of his report of April 26, 2002, contains a statement that it cannot be determined when Ms. McIntosh might be expected to require a hip replacement and that she was a long way off from it. It was pointed out to Dr. Dunbar that she ended up having a hip replacement in 2007. He responded that Ms. McIntosh had a more rapid deterioration than had been anticipated in 2002. Hip “arthroplasty” means hip replacement. [ 187 ] In the last paragraph at page two of his report, Dr.
Dunbar recommended arthroscopic debridement of the hip. He recommended that partly because of its therapeutic potential. Through that procedure, there was a possibility of reattaching the labrum and it could be used to remove loose bodies within the joint. It was also partially diagnostic. It would help better understand the environment the hip was in. [ 188 ] Exhibit 2, Tab 4, contains a report dated February 6, 2006 from Dr. Dunbar to Mr. Bryson. It outlines the additional pathological abnormalities that were observed at the time of the arthroscopic surgery, including
[…]
Loading document…