McNeil/Maidment v. Forbes, 2020 NSSC 16
Opinion
Supreme Court of Nova Scotia Citation: McNeil/Maidment v. Forbes, 2020 NSSC 16 Date: 2020-01-15 Docket: Sydney No. 489251/491353 Registry: Sydney Between: Linda McNeil as attorney for Richard D. Maidment (also known as Richard McNeil) Applicant v. Emeline Forbes as Trustee for Devon McNeil Respondent Library Heading Judge: The Honourable Justice Frank C. EdwardsHeard: January 7, 2020 in Sydney, Nova ScotiaSubject: - Life Insurance policy, beneficiary designation - Effect of a finding of not criminally responsible upon beneficiaries right to receive insuranceproceeds.
Facts: In 2017, Richard Maidment (aka McNeil) was found not criminally responsible after he had caused hiswife’s (Sarabeth Forbes’) death. In 2015, the wife had named Richard Maidment as the primarybeneficiary in her life insurance policy. She also named her infant son Devon as the contingentbeneficiary. Richard’s mother as attorney for her son applies for an order declaring Richard as therightful beneficiary.
Emeline Forbes (Sarabeth’s mother) applies on Devon’s behalf for the insuranceproceeds.Issues: Who is the lawful beneficiary of Sarabeth Forbes’ Life Insurance Policy?Result: Richard Maidment is the rightful beneficiary. A finding of not criminally responsible in Sarabeth’sdeath does not disqualify Richard from receiving the life insurance proceeds. Cases Noticed: Winko v British Columbia (Forensic Psychiatric Institute), (SCC), [1999] 2 SCR625, 175 DLR (4th) 193 Jollimore Estate v.
Nova Scotia (Public Archives), 2011 NSSC 218 Dhingra v Dhingra, 2012 ONCA 261 Nordstrom v Baumann, ( (SCC), 1962] SCR 147, 31 DLR (2d) 255 THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THEDECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET. SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia Citation: McNeil/Maidment v Forbes, 2020 NSSC 16 Date: 2020-01-15 Docket: Sydney, No. 489251/491353 Registry: Sydney
Between: Linda McNeil as attorney for Richard D. Maidment (also known as Richard McNeil) Applicant v. Emeline Forbes as Trustee for Devon McNeil Respondent Judge: The Honourable Justice Frank C. Edwards Heard: January 7, 2020, in Sydney, Nova Scotia Counsel: A. Robert Sampson, Q.C., for the Applicant Emeline Forbes, self-represented, Respondent [ 1 ] The Applicant is seeking an Order to declare Richard D.
Maidment (McNeil) the rightful beneficiary of one hundred percent of life insurance proceeds which were paid into Court by Co-operators Life Insurance Company pursuant to an Order of the Honourable Justice Patrick J. Murray, dated May 16, 2019, in relation to the life of Sarabeth Forbes. Further, the Applicant seeks an Order that the proceeds of the life insurance policy be paid to Richard D.
Maidment (McNeil). [ 2 ] The Applicant also asks this Court to dismiss the application filed by Emeline Forbes as Trustee for Devon McNeil, seeking an Order declaring Emeline Forbes as Trustee for Devon McNeil the rightful beneficiary of one hundred percent of the life insurance proceeds. [ 3 ] I am granting the Application in favor of Richard Maidment (McNeil). Accordingly, I adopt in their entirety the facts, law, and submissions as set out in Counsel’s brief.
With minor editing and some additional commentary, the brief reads as follows: Background [ 4 ] Richard Dwayne Maidment (“Richard”) was born on January 30, 1977. At the time of his birth, Richard's parents, Linda Maidment (“Linda”) and George McNeil were not married. Linda chose to give her son her surname, Maidment. After Richard’s birth, Linda and George (his natural father) were married. Both Linda and Richard assumed the surname McNeil. Although Richard assumed the last name McNeil upon his parents' marriage, no application was ever made seeking to legally change Richard's surname from Maidment to McNeil.
For most of his life, Richard has primarily used the name Richard Dwayne McNeil. Both his birth certificate and driver's licence, however, bear his legal name, Richard Dwayne Maidment. [ 5 ] Sarabeth Forbes ("Sarabeth") and Richard had been in a common law relationship for over ten years before Ms. Forbes' tragic death on April 18, 2017. Together, Sarabeth and Richard had one child, Devon Richard McNeil ("Devon"), on November 9, 2007. In 2008, Richard began working for Nova Scotia Power as a welder. In 2009, Richard and Sarabeth purchased a home in Gardiner Mines together.
Richard was diagnosed with schizophrenia in 2012, which rendered him unable to continue working for Nova Scotia Power. Shortly thereafter, Richard began receiving long term disability benefits. Life Insurance [ 6 ] On July 29, 2015, Sarabeth applied for a life insurance policy through Cooperators Life. Sarabeth named Richard, using his legal name, Richard D. Maidment, and identifying him as her boyfriend, as the primary beneficiary on this policy.
Sarabeth then named Devon, as her contingent beneficiary, with her mother Emeline Forbes as trustee for Devon in the event Devon received any benefits before reaching the age of twenty-five. The policy defines Contingent Beneficiary as “…the person who becomes the beneficiary if all primary beneficiaries predecease the Life Insured or are otherwise disqualified from receiving the death benefit.” (Emphasis added) Sarabeth's Death
[ 7 ] Around the Easter weekend of 2017, Richard's mental health began rapidly deteriorating. Due to Richard’s deteriorating condition, on April 17, 2017, which was Easter Monday, Sarabeth and Devon slept over at Linda and her common law partner David MacNeil's ("David") home. At the time, Linda, David and Sarabeth unsuccessfully sought medical help for Richard. On the morning of April 18, 2017, Sarabeth returned to the home she and Richard shared in Gardiner Mines. It was at that time that Richard killed Sarabeth. Richard was arrested and charged with Sarabeth's murder.
On December 4, 2017, Richard was found not criminally responsible, on account of mental disorder, for Sarabeth's death. Payment of Funds into Court [ 8 ] Richard was then confined to the East Coast Forensic Hospital. Linda and David took responsibility for maintaining the home where Sarabeth, Richard and Devon had resided. Through checking the mail which continued to be delivered to the home, Linda discovered the existence of Sarabeth's life insurance policy held with Co-operators Life. Linda claimed the funds on Richard’s behalf, by way of Richard's power of attorney.
Emeline Forbes also claimed entitlement to the funds as trustee for Devon. Co-operators Life admitted liability for the insurance money under the policy. Because of the two competing claims, Co-operators paid the funds into Court on May 16, 2019. Issue [ 9 ] Who is the rightful beneficiary of Sarabeth’s Life Insurance policy? LAW & ARGUMENT Beneficiary Designation [ 10 ] When Sarabeth applied for a life insurance policy through Co-operators Life on July 29, 2015, she listed Richard D. Maidment (Boyfriend) as her primary beneficiary, and Emeline R. Forbes as trustee for Devon R.
McNeil (Son) as her contingent beneficiary. [ 11 ] Life insurance contracts in Nova Scotia are governed by the Insurance Act, RSNS 1989, c 231 . Subsection 192(1) of the Insurance Act , supra provides, with respect to life insurance, that an insured may designate a beneficiary through the insurance contract, or by declaration: Designation of beneficiary 192
(1) An insured may, in a contract or by a declaration, designate himself, his personal representative or a beneficiary to receive insurance money.
(2) Subject to
Section 193, the insured may alter or revoke the designation by a declaration.
(3) A designation in favour of "heirs", "next of kin", or "estate", or the use of words of like import in a designation, shall be deemed to be a designation of a personal representative. [ 12 ] In this case, Sarabeth designated her beneficiary through the life insurance contract at the time the policy was purchased. [ 13 ] Richard during his life has consistently used two names, both his legal name, Richard Maidment, and the name he informally assumed upon his parents' marriage, Richard McNeil.
Significant evidence has been filed proving that Richard uses both names, and that both the names Richard McNeil and Richard Maidment refer to Richard. From the evidence, it is clear that both names were known to Sarabeth, as the couple gave their son the last name McNeil, and Sarabeth held property together with Richard under the name Richard McNeil. Sarabeth named Richard as the beneficiary of her life insurance policy using the name Richard D. Maidment. Richard's identity has been clearly established.
The fact that Richard has used a name other than the one appearing on his birth certificate for much of his life does not preclude him from benefitting under a life insurance policy where he has been designated by his legal name. Inapplicability of Public Policy Rule [ 14 ] There is a public policy rule which says criminals should not be permitted to benefit from their crimes. That public policy rule has no application to this case. Richard has been found to be not criminally responsible.
He is not a criminal. [ 15 ] Following the criminal trial arising from Sarabeth's death, I remarked that it "would be obvious to anybody who has listened to
the evidence, and the testimony of the doctors, and the submissions of Counsel, that the not criminally responsible defence has beenmade out". The Crown had agreed Richard should be found not criminally responsible. On December 4, 2018, I found Richard notcriminally responsible for Sarabeth's death, on account of mental disorder, in accordance with subsection 16(1) of the Criminal Code,RSC, 1985, c C-46. Subsection 16(1) of the Criminal Code, supra, provides as follows: No person is criminally responsible for
an act committed while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable ofappreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong. [16] The Supreme Court of Canada considered subsection 16(1) of the Criminal Code, supra, in its decision, Winko v BritishColumbia (Forensic Psychiatric Institute), (SCC), [1999] 2 SCR 625, 175 DLR (4th) 193.
In Winko, supra, JusticeMcLachlin, as she then was, confirmed that a finding of not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder is not a verdict of guilt,and that a person so found is not morally responsible for his or her act.
Justice McLachlin further affirmed in Winko, supra, that aperson found not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder is "not to be punished" as "Parliament has signalled that the NCRaccused is to be treated with the utmost dignity and afforded the utmost liberty compatible with his or her situation". [17] The public policy rule was acknowledged by Justice Coughlan in Jollimore Estate v. Nova Scotia (Public Archives), 2011NSSC 218.
In Jollimore Estate, supra, Justice Coughlan confirmed the existence of an exception to the public policy rule, whereby aperson who has killed another, but is found to be of unsound mind, will not be disqualified from benefitting from the deceased person'sestate: [10] There is an exception to the general rule. If it can be established the person who killed another is of unsound mind, the person isnot disqualified from taking a benefit from the estate of the person he or she killed. The onus is on the person claiming on behalf of theperson who killed the other. (In re Pollock: Pollock v.
Pollock, [1941] 1 Ch. 219) [18] In Dhingra v Dhingra, 2012 ONCA 261, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that where a husband, who had been named as thebeneficiary of his wife's life insurance policy, was found not criminally responsible for his wife's death, there was no rationale fordisqualifying the husband from the benefit under the life insurance policy.
The Court reasoned that because the public policy rule isbased on the theory that people should not profit from their wrongs, and a person who is found "not criminally responsible on account ofmental disorder is not 'morally responsible' for his or her act", there is no rationale for applying the rule. [19] This is consistent with the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Nordstrom v Baumann, ( (SCC), 1962] SCR147, 31 DLR (2d) 255, where Justice Ritchie held that while the public policy rule precluding a person from benefiting from his or herown crime applies to intestacies, the rule has no application where the person was "insane" at the time of the killing. [20] In my decision finding Richard not criminally responsible for Sarabeth’s death, I described Sarabeth’s death as “an unspeakablyhorrendous and tragic event for everyone involved.” On April 18, 2017, both Sarabeth and Richard, as well as their families, tragicallyfell victim to Richard's schizophrenia.
Together, Sarabeth and Richard had been facing Richard's schizophrenia since his diagnosis in2012. While the particular circumstances leading to Sarabeth's death are fortunately uncommon, the inherent unpredictability, illness andloss are squarely what life insureds seek to guard their loved ones against by purchasing a life insurance policy. [21] There is absolutely no public policy argument in support of disqualifying Richard from benefitting under the life insurancepolicy Sarabeth purchased from Cooperators Life.
Conclusion [22] In 2015, Sarabeth designated Richard as the beneficiary of one hundred percent of her life insurance policy, and Emeline Forbesas Trustee for Devon, as the contingent beneficiary of one hundred percent of her life insurance policy, in the event that Richardpredeceased Sarabeth. Sarabeth did not revoke or change her beneficiary designation before her death in 2017. Since Richard survivedSarabeth, Richard is the rightful beneficiary of one hundred percent of Sarabeth's life insurance policy.
To paraphrase the insurancepolicy, a finding of not criminally responsible does not “disqualify” (Richard) from receiving the death benefit. [23] There is no lawful reason to disqualify Richard from benefitting under Sarabeth’s life insurance policy. I have carefullyconsidered the arguments put forward on Ms. Forbes’ behalf by her brother, Mr. Hugh Smith. The argument appears to be that Richardcannot make a claim as Richard Maidment after using the name Richard McNeil for much of his life. With respect, that argument is nottenable. In oral argument, Mr.
Smith conceded that Richard Maidment and Richard McNeil was the same person. [24] Mr. Smith also appeared to argue that there is a public policy reason that prevents Richard from claiming the insuranceproceeds. I have already accepted the reasons why that is not so. Richard, because of his mental illness, is not morally blameworthy forSarabeth’s death. If I had convicted Richard of murdering Sarabeth, he could not claim the life insurance proceeds. But I did not andcould not find him guilty of murder.
As noted above, it was obvious that Richard was not criminally responsible for Sarabeth’s death. (My full decision dated December 4, 2017 is attached as an appendix to this decision.) [25] I am therefore prepared to issue an Order; 1. Declaring Richard D. Maidment (also known as McNeil), the rightful beneficiary of one hundred percent of life insuranceproceeds which were paid into Court by Co-operators Life Insurance Company pursuant to an Order of the Honourable JusticePatrick J. Murray, dated May 16, 2019;
2. Directing that the life insurance proceeds which were paid into Court by Co-operators Life Insurance Company pursuant to an Order of the Honourable Justice Patrick J. Murray, dated May 16, 2019 (Syd. No.487376), be paid to Sampson McPhee in trust for Linda McNeil as attorney for Richard D.Maidment (also known as Richard McNeil); and 3. There will be no order for costs . Order accordingly, Justice Frank C. Edwards A screenshot of a cell phone Description automatically generated
A close up of a logo Description automatically generated
A screenshot of a cell phone Description automatically generated
A close up of a logo Description automatically generated
A close up of a logo Description automatically generated
Loading document…