Wellmann v. Moss, 2011 NSSC 360
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Wellmann v. Moss, 2011 NSSC 360 Date: 20111005 Docket: SFHMCA075674 Registry: Halifax Between: Jarred Wellmann Applicant v. Ellie Moss Respondent LIBRARY HEADING Judge: The Honourable Justice Moira C. Legere Sers Heard: September 16, 2011 in Halifax, Nova Scotia
Summary: Primary parent restricting father's right of contact and overnight contact due to desire to continue nighttime breast feeding until child 2 years old. Father's
schedule requires 15 days off shore and 15 days on shore. Issue: Interim parenting, child support and
section 7 expenses. Result: Court ordered parenting strategy with overnights designed with specific goals for long-term resolution.
THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET. SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Wellmann v. Moss 2011 NSSC 360 Date: 20111005 Docket: SFHMCA075674 Registry: Halifax Between: Jarred Wellmann Applicant v. Ellie Moss Respondent Judge: The Honourable Justice Moira C.
Legere Sers Heard: September 16, 2011 in Halifax, Nova Scotia Counsel: Judith Schoen for the Applicant Jarred Wellmann Terrence Sheppard for the Respondent, Ellie Moss By the Court: [ 1 ] I have before me an application dated August 24, 2011 for interim child support and a corresponding application for interim relief by the father on May 30, 2011 for interim access and custody.
[ 2 ] An urgent motion for interim relief for access was received May 31, 2011. Notice was given to the respondent. The matter was booked for an interim motion on access only, with other issues deferred. An interim consent order was entered into on July 18, 2011. [ 3 ] The parties agreed as follows: The mother would have primary care and custody of their only child, Dresdon Acevedo Wellmann, born May 29, 2010. The father would have care and residence on a temporary
schedule every weekday from 7:45 am until 1:00 pm starting Monday, July 18, 2011 until and including Thursday, July 28, 2011 with the final interim parenting
schedule to be determined on September 16, 2011. The father was to pick up the child at the mother's home and return the child to daycare. Additional parenting time was to be agreed upon. The mother was given permission to travel to Quebec for a specific period of time. The parents agreed that no one having care of the child shall consume or be under the influence of alcohol or non-prescription drugs. Anyone transporting the child in a motor vehicle shall do so in a careful and prudent manner. The child was to remain on land and not be taken on boats, presumably pleasure craft.
The child was not be removed from the HRM any more than once per week and that the parent removing him should notify the other parent of the planned trip at least one day prior. The parties agreed that during the 15 day period when the father had parenting time, he was to contact the mother only regarding emergencies. He, however, was to respond to reasonable communication to the mother in relation to the child. While at sea the father was permitted to telephone once per day at a specific time to speak with the child and to be provided a brief update.
The father was to pay child support in the amount of $648 per month plus a percentage of daycare. The total child support payable was $1,140 each month consisting of $648 plus special or extraordinary expenses of $492. [ 4 ] Property issues were also dealt with on an interim basis. [ 5 ] The interim parenting
schedule was set down for a hearing before me. Child support adjustments are also in issue. This is the decision pertaining to those issues. Facts
[ 6 ] Both parties are 27 years old and both are employed. [ 7 ] The father's
schedule reflects 15 days on and 15 days off shore as a marine cook. The mother is a graphic designer. The parties met in high school and reconnected in June 2009. The child was born May 29, 2010. The parties separated April 2011. [ 8 ] This was a short-term relationship filled with conflict. Child Support &
Section 7 Expenses [ 9 ] The father's financial statement prepared on September 12, 2011 indicates a total annual income of $67,536 and an annual income for 2010 of $42,192.51. During the 2010 year he received workers ’ compensation for a period of time. In 2009 he earned $79, 340 and in 2008 $60,013. [ 10 ] The mother's financial statement prepared on August 23, 2011 reflects an annual income of $33,170.40. Her 2010 assessment shows total income of $12,444 affected by the maternity leave. Her 2009 line 150 shows income of $33,605.
Her 2008 assessment shows income of $47,534. [ 11 ] The child support shall be altered to reflect this change in income for the 2011 year effective immediately. According to their current incomes, the father is responsible to pay 67% of the after tax child care expenses. The mother shall provide the after tax calculations forthwith and shall keep him informed of the actual after tax cost of child care on an ongoing basis. [ 12 ] Those amendments to sections 11, 12 and 13 of their previous order shall occur immediately.
The remainder of the child support sections thereafter shall remain unchanged pending further agreement or court order. Parenting Issues [ 13 ] On May 27, 2011 the mother left without notice to the father. She provided him no information as to the whereabouts of her or her son. [ 14 ] She gave him a preliminary indication that she may let him contact the child for his first birthday.
She eventually refused the visit when the father refused to sign her proposal respecting his access schedule. [ 15 ] The child is now 16 months old. [ 16 ] The father commenced an emergency application to have his access restored resulting in an interim consent order. [ 17 ] On his return from sea in September the mother attempted to reduce the father ’ s his contact as of September 3, 2011 to two days per week while he was on shore from 7:45 am to 1:00 pm.
When he did not agree, the mother reduced his contact altogether. [ 18 ] During the course of the child's early life, the father was responsible for day-to-day care, particularly during the initial period of time when the mother returned home after a caesarean section.
[ 19 ] The evidence supports a finding that the father is able to deal with the basic day-to-day care of the child and in fact has done so for periods of time. [ 20 ] Each of the parents accuse the other of excessive drinking and use of soft drugs. Although 27 years old, these parents present as immature. Despite attending the parent information program, they have yet to fully focus on the best interests of their child to resolve the difficulties between them. [ 21 ] The evidence confirms that prior to the pregnancy, both mother and father used alcohol and soft drugs problematically.
The mother, it appears, ceased this activity on pregnancy.
She advises she uses alcohol occasionally now. [ 22 ] There is no indication that her current alcohol use interferes with her ability to provide a safe environment for the child. [ 23 ] The mother, however, uses the father's historical consumption to suggest he is unable to abstain from alcohol and marijuana sufficiently to address the safety issues inherent in parenting a young child. [ 24 ] The father has advised the court that he has ceased smoking marijuana completely and drinks moderately. [ 25 ] The father is prepared to consent to a prohibition against the use of alcohol or non-prescription drugs while caring for the child.
Both parties have consented to the inclusion of this prohibition in the original orders. [ 26 ] During the course of their relationship and subsequent to the separation, the conduct of the parties indicate a certain immaturity and lack of experience and life skills. [ 27 ] When not in a positive relationship with the father the mother has taken unilateral action and prohibits contact between the father and the child. [ 28 ] The father suggests the mother experienced depression and variability in moods.
The mother has admitted this in a letter to him during the course of their relationship. [ 29 ] The mother has also advised that when not drinking or under the influence of marijuana he is a good father. [ 30 ] Both parents have given evidence regarding the other's lack of good judgement. [ 31 ] The mother left her young child with someone she later learned was a drug dealer, in order to allow her a short time to apply for a job.
It was a brief lapse of judgment. [ 32 ] When frustrated by the mother's attempts to prohibit contact, the father acted unilaterally in removing the child from the daycare when he was unable to obtain the mother's agreement for parenting time. This is not to be repeated. [ 33 ] The parties text each other and the content of the texts are not always appropriate or civil. [ 34 ] The father has on occasion removed some of the child's clothing when returning the child to the mother because the parents have not been able to resolve the issue of the transfer of clothes back and forth to each other.
[ 35 ] While the mother reported to the RCMP on May 27, 2011 that she was afraid of the father; on June 10 and 11, she engaged in intimate relations with him and indeed invited him over to her apartment. [ 36 ] While not admitted by the mother in evidence, the father advises of the assistance he has given the mother on occasion, such as helping her look for an apartment. [ 37 ] The father has tendered uncontested evidence by a friend, a third party observer, that he is appropriate with the child and has been observed to be a good father, generous and a supportive individual. [ 38 ] As the difficulties between the parties escalated, they began to investigate the appropriateness of each other's household. [ 39 ] The parties do not appear to respect the rights of the other parent or the rights of the child to be significantly connected to his parents. [ 40 ] The mother indicates that she wishes to breast feed until the child is two years old and therefore is not prepared to grant overnight access.
While breast feeding is not the sole source of nutrition for the baby, indeed not the principal source of the child's nutrition, the mother maintains an evening feeding for comfort and bonding between the child and herself. [ 41 ] There is no doubt that due to the father's employment situation, he will not always be present in order to be primary caretaker of the child.
Conclusion [ 42 ] I continue the interim consent order which grants the primary residence of the child to the mother with parenting time to the father. [ 43 ] The parties will have joint custody of this child and will continue to be jointly responsible for making major decisions together, consulting one another on all major issues. [ 44 ] The decision-making on a day-to-day basis will remain with the parent who has the care of the child at that particular time. [ 45 ] The mother will have the right to make decisions regarding the child's medical care on a day-to-day basis while the father is at sea.
Major issues other than urgent issues shall be made after consultation and consensus.
In the event the consensus cannot be reached, the parties shall seek a second opinion from an appropriate professional depending on the issue to be resolved. [ 46 ] Both parents shall be entitled to information and consultation with third-party service providers including medical, health professionals and educators. [ 47 ] The parties have agreed on a daycare centre and the child will not be removed from the daycare centre by either parent to be placed in another daycare centre until the parties consult and agree. [ 48 ] The child will not be unilaterally removed from the daycare except according to the court-ordered
schedule of parenting time. [ 49 ] The parties have agreed that no one having care of the child shall consume or be under the influence of alcohol and
non-prescription drugs. [ 50 ] Anyone transporting the child in a motor vehicle shall do so in a careful and prudent manner. [ 51 ] With respect to taking the child at his age on a pleasure craft, the parties agree that this shall not be done without consultation and consensus between them. [ 52 ] If either parent wishes to take a vacation outside Halifax Regional Municipality, the parties shall obtain consensus, which consensus will not be unreasonably withheld. The child shall not be removed for more than one week unless the parties consent.
The party removing the child shall ensure that the other parent has the full particulars about the planned trip, including the date of departure, the date of return and a manner in which the telephone contact can be continued during the child's time away. [ 53 ] The father has provided the Court with a three-month schedule. He is at sea for the balance of the month of September. [ 54 ] His new
schedule at sea has him away on September 21, 2011; returning October 6, 2011; remaining on land until Friday, October 21, 2011, departing again on October 21, 2011 until his return on November 5, 2011. Generally he is at work for a 15-day period followed by a 15-day period at home. [ 55 ] The
schedule will be as set out below. The
schedule is intended to minimize the daily transitions for the child between care givers. - To gradually reintroduce the father after each 15-day period at sea in such a way as to increase his contact and the child's comfort level with his return. - It is intended to minimize the transitions between the parents on daytime access to reduce the transitions by eliminating the return to the daycare and increasing the more normal transition between parents. - It is also to provide times when the child continues to be at the daycare and continue to be familiar with the care givers there as well as the other children. - It is to maximize the father's contact and to have that contact occur during the mother's natural work hours. - It is to introduce overnights once a week (twice during the 15-day period) at a time when it would allow the mother to continue with her comfort feeding at night and to allow the father to have an overnight into the next day when he is able to focus solely on his child. - It also reduces his contact on the day before he leaves but allows the child to have sufficient contact to ensure that when he returns after 15 days, he minimizes the possibility of the child's strangeness to him, given the age and stage of the memory development of the child. [ 56 ] The parties should understand that given the current
schedule they maintain, this is a temporary
schedule which will require adjusting as the age and stage of the child develops and as their schedules change. It is important to understand that barring difficulties, the father will be looking and likely receive more extensive parenting times. [ 57 ] The parties are encouraged to recognize that the focus of the courts will be to maximize the child's time with the parents, to stabilize the child, to remove the child from any conflict and to consider and favor among many factors the parent who exhibits maturity and a desire to facilitate appropriate, safe, healthy and peaceful parenting time with the other parent.
[ 58 ] The parties are encouraged to be flexible with one another to watch their child's adjustment and minimize any conflict between them. [ 59 ] They are to communicate via email at a very minimum to report generally (and not necessarily in minute detail) on the child's health, needs and to report on how well the day went and any milestones reached. [ 60 ] The father is encouraged to contact the mother during his transition to address any questions that he has regarding the child's care and to communicate regarding any health issues. [ 61 ] Otherwise, the parents need not continue to harass each other by phone calls when the child is in the other's home.
The use of the telephone is to be reasonable and appropriate given the circumstances. [ 62 ] The parents will make every reasonable attempt to have the child attend one doctor for continuity of care where possible.
Schedule [ 63 ] The parties will keep each other advised of their
schedule and the mother will advise the father when she returns from her ordinary work hours so that the child may be returned to her home. I crafted this
schedule presuming her work day ends at or around 4 or 4:30 pm. [ 64 ] In October the father returns on Thursday, October 6 th . Given he may need the first part day to settle himself, he shall pick up the child at the mother's home at 7:45 am on the 7 th and return the child to the daycare at 1:00 pm. This is solely to recognize that he has been away for a period of time and needs to transition the child back.
In future this may not be necessary. [ 65 ] On Saturday, October 8 th , he will pick the child up again at 7:45 am and return to the mother ’ s residence at 1:00 pm. [ 66 ] On Sunday, October 9 th , he will pick up the child at 7:00 pm at the mother's home, allowing the mother an opportunity to that time to complete her evening comfort nursing prior to this time and return the child to the mother after work on Monday, October 10 th .
This will give the mother some Sunday time with her child as well. [ 67 ] The child will be at the daycare on Tuesday, October 11 th if the mother is working. [ 68 ] The father will pick up the child on Wednesday, October 12 th at 7:45 am and return the child to the mother after work on this date. [ 69 ] The father will pick up the child on Friday, October 14 th at 7:45 am and return the child to the mother after work on this date. [ 70 ] On Sunday, October 16 th , the father will have the child overnight from 7:00 pm and return the child to the mother after work on October 17 th . [ 71 ] On Wednesday, October 19 th , the father will have the child from 7:45 am and return the child to the mother after work on this
date. [ 72 ] In November, the father returns from sea on Saturday, November 5 th and he will recommence his parenting time on Sunday, November 6 th at 7:45 am until 1:00 pm, returning the child to the mother ’ s home. [ 73 ] On Monday, November 7 th , the father will have parenting time from 7:45 am, returning the child to daycare at 1:00 pm. [ 74 ] The father will have parenting time on Tuesday, November 8 th from 7:45 pm until Wednesday, November 9 th , when he will return the child to her work or other agreed upon place. [ 75 ] On Friday, November 11 th , the father shall pick up the child at 7:45 am, returning the child to daycare at 1:00 pm. [ 76 ] On Sunday, November 13 th , the father shall pick up the child at 7:00 pm, returning the child to the mother on Monday, November 14 th after work on this date. [ 77 ] On Wednesday, November 16 th , the father shall pick the child up at 7:45 am and return the child to the mother after work. [ 78 ] On Friday, November 18 th , he shall pick up the child at 7:45 am and return the child to the mother after work. [ 79 ] On Saturday, November 19 th , the day before he returns to sea, he shall have a half-day parenting time with his child, leaving on Sunday, November 20 th . [ 80 ] Due to the changing schedule, it is difficult to place the two overnights on a Sunday night. [ 81 ] However, as the parents become adjusted to this schedule, they can transfer this
schedule with adjustments as agreed upon between them into December and forward. [ 82 ] The matter should come back to court in January for a half-hour review prior to which the court should receive a brief letter from the parties identifying any issues, any consents reached between them and a report on whether there is a need to have the court intervene to continue this schedule. [ 83 ] The December
schedule of the father has not been provided to me. The parties are encouraged to set the matter down for a brief period of time (an hour) in December in the event they are not able to agree on parenting contact for both parents during the Christmas holiday. [ 84 ] Counsel for the father shall draft the order. Legere Sers, J.
Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday October 2011 1 2 3 4 5 6 Father returns 7 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to daycare at 1 pm 8 Father picks up child at 7:45am; returns child to mother at 1 pm 9 Father picks up child at 7:00 pm for an overnight visit 10 Father returns child to mother after work 11 12 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother after work 13 14 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother after work 15 16 Father picks up child at 7:00 pm for an overnight visit 17 Father returns child to mother after work 18 19 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother after work 20 21 Father leaves 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday November 2011 1 2 3 4 5 Father returns 6 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother at 1 pm 7 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to daycare at 1 pm 8 Father picks up child at 7:45 pm for an overnight visit 9 Father returns child to mother after work 10 11 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to daycare at 1 pm 12
13 Father picks up child at 7:00 pm for an overnight visit 14 Father returns child to mother after work 15 16 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother after work 17 18 Father picks up child at 7:45 am; returns child to mother after work 19 Father shall have ½ day parenting time with child 20 Father leaves 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday December 2011 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Loading document…