Ryckman v. Ryckman, 2020 NSSC 44
Opinion
Supreme Court of Nova Scotia (FAMILY DIVISION) Citation: Ryckman v. Ryckman , 2020 NSSC 44 Date: 2020-01-31 Docket: 1206-6754 Registry: Sydney Between: LORETTA RYCKMAN Applicant v. FRANCIS RYCKMAN Respondent Library Heading Judge: The Honourable Justice Lee Anne MacLeod-Archer Heard: October 21, and 22, 2019 in Sydney, Nova Scotia Final Written Submissions: December 13, 2019 Written Decision: January 31, 2020 Issues:
(1) Determination of income for purposes of child support
(2) Retroactive child support Result: Income imputed to Respondent; retroactive child support awarded to Petitioner, Respondent’s claim for retroactive child support dismissed. THIS INFORMATION SHEET DOES NOT FORM PART OF THE COURT'S DECISION. QUOTES MUST BE FROM THE DECISION, NOT THIS LIBRARY SHEET. SUPREME COURT OF Nova Scotia FAMILY DIVISION Citation: Ryckman v. Ryckman , 2020 NSSC 44 Date: 2020-01-31 Docket: 1206-6754 Registry: Sydney Between: LORETTA RYCKMAN Applicant v.
FRANCIS RYCKMAN Respondent Judge: The Honourable Justice Lee Anne MacLeod-Archer Heard: October 21, and 22, 2019, in Sydney, Nova Scotia Written Release: January 31, 2020 Counsel: Candee McCarthy for the Applicant Gordon Gear for the Respondent
By the Court: Facts [ 1 ] The parties were married on September 7, 1996 and separated on October 8, 2010. They have four children, including their daughter Tiara and son Brett. Mr. Ryckman now resides in Ontario, while Ms. Ryckman (who goes by Littlejohn) resides in Cape Breton. [ 2 ] The Ontario Family Court issued a parenting order on September 9, 2011. It granted Ms. Littlejohn custody of Tiara, while Mr. Ryckman was granted custody of Brett.
There was no order made for child support because “the respondent father has not produced any financial information as ordered and as each parent has custody of one child, no child support shall be paid by either party to the other”. No analysis under s.9 of the Child Support Guidelines was completed, presumably because Mr. Ryckman’s didn’t disclose his income. [ 3 ] Ms. Littlejohn filed a Petition for divorce on November 3, 2014. Mr. Ryckman filed an Answer on April 3, 2017. [ 4 ] The parties resolved property claims in advance of the divorce hearing.
Shortly before the divorce hearing, they also resolved the parenting claims. The only two issues to be addressed at the trial were therefore: 1. What is Mr. Ryckman’s income for purposes of payment of child support? 2. What child support is payable for the dependent children? Divorce [ 5 ] All jurisdictional requirements of the Divorce Act [R.S.C., 1985, c. 3 (2nd Supp .)] have been met. There’s been a permanent breakdown of the marriage. The divorce and name change are granted. Issue #1 [ 6 ] Mr. Ryckman is a professional wrestler who runs his own businesses.
He says that the child support payable by him should be based on his average income reported on line 150 of his tax returns, which amounts to $15,440.39 per annum. [ 7 ] Ms. Littlejohn asks the court to impute income to Mr. Ryckman. She says that he has failed to file the appropriate income disclosure, that he’s hiding income, that he lacks credibility with respect to his income and income sources, and that his lifestyle suggests a much higher income than reported. [ 8 ] Credibility plays a role in assessing the evidence for purposes of imputing income. In order to accept Mr.
Ryckman’s argument that his reported average income should be used for purposes of child support, I would have to accept that his line 150 income accurately reflects the income available to pay child support. I do not. [ 9 ] Mr. Ryckman’s evidence was rife with inconsistencies and claims that lack credibility. A number of the examples are outlined in the closing submissions presented by Ms. Littlejohn’s counsel. The ones that resonate in particular are as follows: 1.
He did not provide disclosure of his business interests, nor did he fully disclose his business expenses, despite numerous requests from counsel and court orders and direction to do so. 2. He did not provide documentation to show who receives the subcontract fees which are paid to wrestlers. He denies that he receives any of those fees. 3. Mr. Ryckman initially claimed he no longer wrestles, but on cross examination he conceded that he does still get into the ring on occasion. 4. His evidence as to the rate of pay when he does wrestle lacks credibility.
It’s unlikely that he’s paid only $100.00 (or the equivalent of two props used in the show) while others are paid more. 5. His evidence that he is not paid a commission from wrestling productions was challenged on cross examination. He conceded that he receives money, and the invoice he produced confirms this. 6. Mr. Ryckman didn’t provide documentation from Ticketmaster to show the amount of tickets sold for a major event he produces at Scotiabank Centre each year, though he concedes that this is a major event for him, and that the Ticketmaster commission is significant.
This would suggest a large sales volume, which would, in turn suggest high revenues. 7. His evidence with respect to the viability of his wresting school is contradictory. At one time, he claimed it’s doing better, but then he said it’s on the verge of closing. The latter claim also contradicts statements made in advertising for a related company, an off-spring from his wrestling school. 8. Mr. Ryckman’s suggestion that all businesses mislead the buying public in advertisements is simply not credible.
He asks the court to take judicial notice of the fact that “the majority of advertisements presented to potential customers, whether it be ticket
purchasers or product consumers, frequently stretch the truth or provide an augmented version of a product”. The advertising standards council of Canada and consumer organizations would certainly disagree, as do I. Further, Mr. Ryckman asks the court to take judicial notice of this and several other statements, but he didn’t reference the test for judicial notice nor analyse it in his submissions. Further, judicial notice is not a substitute for evidence. 9. Mr. Ryckman claims to lead a meagre existence, but on cross-examination it became apparent that he leads a very comfortable life with his new partner.
They drive high end vehicles (whether pre-owned or not), eat out frequently, and have taken family trips to sunny destinations in recent years. His credit card statements show a pattern of expenses that are in keeping with this lifestyle. 10. His evidence that he has nothing to do with DanceFit Canada, which he claims is his fiancé’s business, lacks credibility. The evidence discloses that he is listed as “Director and Studio Owner” on the business website and that the studio was established before he re-partnered.
In addition, his son testified that the studio is a “family business” in which he, his brother and his father are partners. If DanceFit is currently held in his fiancé’s name, that is a matter of convenience. 11. I reject his claim that he doesn’t know what a “sister company” is in the legal sense. He uses the same term in describing another business which falls under the umbrella of its parent company, which he owns. He’s been in business long enough to understand that term and its implications. 12.
He claimed not to be familiar with a tax form produced in evidence, and then claimed that his accountant prepared it without his instructions, which is unlikely. 13. He claims his accountant directed him to falsely report his marital status for purposes of Revenue Canada. That’s also unlikely, particularly given that he has had two accountants, and both would not make the same mistake, or breach their professional obligations. 14. He claimed little knowledge about financial statements and HST filings, though he has been in business for two decades. 15. Mr.
Ryckman’s evidence was evasive, defensive, exaggerated, and strategic throughout his testimony. [ 10 ] Further, Mr. Ryckman was obliged to make complete disclosure according to s.21 of the Child Support Guidelines . Despite many requests from counsel, as well as court orders and directives, he failed to fully comply in a timely manner. As the Supreme Court of Canada noted in Leskun v. Leskun, 2006 SCC 25 : Non-disclosure of assets is the cancer of matrimonial property litigation. It discourages settlement or promotes settlement which are inadequate. It increases the time and expense of litigation.
The prolonged stress of unnecessary battle may lead weary and drained women simply to give up and walk away with only a share of the assets they know about, taking with them the bitter aftertaste of a reasonably-based suspicion that justice was not done. The suspicion here is that Mr. Ryckman didn’t make full disclosure because he has income to hide. [ 11 ] Mr. Ryckman claims an average gross income of over $150,000.00, but an average net income of only $15,440.22. He deducted numerous expenses for tax purposes.
However, as indicated in s.19(2) of the Child Support Guidelines , I’m not obliged to accept that an expense is reasonable, solely because it’s permitted as a deduction by Revenue Canada. I am obliged to review deductions through the lens of whether it’s reasonable for purposes of child support. [ 12 ] Mr. Ryckman reports income from his wrestling business on his personal return. Ms. Littlejohn argues that he’s a shareholder, director, and officer of at least one company for which disclosure hasn’t been made. If so, s.18 of the Child Support Guidelines would apply.
It allows the court to determine his annual income for child support purposes by including: (
a) all or part of the pre-tax income of the corporation, and of any corporation that is related to that corporation, for the most recent taxation year; or (
b) an amount commensurate with the services that the spouse provides to the corporation, provided that the amount does not exceed the corporation’s pre-tax income. Adjustment to corporation’s pre-tax income
(2) In determining the pre-tax income of a corporation for the purposes of subsection (1), all amounts paid by the corporation as salaries, wages or management fees, or other payments or benefits, to or on behalf of persons with whom the corporation does not deal at arm’s length must be added to the pre-tax income, unless the spouse establishes that the payments were reasonable in the circumstances. [ 13 ] Further, Mr. Ryckman’s partner runs one of the businesses. A couple of tax documents were produced at trial, but she didn’t testify and her income tax returns weren’t disclosed. [ 14 ] Ms.
Littlejohn argues that Mr. Ryckman lives a lifestyle that wouldn’t be possible on the income he reports to Revenue Canada. She also argues that because his partner is non-arms’ length and operates a business in which Mr. Ryckman is involved, her income must be considered as part of the complete picture. [ 15 ] I find, on a balance of probabilities, that Mr. Ryckman’s line 150 income doesn’t represent his actual income or his ability to pay child support. I’m therefore prepared to impute income based on s.19(1)(d)(
f) and (
g) of the Child Support Guidelines . [ 16 ] I have analysed Mr. Ryckman’s income tax returns, as well as the expenses he produced at trial. If I add back the items allowed under
Schedule III of the Child Support Guidelines , as well as a portion of his (unreasonably high) vehicle and meal expenses,
and allow for unreported income, the figure of $72,000.00 suggested by Ms. Littlejohn in her final submissions is in line with my calculations. [ 17 ] However, I reject Ms. Littlejohn’s suggestion that income should be imputed at $150,000.00. That figure isn’t supported by the evidence. Rather, I am satisfied that Mr. Ryckman should pay child support for the child Tiara based on an imputed income of $72,000.00 for the years 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2020. Issue #2 [ 18 ] Ms. Littlejohn seeks a retroactive award, as well as prospective child support for Tiara.
She limits her retroactive claim to the filing date of November, 2014. [ 19 ] Mr. Ryckman seeks retroactive child support for Brett, payable by Ms. Littlejohn. He first advanced a claim for child support in the Answer he filed on April 7, 2017. Retroactive Child Support [ 20 ] An analysis under D.B.S. v. S.R.G. [2006 SCC 37] is required where both parties are seeking a retroactive child support award.
I must consider the child’s circumstances; the reasons for any delay in seeking child support; if there’s blameworthy conduct on the part of the payor; and any hardship a retroactive award might create for the payor. [ 21 ] Brett’s circumstances are: he incurred student loans to attend Canadore College, where he attained his diploma in recreation therapy in 2018; he’s working at a call centre; and he moved out of his father’s home a year ago.
There’s no direct evidence that he would benefit from a retroactive award at this point, though it could be inferred that a retroactive award would be used to pay down his student loan debt. However, his father seeks set-off of retroactive support for Brett against monies he owes for Tiara’s support. It’s clear that Brett would not benefit from a retroactive award. Tiara’s circumstances are: she’s a high school student living at home with her mother and she’s expected to graduate next year. [ 22 ] If Mr.
Ryckman is required to pay a retroactive child support award for Tiara, it may cause hardship, but he’s had the benefit of not paying child support since Brett ceased to be a dependent child. Even after Brett moved out, Mr. Ryckman failed to pay support. Any hardship he encounters is of his own making. [ 23 ] Tiara is still in high school. She could use a retroactive award for her future education. Given that she has graduation expenses looming as well, I have no doubt that Ms. Littlejohn would use these funds for Tiara’s benefit. If Ms.
Littlejohn is required to pay retroactive support for Brett, she would face hardship. Her income is much less than what I’ve imputed to Mr. Ryckman. She’s cashed RRSP’s to meet her expenses over the years, and she still has a dependent child living with her. [ 24 ] Ms. Littlejohn applied for support when she filed the Petition on November 3, 2014. Brett had only graduated from high school five months earlier, so there is no delay. [ 25 ] Mr. Ryckman was made aware of Ms. Littlejohns’s claim for child support when he was served, but he didn’t file an Answer in the time required by the Civil Procedure Rules.
Brett wasn’t attending school or college in November, 2014. In fact, he took two years off to work and decide on his future career path. [ 26 ] When Mr. Ryckman eventually filed his Answer in April, 2017, he claimed child support for Brett. By that time, Brett was 22 years old. He’d been out of school for 2 ¼ years before enrolling in college to complete a program which he hasn’t used to earn income. Neither he or his father notified Ms. Littlejohn of his plans, nor did they provide her with any information after Brett enrolled.
Given the fact that the Supreme Court has identified the need for certainty in orders, this delay in not reasonable. [ 27 ] Ms. Littlejohn is not guilty of blameworthy conduct. She disclosed her income information as required, and she pursued her claim in a timely fashion. She wasn’t required to pay child support for Brett under the Ontario order issued on September 9, 2011. Brett reached the age of majority on May 23, 2012, only eight months later. She wasn’t provided with information to suggest he was still a dependent child thereafter, nor was she presented with a claim for child support until 2017.
She has never been provided with information on Brett’s expenses or income. [ 28 ] Mr. Ryckman didn’t disclose his income information in 2011, and he delayed filing his personal income information until forced to do so. He hasn’t fully disclosed his business and/or corporate holdings and income information, and he failed to comply with the disclosure requirements for a child over the age of majority. [ 29 ] Balancing these factors with the need for certainty and flexibility, I find that a retroactive child support award for Tiara is appropriate. A retroactive award for Brett is not.
Child Support for Brett [ 30 ] In the event I am wrong in denying a retroactive award for Brett, I’ll analyse his father’s claim. Mr. Ryckman claims that Brett was dependent on him until June, 2018. [ 31 ] When Mr. Ryckman applied for child support in April, 2017, Brett was attending college. Between 2014 – 2016, he worked full-time. He started his college program in September, 2016 and graduated in June, 2018. If he wasn’t a dependent child at the time the claim was made for child support, then I have no jurisdiction to make a retroactive child support order ( D.B.S. (supra); Smith v.
Selig, 2008 NSCA 54 ). [ 32 ] In order for Brett to be considered a dependent child of the marriage in April, 2017 he must meet the definition of a dependent child in the Divorce Act . That is defined in s.2(1) of the Divorce Act :
… child of the marriage means a child of two spouses or former spouses who, at the material time, (
a) is under the age of majority and who has not withdrawn from their charge, or (
b) is the age of majority or over and under their charge but unable, by reason of illness, disability or other cause, to withdraw from their charge or to obtain the necessaries of life; [ 33 ] Numerous courts have accepted that pursuit of post secondary education or training is “other cause” for purposes of s.2(1) . The Nova Scotia courts have been clear that a child who loses their dependent status may regain such status through educational pursuits. In Lockerby v.
Lockerby 2017 NSCA 26 the court accepted a trial judge’s finding that there was a change of circumstances because the child regained status as a dependent child of the marriage by reason of her educational pursuits, and her inability to fully fund her expenses. [ 34 ] Brett’s evidence shows that after receiving his high school diploma, he worked two jobs for about four months, and then dropped one job to work full time at Foot Locker. He testified that he received on average of 24 hours of work per week at $14.00 per hour, plus extra shifts in the lead up to Christmas.
No tax returns have been filed for Brett, but by my calculation, he had income of at least $18,000.00 per annum. [ 35 ] Brett also testified that he paid for his post secondary education through student loans and government funding. He said that his father helped by providing food, clothing, and shelter. He also said that if he was broke, he would borrow money from his father and repay it. No documents were tendered to show what amounts he borrowed from either source. [ 36 ] I don’t have the necessary information to assess his ability to obtain the necessaries of life after 2014.
However, even if Brett regained his status as a dependent child while pursuing his recreational therapy diploma through Canador College between September, 2016 and May, 2018, I would have to apply s. 3(2) of the Child Support Guidelines: Child the age of majority or over
(2) Unless otherwise provided under these Guidelines, where a child to whom a child support order relates is the age of majority or over, the amount of the child support order is (
a) the amount determined by applying these Guidelines as if the child were under the age of majority; or (
b) if the court considers that approach to be inappropriate, the amount that it considers appropriate, having regard to the condition, means, needs and other circumstances of the child and the financial ability of each spouse to contribute to the support of the child. [ 37 ] These sections require compliance with Civil Procedure Rule 59.22(1), which sets out the following disclosure obligations: Disclosure of financial information for child support and other claims 59.22
(1) A party who makes the following claim for child support, and the party against whom the claim is made, must file the following statement or statements: Claim Statement child support in the table amount under the Guidelines and no other financial claim by the party claiming, none by the party claimed against, a statement of income special or extraordinary expenses under the Guidelines by the party claiming, a statement of special or extraordinary expenses by both parties, a statement of income if the child is able to contribute to the special or extraordinary expenses by the party claiming, an additional statement of the child’s income or ability to contribute child support that is different from the table amount, or the table amount plus special or extraordinary expenses by both parties, a statement of income and a statement of expenses if child support is also for a child who is nineteen years of age or older by the party claiming, an additional statement of the child’s income and expenses [ 38 ] Mr.
Ryckman hasn’t complied with Civil Procedure Rule 59.22. I have no way to assess Brett’s needs and means for purposes of s3(2) and s.7 of the Child Support Guidelines . I don’t have information on Brett’s college expenses or savings, his income tax returns, his loan amounts, or the other information I’d need to analyse his situation. [ 39 ] As a result, I conclude that Brett was no longer a dependent child after June, 2014. Even if he regained his dependent status, I have insufficient evidence to make a child support order. Child Support for Tiara [ 40 ] Tiara is under the age of majority, so Mr.
Ryckman must pay the table amount for her based on the income I’ve imputed to him under the Ontario table, from December 1, 2017 and continuing monthly for so long as Tiara remains a dependent child. Costs [ 41 ] I will accept submissions on costs on or before February 13, 2020.
MacLeod-Archer, J.
Loading document…