Founders Square Limited v. GDI Services (Canada) LP, 2020 NSSC 41
Opinion
SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia Citation: Founders Square Limited v. GDI Services (Canada) LP , 2020 NSSC 41 Date: 20200129 Docket: Hfx No. 476486 Registry: Halifax Between: Founders Square Limited Plaintiff v. GDI Services (Canada) LP Defendant Judge: The Honourable Justice Ann E. Smith Heard: December 18, 2019, in Halifax, Nova Scotia Final Written Submissions: Plaintiff – December 20, 2019; Defendant – December 23, 2019; Reply Plaintiff – December 30, 2019 Counsel: John T. Shanks, for the Plaintiff James D. MacNeil, for the Defendant By the Court: Introduction [ 1 ] GDI Services (Canada) LP (“GDI”) moves for
summary judgment on evidence pursuant to Civil Procedure Rule 13.04 in relation to its Counterclaim against Founders Square Limited (“FSL”). [ 2 ] GDI provided cleaning services to FSL pursuant to a contract with it. Certain of its invoices were not paid by FSL. FSL did not pay the invoices because it was not satisfied with the quality of cleaning services provided by GDI, and as a result terminated its contract with GDI.
In the aftermath of the termination of the contract, there were public protests carried out on FSL property by GDI employees and the union representing them following their dismissal from the employ of GDI. FSL alleges that these GDI employees communicated false and misleading allegations of racial discrimination on the part of FSL arising from their dismissal to media outlets which were broadcast nationally. FSI claims that GDI breached its contract by failing, among other things, to correct those allegedly false and misleading statements. [ 3 ] FSL commenced action against GDI for breach of contract.
GDI filed a defence and counterclaim. [ 4 ] GDI now seeks
summary judgment on part of that counterclaim. GDI seeks an order for judgment in the amount of $58,365.38 plus interest with respect to the unpaid invoices issued to FSL. GDI has other counterclaims against FSL, for which it does not seek
summary judgment. These include counterclaims for loss of reputation and intentional interference with economic relations. [ 5 ] FSL does not contest the granting of judgment in favour of GDI but says that since its originating action against GDI has not yet been determined, the order for
summary judgment in favour of GDI should be stayed until the originating proceeding is determined. In that regard, FSL relies upon Civil Procedure Rule 13.07(2). The Evidence on the Motion
[ 6 ] FSL relies on the Affidavit of Nick Garside, sworn December 10, 2019. Mr. Garside states in his Affidavit that he is a Senior Property Manager at The Armour Group Limited (“AGL”) and that AGL is the sole shareholder of FSL and Armour Developments Limited (“ADL”). Mr. Garside further states in his Affidavit that ADL is the owner of the Founders Square property located at 1701 Hollis Street, Halifax (“Founders Square”) and that FSL leases Founders Square from ADL. Mr.
Garside also states in his Affidavit that AGL acts as agent for FSL in the administration of its contracts, including the subject contract with GDI. [ 7 ] Mr. Garside states in his Affidavit that in August 2017, GDI and FSL renewed a contract for the provision of cleaning services at Founders Square (the “Contract”) for a one-year term. Mr. Garside goes on to state in his Affidavit that throughout the term of the Contract, FSL received numerous complaints from tenants of Founders Square with respect to the quality of cleaning services provided by GDI. [ 8 ] Mr.
Garside states in his Affidavit that on February 28, 2018, he wrote to GDI and provided written notice that FSL was terminating the Contract effective March 31, 2018. He hand-delivered the February 28, 2018 letter to Sheridan Curnew, his principal contact at GDI, on February 27, 2018. Mr. Garside’s Affidavit evidence as to events following the termination of the Contract is as follows: Post-termination Protests 13.
Following the termination of the Contract, employees of GDI who had provided contracted cleaning services at Founders Square, the union representing them, and others complained publicly and to the media that GDI employees were terminated as a result of racial discrimination by FSL and AGL. These individuals engaged in protests at Founders Square and other AGL locations over the course of a number of days and communicated allegations of racial discrimination on FSL and AGL’s part to media outlets which were broadcast nationally. 14.
Due to representations made during these protests, AGL was required to issue a Protection of Property Notice under the Property Protection Act in relation to Founders Square and other impacted AGL properties. 15. Due to the content of the protests and in order to ensure safe workplaces, FSL advised GDI that its employees should not report to work at Founders Square for the remaining week of the contract term. FSL confirmed to GDI in writing that GDI would be paid in full for this period, even though the workers would not be required. 16.
FSL retained Deep Down Cleaning Services for the final week of the contract term and was obligated to pay for the services of two cleaning companies during this period. 17. Following the termination of the Contract employees of GDI commenced Human Rights Act proceedings against AGL. These complaints required FSL and AGL to retain legal counsel to defend these allegations. These proceedings were dismissed by the Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission on September 18, 2019. A copy of the dismissal letter from the Commission is attached as Exhibit “C” to this affidavit. 18.
In the midst of the public protects and media reporting, both FSL and AGL made multiple requests of GDI to take the necessary steps to correct false information provided by its employees or reported in the media regarding the circumstances of the termination of GDI employees. 19. FSL and AGL were required to expend significant time and resources in responding to factually inaccurate and misleading claims of employees of GDI and others involved in the public protests and claims contained in the media reports relating to the involvement and participation of FSL and AGL in the dismissal of the GDI employees. 20.
These included the costs incurred in securing the services of a public relations company to respond to allegations of racially discriminatory behaviour, the costs of commencing and prosecuting defamation lawsuits relating to the public protest and media coverage, and the costs of preparation and investigation relating to anticipated human rights complaints threatened against FSL and AGL and additional security costs incurred at both Founders Square and other AGL locations which were the subject of protests. [ 9 ] In cross-examination on his Affidavit, Mr.
Garside agreed that the Protection of Property Notice that AGL issued due to alleged representations made by GDI employees during public protests was issued not to GDI, but rather to “All Members, Officers and Executives of Service Employees International Union (“SEIU”), Local 2” (the “Union”). Mr. Garside was not aware of any such Notice being issued to GDI. [ 10 ] Mr. Garside also agreed in cross-examination on his Affidavit that he was aware, after the protests, that the employees of GDI who were protesting were Union members.
There were other protestors as well, but his evidence was that he could not provide the identity of those persons. [ 11 ] Mr. Garside also agreed in cross-examination that the human rights complaint referred to in his Affidavit (which was dismissed by the Commissioners of the Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission) was filed by individuals against AGL and Deep Down Cleaning Services, and not against GDI. [ 12 ] GDI relies upon the Affidavit of Sheridan Curnew, General Manager (Nova Scotia/Newfoundland) of GDI. In his Affidavit Mr.
Curnew confirms that GDI entered into the Contract with FSL in August 2017 to provide cleaning services within Founders Square. Mr. Curnew states in his Affidavit that at the time FSL terminated the Contract with GDI, invoices for services rendered by GDI for January and February 2018 were outstanding. He states that those invoices have never been paid. Mr. Curnew’s Affidavit attaches copies of the unpaid invoices. Mr. Curnew was not cross-examined on his Affidavit. Facts The Contractual Relationship between FSL and GDI:
[ 13 ] The Contract laid out certain obligations on the part of GDI: 5.1 The Contractor shall perform the Scope of Work identified in the document attached as
Schedule “A” in a first class manner using quality materials, qualified workmen, proper equipment and workmanship to the Client’s satisfaction as determined in the Client’s sole discretion. 5.2 At all times the Contractor shall act in a professional manner and provide the Services in the best interests of the Client. [ 14 ] Counsel for FSL placed emphasis during the hearing on what he referred to as the “robust” indemnity clause in favour of FSL, which provides:
Part 9: INDEMNITY The Contractor shall indemnify and hold harmless, and when requested by the Client, defend the Client, its directors, employees, agents and subsidiaries from and against all liabilities, suits, actions, judicial or administrative proceedings, claims, demands, damage, penalties, fines, costs and expenses of whatsoever kind or character (including but not limited to all costs and fees for investigation and defense thereof) arising out of or by reason of any liability or obligation in any manner caused or occasioned or claimed to be caused or occasioned by any act, omission, fault or negligence of the Contractor or anyone acting on his behalf, including but not limited to Subcontractors and sub-vendors, and the employees and agents of any of the foregoing, in connection with or incidental to the performance of or failure to perform any covenant or obligation under the Agreement or related to the Services.
This indemnity shall extend to any injuries (including death) or damage to any person or damage to or destruction of any property of any person or entity employed by or acting on the Contractor’s behalf under the Agreement, except where solely caused by the negligence of the Client. [ 15 ] On May 22, 2018, FSL brought an action against GDI for alleged breach of its contractual obligations, i.e., to perform work “in a first class manner” and to “act in a professional manner and provide the services in the best interest of the Client.” [ 16 ] The contractual breaches alleged by FSL in its Statement of Claim include: (
a) GDI's failure to provide cleaning services at Founders Square in a “first class” manner; (
b) GDI’s failure to take reasonable, or any, corrective action when notified of deficiencies in the services provided at Founders Square; (
c) GDI’s failure to properly train and instruct its employees; (
d) GDI’s failure to bring incidents of substandard performance to the attention of its employees; (
e) GDI’s failure to provide additional training, supervision or equipment as necessary for its employees to address complaints relating to cleaning services provided at Founders Square; (
f) GDI’s failure to act “in the best interests” of FSL by failing to advise its employees of incidences of substandard performance and by failing to properly advise its employees of FSL’s decision and reasons for terminating the Contract; (
g) GDI’s failure to act “in the best interests” of FSL by failing to correct allegedly false statements and allegations made by its employees and others during the public protests and to the news media relating to the cause of the employees’ termination by GDI; and (
h) GDI’s failure to act “in the best interest” of FSL by failing to respond to media inquiries and to correct allegedly false and misleading statements publicized by its employees and others and reported by news media relating to the cause of the termination of GDI’s employees and the cause of FSL’s termination of the Contract. [ 17 ] A review of FSL’s plead claims against GDI shows that these claims may be roughly divided into claims related to GDI’s performance of cleaning services to the standard stipulated in the Contract, and claims relating to GDI’s alleged failure to act in the best interest of FSL during protests following the termination of the Contract.
FSL says that both these aspects of its claims against GDI are firmly rooted in the Contract. Issue: Should the Order for
summary judgment be stayed pending determination of FSL’s claim against GDI? LAW and ANALYSIS [ 18 ] The parties agree on the test for
summary judgment on evidence. There is no need to go through the analysis required by the Rule and the case law since the parties agree on the test. [ 19 ] The parties also agree as to the “math” of GDI’s outstanding invoices, i.e., that the outstanding invoices total $58,365.83. Specifically, FSL says that had the cleaning services been properly provided, that amount would be owed to GDI for its work plus the contractual rate of interest the parties agreed to in the Contract.
FSL adamantly maintains that the adequacy of GDI’s provision of services was such that it received numerous complaints from tenants which ultimately led it to terminate the Contract with GDI. FSL says that the amounts owed to GDI were withheld specifically because there was an expectation that there would be legal claims against GDI as to the adequacy of those services, i.e., for breach of the Contract.
Issue: [ 20 ] The only issue in contention on this motion is whether equitable set-off applies to FSL’s claims against GDI, and if so, whether any judgment GDI has against FSL should be stayed pending a determination of FSL’s action.
[21] FSL says that equitable set-off applies and that any judgment GDI has against it for the unpaid invoices should be stayed. GDIsays that equitable set-off does not apply and no stay of judgment should be ordered. GDI also says that FSL has not met the evidentiaryburden required for this Court to order set-off. Does Equitable Set-Off Apply and Should Judgment be Stayed? [22] As stated earlier in this decision, FSL relies upon Civil Procedure Rule 13.07 which it contends clearly contemplates that itmay be appropriate for a judge to stay a
summary judgment order where a related proceeding remains unresolved. Rule 13.07 provides: 13.07 Order for
summary judgment
(1) An order for
summary judgment may provide any remedy the court provides on the trial or hearing of a proceeding.
(2) The judge may stay an order for
summary judgment until a related proceeding is determined. [emphasis added] [23] The issue of equitable set-off in the context of a
summary judgment motion was considered by Associate Chief Justice DeborahK Smith, as she then was, in Agate Developments Ltd. v. United Gulf Developments Ltd., 2008 NSSC 144. At para. 39 Smith, ACJstated: [39] …Set-off in equity does not require mutuality nor do the cross obligations need to be debts [see Singer v. Sommex Maritime Ltd, (NS SC), [1996], 148 NSR (2d) 118) at para. 15]. In Singer, supra, Davison, J. referred to the following principleswhich were set out by the British Columbia Court of Appeal in Coba Industries Ltd. v. Millie’s Holdings (Canada) Ltd. et al. (1985),20DLR (4th) at pp. 696-697:
(1) The party relying on a set-off must show some equitable ground for being protected against his adversary’s demands: Rawson etal v. Samuel (1841), Dr. & Ph. 161, 41 E.R. 451.
(2) The equitable ground must go to the very root of the plaintiff's claim before a set-off will be allowed: British Anzani.
(3) A cross-claim must be so clearly connected with the demand of the plaintiff that it would be manifestly unjust to allow theplaintiff to enforce payment without taking into consideration the cross-claim: Federal Commerce & Navigation Ltd.
(4) The plaintiff’s claim and the cross-claim need not arise out of the same contract: Bankes v. Jarvis, [1903] 1 K.B. 549; BritishAnzani.
(5) Unliquidated claims are on the same footing as liquidated claims: the Newfoundland case. [24] In Agate Developments Ltd. v. United Gulf Development Ltd., Smith A.C.J. determined that United Gulf’s claim for set-off didnot go to the very root of the claim advanced for
summary judgment. She found that the causes of action, which she said might beconnected, were not so closely related that Agate should be denied its right to partial
summary judgment until the claim for set-off wasdetermined. [25] As I understand the facts before the Court in Agate, Agate and United Gulf entered into an agreement of purchase and sale of acertain property. There was an agreed purchase price and an amount to constitute a deposit with the balance of the purchase price beingsecured by a vendor take-back mortgage. The mortgage provided for four annual instalments. The parties agreed that United Gulf paidthe first three instalments under the mortgage, but not the last. Agate brought action under the mortgage. United Gulf counterclaimed.
It claimed set-off with respect to any amount claimed by Agate under the mortgage or otherwise in an amount equal to monthlycommercial rent and taxes on a portion of the mortgaged lands which it alleged Agate had used or allowed a related company to use,without its consent. [26] ACJ Smith denied United Gulf's request to stay Agate’s
summary judgment, stating: [41] In the case at Bar, I am not satisfied that United Gulf's claim for set-off goes to the very root of the claim being advanced in thisapplication for partial
summary judgment in such a way that it would be manifestly unjust to allow Agate to enforce this part of its claimwithout taking the Counterclaim into account. In my view, the causes of action, which may be connected, are not so closely related thatAgate should be denied its right to partial
summary judgment until the claim for set-off is determined. United Gulf’s Counterclaim is aseparate action which may proceed to trial notwithstanding that a partial
summary judgment has been granted. [27] In Singer v. Sommex Maritime Ltd. (1996) (NS SC), 148 NSR (2d) 118 the plaintiff sought
summaryjudgment with respect to unpaid invoices for products (beds) delivered to the defendant over the course of six years. The defendant hadnever raised an issue about the quality of the beds. The defendant’s assignee then claimed that the beds were of poor andunmerchantable quality. The assignee did not dispute that the invoices were not paid but claimed in its defence that the beds were ofpoor and unmerchantable quality. Justice Davison determined that equitable set-off applied to a particular shipment because thedefendant had made an arguable point that the claim for equitable set-off existed.
Summary judgment, though granted, was stayed,pending a determination of whether the set-off should be allowed in respect of the particular shipment. [28] More recently, in Boudreau v. Darnoc Investments Inc., 2009 NSSC 77 Duncan J. of this Court stayed a judgment in an actioninvolving mutual allegations of breach of an agreement of purchase and sale. The plaintiff in that case sought an order for
summaryjudgment for the unpaid balance of a purchase price for shares transferred by the plaintiff to the defendant. The defendant acknowledgeda failure to pay the purchase price owing but claimed set-off and a counterclaim against the plaintiff arising from various alleged
breaches of the agreement of purchase and sale. [ 29 ] Duncan J. found that the defendants’ claim for equitable set-off was closely connected to the plaintiff’s claim, noting that both claims arose from the provisions of the agreement of purchase and sale.
He stated that the defendants’ claim, if successful, “has the potential to impeach the plaintiff’s claim and therefore it would be ‘manifestly unjust to enforce payment without considering the counterclaim’.” Positions of the Parties [ 30 ] The parties are largely in agreement as to the legal framework the Court must apply in determining whether judgment for amounts owed to GDI on the outstanding invoices should be stayed by operation of the doctrine equitable estoppel. Counsel have provided the Court with most of the same legal authorities.
The disagreement between the parties is the application of the doctrine to the facts before the Court. There is also disagreement as to the evidentiary burden FSL must meet in order to be granted a stay. [ 31 ] The question comes down to this: Is there a sufficient nexus between the claims of FSL and the claims of GDI such that it would be manifestly unfair to allow GDI to receive its judgment and be able to enforce that judgment against FSL while FSL’s claims are yet to be determined by a Court? [ 32 ] I will now review the positions of the parties on this issue.
FSL [ 33 ] As noted earlier in this decision, FSL says that there is such a nexus between the claims of both parties so that it would be manifestly unfair for GDI to obtain a judgment against it when its claims against GDI relating to the very services for which GDI seeks to be paid in full, remain outstanding. [ 34 ] FSL says that its claims against GDI are all rooted in breach of Contract.
Counsel for FSL points to the plead allegations that GDI breached covenants in the Contract by its inadequate provision of cleaning services and that those alleged breaches of covenants led to other damages which counsel referred to as “response costs” arising from the protests, allegations made by GDI employees against FSL and the human rights proceeding commenced against FSL as a result of the termination of the Contract and the manner in which GDI allegedly dealt with, or failed to deal with its employees.
It is noted that FSL also has parallel claims based in tort arising out of the same alleged post-termination activity on the part of FSL. [ 35 ] Counsel for FSL points to clause 5.1 of the Contract (reproduced above) which provides that GDI shall perform the scope of work as identified in
Schedule “A” “in a first class manner”, and clause 5.2 which provides that “at all times the Contractor (GDI) shall act in a professional manner and provide the Services in the best interests of the Client (FSL).” [ 36 ] Paragraph 35 of FSL’s Amended Statement of Claim against GDI lists eight enumerated allegations of specific breaches of the Contract (reproduced earlier in this decision) which FSL says led it to terminate the Contract and having to incur substantial additional costs flowing from the termination of the Contract. [ 37 ] In terms of the principles that the Court must keep in mind in considering a claim of equitable set-off, as outlined in Singer v.
Sommex ( supra ), counsel for FSL describes the first principle as a
summary statement. It is the second principle, i.e., that the equitable ground “must go to the very root of the plaintiff’s claim before a set-off will be allowed” which is part of the real meat of the doctrine. [ 38 ] Counsel for FSL acknowledges that GDI’s claim is very specific – it did the work and wants to be paid for it. However, FSL’s response to that claim is that GDI did the work poorly and is not entitled to be paid the full amount of the outstanding invoices as claimed.
In addition, counsel for FSL says that the breach of the Contract occasioned by the poor performance of GDI’s work caused FSL to suffer significant loss.
Those losses, he says include the need to terminate the Contract, the need to immediately bring a new cleaning services contractor to the site (and the attendant costs flowing from that) and the fact that there was a week when it was paying both the new service provider (Deep Down) and GDI. [ 39 ] FSL says that that specific component of its claim against GDI (the quality of the services provided in alleged breach of the Contract) impeaches or goes to the very root of FSL’s claim. [ 40 ] FSL also says that its other claims are also rooted in the Contract.
It says that GDI had other obligations under the Contract than to provide cleaning services. It points to clause 5.2, i.e. that GDI act at all times in the best interests of FSL. It contends that it is not appropriate for GDI to simply claim that they provided cleaning services and are entitled to be paid for them, without considering the other obligations FSL claims it had under the Contract. [ 41 ] Counsel for FSL says that the parties to the Contract specifically contemplated that there could be cross-obligations which the parties might need to address.
He points to the “indemnity clause” set forth earlier in this decision.
That clause which counsel describes as “robust” states that GDI must indemnify FSL against all liabilities, suits, actions, judicial or administrative proceedings, claims, demands, damage, penalties, fines, costs and expenses of whatsoever kind or character….arising out of or by reason of any liability or obligation in any manner caused or occasioned or claimed to be caused or occasioned by any act, omission, fault or negligence of the Contractor (GDI)…incidental [to] the performance of or failure to perform any covenant or obligation under the Agreement or related to the Services. [ 42 ] FSL says that the response which it was required to mount to the protests and to the human rights claim against it following termination of the Contract fit squarely within the indemnification clause and therefore it was clearly in the contemplation of the parties that allegations for breach of specific covenants of the Contract which caused FSL to have to respond as it did, would be off-sets or indemnifications between the parties within the terms of the Contract.
[ 43 ] FSL says that the cases relied upon by counsel for GDI where a stay was not granted, are not cases where the mutual claims between the parties all neatly flow from the terms of a single contract, which he says is the case before this Court. GDI [ 44 ] GDI says that equitable set-off does not apply to the circumstances before this Court.
It says that FSL’s claim is not so closely linked to GDI’s claim for unpaid invoices such that equitable set-off applies. [ 45 ] Counsel for GDI contends that FSL’s claim, as plead, against GDI for the costs of security, business losses, etc., arising out of the protests clearly related to members of the Union, and not GDI. For example, the Protection of Property Notice was issued to the Union.
The human rights complaint was against AGL and Deep Down, not GDI. [ 46 ] Counsel for GDI says that there is no evidence before this Court that the part of FSL’s claim arising out of the post-termination protests goes to the very root of GDI’s claim. [ 47 ] An issue arose during the hearing of this motion concerning the evidentiary requirements in the context of a request for stay of an order for
summary judgment pending determination of a related claim. The Court invited written submissions from the parties on this specific point. The Court received submissions from counsel for FSL on December 20, 2019, from counsel for GDI on December 23, 2019 and reply submissions from counsel for FLS on December 30, 2019. The Court has carefully reviewed these submissions. [ 48 ] FSL submits that the test and legal framework for entitlement to an order for
summary judgment on evidence pursuant to Rule 13.04 is distinct from that which applies to a request for a stay of such an order under Rule 13.07(2). [ 49 ] Further, FSL submits that even if the Rule 13.04 evidentiary requirements applied to a request for a stay, it has submitted sufficient evidence in accordance with the parameters of that Rule , so as to establish its entitlement to a stay based on its claim of equitable set-off. [ 50 ] GDI contends that FSL is bound by, and has not met the evidentiary requirements stipulated at Rule 13.04(4), which reads: On a motion for
summary judgment on evidence, the pleadings serve only to indicate the issues, and the subjects of a genuine issue of material fact and a question of law depend on the evidence presented. [ 51 ] However, FSL points out that Rul e 13.04(5) goes on to provide as follows: A party who wishes to contest the motion must provide evidence in favour of the party’s claim or defence by affidavit filed by the contesting party, affidavit filed by another party, cross-examination, or other means permitted by a judge. [emphasis added] [ 52 ] FSL says that it is not a party that is either (
a) seeking a motion for
summary judgment, or (
b) contesting the motion for
summary judgment. Rather, says FSL, it simply requests that this Court exercise the judicial discretion afforded by Rule 13.07(2) to stay the Order for
summary judgment until FSL’s claims against GDI are adjudicated. Rule 13.07 states: (
l) An order for
summary judgment may provide any remedy the court provides on the trial or hearing of a proceeding.
(2) The judge may stay an order for
summary judgment until a related proceeding is determined. [ 53 ] FSL says that there is nothing in the construction of Rule 13.07 to suggest that the evidentiary requirements to establish entitlement to a
summary judgment Order under Rule 13.04 or Rule 13.03 must also apply to the exercise of judicial discretion provided for in Rule 13.07. [ 54 ] FSL also points to the Judicature Act , RSNS 1989 c 240 which empowers the Court to recognize and administer equitable rights.
Section 41 provides that the Court may order a stay of proceedings “so far as is necessary for the purposes of justice” where a party is entitled to such a stay on equitable grounds: Rules of law 41 In every proceeding commenced in the court, law and equity shall be administered therein according to the following provisions: … (
d) the Court shall recognize and take notice of all equitable estates, titles and rights, and all equitable duties and liabilities appearing incidentally in the course of any proceeding, in the same manner in which the court of equity judge, or the said Court of Chancery, would have recognized, and taken notice of the same, in any suit or proceeding duly instituted therein before the first day of October, 1884; (
e) no proceeding at any time pending in the Court shall be restrained by prohibition or injunction but every matter of equity on which an injunction against the prosecution of any such proceeding might have been obtained prior to the first day of October, 1884, either unconditionally or on any terms or conditions, may be relied on by way of defence thereto provided always that nothing in this Act contained shall disable the Court from directing a stay of proceedings in any proceeding pending before the Court if it or he thinks fit, and any person, whether a party or not to any such proceeding who could have been entitled, prior to the first day of October, 1884, to apply to the Court to restrain the prosecution thereof, or who is entitled to enforce by attachment or otherwise any judgment, contrary to which all or any part of the proceedings have been taken, may apply to the Court thereof by motion in a
summary way for a stay of proceedings in such proceeding either generally, or so far as is necessary for the purposes of justice and the Court shall thereupon make
such order as shall be just; [emphasis added] [ 55 ] This Court finds that the authority to grant an equitable stay of a proceeding or a portion of a proceeding pursuant to Rule 13.07(2) is not tied to the evidentiary requirements for the granting of
summary judgment. [ 56 ] In any event, this Court finds that FSL has presented sufficient evidence on this motion to meet any evidentiary requirement necessary for the Court to determine the equities of granting a stay. FSL has not just relied upon the pleadings to indicate the issues raised on the parties’ claims against each other. It also tendered the Affidavit of Nick Garside which sets out in detail the facts which FSL say support its allegation that there are mutual claims grounded and rooted in the Contract. [ 57 ] This Court finds that it is appropriate in all of the circumstances, to stay the
summary judgment order with respect to GDI’s counterclaim for the unpaid invoices. The Counterclaim arises out of the same contractual relationship on which FSL's action is based. FSL’s claims for breach of contract are centered on GDI’s performance of its contractual obligations. GDI’s
summary judgment claim is for full payment of the services it provided under the Contract. FSL’s post-termination claims are also rooted in alleged breach of the Contract. The fact that the human rights claim was not brought against GDI and the Protection of Property Notice not filed against GDI, does not mean that FSL’s claims for breach of the Contract following its termination are not rooted in that Contract. [ 58 ] This Court finds that it would be manifestly unfair to allow GDI to obtain and enforce judgment against FSL in all of the circumstances. [ 59 ] GDI is granted (partial)
summary judgment in the amount of $58,365.83 plus interest, but
summary judgment in that amount is stayed, pursuant to Rule 13.07(2) until such time as FLS’s action against GDI for breach of contract and GDI’s remaining counterclaims are determined. [ 60 ] FSL is entitled to costs on this motion. If the parties cannot agree on costs, I will receive written submissions within 30 calendar days from today. Smith, J.
Loading document…