Dooley v. Dooley, 2020 NSSC 109
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Dooley v. Dooley , 2020 NSSC 109 Date: 2020 - 03 - 23 Docket: 1201-66395; SFH-82243 Registry: Halifax Between: George Dooley Petitioner v. Bernice Dooley Respondent LIBRARY HEADING Judge: The Honourable Justice Elizabeth Jollimore Heard: November 21 – 22, 2019 Submissions: December 5, 2019 by Karen Killawee December 20, 2019 by M. Louise Campbell, Q.C.
Summary: Former husband applied to reduce spousal support and arrears and to impose a termination date on spousal support. No reduction of ongoing payments where no material change proven. Former husband’s evidence that past change in his income was not of his making was rejected. No evidentiary or legal basis to impose a termination date. Application dismissed. Key words: Family, Variation, Material change in circumstances, Termination, Spousal support, Arrears, Legislation: Divorce Act , R.S.C. 1985 (2 nd Supp.), c. 3, subsection 17(4.1) THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOESN’T FORM PART OF THE COURT’S DECISION.
QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET . SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Dooley v. Dooley , 2020 NSSC 109
Date: 2020 - 03 - 23 Docket: 1201-66395; SFH-82243 Registry: Halifax Between: George Dooley Petitioner v. Bernice Dooley Respondent Judge: The Honourable Justice Elizabeth Jollimore Heard : November 21 – 22, 2019 Submissions: December 5, 2019 by Karen Killawee December 20, 2019 by M. Louise Campbell, Q.C. Counsel: M. Louise Campbell, Q.C. for George Dooley Karen Killawee for Bernice Dooley By the Court: Introduction [ 1 ] George Dooley wants to vary his obligation to pay spousal support. Specifically, he asks to reduce his ongoing payments, reduce arrears, and have a termination date imposed.
His variation application is under subsection 17(4.1) of the Divorce Act , R.S.C. 1985 (2 nd Supp.), c. 3. [ 2 ] Mr. Dooley must prove there has been a change in his condition, means, needs or other circumstances or those of his former wife, Bernice Dooley, before I may vary the Corollary Relief Order: Divorce Act , R.S.C. 1985 (2 nd Supp), c. 3, subsection 17(4.1). The change “must have some degree of continuity, and not merely be a temporary set of circumstances”: LMP v.
LS , 2011 SCC 64 at paragraph 35 . [ 3 ] I’m to consider the parties’ circumstances when the Corollary Relief Order was granted in deciding whether a change is material: RP v. RC , 2011 SCC 65 at paragraph 25 . If a circumstance existed when the Corollary Relief Order was granted, that circumstance can’t be a material change. If the circumstance didn’t exist, but the parties actually contemplated it, the circumstance isn’t a material change: Dedes v. Dedes , 2015 BCCA 194 at paragraph 25 .
[ 4 ] If a change is proven, I am to consider the change in making the variation order. Has there been a material change in circumstances? [ 5 ] Mr. Dooley claims there have been 4 changes in his circumstances since the Corollary Relief Order was granted in May 2014: • the Canada Revenue Agency re-assessed him for income taxes of $295,000 • he retired • he has separated from his second wife, Laurie Dooley • he has financial obligations for the 3 children of his second marriage • [ 6 ] I’ll address the CRA re-assessment and retirement individually, and the claims relating to his second family together.
CRA re-assessment [ 7 ] In 2017, the CRA re-assessed Mr. Dooley for income taxes of $295,000. Mr. Dooley had additional debts of almost $60,000 and there was a mortgage of $375,000 on the matrimonial home he shared with Laurie Dooley. He said that as a result of his financial position, he declared bankruptcy on May 1, 2017. [ 8 ] According to his bankruptcy documents, Mr. Dooley was entitled to an automatic discharge on January 29, 2018, unless his discharge was opposed. When cross-examined, Mr. Dooley claimed he didn’t know when he would be discharged.
He said he owed his trustee some money and wouldn’t be discharged until that was paid. He didn’t say how much he owed, when he expected to repay it or why he hadn’t repaid it. [ 9 ] According to his bankruptcy documents, Mr. Dooley was to pay his trustee $180 each month. In his Statement of Expenses, he claimed he was paying $500 monthly which suggests Mr. Dooley will be discharged quickly. [ 10 ] While Mr. Dooley is undischarged, his trustee owns his interest in the matrimonial home (and his RRSPs) and these are beyond Bernice Dooley’s reach as a creditor. [ 11 ] Once Mr.
Dooley’s discharged, he has no further obligation to pay the debts that formed his bankruptcy. So, the $295,000 re- assessment doesn’t hinder his ability to pay spousal support. In fact, the bankruptcy ultimately improves his ability to pay spousal support by relieving him from the requirement to pay the re-assessment and other debts. [ 12 ] The monthly budget Mr. Dooley is allowed by his trustee included spousal support payments but only at the rate of $315, rather than the $5,000 he is required to pay. It isn’t clear whether Mr.
Dooley told his trustee the correct amount. [ 13 ] The bankruptcy does not eliminate Mr. Dooley’s spousal support arrears. [ 14 ] Mr. Dooley’s bankruptcy is a temporary circumstance which ultimately improves his ability to pay spousal support. The CRA re- assessment is not a material change in circumstances.
Retirement [ 15 ] In their agreement, the parties agreed that Mr. Dooley’s retirement would be a change in circumstances. Mr. Dooley says he’s retired. Bernice Dooley disagrees. [ 16 ] Mr. Dooley opened Dooley’s Pharmacy in 1984. He owned 40% of the pharmacy and he kept this when he and Bernice Dooley divorced. [ 17 ] Mr. Dooley began receiving Canada Pension Plan payments in mid-2015. [ 18 ] Mr. Dooley sold his interest in Dooley’s Pharmacy in September 2015. He received $455,000.00 from the sale. Mr.
Dooley says he kept none of this money for his retirement. [ 19 ] George Dooley kept the matrimonial home where he and Bernice Dooley had lived after their divorce in May 2014. Following the divorce, he renovated the home, including replacing windows, flooring and the roof. After selling his share in the pharmacy business in September 2015, he tore down the renovated home and used the business sale proceeds to build two new homes on the land: one home where Mr. Dooley, Laurie Dooley and their children lived, and a second home where Laurie Dooley’s parents live. [ 20 ] Mr.
Dooley said his “intention was to continue working at Dooley’s Pharmacy as a pharmacist for a couple of years following the sale, until [he] retired completely.” [ 21 ] After he sold the pharmacy in September 2015, Mr. Dooley was kept on as a pharmacist with no guaranteed hours. [ 22 ] In his August 2016 affidavit, Mr. Dooley swore that he hadn’t worked at Dooley’s Pharmacy since May 2016. However, in his November 2019 affidavit, he swore that he continued to work there on a part-time basis in 2017. He also worked at other pharmacies in Nova Scotia before moving to Nunavut in September 2017. [ 23 ] Mr.
Dooley hasn’t identified any period when he was not working. He hasn’t identified any period – ever – when he hasn’t been registered as a licensed pharmacist. [ 24 ] In addition to using all the proceeds from the sale of his business to build two homes while saving none for his retirement, Mr. Dooley has voluntarily assumed additional financial responsibilities: • In January 2016, at age 62, he adopted Laurie Dooley’s 3 youngest children. The twins were then 10 years old and the older son was 16. None of these children has completed high school. • Mr.
Dooley provides housing for Laurie Dooley’s parents and her brother. He does this whether or not they pay any money for their accommodation. • [ 25 ] Mr. Dooley hasn’t retired. He lacks the means to retire and has taken on financial responsibilities that are incompatible with reducing his income. This is not a material change in circumstances. Mr. Dooley’s separation from Laurie Dooley Mr. Dooley’s financial obligations for the 3 children of his second marriage
[ 26 ] There must be a material change before I can vary an order. If there’s no change, the order is deemed to still be correct: R.P v. R.C. , 2011 SCC 65 at paragraph 25 . [ 27 ] Mr. Dooley’s evidence about his separation and his children is deficient. He didn’t provide evidence about the circumstances that existed or those that were actually contemplated when the Corollary Relief Order was granted, so I cannot determine whether his current circumstances are different. [ 28 ] Two months after George and Bernice Dooley divorced, George Dooley re-married.
Less than 19 months later, on January 10, 2016, George Dooley and Laurie Dooley separated. [ 29 ] If George and Laurie Dooley weren’t in a relationship in May 2014, the end of their relationship isn’t a change. It is a return to the situation that existed when the Corollary Relief Order was made. [ 30 ] Alternately, if George and Laurie Dooley were in a relationship in May 2014, I need to know the nature of their relationship. Were they living together?
Were they sharing income and expenses? [ 31 ] For example, if they weren’t living together and there was no sharing of income or expenses, the separation is not a change. It is a return to the situation that existed when the Corollary Relief Order was made. [ 32 ] Alternately, if they were living together and Laurie Dooley’s financial contribution to the couple’s expenses was essential to the amount of support Mr. Dooley agreed to pay Bernice Dooley, then the separation and the loss of her contribution could be relevant to the amount of support Mr.
Dooley can afford to pay. [ 33 ] Or, if they were living together in May 2014 and George Dooley was supporting Laurie Dooley, the end of their relationship may mean that George Dooley has fewer financial obligations and is better able to pay support. [ 34 ] George and Laurie Dooley signed a separation agreement in February 2017. Under their agreement, neither has any claim to spousal support. Each kept his or her own investments, savings, RRSP contributions, and car. They agreed they’d both continue to live in the matrimonial home and that either could, at any time, apply to court to divide the home. [ 35 ] Mr.
Dooley has testified both that Laurie Dooley has claimed support in her divorce petition and that she has not. He was asked to provide a copy of the petition and did not. [ 36 ] Mr. Dooley hasn’t proven that his separation from Laurie Dooley is a change in circumstances. I can’t conclude the separation has affected Mr. Dooley’s ability to pay spousal support because there’s no evidence they were in a relationship or, if they were, the nature of their relationship when the Corollary Relief Order was granted. [ 37 ] There are similar problems with Mr. Dooley’s evidence about his obligations to his sons.
I don’t know whether the boys were part of his household and being supported by him when the Corollary Relief Order was granted. Certainly, if they were, then the current obligation to support them (even if now formalized in adoption orders) isn’t a material change. [ 38 ] George Dooley adopted Laurie Dooley’s older son less than a week before the couple separated. The order for the twins’ adoption came 8 days after the separation. [ 39 ] The couple’s separation agreement contains no terms about parenting or child support. [ 40 ] Mr. Dooley’s tax returns don’t show any child support payments.
I assume this is because his payments are voluntary and not
made under an agreement or order. [ 41 ] Mr. Dooley swore his monthly child support payment is $2,729.81 on his November 2019 Statement of Expenses. Living in Nunavut, this amount of child support is required of a parent of three whose annual income is in the range of $137,000 to $138,000 under the Federal Child Support Guidelines . After paying this child support, Mr. Dooley would still have approximately $104,000 for his own needs and Bernice Dooley’s spousal support payments. [ 42 ] Mr. Dooley said that his entire net pay cheque is deposited into Laurie Dooley’s bank account.
He has no access to the money deposited into her account. From this account, she pays expenses to maintain the home. The mortgage and car payments are debited from her account. George Dooley is providing Laurie Dooley with far more money than required by the Federal Child Support Guidelines . [ 43 ] Mr. Dooley’s November 2019 Expense Statement shows a monthly deficit of $1,522.
This is wrong for 3 reasons: 1. he deducts a CPP contribution that is $71.73 more than the statutory maximum contribution 2. he deducts an EI contribution that is $26.63 more than the statutory maximum contribution 3. he has double-counted his medical insurance of $10 [ 44 ] Mr. Dooley claims his monthly income tax bill is $3,845. If he paid his spousal support, his monthly income taxes would be $477.
The tax saving alone provides $3,368 of his $5,000 monthly spousal support payment and leaves him to finance only $1,632. [ 45 ] Other expenses are questionable: he claims $100 for post-secondary education costs but none of his children have completed high school. He has a monthly expense of almost $1,000 for a car. While he is required to pay this debt under his separation agreement with Laurie Dooley, George Dooley has no driver’s license. He lives in Nunavut and the car is in Nova Scotia, used by his oldest son and Laurie Dooley’s daughter.
Laurie Dooley has a car of her own. [ 46 ] George Dooley is paying Laurie Dooley $300 each month for a debt: she paid his airfare from Rankin Inlet to Inuvik and he’s repaying her. However, his employer has already reimbursed him for this expense so it could have been repaid by now and wouldn’t be a long-term cost. [ 47 ] Deducting the expenses Mr. Dooley has overestimated (CPP, EI and medical insurance) and the questionable expenses means that Mr. Dooley can meet his spousal support obligation to Bernice Dooley. [ 48 ] I conclude that there has not been a material change in circumstances. Mr.
Dooley’s monthly spousal support payments of $5,000 will continue. Should arrears be reduced? [ 49 ] Mr. Dooley asks to reduce his spousal support arrears. I may reduce or cancel arrears depending on the answers to 2 questions: • Was there a material change in circumstances during the period of retroactivity? • Having regard to all other relevant circumstances during this period, would Mr. Dooley have been granted a reduction in his support obligation but for his untimely application?
[50] These questions originated in PMB v. MLB, 2010 NBCA 5 at paragraph 2. Our Court of Appeal has adopted this analysis inSmith v. Helppi, 2011 NSCA 65. [51] The New Brunswick Court of Appeal said that “[A]s a general proposition, the court will be asking whether the change wassignificant and long-lasting; whether it was real and not one of choice”: PMB v. MLB, 2010 NBCA 5 at paragraph 2; Smith v. Helppi,2011 NSCA 65 at paragraph 21. [52] Bernice Dooley says that any changes to Mr. Dooley’s circumstances are ones he chose: selling his business and moving tonorthern Canada to work. [53] Mr.
Dooley bears the burden of proving that the change was real. This puts Mr. Dooley’s credibility squarely in issue. I findthat he is not credible, and I reject his evidence that the change is real. [54] There were inconsistencies in Mr. Dooley’s evidence, both over time and between documents. • in his September 2016 affidavit, Mr. Dooley swore that he only worked at Dooley’s Pharmacy since separation. This was untrue. He provided a pay record showing he had worked at Saulnierville Pharmacy during this time • Mr.
Dooley did not claim the income he earned from at least one of his other employers on his 2016 or 2017 tax returns • Mr. Dooley’s 2016 tax return showed total taxable income of $77,534. His income was being deposited into Laurie Dooley’sbank account. The amount deposited in her bank account in 2016 exceeded Mr. Dooley’s total taxable income by more than $100,000. There was no explanation where all this other money originated • the Minutes of Settlement incorporated into the Corollary Relief Order stated that Mr. Dooley’s current income was $162,690. Inno year was Mr.
Dooley’s income the amount stated in the Minutes of Settlement • he claims an expense for travel to see his children in Nova Scotia but admitted that his employer paid this expense [55] I have elsewhere identified other inconsistencies in Mr. Dooley’s evidence: whether Laurie Dooley claimed spousal support inher divorce petition; his claim to his trustee that his spousal support obligation was $300 each month; his claim that he owes LaurieDooley for a debt that was repaid to him by his employer. [56] Mr.
Dooley has done (or not done) things to prevent MEP’s collection of spousal support: he’s failed to notify MEP aboutchanges to his employment and address and he’s deposited his entire net pay into a bank account solely in Laurie Dooley’s name. [57] Ms. Dooley questions whether Mr. Dooley’s separation from Laurie Dooley is bona fide. Mr. Dooley provides Laurie Dooleywith more money than she is entitled to, based on the Federal Child Support Guidelines and their separation agreement. Mr.
Dooleysays that he and Laurie Dooley have “a working relationship”, but he can’t obtain information from her about the matrimonial home’scosts (insurance, property taxes). [58] I don’t accept that Mr. Dooley’s trustee doesn’t have information about the cost of home insurance and property taxes or won’tprovide it. I don’t accept that Laurie Dooley won’t provide information about the home’s costs or any financial contributions her parentsor brother make to their accommodations.
These assertions aren’t in keeping with “the preponderance of probabilities which a practicaland informed person would find reasonable given the particular place and conditions”: Faryna v. Chorney (BC CA),[1952] 2 D.L.R. 354. [59] Because I reject his evidence, I dismiss Mr. Dooley’s request to reduce the arrears of spousal support. Should a termination date be imposed?
[ 60 ] Bernice and George Dooley were married for 34 years. When she married, Bernice Dooley largely withdrew from the workforce to support her husband as a homemaker and primary caregiver to their four children. One of their children, now in his 30s, is on the autism spectrum and is still somewhat dependent on Ms. Dooley. Mr. Dooley doesn’t contribute to his support. [ 61 ] Since the divorce Bernice Dooley, who is now 65, has taken some courses financed by an inheritance from her late father, worked part-time and made some applications for work. She has also worked as a volunteer.
At her age and with her limited and dated employment history, there is little prospect of employment that would make her self-sufficient. [ 62 ] Mr. Dooley made no reference to any evidence or law to support the request for a termination date in his post-hearing submissions. There is no evidence to support a termination of her spousal support and I dismiss this request. [ 63 ] After the divorce, Bernice Dooley’s father died. In his will, he gave certain financial assets to her and her sister – excluding their other siblings from this gift.
Bernice Dooley’s equal share of these assets was worth $59,647 (approximately $15,700 of this was subject to capital gains tax). Ms. Dooley’s tax returns don’t show the taxes she paid on the shares she received. [ 64 ] Ms. Dooley and her sister believed their father hadn’t been competent when he made his will, so they directed the executors to divide this gift with their siblings and the children of their deceased siblings. In doing so, each woman gave up over $44,700, and received only $14,911 – again, the amounts are pre-tax. Mr.
Dooley points to this decision, arguing that she should have considered it more carefully. [ 65 ] I find Ms. Dooley’s decision to share the bequest from their father was a reasonable one where they believed their father wasn’t competent when he made his will. Sharing the bequest saved the expense of litigation. Conclusion [ 66 ] I dismiss Mr. Dooley’s application to reduce his ongoing support payments, reduce arrears, and have a termination date imposed. [ 67 ] Mr.
Dooley didn’t ask to be relieved of his obligation to secure Bernice Dooley’s spousal support by maintaining her as beneficiary of a $300,000 life insurance policy (Great-West Life policy 24****04). He is still obliged to maintain this policy and to provide annual confirmation to Bernice Dooley that the policy is current. If he does not maintain the policy, his ongoing spousal support obligation is a claim against his estate. [ 68 ] An order dismissing Mr. Dooley’s variation application is attached. ______________________________ Elizabeth Jollimore, J.S.C.(F.D.) Halifax, Nova Scotia
Loading document…