R. v. Murphy, 2020 NSSC 35
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia Citation: R. v. Murphy , 2020 NSSC 35 Date: 20200131 Docket: CRH 474606 & 474607 Registry: Halifax Between: Her Majesty the Queen v.
Lonnie Mercelle Murphy and Michelle Lynn Yetman DECISION Judge: The Honourable Justice Jamie Campbell Heard: May 27, 28, 29, 30, July 15, 16, 18, 19, October 28, 2019, and January 2, 2020, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Written Decision: January 31, 2020 Counsel: Shauna MacDonald, for the Provincial Crown Jill Hartlen, for the Federal Crown Mark Knox, for the Defence of Lonnie Murphy (May 27 to July 18, 2019) Lonnie Murphy, self-represented (July 19, 2019) Michael Rombis, for the Defence of Lonnie Murphy (October 28, 2019 and January 2, 2020) Geoffrey Newton, for the Defence of Michelle Yetman By the Court (orally): [ 1 ] Mr.
Murphy and Ms. Yetman have been charged with possession for the purpose of trafficking cocaine and cannabis (marijuana), under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act . They have also been charged with multiple counts of possession of stolen goods, possession of stolen goods for the purpose of trafficking, and with offences relating to the storage and possession of a firearm, under the Criminal Code . [ 2 ] The Federal Crown has indicated during the trial that they would not be seeking a conviction against Ms. Yetman for the charge relating to cannabis (marijuana).
The Federal Crown wrote to the court on December 4, 2019 agreeing with Ms. Yetman’s counsel that the Crown had not proven beyond a reasonable doubt the essential elements of the offence involving cocaine as it relates to Ms. Yetman. The offences relating to the firearm were also noted by the Provincial Crown as not having been proven against Ms. Yetman. [ 3 ] This is a rather lengthy decision. I will provide Mr. Murphy, Ms. Yetman and the Crown with written reasons for the decision. It is not my intention to have you sit through a reading of the written decision, but I will provide an oral
summary in court this morning. I stress that the full reasons are those in the written format.
Summary [ 4 ] Ms. Yetman has been found not guilty with respect to all charges, Counts 1 to 14 under the Criminal Code , and Counts 1 and 2 under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act . [ 5 ] Mr. Murphy has been found guilty of some offences and not guilty of some offences. [ 6 ] The only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the evidence relating to the cocaine and marijuana is that Mr. Murphy possessed both cocaine and marijuana for the purpose of trafficking. I find him guilty of both offences. [ 7 ] Mr.
Murphy was charged with various firearms offences related to a rifle that was found in the pawn shop. The way the firearm was kept within the pawn shop permits the reasonable inference to be made that when Mr. Murphy bought an interest in the pawn shop the firearm was already hidden, intentionally or not, out of sight, and that he did not have knowledge of it. I find him not guilty of the firearms offences. [ 8 ] With regard to the possession of stolen property charges, the Crown has proven that Mr.
Murphy was in possession of the items related to businesses named in the indictment and some not named in the indictment but identified as persons unknown. With respect to some of the property of Long and McQuade, Duron Atlantic, Stephen Bradley, Economy Glass, and several other retailers not named in the indictment, but named at trial, the Crown has proven that the property was stolen. The Crown has not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that property associated with Canadian Tire was stolen. The Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr.
Murphy knew that the property was stolen or was suspicious about whether the property was stolen and chose not to ask questions. The Crown has proven that Mr. Murphy had stolen property from several retailers, knowing that it was stolen and that the value was more than $5,000. The Crown has also proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Murphy had stolen property in his possession, knowing that it was stolen and possessed it for the purpose of trafficking in those stolen goods. [ 9 ] I find Mr. Murphy not guilty on Counts 3 and 8 relating to Canadian Tire. [ 10 ] I find Mr. Murphy guilty on Counts 1, 2, 6, and 7.
Those relate to possession of stolen goods from Long and McQuade, Duron Atlantic, Stephen Bradley, and Economy Glass. I find Mr. Murphy guilty on Count 9, relating to possession of property valued at more than $5,000, the property of persons unknown. I find Mr. Murphy guilty on Count 10, which charges possession for the purpose of trafficking property with a total value of more that $5,000, the property of persons unknown. [ 11 ] I will hear arguments from counsel at the time of sentencing on whether a stay should be issued with respect to Count 9. The Nature of the Charges [ 12 ] Mr.
Murphy owned the London Pawn Shop and Ms. Yetman was an employee who also held a key to the property. The Crown established Mr. Murphy’s ownership of the business using documents addressed to him as the proprietor of that business. An invoice from Pulse Signs from either February 8, or June 2, 2017 was prepared for London Pawn Shop, c/o Lonnie Murphy. The Nova Scotia Power service contract dated January 25, 2017 was sent to Lonnie Murphy at London Pawn Shop. The Nova Scotia Power bill for service from March 23 to May 24, 2017 was sent in Mr. Murphy’s name.
The Storage Inn receipt dated February 28, 2017 was sent to London Pawn Shop, c/o Lonnie Murphy and the rental agreement with that company was signed by Lonnie Murphy. The Bell Aliant bill from April 30, 2017 was sent to Lonnie Murphy, c/o London Pawn. The Kwik Copy invoice from either February 2, or September 9, 2017 were sent to Lonnie Murphy. There is ample evidence that Mr. Murphy was an owner of the London Pawn Shop. [ 13 ] Mr. Murphy said that he was a part owner of the pawn shop with Donnie Francis. He bought into the business and he and Donnie Francis split the money in the till each day.
There is no record of Mr. Francis’ involvement with or ownership of London Pawn Shop. There are no documents with his name on them. Donnie Francis has not been charged. The issue is not whether Mr. Francis may be guilty of any offences. The Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Lonnie Murphy was at least an owner of London Pawn Shop who bought and sold goods and who would financially benefit from the business undertaken at the pawn shop. [ 14 ] On October 26, 2017 the police executed a search warrant on the London Pawn Shop.
It was a large operation that involved removing many items from the pawn shop to a storage facility set aside for the evidence in this case. It involved several police officers. They found drugs in the pawn shop and goods that the Crown says were stolen. The Crown case is based solely on the presence of the items within the pawn shop. There is no evidence of what led the police to obtain a warrant and no evidence of any activity by either of the accused in the time leading up to the execution of the warrant. [ 15 ] These are criminal charges.
The Crown must prove each of the essential elements of the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. For all these charges the Crown relies on inferences that can be drawn from the evidence. The case is based on circumstantial evidence. The inference that the Crown puts forward must be the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the surrounding circumstances. If there is another reasonable inference that can be drawn the charge has not been proven. [ 16 ] As is the case in drawing any inference, the court must consider all the surrounding circumstances.
Each piece of circumstantial evidence may be explained by another reasonable inference. The question though is whether in combination that evidence allows for another reasonable inference to be drawn. Strange coincidences happen. It is reasonable to assume that they do. It would be unreasonable to assume that strange or unreasonable things never happen. Several of them together would speak to the strength or reasonableness of the inference sought to be made. The Trial [ 17 ] The validity of the warrant executed on October 26, 2017 was challenged by Mr. Murphy. Ms. Yetman did not join in that application.
For reasons given in court on March 13, 2019, the warrant was found to have been properly issued. [ 18 ] A motion for severance was made on behalf of Mr. Murphy. It was heard on May 9, 2019. Once again Ms. Yetman did not join in the motion for severance. The motion was not granted.
[ 19 ] The trial itself began on May 27, 2019. A voir dire was held to determine whether the Crown’s drug expert should be permitted to give opinion evidence, as an expert. The trial was scheduled to be completed on Thursday, May 30, 2019. It was not. At the request of Mr. Murphy’s then counsel, Mark Knox, Q.C., an adjournment was granted to consider the potential for another severance motion and a motion for a directed verdict. [ 20 ] Another week for trial was found. The trial was to be completed during the four days, July 15, 16, 18, and 19, 2019. The directed verdict motion was heard on July 15.
A decision was given on July 16, granting that motion in part and issuing not guilt findings with respect to some of the charges. Mr. Knox said that he was considering a further motion relating to the warrant but was not sure of the form that motion should take. Defence evidence was heard on the afternoon of July 16, and again on July 18. Mr. Knox anticipated that evidence would be concluded on July 18 and July 19 was reserved for argument. [ 21 ] Late in the day on July 18, a recess was called. Mr. Knox informed the court that there had been a breakdown in the solicitor- client relationship between him and Mr.
Murphy. Mr. Murphy said that he was not satisfied with the representation he had received from Mr. Knox and wanted an Ontario lawyer who would apply Canadian law rather than a Nova Scotian lawyer who would follow Nova Scotian law. He noted that he wanted to make an “innocence at stake” motion and said that he had been framed by the police, who he said were lying and an informant, who was also lying. He expressed in the clearest of terms his lack of confidence that he would receive a fair trial and his perception that this was all a set up to send him to jail. [ 22 ] Mr. Murphy provided a letter from Michael J.
Rombis, a barrister from Toronto who asked for an adjournment so that he could be formally retained and review the recordings of the proceedings. [ 23 ] Ms. Yetman, the co-accused, wanted to have her trial completed. Her rights had to be balanced against Mr. Murphy’s right to make full answer and defence. It was significant that Mr. Murphy discharged his counsel at a point when the trial was almost completed. [ 24 ] Given the ethical concerns for Mr. Knox, it would not have been appropriate to require him to continue on the file. Requiring Mr.
Murphy to represent himself, as argued by the Crown, would address the concern that Ms. Yetman not be dragged along in the process and would bring the trial to a conclusion. Having heard Mr. Murphy address the court it was evident that he would not be a self- represented or unrepresented accused who would be inclined to comply with the requirement to focus on material issues in dispute. Even though the trial had been largely completed, if Mr. Murphy represented himself, he would be requiring more time to bring more witnesses. [ 25 ] Scheduling of course was an issue. Ms. Yetman’s counsel, Mr.
Newton, and I, were both scheduled for lengthy trials that extend well into June of 2020. Mr. Murphy was granted an adjournment to August 8, 2019 to appear in Crownside to formally
schedule further dates. Counsel were informed of the available dates, October 28, and December 6, 13, 23, and 27. Crown counsel and Mr. Newton would each make themselves available for those dates and Mr. Murphy confirmed that he would get a lawyer who was available for those dates for the continuation of the trial. [ 26 ] Mr. Rombis advised the court that he would be leading evidence on behalf of Mr. Murphy on October 28, 2019. Mr. Murphy gave evidence that day and was the 28 th witness in the trial. December 6 was reserved for argument and the matter was set to return on December 13 for decision. Mr.
Rombis contacted the court on December 5 to indicate that the transcripts of the trial had not been completed so that he could not argue the case on December 6. The December 13 date was adjourned to allow Mr. Rombis to review the transcripts. The matter was adjourned and scheduled for argument on January 2, 2020. The Drugs [ 27 ] During the search the police found a total of 3488.5 grams of cannabis (marijuana) and 52.1 grams of cocaine. The cocaine was found packaged in 2 bags. One contained 50 grams and the smaller bag contained 2.1 grams.
The 50-gram bag was found on a shelf under the counter in the office of the pawn shop. That was the counter behind which Mr. Murphy was found when he was arrested. [ 28 ] The police located 2 bags of marijuana in a dresser in the storage room of the pawn shop. Those bags contained 166 grams and 448.1 grams respectively. Three smaller bags of marijuana were found inside a larger shopping bag in the same dresser. Ten bags of marijuana were found in a larger red “targus” bag in the storage or garage area. They totalled 2.857 kilograms.
The total amount of marijuana again was 3488.5 grams. [ 29 ] During the search the police located a bag containing 2.1 grams of cocaine together with a bag containing 20.5 grams of benzocaine. Those bags were found close to where Mr. Murphy was being detained while the search was being undertaken. Cst. John MacNeil was with Mr. Murphy in the office area of the pawn shop. He placed handcuffs on Mr. Murphy. Mr. Murphy sat in the office chair. Cst. MacNeil did not observe any bags near Mr. Murphy. He saw Mr. Murphy moving in the chair and asked him what he was doing.
He then saw the two bags, later identified as benzocaine and cocaine, one on the floor and the other resting on a package of bed sheets. They were in very close proximity to Mr. Murphy. [ 30 ] D/Cst. Michael Sanford was in the room at the time. He saw Mr. Murphy moving in the chair. He observed a small bag fall from near the area where Mr. Murphy’s hands were. That was the smaller of the two bags. He did not see the larger bag resting on the bed sheets until it was drawn to his attention. [ 31 ] Mr. Murphy referred to the police operation as “the set-up”.
He said that he did not use drugs and was “dead set” against trafficking in illegal drugs. The whole thing was set up by the police, the person he believed to have been their informant Josh Beyers, and potentially his former business partner at the pawn shop, Donnie Francis. He said he never dropped the bags and the police were lying. [ 32 ] The police seized $705 in Canadian currency from Mr. Murphy’s wallet. They seized a large quantity of small baggies. These are not sandwich bag size but much smaller. They seized an electronic scale, which was found to have cocaine on it. Mr.
Murphy said that he had no connection with any drug related paraphernalia. He said the plastic bags were used in the business.
[ 33 ] Mr. Murphy said that he was lured to the pawn shop on the day of the raid by a call that a party was going on at the pawn shop. He arrived at about noon and people were drinking and smoking marijuana in the garage area connected to the pawn shop. He looked in for a moment then left. He returned 45 minutes later. The people partying, drinking and using drugs had all left through the back door with no signs that there had been any party there at all. The marijuana, the cocaine and the scale may then have belonged to one of them. [ 34 ] Mr.
Murphy said that he had not dropped the bags of cocaine and benzocaine when he was placed in the office chair during the search. He said that the police must have just put them there in order presumably to have him in possession of some drugs. The other drugs were not his and he had not seen them before. They must have been left by the people who had been having the party and who cleaned up and vanished without a trace except for the drugs left as part of the set up. [ 35 ] Anything, or almost anything, is possible. That version of events is so implausible and unreasonable as to not raise a reasonable doubt.
It would require the police to have colluded to set Mr. Murphy up, not just as individuals but coordinated as a group of officers, and not just as a group of officers but with a group of only vaguely identified others, who were at the party. I accept the evidence of the police officers who identified bags as having been dropped by Mr. Murphy during the search. [ 36 ] Mr. Murphy’s contention was that the group conspiring to have him arrested and convicted, would have left a few thousand dollars’ worth of cocaine and tens of thousands of dollars’ worth of marijuana in the pawn shop for that purpose.
Those drugs would be seized by the police and lost to whomever they had belonged to before. If someone were prepared to sacrifice drugs to catch Lonnie Murphy in their web, they could have done so in a much more cost-effective way. There would be no need to leave drugs of that volume and that value. It is not a scenario for which there is any evidence whatsoever and involves speculation that is unreasonable. The only reasonable inference is that Mr. Murphy was in possession of the drugs. They were in a place that he controlled. And he was found in actual possession of the cocaine and benzocaine. [ 37 ] Mr.
Murphy knew that the substances were cocaine and marijuana. They were kept in a way that would be inconsistent with a mistaken understanding that they were something entirely innocent. A person could not reasonably mistake marijuana in that quantity for something else. Cocaine packaged in the way it was packaged and kept along with benzocaine could not reasonably be mistaken for something else. The drugs were kept in a particular place, knowingly, so he would have access to them. They were kept in that way so that he could have use of them for his purposes.
Given the way that the drugs were stored in the location the Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that they were in the possession of Lonnie Murphy. [ 38 ] The second element is whether Mr. Murphy possessed the cocaine and marijuana for the purpose of trafficking. Once again, that involves a determining not only the strength of the inference based on all the circumstances but considering whether any other inference inconsistent with guilt is also reasonable, even if demonstrably less reasonable. [ 39 ] The Crown led the evidence of D/Cst.
Seebold who was qualified to give opinion evidence of various matters relating to the illegal drug trade and the trade and use of cocaine and cannabis (marijuana). I do not accept the opinion evidence of the expert on the ultimate issue in the trial, here, whether drugs were possessed for the purpose of trafficking. That is a determination for the court to make, based on the reasonableness of inferences. D/Cst. Seebold was not qualified as an expert in drawing inferences.
His evidence with respect to the amounts used and the manner in which drugs are packaged and used was both relevant and reliable. [ 40 ] In this case, D/Cst. Seebold noted that benzocaine had been seized. He explained that benzocaine is a cutting agent used to mix with cocaine to increase the dealer’s profit margin. A user of cocaine would have no reason to mix his or her personal use cocaine with a cutting agent. A user would limit the amount of cocaine used if the dosage was too strong. Benzocaine is not normally used by users for anything. The chemical has legitimate use in dentistry and D/Cst.
Seebold noted that it has some medical uses as well. It is entirely legal to possess and is easily obtained. I accept his opinion in that regard. [ 41 ] Mr. Murphy was found with cash. Drug dealing is a cash business. I accept D/Cst. Seebold’s opinion on that issue. It is however not a piece of evidence that strongly supports the inference of trafficking. There are many reasons why a person may have quantities of cash. That is particularly so when the person has another identifiable source of income and the amount of cash is in the hundreds of dollars, not the thousands.
It is consistent with the inference for which the Crown argues but it is not the most probative of evidence. [ 42 ] A scale with cocaine residue on it was found. D/Cst. Seebold noted that drug dealers use scales. And scales with drug residue on them are often found with drug dealers. I accept that opinion as well. Once again, having a scale with cocaine on it, doesn’t mean a person is a drug dealer. In a pawn shop a drug dealer might have sold the scale to the owner. That is possible. It is highly unlikely though.
The scale was not found in the retail part of the pawn shop where is was exhibited for sale but in the office with the cocaine. [ 43 ] Small plastic bags are used by drug dealers to package their material. The very small bags here are frequently used for that purpose. I accept D/Cst. Seebold’s opinion in that regard as well. But, not everyone with a quantity of small bags is a drug dealer. Not every small plastic bag is a dime bag. In a pawn shop, an owner may use plastic bags to package rings or small items. That is entirely possible. It is in fact what a defence witness Natasha Reilley observed.
The pawn shop used small bags for rings and jewelry in her experience as a customer. [ 44 ] The quantities of drugs are large but not massive. The value of the cocaine seized would range from a bit more that $4,000 to around $5,000. D/Cst. Seebold said that a heavy cocaine user can use between 2-3 grams each day when on a binge. The amount of cocaine would be a significant stockpile for a heavy user. D/Cst. Seebold said that an addict will spend his very last cent. Users don’t usually carry around large quantities of drugs for fear of being robbed or having the drugs stolen.
It is reasonable to assume that a person running a business was not in the same circumstances as an addict living on the street. Mr. Murphy had a safe place to store cocaine and would have the means to buy a larger quantity for what might loosely be called recreational use. It was still a large amount for an individual user to have in his possession. [ 45 ] D/Cst. Seebold said that the marijuana seized at the pawn shop would have a value of between $34,000 and $52,000. A regular user would use up to 3 grams each day and a heavy user as much as 5 grams each day. A gram will yield 2 to 3 joints.
So, 5 grams is about 15 joints per day. D/Cst. Seebold said that 5 grams is enough to keep a person high for 24 hours. To use that amount of marijuana, on a regular use basis, Mr. Murphy would have to be planning to be high for close to 2 years. I accept that opinion. It is also possible that a
person with means, who is not an addict, but a casual user, may decide to buy in bulk to save money. That would be true especially if he were not living on the street but had a secure place in which to store the drugs. [ 46 ] D/Cst. Seebold said that the THC content in cannabis (marijuana) breaks down over time. The shelf life is about 6 months and if it is vacuum sealed, kept out of light and dry, it can last up to one year. I accept that evidence. [ 47 ] So, as is the case with circumstantial evidence each piece may be discounted individually.
What matters is what they mean considered together. [ 48 ] For any inference other than trafficking as a purpose to be considered, Mr. Murphy would have to be a very substantial user of both cocaine and marijuana. He would have to have held a substantial stockpile of both drugs and decided to keep both of those stockpiles at his business. He would have to be a substantial user of both drugs, with substantial stockpiles of both drugs at his business, who also happened to have benzocaine for no apparent reason.
He would have to be a heavy user, with those stockpiles of drugs, with benzocaine and who happened to have acquired a scale that just happened to have cocaine on it. He would have to have been to be a heavy user, with a large stockpile of drugs, with benzocaine, and a scale with cocaine who also happened to do business using the same small bags that drug dealers use and perhaps incidentally also have a large amount of cash in his wallet. [ 49 ] It is not for the expert in this case to make the conclusion.
The conclusion is reached with the assistance of expert opinion evidence, but the conclusion is based on the strength of the inference and the lack of any other reasonable inferences. Here, the only reasonable inference that can be reached from all the evidence is that Mr. Murphy possessed both the cannabis (marijuana) and the cocaine for the purpose of trafficking it.
Any other inference requires not just the occurrence of one possible but unlikely or improbable event but the confluence of a series of possible but improbable and unlikely events. [ 50 ] It should be noted that the evidence supporting possession of marijuana and the evidence supporting the possession of the cocaine are different. The marijuana was not found directly in Mr. Murphy’s immediate possession. It was in another area of the pawn shop where items were being stored. The cocaine was directly and immediately connected to Lonnie Murphy.
The amount of cocaine, the presence of the cutting agent benzocaine and the presence of a scale with cocaine residue on it confirm that Mr. Murphy was in the drug business of selling illegal drugs. It is not using propensity reasoning to use the evidence that supports cocaine dealing to support the inference that the marijuana, kept in the same location and in a quantity and format consistent with trafficking, was also possessed as part of that illegal undertaking. [ 51 ] I find Mr. Murphy guilty of possession of cocaine and cannabis (marijuana) for the purpose of trafficking.
Those are both counts on the indictment dated April 10, 2018. [ 52 ] Ms. Yetman is not guilty of either of those two charges. The Rifle [ 53 ] Mr. Murphy and Ms. Yetman were charged with improper storage of a firearm contrary to regulations made under the Firearms Act . They were also charged with unlawfully possessing a weapon for a dangerous purpose under s. 88(1) of the Criminal Code . The Crown has not asked for a conviction on that charge and a not guilty finding will be entered with regard to it.
They have both been charged with possession of a firearm without a license contrary to s. 91(1) of the Criminal Code and possession of a firearm knowing that they were not the holders of a license. The firearms charges relate to a rifle that was found in the pawn shop. [ 54 ] After the motion for a directed verdict, not guilty findings were entered with respect to Ms. Yetman on each of the firearms related counts, s. 91(1) and s. 92(1) of the Criminal Code . [ 55 ] Mr. Murphy said that he had no idea whatsoever that there was a firearm anywhere in the pawn shop.
He had never seen it, much less possessed it. [ 56 ] The rifle was identified as a Barretta, model CX4 Storm, 9 mm Luger calibre, semiautomatic rifle with a cartridge magazine. It was identified as a firearm but not as restricted firearm. There is no doubt about that Mr. Murphy was not licensed to possess a rifle. The rifle was stored in a way that was entirely illegal. When found it was in a bag, under a shelf, with no trigger lock securing it. [ 57 ] The issue is who, if anyone, possessed it. The rifle was found by D/Cst. Cole who is now dead. D/Cst.
Aptt said that he was in the doorway to the room in which the rifle was found when it was found. D/Cst. Brien with Forensic ID was called. He seized the rifle, documented it and sent it for analysis. That analysis confirmed that the rifle was capable of firing and was a firearm as defined. [ 58 ] When located by D/Cst. Cole it was under a shelf behind other items. It is hard to imagine how he could have identified it as a firearm or anything else without taking it out of the bag, which itself was only barely visible. When D/Cst.
Brien arrived, he said that the bag containing the rifle was still under the shelf and still in that largely hidden location. [ 59 ] The rifle was stored in a manner entirely consistent with the way that other things were stored for use by the pawn shop. It was not displayed and was found among other things piled up on a shelf in the storeroom. There is no evidence that Mr. Murphy ever saw, dealt with, or had any knowledge of the firearm. The firearm was not hidden in a secret compartment or kept in a closet. It was just under a pile of other things.
Give the chaotic state within the pawn shop it is not unreasonable to infer that when Mr. Murphy acquired an interest in the pawn shop, he did not undertake a comprehensive review of the inventory. He may have had no reason to rummage around in the storeroom during the months in which he had an interest in the pawn shop. [ 60 ] I find Mr. Murphy not guilty of the firearms offences. Those are Counts 11, 12, 13, and 14 on the indictment dated April 11, 2018. [ 61 ] Ms. Yetman has been found not guilty of the four firearms related counts on the indictment. The Stolen Property
[ 62 ] Mr. Murphy and Ms. Yetman are charged with a series of offences under s. 355 (
b) of the Criminal Code , possession of stolen property valued at under $5,000, the property of named parties (Counts 2, 3, 6, 7, and, 8). Two counts allege offences under s. 355 (
a) and relate to the property valued at over $5,000. One of those relates to the property of Long and McQuade (Count 1) and the other the property of persons unknown (Count 9). Those are all “possession” offences. Two distinguished by the value of the property. The others, all under $5,000, are distinguished by whether they relate to property of a named person or unknown persons.
Count 10 is the trafficking offence and relates to property valued at more than $5,000, the property of persons unknown. [ 63 ] The common feature of all of them is that the Crown must prove that the person charged possessed the items in question, that the items were in fact obtained by crime, in this case theft, and the that the person knew that the items were stolen. For the s. 355(
a) offences the Crown must prove that the value of the stolen goods was more than $5,000. For the trafficking offence under s. 355.5(a), the Crown must prove that the person had the stolen property in his possession, that the value of the stolen property was at least $5,000 and that the purpose of that possession was to traffic in the stolen property. Each of those things must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Possession [ 64 ] A large quantity of items was found at London Pawn Shop. The pawn shop was owned by Lonnie Murphy. There is no evidence that Ms.
Yetman was a part owner of the business or had ownership or possession of any of the items in the pawn shop. She was an employee. She might or might not have known what was going on in the pawn shop, but it has not been proven that she was in possession of anything in the pawn shop. She had a key to open and close the pawn shop but that does not give her control or possession of everything or anything in the pawn shop. [ 65 ] Ms. Yetman was not a party to the offences involving possession of stolen property.
The evidence does not support her having any control over the property beyond just having a key to open the pawn shop. It is reasonable to infer that she had no interest in and no control over any of the property in the pawn shop. While she did transactions within the pawn shop the inference that she was not aware of the source of the goods is a reasonable one. [ 66 ] Ms. Yetman is not guilty of the property possession offences. She has been found not guilty of the drug related offences and firearms related offences. Ms. Yetman is not guilty with respect to all of the counts on both indictments. [ 67 ] Mr.
Murphy was the owner. He controlled the pawn shop. The items in the pawn shop were his property and he possessed them for his benefit. The Inference of Theft [ 68 ] For any of these charges to be proven the Crown must establish that the property in question was stolen. That is an essential element of the offence that must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. [ 69 ] Before addressing each of the counts the larger perspective must be considered.
In this pawn shop was a large quantity of retail goods, many of them in their original packaging, with price stickers still affixed and some with store security tags still on them. There were multiples of some items in quantities that it is not reasonable at all to suggest were purchased by one person at the retail level and sold or pawned to London Pawn Shop. Retail representatives testified that products from their stores are not sold off to bulk resellers when they are unsold in the retail market. Some companies may do that.
Others do not. [ 70 ] The large quantity of retail merchandise is a significant factor in determining whether it is reasonable to infer that somehow the items made their way to this store legitimately. Coincidences happen. A person might sell their Canadian Tire trolling motor to the pawn shop. Someone else might sell another one. Someone else might sell their tires. All those items might be just like items that were stolen. Someone might sell a large quantity of new undergarments that they somehow obtained. Someone else might sell jeans with security tags still on them.
Each of those events is possible but it is just not reasonable to suggest that all those things could happen. There may be an explanation that can be advanced for each item but together they do not allow for an explanation other than that they were stolen property. [ 71 ] Christopher (Todd) Matheson is a friend of Lonnie Murphy’s. They have known each other for about 11 years. Mr. Matheson works at a local bar. Several years ago, he started buying items from Mariner Auctions. Mostly they were individual items that he bought online and some of them he sold to friends and family.
He said that he’d bought things about a dozen times. Between February and May of 2017, he happened to buy some large pallets of goods from the auction house. He bought a pallet with bicycles on it. He kept one and sold the others to Mr. Murphy. He bought a pallet with air conditioners. They were new and in their store packaging. He kept two and sold the rest to Mr. Murphy at a very modest profit. He sold 6 boxes of Tuck Tape to Mr. Murphy from one of the pallets that he purchased. He bought a pallet with a steam cleaner, Nespresso machines, lawn chairs, mixers and a grocery cart. He sold those items to Mr.
Murphy as well. [ 72 ] Mr. Matheson spoke about the wide variety of items that can be bought at Mariner Auctions. The items include appliances and popular brand clothing. He said that they often had store price tags still on them. He said that they came from national big box retailers and stores like Canadian Tire, Walmart and Home Depot. Mr. Matheson did not purport to be an expert in retail practices or in the details of online auctions. He spoke only from his own personal experience as a person who had bought things at an auction about a dozen times and had been in retail stores. [ 73 ] Mr.
Matheson sold a limited number of items to Mr. Murphy. His evidence may be argued to suggest that Mr. Murphy could have acquired items from others in the same way or may have acquire items himself at auctions. It is significant however that the retail representatives who gave evidence at the trial specifically said that the companies they represented did not sell to bulk sellers for sale at auctions like Mariner Auctions. [ 74 ] Craig Wright was another person who said that he bought items form Mariner Auctions and sold some of those items to Mr. Murphy.
He provided receipts for items that he bought between February and September 2017. Some were for individual items of jewelry. He had bought pallets of miscellaneous merchandise from that company. In cross-examination he was shown the website of the auction company with pictures of the pallets that he bought. He would take the items to Mr. Murphy at London Pawn to see if any interested him and if a price could be agreed upon. He would take smaller items himself to sell at a flea market.
[ 75 ] From the pictures of the pallets that Mr. Wright bought there does appear to be a wide variety of merchandise available. While some of it may have store stickers attached, there were no items visible with security devices attached. None of the items could be identified as having come from the retailers or retail outlets that were alleged to have been the source of the stolen items in London Pawn Shop. [ 76 ] The evidence of Mr. Wright and Mr. Matheson indicates that Mr. Murphy did buy some items from them that they obtained through Mariner Auctions.
It would allow for the inference that retail items that appear to be new and still in their store packaging with some retail stickers still on them, can be bought at auction. The allegation against Mr. Murphy was not however that everything in London Pawn was stolen. Evidence that some items were not, does not address that allegation. Long and McQuade [ 77 ] The first count relates to the possession of stolen property from Long and McQuade. John Parker has been a manager at that company since 2007. He was familiar with the inventory system.
The police located a left-handed Gibson Les Paul custom guitar in the London Pawn Shop. It had a Long and McQuade sales sticker still attached to it. Mr. Parker was asked to identify it. He used the serial number on the guitar to access its history in the Long and McQuade national computer system. That system tracks inventory in the company’s stores across Canada. He found that the guitar matching that serial number had been placed into inventory in the Edmonton store and was missing from inventory and not sold. It was reported stolen.
The case and other items that would normally be sold with the guitar were still in the Edmonton store. The retail price was $5,999, the price marked on the sticker. It is not a commonly sold musical instrument. The guitar had been stolen and the Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that this guitar was stolen property. [ 78 ] Mr. Parker was able to identify other items based on serial numbers. Higher value items and those that are intended to interface with computer software often have unique serial numbers that allow them to be tracked in inventory. Mr.
Parker identified a Protools Quartet music and audio production studio for use with Mac and Windows products. It had a serial number that showed that it was taken into inventory at Long and McQuade but was not sold from the store. It was valued at $2,999. A Maschine Grove Production Studio valued at $799 also had a serial number that allowed the same determination to be made. This item went missing from the Bedford location and was noted as missing on the inventory system on September 15, 2017. Those identified items had been stolen.
Several other Long and McQuade items could be tracked and authenticated by serial numbers. [ 79 ] Mr. Murphy said that he bought the guitar with the price sticker from Long and McQuade on it. He asked whether it was stolen and that was the extent of his investigation. He did not believe that it was necessary for him to call Long and McQuade to ask if they were missing a guitar. He seemed to believe that just asking the person who brought the item into his pawn shop was enough. [ 80 ] Other items could only be noted as having been like ones sold at Long and McQuade.
The company may have experienced losses of those items from its stores and presumed entirely reasonably that they had been stolen. The inference that the items found in the pawn shop were stolen is reasonable. It is not the only reasonable inference that can be made regarding the specific items. Each one may have been at some time bought at a Long and McQuade store and later sold to someone in its original packaging. That is unlikely to have happened but still raises a reasonable doubt as another reasonable inference. [ 81 ] It is not a strong inference. It barely reaches the threshold of reasonableness.
Long and McQuade do not sell inventory to resellers who then unload it at deep discounts. They sell everything in store. As Mr. Parker said, everything has a price at which it will eventually sell. That means that for the non-serial numbered items a remarkable number of people would have to have properly bought Long and McQuade items, and kept them in their original packaging and instead of returning them to the store, which would take them back within a reasonable time, decided instead to sell them or pawn them. That is not very likely at all.
But it could reasonably have happened. [ 82 ] With regard to the Gibson guitar and the serialized items, the Crown has proven that the Long and McQuade items found in London Pawn Shop were stolen. Stephen Bradley’s Amplifier [ 83 ] Count 6 is the charge with respect to property of Stephen Bradley. Mr. Bradley said that his bass amp had been stolen with some other things. He was shown a picture of a bass amp that met the description of his stolen amp. He said that it looked like a dusty version of his amp.
He was not able to point to any identifying feature of the amp that was shown in the picture of the item seized. Mr. Parker from Long and McQuade was contacted. He was able to trace the serial number on the amp found in the pawn shop to an item that had been in the Long and McQuade store and sold to Stephen Bradley. The amp found in London Pawn Shop matched the description given by Mr. Bradley and had the serial number that matched the one that was sold to Steven Bradley by Long and McQuade. The amp seized at London Pawn Shop was Steven Bradley’s amp.
There is no other reasonable inference that could be made having regard to all the circumstances. The amp was sold to Mr. Bradley and he did not sell it to anyone else. It was stolen from him and somehow acquired by Mr. Murphy. Duron Atlantic Equipment [ 84 ] Alan MacPherson gave evidence with respect to the theft of property of Duron Atlantic. That relates to Count 2 on the indictment. The company had tools stolen from a job site on Cork Street in July 2017. He was able to identify that the items depicted as having been seized at the pawn shop were the items owned by Duron Atlantic.
The boxes had the name of Duron Atlantic on them. They had not sold the tools to anyone or disposed of them in any way. There is no reasonable doubt that the tools identified as being the property of Duron Atlantic, were in fact the property of Duron Atlantic and that they were stolen from that company. There is no other reasonable inference that could be made having regard to all the circumstances. Economy Glass Equipment [ 85 ] Count 7 on the indictment relates to the property of Economy Glass. Brandon Garland was an employee of that company.
He had work related property stolen from the back of his work van in October 2017. The items were safety harnesses and a hammer drill. The harnesses had safety tags affixed by the company that did yearly safety checks of equipment for Economy Glass. He was able to identify
the safety harnesses and the drill as being the ones that were taken from his truck. Those items are not retail items. Mr. Garland could recognize the used items as being his and not someone else’s. They are not unique, but they are not so common that Mr. Garland could not identify his own tools. The Crown has established beyond a reasonable doubt that the items were the items that were stolen from Mr. Garland’s work truck and owned by Economy Glass. There is no other reasonable inference that can be made. Canadian Tire Merchandise [ 86 ] Counts 3 and 8 on the indictment are identical.
They allege possession of property stolen from Canadian Tire. They relate to two separate Canadian Tire stores and two separate incidents. One involves tires. Brenda Fisher is the loss prevention officer at the Truro Canadian Tire. They had a theft in September 2017 from the garden centre at the Truro Canadian Tire. Tires were being stored there. The store was later contacted by Halifax Police with respect to tires found in the pawn shop. Ms. Fisher identified the tires as being of a brand carried exclusively by Canadian Tire.
The stickers on the tires indicated that they had been shipped to the Truro Canadian Tire. She could not confirm that the tires at London Pawn Shop were the tires that had been stolen. There is enough information to make that inference. Tires had been stolen, and tires with stickers identifying them as being from that location were found not long after. [ 87 ] It is also reasonable to infer from the circumstances that the tires could have been bought from Canadian Tire. Nothing distinguishes the stolen tires from properly purchased tires.
It is a remarkable coincidence that tires were stolen from the Truro Canadian Tire and new tires with Canadian Tires stickers indicating that they had been shipped to the Truro Canadian Tire were found in the London Pawn Shop. The inference that the tires were stolen is very strong, but it can also be reasonably, though much less reasonably inferred that they were not.
This was not a case involving a large quantity of items req uires multiple people to have acquired tires and sold them. [ 88 ] The Crown has not proven that the tires from the Truro Canadian Tire were stolen property. [ 89 ] The second Canadian Tire incident relates to the Sackville Store. The manager of the store, Norman Hare said that on October 22, 2017, three people came into his store. They were video taped. They managed to get away with some large ticket items by loading them close to the garden centre exit and getting out there before they were stopped.
They were able to identify from the video the items that were taken. They lost two electric trolling motors, 2 stand mixers and 2 chainsaws. He was able to piece together what had been taken by seeing where the people had been in the store and what larger items were missing from the shelves. [ 90 ] Mr. Hare was called to identify some of the items. There were no chainsaws found in the pawn shop. There were however trolling motors and a number of stand mixers.
The motors and the mixers were the kind that were then carried for sale at Canadian Tire and their markings were consistent with having come from Canadian Tire stores. That allows for an inference that the mixers and the trolling motors were from the Sackville store and were the stolen ones. [ 91 ] There is another reasonable inference. The items could have been purchased. There is nothing about either the motors or the mixers that distinguishes them from motors and mixers that were bought by a customer of Canadian Tire and later sold or pawned to London Pawn Shop. [ 92 ] Mr.
Hare identified several other Canadian Tire items. Again, they all show that they were obtained from Canadian Tire at other locations but nothing about them confirms that they were stolen items. It might be entirely reasonable to infer that the items were the items stolen from Canadian Tire, but it is also reasonable to infer that they might have been purchased. Once again, give the number of items that were in their original packaging, with price stickers and store identification still on them, the inference that they were stolen is strong.
Either one Canadian Tire customer or a number of them would have to have been using resale as a substitute for returning unused items to the store. But that coincidence is one that could reasonably have happened. [ 93 ] Because the Crown has not proven that the property alleged to have been stolen from Canadian Tire was stolen a not guilty finding will be entered for Counts 3 and 8. [ 94 ] At this stage there are three just barely reasonable inferences to account for the presence of merchandise at London Pawn Shop.
The Canadian Tire items matching the description of stolen items from the Sackville Canadian Tire, the tires, matching the description of items shipped to and stolen from the Truro Canadian Tire and multiple items that came from Long and McQuade matching the description of things that had been stolen from Long and McQuade are each, on their own explainable by the inference that the goods were legitimately obtained though identical to stolen items.
When that same inference must be used repeatedly, it starts to wear thin. [ 95 ] So, of the s. 355 charges, the Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that stolen items from Long and McQuade, valued at more than $5,000 were in London Pawn Shop. That is Count 1, charging an offence under s. 355(a). The Crown has proven that stolen items belonging to Duron Atlantic (Count 2), Steven Bradley (Count 6) and Economy Glass (Count 7) were found in London Pawn Shop. Those relate to the offences contrary to s. 355(
b) for goods not exceeding $5,000. The Crown has not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the goods from Canadian Tire (Counts 3 and 8) had been stolen. Not guilty findings will be entered with respect to Counts 3 and 8, as well as Counts 4 and 5 for which no evidence has been led. “Unnamed” Retailers [ 96 ] Counts 9 and 10 relate to the possession of stolen property of persons unknown. Those are persons not known in the indictment.
Count 9 charges possession of stolen property valued at over $5,000 and Count 10 charges possession for the purpose of trafficking, property of persons unknown valued at over $5,000. [ 97 ] Samantha Hobeck is a manager at LaSenza in the Halifax Shopping Centre. She identified numerous La Senza products. None could be identified as having been stolen. They do not sell off products to third parties. It would be highly unlikely that such a quantity of undergarments would come into a person’s possession. The inference that the lingerie was stolen is strong.
The only other ways in which the lingerie could have be obtained would require remarkable coincidences. One person would have to have bought a fantastically large quantity of product and decided before removing sales tags that it should be sold rather than returned to the store. Or, a large number of people took that same rather unusual course of action and all decided to sell them to the same place, from whence they eventually made their way to London Pawn Shop. If those are reasonable inferences, they are at best very marginally so.
[ 98 ] Gregory Lowther is an investigator with TJX Canada, which owns Winners and Marshalls. He identified a large number of sheets sets, and other items with the company’s price tag and one with a security tag still affixed to it. That security tag would be the one thing that would distinguish the sheet set as being stolen as opposed to purchased. Mr. Lowther himself said that the security system was not set up in the Bayers Lake location. [ 99 ] The presence of so many sets of sheets in original packaging in London Pawn Shop would require a coincidence.
Either one person bought multiple sheet sets and decided that it made more sense to sell them than to return them or multiple people bought individual sets and reached the same conclusion. The inference of theft is strong. [ 100 ] Mr. Murphy said that he was able to buy sets of sheets at auctions, with the original store price tags still affixed. There was no other evidence of large quantities of that item being acquired in that way. [ 101 ] Brandon Keddy was the District Asset Protection Manager for Hudson’s Bay.
He identified a number of Hudson’s Bay items that are branded for sale only by Hudson’s Bay and others that are consistent with those sold by the store. Once again, items have the original store identification and price tags. Again, numerous people would have to have sold new unused and still packaged items rather than returning them or one person would have to have done that with multiple items. Nothing would serve to differentiate a stolen item from a purchased one. [ 102 ] Lytton Adams has been a manager at Home Depot for 23 years.
Several items seized at the pawn shop were identified as being items that would be carried by or sold by Home Depot. Some items were high theft items. Again, the items were new and still packaged. They were not sold to a reseller and the company does not dispose of inventory that way. It would require another coincidence for these items, packaged and new, to have been sold rather than returned to the store. Home Depot will take anything back that it sells.
But nothing would distinguish a stolen item from an item that was legitimately bought and paid for at a Home Depot store. [ 103 ] Louise Primeau was an employee of Princess Auto. She identified a number of retail items found in London Pawn Shop that were unique to Princess Auto. She noted that some of the items had been written out, meaning that they had been in inventory, based on the SKU number unique to each individual item, had gone out of inventory and had not been sold.
She estimated the value of the items as being about $2,000. [ 104 ] It is not proper to add up unproven counts to somehow make a proven one. A judge cannot use an unproven count of theft of one item as evidence of guilt on another separate count. The evidence of one count can be used to prove another of course. In making inferences all the relevant evidence must be considered. [ 105 ] Circumstantial evidence operates by taking a number of circumstances, each of which does not establish guilt and putting them together to form a strong inference of guilt.
The evidence that relates to the possession of property marked as having come from various retailers is relevant in considering the inference of guilt on the more general count. [ 106 ] It requires a broader perspective. The police executed a warrant at the London Pawn Shop. They found a large quantity of goods that was the property from multiple retailers. In the case of Long and McQuade, as I have noted, the property was proven beyond a reasonable doubt to have been stolen. The property of Stephen Bradley was proven to have been stolen. The property of Duron Atlantic was proven to have been stolen.
The property of Economy Glass was proven to have been stolen. [ 107 ] With Canadian Tire at Counts 3 and 8, the goods appear to be stolen Canadian Tire property, but it may be reasonable, if only marginally so, to suggest that they were legitimately acquired. As for La Senza, TJX, Home Depot, and Hudson’s Bay, for each individual retailer, an inference could be made that the property was legitimately obtained.
It is marginally reasonable that several people might, for whatever reason, have decided that it was easier to sell goods in their original packaging that were bought from a retailer, than to take advantage of that retailer’s return policy. It would be quite an astounding coincidence. It is hard to determine whether it is more unusual for one person to have sold multiple articles of undergarments still with store tags, or for multiple people to have made that decision. [ 108 ] Mr. Murphy is not required to establish the provenance of every or any item in his pawn shop.
He does not have to prove that he legitimately acquired anything. The Crown has to prove its case and Mr. Murphy does not need to prove or disprove anything. He has said that he acquired items at auction. He is entitled to make that contention, but there is no evidence beyond his own words that support the claim that the goods noted as having been from the various retailers were acquired in that way. Once again, Mr. Murphy does not have to prove anything. [ 109 ] The volume of retail goods was substantial. The presence of multiple items from each retailer is significant.
The fact that each was found in original packaging is significant. In some case, as with jeans and at least one sheet set, there were security tags still attached. While each individual item might be explainable as an
article brought in by a customer who bought it from a retailer, the presence of so many items packaged in that way sets up an overwhelming inference that the items were stolen. There is nothing to suggest by their packaging or otherwise that they were acquired through a bulk resale arrangement. Those retailers do not dispose of inventory in that way.
It is not reasonable to infer that they came into the pawn shop individually. [ 110 ] Considering all the circumstances together, the Crown has proven that the only reasonable inference is that goods from the retailers whose representatives testified at the trial were stolen. They were not specifically named in the indictment. [ 111 ] At this stage then the Crown has proven that items in Count 1, from Long and McQuade, Count 2, Duron Atlantic, Count 6, Stephen Bradley, Count 7, Economy Glass, Count 9, unknown persons, and Count 10, unknown persons were stolen property.
Counts 3 and 6 relating to Canadian Tire have not been proven. Possession and Knowledge [ 112 ] For any of these offences, the accused must knowingly possess the stolen items. They were, in this case, in the pawn shop owned by Mr. Murphy. He controlled the premises and made profit from the sales of goods offered for sale in the pawn shop.
[ 113 ] The Crown must prove that Mr. Murphy knew that the property in his possession had been stolen. This was the area upon which Mr. Rombis, counsel for Mr. Murphy focused. He argued that Mr. Murphy subjectively did not know that the items were stolen, and he was not suspicious about whether they were stolen. He acquired items and trusted people who sold them to him. Mr. Murphy asked to make his own remarks to supplement Mr. Rombis’ legal argument. Mr.
Murphy asserted once again that the whole thing was a setup involving a conspiracy among police officers and a police informant. [ 114 ] Willful blindness can establish the required level of knowledge. Willful blindness involves a subjective element. The person must themselves have been suspicious about the property was stolen and made the decision not to inquire, to avoid being encumbered with the knowledge that would be gained from such an inquiry. Willful blindness is a conscious choice not to make an inquiry.
A person may be so naïve and trusting that they believe almost anything. [ 115 ] The question is whether the Crown has proven that Lonnie Murphy was not such a trusting person. The only way to determine that is by inference from the evidence. It is not whether a reasonable person would have been suspicious or whether based on reasonable grounds he should have been suspicious. It is whether he, Lonnie Murphy, was suspicious. As a pawn shop owner, he was under no higher moral obligation to be alert to the potential that he might unintentionally acquire stolen goods.
He was however aware of the context within which he operated his business. Lonnie Murphy knew that he was operating a pawn shop in which he bought goods from people who were not personally known to him and that potentially some of those items were stolen. [ 116 ] When buying a left-handed, Les Paul, Gibson guitar with a Long and McQuade price tag for $5,999 Mr. Murphy would have to know that he was dealing with a valuable item. Why would the owner not have just returned it to Long and McQuade? The same would be true of many of the other higher valued Long and McQuade items.
The only reason not to ask questions in those circumstances is because Mr. Murphy did not want to know the answers. That is willful blindness. [ 117 ] Duron Atlantic had the company name printed on the tools. Lonnie Murphy is not unsophisticated enough to buy tools marked in that way from a person who is not acting on behalf of Duron Atlantic and not ask how he obtained them, unless Mr. Murphy just did not want to know the answer. That is willful blindness. [ 118 ] Mr. Murphy showed a pattern of behaviour when acquiring items to sell in the pawn shop. It is consistent with what he said in his testimony as well.
He asked for a name and contact information from the seller and otherwise just took them at their word that the property was not stolen. Very few, if any people, going into a pawn shop with a stolen item, or a palette of stolen items, would admit to the owner that the property was stolen. It serves the short-term interest of both seller and buyer to answer that the item was not stolen so that both can proceed with the transaction.
That perfunctory inquiry might be sufficient when there is no suspicion to ground any meaningful investigation. [ 119 ] In the case of the property involved in these charges, the grounds for suspicion are so glaring that Mr. Murphy had to have had questions about whether the items were stolen. Again, it is not whether he should have been suspicious or whether a reasonable person would be suspicious. Lonnie Murphy himself was suspicious as to whether the goods were stolen and chose not to make inquiries. [ 120 ] The volume of items was substantial.
It was not simply a matter of one or two mixers or small appliances. There were a large number of items, in retail packaging with retail identification attached and price tags attached. There were multiples of the same item from the same retailer. No one, seeing the wide array of items could not be prompted to ask, “Where did all of this stuff come from?” [ 121 ] The Crown has proven that the items were stolen. They were not bought at an auction as Mr. Murphy said. I do not accept his evidence and his evidence does not raise a reasonable doubt. Mr.
Murphy was not so unsophisticated, naïve, or gullible as to believe that what had come into his possession had been legitimately obtained. [ 122 ] Mr. Murphy possessed the stolen items from several retailers and knew that the items were stolen, or remained willfully blind to that fact. Trafficking [ 123 ] The stolen property was found in a pawn shop. It is a retail location. Things were there either because they had been pawned or were available for sale. There is no reasonable inference that can be drawn other than that the property was possessed by Mr. Murphy for the purpose of selling it.
Value [ 124 ] The total value of all the stolen property well exceeds $5,000. The Gibson guitar itself would exceed that amount. Count 1 has then been proven. A guilty finding will be entered with respect to that charge. [ 125 ] Counts 2, 6, and 7 do not require any value to be established. Those charges have been proven and guilty findings will be entered with respect to those charges. [ 126 ] Counts 9 and 10 each relate to the property of persons unknown. Count 9 is limited to possession and Count 10 involves trafficking. The persons unknown are La Senza, Princess Auto, TJX, Hudson’s Bay, and Home Depot.
The value of the items from three of those retailers alone amounted to $16,000. The value of the items in Counts 9 and 10 exceeds $5,000. Conclusion [ 127 ] The Crown has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that property seized from London Pawn Shop was stolen. It has proven that the property kept at that location was in the possession on the owner, Lonnie Murphy. It has proven that the Lonnie Murphy knew that the property was stolen and the purpose of his having the property in his possession was to sell it to others.
The Crown has proven that the value of merchandise that was the property of unnamed retailers was greater than $5,000. [ 128 ] On Indictment CRH No. 474606 under the Criminal Code :
Count 1 – s. 355(a), Long & McQuade: Guilty Count 2 – s. 355(b), Duron Atlantic: Guilty Count 3 – s. 355(b), Canadian Tire: Not Guilty Count 4 – s. 355(b), No evidence offered: Not Guilty Count 5 – s. 355(b), No evidence offered: Not Guilty Count 6 – s. 355(b), Stephen Bradley: Guilty Count 7 – s. 355(b), Economy Glass: Guilty Count 8 – s. 355(b), Canadian Tire: Not Guilty Count 9 – s. 355(a), Persons unknown: Guilty Count 10 – s. 355.5(a), Trafficking: Guilty Count 11 – s. 86(2), Firearms: Not Guilty Count 12 – s. 88(1), No evidence offered: Not Guilty Count 13 – s. 91(1), Firearms: Not Guilty Count 14 – s. 92(1), Firearms: Not Guilty [ 129 ] On Indictment CRH No. 474607 under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act : Count 1 – s. 5(2), Cocaine: Guilty Count 2 – s. 5(2), Cannabis (Marihuana): Guilty Campbell, J.
Loading document…