R. v. Al-Rawi, 2020 NSSC 263
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia Citation: R. v. Al-Rawi , 2020 NSSC 263 Date: 2020 08 28 Docket: CRH 485671 Registry: Halifax Between: Her Majesty the Queen v. Bassam Aladin Al-Rawi DECISION Judge: The Honourable Justice Gerald R.P. Moir Heard: February 20, 21, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 2020, March 2, 2020 and August 24, 25, 26, 2020 in Halifax, Nova Scotia Oral Decision: August 28, 2020 Written Release: October 1, 2020 Counsel: Carla Ball, for the Crown Ian Hutchison, for the Defence Moir, J. (Orally): Introduction [ 1 ] Mr. Al-Rawi is charged with committing sexual assault on Ms.
ECB at Halifax on December 15, 2012. [ 2 ] The charge was laid in 2018. Mr. Al-Rawi elected trial by judge alone in this court, and he reported for his trial before me on eight days between February 20, 2020 and March 2, 2020. [ 3 ] The trial was adjourned to June 1, 2020 because the Crown adduced an opinion from its expert toxicologist that was not covered in the s.657.3 expert’s report. Mr. Al-Rawi required an opportunity to retain his own toxicologist. [ 4 ] Mr. Al-Rawi and his wife live in Germany. Travel restrictions in Germany and Canada imposed to protect against the COVID- 19 virus prevented Mr.
Al-Rawi from travelling here to resume his trial on June 1, 2020. (He had always been faithful to his terms for release.) So, trial was adjourned to resume on August 24, 2020. [ 5 ] Mr. Al-Rawi and his wife travelled to Nova Scotia and underwent COVID-19 phase two restrictions, so the trial was able to resume on August 24. I heard the toxicologist cross-examined. [ 6 ] Submissions were made on August 26 and I adjourned my decision until today. [ 7 ] I will discuss some general problems this case presents. Then, I will summarize the evidence and some of my findings. Then, I shall state my conclusions.
Problems with the Case for the Crown [ 8 ] There are problems that could, on their own, give rise to reasonable doubt. [ 9 ] The main witness for the Crown, the only witness to the crucial events, recalled some details vividly but said she could not recall others. For example, Ms. ECB could not say whether Mr. Al-Rawi was the man she was with on the night in question, and many details that would have helped on that subject were said to be beyond her memory.
[ 10 ] According to Ms. ECB, she and the man found themselves in his residence in an apartment building. We saw surveillance video of a parking garage. It is not clear, but it does show a woman and a man leaving a just-parked vehicle and walking across the parking lot floor to an exit. Ms. ECB identified herself as the woman in the video. However, she had no memory to draw on that would pinpoint the location or the identify of the man. [ 11 ] Ms. ECB could not give us the apartment number. Once inside, she recalls being asked to put her cellphone away, and smoking marijuana.
She does not otherwise have a good memory of what was discussed. Again, details that could help with identification are missing. [ 12 ] The problem with the Crown’s case about sparce evidence on the identity of the accused is compounded by another problem about delay. [ 13 ] There was a long delay between Ms. ECB making a complaint to the police and the laying of the charges. The offence allegedly occurred on December 15, 2012. She presented herself for examination by a sexual assault nurse examiner later that same day.
Three days later she was interviewed by the police, and she provided a video statement. [ 14 ] The police interviewed Mr. Al-Rawi on March 22, 2013. They advised Ms. ECB that they were not laying charges. [ 15 ] Four years later, Ms. ECB was listening to the CBC while driving to work. She learned that a taxi driver had been acquitted of sexual assault. The first name of the accused matched her record of the taxi driver’s name against whom she had complained.
She contacted the police again and she granted an interview to the CBC. [ 16 ] In cross, she was asked whether she contacted the police and the CBC out of anger. She said her contact with police was to discover whether her complaint was a related case. Also, she was frustrated and she felt guilty about the other woman’s case. [ 17 ] A few months later, the police told Ms. ECB that they were laying charges on her complaint after all. [ 18 ] When considering the testimony of Ms.
ECB, I must examine any distortion caused by the frustration or the guilt, over the many years between the events and the trial. [ 19 ] I must also bear in mind the potential for erosion of witnesses’ memories over the several years between the alleged incident and their testimony. Night on the Town [ 20 ] On the morning of Friday, December 14, 2012, Ms. ECB’s colleague and friend, Mr. AG, drove her and another colleague to Halifax where they were to attend a luncheon for professional accountants. They planned a night on the town with friends. Ms.
ECB’s brother had a condominium on Cornwallis at Barrington Street, and she had arranged to stay there. [ 21 ] Ms. ECB could not recall whether she had any alcohol at the lunch, but Mr. AG testified that she accompanied him to the bar for a drink before the meal began and that she had a glass of wine at her place during the meal. I accept his evidence on that point. [ 22 ] After lunch, the three colleagues drove to the home of a mutual friend, Mr. AL, who lived on Cornwallis Street not far from Ms. ECB’s brother. They changed into casual clothes and walked to a downtown bar. Mr.
AL joined them there. [ 23 ] The group ordered an eighty-ounce “brewtender” for their table. Ms. ECB says they drank two “brewtenders”. Mr. AG says there was only one. [ 24 ] Ms. ECB, Mr. AG, and Mr. AL moved from the tavern to a Korean restaurant in the downtown part of Barrington Street. They were joined by Mr. MWC. The group of four enjoyed a meal of meats and vegetables cooked tabletop. [ 25 ] Ms. ECB said she was happy to be with friends and, by this time, she was experiencing a “happy drunk”. She does not recall whether she had alcohol with the meal. Mr. AL drank a beer or two, and he said Ms.
ECB drank about the same. Mr. AG said all four had drinks. Mr. MWC could not be sure. [ 26 ] After about an hour at the Korean restaurant, the party rushed to the Metro Centre to arrive on time for a Mooseheads’ game. There they were joined by some others. During the game, Ms. ECB obtained at least two plastic tumblers of beer. It is possible she did not finish the second, or last, of these. She says she remembers gauging the effects of the day’s drinking, and telling herself to slow down. [ 27 ] Nevertheless, when the hockey game was over at nine o’clock or so, Ms.
ECB and friends headed for another downtown bar. They took a table and ordered pitchers of beer. Ms. ECB does not recall how many pitchers they went through. She said she was drunk then and “my memory starts to become fuzzy”. [ 28 ] Mr. MWC said they ordered several rounds of pitchers of beer, which were shared by all. The party consisted of himself, Mr. AL, Mr. AG, Ms. ECB, and one other person. In the end, he was a seven or eight on a scale of ten degrees of intoxication. Ms. ECB appeared to be an eight or nine. Her speech was slurred. She was having difficulty walking. [ 29 ] According to Mr.
AL, the members of the party drank about the same amount of beer. He said “we were getting very drunk”. That was based on his intoxication and the fact that the others drank about as much as he did. [ 30 ] Mr. AG said there were many pitchers of beer on the table. Everybody drank from them. He became very intoxicated. Everybody at the table was very intoxicated. [ 31 ] The party left the tavern after about four hours of drinking beer. Ms. ECB says she has no memory of leaving. After that gap,
she remembers being outside with Mr. MWC. She abandoned him, and set out for her brother’s place, but became disoriented and lost. [ 32 ] Mr. MWC explains that the two of them lagged behind the others. They left the tavern, which is at the corner of Duke and Granville, and travelled uphill to Prince. It was on Prince Street that Ms. ECB departed. He tried to get her to return towards the group but she gave no coherent response and moved away again, towards the Grand Parade. [ 33 ] Mr. AL recalled being well ahead of Mr. MWC and Ms. ECB on the way to a tavern on Brunswick and Prince. He walked with Mr.
AG and another. He did not see Ms. ECB until the next morning. [ 34 ] Mr. AG recalls being in line to enter the tavern. He had a view down Prince Street. He got a quick glimpse of Mr. MWC and Ms. ECB thirty to forty feet away. He next saw Ms. ECB at Mr. AL’s home the next morning. Taxi [ 35 ] Ms. ECB says she lost memory after she became disorientated. That would have been near the Grand Parade. She does not remember where she walked or how long it took. This gap in memory ends with her talking to a taxi driver. She does not know how the encounter came about. She cannot identify the driver.
She cannot recall what they discussed. [ 36 ] It appears the cab left and returned. Ms. ECB got in. She cannot say why, except it had something to do with whatever they discussed. She could not identify the driver, but from her memory inside the vehicle she said he was Middle Eastern, clean shaved, and had short hair. English was his second language, and he spoke it well. He appeared to be in his 30’s. [ 37 ] They arrived at the brother’s building. Ms. ECB and her brother had been in contact by telephone and text message frequently during the evening of December 14, 2012 and the early hours of December 15.
From the logs, we can approximate that Ms. ECB and the taxi driver were at the brother’s building after two o’clock in the morning. Her brother was not home. [ 38 ] According to Ms. ECB, the driver said he was not going to leave her out in the cold and invited her to join him in the taxi. After awhile, the driver put the taxi in drive. [ 39 ] Cross-examination made it clear that Ms. ECB was free to wait in the lobby of her brother’s building, but she chose to accept the driver’s invitation to be with him in his taxi. They were having a nice conversation. [ 40 ] The taxi drove a long distance. Ms.
ECB says she lost memory of this interval. However, her phone log has an entry at 2:21 for a phone connection to her brother’s that lasted six minutes and twelve seconds. [ 41 ] For Mr. Al-Rawi, it is submitted that her brother told her he was at home or going there and that Ms. ECB suppressed her memory of that to augment her evidence on consent. We cannot tell how much of the six minutes were spent in conversation. The log does show that she failed to take her brother’s calls immediately after the six-minute connection ended. [ 42 ] In early January 2019, Ms. ECB prepared a spreadsheet for the police.
In reference to the six-minute call, it said “Discussed when he is going to be back so I could get into his apartment”. At trial she testified that this was her assumption. As I said, Mr. Al-Rawi submits Ms. ECB deliberately suppressed what was actually discussed. [ 43 ] A text message sent by Ms. ECB’s brother to her just minutes after he failed to reach her by telephone tells us something about what was under discussion. It may also explain why the connection lasted for six minutes. It says, “2135 Brunswick St”. That is not the brother’s address. Identification [ 44 ] Ms.
ECB remembers being in an underground parking lot. We have surveillance video from such a parking lot, and we have surveillance video from an apartment building lobby. The imprints record times at about 2:30 in the morning of December 15, 2012. [ 45 ] The videos show two people. They are not clear. One is a man, the other is a woman. From his appearance when he gave a police statement and from his appearance in court, the man could be Mr. Al-Rawi, but he could as well be someone else. The woman could be Ms. ECB, or someone else. [ 46 ] Ms. ECB said that the person she was with had short hair. Mr.
Al-Rawi, when he appears in court, is bald. However, the video tape of him during his police interview shows that he did in fact sometimes wear his hair short. [ 47 ] Ms. ECB says the woman is her. This is not because she recalls the recorded events. She recognized her hairstyle, her purse, her jacket, her boots, and the style of heel on her boots. Also, her presence in a building of that kind is consistent with her recalled memories. [ 48 ] Two witnesses provided circumstantial evidence that could assist with identification. They are Mr. David Gordon Vieth, an apartment building manager, and Mr.
Ala Hadad, a retired taxi driver. [ 49 ] In 2012, Mr. Vieth managed apartment buildings on Bedros Lane with the assistance of his wife, Susan Vieth. One of the buildings was 40 Bedros. He and his wife had apartment 313, three flights up from the parking lot and the lobby. A gentleman he referred to as Abdul lived in 306. Mr. Vieth identified Mr. Al-Rawi in court as that tenant, although his first name is Bassam, not Abdul. [ 50 ] A lease starting January 1, 2010 shows Bassam Abdullatif and Ala Hadad as the tenants for an apartment at 22 Bedros.
At some time, “Abdullatif” was crossed off, “Al-Rawi” was written in, and the apartment was changed to 306 at 40 Bedros. A termination notice effective February 1, 2013 purports to be signed by Bassam Al-Rawi. [ 51 ] When he was interviewed by the police three months after the alleged assault, Mr. Al-Rawi acknowledged he had lived at apartment 306, 40 Bedros Lane.
[ 52 ] Landlord records show that two out-of-doors parking places were assigned to apartment 306. These records, and the renewal documents, referred to a “Bassam Abdullatif” and “Abdullatif, Bassam”. A cancellation notice for one of them is addressed to “Susan” and signed by “Bassam”. [ 53 ] Mr. Vieth testified that the tenant in 306, who he knew as Abdul, was given indoor parking stall number ten. There is no record of this. Mr. Vieth said that Abdul was given the indoor stall for free, and his wife only records parking spaces a tenant was paying for. [ 54 ] Mr. Vieth knew Abdul to be a taxi driver.
There were two other taxi drivers in the building and they did not resemble Abdul. Evidence shows that there were at least four tenants who were taxi drivers, if Mr. Vieth’s evidence about the other two is accepted. [ 55 ] Mr. Vieth was well familiar with Abdul’s cab. He was shown the surveillance videos. When one enters the garage, Mr. Vieth’s one-time stall is straight ahead. The parking lot is L-shaped. One has to turn left at the bend and number ten is immediately to the left of that. [ 56 ] The man known as Abdul had driven Mr. Vieth before. He recognized his taxi in the first surveillance video.
We see the vehicle being parked, the driver and the passenger getting out of it, and the two of them making their way towards the lobby door. Mr. Vieth claimed to recognize the man in the video as Abdul by his white sweater. [ 57 ] For Mr. Al-Rawi, it is submitted that I should approach Mr. Vieth’s testimony with caution. He had to look after many tenants in a transient industry. The records do not support parking stall #10 being Mr. Al-Rawi’s. There is nothing distinctive about a white jacket or sweater. The surveillance video does not depict colour, at least not well.
He was wrong about what country in the Middle East Mr. Al-Rawi came from. [ 58 ] I accept Mr. Vieth’s evidence about parking stall #10. I do not see his identification as being the same as in a police line up. It is influenced by the context: a taxi cab being parked in number 10 by a male driver like Mr. Al-Rawi, who looks similar to him when he gets out. [ 59 ] Mr. Hadad is a retired taxi driver. He moved from Iran to Canada thirty years ago and drove a cab in Halifax most of that time. He returns to the old country for visits of a month or so at least once a year.
It is likely he was in Iran in December, 2012. [ 60 ] At that time, he shared a two-bedroom apartment with Mr. Al-Rawi, apartment 306 at 40 Bedros Lane off Larry Uteck Drive near the intersection with the Bedford Highway. Mr. Hadad identified Mr. Al-Rawi when he testified. [ 61 ] Mr. Hadad was shown the surveillance videos. He saw that the taxi had roof light 062. He said that was his number. The number on the roof light in the video is fuzzy at times. It looks like 042 to me, but it could be 062 for someone who saw the roof light many times. Mr. Hadad lent the roof light to Mr.
Al-Rawi from time to time. [ 62 ] They had two parking places. One was outside. That was Mr. Hadad’s. The other was inside. Mr. Al-Rawi used it. Mr. Hadad said the taxi in the video parked in Mr. Hadad’s space. It looked like Mr. Hadad’s car. He saw bottles of oil at the end of Mr. Al-Rawi’s space. He said he used those for his vehicle. Mr. Hadad had seen bottles there many times. [ 63 ] When the driver got out of the taxi and walked towards the lobby door and when the video showed him in the lobby, Mr. Hadad identified the driver as Mr. Al-Rawi. In both instances, Mr. Hadad claimed he could identify Mr.
Al-Rawi by his height and his white jacket. [ 64 ] For Mr. Al-Rawi, it is submitted that Mr. Hadad’s testimony is problematic. Because of the roof light, he was initially a suspect and, therefore, his testimony comes with a bias. There are inconsistencies about how long he actually lived in apartment 306. His opportunities to observe Mr. Al-Rawi were also limited by the time he spent working and the time he spent with grandchildren. [ 65 ] Despite these and other concerns, I found Mr. Hadad to be a credible witness. Again, we are not dealing with identification similar to a police line up.
However, it proves that the man who got out of the taxi after parking it and walked to the lobby and the elevator looks similar to Mr. Al-Rawi. Also, I accept the evidence about parking stall #10. [ 66 ] Finally, we have Mr. Al-Rawi’s statement to the police. I have already commented on his appearance and his admission about apartment 306. [ 67 ] Ms. ECB provided the police with her photograph in portrait form. We have an original as an exhibit. In the video, the interrogator says to Mr. Al-Rawi “That’s the picture she sent.” And that appears to be truthful from the recording.
You can see the picture in the recording. [ 68 ] Mr. Al-Rawi said “I don’t know if I know her or not.” Then, “Her face is familiar for me. …Her face is familiar.” Later, “So, this girl…I know her face.” And later, “I do remember her face. …I do remember this person, but I can’t remember the situation.” [ 69 ] Mr. Al-Rawi remembered Ms. ECB’s face. The statement makes that obvious. At times I think he was just trying to get information from the interrogator when he says things that could be an admission of having sex.
However, he goes a step beyond admitting his recognition of her face when he says, “I remember this girl. …For one night and then disappeared. …In my knowledge, like in my eyes and in my mind, next day that’s it. Bye. Bye.” [ 70 ] It has been proved beyond reasonable doubt that Bassam Al-Rawi was the driver with Ms. ECB on the morning of December 15, 2012. Ms. ECB’s Evidence of Assault [ 71 ] She testified that the next memory she has after exiting the car in the parking garage is being alone in an apartment with the
driver. She believed he was going to take her back to her brother’s place, and she was not scared at that time. [ 72 ] Ms. ECB was sitting on a couch when the driver brought her a bag of marijuana. She said aloud that she was too drunk to roll a joint. He rolled one and lit it. She had a couple drags, so she said. This is denied by Mr. Al-Rawi in his police statement. [ 73 ] Ms. ECB recalls trying to reach her brother. She cannot recall what the driver said, but she does recall her feeling that he wanted her to put the phone away. She was becoming anxious. [ 74 ] Next, she found herself in the bedroom.
She has no recollection of moving there. She says she does recall realizing she was in a bad situation. Since the driver had smoked dope, he was not likely to be driving her back to her brother’s place. [ 75 ] Ms. ECB did agree in cross-examination that she had been capable of calling a taxi, and paying for one, after she concluded that the driver was not going to take her back to her brother’s place. She did not know why she failed to take that course. Once she became anxious, she could have called 911. She did not.
And nothing prevented her from exiting the apartment that she can recall. [ 76 ] The Crown raised objections to some of this line of cross-examination. The objections would have been sustained if the evidence was for establishing lack of consent or mistaken belief in consent: R. v. Ewanchuck, 1999 SCC 711, particularly paras. 23 to 25; and R. v. Barton, 2019 SCC 33 , particularly para. 90 and 98. [ 77 ] First, a smaller point. Then a larger one. Ms. ECB testified to the effect that she was concerned an attempt to exit the apartment might provoke a confrontation.
The objected questions explore the credibility of that testimony. [ 78 ] As I said in the beginning, this case presents a challenge because the most important evidence for the Crown is said to have been drawn from a memory severely compromised by alcohol. Whatever can be proved to help with that challenge is admissible. It may help with the assessment of Ms. ECB’s level of intoxication and the reliability of memories she says she does recall. [ 79 ] Ms. ECB says she was drunk, she did not know where she was, and her phone was close to dead.
She did not want to be in a bedroom, but she felt she could not “effectively” escape. [ 80 ] Ms. ECB says that, in her distressed state, she made a plan. She laid on the bed. She kept her eyes closed and went motionless, pretending to have passed out. [ 81 ] The driver approached her. He slapped her face lightly. He said “I know you’re there.” And “Stop doing this.” He undressed her. She did not cooperate. She kept her eyes closed. [ 82 ] Ms. ECB says that the driver had intercourse with her. She did not cooperate. He seemed to position himself for anal penetration. She blocked him and spoke for the first time.
Later he attempted to obtain oral sex, but Ms. ECB did not cooperate. [ 83 ] Ms. ECB does not remember how the assault ended. She recalls going to the washroom and vomiting. She says she was extremely drunk. She was nauseous and a bit dizzy. [ 84 ] Ms. ECB says she returned to the bed. She explains that she did not think she had any option. She did not know how to get out of the situation. Next Morning [ 85 ] Ms. ECB says she woke at ten o’clock. She vomited again, quickly dressed, gathered her belongings, and left the apartment. Her phone was dead.
She says she was very hung over and she also felt scared. [ 86 ] Ms. ECB recalls finding an exit light and descending three flights of stairs to a door leading outside. She left the building, but did not recognize where she was. [ 87 ] She saw several apartment buildings. A long driveway or a street led to a city street. Ms. ECB walked downhill on the city street to another, where she entered a retail establishment. The manager called a cab for her. [ 88 ] Ms. ECB’s description of the buildings and city streets is consistent with Mr. Vieth’s evidence and Mr.
Hadad’s evidence about 40 Bedros Lane, the apartment buildings on the Lane, its leading to Larry Uteck Blvd., and the Blvd. leading downhill to the Bedford Highway. [ 89 ] The cab took Ms. ECB to the home of her friend, Mr. AL. She told him about what had happened. Later, Mr. AG arrived. She told him what had happened. Mr. AG was to drive her home. After some conversation, she called 811 and decided to report to a hospital in Pictou County to undergo a sexual assault examination. Twice before leaving Halifax, Ms. ECB had to excuse herself to vomit. [ 90 ] Two sexual assault nurse examiners examined Ms.
ECB on the evening of December 15, 2012. They found her cervix to be reddened and excoriated, which could have been caused by aggressive penetration among other things. They took swabs from various parts of her body, a slide for detecting sperm, and a urine test. They preformed polylight tests. [ 91 ] Semen was not detected. Ultimately, no alcohol was detected in a urine sample. Carboxy-THC
[ 92 ] The main inactive metabolite of THC was detected. Its presence in urine confirms cannabis use, but the use may have occurred anytime over previous weeks. [ 93 ] The analysis was done at the RCMP Lab Services by Ms. Lori Campbell. She retired. Her work was reviewed by Mr. Christopher Keddy, who testified as an expert toxicologist on behalf of the Crown. [ 94 ] Mr. Keddy did not have enough detail to calculate the amount of alcohol in Ms. ECB’s system based on number of drinks consumed, her sex, her body weight, and the time of consumption.
It seems clear that the evidence before me does not provide those details, especially the amount of alcohol consumed. Whatever the amount, it appeared from the sample to have been eliminated from her body by the time the sample was collected, assuming that sample was from her body. [ 95 ] In Mr. Keddy’s opinion, the vast majority of people could eliminate alcohol concentrated at 160ml to 320ml percent in sixteen hours, the time between Ms. ECB’s arrival at the apartment and her examination. [ 96 ] Cannabis is quite the opposite. Evidence remains in the blood for half a day or a day to thirty days. Mr.
Keddy expressed the opinion that detection in a frequent user would be expected about thirty days after last use where an infrequent user would eliminate Carboxy-THC in twelve to twenty-four hours. Ms. ECB’s testimony suggested infrequent use. [ 97 ] In cross-examination, Mr. Keddy recalled a study that showed Carboxy-THC could remain in the body of an infrequent user much longer than twenty-four hours. Apparently, the difference is explained by what low-end cut-offs are used. In any case, tests for THC only have an on and off switch. They do not show quantity. [ 98 ] Mr.
Keddy gave opinions about the effects of alcohol on a person at the time of consumption. He spoke of tolerance in a person who enjoys social drinking, consumption of moderate amounts on a regular basis. That is consistent with Ms. ECB’s evidence about her consumption of alcohol. At around 50 ml percent, such a person experiences mild euphoria and decreased impulse control. [ 99 ] At 50 ml to 100 ml percent, one experiences reduced judgment, reduced decision-making skills, and decreased ability to process information.
The person may have blurred or double vision, lose fine motor control, and have difficulty with balance and coordination. [ 100 ] In the 100 ml per gram to 150 ml percent level, the described effects worsen. Memory may be compromised. Mr. Keddy described blackouts, in which memory of a conscious period is lost completely. The literature suggests memory is not even formed. Fragmented memory is a less profound loss. The subject forgets memories. They can sometimes be recalled when prompted with cues. [ 101 ] Mr. Keddy also expressed the opinion that using different drugs together can produce complex effects.
When alcohol and cannabis are used together, they enhance the effects of the other. [ 102 ] The testing also found ephedrine and acetone. I do not find this evidence to be of assistance as proof in favour of or against a material fact. [ 103 ] There are some questions about the chain of custody with the urine sample. The results have no bearing on my finding about alcohol consumption because the putative sample produced no results for alcohol. Chain of custody aside, the results about THC are only minimally corroborative of Ms.
ECB’s testimony because of the long timeframe and the restriction to presence or absence. As I said, the ephedrine and acetone findings are barely material. [ 104 ] I found Mr. Keddy’s opinions about the effects of alcohol and THC on a person to be more helpful. Credibility of Ms. ECB [ 105 ] The main attack on Ms. ECB’s credibility is an assertion that her recall was selective. She recalled much but ignored memories that contradicted her desire to turn consensual sex into unconsented sex. Why she formulated such a desire is not explained. [ 106 ] Ms.
ECB is criticized for bias because she went to the police and the CBC when she learned that a “Bassam”, who was a taxi driver, was acquitted of sexual assault upon a passenger. A lawyer would take nothing pertaining to guilt out of a finding of not guilty. A lay person might see things differently. In any case, this happened years after Ms. ECB underwent an invasive examination and complained to the police. [ 107 ] Ms. ECB was cross-examined on her evidence that she was very intoxicated by reference to her use of her telephone and her text messages.
She was able to make frequent use of both without making many mistakes. She was challenged on her gaps in memory and it is submitted she testified selectively in favour of her goal of a conviction. [ 108 ] I am satisfied that Ms. ECB did not exaggerate her drunkenness on the morning of December 15, 2012. Common sense tells us that people who drink the quantities of beer that were consumed by Ms. ECB and her friends that night would be intoxicated. We do not know exactly how much was consumed, but we know it was a lot. [ 109 ] Also, I found Ms.
ECB and her friends credibly described the effects on them of their drinking that night. So, in addition to the evidence of quantities and times, the evidence of effects confirms what common sense tells us. [ 110 ] Thirdly, the very thing that makes us cautious about accepting Ms. ECB’s testimony makes her claim of severe intoxication ring true. Her testimony presented an unvarnished recollection from the hours in which she became increasingly intoxicated.
Her blurry recollections, her gaps in memory, her bad judgments, and her misconceptions conveyed what the expert toxicologist, and common sense, tell us to expect from recollections of a drunken experience. [ 111 ] Ms. ECB was cross-examined on her statements to police, documents she prepared for their consideration, and the transcript of her testimony at preliminary inquiry. This was helpful for clarifying and refining evidence on memory gaps and levels of intoxication, but
the cross-examination did not reveal serious contradictions impeaching credibility. [112] This gives me confidence in the testimony I heard from Ms. ECB. First, in the days following the events, Ms. ECB carefullyexamined what she could recall, and what she had to surmise, in order to present the police with a reliable spreadsheet. I am satisfied shedid so out of a desire to preserve what she could recall. [113] Second, she has had years to imagine sharpened recollections, to imagine filling for gaps, to find explanations for bad judgments,and to correct the misperceptions. She did none of those things.
As I said, her testimony reflected what one would expect fromrecollection of a drunken experience unvarnished. [114] I do not detect lapses of memory over the years since Ms. ECB left that apartment. Perhaps, this is because of her diligence inpreserving what memories she had after she left that apartment. [115] Ms. ECB was cross-examined on alternatives to her bad judgments, such as not leaving the apartment and concocting a plan tofeign sleep instead. As I said, this was not for some notion of consent based on stereotype. It tested credibility.
However, her badjudgments were consistent with intoxication. [116] It is submitted that Ms. ECB’s sharp memories from the assault itself, the detail she was able to recall from then, contrasted withher purported failure of memory from before. Firstly, her memory was not perfect at any time. Secondly, one expects an intoxicatedperson who undergoes a violent assault to be more alert when the assault happens. [117] I believe Ms. ECB. Conclusion [118] My colleague, Justice Arnold, recently released a decision that comprehensively reviews the law of sexual assault.
It is R. v.Percy, 2020 NSSC 138. [119] The elements of sexual assault are discussed at paras. 90 and 91 of Percy. The elements of the actus reus are simply (1) touching(2) of a sexual nature, and (3) absence of consent. In this case, the evidence establishes beyond doubt the first two elements. [120] At para. 92, Justice Arnold refers to the definition of consent in s.273.1 of the Criminal Code. It means, “the voluntary agreementof the complainant to engage in the sexual activity in question”. Consent as an element of the actus reus depends on the complainant’sstate of mind, not the accused’s: paras. 92 to 95.
It is made out if the complainant testifies that she did not consent, and the trier of factaccepts that evidence. At that, the consent must be in place when the sexual activity takes place. That is the only relevant time, not beforeor after: para. 96. [121] Ms. ECB testified, over and over, that she did not want sex with Mr. Al-Rawi. For the reasons given at length in the parts of thisdecision on “Ms. ECB’s Evidence of Assault” and “The Credibility of Ms. ECB”, I accept her evidence on consent.
The third element ofthe actus reus of sexual assault has been proved beyond reasonable doubt. [122] The Crown relies on exclusion of consent in s.265(3)(b), which involves “fear of the application of force”, and s.273.1(2)(c)about “abusing a position of trust”. While Ms. ECB testified about her mounting fear in the bedroom, her testimony does not support afinding that she feared application of force. While there are authorities suggesting that a taxi driver occupies a position of trust, the eventsin question are far removed from the performance of taxi duties.
However, there is no need to resort to these sorts of considerations. SeePercy at para. 92. [123] In his statement to police, Mr. Al-Rawi denies using force on Ms. ECB. However, his statement says nothing about hercommunicating consent. So, the concerns underlying R. v. W.(D.), (SCC), [1991] S.C.J. 26, do not arise at this point. SeePercy, paras. 104 to 106. [124] The subject of consent is revived when the trier of fact considers mens rea and a defence of honest but mistaken belief: paras. 94,and 143 to 152.
The accused must have believed, honestly though mistakenly, “that the complainant actually communicated consent,whether by words or conduct”: para. 148. This cannot be based on “silence, passivity, or ambiguous conduct”: para. 150. [125] Further, s.273.2(a)(ii) of the Criminal Code precludes the honest but mistaken belief defence where “the accused did not takereasonable steps, in circumstances known to the accused at the time, to ascertain that the complainant was consenting”.
See also para.149 of Percy. [126] The exculpatory mens rea intent and the honest but mistaken belief defence do not arise on the facts of this case. A drunkenperson who feigns sleep and maintains silence when the feigned sleep does not prevent being stripped and assaulted communicatesnothing about consent. Indeed, the feigned sleep is proof that no consent is communicated. [127] Nothing in Mr. Al-Rawi’s police statement contradicts Ms. ECB’s evidence about being intoxicated, not wanting sex, andfeigning sleep. So, the concerns underlying R. v.
W.(D.) do not arise. [128] The finding that identity has been proven beyond reasonable doubt is based on circumstantial evidence and Mr. Al-Rawi’sadmissions to the police. The finding is mindful of the law on the use of circumstantial evidence as discussed at paras. 107 and 108 ofPercy. [129] I find it has been proved beyond reasonable doubt that on December 15, 2012 at Halifax Mr. Al-Rawi touched Ms. ECB in asexual way without her having communicated consent. I find the evidence excludes, beyond reasonable doubt, an honest but mistakenbelief in consent. Therefore, I find Mr. Al-Rawi guilty.
J.
Loading document…