The Halifax Regional Municipality Pension Committee Plaintiff v. State Street Bank v. Trust Company and State Street Global Advisors Ltd./ Conseillers En Gestion Global State Street, Ltée, 2011 NSSC 355
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Halifax (Regional Municipality Pension Committee) v. State Street Global Advisors Ltd., 2011 NSSC 355 Date: 20110930 Docket: Hfx 309063 Registry: Halifax Between: The Halifax Regional Municipality Pension Committee Plaintiff v.
State Street Bank and Trust Company and State Street Global Advisors Ltd./ Conseillers En Gestion Global State Street, Ltée Defendants NOTE: RESTRICTED TO FILENET Judge : The Honourable Justice Patrick Duncan Heard: August 18, 19 and 20, 2010, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Counsel: George MacDonald, Q.C., Jane O ’ Neill, and Peter Rogers, Q,C, for the plaintiff Michael Ryan, Q.C. John Keith, Christopher Zimmerman, Andrea Robinson, and Michael Dube for the defendants I N D E X
I N D E X Heading Paragraph Number INTRODUCTION 1 Background 3 Legal Principles 20 Meaning of relevancy 29 Analysis 40 PLAINTIFF ’ S FIRST MOTION 43 The
Preamble 46 Category 1 49 Category 2 95 Category 3 100 Category 4 111 Category 5 119 Category 6 126 Category 7 132 Category 8 152 Category 9 166 PLAINTIFF ’ S SECOND MOTION 177
Analysis 178 Heading Paragraph Number PLAINTIFF ’ S THIRD MOTION 226 DEFENDANT ’ S FIRST MOTIONS 237 Category 1 and Category 2 241 Analysis 252 Category 3 and Category 4 277 Northern Trust 282 RBC Dexia 283 Brockhouse Cooper and Ryan Anderson 291 Category 5 302 Background 303 Relevance 310 Solicitor - Client Privilege General 316 Express and Implied Waiver of Privilege 318 Analysis 322 Conclusion 342
DEFENDANTS ’ SECOND MOTION 346 CONCLUSION 348 By the Court : INTRODUCTION [ 1 ] The plaintiff Halifax Regional Municipality Pension Committee (the Committee) has presented three motions seeking an order: 1. To compel the defendants (collectively, State Street) to make disclosure of several categories of documents; 2. Providing State Street with directions on disclosure; and 3. Setting dates for the trial of this matter. [ 2 ] The defendants counter with two motions seeking an order: 1.
To compel the plaintiff to expand the parameters of their search for relevant documents and electronic information and to disclose such information as those searches reveal, including a requirement that the plaintiff’s law firm, McInnes Cooper, produce documents and information over which the plaintiff claims solicitor-client privilege. 2. To set a
schedule for the exchange of relevant documentation/electronic information and discovery examinations. Background [ 3 ] The Committee is the pension manager for employees of the Halifax Regional Municipality and certain other Halifax public sector employees. [ 4 ] The defendant State Street Global Advisors Ltd./ Conseillers En Gestion Globale State Stree Ltee (SSGA Can) is a federally incorporated company with its’ registered office in Montreal, Quebec. It is registered to carry on business in Nova Scotia and was a party, with the Committee, to an Investment Management Agreement, dated January 16, 2007.
SSGA Can is alleged by the plaintiff to have been acting as investment manager for the Committee at times relevant to this claim. [ 5 ] The defendant State Street Bank and Trust Company (SSBTC) is a Massachusetts trust company. It provides, among other things, financial services to institutional investors, including custody services, trust services, investment management, trading services, and investment servicing. [ 6 ] State Street Global Advisors (SSGA US) is an investment management firm with its offices in Massachusetts. It is alleged to
be the investment arm of, and a division of SSBTC. [ 7 ] In the first half of 2007 there were meetings of Committee representatives with representatives of SSGA Can, the Global Alpha Edge Fund (the Alpha Fund) managers, SSGA US and SSBTC. There was various correspondence among these parties. [ 8 ] The Committee decided to invest in a “130/30 strategy”. Under this strategy, short positions are taken to a maximum of 30% of portfolio value. The risks associated with short positions are hedged by taking long positions to a maximum of 130% of portfolio value.
The Statement of Defence filed by State Street provides the following explanation of "short positions" or "short selling": "Short positions" or "short selling" is an investment strategy in which an investor sells stock it does not own. The investor must first borrow the stock from a broker. Investors who sell short do so believing the price of the stock will fall and that they can buy the stock back at a lower price and therefore make a profit.
However, if the price of the stock rises, the investor may be required to buy the stock back at a higher price, incurring a loss. [ 9 ] This investment strategy can employ different percentages ( e.g., 120/20; 130/30; 140/40) and is referred to generically as an “extension strategy”. [ 10 ] On July 30, 2007 the Committee entered into an Agreement of Trust (AoT) with SSBTC to settle funds on the latter to pursue this strategy.
The Committee transferred approximately $47 million (the Halifax assets) to SSBTC , which were intended for investment in the Alpha Fund, a common trust fund controlled by the defendant SSBTC. The investment was managed from August 9, 2007 to September 15, 2008 by SSGA US. [ 11 ] The Alpha Fund had been created by two earlier declarations of trust. In October, 2004, SSBTC signed a general Declaration of Trust over all of its global managed common trust funds. This document contemplated the declaration of new common trust funds.
The Alpha Fund was established by a separate trust declaration and became subject to the general Declaration of Trust as well as the terms specific to the Alpha Fund Declaration. [ 12 ] Custody of, and prime brokerage for, the Alpha Fund, which included all of the Halifax assets, was given by SSBTC to Lehman Brothers Inc. (LBI). In turn those assets were transferred to Lehman Brothers International (Europe), (LBIE).
The Committee alleges that it was not informed that custody of the Halifax assets had been transferred to Lehman and that authorization for the transfer was not given. [ 13 ] SSBTC and Lehman are alleged to be signatories to the following agreements (the Lehman Agreements): (
a) Margin Lending Agreement dated May 7, 2007, between LBIE and SSBTC, as Trustee of the Alpha Fund; (
b) Customer Account Prime Brokerage Agreement dated May 7, 2007 between SSBTC, as Trustee of the Alpha Fund, and LBI, for itself and its affiliates, including LBIE; (
c) Global Master Securities Lending Agreement, undated, between SSBTC, as Trustee of the Alpha Fund, and LBIE. [ 14 ] The Lehman Agreements purportedly grant Lehman authority to deal with any assets of the Alpha Fund in its’ possession, free and clear of any trusts or obligations to segregate them for protection in the event of insolvency. They allow Lehman to characterize them as "collateral" and to pledge them as collateral for Lehman's own loans. The following clauses of the Agreements have been identified by the plaintiff as particularly relevant to the present motion:
[Lehman] ... shall have a lien on and a continuing first priority security interest in all of [the Alpha Fund] cash, securities, financial assets and other property from time to time delivered ... or otherwise held by, or under the control of [Lehman] (the "Collateral") ... Affidavit of T. Troy, Exhibit "1D", Clause 5(b) [the Alpha Fund] hereby authorizes [Lehman] to lend either to itself or to others any or all Collateral, to convey therewith all attendant rights of ownership ... and to use all such Collateral as collateral for its general loans.
Any Collateral, together with all attendant rights of ownership, may be pledged, repledged, hypothecated or rehypothecated either separately or in common with other property for any amounts due to [Lehman] ... Affidavit of T. Troy, Exhibit "1D", Clause 5(c) ... cash delivered by [the Alpha Fund] will not be client money pursuant to the Rules [of the Financial Services Authority of England and Wales] and will not be subject to the protections conferred by the Rules.
Such cash will not be segregated from the money of [Lehman] or any other counterparty of [Lehman] and will be held free and clear of all trusts…[Lehman] will use such cash in the course of its business and [the Alpha Fund] will, therefore, rank as a general creditor of [Lehman] in respect of such cash." Affidavit of T. Troy, Exhibit "1D", Clause 7(c) ... [the Alpha Fund] represent[s] that all Assets shall at all times be free and clear of all liens, claims and encumbrances of any nature for the benefit of a party other than a Lehman Brothers entity... Affidavit of T.
Troy, Exhibit "1E", Clause 4(c) [the Alpha Fund] hereby authorize[s] Lehman Brothers to lend either to itself or to others any Assets, to convey therewith all attendant rights of ownership ... and to use all Assets as collateral for its general loans. Any such property, together with all attendant rights of ownership, may be pledged, repledged, hypothecated or rehypothecated either separately or in common with other property for any amounts due to Lehman Brothers thereon or for a greater sum, and Lehman Brothers shall have no obligation to retain a like amount of similar property in its possession and control...
Affidavit of T. Troy, Exhibit "1E", Clause 20(a) [ 15 ] It has been suggested that throughout the time that SSBTC invested the Halifax Assets in the Alpha Fund, numerous media reports discussed financial turmoil within Lehman Brothers, leading to a ratings downgrade in June, 2008 by Moody's Investment Service, Standard & Poors, and Fitch Ratings. [ 16 ] LBI declared bankruptcy on September 15, 2008. LBIE was placed under administration in England on the same date. The administrator of LBIE, PricewaterhouseCoopers, has taken the position that the Halifax assets, as part of the Alpha Fund assets, are “frozen”.
Repeated demands made to the defendants for return of the Halifax assets, have not been successful. [ 17 ] The Committee filed the present action on March 25, 2009, seeking a return of the Halifax assets. It was amended on two occasions, the Second Amended Statement of Claim having been filed July 16, 2009. The Committee claims against the defendants for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, and breach of contract. [ 18 ] A Defence to the claim was filed on August 19, 2009. It includes a general denial of the allegations.
It specifically pleads that the plaintiff is a sophisticated investor that was aware of the role of a prime broker and the risks associated with the 130/30 investment strategy. The plaintiff asserts that the AoT provides all necessary authority for the actions of SSBTC.
The Defence characterizes the Lehman insolvency as “sudden and unexpected” and that the defendants’ conduct insofar as the selection of Lehman as a prime broker was consistent with industry and contractual expectations of the defendants. [ 19 ] The parties have been unable to resolve differences over the extent of their mutual disclosure obligations in this litigation, or
the timetable by which to effect disclosure and discovery. Legal Principles [ 20 ] The Nova Scotia Civil Procedure Rules require every party to litigation to make “full disclosure of relevant documents and electronic information”. It is presumed to be necessary for justice in a proceeding. see , Rule 14.08 (1) . [ 21 ] This presumption equally applies to, among other things, the disclosure of electronic information: 14.08
(5) The presumption for disclosure applies, unless it is rebutted, on a motion under Rule 14.12 , Rule 15.07 of Rule 15 - Disclosure of Documents, Rules 16.03 or 16.14 of Rule 16 - Disclosure of Electronic Information, Rule 17.05 of Rule 17 -Disclosure of Other Things, or Rule 18.18 of Rule 18 - Discovery. [ 22 ] Parties to litigation have a concomitant duty to find and preserve relevant information as enunciated in Rule 14.08(2): 14.08
(2) Making full disclosure of documents or electronic information includes taking all reasonable steps to become knowledgeable of what relevant documents or electronic information exist and are in the control of the party, and to preserve the documents and electronic information. [ 23 ] Rule 15 sets out a topic specific framework for the identification, preservation and disclosure of documents.
Rule 16 similarly sets out a specific framework within which “electronic information” must be searched for, preserved and disclosed. [ 24 ] What is determined to be relevant and disclosable has the potential to substantially shape the way in which the parties map out their litigation strategies.
The parties do not agree as to what are the appropriate parameters of their respective searches for relevant materials. [ 25 ] In support of its’ motions, the plaintiff says that a definition of “relevancy” that is too restrictive will result in a failure to capture information in the possession or control of the defendants that is necessary for the plaintiff to properly advance its’ claim.
This would, in their submission, result in an unreasonable limitation upon the information available for the discovery of witnesses. [ 26 ] The defendants argue against the relevancy of some of the information that the plaintiff seeks. They add that some of the plaintiff’s requests will generate cost, and a burden, that is disproportionate to the likely probative value of the information sought by the plaintiff.
In this latter proposition they rely on the provisions of Rule 14.08(3) which states: 3) A party who proposes that a judge modify an obligation to make disclosure must rebut the presumption for disclosure by establishing that the modification is necessary to make cost, burden, and delay proportionate to both of the following: (
a) the likely probative value of evidence that may be found or acquired if the obligation is not limited; (
b) the importance of the issues in the proceeding to the parties. [ 27 ] In advancing this argument, the defendants must also comply with the evidentiary obligations set out in Rule 14.08(4):
(4) The party who seeks to rebut the presumption must fully disclose the party’s knowledge of what evidence is likely to be found or acquired if the disclosure obligation is not limited. [ 28 ] In support of their first four motions the defendants submit that the plaintiff has not taken “all reasonable steps to become knowledgeable of what relevant documents or electronic information exist and are in [its’ control]” as required by Rule 14.08(2). Meaning of relevancy [ 29 ] Rule 14.01 defines “relevant” and “relevancy” as follows: Meaning of “relevant” in
Part 5 14.01
(1) In this Part, “relevant” and “relevancy” have the same meaning as at the trial of an action or on the hearing of an application and, for greater clarity, both of the following apply on a determination of relevancy under this Part: (
a) a judge who determines the relevancy of a document, electronic information, or other thing sought to be disclosed or produced must make the determination by assessing whether a judge presiding at the trial or hearing of the proceeding would find the document, electronic information, or other thing relevant or irrelevant; (
b) a judge who determines the relevancy of information called for by a question asked in accordance with this
Part 5 must make the determination by assessing whether a judge presiding at the trial or hearing of the proceeding would find the information relevant or irrelevant. [ 30 ] This provision was considered by Justice Moir in the case of Saturley v. CIBC World Markets Inc . 2011 NSSC 4 . He sums up by setting out the following principles: 45 As I read Rule 14.01(1) , counsel who are deciding whether to make an issue about the relevancy of something for disclosure, or at discovery, must do their best to put themselves at the vantage they will have at the beginning of the trial.
And, when the issue goes to chambers, counsel will have to do their best to give the chambers judge the vantage the trial judge would have at the beginning of the trial.
And, the chambers judge must make a ruling from that vantage, imperfectly constructed though it may be. 46 This examination of the legislative history, the recent jurisprudence, and the text of Rule 14.01 leads to the following conclusions: * The semblance of relevancy test for disclosure and discovery has been abolished. * The underlying reasoning, that it is too difficult to assess relevancy before trial, has been replaced by a requirement that judges do just that.
Chambers judges are required to assess relevancy from the vantage of a trial, as best as it can be constructed. * The determination of relevancy for disclosure of relevant documents, discovery of relevant evidence, or discovery of information likely to lead to relevant evidence must be made according to the meaning of relevance in evidence law generally. The Rule does not permit a watered-down version. * Just as at trial, the determination is made on the pleadings and evidence known to the judge when the ruling is made.
In my opinion, these conclusions follow from, and are enlightened by, the principle that disclosure of relevant, rather than irrelevant,information is fundamental to justice and the recognition that an overly broad requirement worked injustices in the past. 47 In my opinion, these conclusions do not suggest a retreat from the broad or liberal approach to disclosure and discovery of relevantinformation that has prevailed in this province since 1972. [31] Bryson J.A., writing in Brown v.
Cape Breton (Regional Municipality) 2011 NSCA 32, approved of Justice Moir’sconclusions. see, at paras. 12-13. [32] The starting point for any analysis then is the “... meaning of relevance in evidence law generally”. I have considered thehelpful review of case and academic authority that discusses the meaning of “relevance”, provided by LeBlanc J. in Murphy v. Lawton’sDrug Stores Ltd. 2010 NSSC 289 at paras. 14-20. [33] The following are representative statements of the law by which I have guided myself in making the findings set out herein.
Atpage 30 in The Law of Evidence, 5th ed. revised, (Paciocco, David M.; Struesser, Lee) (Toronto: Irwin Law, 2010) the authorsdescribe the concept of relevance: Evidence is relevant where it has some tendency as a matter of logic and human experience to make the proposition for which it isadvanced more likely than that proposition would appear to be in the absence of that evidence.
To identify logically irrelevant evidence,ask, “Does the evidence assist in proving the fact that my opponent is trying to prove?” While the concept of materiality describes the relationship between evidence and the matters in issue, logical “relevance” is aboutthe relationship between evidence and the fact it is offered to prove. There is no legal test for identifying relevant evidence. Relevance isa matter of logic.
To identify logically irrelevant evidence, ask, “Does the evidence assist in proving the fact that my opponent is tryingto prove?” For example, evidence that the breath of the accused smelled of alcohol is relevant to whether her ability to drive wasimpaired by alcohol.
Evidence that she was seen drinking alcohol a week before is not. [34] And at page 31: 3.3) The Standard of Logical Relevance Evidence is relevant where it has some tendency as a matter of logic and human experience to make the proposition for which it isadvanced more likely than that proposition would be in the absence of that evidence. [ see, R. v. J. (J.-L.), 2000 SCC 51 , [2000]2 S.C.R. 600 at para. 47, and R. v. B.(L.), above note 4 at 47– 48. See the American Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 401, and thedecision of La Forest J. in R. v. Corbett, (SCC), [1988] 1 S.C.R. 670.] [35] In R. v.
Arp, (1998), (SCC), 129 C.C.C. (3d) 321 the Supreme Court of Canada has said: To be logically relevant, an item of evidence does not have to firmly establish, on any standard, the truth or falsity of a fact in issue. Theevidence must simply tend to “increase or diminish the probability of the existence of a fact in issue.” . . . As a consequence, there is nominimum probative value required for evidence to be relevant. [at p. 338] [36] Sopinka, Lederman and Bryant, in The Law of Evidence in Canada, 3rd ed. (Markham: Lexis Nexis Canada, 2009), state, atpara. 2.35:
§2.35 A traditionally accepted definition of relevance is that in Sir J.F. Stephen’s A Digest of the Law of Evidence , where it is defined to mean: ... any two facts to which it is applied are so related to each other that according to the common course of events one either taken by itself or in connection with other facts proves or renders probable the past, present, or future existence or non-existence of the other. [ 37 ] There are degrees of relevance.
The concept is discussed in Witnesses (Mewett, Alan W.; Sankoff, Peter) (Toronto: Carswell, looseleaf 1991 as updated to 2011- Rel. 2), at p. 1-13: Relevance is not a black or white concept. Evidence may range all the way from being conclusive proof of an issue down to being vaguely and only of the slightest assistance and from there down to the point when it ceases to be relevant.
While there is no difficulty in determining relevance at the upper end of the scale, the problem that arises is usually at the lower end of the scale. [ 38 ] So although we have moved away from a “semblance of relevancy” threshold for disclosure, disclosure is required of what may be relevant though “only of the slightest assistance”. [ 39 ] Rule 14.08(3) must be seen in this light. It will not justify an exemption of that which is highly relevant. It may support relief from disclosing otherwise relevant information that the cost and delay does not justify production of.
Analysis [ 40 ] This case has the potential to be a complex piece of litigation. There is a significant sum of money at stake.
The plaintiff is a manager of almost $1.0 billion in assets but operating out of a single location with a concentrated professional management structure and a volunteer Committee. [ 41 ] Costs of the burden to identify, preserve and disclose relevant information is, on the face of it, less onerous for the plaintiff, but it has expressed privacy concerns for the personal information of the volunteers who employ personal computers in receiving and storing information, and concerns for the information of uninvolved co-workers who share their employer’s data storage systems. [ 42 ] State Street is part of a complex corporate structure that has multiple related entities, with significant numbers of employees and clients.
It operates globally. That, in and of itself, is not an excuse to limit production that is otherwise called for by law. If , however, its' disclosure obligation is defined too broadly, then there is a risk of generating delay, unwarranted cost, and an unhelpful, and unfocused search for, and production of, information throughout a large, multi-dimensional corporate structure.
PLAINTIFF ’S FIRST MOTION [ 43 ] The plaintiff’s first motion seeks an order directing the defendants to produce, pursuant to Civil Procedure Rules 14.12(1), 15.07(2) and 26.02(3) , documents falling into nine categories to specifically include though not be limited to thirty three subcategories. [ 44 ] During the hearing, counsel for the plaintiff submitted a revised and narrower form of order than that sought in the original motion documents.
[ 45 ] The defendants, without conceding the relevance of any of the sought after information, responded with its’ own version of that proposed order. They allow that certain of the requests could be complied with, and without undue burden as contemplated by Rule 14.08(3) . The defendants’ version is generally distinguished from that of the plaintiff in the following ways: 1. The order would apply to “decision makers” only; 2. The order would limit the application of the order to four funds for which Lehman Brothers was the Prime Broker; 3. The order restricts the applicable time periods. 4. The order would not include those items where to comply would be unduly burdensome. The
Preamble [ 46 ] The parties disagree as to the form of
preamble to the proposed order which responds to the plaintiff’s first motion. The following, taken from the defendants’ draft, sets out the difference in the underlined phrasing.
THAT the Defendants State Street Bank and Trust Company and State Street Global Advisors Ltd./Counseillers en Gestion Global State Street, Ltèe (collectively “State Street”) must produce the following documents created prior to September 15, 2008 (unless a different time period is specified below): [ 47 ] The defendants seek that the production be limited to relevant time frames which they initially define by the date of the LBI declaration of bankruptcy, and the placement of LBIE under administration in England, both events which took place on September 15, 2008. [ 48 ] I agree with the defendants’ reasoning and proposed form of
Preamble subject to variations within specific categories and/or subcategories. In particular, there are some sources of relevant information that post date the September 15, 2008 date which should be disclosed. Category 1 [ 49 ] The plaintiff seeks: All documents relating to State Street’s knowledge of the risks involved in counter party concentration of credit risk with a single institution. [ 50 ] The plaintiff submits that State Street should not have allowed all of the Halifax assets to be placed in the custody of a single prime broker, Lehman.
They say that the financial crisis of 2008, including the insolvency of Bear Stearns, created a foreseeable risk of prime broker default and consequential losses as incurred by the plaintiff. [ 51 ] In this category, the plaintiff seeks documents that show what information about this credit risk was available to the defendants prior to the Lehman insolvencies. They point to evidence that the defendants employed analysts to assess the credit risk of
counterparties; that SSGA established policies and procedures to select and monitor prime brokers, and that there were options available to the defendants to avoid the risk, primarily by the use of multiple prime brokers. [ 52 ] The information sought is said to evidence whether: (
i) State Street failed to disclose information that was relevant and material to the investment of the Halifax assets; (ii) Lehman’s insolvency was unforseen; (iii) the defendants’ actions were reasonable in light of the information available; and (iv) the defendants acted reasonably by depositing the entirety of the Halifax assets with Lehman and allowing them to be transferred to the United Kingdom. [ 53 ] The defendants’ response is germane not only to this category but to others to be considered.
In general they take the position that the plaintiff’s requests are overly broad, and disclosure should be limited to that information relating to the selection and monitoring of Lehman as the prime broker for the Global Alpha Edge fund.
They say that no case has been made out to show that information relating to other funds, investors, or prime brokers is relevant to this matter. [ 54 ] The defendants also argue against being subjected to the burden that compliance with the plaintiff’s request would place upon them where they say there is little likelihood of identifying anything that has probative value. [ 55 ] Speaking to that burden they adduced evidence that as at July 2010 State Street spent over $1.0 million USD collecting and reviewing the documents of 23 custodians for privilege and relevance.
They suggest that some 8 million documents were already under review, before the application of any expanded search and disclosure parameters that might be imposed as a result of these motions. [ 56 ] As to the places and people to search: State Street is described as “... a global corporation which, at the end of 2009, had total assets of $157.95 billion USD, total deposits of $90.06 billion USD, $18.79 trillion USD of assets under custody and administration, and $2.92 trillion USD of assets under management.
Between 2007 and 2009, State Street employed between approximately 27,100 and 28,400 employees around the world.” [ 57 ] As to the funds to search: The defendants state that as at September 30, 2008 they managed 35 prime brokered funds, using seven different prime brokers.
Twenty two of those funds employed a form of “extension strategy”. [ 58 ] As to the scope of the transactions under review: The defendants offer as an example of the importance of a focused search that “...for custody customers alone, approximately 225,000 counter party transactions...” are undertaken daily. [ 59 ] The defendants equate the plaintiff’s requests to a proposal for a “grand rummaging through voluminous paper and electronic files”. [ 60 ] I turn now to the specifics of the requested disclosure. Category 1 - Introduction [ 61 ] The first category sought by the plaintiff is introduced as follows:
(
i) All documents relating to State Street’s knowledge of the risks involved in counter party concentration of credit risk with a single institution, in relation to any State Street fund utilizing a prime broker, including edge or extension strategy funds, including but not limited to the following: [ 62 ] The defendants’ proposal is: (
i) All documents in the possession of State Street custodians who were responsible for the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker of those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers relating to State Street’s knowledge of the risks involved in counter party concentration of credit risk with a single prime broker, including but not limited to the following: [ 63 ] Having considered the positions of the parties I have concluded that there is an insufficient evidentiary basis existing at this time to merit an unrestricted disclosure in relation to “any State Street fund using a prime broker” (of which there are said to be 35).
In saying this I have considered how the plaintiff’s proposed version would meet their four objectives set out above. It does not. [ 64 ] I agree that it is the so called “decision makers” whose knowledge is relevant and material. It is important that the disclosure include that information which was in their possession or control at relevant times and which speaks to the counter party concentration of credit risk with a single prime broker, irrespective of whether that information relates directly to Lehman.
If it was in the decision makers’ possession or control before, or while they made assessments of the appropriateness of hiring and retaining Lehman as the prime broker then it is disclosable. [ 65 ] Counsel for the plaintiff has expressed concerns about the restriction to “custodians” which the defendants’ arguments would seem to equate to “decision makers”. The real issues are (
i) who is captured by those terms; and (ii) who makes the determination as to whether an individual falls into the class. [ 66 ] For clarity, the term “decision makers” or “custodians” being the word employed in the introduction to category 1 should not be limited to the person or persons who handled the plaintiff’s investment, but should include the most senior management of State Street who had oversight of the decisions to hire and retain Lehman as a prime broker.
Their knowledge, the degree to which they share that knowledge with the operational staff, and their role in setting corporate policy and direction is very relevant to the manner in which the day to day decision makers fulfilled their tasks. [ 67 ] It will be for the defendant to ensure that this information is searched for and disclosed as required by the Rules. [ 68 ] I have included wording to ensure that the obligation on the defendants conforms to Rule 15.02(1) and note that the defendants have an obligation under Rule 15.02(2)(
a) with respect to documents “once controlled but no longer controls ...”. [ 69 ] Therefore the Introduction to Category 1 will read: (
i) All documents in the possession or under the control of the State Street custodians (which term includes senior management of SSGA, SSBTC or who were involved in the operation of the Global Alpha Edge Fund) who were responsible for or oversaw the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker of those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers, and which relate to State Street’s knowledge of the risks involved in counter party concentration of credit risk with a single prime broker, including but not limited to the following: [ 70 ] There are six subcategories of information sought.
I will set out the parties respective positions as each are considered.
Category 1, Subcategories (a), (
b) and (c) [ 71 ] The plaintiff seeks: (
a) any audited financial statements prepared between January 1, 2007 and September 15, 2008 for any State Street common trust fund or other investment fund utilizing extension strategies, (
b) any communications between State Street and PricewaterhouseCoopers or other auditors concerning the audited financial statements set out in subparagraph (i) (
a) above, (
c) any documents relevant to State Street’s knowledge of the statement of PricewaterhouseCoopers found on the December 31, 2007 audited financial statements (dated June 25, 2008) for the Global Alpha Edge Fund, which expressly warns of “counter party concentration of credit risk with a major financial institution”, [ 72 ] The defendants' responses are: (a) [Defendants are willing to produce the financial statements for those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers] (b) [ Unduly burdensome ] (c) [ Encompassed within prior searches and productions ] [ 73 ] After the Lehman bankruptcy, the plaintiff obtained a copy of the financial statement prepared for the Alpha Fund and dated December 31, 2007.
A note on these financial statements (dated June 25, 2008) is said to expressly warn of counter party risk resulting from the concentration of assets with a single entity. The note in question says: At December 31, 2007, the fund had counter party concentration of credit risk with a major financial institution. All amounts receivable and security positions held are deposited with this financial institution.
Credit risk exists to the extent that financial institution may be unable to repay amounts owed to the fund. [ 74 ] By its response, the defendants acknowledge the relevance of this information but seek to limit the disclosure to the financial statements prime brokered by Lehman Brothers.
They argue that to accept the plaintiff’s position will require an examination of all the materials exchanged among many persons over the approximately 10 months required to prepare each statement for the 22 funds using the extension strategy. [ 75 ] The plaintiff responds that it is entitled to know when this warning first started to appear on any of the statements, for any of these funds. They want know whether this warning was general to all prime brokered funds or only to those for Lehman Brothers International Europe brokered funds.
The distinction could signal awareness of a risk that would be material to the investor. The plaintiff says that because of the limited time frame specified in its request there can be no argument of undue burden. In effect, they are looking for the statements that would encompass the 2006 and 2007 years. [ 76 ] I observe that the
Preamble limits the disclosure to that information in the possession or control of a limited group of
custodians, which to some degree would limit the extent of the disclosure requirements generated by the plaintiff’s request. For example, if the custodians did not have the financial statements, and did not participate in the preparation of those other financial statements, then it is unlikely to be disclosable under this provision. There would be resources expended in the search, but the defendants make it clear that they are already conducting searches in relation to those persons.
This provision is only to ensure that as they continue those searches, they identify and disclose this additional information. [ 77 ] The question then is whether there are reasonable limits to impose based on relevance as measured against the burden and probative value. [ 78 ] Category1(
a) as requested by plaintiff is very limited, it seeks only the final audited financial statements and not the working documents generated in the preparation of the statements. These are statements that should be readily identifiable and capable of production. I believe that there are 22 funds and it is likely to generate 2 reports for each making a likely maximum total production requirement of 44 financial statements. [ 79 ] I conclude that the plaintiff will have the information they seek in 1(
a) which will read: (
a) any final audited financial statements prepared between January 1, 2007 and September 15, 2008 for any State Street common trust fund or other investment fund utilizing extension strategies. [ 80 ] As to 1(
b) I agree with the defendants that it is overbroad, even when limited to the “decision makers”. [ 81 ] The objective is to identify that information which informed the decision making with respect to the investment with LBI and ultimately LBIE, together with the risks associated with such an investment arrangement. If a decision maker communicated with auditors specifically on the inclusion or the significance, or the meaning of such a warning in the financial statements, then it does speak to their assessment in hiring and retaining LBI and should be disclosable.
This is so irrespective of whether the communications exchanged related to the Alpha fund or some other fund using the same strategy. [ 82 ] If the decision makers were alerted to the risks indicated by the warning set out in the Alpha Fund statement for 2007, and that they were greater for some prime brokered funds than others then it goes directly to the defendants’ statement in paragraph 6 of its Defence that “at all times preceding Lehman ’s insolvency, State Street ’s actions were entirely reasonable in light of the information available . ” ( Emphasis added ) I take this to mean that “information” which was “available” to the decision makers. [ 83 ] As to paragraph 1(c), the defendants say that current searches are already meeting this request.
As such it could be included in the order as submitted. However, I have concluded that it should be varied to ensure that the information emanating from the financial statements produced in response to 1 (
a) and that I conclude is relevant and disclosable is captured in the wording. [ 84 ] For greater certainty, the wording in (
c) is framed by the Introduction to Category 1 and so will include any communications between the “decision makers” (as set out in the
Preamble) and PricewaterhouseCoopers or other auditors that speaks to any warnings of "counter party concentration of credit risk with a major financial institution" and that arises from the audited financial statements required to be produced by 1(
a) above. [ 85 ] In
summary the plaintiff’s motion to include 1(
b) is denied, while 1(
c) will be replaced by the following: (Note: the paragraph and subparagraph numbering will be changed in the final order to reflect the proper sequence. I retain the parties’ paragraph numbering for the purposes of the analysis only) (
c) any documents relevant to State Street’s knowledge of the statement of PricewaterhouseCoopers found on the December 31, 2007 audited financial statements (dated June 25, 2008) for the Global Alpha Edge Fund, or included in the audited statements produced
pursuant to (
a) above and which expressly warns of “counter party concentration of credit risk with a major financial institution”. Category 1 Subcategory (d) [ 86 ] The plaintiff request that the defendants produce: (
d) any documents explaining why the audited financial statements referenced in subparagraph (i)(
c) were not provided to the Committee until after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, (in this Notice, “Lehman Brothers” includes all of the Lehman entities referred to in paragraph 1 of the Agreement dated May 7, 2007 between Lehman Brothers Inc. and State Street Bank and Trust) [ 87 ] The defendants submit that this request is “Encompassed within prior searches and productions”. This position was founded on a narrower
interpretation of what 1(
c) would include. I grant the plaintiff’s motion to include disclosure set out in 1(
d) but to achieve the original purpose the wording will need to be changed since the variation I have permitted above will generate documents that are not related to this request. I am not including reference to the financial statements for the other extension funds as the relevance to this particular warning cannot be determined at this time. [ 88 ] What has been identified in argument as paragraph 1(
d) will now read: (
d) any documents explaining why the audited financial statements of PricewaterhouseCoopers for December 31, 2007 (dated June 25, 2008) for the Global Alpha Edge Fund, which expressly warns of “counter party concentration of credit risk with a major financial institution”, were not provided to the Committee until after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, (“Lehman Brothers” includes all of the Lehman entities referred to in paragraph 1 of the Agreement dated May 7, 2007 between Lehman Brothers Inc. and State Street Bank and Trust) Category 1 Subcategories (
e) and (f) [ 89 ] The Plaintiff seeks: (
e) any documents relating to strategies employed or not employed by State Street to mitigate prime broker counter party risk in relation to any State Street fund utilizing a prime broker, including edge or extension strategy funds, (
f) any documents relating to the consideration of risks associated with the use of prime brokers or the use of particular prime brokers, including European prime brokers, and any protections taken by State Street, for its own protection or that of its customers, against the risk, in relation to any State Street fund utilizing a prime broker, including edge or extension strategy funds; [ 90 ] If granted, then disclosure would relate to 35 funds. [ 91 ] The defendants counter that this should be limited to the four funds prime brokered by Lehman. They propose: (
e) any documents relating to strategies employed or not employed by State Street to mitigate prime broker counter party risk for such funds ,
(
f) any documents relating to the consideration of any risks associated with the use of a prime broker generally or Lehman Brothers, including Lehman Brothers International (Europe), specifically for such funds , and any protections taken by State Street, for the protection of the investors in such funds against any such risk s , [ 92 ] The plaintiff is concerned that the combined effect of limiting this disclosure to the four funds and only for the “custodians” or “decision makers” is unduly restrictive and creates substantial risk that there will be no opportunity to obtain information that would show a contrast in how risks were managed and which could show negligent handling of the plaintiff’s funds. [ 93 ] I am satisfied that the information sought by the plaintiff is relevant to the extent that the material relates to funds employing extension strategies.
I am not satisfied that relevancy has been made out as it relates to the remaining funds that are prime brokered. I conclude that the plaintiff’s request is granted but to apply only to the 22 prime brokered funds employing extension strategies. [ 94 ] Paragraphs 1(
e) and (
f) will read: (
e) any documents relating to strategies employed or not employed by State Street to mitigate prime broker counter party risk in relation to any State Street prime brokered fund employing an edge or extension strategy; (
f) any documents relating to the consideration of risks associated with the use of prime brokers or the use of particular prime brokers, including European prime brokers, and any protections taken by State Street, for its own protection or that of its customers, against the risk, in relation to any State Street fund prime brokered fund, employing an edge or extension strategy; Category 2 [ 95 ] The plaintiff seeks more complete information as to SSBTC’s effort to retrieve the Fund assets frozen in the Lehman insolvency administration. [ 96 ] The debate between the parties is not whether the plaintiff is entitled to know what the status of the claim in the Lehman insolvency is, but whether and the extent to which such information is relevant in this action. [ 97 ] The defendants say that there is no pleading suggesting a claim is made against them for the manner in which they have pursued the Fund’s insolvency claims.
As well they say that they have been providing regular reporting in detailed written updates regarding SSBTC’s effort to retrieve the Fund assets frozen in the insolvency administration. [ 98 ] The plaintiff says that this information is relevant to damages - they want to know whether the defendants are advancing their interests unreservedly, or are they making concessions in favor of other creditor groups, in particular putting the defendants’ interests ahead of those of the plaintiff. [ 99 ] The defendants have not returned the invested funds to the plaintiff, in part because they submit that the funds are “frozen” in the insolvency administration.
I am satisfied that the plaintiff is correct in suggesting that the communications being sought are relevant to a potential damage claim and that there should be production, though not on the basis of the first submissions of the plaintiff, but rather on the common position adopted by the parties at the end of oral submissions. My acceptance of that conclusion was made subject to a determination of relevancy, which was not conceded by the defendants. Having concluded that the information is relevant I order that the defendants must produce:
(ii) All communications between State Street and PricewaterhouseCoopers, in its capacity as administrator of Lehman Brothers, following Lehman Brothers’ filing for bankruptcy protection on September 15, 2008 concerning the Global Alpha Edge Fund, or collectively concerning all four edge or extension strategy funds for which Lehman Brothers International (Europe) acted as prime broker; Category 3 [ 100 ] In the Notice of Motion the plaintiff sought: (iii) All documents evidencing State Street’s awareness of, analysis of, and response to the collapse of Bear Stearns in March 2008; [ 101 ] During the hearing, the plaintiff presented a revised request: (iii) All hard copy or electronic documents in the possession of State Street custodians who have been, or will be, subject to an electronic search or targeted document follow-up for relevant hard copy or electronic documents, by agreement, order, or otherwise, evidencing State Street’s awareness of, analysis of, and response to the collapse of Bear Stearns in March 2008; [ 102 ] Defendants’ pre hearing brief took the position that Bear Stearns’ situation was radically different than that of Lehman and had no bearing on the Alpha Fund management.
As such it was not relevant. [ 103 ] The plaintiff’s evidence includes a so called “Bear Stearns email” which was sent out to clients of State Street in the wake of the Bear Stearns collapse. It is entitled “ Is Lehman one of SSGA ’s Prime Brokers?
If so, what is your opinion of Lehman and are they subject to similar risks as Bear Stearns? ” It states that Bear Stearns “... has never been an approved prime broker at SSGA.” It draws comparisons between Lehman and Bear Stearns to differentiate the two. [ 104 ] I have also been presented with an email comparing the failures of Bear Stearns and Lehman, and seeking to differentiate State Street’s responses.
It is captioned “Why didn ’t we react to the market events regarding Lehman earlier, especially post Bear Stearns? ” [ 105 ] I am satisfied that the defendants saw the circumstances of the failures of the two entities as related, if only to explain why the failure of Bear Stearns should not have alerted them to the problems with Lehman. The underlying analysis that was conducted in-house to reach that conclusion is relevant to the forseeability of the Lehman collapse and the failure of the defendants to react in a timely manner so as to protect the plaintiff’s assets.
The disclosure sought is relevant. [ 106 ] The defendants also submitted that complying with the request would create an undue burden for which they seek relief pursuant to Rule 14.08(3) . The plaintiff, perhaps recognizing the merit of this position restricted the scope of the desired disclosure in the second version.
The defendants did not have an opportunity to assess whether this more restricted request would also be unduly burdensome and requested an opportunity to consider and possibly make further representations. [ 107 ] To this suggestion, the plaintiff says that there is sufficient information before the court to resolve the matter without further information. [ 108 ] While I am inclined to agree with the assessment of plaintiff’s counsel, fairness requires that the defendants be provided the opportunity they seek to consider and if necessary to make further submissions. [ 109 ] In the absence of evidence that satisfies Rule 14.08(3) the plaintiff’s motion will be granted.
[ 110 ] A determination of the motion in respect to Category 3 is held in abeyance pending further submissions of counsel. I will address this with counsel at our next case management hearing.
Category 4 [ 111 ] The plaintiff seeks: (iv) All hard copy or electronic documents in the possession of State Street custodians who have been, or will be, subject to an electronic search or targeted document follow-up for relevant hard copy or electronic documents, by agreement, order, or otherwise, evidencing State Street’s awareness of, monitoring of, analysis of, or response to market concerns regarding Lehman Brothers from January, 2008 to September 15, 2008, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents that refer to the decreasing market price for Lehman Brothers shares, (
b) any documents that refer to downgrades in Lehman Brothers’ credit rating, or changes in the pricing of Lehman credit default swaps (
c) any documents that refer to increases in security requirements, interest rates or other terms associated with money or assets loaned to or subject to rehypothecation by Lehman Brothers, (
d) any documents evidencing any requests by clients of State Street to avoid transactions with Lehman Brothers as a counter party, (
e) any documents that refer to efforts by Lehman Brothers to persuade State Street to continue to use it for prime brokerage services or other services involving counter party risk or which indicate or imply consideration for State Street continuing to use Lehman Brothers for such services; [ 112 ] The defendants respond: (iv) All hard copy or electronic documents in the possession of State Street custodians- who were responsible for the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker for those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers , evidencing State Street’s awareness of, monitoring of, analysis of, or response to market concerns regarding Lehman Brothers from January, 2008 to September 15, 2008, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents that refer to the decreasing market price for Lehman Brothers shares, (
b) any documents that refer to downgrades in Lehman Brothers’ credit rating, or changes in the pricing of Lehman credit default swaps (
c) any documents that refer to increases in security requirements, interest rates or other terms associated with money or assets loaned to or subject to rehypothecation by Lehman Brothers, (
d) any documents evidencing any requests by clients of State Street to avoid transactions with Lehman Brothers as a prime broker ,
(
e) any documents that refer to efforts by Lehman Brothers to persuade State Street to continue to use it for prime brokerage services which indicate or imply consideration for State Street continuing to use Lehman Brothers as prime broker ; [ 113 ] The parties again debate the breadth of the class of persons whose records are to be searched for the information required.
As I have previously determined, the problem is with the description of the class of “custodians” and I will resolve it in the same manner to reflect an expanded definition of who the decision makers are: (iv) All documents in the possession or under the control of the State Street custodians (which term includes senior management of SSGA, SSBTC or who were involved in the operation of the Global Alpha Edge Fund) who were responsible for or oversaw the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker of those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers, evidencing State Street’s awareness of, monitoring of, analysis of, or response to market concerns regarding Lehman Brothers from January, 2008 to September 15, 2008, including but not limited to the following documents: [ 114 ] Having determined the class to be searched I turn to the subcategories requested.
The parties’ differences are in (
d) and (e). [ 115 ] As to 4(d), I agree with the defendants that the reluctance of a client to use Lehman as a prime broker is relevant to the claim. Any similar reluctance to Lehman acting as a counter party is not so apparently relevant having regard to the many and quite likely unrelated counter party transactions that take place on a daily basis. [ 116 ] As to 4(e), I accept the plaintiff’s version.
The relevant issue is whether a special relationship existed as between Lehman and State Street that influenced the latter to use Lehman’s services, and undermined the defendants’ independent judgment in deciding whether to hire and retain them to act as a prime broker. [ 117 ] An incentive would not necessarily have been provided to encourage use as a prime broker, but the consequence of incentive in a collateral commercial relationship of the two could result in the same outcome as if the incentive was directly tied to use as a prime broker.
Again, the information sought is restricted by the class of persons who are being searched.
This is not an unfettered global search but a targeted search of those who decided and those who oversaw the decision making. [ 118 ] Therefore Category 4 will be: (iv) All hard copy or electronic documents in the possession or under the control of the State Street custodians (which term includes senior management of SSGA, SSBTC or who were involved in the operation of the Global Alpha Edge Fund) who were responsible for or oversaw the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker of those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers, evidencing State Street’s awareness of, monitoring of, analysis of, or response to market concerns regarding Lehman Brothers from January, 2008 to September 15, 2008, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents that refer to the decreasing market price for Lehman Brothers shares, (
b) any documents that refer to downgrades in Lehman Brothers’ credit rating, or changes in the pricing of Lehman credit default swaps (
c) any documents that refer to increases in security requirements, interest rates or other terms associated with money or assets loaned to or subject to rehypothecation by Lehman Brothers, (
d) any documents evidencing any requests by clients of State Street to avoid transactions with Lehman Brothers as a prime broker,
(
e) any documents that refer to efforts by Lehman Brothers to persuade State Street to continue to use it for prime brokerage services or other services involving counter party risk or which indicate or imply consideration for State Street continuing to use Lehman Brothers for such services; Category 5 [ 119 ] The plaintiff seeks: (
v) All documents relating to the choice of prime broker for the Global Alpha Edge Fund and other funds using an extension or edge strategy, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents relating to the selection of any Lehman Brothers entity as prime broker, whether in connection with the Global Alpha Edge strategy or otherwise, (
b) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to use Lehman Brothers as the prime broker for some extension or Edge Funds, and Goldman Sachs or other prime brokers as the prime broker for other extension or edge strategies, (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to allow a Lehman Brothers’ European affiliate, Lehman Brother International (Europe), as prime broker for some extension or Edge Funds, (
d) any documents that refer to the reason for including the Committee in the particular Global Edge Fund in which it was included; [ 120 ] The defendants suggest: (
v) All documents in the possession of State Street custodians who were responsible for the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker for those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers relating to the choice of prime broker for the Global Alpha Edge Fund and the other Extension/Edge funds using Lehman Brothers as prime broker , including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents relating to the selection of any Lehman Brothers entity as prime broker for such funds , (
b) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to use Lehman Brothers as the prime broker for such funds , (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to allow a Lehman Brothers’ European affiliate, Lehman Brother International (Europe), as prime broker for such funds , (
d) any documents that refer to the reason for including the Committee in the particular Global Edge Fund in which it was included;
[ 121 ] The class of persons whose records are to be searched will be defined in the same manner as I have previously held to constitute the decision makers. They are the group likely to hold this relevant information. [ 122 ] The parties again disagree on whether the search should include information relevant to funds and prime brokers other than the extension funds brokered by Lehman. [ 123 ] The plaintiff suggests that there is relevance in how and who was selected as the prime broker for the 22 extension funds.
The defendants say that relevance should be circumscribed by the decision to choose Lehman as a prime broker for four extension funds, and that relevance of the selection process for other funds is not relevant. I agree with the defendants. In this instance the plaintiff has not made out its’ case to cast the net so wide. [ 124 ] Even if relevant, I am satisfied that such a requirement for disclosure would generate a burden disproportionate to the probative value of the information sought.
The ability of the plaintiff to advance its’ position on the important issues of the claim should not be undermined by this limitation. [ 125 ] I conclude that Category 5 will read: (
v) All documents in the possession or under the control of the State Street custodians (which term includes senior management of SSGA, SSBTC or who were involved in the operation of the Global Alpha Edge Fund) who were responsible for or oversaw the decision to hire and retain Lehman Brothers as prime broker of those State Street Extension/Edge funds prime brokered by Lehman Brothers, relating to the choice of prime broker for the Global Alpha Edge Fund and the other Extension/Edge funds using Lehman Brothers as prime broker, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any documents relating to the selection of any Lehman Brothers entity as prime broker for such funds, (
b) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to use Lehman Brothers as the prime broker for such funds, (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain the decision of State Street to allow a Lehman Brothers’ European affiliate, Lehman Brother International (Europe), as prime broker for such funds, (
d) any documents that refer to the reason for including the Committee in the particular Global Edge Fund in which it was included; Category 6 [ 126 ] The plaintiff seeks: (vi) All documents relating to the use of the following disclaimer, or a disclaimer of a similar nature, by State Street in certain of its account summaries for its extension or edge strategies: “in the event of a failure or insolvency of the prime broker or its related entities, the Assets and Rehypothecated Assets are subject to set off loss and the fund may become an unsecured creditor of the prime broker”,
including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any account summaries posted to the State Street “Client Corner “ website for the Committee or other extension or edge strategy investors after January, 2007, (
b) any documents that evidence when such disclaimer first came into use for any extension or edge strategy, (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain why the disclaimer was not present in the account summaries provided by State Street to the Committee prior to September 15, 2008; [ 127 ] The defendants respond: (vi) All documents created prior to July 1, 2009 relating to the use of the following disclaimer, or a disclaimer of a similar nature, by State Street in certain of its account summaries for any Extension/Edge fund prime brokered by Lehman Brothers : “in the event of a failure or insolvency of the prime broker or its related entities, the Assets and Rehypothecated Assets are subject to set off loss and the fund may become an unsecured creditor of the prime broker”, including but not limited to the following documents: (
a) any account summaries posted to the State Street “Client Corner” website for the Committee or other such Extension/Edge fund investors after January, 2007, (
b) any documents that evidence when such disclaimer first came into use for any such Extension/Edge fund , (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain why the disclaimer was not present in the account summaries provided by State Street to the Committee prior to September 15, 2008; [ 128 ] The plaintiff is not opposed to the inclusion of a specific date by which such documents were created, however seek a much later date. In support of this position they note that the “disclaimer” found was from June 2009.
The plaintiff says that using the July 1, 2009 date does not assist them to assess whether it was “run” on other occasions. [ 129 ] Relevance is not in issue and there is no substantial increase in the burden that a later date would generate, given the very specific information being sought. I accept that an appropriate date is July 31, 2010. [ 130 ] The second dispute relates to the fund summaries that are to be reviewed for this disclaimer. I do not agree with the defendants in this instance.
The disclaimer information is highly relevant to the awareness of the defendants to the risks, and to the recognition of the obligation to advise its’ clients of that risk. Evidence that speaks to when the defendants recognized that risk, and who received the warning and when, goes to the manner in which the defendants met their obligations to their clients.
Isolating the four Lehman brokered funds would provide an incomplete picture. [ 131 ] I conclude that disclosure in Category 6 will be: (vi) All documents created prior to July 31, 2010, relating to the use of the following disclaimer, or a disclaimer of a similar nature, by State Street in certain of its account summaries for its extension or edge strategies: “in the event of a failure or insolvency of the prime broker or its related entities, the Assets and Rehypothecated Assets are subject to set off loss and the fund may become an unsecured creditor of the prime broker”, including but not limited to the following documents:
(
a) any account summaries posted to the State Street “Client Corner “ website for the Committee or other extension or edge strategy investors after January, 2007; (
b) any documents that evidence when such disclaimer first came into use for any extension or edge strategy, (
c) any documents that refer to or which may explain why the disclaimer was not present in the account summaries provided by State Street to the Committee prior to September 15, 2008; Category 7 [ 132 ] The plaintiff seeks: (vii) All documents in the following categories related to securities lending by State Street: (
a) any documents related to any potential or actual securities lending arrangement involving the Committee’s assets, or those of the Global Alpha Edge Fund, including any documents explaining the extent to which the assets of the Global Alpha Edge fund were being loaned to Lehman Brothers or were purportedly being used as collateral for the short sales, (
b) any documents containing securities lending terms and conditions for those State Street Common Trust Funds which lent securities to Lehman Brothers in the period between March 1, 2008 and September 15, 2008, (
c) any presentation materials used by State Street’s Security Finance Division between April 2007 and September 15, 2008 that contains any mention of securities lending risks of any kind, save and except that production shall not be required in the event that the content of the documents in relation to securities lending risks is identical to that within another document being produced; [ 133 ] The defendants submit: (vii) [
Preamble unnecessary and confusing ] (
a) Any documents related to any potential or actual securities lending program involving the Committee’s assets, and any documents explaining the extent to which the assets of the Global Alpha Edge fund were rehypothecated by Lehman Brothers or were purportedly being used as collateral for the short sales, (b) [ Irrelevant and Unduly burdensome ] (c) [ Irrelevant and Unduly burdensome ] [ 134 ] The plaintiff says that the Alpha Fund loaned securities, including the Halifax assets, to LBIE.
It relies on a letter dated October 8, 2008, from Philip Gillespie, in-house counsel for State Street, to counsel for the plaintiff, to support this assertion which letter says, in part, “... the [Alpha ] Fund loaned securities, including the HRC assets, to LBIE in execution and furtherance of the Fund ’s investment strategy and directives. ” This was sent in the wake of the Lehman failure. [ 135 ] The plaintiff adduced evidence that the Committee had, in September of 2007, confirmed in writing its refusal of authority to engage in securities lending in their “CAFI SWF”.
The Committee intends to argue that the defendants knew or ought to have known
that it would not have approved of the transfer of the assets on terms set out in the Lehman agreements. [ 136 ] It concludes that to pursue this argument it requires the information in this category. [ 137 ] The defendants submit that the vast majority of the documents and electronic information that the plaintiff seeks in this category are not relevant to the litigation; and that which is relevant is a subject of the ongoing searches. [ 138 ] They deny that securities lending is a program that was available to investors and refer me to a May 11, 2007 email from Patrice Denis of SSGA Can to Terri Troy which says: “For your information, securities lending is not available for 130-30 strategies due to the structure with Prime Brokers. ” I note that this predates the SSGA US investment management which did not begin until August of that year.
The defendants also provided evidence of Rebecca Hayes confirming that the Alpha Fund did not participate in a securities lending program. [ 139 ] The apparent contradiction between the Denis email and the Hayes affidavit evidence, and the Gillespie letter makes disclosure of some kind relevant to shed light on whether and to what extent securities lending was occurring. If it was occurring, then it is relevant to the plaintiff’s case to know what the defendants understanding was as to the (un)willingness of the plaintiff to permit such a practice. [ 140 ] I accept the defendants’ submissions that the
preamble is unnecessary. [ 141 ] The defendants submit that their version of (
a) will capture: 1. the relevant communications that speak to the Committee’s decision not to participate in the security lending program and in the CAFI Investment; and 2. the unavailability of securities lending in the Alpha Fund. [ 142 ] By employing the words “program” instead of “arrangement” to describe the manner of securities’ lending; and the term “rehypothecated” instead of “loaned” the defendants’ version seems to be more focused, perhaps more accurate.
After all, hypothecation “...is a pledge of security or collateral for a debt, without delivery of title or possession.” see, Black ’ Law Dictionary, 9 th ed., (Garner, Bryan A. ed.) (St Paul MN: West, 2009) [ 143 ] However, I favor the language of the plaintiff as their terms would include programs and rehypothecation but without limitations that may unnecessarily restrict access to relevant and disclosable information. [ 144 ] As to subcategories (
b) and (
c) the defendants do not concede relevance but add that the burden generated would be unjustified in any event. The defendants say that it is searching for and intends to produce any non-privileged documents and electronic information related to the negotiation of the Fund’s prime brokerage agreements with Lehman, including the Global Master Securities Lending Agreement. [ 145 ] The plaintiff submits that in (
b) it hopes to find communications that will evidence whether the rights awarded to Lehman under the Lehman Agreements are similar to the rights granted to Lehman under securities lending agreements with respect to State Street’s Common Trust Funds. [ 146 ] I do not agree that this information sought is relevant, at least based on the information before the court on these motions.
The terms and conditions on which Lehman was loaned securities by any of the Common Trust Funds would not enhance the understanding of whether the defendants knew of the plaintiff’s unwillingness to participate in such programs, or whether their assets were used in such a program in contravention of the authority that it provided. The plaintiff’s request in (
b) is refused.
[ 147 ] As to (
c) the plaintiff says that the principal securities lending risk is a common feature of securities lending and the Lehman agreements and that presentation materials produced by State Street evidencing securities lending risks during the April 2007 to September 15, 2008 time frame are relevant to the following issues: 1. State Street’s knowledge of securities lending risks; 2. State Street’s practice regarding disclosure of securities lending risks to its clients; 3.
Whether State Street correlated securities lending risks to prime brokerage risks in its presentation materials. [ 148 ] The defendants says that it is required to and will produce any presentations made to the Committee and that relate to any issues relevant to the matters raised in the pleadings. [ 149 ] They note that its’ Securities Finance division had 445 “agency” securities lending clients, with US$2.4 trillion in lendable assets. It operated 330 lending funds, with US$189.3 billion in lendable assets.
During the relevant period, it says that it is likely that at least 1000 presentations referring to securities lending would have been made to agency lending clients, securities lending fund investor clients and prospective investors in funds participating in securities lending programs. [ 150 ] Presentation materials employed in communications with the plaintiff are clearly relevant and will be disclosed. I am not satisfied that presentations made by the defendants to unrelated parties is relevant.
I am also satisfied that the search requested would create a significant burden and with a relatively low likelihood of providing relevant information. [ 151 ] In
summary, the
preamble, and clauses (
b) and (
c) of the plaintiff’s proposed order will not be included. The motion reflected by the plaintiff’s wording in clause (
a) will be granted. Category 8 [ 152 ] The plaintiff seeks: (viii) All documents evidencing any participation by State Street, pension plans or funds for employees of State Street, or clients of State Street’s internal advisory group, in an “extension strategy” or “edge strategy” investment. Said documents shall include, but not be limited to any documents evidencing: (
a) the date(
s) of any such investment, (
b) the amount(
s) of any such investment,
(
c) the amount(
s) and date(
s) of any withdrawal(
s) from any such investment, (
d) the identity of the prime broker(
s) used for any such investment, (
e) whether the prime broker(
s) used for any such investment was involved in a tri-party agreement, (
f) whether custody of the assets was given to the Prime Broker(
s) for any such investment, and the extent to which custody of the assets was transferred, (
g) any change in the Prime Broker(
s) for any such investment, and any documents evidencing the reason(
s) for any such change, (
h) any contractual and financial arrangement(
s) made with the Prime Broker(
s) for any such investment, (
i) the country in which assets for any such investment were held by a Prime Broker(s), (
j) any communications concerning counter party risk or the financial health of prime brokers, whether such communications were internal to State Street, made between State Street and its employees’ pension plan representatives, or made between State Street and clients of State Street’s internal advisory group. [ 153 ] The plaintiff alleges that the defendants failed to act in the best interests of the Committee, and placed its own interests ahead of those of the Committee by “... removing the Halifax Assets from the Alpha Trust Fund” and “... in continuing to leave custody of and title to the Halifax Assets with LBIE”. See, para. 50(ix) and (
x) of the Claim. [ 154 ] The defendants plead that it acted in good faith at all times material to the claim. See, para 7 of the Defence. [ 155 ] This request intends to access information which the plaintiff says is relevant to both these claims and the defence. The plaintiff adds that this information is relevant whether it proves or disproves matters at issue in the action. [ 156 ] The facts upon which this motion is based are set out in the materials.
In the early part of 2010, State Street entered into a Settlement Agreement with the Massachusetts Attorney General and the Massachusetts Securities Division of the Office of the Secretary of State: ... to resolve their investigations into losses incurred by, and disclosures made with respect to, certain active fixed income strategies managed by ... SSGA ... during 2007, and earlier periods. ... [ 157 ] It appears that SSGA adopted a no contest position and paid out approximately $663 million in compensation, fines and disgorgement of fees and interest. Their activity was described in an
article reporting on the settlement as an allegation that it “misled investors about the risks of its Limited Duration Bond Fund: State Street was alleged to have “...favored certain investors, including clients of State Street’s internal advisory groups with fuller information about the fund’s exposure to subprime mortgages, allowing those clients - including State Street’s own pension funds... to get out early... Other investors... were given information that understated the fund’s exposure to risky subprime mortgages, as well as its use of derivatives and leverage ... [ 158 ] The defendants resist the motion arguing:
1. What the defendants did, or did not, do for other clients or its own pension fund is irrelevant, particularly since no complaint is made about the extension fund strategies per se. The relevant standard of care is measured by the trust documents governing the plaintiff’s investment in the Alpha Fund, not by comparing with other investors. 2. That the information sought in relation to the “internal advisory groups” is similarly irrelevant in that the three groups encompassed by that descriptor serve external clients, as well as State Street.
Investment programs and strategies pursued on behalf of these various clients have unique characteristics which render a comparison valueless. Affidavit evidence indicates that no client of the internal advisory groups was invested in the Global Alpha Edge Fund although some were invested in extension strategies including those managed by SSGA. 3.
It would be unduly burdensome. [ 159 ] I am not satisfied that a causal link has been made that warrants the disclosure sought by the plaintiff. [ 160 ] Information upon which this request has been advanced supports the notion that the defendants have been investigated for and paid compensation to other clients, for giving preferential treatment to some clients over others, in particular in the extent to which it disclosed risks associated with sub prime mortgages. [ 161 ] I agree that if other clients of the internal advisory groups, including State Street pension funds, were invested in the Alpha Fund, then it would be relevant to understand whether the defendants demonstrated an awareness of the risk by giving preferential treatment to some of those clients over others.
It would at the very least demonstrate that the defendants were aware of the increased risk, and that steps were necessary for the clients to be protected against those risks. However, the sworn evidence of Rebecca Hayes is that “No client to the internal advisory groups was invested in the Global Alpha Edge Fund.” See , at para. 27. [ 162 ] Against this factual backdrop, the effect of the proposed order would require a search for and disclosure of information that, at this point, has not been shown to be relevant.
It relates to different clients, different investments, and possibly different time frames. [ 163 ] The plaintiff acknowledges that they cannot say that the information exists, or that it would support its position. I acknowledge that in some situations the lack of confirmatory information can be as
[…]
Loading document…