R. v. Hutchinson, 2011 NSSC 361
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Hutchinson, 2011 NSSC 361 Date: 20110928 Docket: CRH 328502 Registry: Halifax Between: Her Majesty The Queen versus Craig Jaret Hutchinson LIBRARY HEADING Judge : The Honourable Justice C. Richard Coughlan Heard: July 4 and August 29, 2011, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Decision: September 28, 2011 (Orally) Written Release of Decision: November 16, 2011 Subject: Criminal Law - Aggravated Sexual Assault
Summary: Mr. Hutchinson and N.C. were involved in an intimate personal relationship. Ms. C. consented to sexual intercourse with Mr. Hutchinson. The consent was for sexual intercourse with contraception (condoms) except during her menstrual
period each month and after September 5, 2006. Mr. Hutchinson poked holes in the condoms and engaged in sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using the damaged condoms. Ms. C. became pregnant and eventually had an abortion. Issue: Did Mr. Hutchinson commit aggravated sexual assault on Ms. C.? Result: Ms. C. consented to sexual intercourse with Mr. Hutchinson using contraception except for periods she consented to unprotected sexual intercourse. Ms. C. did not consent to sexual intercourse with damaged condoms. In having sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using damaged condoms Mr. Hutchinson committed a sexual assault.
It was not established that Ms. C. became pregnant during sexual intercourse with damaged condoms. It was not shown Mr. Hutchinson’s actions endangered Ms. C.’s life. Mr. Hutchinson is not guilty of aggravated sexual assault, but guilty of sexual assault. THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET . SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Hutchinson, 2011 NSSC 361 Date: 20110928 Docket: CRH 328502 Registry: Halifax Between: Her Majesty the Queen versus Craig Jaret Hutchinson
Editorial Notice Telephone numbers have been removed and replaced with asterisks in this electronic version of the decision. Restriction on publication: Restriction on publication of any information that could identify the complainant, pursuant to s. 486.4(1) of the Criminal Code Judge: The Honourable Justice C.
Richard Coughlan Heard: July 4 and August 29, 2011, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Decision: September 28, 2011 (Orally) Written Release of Decision: November 16, 2011 Counsel: Kimberley McOnie, for the Crown Patrick MacEwen, for the Defence Coughlan, J. : (Orally) [ 1 ] Craig Jaret Hutchinson is charged that, in committing a sexual assault on N.C., he endangered her life, thereby committing an aggravated sexual assault. [ 2 ] N.C. and Craig Hutchinson were involved in an intimate personal relationship from January, 2006 to October or November, 2006. Ms. C. testified she and Mr.
Hutchinson had sexual relations three to four times a week. They used condoms during sexual intercourse as birth control to prevent pregnancy. They did not use condoms during her menstrual period as it was her understanding she could not become pregnant while she was menstruating. They always used condoms during the time she could become pregnant. She would put the condoms on Mr. Hutchinson which he enjoyed. [ 3 ] During the summer of 2006, Mr. Hutchinson began putting the condoms on himself and told Ms. C. not to look. She thought that odd. At that time, Ms. C. told Mr.
Hutchinson she needed a break - she was not happy in the relationship. [ 4 ] Mr. Hutchinson was checking her phone calls and text messages. Ms. C. spoke of her unhappiness. Mr. Hutchinson wanted to work their problems out. In July, 2006, a condom being used by them in sexual intercourse broke. Around August 5, Ms. C. had a menstrual period. The broken condom did not cause a pregnancy. [ 5 ] During late August, 2006, Mr. Hutchinson was insistent Ms. C. should have a pregnancy test. She took a home pregnancy
[ 5 ] During late August, 2006, Mr. Hutchinson was insistent Ms. C. should have a pregnancy test. She took a home pregnancy test on September 5, 2006, which was positive. She remembered the date as her menstrual period was supposed to start on September 5th. Ms. C. had taken a home pregnancy test about a week earlier, which was negative. [ 6 ] Ms. C. thought it was odd as they always used condoms. It did not make sense. Mr. Hutchinson was very happy with the positive test. [ 7 ] Ms. C. thought they would deal with the situation, try to work out their relationship. They planned to have the baby. [ 8 ] Ms.
C. asked Mr. Hutchinson to give her a break so she could decide if they would stay together. Mr. Hutchinson would not leave her alone, texting her. [ 9 ] Ms. C. ended the relationship the first of November, 2006. Mr. Hutchinson was at her home in Timberlea, Nova Scotia. Ms. C. told him she was not happy - the relationship had to end. Mr. Hutchinson was upset. He passed out in the driveway. [ 10 ] Mr. Hutchinson continued to text messages to Ms. C. a lot. He also called her on her telephone. Ms. C. asked Mr. Hutchinson to stop texting her. She read the messages from Mr.
Hutchinson for awhile and then for about a week she did not read his messages. Mr. Hutchinson called her and asked if she was checking his messages. Ms. C. recognized Mr. Hutchinson’s voice on the phone and when she checked the messages Mr. Hutchinson’s name and telephone number were displayed on her telephone. Ms. C. read the text messages, which stated: The Anger I Was Wrong. I Wanted A Baby With U So Bad I Sabotaged The Condoms So Now They R Not Safe. Sory & Craig * (1/2) They Wil B Mailed. Sory 4 The Anger I Was Wrong.
I Wanted A Baby With U So 11/05 Craig * (2/2) W 1 Fri I Took Clothes Poked Holes In them Al. I Don’t Want U 2 Get A STD. I Steped On U Phone Charger I think I Broke It. I Owe U A Ne Craig *(1/2) Throw U Condoms Away I Poked Holes In Them Al. I Don’t Want U 2 Get A * 2 Protect U I Need to Tel U Something I Did 2 Months Ago. I 1 Cal & Is Al It Wil Take. pls 11/05 2:22 P Craig * 2 Protect U I Need to Tel U Something I Did 2 Months Ago. I 11/05 Craig * (2/2) Now I Wil Leave U Alone. [Telephone Number Deleted] [ 11 ] After reading the messages Ms. C. checked the condoms and they all had holes poked in them. Ms.
C. thought she gave the box of condoms to Constable Tracy Chambers.
[ 12 ] Ms. C. was in shock. Poking holes in condoms was the last thing she thought somebody would do. She would not consent to sex with condoms with holes in them. [ 13 ] Ms. C. had a number of appointments with her family doctor, Dr. Rowicka. [ 14 ] She decided to have an abortion, which took place on November 16, 2006. For the two week period after the abortion, she had extreme pain, lots of severe pain in her abdomen, had blood clots and she missed work. She was three to four days off work at the time she had the abortion. Ms. C. took Ibuprofen. She did not recall if she took antibiotics. [ 15 ] Ms.
C. was aware condoms were not a hundred percent guarantee against pregnancy. She knew condoms could break, slip or leak. [ 16 ] As the relationship went downhill, Mr. Hutchinson and Ms. C. had sexual intercourse less frequently. [ 17 ] After the positive pregnancy test of September 5, 2006, Ms. C. and Mr. Hutchinson did not use birth control. [ 18 ] Ms. C. consented to sexual intercourse with Mr. Hutchinson. [ 19 ] Dr.
Margaret Rowicka was qualified as a duly qualified general medical practitioner, licensed to practice medicine in Nova Scotia, and qualified to give opinion evidence on the diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of human beings and, in particular, uncomplicated pregnancies in women. [ 20 ] She was Ms. C.’s physician in 2006. Ms. C. saw Dr. Rowicka’s colleague on October 17, 2006 and was sent for blood work to confirm her pregnancy. On October 24, 2006, Dr. Rowicka examined Ms. C., who was about seven weeks pregnant. Dr. Rowicka next saw Ms. C. on November 3, 2006. Ms.
C. told her she had broken up with her partner one week earlier. She was considering terminating her pregnancy. Dr. Rowicka referred Ms. C. for counselling and scheduled an ultrasound to date the pregnancy. Dr. Rowicka next saw Ms. C. after the abortion, on November 23, 2006. Ms. C. had bleeding and sharp cramps. Dr. Rowicka treated Ms. C. with antibiotics and told her to take Ibuprofen. She diagnosed Ms. C. as having suffered endometriosis, which is an infection of the lining of the uterus, which is treated with oral antibiotics. On November 27, 2006, Dr. Rowicka saw Ms.
C., who was better - the pain was resolving. Ms. C.’s cervical opening was still open, which concerned Dr. Rowicka, as some of the tissue from the abortion could still be in her uterus. Dr. Rowicka again saw Ms. C. on December 1, 2006. Ms. C. was still bleeding and was experiencing sharp pains. Dr. Rowicka was concerned as Ms. C. was still bleeding more than expected. She sent Ms. C. for an ultrasound on an urgent basis to determine if part of the pregnancy was still in Ms. C. On December 8, 2006, Dr. Rowicka saw Ms. C. who was still bleeding - things were settling down. Dr. Rowicka stated Ms.
C. suffered complications from the termination of the pregnancy. [ 21 ] Dr. Rowicka testified there is a low risk of death in giving birth. Dr. Rowicka did not know if it is possible for a woman to get pregnant during her menstrual period. The pregnancy had no complications for Ms. C. After the abortion, from November 16 to December 8, 2006, Ms. C. suffered from pain and bleeding. The bleeding worked itself out.
Most pregnancies go full term without complications - there is a very low risk of death. [ 22 ] The doctor who performed the abortion was qualified as a duly qualified medical practitioner licensed to practice medicine in Nova Scotia and qualified to give opinion evidence on the diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of human beings, particularly in the areas of pregnancy and its termination. [ 23 ] The doctor performed the abortion procedure on Ms. C. on November 16, 2006. At the time, Ms. C. was nine weeks pregnant. The doctor determined the gestation by means of an ultrasound and her examination of Ms. C.
[ 24 ] The doctor who performed the abortion testified abortion is largely a safe surgical procedure. Complications are uncommon. Possible complications include excessive bleeding, injury to the uterus and cervix, infection, blood clots, infertility and very rarely death. The most common complication is PAS (post abortion syndrome), which includes blood clots, severe cramping and pain, and which occurs in one in 100 cases. Death and allergic reaction occur in just a fraction of cases. [ 25 ] Ms.
C. received counselling from a social worker. [ 26 ] The doctor who performed the abortion testified it is possible for a woman to become pregnant during her menstrual period. [ 27 ] The doctor advises people on birth control. If used properly, condoms are an effective birth control method. They are eighty to eighty-five percent effective. A condom would not be effective birth control if there was a pin prick in it. There needs to be a barrier to be effective.
There is still a possibility of pregnancy with the use of condoms. [ 28 ] Constable Tracy Chambers is a member of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, who was stationed at the Tantallon, Nova Scotia detachment in 2006. On November 30, 2006 she attended at Ms. C.’s residence. Constable Chambers viewed text messages on Ms. C.’s cell phone and photographed the messages, which photographs were entered into evidence and were the same messages of which Ms. C. testified.
Constable Chambers obtained a production order which showed the phone from which the messages were sent was owned by Craig Hutchinson when the messages were sent. During the same visit, Constable Chambers seized the box of condoms which were entered into evidence and identified by Ms. C. [ 29 ] I find Craig Jared Hutchinson and N.C. were in an intimate personal relationship from January, 2006 to the end of October, 2006. During most of that period, they engaged in sexual intercourse three to four times a week. Ms. C. consented to sexual intercourse with Mr. Hutchinson. Until Ms.
C. had the positive result from the home pregnancy test on September 5, 2006, the consent was for sexual intercourse with contraception (condoms) except during her menstrual period each month. During her menstrual periods and after the positive result from the September 5, 2006 home pregnancy test, the consent was for unprotected sexual intercourse. Mr. Hutchinson knew Ms. C. did not want to become pregnant. Ms. C. used contraception (condoms) at times she believed she was at risk of becoming pregnant. Ms. C. did not consent to unprotected sexual intercourse with damaged condoms. [ 30 ] Mr.
Hutchinson is charged with sexual assault on Ms. C. which endangered her life, thereby committing an aggravated sexual assault. The relevant sections of the Criminal Code are ss. 265 , 273.1 and 273(1) : 265.
(1) Assault - A person commits an assault when (
a) without the consent of another person, he applies force intentionally to that other person, directly or indirectly; . . . .
(2) Application - This
section applies to all forms of assault, including sexual assault, sexual assault with a weapon, threats to a third party or causing bodily harm and aggravated sexual assault.
(3) Consent - For the purposes of this section, no consent is obtained where the complainant submits, or does not resist by reason of (
a) the application of force to the complainant or to a person other than the complainant;
(
b) threats or fear of the application of force to the complainant or to a person other than the complainant; (
c) fraud; or (
d) the exercise of authority. . . . . 273.
(1) Aggravated sexual assault - Every one commits an aggravated sexual assault who, in committing a sexual assault,wounds, maims, disfigures or endangers the life of the complainant. 273.l
(1) Meaning of “consent” - Subject to subsection (2) and subsection 265(3), “consent” means, for the purposes of sections271, 272 and 273, the voluntary agreement of the complainant to engage in the sexual activity in question. [31] In describing the components of sexual assault, Major, J., in giving the majority judgment in R. v. Ewanchuk, (SCC), [1999] 1 S.C.R. 330, stated at paras. 23, 25 and 26: A conviction for sexual assault requires proof beyond reasonable doubt of two basic elements, that the accused committed the actus reusand that he had the necessary mens rea.
The actus reus of assault is unwanted sexual touching. The mens reas is the intention to touch,knowing of, or being reckless of or wilfully blind to, a lack of consent, either by words or actions, from the person being touched. . . . . The actus reas of sexual assault is established by the proof of three elements: (
i) touching, (ii) the sexual nature of the contact, and (iii)the absence of consent. The first two of these elements are objective. It is sufficient for the Crown to prove that the accused’s actionswere voluntary. The sexual nature of the assault is determined objectively; the Crown need not prove that the accused had any mens reawith respect to the sexual nature of his or her behaviour: see R. v.
Litchfield, (SCC), [1993] 4 S.C.R. 333, and R. v.Chase, (SCC), [1987] 2 S.C.R. 293 The absence of consent, however, is subjective and determined by reference to the complainant’s subjective internal state of mindtowards the touching, at the time it occurred: see R. v. Jensen (1996), (ON CA), 106 C.C.C. (3d) 430 (Ont. C.A.), atpp. 437-38, aff’d (SCC), [1997] 1 S.C.R. 304, R. v. Park, (SCC), [1995] 2 S.C.R. 836, at p. 850, perL’Heureux-Dubé J., and D. Stuart, Canadian Criminal Law (3rd ed. 1995), at p. 513. [32] In this case, Mr. Hutchinson applied force to Ms. C., he had sexual intercourse with her.
The contact was sexual in nature -sexual intercourse. [33] Did Ms. C. consent to the “sexual activity in question”? [34] In giving the majority judgment in R. v. J.A., 2011 SCC 28, McLachlin, C.J. stated, “The definition of consent for sexualassault requires the complainant to provide actual active consent throughout every phase of the sexual activity.” [35] Until Ms. C. had the positive result from the home pregnancy test on September 5, 2006, the consent was for sexualintercourse with contraception (condoms) except during her menstrual period each month.
During her menstrual periods and after thepositive result from the September 5, 2006 home pregnancy test, the consent was for unprotected sexual intercourse. Ms. C. did not
consent to unprotected sexual intercourse with damaged condoms. Ms. C. used contraception (condoms) at times she believed she was at risk of becoming pregnant. [ 36 ] Did Mr. Hutchinson have sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using condoms he had sabotaged, and has it been proved beyond a reasonable doubt? [ 37 ] I find Mr. Hutchinson sabotaged condoms and engaged in sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using the damaged condoms. [ 38 ] When Mr. Hutchinson and Ms. C. had sexual intercourse they used condoms during times Ms. C. thought she could become pregnant. Ms. C. put the condoms on Mr. Hutchinson, which he enjoyed.
That changed in the summer of 2006. Mr. Hutchinson began putting the condoms on himself and told Ms. C. not to look. [ 39 ] Although they were using condoms during intercourse, during late August, 2006, Mr. Hutchinson was insistent Ms. C. take a home pregnancy test. Ms. C. took a test which had a negative result. Mr. Hutchinson wanted Ms. C. to take another test, which she took on September 5, 2006. The result was positive. Mr. Hutchinson was happy with the result. [ 40 ] Ms. C. received a telephone call from Mr. Hutchinson - she recognized his voice and Mr.
Hutchinson’s name and telephone number were displayed on her telephone. [ 41 ] Mr. Hutchinson told Ms. C. there was something really important he had to tell her. Mr. Hutchinson told her he poked holes in all the condoms and he was sorry but he wanted a baby with her so bad, and he wanted Ms. C. to throw the condoms out as they were not safe any more. [ 42 ] Ms. C. read the text messages in which admissions were made that the condoms were sabotaged by poking holes in them as Mr. Hutchinson wanted a baby with Ms. C. [ 43 ] From all the evidence, I find Mr.
Hutchinson sabotaged the condoms by poking hole in them, and then had sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using the damaged condoms. [ 44 ] There was no voluntary agreement of Ms. C. to the sexual activity in question, which was sexual intercourse without contraception. [ 45 ] Therefore, the actus reus of sexual assault has been established. [ 46 ] In dealing with the elements of the mens rea of sexual assault, Major, J. stated in R. v. Ewanchuk , supra, at para. 42 : ...
As such, the mens rea of sexual assault contains two elements: intention to touch and knowing of, or being reckless of or wilfully blind to, a lack of consent on the part of the person touched. See Park , supra, at para. 39 . [ 47 ] Here Mr. Hutchinson intended to engage in sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using damaged condoms and he knew Ms. C. did not consent to sexual intercourse without contraception. [ 48 ] Both the actus reus and mens rea of sexual assault have been established.
[ 49 ] Did Mr. Hutchinson having sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using damaged condoms result in Ms. C. becoming pregnant? [ 50 ] Ms. C. had a positive result from the home pregnancy test she took on September 5, 2006. After that date, she engaged in consensual unprotected sexual intercourse with Mr. Hutchinson. On October 24, 2006, Dr. Rowicka examined Ms. C. and testified she was about seven weeks pregnant - which would place conception around September 5, 2006. Ms. C. had the abortion on November 16, 2006.
The doctor who performed the abortion testified at the date of the abortion, gestation was exactly nine weeks. The following evidence was given by the doctor on cross-examination: Q. ... you had indicated that at the time the abortion was performed Ms. C. was nine weeks pregnant? A. Yes. Q. And that was determined by use of an ultrasound? A. Yes. Q. Now, from your experience is that ... the use of the ultrasound, is that a more accurate method of determining gestation than subtracting three days ... or three months from the first day of the last period and adding seven days? A.
Yes, the ultrasound is more accurate. Q. Okay, so nine weeks would be ... would be a fairly good ... a fairly good idea of ... of the gestation in this particular case? A. I think in fact nine weeks would be the exact gestation. And the reason I say that is that after the procedure, I examined the pregnancy tissue and so I could tell that it was exactly nine weeks. [ 51 ] The evidence is an ultrasound is more accurate in determining gestation than a doctor’s opinion without the test. Nine weeks prior to November 16 is September 14. Dr. Rowicka testified home pregnancy tests are not a hundred percent accurate.
There can be false negative or false positive results. It may be that Ms. C. became pregnant during consensual unprotected sexual intercourse between September 5, 2006 and September 14, 2006, or during consensual unprotected sexual intercourse during her menstrual period. The doctor who performed the abortion testified it is possible for a woman to become pregnant during her menstrual period. [ 52 ] Mr.
Hutchinson is charged with aggravated sexual assault. [ 53 ] In dealing with a charge of aggravated assault, Binnie, J., in giving the Court’s judgment in R. v Williams , 2003 SCC 41 , stated at paras. 41 , 43, 45, 47 and 49: The requirements of an aggravated assault include those of the assault itself plus, as mentioned, certain listed consequences: 268.
(1) Every one commits an aggravated assault who wounds, maims, disfigures or endangers the life of the complainant. The prosecution must establish all of the elements of an assault plus the aggravating circumstance.
. . . . In Godin, supra, Cory J. stated, at p. 485, “[t]he
section pertains to an assault that has the consequences of wounding, maiming ordisfiguring” (emphasis added) or (to complete the list) endangering life. “Endanger” means to “[p]ut in danger ... put in peril ... [i]ncurthe risk”: New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary on Historical Principles (1993), vol. 1, at p. 816. As to the focus on consequences,see generally R. v. Brodie (1995), (BC CA), 60 B.C.A.C. 153, at para. 4; R. v. Dewey (1999), 1999 ABCA 5, 132 C.C.C. (3d) 348 (Alta. C.A.), at para. 9; and R. v. Ross, [1998] O.J. No. 3427 (QL) (Gen. Div.), at para. 23.
See also R. v.Vang (1999), (ON CA), 132 C.C.C. (3d) 32 (Ont. C.A.), at para. 12. . . . . The “aggravation” in aggravated assault thus comes from the consequences. In DeSousa itself, the Court held, at pp. 966-67, perSopinka, J.: No principle of fundamental justice prevents Parliament from treating crimes with certain consequences as more serious than crimeswhich lack those consequences. . . . . The same act of assault may injure one person but not another.
The implicit rationale of the law in this area is that it is acceptable todistinguish between criminal responsibility for equally reprehensible acts on the basis of the harm that is actually caused. ... [Emphasisadded.] . . . . I therefore agree with the majority of the Court of Appeal of Newfoundland and Labrador that proof of endangerment of thecomplainant’s life was an essential element of the prosecution’s case for aggravated assault. . . . . The trial judge erred, with respect, in switching the focus from the consequences of the assault to the nature of the assault (“by its natureit endangers”).
There are several provisions of the Criminal Code that differentiate charges on the basis of the nature of the assault, e.g.,s. 271 (sexual assault), but s. 268 (aggravated assault) is not one of them. Under that section, the court is directed by Parliament to focuson the consequences. [54] In this case did Mr. Hutchinson endanger Ms. C.’s life? As previously stated, it has not been established beyond a reasonabledoubt that Mr. Hutchinson’s actions - having sexual intercourse with Ms. C. using condoms he had sabotaged caused her pregnancy. However, as Cory, J. stated in R. v.
Cuerrier, (SCC), [1998] 2 S.C.R. 371 at para. 95: The respondent was charged with two counts of aggravated assault. This charge requires the Crown to prove first that the accused’s acts“endanger[ed] the life of the complainant” (s. 268(1)) and, second, that the accused intentionally applied force without the consent of thecomplainant (s. 265(1)(a)). Like the Court of Appeal and the trial judge I agree that the first requirement was satisfied. There can be nodoubt the respondent endangered the lives of the complainants by exposing them to the risk of HIV infection through unprotected sexualintercourse.
The potentially lethal consequences of infection permit no other conclusion. Further, it is not necessary to establish that thecomplainants were in fact infected with the virus. There is no prerequisite that any harm must actually have resulted. This firstrequirement of s. 268(1) is satisfied by the significant risk to the lives of the complainants occasioned by the act of unprotectedintercourse.
[ 55 ] Did Mr. Hutchinson’s actions cause significant risk to Ms. C.’s life? [ 56 ] Dr. Rowicka testified there is very low risk of death resulting from pregnancy. It does not happen very often. The doctor who performed the abortion, in dealing with a release a person undergoing an abortion signs, testified concerning the complications which could result from an abortion: Q. Now the release which is now before the Court, do you have a copy of that release ... A. Yes. Q. ... in front of you there? A. Yes. Q.
The release actually says that ... about middle of the page in the second numbered paragraph, it lists possible complications and consequences. And the second sentence says “very ... very rarely these complications could require further surgery and/or lead to infertility”. A. Yes. Q. “Allergic reaction, post abortion syndrome and death.” Okay, and the allergic reaction, PAS and death, is that your handwriting? A. Yes. Q. Okay, and you would agree that those also very rarely occur? A. Yes. Q. And in fact I would suspect that death is extremely rare? A. Yes. Well, if I could qualify.
PAS would be the most common complication of those three, and it happens approximately one in 100 abortions. But the other two reactions: allergic reaction and death, are very rare. Q. So, the ... the most common complications of those three happens about 1% of the time? A. Yes. Q. And obviously an allergic reaction and death would be far less than 1% of the time? A. Yes.
Q. Just be a fraction of a percent? A. Yes. [ 57 ] I do not have evidence before me as to how frequently pregnancy or abortion results in death of the mother. Considering the evidence, it has not been established Mr. Hutchinson’s actions exposed Ms. C. to a significant risk to her life. The Crown has not shown Mr. Hutchinson’s actions endangered Ms. C.’s life. [ 58 ] I find Mr. Hutchinson not guilty of aggravated sexual assault, but guilty of sexual assault. ______________________________ Coughlan, J.
Loading document…