R. v. Corcoran, 2020 NSSC 38
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia Citation: R. v. Corcoran , 2020 NSSC 38 Date: 20200128 Docket: CRAT, No. 485001 Registry: Antigonish Between: Her Majesty the Queen Appellant v. Colin Donald Corcoran Respondent DECISION Judge: The Honourable Justice N.M. Scaravelli Heard: November 25, 2019, in Antigonish, Nova Scotia Written Decision: January 28, 2020 Counsel: Jonathan Gavel, for the Appellant Nicole Rovers, for the Respondent By the Court: INTRODUCTION [ 1 ] This is a
Summary Conviction Appeal by the Crown appealing a decision of Judge Richard MacKinnon staying the Information laid against the respondent, Colin Donald Corcoran. BACKGROUND [ 2 ] In November 2017, Mr. Corcoran was arrested and charged with sexual interference with a minor under
section 151 of the Criminal Code . The trial was heard over several days in late 2019. When the Crown called the complainant to testify, counsel for Mr. Corcoran objected on the grounds that the defence had not been given sufficient disclosure such that he could know and meet the case against him. The Crown maintained the objection was an attempt to re-hear the same issue that had already been decided by the trial judge at a previous voir dire. [ 3 ] On January 18, 2019, the trial judge issued an oral decision, finding in favour of Mr. Corcoran and staying the Information. On February 8, 2019, the Crown filed the Notice of
Summary Conviction Appeal. The grounds of appeal are as follows: 1. The Honourable Judge Richard J. MacKinnon erred in finding that the Respondent’s
Section 7 Charter rights had been breached. 2. The Honourable Judge Richard J. MacKinnon erred in finding that the stay was appropriate remedy under Section 24(1) of the Charter. 3. Such other grounds as may appear.
[ 4 ] Following the filing of the Notice of Appeal on February 13, 2019, Crown counsel appeared in Supreme Court Chambers in the months of March and April indicating that the Crown had been unable to serve Mr. Corcoran and requested adjournments of the matter to set dates. Mr. Corcoran was personally served with the Notice of Appeal on May 3, 2019. [ 5 ] On May 31, 2019, Mr. Corcoran filed an affidavit and written submissions with the Court seeking dismissal of the Notice of
Summary Conviction Appeal as it had not been served in accordance with
Summary Conviction Appeal Rules, as contained in the Criminal Code and the Nova Scotia Civil Procedure Rules. Mr. Corcoran’s affidavit described his availability for service. [ 6 ] The first appearance in Chambers with both parties and counsel occurred on June 4, 2019 before Justice Scott Norton. Counsel and the court agreed that the issue of improper service would be addressed at the time of the appeal hearing. Justice Norton set dates for hearing of the appeal and filings of the Appeal Book and Factums. [ 7 ] The Crown submits that there is no specific timeline for service of the Notice of Appeal in an appeal under
section 813 of the Criminal Code . Section 815(1) is silent as to any timeline for service of the Notice as opposed to section 830(3) which sets out timelines. Alternatively, the Crown submits that if there is an applicable timeline for service of the Notice, and if it was exceeded, an extension of that timeline was “implicitly” granted by Justice Norton. PRELIMINARY ISSUE (
a) Was the Crown required to effect personal service on the Respondent within a designated time frame? [ 8 ] Although Mr. Corcoran submits the timeline under Section 830(3) of the Criminal Code applies, this is an appeal under
section 813 of the Criminal Code .
Section 813 (b)(
i) specifically refers to this type of proceeding. 813 Except where otherwise provided by law … (
b) the informant, the Attorney General or his agent in proceedings under this Part may appeal to the appeal court (
i) from an order that stays proceedings on an information or dismisses an information, (emphasis added) … and the Attorney General of Canada or his agent has the same rights of appeal in proceedings instituted at the instance of the Government of Canada and conducted by or on behalf of that Government as the Attorney General of a province or his agent has under this paragraph. [ 9 ] The proceedings set out in
section 813 are guided by
section 815 815(1) An appellant who proposes to appeal to the appeal court shall give notice of appeal in such manner and within such period as may be directed by rules of court.
(2) The appeal court or a judge thereof may extend the time within which notice of appeal may be given. [ 10 ] The “rules of court” referred to in section 815(1) are found at Civil Procedure Rule 63 –
Summary Conviction Appeal 63.03
(1) All Rules outside this Rule apply to the extent that they provide procedures that are suitable to a
summary conviction appeal, and are not inconsistent with the provisions of the Criminal Code or this Rule.
(2) In particular, Rule 91 – Criminal Appeal, made by the judges of the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal applies, including the Rules providing for a prisoner appeal, cross-appeal, transcript, and appeal book, subject to each of the following modifications or exceptions:
(
a) Rule 91 must be read as if a reference to the registrar were a reference to the prothonotary; (
b) the copy of the decision under appeal required in the appeal book must be a written decision issued by the trial judge, a written version of an oral decision signed by the trial judge, or a transcript of the decision certified by the trial judge to be accurate; (
c) no provision in Rule 91 about leave to appeal applies; (
d) no provision in Rule 91 that is inconsistent with the Rule 63 applies. [ 11 ] Rule 63.06(3) provides that “notice must be given to a respondent who is not the Crown in accordance with the provisions for giving notice of a proceeding to a party in Rule 31 – Notice” (personal service). [ 12 ] Rule 63.03 indicates that in
summary conviction appeals, several sources for procedure may overlap. Therefore, other Rules that are suitable and not inconsistent with Rule 63 and other procedures set out in the Criminal Code will apply, specifically Rule 91 . Rule 91 is not silent on the deadline for effecting service. Rule 91.10(1)(
b) provides that an appellant must personally serve (or otherwise permitted by a Judge), the Notice before the deadline set out in Rule 91.09(1). This is consistent with Rule 63 which points to Rule 31.02, personal service unless an exception applies. Rule 91.09 reads 91.09
(1) For the purpose of
section 678 and 839 of the Code, a person may start an appeal of a judgment by filing a notice of appeal no more than twenty-five days after one of the following: (
a) the day the appellant is sentenced, if the appeal is from a conviction, finding of guilt, or sentence, or both a conviction or finding of guilt and a sentence; (
b) the day a judgement is made, if the appeal is from an acquittal or other judgment that is not a conviction, finding of guilt, or sentence . (emphasis added)
(2) The period is calculated under Rule 94.02, of Rule 94 –
Interpretation, and it is subject to being extended under
section 678 of the Code or Rule 91.04. [ 13 ] Although Rule 91.09 states it applies for the purpose of
section 678 and 839 of the Code , neither of which apply in this case, the question is whether the provisions in the Rule are inconsistent with Rule 63 or applicable sections of the Criminal Code . In my view, the deadline set out in Rule 91.09(1) is both suitable and consistent with Rule 63 and the Code . First, there is nothing in Rule 63 or relevant sections of the Code that provide a different deadline for service of the Notice. Second, the deadline for filing the Notice of Appeal set out in Rule 63.05(1)(
b) also provides for 25 days. It is consistent that the deadline for filing and serving a Notice of Appeal is the same. [ 14 ] In this case, the decision by the trial judge was released on January 18, 2019. The Crown filed its Notice of Appeal on February 8, 2019, which is 15 free and clear days from the date of the decision. According to the respondent’s brief, the Crown did not serve Mr. Corcoran until May 3, 2019. This well exceeds the 25 day deadline provided for by the Civil Procedure Rules. [ 15 ] The Crown was required to effect personal service on the respondent which it failed to do in a timely manner. (
b) Did the Chambers Judge implicitly grant an extension to the time frame required to serve notice? [ 16 ] Failure to effect proper service of the Notice of Appeal goes directly to the jurisdiction of the Court to hear the appeal. [ 17 ] Rule 63.05(2) points to section 815(2) of the Criminal Code for allowing an extension of the timeline for giving a Notice of Appeal. 815(2) The appeal court or a judge thereof may extend the time within which notice of appeal may be given.
[18] The onus is on the respondent seeking extension of time for service to provide evidence justifying the extension. InBellefontaine v.
Schneiderman, 2006 NSCA 96, the court cited with approval the test to be applied on an application to extend thetime. [3] A three-part test is generally applied by this Court on an application to extend the time for filing a notice of appeal, requiringthat the applicant demonstrate (Jollymore Estate Re (2001), 2001 NSCA 116 , 196 N.S.R. (2d) 177 (C.A. in Chambers) at para.22): (1) the applicant had a bona fide intention to appeal when the right to appeal existed; (2) the applicant had a reasonable excuse for the delay in not having launched the appeal within the prescribed time; and (3) there are compelling or exceptional circumstances present which would warrant an extension of time, not the least of which beingthat there is a strong case for error at trial and real grounds justifying the appellate interface. [4] Where justice requires that the application be granted, the judge may allow an extension even if the three parttest is not strictly met (Tibbetts v.
Tibbetts (1992), (NS CA), 112 N.S.R. (2d) 173 (C.A. in Chambers)). [19] Regina v. Holmes, (1983)40 O.R. (4d) 707 (ON CA), relying on Neal v. Saskatchewan (Attorney General), (1977) (SCC), 2 S.C.R. 624 (SCC) and R. v. Ruffo, (ON CA), 1982 O.J. 155 (ON CA) held that where anaccused is not served within the time limit prescribed by the Rules, in the absence of a valid Order extending time for service, thesummary conviction appeal court does not have jurisdiction to entertain the appeal.
The Court reasoned that compliance with the timelimit was a condition precedent to the Court’s jurisdiction and can only be complied with if there is a valid Order extending the time forservice. [20] At no time during the proceedings did the Crown make application or provide admissible evidence to enable the Court todetermine if an extension of time for service was justified. Any such application would have to take into consideration the affidavit filedby Mr. Corcoran.
Mere failure by the Crown to comply with its duty to effect appropriate service does not justify an extension. [21] Absent an application to extend time for service, jurisdiction to hear the appeal lapsed and neither the Chambers Judge nor thisCourt has the jurisdiction to extend time. Mr. Corcoran’s response to the application after jurisdiction lapsed does not remedy the defectin service, especially when an early objection to service was made. [22] As a result, I find that this Court does not have jurisdiction to entertain the appeal. Scaravelli, J.
Loading document…